Has Donald Trump's visit changed India-US ties?
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 07. 2024
- #CutTheClutter
In episode 399 of Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta and Jyoti Malhotra discuss how US President Donald Trump’s visit has changed India-US relations. From exports to the defence deal and how this will impact India’s relations with China, the two decode all the questions which surround Trump’s maiden visit to India.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For a detailed coverage of Donald Trump's India visit, click here: theprint.in/tag/trump-india-v...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch more Cut The Clutter episodes here: • Cut The Clutter with S...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Yankee go home but take me with you - Jairam Ramesh explaining anti americanism in India..what a brilliant quote.
Sonia's not an ex PM or president of India. Why should she be invited.
Cause she is the chairperson of UPA the opposition coalition as well as the president of INC which is the primary opposition.
Subhadeep Das protocol does not allow her. Nitin Gadkari was not invited when UPA government was inviting then US president. BJP did not cry like Congress is doing now!!
She is queen of slaves called left and liberals
@Vikramm Menonn Your Gobar Brain is well and active
and Gomutr tonic is keeping it active Bear Grylls taught your guru to drink Elephant dung tonic have you started on it.
Idiot did Trump talk about any religion then why bring Christianity here
Ur point is absolutely correct , y should a political parties something be invited for an american presidents visit . Just because everyone before bjp rule licked sonias foot doesnt make it a law
Cut the clutter is better with just Mr. Gupta alone
(Myopinion)
I agree
I agree
Camera adjustment can be ignored, as almost all viewers are regular followers here 🤭
Noticed it after reading your comment. He needs youtubing lessons I guess
Mr. SG cannot be so naive as to not understand that timing of events in Delhi are not coincidental
Can't SG give some credit where it's due! The riots were pre planned to coincide with the visit
One of the best from Shekhar Gupta. The brazen hypocrisy in Indo-US relationship is now buried forever.
Indians are poor. They need a foreign power like the USA to help counter China.
China doesn't need anyone to establish itself as a global hegemon.
@swetab singh Prediction is easy to make. Anyone can make predictions. Everyone in the 1960s thought Soviet Union was going to be No.1 economy of the world. But it collapsed into 16 countries in early 1990s.
Indians can never be a superpower if they only import technology and innovation. Right now Indians produce almost nothing for the world .
It is on the rioters to defame India. Not government’s fault. How disingenuous to blame govt
Delhi muslim rioters have to be treated well and given a lesson they never forget.
Dehli Muslims, Dallits, Sikhs, Christians and other minorities will teach a tough lesson to hindutva supporters.
@@gffpak May I know why u involving other minorities 😂......
Shekhar Gupta is a seasoned, hardened journalist. His interviewer is comparatively a complete ignoramus and it shows. Thanks SG for making things so clear despite that.
SG is stupid.
I am amazed with the intelligence, confidence and the veracity Mr.Sekhar answered all those questions so spontaneously. He should ideally help our internal intelligence services to improve the situations in this country than just being an externally facing journalist. He has got the mind power.
Thanks for your comment, Surya. Do subscribe to our channel for more videos.
What is absent from media coverage here in India is the seriousness of outbreak of COVID-19. This is turning out to be a tragic black swan event. The impact of this outbreak is going to be huge as in a globalised world dependent on global value chain (GVC), China which is a big part of this GVC is literally shutdown with productivity nearing nothing. In this scenario, America and other countries including India are going to suffer quiet badly with Indian economy already in doldrums. That being said, what should be a concern is the spread of this virus in India. At the moment it seems that India has contained the virus but with outbreaks in other parts of world, if an outbreak occurs in India, it is going to be a nightmare for health services. Keeping fingers crossed and hoping that virus die down with increase in temperature (currently no evidence exist that back this theory).
Journalists are very busy narrating anti BJP but in vain. Barkha, rajdeep, rana.. dying hard
Maybe if the subject matter of the interview had anything to do with public health or contagious disease, the interview would have been with an infectious disease specialist? I am not sure the coronavirus is any more dangerous than the common cold or flu. I really feel like people are freaking out about nothing.
Really? Dude it's for real n no its not u r common cold n flu its fatal
daksh singh Cold and flu can be fatal for people who are immunocompromised as well. I would like for the media to start interviewing people who have had it. They try to scare us into getting flu shots every year with statistics about how many people have died from the flu, but I have never known anyone who has known someone who has died from the flu.
@@really5580 I urge you to reconsider your analysis. Common Cold and Flu are less lethal than this COVID-19. Why? Because common cold and flu does not give around 20% of the infected patients pneumonia and serious respiratory disease . Also, governments around the world do not impose strict quarantine measures to slow down spread of common cold. It is true (from current empirical evidence) that patients with age above 70, having co-morbidities like cancer, uncontrolled diabetes and hypertension (high blood pressure) are at a more serious risk but we have to remember that we are in early stages of the outbreak. No cure or vaccine will be available for next 16 to 18 months. The Case Fatality Rate (CFR) is, with current studies, around 2.5% little more or less. Even at this rate if number of infected grew to millions the number of deaths will be astronomical. I agree that there are fear-mongers who try to paint a picture of doom for society but one cannot afford to overlook credible scientific data. Prestigious medical journals around the world are indicating towards the possibility of this being a pandemic.
Seems like nobody cares that there is a video being shot in the office
Good evening Shekharji, may I request you to please make a presentation on real motive of Delhi riots during Mr.Trump's visit to India. Modi's supporters and his party menbers definitely do not want this embarrassing situation. Then who are the actual players acting from behind the scene..
Live decluttering issues is more fun
Glad to hear that, Amit. Do subscribe!
Yankee go back and take me with you! 😂👏🏻
An advice for camera person, make your frame and light shooting before taking final take.
SG sir is on fire.. so good to listen to him.. love
Thanks for watching. Do subscribe to our channel for more videos.
Shekhar came hard on NAM ..Also Mr.Gupta looks very aggressive in his analysis
Evangelical Christians, Shekhar, that's his major supporter, not just Christians, there are over 65 - 70 denominations ! ====== Matts'
It looks like he is very much frustrated bcoz things went well in favour of Mr. Modi
Very important point to make. Many Christian groups in US are actually anti-trump.
Can we outsource our Governmental functioning to USA or Britain for a few years ?
You can see this video at 1.75x speed and it still sounds normal
Why is your interview so crafted that it shames Mr.Modi's government. Riots are often caused by irresponsible people.
Occurrence of Riots are indicative of bad govts.
Agreed with your analysis... pls keep going this way so that bitter truth should come out one day and helping people with reality ...
Thanks for your comment, Ravi.
The brilliant impulsive outpouring of his analysis & thoughts is so Original .Thank u Sekhar Gupta for speaking your mind rather than a scripted response prepared by your Research Team. Lovely this is your masterpiece Nathan Sekhar Sydney, Australia.
Thanks, Nathan. Stay tuned for more videos.
Mr. Shekhar is getting frustrated these days with biased news.
Yes...even I can feel that he is frustrated
@@findingplaces1986 He stands stark naked before thinking minds because of his bais reporting
Damage to India...world is not so synical...one roit damage Indian image ...country history and people matters ...few radicals or liberal cannot damage Indian image
Shekhar Gupta at his best...
I always miss the opportunities to ask SG sir question for these live streams.
Sir, I am a religious follower of "Cut the Clutter" which helps me understand the reality behind the news with good facts and figures. In this episode you mentioned few points about American electoral system. It's a very different system than what we follow in India, but it will be interesting if you can do an episode to de clutter the "American Electoral System'.
Why don't you guys sit down and talk.??
Jitin Sharma lol 😂
Wow. " India was balancing nothing. India was frankly bullshitting...... Mrs Gandhi came with limited intellect...."... AWESOME Shekhar G. Didn;t expect this level of honesty.
9:24 absolute love to Mr Gupta for telling the truth.
Sir what is the deliveries and what is the show off
25:40 It's not the first time lethal equipment has been bought from US in recent times.
P8 Poseidons are equipped with US made torpedos.
Harpoon missiles were first procured in 2010.
M4 Carbines and Stingers have been in service for some time.
I couldn't find anyone in Indian news channels or youtubers explaining political news better than shekar Gupta....👌👌
Glad to hear that, Praveen. Stay tuned for more videos.
Fix that light! Fix that light! 😂 😂 😂 Please. 🙏
Shekhar gupta is undoubtedly one of the most underrated journalists in India.
Cant she put her mobile down,its disturbing.
She is asking questions of viewers which are coming live on the phone.
The question that she is asking is coming from the people watching the live stream.. she is reading out their questions from the phone.
Soniya, neither opposition leader in Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha nor her Party is legally a opposition party. I wanted to know whether you talk of how UPA ignored opposition parties during earlier president visit.
What is in that trade deal that is creating a lot of buzz. Why is india resisting it.
They want us buy more agri products from USA.....but don't agree , also they want us to reduce import duties on various medical equipment....we want more things in return like gsp plus
I think Shekhar Gupta must go to press conferences organized by other heads of state in India. So better and relevant questions could be raised.
Many media houses against govt, journalists too. Anything
Is criticised by media, why women and children dragged
To streets by protesters? Who
Is funding? These media never give reasons, suppose
Govt taking stern action that
Is also criticised, sekhar gupta
As senior journalist say something about reality too
Don't you see any development?
Both Modi and Trump are nationalists working hard in their own national interests.
I've been a news nerd for as long as I can remember. I think, right now, Bill Maher (for US views) and Ravish Kumar (for India views) capture my thoughts about 60% of the time. Shekhar, on the other hand, capture my India-and-outside thoughts 80% of the time. Not that I'm a noted expert, but good to have journalists like them who can capture and express what intellectuals think. Wish I could have a breakfast with Shekhar sometime soon.
I always wonder why all of these journalist like Gupta , who are in the 60s and probably were on the payroll of KGB from 70's to until Indira's death. Never ever even mention of that whole episode. That's when Indira made the deal with USSR in return for Lal Bahadur Shastri's murder. They just don't even mention why US and whole of west ignored India through the 70's & 80's. When KGB was running India and every one in Delhi was on KGB's payroll. Gupta is one of the classical hypocrite who doesn't want to bring up this topic in order to not expose him self. But truth will come out one day. May after Putin the ex KGB demit office.
www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/the-kgb-papers-it-seemed-like-the-entire-country-was-for-sale/cid/1023636
Why should we invite Sonia Gandhi?
Inki mummy hai na manmohan Singh ko bulaya tha but gye nahi
Another excellent analysis Sekhar Sir - after listening tp yr discourses, I feel thereafter going thru any news debates is a waste...
Are we going to take dictation from other countries ? A reminder ... we became an independent country in 1947 and CAA is an internal matter just as building a wall along the Mexican border was for the US. You are trying to read too much in to what discussion would have taken place between Mr Modi and Mr Trump.
Sir... U r looking frustrated
i think you are new here
Once again Shekhar Gupta sir roked again and answered all questions
I guess Mr. Gupta is all out against Modi for not getting an invite from the Govt. to be part of media contingent for Trump banquet dinner.. LOL
Russia stood behind India When America had send its 6 th fleet to Bay of Bengal during 1971 war.
Awesome. Your analysis is frank.
@31.24 Gujarati way of doing business? You mean the way you get what you want and also make other party smile and happy? Yup that’s it.
Superb
Insightful
Modi is the best pm of India. Modi is the saviour of India. Yes. I am an Andhbhakt. I am proud of this. Jai Hind
Me too. He is the saviour of our beloved country.
Hi Shekhar sir, would like you to do a CTC on new revised 12 indicators of GDP measurement introduced by RBI and it's implications
Thanks for the suggestion. We'll look into it.
you are on fire today good to hear.
The Print... Please work on camera angle now n picturization, n after lot of criticism for audio, you guys have really worked on it n improved....
*S. Gupta speaks pure Indian English*
Gupta chacha...Yaar Hunk lag rahe ho... killer👌
You too r exposed Mamoon Gupta
Akhand Pratap Singh lol.....true...have requested him to wear formals......
How Can a friend of your enemy be your friend too?
True, a country is as good as its economy.
very blunt and brutally accurate
V well explained
If you do not buy from the USA, you are not a friend of the USA. SG ignores the fact that Trump is a businessman.
Excellent thought provoking analysis.
Good... Better Mic Pls.. Bit of echo issue
Great analysis.
Amreeka se aake Uncle aapko nahi bachayega - hahaha, thank you Shekhar for making it simple and decluttering
Thank you for frank clear answers
Thanks for watching, Khrupa.
The way mr Shekhar Gupta ignored her at 15:58, modern feminists would call it mansplaining.
SG analysis is extreme so much of emotuons.
Outstanding analysis. Frank and Indepth.
Shekhar Sir, I am expecting your views on the horrible killings in Delhi and the Government's response.
Shekhar ji always have this lady with you .You are very mercurial today.Thoughts are coming very quickly to you .I think someone in the canvas has excited you 😂.Very interesting you cluttering very nicely...
What's up Ruhi 4:56
Well, she seems boosy
She's least bothered about GuptaJi's interview and left home.... Anyways it's annoying to see her shows...
Wow👍
Great video w/ Shekhar speaking the truth as usual, but pulling no punches whatsoever. I’d be as animated if my city was burning that night.
Very good
Camera is so distracting...why change focus every time
Indians and Americans are guided by essentially the same fundamental values - be productive, be good, enjoy life. India was born into the Cold War hence it was understandable that America's position on India, and vice versa, was relative. Now that the Cold War is over for 30 years, time for natural partners to work together. Remember that what is powering Indo-US relations is the burgeoning people to people links, with the governments piggybacking on that. And with little to no government support from either the US or India, Indian Americans are the most successful ethnic group in the most successful economy in the world. Indians in India have barely started on their path to middle-income, so this is the most promising relationship on earth at this point.
Thank you Mr. SG for sometimes close to outbursts! Bit sad that oil supplies did not figure much in the discussion. That is the real, slow game changer.
Sir another awesome presentation.....loved the India was bullshitting it’s way ......jyothi ma’am.....still coming unprepared......is being woke a cv requirement to be on print....thank u sir......
Very correct. Only economy can make india strong.
What about the 7th Fleet in the Bay of Bangal in 1971 ?
19:32.
“we have to recover all of the occupied Kashmir” then he corrects that to “Pakistan occupied Kashmir.” 🤔
21:32
Pakistan is a dangerous place....
Rishin, you missed my point or ignored it.
quoting Allama Iqbal's poetry at 28:53 was great
Why haven't they fired Jyoti Malhotra yet? The woman doesn't know how to be quiet.
I think she was SG girlfriend during Thier college days, I mean,
girl -friend.
👍
I like Shekhars guptas views on this
Shekhar, not impressed with wrong quoting of the sher - 'Khud hi kar buland itna...'. It's not 'taqdeer' but 'tadbeer' (throw of dice).
Shekhar is now more balanced, his indepth knowledge & views are awesome. Background movement should be avoided.
We appreciate the feedback. Thanks!
India spends Rs 300 crores (about $ 50 million ) for this reception of Trump who got a defense contract of $3 billion but Pakistan gained without doing anything. Americans are now giving away Afghanistan to Pakistan as it was before 2001 from 1992. The USA gave permission to Turkey, the friend of Pakistan, to invade Syria. It is a net loss for India.
Shekhar Sir, Im a big fan of yours and I never miss any of your videos. They are really interesting but today I had to rewind the video several times to watch it properly because I was continously getting distracted by the girl in jeans walking in the background. I know that it is your office and people are busy but it is very disturbing while watching the show. You can check yourself if you feel that I am wrong.
Thank you. Padmaja
When the visiting First Lady of U. S. Madam Melania Trump visited the Model School in Delhi, should n't some minister or some high ranking Officer of the Govt. have accompanied her. there ?
Is it not lack of regard or lack of courtesey to a very important dignitary ?
Muslims of Delhi put India down in front of US president visit. Poor on Amit Shah not expected this
shekhar ji , are you sure trump asked "as if u share border with china?". it changes many of my perceptions. u must clarify or repeat it once more with authenticity.it is extremely important
Regards
Where is Kejriwal . What he was doing during election was it not Muslim appesment . Now why can’t he take out rally and calm down his relative Muslims .