'Vacuum for terror' created by security services could threaten Putin's regime | Philip Ingram
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 05. 2024
- Destabilisation of the world system by China and Russia has caused their security agencies to take an eye off terror groups and created a 'vaccuum' for terror attacks, Philip Ingram tells #timesradio
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Dictators don't care about the people they rule over. It's always about themselves.
It's about the state, that's all this dictator care about. He don't give a f**ck about the people.
Putin creates always and everywhere terror, he is the troublemaker, and he doesn't care, what a shame!!!!
Trumps a dictator wanna be
@@nuttywalls8190 i know where I'm going ia what MATTERS
This is a battle between Good and Evil. Lying is the main weapon of Evil. Good is winning now, Evil is losing, so there will be more and more lies from Western media and pro-Western bloggers. Sanctions didn't work, billions in weapons didn't help, the counteroffensive didn't work, propaganda didn't work, terrorism is all they have left. Terrorism won't work either. It just shows how desperate Evil is.
Amazingly clever man!Excellent interview!Thank you😊😊😊
Excellent insight and oversight!
It was incompetence that the authorities didn't intervene immediately. There was a relatively recent case in Uvalde, Texas, where at a school shooting police waited outside the building for something like 45 minutes before they did anything so the perpetrator could shoot more school children.
But still the shooter was shot. Where were the security services in moscow? How could the terrorists escape?
There were police in that venue. And the police station was 5 mins walk away. But it wasn't just cops that took 1 hour 40 mins, suspiciously it was also the fire and ambulances absent as well. Can't help but think dark thoughts.
It was incompetence as well as deep rooted paranoia. Never assume the obvious, there is always a hidden agenda, Maskirovka,
Russia has done similar suspicious things in decades gone by. Some refer to them as "inside jobs." I don't believe it myself, but some claim Dunblane was a similar thing.
@@m.walther6434If it walks like a duck and quacks, it's probably a duck.
Prior to this event there were warnings from other countries of a 'terrorist attack in Moscow, possibly on a threatre', the venue did not screen for weapons (which always occurs), the police did not respond despite having a station 50 metres away, the alleged attackers drove away in the same car that was allegedly intercepted on the highway to Belarus, having escaped the most secure part of the most secure city in Russia, then driven for hours. Hmmm, how did these Tajiks enter the country, how did they aquire automatic weapons and ammo and bomb-making equipment in a massively surveiled police state? And what, they just walked past security with Kalishnikovs, wearing military fatigues?
It's also an interesting coincidence to occur right after Putin's 'election', to conveniently be blamed on Ukraine (which makes no sense), right before a larger mobilization that was expected.
So yeah, this smells like a false flag staged by Putin. The FSB was caught planting a bomb in 1999, to inspire fear of terrorism, to justify the Second Chechen War, which solidified Putin's hold on power.
Putin has a history with false flag events to justify war. Ukraine has no history of terrorism. This event can work to Putin's benefit but would very much work against Ukraine's desires.
Is Islamic State or the Russian state responsible? Both can be true. All the FSB had to do was to allow IS to get easy access to weapons, to drop security and let them do their attack, to then blame on Ukraine.
You're right, assumptions are bad ... but if it walks like a duck and quacks, it just might be a duck.
Al this was done by themselves to find support by their own people
How can they talk about terrorism by someone else.
Because they are full of it - and always have been!
very good interview!!!!! lot's of new and great info, thanks
Such as?
If only any of it were true
Why on this one day, were the metal detector machines not working???? And Yes, why did it take the riot police just 5 minutes away, 90 minutes to respond.????
You think metal detectors would have changed the situation?! I don't think the strikers were hiding their weapons
Because it was a blatant inside job.
And this is not Russia’s first rodeo either.
Becsuse the USA was involved
There hasn’t been any attacks recently but two afghans (possible ISIS-K?) were arrested in Germany just the other week for planning an attack in Sweden. They had automatic weapons. Last year ISIS-K pulled off a string of assasinations in Afghanistan including a provincial governor.
There was a recent attack in Afghanistan on the 21st of March where 20+ were killed.
Lol.
They killed 89 people and injured nearly 300 at a memorial event for Soleimani in Iran in January this year.
Is that not recent enough?
The concert hall was totally destroyed. Why didn't the sprinklers in the concert hall work? Did the contractors not bother to install a sprinkler system?
You find the sprinkler system on a bank account in Switzerland
There's almost no quality or safety control of any kind in russia, I know this first-hand
Even the emergency exits were locked, which are supposed to be open. Let alone the police and FSB bureau is 2 mins away, yet it took them more than an hour.
Russia's security apparatus is not designed for stuff like this; it's an apparatus designed to protect the elites from protests. They can only do it well on high profile occasions, like olympics etc.
@@AeSyrNation Yes. A mining engineer once told me that he went from Scotland to work in Russia as an advisor, and that mostly he spent his time discouraging the local miners from accidentally killing themselves.
@andyhurrell everything to do with mining and high-voltage power line construction and maintenance carries with it a roughly 50% mortality rate.
This I, funnily enough, also know first-hand, but apart from that, it's just a well-known thing in russia.
People usually agree to those jobs because they're relatively short-term (usually 3-6 months) for, by russian standards, astronomical pay-offs
Nice, and refreshing, to hear from an expert who knows what he is talking about.
Or not. Would you be able to tell the difference?
"Is putin high on his own supply" Only in Britain 😂
This man has a very good analysis of the Ukrainian strategy. Only one side has the moral high ground in the way it fights in this war.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Are you a Banderite 😊😂😂
@@sickboy8682 do you know sickboy8683?
@sickboy8682 do you know who they are?
@@AeSyrNationazov
Very substantial reasonng! Clearheaded man - well he's an analyst for a reason, obviously. Please bring him on as often as appropriate / relevant, because he also doesn't push some strange agenda or something. He "just" represents a sober and knowlidgeable view!
He is not pushing an agenda? Probably nothing obvious, he is just lying with every breath he makes. Not sure if that is an agenda in itself, he is just forming a completely false image in the brain of gullible people who get all their news from Times Radio and similar sources.
Police action was slow because none of the concert-goers were holding blank placards.
I do believe ISIS did it? But russia didn't know it would happen, really? - In the concert hall, people panicking, being murdered all around, _who_ were the dozens of equally dressed "little blue men" who weren't being shot at, and remained calm? - As firearms the terrorists used the AK-101, a weapon that _only_ the russian special security service use and have access to. How did the terrorists get those weapons? Some parts of this story are very weird.
Russia obfuscates. Ignore everything they say if you want to keep your sanity.
Especially if you're a Brainwashed fool ! 🤣
That is a superb advice! Ignore everything that does not fit into your world view. God forbid you find out something that clashes with it. Keep it up!
In their grief over lost loved ones , in this awful disaster,I wonder if Muscovites could realise that this grief is being experienced by the families of the hundreds of thousands of soldiers who have died in Putins war on Ukraine …. maybe too many of those soldiers have been ripped out of some of the ethnic communities within Russia…. and grief is turning to anger in those places !
People in Moscow need to pay heed to the actions of their country …. Ukranians have their buildings bombed on a daily bases by Russia…. children mothers and the elderly are experiencing this type of atrocity regularly…..
Seems to me that the conscience of the Russian people could do with some examining!
It's Washingtons war, Carole. Do some research. Start with Foreign Affairs magazine spring/summer 1997, Zbigniew Brezhinski.
Washington tries to fight against men like Putin, Saddam, and Gadaffi; Russia tries to fight against Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, Batak Obama. Sure it’s messy but pick your side carefully.
@@johnhume4346 couldn’t get info unless I subscribed……did google Brezhinski tho …can see he was a diplomat/National security advisor for Jimmy Carter…do you mean that with better diplomacy this Russian war with Ukraine could have been avoided? Seems the US could have given Ukraine what it needed to push Russia out immediately tho ………once it started! Maybe if Ukraine had remained neutral and not declared its intention to join NATO………maybe Putin could have accepted their sovereignty!! But Putins rhetoric of late indicates he is mad for expansion!
@carolechapman7857 Russia sees nato expansion as an existential threat. We gave our word in the 80s, and we would not expand nato "one inch to the east" in 1997. Brezhinski published a book called "the grand chessboard" and Bill Clinton decided to use that book as a blueprint for US foreign policy. In effect, the spread of US global hegemony. (Not everyone views US dominance as the model to follow). The 2014 us backed coup in Ukraine was the final straw for the Russians.
Nyet means nyet.
Excellent interview! Always enjoy Mr. Ingram’s analysis! 🇺🇦✌️
Ukreign killed Who's streets: Our streets. The British police are after you.
Analysis involves looking at the facts and the big picture and trying to understand what the reality is. This was a bunch of lies, misleading nonsense and downright ludicrous logic.
@@libertarianbydefault Clearly another ruzzian bot!!
On one of the tapes, i saw an officer with a dog walking around before the concert started.???
Is it possible that Putin himself masterminded this horrendous act so he could lay the blame on Ukraine? That would explain the terrible response times!
Well Putin is certainly well-capable of not batting an eyelid over the death of 100+ of his own people !
Excellent ananlysis.
Why? I found it to be lacking evidence. All just talk.
@@kennethkeen1234somwun who carnt shpell shud wirk for the bbc lolz
Excellent stream of "Here is what I think but will present as factual truth".
Having listened a second time: still an excellent analysis, based on a large amount of facts.
@@monikahammaren8509 What facts? I am not trying to be argumentative but Phil is full bias and propaganda. You want actual analysis and facts - try The New Atlas. Brian Berletic actually performs analysis of the attack and the way the US has been involved in this kind of operations for decades. Try Sonar21 - Larry Johnson actually performs analysis. And unlike Phil, Larry is actually qualified to perform analysis, because he is an ex-CIA analyst. Or you can dismiss all this as "Putin propaganda" and keep listening to Times Radio. :D
And whilst you have air-time could you expand on the use of mobile crematoria by Russian forces in Bucha & Mariupol amongst other places: why is Senhor Gutteres, UN 0:15 0:15 Secretary General. so pointedly silent on Putin’s behaviour on the international front?
Excellent video, I love all your accents of course but Phillip's accent is just wonderful.
So true
What if the attack is similar to that of bombing of building to implicate chechinia?
It is the same. Although this time it could be actors in the Russian government who want to replace Putin, for example Patrushev
The police were 90 minutes late to the terrorist attack. It was almost as if someone told them to stand down so there would be as much carnage as possible.
Either that or... it was the good ole ruzzian incompetence.
they let the perpetrators to run to their master and alas😂😂😂
Did you notice the cop inside the complex, with the Dog, just walking away, at the onset of the shooting?
And the police Canine van, parked outside?
Yep. Putin thought oh, well. Their slaughter lets me feed mum propaganda machine to be swallowed by gullible, brainwashed Russians. Why he bothers lying … everyone know he’s lying.
FSB vs Putin.
Thank you for this thoughtful analysis. Mr. Ingram is a wise, wise man.
On 22 March, terrorists attacked a terrorist state. The terrorist state, Russia, is led by an incompetent dictator and incompetent security services that are tasked to protect the power elite. Protecting people and public safety is not their concern unless they are directed to do so since independent thought, initiative, and honesty are seen as a dangerous trait in Russia. Only loyalty to the dictator and unquestioning obedience is valued.
Calm down and try to say it again without all the silliness.
@@kennethkeen1234 Sorry the truth offends you, Karen, I hit close to the mark then. 😉
You offer no logical arguments so this is a Logic Fallacy called Attacking the Person, used when you cannot come up with facts, data, or intellectual arguments.
Attacking the Person Logic Fallacy: This fallacy occurs when, instead of addressing someone's argument or position, you irrelevantly attack the person or some aspect of the person who is making the argument.
You sound much like a clearly misinformed Ru bot@@kennethkeen1234
Hey YT... read this [...... ]
@kennethkeen1234 MRO's theory sounds more probable than your remark, which states nothing!
FSB is there only for Putin’s safety number and secondary are Kremlin's elites under Putin! FSB doesn't care and aren't paid for the safety of Russian citizens. In truth, citizens are the state's enemy!
You forgot abt the 400+ Himars that Poland will buy👍
Really? Great job Russia😅
Mi6 getting the blame now from Russia 🙄
In 1942, the British defence budget was 40% of GDP. It’s 10x to 20x cheaper to properly prepare for war.
Arranged by Putin why didn’t police turn up for an hour
Because THEY would have ended up in jail.
takes them minutes to arrest protestors!!!
Last 10-minutes is well stated. Thanks n
Where are the F-16 planes
What are you talking about? fool.
They will be here right before summer time!
The only Thing Putin understand is power
Closing the border when they are already in your countries what is the points 😂
At least to make it more difficult for more to sneak in? Is that a simple enough point for you to comprehend?
The attackers weapons were riffles that only FSB use and have access to and FSB where in the concert hall.
And one of the FSB officers that captured the attackers were seen sitting in the concert hall.
There's a police department in the building right next to the concert hall but it took them 90 minutes to get there?
It all smells to high heaven
The FSB also hires former ISIS fighters from Russia and other former USSR countries in exchange for a reduced sentence, some of these fighters are sent to Ukraine to infiltrate muslim units fighting for Ukraine. I bet they'll find some "connection" between one or more of these scapegoats or terrorists and some Chechen or Tatar unit in Ukraine.
Agreed. It’s most definitely an inside job.
Thank you.
Continuous retreat and defeat at every step is being called "positional warfare", for all those unaware.
Interesting thank you.
Not incompetence! They were not prepared! They were hiding. Waiting.
You have a huge cold, James. Take care !!❤🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
The West could ramp up production of drones to bridge the gap between supply of more advanced technology.
I think they're planning to send a million drones to Ukraine this year.
Very informative and interesting piece.
Good interview.
Great interview and fascinating
Interesting insight 👍
Great show! Hopefully, we (USA) can get our act together.
We will within the next month, $61 billion will be passed
Is it possible the attack, the claim of responsibility are FSB manufactured?
Why 'some sinister ' could be credible - there has been long infighting within FSB for control of Moscow. Osechkin covered this internal struggle a year ago.
Its Crapita festroying our recruitment
Sounds good. Even if it's 25%, it would be an unimaginable disaster if that was the case for the USA.
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🌹❣️✊🏼 NATO needs to support Ukraine fully; especially the U.S.!
NATO does not NEED this. It "kind of wants to", as long as it does not cost too much
UK Did it last year with the Sunday 3 o'clock alarm via phones and the appeal for more troops.
they were caught too easily, something fishy going on!
It is not true that the involvement of ISIS is being dismissed - it has been established that they were the ones who carried out the attack. What is being dismissed is that mercenaries (and those attackers behaved like mercenaries) got the idea to do this on their own, that no one put them up to this. And this is where the trail is leading to Ukraine, MI-6 and CIA. Times Radio dismissing this detail is telling.
I wish the Brit’s weren’t scared of Trump. He’s going to jail not the White House.
We Brits aren’t remotely scared of Trump. What are you talking about?
But I do agree, he’s most likely going to jail.
Every one of these interviews lately with British* guests say so themselves. Philip Ingram said so in this video. Something along the lines of we’re worried about a possible Trump presidency. It’s what prompted me to type the original comment.
But, I am scared of this being said too much for fear of voters not showing up thinking Biden is a sure thing.
*I should be careful calling out the British exclusively because I’m not sure where all these interviewees are from. I’m just going off of their accents.
Some great questions and some great answers. Damning indictment of Min of Defence spending. Somebody need to get in there and sort it out.
CANADA also warned Russia Why don’t you mention that
So sick
Two percent is a peacetime level of spending. A country saying they will spend the minimum 10 years from now. That is not a defensible country
Question From a RA, risk assessment, viewpoint should tug attendance consider 1. The speed of vl wrt the amount of kinetic energy, 2 single point failure such as DP class vls use i.e. redundancy such as twin propellers, bus bar configuration. There are many more consideration which RA may include, Cost always being a main driver
Putler's vaunted security forces blew it bad. Putler is blaming others for his own bungling.
The “Hitlerisation” of Putin is infantile. I’d explain why but you don’t have the IQ.
@turbolevo8703 I have an academic degree. I have a PhD in Biology so I am looking forward to your wise words.
This has been really informative and eye opening. Would like to know what Labour would offer if they get into power
❤❤❤❤❤
who
The civil service procurement seems to endlessly buy cheapest and then find out the quality isn't there.
No no no!
There are number of videos from within the theater where some fit man in blue shirts were exchanging instructions to close the doors that would stop people from leaving the theater. They seem to be calm and not worried at all. FSB assets?
Common sense! Why are they celebrating amidst this terrible war? War is a terrible thing for humans. Human life is so precious: this a simple fact all humans know. See! Those who didn't attend are safe at home.
are there any more recruits available?....let alone stripping their borders of actual defense border forces...the east of russia is wide open for china recapturing lost 1800s territory...all for the sake of one man?
Black Swan Event? Thousands of Security at Navalmy Funeral but none at Concert Venue despite repeated warnings from USA, UK and presumably others, teported local Concert Security ran sway locked themselves in office.Just like Tunisia years ago when Llocal Jihadi shot many victims on beach, local vops locked themselves in office mobile police including head of police turned off their radios
People holding a blank piece of paper get a way more swift response from the security services than the terrorists did firing off multiple weapons in the concert arena. Now, ain’t that something to consider!
"Defence products tends to be made in your own country" - that might be the case for some large countries, but for most of the small country defence hardware spending is money out of the country. Military salaries, of course, is all domestic.
Germany considering closing their borders? That’ll be the day! I thought Germany had a permanent open door policy - for the world and his dog.
This vote will definitely be about defense...and British economy...and NHS...and youth apprenticeships to higher levels...and homes for everyone instead of housing collections for the few
So everything then? Lol a bit of a dopey comment really
If you had of mentioned Canada warnings it can’t be pointed to the US duh
Times radio asking same questions with every guest
Whilst I always enjoy your show I should ask why there is no counter to the hateful and maniacal broadcasts given on mainstream Russian TV, causing hysteria and gross deception for Russian popular consumption; surely we could advocate for Ukrainian supporters in adjacent countries to open second or even third and fourth fronts in previously occupied lands such as N. Ossetia, Abkhazia, Armenia, Trans Nistria etc.?
You mean clobber people who do not want to be parts of Georgia or Moldova respectively (I am dropping Armenia because it makes no sense)? You are a truly peace-loving, democratic, freedom-supporting chap I see. Or are peace, democracy and freedom reserved only for the "good guys"?
Unfortunately, Ukraine gave up their nukes. If they did not Russia would not start the war.
Well Russia (and the UK and USA) signed a treaty that they would protect Ukraine if they were invaded. Everyone stuck to the agreement - apart from the Russian’s. Funny that!
Its a worm moon
...chit is
Hittin da fan.
Worm moons are
Very very active ...
Life changing.
it is appalling the lack of support from the USA... not a dependable nation... one hopes other nations are taking note as they cannot depend on USA support... the Americans will sit back and watch.. as nations are destroyed...
You do know that Idiot Trump is the sole reason why our foreign aid is being held up, 1 person who isn't even in office is wailing his autocratic hand in politics!
Trumpy's time here in the free world will be over soon!
As someone else said America also put out that there were WMD.
Ok and they left Iraq and Afghanistan, we can say that those invasions were a mistake.
In UK the threat level is so high our prime minister has policemen and women running along the sides of his Cavalcade😮
You are obviously clueless about the UK, that's for sure
@@suburbia2050 czcams.com/video/zOjSCZYU9Qo/video.htmlsi=tGHNsx27s9ym2UR6
What about the men dressed in identical blue jumpers and jeans telling people to close the doors. One of them looks very similar to a man who appears with the beaten up (alleged) perpetrators.
"The terrorists went down that street there, and then, they went like that and then like that aaand like that, and then they went in that direction, like towards Ukraine and stuff..."
Putin : "Thankyou Shoigu."
Yep towards the Ukrainian border, or towards Belarus or east or west or north.
If "getting high on your own supply" was a thing,, then this guy is Ozzy Osbourne.
Belgarod is the new sacrifice 😂😂😂
Victim blaming ok when it suits.
Russian leadership and security services are desperate to blame anyone else other than themselves for the sad consequences of taking their eye off the ball, including ignoring explicit warnings out of paranoia and delusion. No-one blames innocent civilians, not even 'propaganda pushers' like Times Radio.
Only one person to blame, and that little man lives in the Kremlin.
WERE THEY FROM TAJIKISTAN OR AFGHANISTAN? I thought they were Tajik.
Night
I don't think they made the case that "'Vacuum for terror' created by security services could threaten Putin's regime". If you do, put a timestamp in a comment.
wait til the F16's arrive!!
Could you get any more flags into that camera shot? 🤔
Them flags are really kool 😊😊😊
What a w…..! He has zero idea!!
A lot of interviews several months with "could .. putin...". Always could.. sounds like if the sun shines than is it not nighy
He's right 😊. I've seen On international security council live meeting last night. The Rat is trying to push uncle Sam out and take over
James looks like Putin attacking Putin😅
James really didnt ask very good questions.
I was surprised at how childish he looked in his playjacket. Surely they could have afforded someone who looks a little serious at least.
Could you ask any better, what are they?
Yeah, like essential questions like " "what is your favorite color" , "what is your favorite breakfast".
They only asked about the terrorist attack and Ukraine. How strange.
@@Amradar123 James pretty much asked the same mundane questions i'd seen other radio jocks ask about the same topic,its like they all take cue's off each other,your sarcasm makes you appear immature btw.
So many people die and in terrible situations just because of the few elite.
…..because of one little elite!
Interview Jeffery sachs I dare you!
Sachs has turned into a dork. It is over 30 years since he was in the limelight as the Soviet Union collapsed and vassal countries turned to democracy and capitalism.