The Chosen's biblical roundtables: Full episode one discussion
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2019
- A Catholic, a Jew, and an Evangelical walk into a bar...
Maybe not quite, but we did have The Chosen's three biblical consultants gather to discuss each episode, including this discussion on Episode One of the series. We don't necessarily agree on everything, but it was important to hear from each of these faith traditions while scripts were written and again after the episodes were done.
Full episodes of all Biblical roundtables are available in our app under "Deep Dive"
Watch The Chosen on our free app: thechosen.tv/app
Go deeper with The Chosen Devotional: thechosen.tv/store
Wear The Chosen: www.thechosengifts.com
Get Season One on DVD or Blu-ray: thechosen.tv/store
#BingeJesus by subscribing to our CZcams channel:
czcams.com/users/thechosense...
Watch More!
The Chosen BTS: Jesus heals Mary
• The Chosen behind-the-...
The Chosen "Trouble" trailer
• The Chosen: "Trouble" ...
The immense weight of playing Jesus
• The immense weight of ...
GetUsedToDifferent by following us:
/ insidethechosen
/ thechosentvseries
/ thechosentv
/ thechosentv - Krátké a kreslené filmy
The best thing about this approach to storytelling is that it makes the truth more real. It does not replace the truth. It makes me want to read my Bible and think, “Could it have happened this way?” And often I conclude that, “Yes, it may not have happened that way, but it could have! It then makes me think outside the box and enriches my understanding and interpretation of scripture. The Chosen is a great show. I highly recommend it!
exactly!! this show made me relate to all these events as sommething that happens today, to us, to me and not something that happened once and thinking in probabilities is what life asks from us ALL the time....and i was thinking why nobody ever showed it this way:)
I'm so happy with how we can all feel this about this show.
that is what skilled preachers of the Bible do. They must use pictures. Our minds work that way. Havent you heard, a good picture is worth a thousand words.
That scene between Eden and Simon at the grape vat is the most romantic and beautiful scene between a couple that I have ever seen in any movie, period.
I felt like one of them was about to walk off in a huff about something during that scene. But then I realised my expectation of this comes from secular tv shows
Agree, I welcomed that scene and keep it in my heart for ever. Movies and other shows should learn to bring back this scenes.
I agree with your viewpoint 👍 . Scripture says when 2 or more are together , Jesus is there also !!! A couple with Strong Faith and Love will always have Jesus with them. A true blueprint for happiness and blessings. A powerful scene for sure 💖
I felt like juice coming out from the tank was like scary sorry for bein a weirdo
@@sarahd3307 it also could have been symbolic! I did think about how wine was made when I saw that. We are all weirdos in some way haha. God loves Weirdos!
As a Catholic, I find these discussions to be not only fascinating but also extremely beneficial to my outlook of religions. Thanks so much and God Bless!
God bless you 🥰 It not about religion its about relationship. Jesus came to save the sinners.
-Once was lost but now I am found.
Catholics, original Christians, added doctrine based on what they knew to be true through sacred tradition and clarify teachings from the bible. It does take away from the bible. It only provides a deeper understanding of it. This commentary is a bit screwed towards the "protest"ant mindset. :-(
@@annab3868 The guy in the yellow sweater for sure was confrontational and condescending towards the priest the entire conversation. But whats new with a protestant acting anything but "christian like" towards a catholic.
@@tun6006 me. But it's probably the pagan stuff that gets him, not the guy himself.
@@annab3868 I think you meant to say, it does
"Not" take away from the Bible
I am beyond excited to see these three believers have a safe place to come together and express themselves. This is so powerful for those of us who grieve over the division. These three men are amazingly aligned in their faith. They articulate their beliefs so well without offense. Please do more of this it means so much to me and I’m sure to others who pray for unity. Powerful stuff! Please keep these conversations going
Just amazing how much work and painstaking detail Dallas has put into this😁 God Bless all the people who are making this happen 🙂
Carolyn Edgar you took the words right out of my mouth. So amazing!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Dallas, beside talking too much, is a genius thinker.
@@mariaesparza4067 amen🤗
Absolutely!
@@carolynedgar1090 yes
My neighbors are 86 yr old Catholic couple and they were blown away byt this series! Loved it and shared it with everyone they know!
I, too, am 86, a cradle Catholic, am blown away by the effort and study and study you have put into this series. The Ignatian way of reading and meditating on Scripture is so evident.
Lifelong Protestant, Catholic for 3 years, doing doctoral work on Jesus and his humor. Thank you SO much for this series! Finally to see Jesus laugh and be fully human! And to look more Jewish and not be a skinny depressed looking Anglo!
Hi! Fellow catholic here, I would love to know more about that doctoral work on Jesus's humor! I've always think that he must be really joyful and funny. We have humor, and it's good, so it must come from Him! Good luck and God bless
Also a fellow catholic and would love to read your work on Jesus humour, since I was a child I always pictures God and Jesus in my prayers as someone kind, but also humorous, it took me some time to realize a lot of people didn't share their view (which really saddens me) so both this show and your work, really interests me.
Pretty please, let us read your doctoral work once it's finished.
I'm so joyful just thinking of it
God bless you 🙏
How do you know what Yeshua looked like? The fact that you frame your image of Him as important to you, instead of allowing Scripture to define and interpret Him, makes me wonder if you have even read the Bible?, and seen who He is really, because if you had with eyes that truly see, and ears that truly hear, you would have noticed how the Most High is described, His physical attributes, and that Yeshua ONLY cared about the heart. Yeshua wouldn't care one bit about how he was portrayed in terms of His physicality, only that His words were accurately portrayed so that their meaning and their Spirit brought clarity, clarity of His Spirit, His Love, and His Light! You sound like one of these "woke" lunatics that are ruining the world, and our country, lost in their darkness, and the darkness of the world, the world of illusion.
@@j.b.8767 you can grab your judgement of me (which is stupid I have read it several times from childhood to now) and kindly keep it to yourself
This is such a wonderful discussion. I especially appreciate the drs. comments being an evangelical myself. I am 78 and hope I get to live long enough to see all seasons.
You will watch all the seasons, all of them
for your own sake come into communion with the Chruch, not matter how bad it seems from time to time we need humility
you have precious little time to do so
May The Lord continue to bless you and keep you strong.
Well to be fair if you don’t make it the show you will be seeing will be way better 😉.
@@Captain-Awesome My thought exactly. ❤️
A discussion rich in wisdom, honesty and insight. More of this please!
I love the commonalities revealed through this discussion. Faith really is beautiful.
Loved this...I have read THE BOOK many times over my 70+ years...but this movie helped me so much to experience the GENTLENESS of Jesus, in words, eyes, and body language. It has helped me be more gentle with myself. THANK YOU
I am so impressed by the Rabbi and his appreciation of the authenticity of The Chosen. I'm a Catholic convert with deep love and respect for the Jewish tradition and the Hebrew Bible, which I have been spending time studying (in Hebrew). We are all children of the One Holy One - "Eyeh Escher Eyeh". This whole series rings true. Much gratitude for you all.
"blessed be the peacemakers" - this round table of religious traditions representation is a table where peace is existing - especially pertinent in view of history. it's a blessing that this TV show is assisting toward transcending beyond regrettable aspects of that past history
I am a lifelong Catholic and I really enjoy this show. God bless you!
I love seeing this. The show is amazing! But the fact that people from several faith traditions can talk in respect for each other, that is terrific as well. We all worship the same God, after all!
This a a great discussion, such respect for each other's beliefs. This is pure religion on screen, to be open minded brings the spirit and The Chosen episodes are touching people's hearts ☺. Thank you Dallas and the team.
I’d say being “open minded” in the sense of allowing room for totally opposing views, especially ones that clearly contradict scripture, is dangerous. we are told to test all things, and that the spiritual man judges all things.
I really like how they did this. Please please PLEASE continue these round tables.
i’ve read my Bible cover to cover, like a novel, and now on my 2nd round. BUT after watching the Chosen series, it’s become MORE ALIVE for me…. their humor, their heartaches, their doubts, their faith…. EVEN their names, now i know who is who EASILY.
Thank you, Chosen team! ❤❤❤
That scene at the end with Jesus and Mary-- those words!!! I cry every time! Those words are exactly what we all want to hear-- You are mine! Well done!!!! This series has changed my life!
The keyword here is "plausible". If only we can do away with the "rigid legalism" and just enjoy the show, then there shouldn't be criticisms, instead, there should be compliments on how the bible is brought to life and help us want to dive deeper to the Word of God. So I for one am going to say "Thank You, Jesus! Thank You for leaving us with such rich words that even if we study Your Word 24/7, we would still be in awe of what You have done and what You are doing. Thank You for such creativity, even by The Chosen Team. Thank You, Dallas Jenkins, and each and everyone who made a commitment to make this show possible." I can't wait for the succeeding seasons! Keep up the good work! :)
I love how much thought, prayer and contemplation went into the creation of each episode. Thank you for all of this work - it blesses and enhances the final product, for sure!
I really felt close to Jesus after watching The Chosen
You are not alone. Most of us do. Of course, that is the will of God that we know that He is always with us and we have an intimate relationship and The Chosen aims to achieve that and many other important messages of the Gospel.
@Gabriel Wilder I can't believe this worked! Give it a try!
@Emilio Remington bots
@Clouseauish the God one
are you nuts? Catholics are NOT Christians.
The woman by the well...my favorite scripture... At this round table discussion we see all barriers shattered to pieces. Thanks God for inspiring the making of the Chosen.
My fave also!! 👏🙏❤
The woman kept building religious barriers " thats the fountain of our father Jacob"..." thats the mount we worship"... and Jesus just catch her attention with the things she really needed to hear, unfolding her heart to the truth she needed a Messiah more than man made traditions, desperately. Hes always one step ahead our best arguments hahah
Watching The Chosen makes me feel closer to Jesus
I am only alive due to Jesus. I was supposed to be dead from a car wreck on Oct 22, 1999. Almost 21 years. I love these films.
Hallelujah 🙌✝️ Jesus has literally saved my physical life SO many times I can't count anymore. Hallelujah 🙌
Jesus needs you J Burritt! And He loves you ❤
May God continue to be with you ( I was born that exact date)
GOD BLESS YOU WERE SAVED
Episode one I watched halfheartedly - not really focused enough to catch what this person Lilith was doing or who she was. When Jesus calls her out as Mary and says YOU ARE MINE - my insides both crumbled and exploded!!! The music crescendo empowered the visual and in that moment I was totally and completely hooked!!! This did start the series off with a tremendous bang.
I dont normally like to watch the thing with powerful spiritual significance being dissected down to the nuts and bolts for it tends to 'naturalize' and minimize a the thing that had a spiritual weightiness; however, I enjoyed this discussion greatly and appreciate the varying religious perspectives. Its like everything being done around this series is just so anointed and seems to be a demonstration of God's stamp of approval.
same 😂 thank you for describing the feeling perfectly ! that moment
I have never seen Jesus portrayed in such a relatable way in any other movie or series. In other versions he always seems sad and disappointed because of mankind's ways. In this series he is totally relatable as a human being that you would have liked and been drawn too. I have seen the first season several times and recommended many family and friends to watch it including non Christians. The response has been overwhelmingly positive. I love that Jesus is shown with a sense of humor and kindness in getting to know everyone he meets. His understanding of each individual and love he has for his followers regardless of their past is truly a gift for your heart and has brought my personal faith closer to him. Thank you for this gift.
are you nuts? Catholics are NOT Christians.
@@56pjr False
I agree with what Dr. Huffman said about how we "flatten" scripture. I had a hard time relating to who each of these characters were. Perhaps it's a lack of imagination or something, but it actually made it harder to understand. I have since had a better understanding and relationship with my bible but it was seeing past the black and white text to do that. This series has furthered my understanding of scripture by understanding the possibilities of what their character was like.
The Chosen has made me question why we have ignored the humanity of Jesus? God knows how hungry we all are for His gentle signs of love; how could we have missed this so very important message sent from God. I am grateful I have been blessed by these shows to see Jesus as someone, in my heart of hearts, knows he truly was. The winks brought tears to my eyes, as did the smiles, the hugs, the laughter. The creators and actors of The Chosen have been the catalyst of healing for me and so many. Thank you
The Catholic Church never has: “fully God, fully man.” Hypostatic union.
Dallas has directed the most beautiful depiction of Christ, His disciples, and the stories he told her brought to life in the most delightful way. I cannot wait for Season 2. Thank you Dallas. I don't know how we can thank you enough! Just in time for the World Revival!
I want to share about my near-death-experience together with my deceased daughter. It's a NDE story about the way our lives are judged and measured and analyzed by ETERNITY. It's about the strength of forgiveness that can change everything for the better, even on the other side. It's a story of hope and blessings to everyone who is looking for a PROOF OF ETERNITY, and that's the title of my book PROOF OF ETERNITY by Alba Monn. It's a story of hope and blessings to everyone who is mourning about the loss of a loved one, especially for parents who have lost their own children. I came to testify that ETERNITY is a fact, that our loved ones live on on the other side, that they want for us to be comforted and completely consoled by the truth, because the truth will set you free.
Blessings to everyone
I’m really believing that Gods hand is really at work here in this series about Christ!! I thank the Lord for such great writers. May He continue to Bless all of your efforts to present our Christ to the world!! I’m always so excited to see your film!! I just love them!!
I really like the openness in this ecumenical discussion.
I would like to tell you that I was gambling, not drinking and was touched by the Holy Spirit. I didn't even know it was the Holy Spirit. I knew instantly that something Holy touched me. I ran and told my husband something Holy touched me. That day changed my life forever... Love the Chosen.
God bless this program, in Christ Jesus. Amen.
This is so interesting and the fact that you have cared about all of the faiths that are affected by the story of the chosen and accepted their counsel is obviously a strong component of why this series resonates with so many and touches us on a deep level. One thing that is confusing to me it that I always thought the admonishment at the end of Revelation applied only to the Book of Revelation. The New Testament as a whole was not put together as a "book" until after John's time.
The Chosen is going to talk to many people from different backgrounds! A very anointed work and I truly see a lot of depth and great effect in it.
We need to share them with all others we know. Blessings
You see - this show also inspired more dialog between churches
Oh, I think Jesus really loves it 😊
Is there anyone who was raised in Christianity who didn't wish they had lived in the Bible Days and experienced seeing Jesus and the disciples? I know I did ! This Series is giving me a chance to Be There, to Experience personally the life of Jesus. There is a huge Emotional Impact and not just when there are Miracles. Seeing people's lives changed by their contact with Jesus is so moving. I have been brought to tears for some reason in Every Episode, in both happy and sad situations. This is reviving my spirit and inspiring me to reconnect with the Lord in a deeper way ! Thank you! This is a real Blessing !
Yehshua...Messiah for all. His name MEANS salvation!!!
Why were the round tables removed from The Chosen app? I only viewed a few but looked forward to getting through them eventually. I loved how the focus was on what brings us together as believers rather than what divides us.
not removed, just placed in a folder “Bible Stuff” at the heading along with the “Home” button
What I love the most about this series is how it shows the human side of those we have read about in the Bible. It makes things more real
I love how at 31:14 when he’s describing redemption and exile that the catholic and evangelical both start to smile and get happy knowing that the difference is God being there.
are you nuts? Catholics are NOT Christians.
@@56pjr how dare you judge my salvation! Judge not lest you be judged. For with what judgement you judge, you shall be judged... Matt 7:1-2
I am a convert to Catholicism & have never seen such a Christian people or sincere Christian worship.
@@56pjr what a ridiculous claim. come on now.
You mock God's Word, the bible. Repent or burn.
@@56pjr Only God decides that so SILENCE, is it you who spoke everything into being? Where you there to witness His glory? I know you meant it good but don't just "yell" repent or burn because it's not up to you. God bless you and don't take this as an attack of sorts I just want to tell you to share info better and not like that.
Y.E.S. ! ! ! This just gets better and better. I truly love y'all. "...For such a time as this..."
My family is all what I would call devout Catholics and we love The Chosen! They do a phenomenal job bringing the scripture to life! We tell everyone to watch it! Thank you to all your hard work Dallas! Praying for you and all of The Chosen team!
21:40 “evangelicals are very sceptical about calling anyone a saint”?
Saint is the word used by most translations to talk about anyone who is saved and made holy through Christ’s death.
If you’re a true Christian, if Christ actually lives in you, then you are a saint. Even if you don’t feel like one.
We are all saints in the making, I agree. Jesus only got the process started
@@FiatVTua333 Yes. But I'd say much more than that. We are saints in the present. We have been given His righteousness. We grow into who we already are in Him. Bless you 😁
In the Catholic faith a saint is a person who makes it to heaven. Saint with a capital 'S' is a someone who has Died and has enough miracles attributed to the intercession of that person therefore we KNOW that person is in heaven. We believe the miracles would not have happened if that person is not in the presence of God in heaven. They are in God's presence in Heaven which is why the miracles came to pass. To clarify, God chooses to grant the miracle because of the Saint praying for it.
am thinking the context was more about canonization of an honorific sainthood status - not salvation status. Evangelicals might be ok with St. Peter or St. Paul, but start to squirm a bit when going beyond the apostles in so far as using that appellation as part of the person's title
amen, if we’ve been sanctified by the blood of Jesus then we are saints
What a great table talk. Thank you for this Dallas! Clarifying the purpose of the why and how the chosen came to life is fantastic. I've read the bible many times and I still have many questions to understand what was going on in that time. Your project has just been a bigger resource to my learning of the word of God. My imagination has never gone so far like yours has. Thank you for being so creative and bringing something new to us all. I am enjoying everything you and everyone involved are doing, the behind the sense, funny videos, the set, getting to know the cast,, etc.
I'm pretty sure this will never reach Dallas but I truly hope we get many more of these roundtable discussions between the four of you because it is an eye-opener as to what sort of discussions occur behind the scenes to come to the storyline portrayed in the chosen episodes. Really interesting!!
wow i have learnt so much and from different perceptions of christ God bless yall not to mention am a cross between pentacostal and evangelical, i got know why haven't i been watching these discussions!!
1st time listening in on the roundtable discussion. Really appreciate the depth of searching and understanding. These teachers really teach!
Hello Dallas
I just want to say thank you for showing Peter breaking the commandments of the Sabbath cause many, many , many of us do that and that's what is happening. This literally helps us understand nothing happens when you put everything else first and God last or even so it is ok to break a commandment for our needs cause our needs are provided by our Heavenly Father so really it is not an option or a choice breaking a commandment. We have to keep each of them.
i just want to say this... cool profile picture lol
Why did it take me so long to find this!?! I was talking about the show with a friend over a campfire and he turned me on to the extra stuff. Thank you so much for this ministry and may God continue to bless you and keep you safe!
Your not alone in that. Learned of it a few months ago and tried to watch the first episode, couldnt get into it. There was alot of distractions while we were trying to watch. Revisited it a couple weeks ago.....and really engaged! Binged the entire first season, and first three episodes of S2 in a couple days. Absolutely cannot get enough of this bonus content now waiting for new episodes to be released.
are you nuts? Catholics are NOT Christians.
Very good talks and helpful to bring bible to live today. Thank you very much
I just praise God for the huge amount of work Dallas, the cast and the crew are putting into creating the Chosen, yet making sure it honors Scripture by consulting Bible scholars. Many thanks!
Love that these faiths came together, it’s amazing how much each belief has so many more similarities then sometimes we realize. We need to give credit to that and recognize that we are not all as different as some would like us to believe.
The more I learn about this production the more I appreciate the work and dedication of all involved, but above all, the love I have for the Lord only increases. He’s being glorified! ❤️
Agree and thankful.
After watching a few episodes, I really enjoyed this conversation explaining some of the details and background on the production of The Chosen. Your hard work is very much appreciated!
Thank you so much for all your efforts to make this show as authentic as possible GOD bless you all
THANK YOU DALLAS. I FEEL MUCH MORE SAFE WITH YOUR ATTENTION TO DETAILS AND GOD.
Love these conversations! So appreciate learning from the different perspectives represented here. Thanks, Dallas, for going “the extra mile”: to ensure historical/cultural authenticity and creative plausibility for The Chosen.
Keep this up and you are going to create a wonderful, respectful world where we LISTEN to each other!!!!!!
Our Father in heaven must be “well pleased”. THANK YOU!!!!
I disagree as a Catholic. I have no qualms with Simon Peter and how he was portrayed. We remember that Peter denied knowing Christ 3 times. He was anointed on Pentecost and went on to head the church and die for his faith. Saints were human ! They struggled and inevitably chose to give it all to The Lord in true obedience. No need to be scared of that portrayal. Love the show!!
yeah evangelicals is really annoying lol, they are just spiritually dead, most of the american one
@@feliciaf8 how many do you actually know , personally?
@@feliciaf8 evangelicals put this show together. Dallas is an evangelical.
@@liljade53 yeah that's the sad part, i hope it was written by catholics or orthodox
@@feliciaf8 LOL, whatever
I really enjoyed episode 1, and enjoyed this dialogue!!! Very happy that these voices were heard, and the writers took their views and expertise into account. Can't wait to continue watching.
This show is SO anointed! It has made such an impact in my life. I love the level of excellence in every detail of the show.
This series makes the story look real and you are drawn in because they feel like we would feel if Jesus came now in our time to our village.
I'm New in The Chosen App. I'm from.Colombia. God bless You. You bring heaven on heart.
Wish all 8 episodes of the discussion panels were on CZcams. Only seen this one. Can't watch on my phone cause it would eat up my data like a lot... Can't wait for more episodes! God bless!
The marriages of Peter & Nicodemus were eye opening! One wife expected her husband to follow Jesus. The other wife wants her ‘old life’ back. She seemed to shame Nicodemus into doing ‘the right thing’. My heart broke for Nicodemus.
Well N's wife didn't know he met the Messiah. You cannot compare both situations and shouldn't blame N's wife
@@CoachMischatrue, but N’s wife also didn’t care enough at what is bothering N, why he wanted to stay. She just assumed he is being silly.
Thank you JESUS ❤️🙌
I wish you had invited to this roundtable the Franciscan Priest who gave an awesome review to the series...
I think this show is magnificent. Just Love it soooo much.
Mary's declaration in Luke 1:46ff is profound. "My soul magnifies the Lord, And my spirit has rejoiced in God MY Saviour..."
In the last day there will only be two churches. I love the unbiased faith of those who love and serve God coming together to make this film. It's a beautiful work.
Discernment...not just Imagination...when you percieve and discern...
Agreed.
Right, for instance, the episode of the Samaritan woman is a great example of wonderful perception and incredible discernment. One of my favorite scenes!!!🙏❤👏🥰
Great discussion! Some fascinating revelation. Looking forward to seeing this in Canada!
The Holy Spirit ignites the imagination and fills in the beautiful details making this just come alive in ways that are true....Deeply moving and alive!
This is the best.I am sharing all I know about CHOSEN. God bless
Thank You so much Dallas! I am so Grateful ☺
I'm a fairly traditional orthodox Catholic (not a sedevacantist though!) and I love 'The Chosen' !!!!
Thank you so much for all of this, every piece of content I have watched from this show was amazing!
I’m touched by the tangible reality of the humanity of Jesus, and the thoroughness that’s woven into every aspect of this amazing portrayal of Jesus bar Joseph. Who earned His Chosen position of The Messiah… Our Lord and Savior Jesús Christ. Bravo👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
I love this show. I don't know enough about Judaism. It really is amazing to me. I find that I have grown spiritually from this show. There is so much of our Christian heritage that we don't know about. I appreciate it so much. I am donating to the show tomorrow. It really is so needed. Even my teenager's love it, and the one is wanting the t-shirt for his birthday!
Dallas, I am a modern Catholic, so I don’t know why other Catholics will take bad.
I am new to you, your community and especially to The Chosen. However, I love this type of round tables and for what is worth, you should keep doing them. God love you and your family.
I wish Dallas would reach out to or look up Dr. Scott Hahn someday. 🙂
Absolutely
I loved the scene Jesus and Mary
Thank you Dallas for being so open-minded to have an open discussion and understanding of all denominations. You are a role model for the world for how disagreements or differences can be done respectfully. I wish our entire world in the religious and political Arena could work that way! Wouldn't that be amazing?! We all love our Lord and we all are doing our best to serve him.The panel was very kind and understanding and respectful of each other's differences. Dallas I understand that some evangelicals believe that we Catholics idolize statues but that is not true we honor the beautiful historical religious people in scriptural history.We honor Mary the Mother of God, we do not worship her. Miracles have been done through the power of Jesus through his mother with many miraculous appearances through history to encourage people to pray . Catholics pray to Mary with the Hail Mary prayer using verses from the scriptures of the Bible to ask her to pray to her son Jesus for us as her intercession with Jesus is a very strong bond. That bond is beautifully exemplified in the movie The Chosen. Great Job Dallas!
This was really a enlightening table talk....God bless you men of courage
As someone who is theologically and philosophically inclined I appreciate The Chosen as it provides a decent amount of context (with some artistic liberties to be sure) of the Gospel narratives to a large group of believers and non-believers alike who I believe like me appreciate a point of context to connect more with the Gospel narratives. I also like that it is providing alternative “entertainment” (or perhaps “edutainment”is a better word?) that carries themes that are redemptive and hopeful in juxtaposition to the overwhelming hedonistic and nihilistic content that seems to be popular on streaming platforms these days.
What a great conversation about interpretation of the Bible.
I am so glad you guys are having these discussions. It’s just so cool
Love what the Rabbi says and how Hebrew and Aramaic can so capture, with just one word because of its many nuances, the meat of a subject. My mother would not allow us to play with Quija boards, etc. because she felt it would open us up to evil. At the time, I was a kid, I thought it was because she was so English and it was an old English wive's tale. Now I find out she was right and, apparently, a tad Jewish since what the Rabbi said is essentially the case! haha
funny, my grandmother would not allow us as Catholic boys to play with the quiji boards as she would caution: when you open that door you have no control over what comes through that door.... scared the bejeebers out of us!
I played it and paid dearly for it many years later. Had Jesus not stepped in, I wouldn't be here now.
@@mountainwarrior8387 PRAISE THE LORD!!!! If you need anything let me know!! God bless you brother or sister!
@@mountainwarrior8387 omg
What happened??
@@chelseaxoxo784 When I was eight years old, I and several friends were "playing" with a Quija board. Whatever was guiding it seemed to focus on me. I asked its name and it spelled out "Joe Joe". Being young and, let's face it, stupid, I was flattered. Off and on for the rest of my life, supernatural things begin to take place. Nothing scary, at least not at first. When I was in my mid-30s, I knew without a doubt the "nothing scary things" began to take on a much more ominous presence. I began to hear vile threats against my life and those of my family. In shark terror, and scrambling to hold onto my sanity, I screamed, "Who are you??" I heard these simples words and thought my fate was sealed. "We are Joe Joe!" Words cannot be to describe my sheer terror. For the next eight months, I was tormented day and night, ending up in several institutions where no one could help me. Many, many times I called out begged God to help me. I thought my cries were falling on death ears because I had done this to myself. One day in the middle of my madness, the voices stopped; the tormented ended. God has stepped in and set me free! God gave me many dreams to confirm to me that He would never allow it to happen again and He's answered my many questions about why it happened in the first place. It's very long and very powerful story. But more important than any of it is the fact that God loved me enough to set me free and I give Him ALL GLORY AND ALL HONOR for His mercy and grace!!!
I was in a detox unit in Florida in a horrible physical and spiritual condition, waiting for an ambulance to take me to the ER because my blood pressure became uncontrollable when Jesus changed my life..so portraying Jesus going into a bar in my opinion is great and probably something he would have done to save that one sheep, he often used that in his parables. Did he not?
I agree with the evangelical preacher, I couldn't wait to grab my Bible, The Chosen helped to deepen the connection, and helped me to imagine what the characters were going through in the moment and what they may have been like, (like the Catholic priest encouraged).
Same here. The practice of imaginatively reading the scriptures by St Ignatius of Loyola is truly a powerful and immersive experience. (See Ignatian Contemplation) It's like a time machine that transports you to Jesus' time. I imagine how I would feel, what my reactions would be, what I would say to Jesus, and what He would say to me. Sometimes I imagine I'm one of His disciples. There are moments when I'm crying especially when meditating on the passion narrative/the sorrowful mysteries of the rosary. When meditating on the mysteries of the rosary, I imagine holding Mother Mary's hand as she walks me through her Son's life and try to empathize with her and imagine how she's feeling; like when the Angel Gabriel appeared to her in the annunciation, her worry when her Son is missing, her agony when her Son is being humiliated, tortured, and killed, etc.
Thank you Dallas, for acknowledging what Greek believers have done for Christianity. Its often overlooked
This is so good! We definitely need more of these!!
About Mary and Jesús scenes; when she sadly said “He doesn’t need me anymore” brought tears to my eyes, been there said that, but a nice laughter when he came back tires to the camp. No Matt how old your children are you are there for them🙏🙏
I’m really appreciative of the effort that was put into this show, and I love the fact that these round tables are held with constructive criticism from people who know what they’re talking about. It’s awesome to see these traditions in conversation with eachother: this is *real* ecumenicism - the kind that really matters.
used to be these traditions really upheld but not anymore
Bird man: I don’t agree or understand ! Do you practice your faith? If not how can you judge others?
@@jamesmaher1989 yeah you don't understand what i'm trying to say. yes i practice my faith but i'm still in the fork road of Catholicism or orthodoxy. what i'm trying to say is about protestantism
birdman that’s ok 👍 perhaps each faith tradition helps us to approach and draw closer to God? Perhaps no single tradition gives us the whole picture?
Jesus Christ is the way the truth and the life
I loved listening to this dialog. Fascinating ! Thank you.
You start out with a bar joke and end up at the bar scene. Now that's a roundtable....Lol. Just love these discussions and all the input and thought process that have gone into this episode. Looking forward to all the rest. God Bless!!