Buddhist Response to Zakir Naik's Claims About Buddhism - REACTION
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- Buddhist Response to Zakir Naik's Claims About Buddhism - REACTION.
► Subscribe: / @ftdspeaks
► Recent Videos: • Christian And Muslim D...
► Become A Member: / @ftdspeaks
---------------------
Original Video: • Buddhist Response To Z...
#Reaction #Buddhist #ZakirNaik #Buddhism #response #religion #islam #muslim
SOCIAL MEDIA
Facebook: / ftd-speaks-10449432206...
Instagram: / ftdonline
Twitter: / ftdonline
VIDEO EDITOR
Tori Melbourne: / littlered_tori
What a illogical joker Naik😂😂 he don't even understand what 4 noble truths means and why 8 fold path is suggested
You even donot know to understand the basic and goes into complicated and fails and brainwashed, that is it with you
While Buddhism is a tradition focused on spiritual liberation, it is not a theistic religion. The Buddha himself rejected the idea of a creator god, and Buddhist philosophers have even argued that belief in an eternal god is nothing but a distraction for humans seeking enlightenment.
Muslims talk about logics are the most hilarious thing I've ever heard.
The reality of the world is full of suffering. Buddha is showing us how to overcome them, learn Buddhist self awareness and try overcome the suffering caused by unpredictable hevan.
Zakir naik dont know about buddhism, even 4 nobel truth.. If you do not know something, it is better not to talk about it.. and im telling you all my friends who comment here.. please watch this video with open mind.. then you will realize what is truth or not..
Namo Buddhaiyae, Om Mani Padma Hum. A best path to the superior most the Almighty the ultimate is only through the Enlightened Buddha.
There is a concept of one God in Islam but God has no place in Buddhism and the Buddha said that I am not an incarnation or a prophet of any god. Islam is totally anti-science and Buddhism is based on science.
Non-violence is important in Buddhism, and what is in Islam is known
Does anyone notice that at one time the monk said God is not all powerful as he allows suffering…however in another breath, he sees understanding suffering as something that is actually good to get to the path…question is if understanding suffering is important for the path, how can you achieve that in absence of suffering
You right
the way one monk i met put it "if the world never knew what a lie is, then truth ceases to exist, because without lies, there are no truths"
Good point..!
So basically God allows suffering because He wants us to get to the path. Allowing us to suffer to get to the path means God is not all powerful? Mental gymnastic.
If you understand suffering, suffering doesn't exist anymore. You can't achieve that in absence of suffering. The absence of suffering is the final goal.
I am not a buddhist but I admire buddhist teachings and it is horrible to see how many people simplifies them or just lie about them
Study "Abidhamma" in Theravada u can understand the depth of Buddhist philosophy.
Please share some link or a pdf
Brilliant explanations. Person who don't have open mind, who cannot understand easily.
I think every muslim that watched this video want to answer the point that he made, me too, but my English is poor 🤣
Oh NO...
same problem with me!!!😅😅
I tried bro. 😂. My English is bad too.
සබ්බ පාපස්ස අකරණං
කුසලස්ස උපසම්පදා
සචිත්ත පරියොදපනං
එතං බුද්ධානසාසනං
මෙම ගාථාවෙන් කියවෙන පරිදි සියලු බුදුවරුන් ගේ අනුශාසනය වන්නේ සියලු පව් නොකිරීමද, කුසල් දියුණු කර ගැනීමද, සිය සිත පිරිසිදු කිරීමද වේ. (ධම්ම පදය - බුද්ධ වග්ගය, පස්වන ගාථාව).
As someone who has studied Buddhism for a long time, let me tell you this: Buddha actually didn't say anything about God, or even if he said, we lost it somewhere in history. Buddhism, like any other religion, has many sects, two of the main are known as Hinayana and Mahayana. The Mahayana Buddhists have been influenced a lot by Hinduism, after the 8th century shankarachrya started converting them back to Hinduism, left, right and centre. He would debate the Buddhist monks with the condition that if he won, the monk and all his followers would convert to Hinduism. After this, many things were changed dramatically in Buddhism. The Tibetan Buddhists that you see (Dalai Lama's sect), are Mahayanas and they actually worship Buddha, though Buddha never claimed to be God, just like Christians have done with Jesus. The Buddhism that you see these days is mixed a lot with Hinduism. In Tibet, you'll even find casteism among Buddhists, that too, very strong. The same thing that Buddha fought his whole life.
On the other hand, Hinyanas still have a somewhat purity of Buddhism left in them and they still don't talk about God. Some of them might talk about a Supreme Creator, but it doesn't come from Buddha. It comes from later developments in Buddhism.
In short, if you read deeply, even if there are many things i don't agree with Dr. Zakir Naik on, he wasn't wrong with this.
To know more, read about the life of Buddha from real books. You'll get to know.
you've helped me a lot.
Thanks. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@dan mann nothing to do with Buddhism and statues where made for reminders
@dan mann Any religion that kisses black stones with no artistic value at least are so 20,000 BC. CAVEMAN REPRESENT !!!
TRUST ME. ZAKIR NAIK DOESN'T KNOW JACK SH*T ABOUT BUDDHISM ! His Buddhist knowledge is EXTREMELY SUPERFICIAL.
@@dravidamonkey4253 He's right with this one, though. You can't prove a person wrong by saying he's wrong, you know? You need to give evidence of either what he is saying is wrong (from actual Buddhist scripture, or atleast from a very reliable historian), or you have to find evidence of the opposite of what he's saying to be true (again from sources and not some monk). In short, you need to prove him wrong by quoting SCRIPTURES.
I would suggest you read Romila Thapar's book on ancient India. She has written in detail about it.
If any viewer have similar thinking please watch Jeffrey Lang's The purpose of life.
His videos are beautiful. When I watch his points and analysis time goes by like a fly. He is really a smart guy.
@@Ahra-Su indeed ....🙏🙏
He's professor in mathematics in University in America 🇺🇸
Namo buddhaya ❤️
There is a big misconception about buddhist statues. Buddhists began to sculpt statues after they met the greeks and for a lot of buddhists: Statues are not objects of idolatry, but reminders of the teachings, and the Buddha is not considered a god but a great spiritual teacher.
About the belief in god, there are buddhists who believe in god or gods and there are others who don't. There is a story about the buddha in which he is asked stuff like: "Is there a god?" or "How did the world begin?" And he replied: I DON'T KNOW. There may be a god or not, but this is not important to me as my teachings are centered in the understanding of realities nature and specially for a practical approach. The aim of my teachings is above all the overcoming of suffering.
Maybe that's the reason why buddhism is in general known for respecting other believes. Note that the Buddha was a really racional teacher as he taught things like: "Never accept any truth, even those which I'm preaching without investigating it by yourself first." He was the most scientific spiritual leader I've ever come across.
When understanding the attributes of Allah. We cannot assume only one attribute applies at a single time. If we say Allah is All Mercy All Loving but then question why humans are suffering, then we forgot that this life is a test and Allah is All Just. And Allah tests those who He loves (actually acknowledging His All Mercy attribute at the same time) where to those who passes tests will be increased their ranks in the Hereafter and those who doesn’t will be judged with total justice. If theres no punishment or no rewards then God is not All Just and if theres no suffering (test) then theres no point living a temporary life.
For argument sake say Buddhist concept corrected Dr Zakir Naik. The Buddhist point totally neglects the existence of God. Happiness & Suffering. Relationship with the law of nature of life. And how to deal with it. Still cannot justify the wisdom behind the purpose of existence of happiness & suffering.
Every concepts of existence has it own purposes and wisdom. And if we ask the question what is the wisdom and reasoning behind it. Who are we mere humans who are just the ones experiencing it and not the one creating or bring it into existence in the first place to define it. Yes we can as an individual or as a group or community come out with a way we find best to deal with suffering/desires but still it doesn’t justify or clarify the wisdom or any reasoning of the existence of it in the first place. And something cannot come from nothing.
Hence, it leads logically to refer to the Almighty Creator of all things including happiness and suffering to tell us the wisdom and reason of its existence within the law of nature of life.
No one created the universe. Abhidhamma explains the process in the universe. I could prove those explanations mathematically.
Your allah is fake fabrication god you i**ot.
Hardest pills to swallow is "God created Good and Evil"...
This life is a test and good and evil part of it...
@@ssheikh3598
Stupid there is many scientific things to be learn
Go and learn those instead of reading dumb quran which is against to human kind.
I don't understand this philosophy will a loving father who created will punish his own children for not praising him ?🤔
Buddha was just like any other philosophers. He taught life philosophy from his perspective. God religion is totally different and is something that is not meant to be understood all. It takes strong faith and believe in the creator. As much as I think some of Buddhist teaching is good, I cannot imagine my existence without my creator and follow his guidances. In modern world, I’m concerned about being deceived and not being able to tell right from wrong. Islam and Islamic practices protect me from that. The god religion is religion that tells everyone is equal and no one is above any other people. Allah created us the same way. Buddha origin was India and had root from Hinduism, and we all know about caste system in India so this believe still continue in Buddhism. They believe in past life, karma and reincarnation. They believe that if someone is better than others in this life or was born in wealthy family, it meant he or she did good things in past life so people worship or held that person up higher above them.
Until and unless you won't study Buddhism with unbroken enlightened authentic master you will never understand what is "Samyak Samboddhi " and "Samyak Sambuddha" .
Prove Allah exists before commenting on Buddhism
I'm glad you have faith but what's wrong with these beliefs? If you imagine that submitting to a wrathful deity willl land you in his palace in the sky with 72 virgins attending you after death then why would it be so hard to believe in rebirth and kamma?
Buddha's teachings are not only theories but also actual practices to end suffering. Don't you ever say it just a philosophy or theory if you have not ever experienced the actual practice. There are three sasanas in Buddhism.
1. Pariyatti sasana (theoretical studies of Buddha's teachings) such as Buddhist universities or colleges.
2. Pattipati sasana (actual practice of Buddha's teachings ) such as Vipassana centres, meditation centres and forest tradition.
3. pativeda sasana (becoming enlightened perons after practicing Buddhist dharma). This sasana is as a result of practicing two sasanas above.
Ntd Tmn one of the example of criticizing something without fully understanding it. For you to say that Buddhism have some roots in Hinduism is half right, and the fact that you presumed Buddhism believes in caste system while in fact Buddha was strongly against that part in Hindu. Some meditation practices from Hindu was used in Buddhism because before there was Buddhism, Buddha learnt from teachers from Hindu and Buddha picked the meditation techniques that will help reaching enlightment.
Now to counter your statement that say god created everything as equal, then you haven't seen babies with congenital abnormalies that don't even last a day in this world and aren't able to even grasp the concept of god?
The problem with this "path" (or faith) is:
Not all things that happens to us or to others dependent on our desires or intentions or our actions or inaction:
Two examples:
1- natural disasters!
2- as mad man or politician who causes havoc or hilarious situation!
So it is not comprehensive...there is a leak.
Then does it depends upon the will of GOD?
according to buddhism there are 5 ways things happens to been's.action or karma is just 1 out of 5.
1. bija niyama
2. dhamma niyama
3. kamma niyama
4. rhithu niyama
5. chitta niyama
natural disasters goes under number 4. your second example can falls under number 2,3 and 5. so there are no leaks. only leak there is is most people think karma concept in hinduism and budhism are same. thats why they ask these kind of uneducated questions.
Wow problem with this path? Are you a master in Buddhist dharma and meditations?
Lol read these replys 😂 samwon you are being roasted 😂😂
Most of muslims are jokers. 😂
This place isn't meant to be heaven. Every person goes through their own test that god gives them. God WILL take into account your situation when judging you to put u in heaven or hell
God is so powerful he gave us the free choice of desire and with that we have to face the consequences in this life and the life after,and we would have no excuses since we desired to go either way.
god is not real, free will is incompatible with an existence of the abrahamic god
true!
Just bcuz Allaah is Most Gracious Most Merciful, it doesn't mean His not testing mankind, He is also
The Loving.
[He] who created death and life to test you [as to] which of you is best in deed - and He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving
Surah al mulk 2
Liars 😂
@@lionelbandara8116 unlike you , we dont lie.
Alllah is merciful but pple are suffering 😁😁😁
@@stvlktube it's bcuz they caused it, or its a Test or it might be a punishment.
@@ummzaynul370punishing without a reason..😁😁😁
Here dr. Zakir Naiks speach was very clear and so true... I donot know what the monk sayss
That's the problem, if you don't know what the monk speaks, you can never understand Buddhism and you can never clarify whether Zakir Nalayak was correct of false.
Desires which cause suffering are not the desires which end suffering. The buddha said to abandon the first type of desire not the second. The desire to meet the expectation is not the desire which eradicates expectations.
Bullshit
The how many Muslims commenting over here about what wrong with Buddhism .like they know Buddhism than Buddhist themselves ..wtf .
TRUST ME. ZAKIR NAIK DOESN'T KNOW A THING ABOUT BUDDHISM ! His Buddhist knowledge is EXTREMELY SUPERFICIAL.
Of course! Buddhism is something we need to understand in a deeper level. Nobody can understand it just by superficially looking at it. ♥️
I agree with Dr. Zakir, Buddhism is a humane attempt to understand life from Islam's teaching. Buddhism is missing a huge part of life. Only in Islam this clearly identified and we are told about. Allah worn us from our "Nafs Amara belsouk" and from the "Shetan" . Two factors affect us in life . Buddhism only tackle one side, our "nafs" which not enough.
Abhidhamma teachings in Buddhism show that the Buddha knew about the fundamental process in the universe. No other religion taught quantum physics.
I have a video about Buddhism and quantum mechanics.
as a buddhist i do find your points valid, yet at the same time i have seen to much questionable words from zakir to trust him. it is the same reason i converted from Christianity, the self contradictory nature of religion will always cause distrust, yet buddhism is not like that
@@bigfrankfraser1391, If you can see my previous comments. And watched it. You will be able to gain some deep understandings about Buddhism.
@@smlanka4u even in Quran many things are proven by science and in hindu's text too this give us hint there is Almighty who knows everything who created us.
Prove Allah exists. And after that prove Muhammad is his messenger before talking about Buddhism. Falsity of Buddhism doesn't have anything to do with Islam is true
⨍Υׁׅᝯׁ֒ƙׁׅ ꪱׁSᥣׁׅ֪aꩇׁׅ֪݊
If someone says Buddha didn’t have any power, they will definitely be wrong. He had power and so do his principals. However, he banned all his principals from using their power, because the core of Buddhism is intelligence and enlightenment. Power only makes people blindly believe the one who has it is God or something. Even one has power, they can’t escape from the circle of reincarnation and karma. In Buddhism, even the creatures living in Heaven still get back to the Earth or Hell. Heaven, Earth (actually we call it a different name, but my English is not good enough), and Hell are still in the circle of Reincarnation. When someone enjoys good Karma (reborn as a creature in Heaven, and has long life span), they still get punished by going to Hell and Earth because of bad Karma. No one can escape that circle, only the awakened persons can. Not what good things one has done, only enlightenment helps people to escape from it. If one did good things, they will be born in Heaven to enjoy what they have done in the previous life. But they are still a creature in Heaven and still have life span, the same for creatures in Hell. That’s why we call Buddha the Master of God and Human. I’m just sharing my knowledge of Buddhism. I’m not attacking other religions. Peace for the world.
You're absolutely right.
Buddha focus on intelligence to end from suffering and get enlightenment.
Definitely Nothing has to do with the Power.
These guys just don't get it.
Buddhism is a philosophy (human attempt at understanding the world). Islam is the guidance from the creator.
Not controlling ones lust and desires leads to bad decisions and consequences.
The Buddha spoke of two kinds of desire:desire that arises from ignorance and delusion,which is called tanhā, craving, anddesire that arises from wisdom and intelligence,which is called kusala-chanda
@@minthura9053 The buddha is a preacher who came to this world to preach the truth and he says there is only one God you should worship, but why are you guys worhiping him and every monks? You should worship the only one true God? right??
Also he says there will come aother buddha, and clearly that is prophet Muhammad... and you guys are not accepting the truth!?
buddha teach us to live in correct way- middle path
and we not consider about any god LOL
It isn't desire. It's dukha. Which translates more as craving.
Desire is a basic human emotion. if you don't have a desire then there is no meaning in life and purpose in life. But If you have controlled desire with the hope of a happy ending ( heaven), then It will make your life easier and also make you a living being. Without desire, anyone is like a thing without life.
For Buddhist, desire is required - Samvega, spiritual yearning.
a religion must be clear, straight forward, non contradictory and non confusing. only islam regroup those traits.
Controls on desires is good even Islam teaches the same but with addition that outcome for this hardship will be rewarded in life hereafter, desires installed in humans to push them to work and work hard to be productive in society, so Islam is strictly against Monkhood instead teaches Enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong by living in human society. If all good peoples go out from society then what left behind will be evil. Truly Allah gave us the right path through Quran which is the biggest blessing that improves humanity and civilizations. Islam gave us the sense of responsibility towards family and neighbours simultaneously controlling desires as well.
Budshism is more like a way of life. But not a religion/faith.
Buddhism is a philosophy unlike Islam which is a religion where people are made to fear god & to do wrong things. Buddhism says not to harm animals / humans if you think its painful for you too. But if you think otherwise, its upto you to hurt, harm or kill a living being. The 4 noble truths are Whats suffering? Reason for suffering? How to relieve suffering? Relieve suffering. The 8 fold path is a different thing. Thats not embedded in 4 noble truths. Zakir is wrong here. You cant compare a Philosophy with a Religion where freedom of thought & choice is limited. To understand Buddhism, you need both mental & physical ability to achieve success. 😇
Islam doesn’t say that GOD is all loving only…..
Then why most of muslims are ptoviding terrorism to destroy other people and always say "allha akbharr"😅
His first attribute name meaning is Ar-Raheem (The most merciful) dont say lie here the God is the most loving and in Islam says Allah love you more than 70 times your mother
@@shafnisha1171😂😂😂
@@shafnisha1171😂 Be merciful on the liars, bro
Budhists : how to beat around the bush
Muslims : how to beat around the bush to get out of it
So Buddhism is agnostic. Interesting
The thing that the second man said about desires is hilarious, did he just think that fancy words are enough to prove his point? How does one human soul become two persons? Just making a philosophical lecture on this doesn't make it true.
where did he said that one soul become two ?
Buddhists Dont believe in Soul
what are you even spouting?
It’s just a mental state
The Buddha spoke of two kinds of desire:desire that arises from ignorance and delusion,which is called tanhā, craving, and desire that arises from wisdom and intelligence,which is called kusala-chanda
BUDDHISM IS ABOUT FINDING ONE TRUE SELF TO OVERCOME THIS SUFFERING SOCIETY.
indeed Prophet Muhammad is the final and last Messenger of Allah! In every religion he is said that he will be coming!
Who care and he’s also married with 6 year girl right so shame
Bullshit
ISLAM IS THE TRUTH I CONTINUE TO BE AMAZED AT HOW TRUE ISLAM IS CANT WAIT TO HUG ALLAH AND THANK HOM FOR ALL HE HAS DONE FOR ME AMEN GLORY TO ALLAH MAY ALLAH BLESS AND PROCTECT THE LOST SOULS OUT THERE LOOKING FOR GUIDANCE AND MAY ALLAH SHOW THEM HIS LIGHT AND LOVE 🙏
Lol 😆
Comedy of the century.
@@mr.anonymous7114 where is true.? Show me with proof. Like Quran
@@umidboyxonov1090
Quran.
Lol you mean comedy book.
@@umidboyxonov1090
Go and get educated kid.
Still I cannot understand, why Allah created his religion in hot burning middle east and majority of islamists fighting with each other and suffering in this harsh environment.
But other believers are living in very comfortable lifestyles and comfortable environments. if so?
Now these allah's fellow men trying to settle in those comfort zones by force. because of jealousy.
IT'S NOT DESIRE!!! IT IS ATTACHMENT AND IGNORANCE! (The problem of translating stuff without understanding the contexts... Search on the internet the word "Taṇhā")
Naik has not studied the Buddism.he is confused.Buddhism is a very very complex philosophy. Really Not easy to understand .Naik is an ant infront a jaint Tusker
Studying suffering is the most important thing in Buddhism.
Namo buddhay 🙏.
I think Dr Zakir Naik has lost the meaning in translation. If you replace the word desire with attachment it will make sense.
I was taught about the four great truths in Pali.
When its translated ,it’s something like this.
Pain
Cause of pain
Eradication of pain
Way of eradication
As a religious scholar he should be more responsible and accountable about his statements. You can’t disregard an entire philosophy that is logically sound and scientific with plays on words.
Even though i was born to a household with buddhist philosophy , im currently following islamic teachings and practices . Want to learn about their perspective.
But certainly not satisfied with Dr Zakir Naik’s answers on some of the questions.
Explaining the god’s reason for creation using a simple school exam is not very intellectual.
And its a wrong approach, it may describe the situation in the exam room but not the creation.
If I don’t rmb wrong , Buddha didn’t answer the question of existence of God , and how universe was created. Buddha thinks it is not a the most pressing concern.
Dr Zakir is the person that
Shown the light to righteous teaching of Islam that cover all major religion
Ameen ya Rab
@@BardiXOfficial
No ,not Dr Zakir Naik,
The Actual fool is you 😂
You are too dumb for not knowing your faith ,
Stupid fool is you 😂
Zakir Naik is a joker
Dr Zakir is such a person if he finds logic in any religion,he says he can be a prophet prior to prophet muhammad .
@@Tobiraaaama
You are more pathetically low iQ
Just being stupid to comment
@@jambiarbi4073 Maybe..i try to analyse things not just blindly follow what a person or book says without using our own self consciousness
IF ZAKIR SOME ACCEPTS SAYINGS OF BUDDHA SO WHY DON'T HE ACCEPT TOTALLY.😝
Technically I Am a Monotheist.
What Monotheists have in common is the Macroscopic 'We are alone Worldview.'
If ever the existence of unearthly technology such as the Vimana becomes commonplace, one will Discover how far and high SAI Gautama is.
Sincerely,
I just want to say that I have heard the first "monk" speak before and he is far from a scholar. I am a practicing Buddhist and also a major in religious studies for what it's worth. I hate to say this but the first monk has no right to call himself a Buddhist much less a monk. He mocked the death of a fellow monk and bragged about meditating next to girls in bikinis. He mixes Buddhism with his own personal opinions and beliefs and tries to make it sound like Buddhist teachings. I'm doing my master's in Asian Religions and most Buddhist schools (especially Theravada and Zen) do not contradict the Academic faiths. Hope this helps shed a little light on this video.
The true Buddhist monks are very few nowadays. And also most of them don't do lectures. They practice themselves.
How many So called Buddhist scholars are enlightened ?
I'm really confused what the monk is saying.....🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Same, his voice is so soothing, I lost my train of thought 😂
The simple logic what buddha said is that u use my boat to go otherside of the river and after u go to the other side u donot need it any more !
Zakir Naik disappear in front of this wise Buddhist monk. Buddhism is the true religion that everyone should follow.
The third great truth tells us what to remove and the fourth great truth tells us how to remove
I have listened to Buddhist Monks before I didn't hear them
talk much about God. As if he's out of the equation
yes, we are our own creator , everything that we perceive is the projection of our mind.
Not every monks studied and practiced Buddha's teachings very well.
Even in Islamic tradition we are told to suppress the desires of the Nafs in order to attain the higher spirituality
In Buddhism there are meditation to uproot these desires , by suppressing it won't work .
suppression never works
@@tsurugi5 so you are saying if you have a desire to rape someone, kill someone or beat someone, you should do so? If you are obese and having health problems you should fulfil your desire to eat as much and as unheathily as possible? If you are a diabetic you should consume as much sugary foods as you desire?
@@yusufk5298 no but suppression will never work because all it is going to do is make these desires stronger, only way is to uproot them entirely
@@tsurugi5 okay i get that now.
Suffering is to humans... what water is to fish, we are designed to thrive even when exposed to suffering and fish are designed to swim through water even if there's a heavy flow
So the creator is not merciful because there is suffering in the world. Then you say suffering is our friend, does anyone else see this direct contradiction?
I feel sorry for your ignorance .
Aspirations, goals and desires are not synonyms.
Zakir naik plays with rhetoric.
Certain words don't even have justified equivalent english synonyms, but just working with nearly equivalents.
The buddhist monk explained everything gracefully.
That's why we living life in peace
sorry I couldn't complete
Ok that is one view of a monk, but what about the other Buddhists teachings? I don't think zakir nair wasn't totally wrong as there are many different explanations of the Buddhists beliefs.
Tbh i found it complicated to understand this Buddhist scholar's explanation.. for me Islam is easy to understand about desires and sufferings and act upon something beneficial or good and do something to change it.
Thanks for your comment. And if something is difficult to understand for you, doesn't mean it's wrong. This is also only Dr Zakir Naik's understanding of Buddhism.
True Buddhism is complicated to understand , it need effort .Buddhism is not a faith based religion but the wisdom based religion . That is why during ancient India Buddhism became popular among elite group of society like scholar's ,kings, merchants and slowly it went to the general mass of people.
@@urgenlama7302 oh okay
@@urgenlama7302 exactly
Wow Buddhism ia phenomenal!!!
React To
Exposing Zakir Naik The False Claim made On Hinduism Part 2 By Dharma Speaks
Do what Eve you can . you can't challenge Muslim
My understanding Buddhism is religion that turns yourself to be God. Well the application to be a God is always on when you be a god you do nothings except sitting in nivarna like a stone. So when everybody try to remove the suffering the world will be stone rock like moon because no need to do anything just rotten on meditation . 😁
Hello,
Lot of people think that Buddhism is a philosophy ; please stop thinking this because is not true. The path given by the Buddha is entirely spiritual. Or if you wish, the philosophical aspect (using rationality or a pattern of ideas) of his teaching is only a preliminary step in order to provide the motivation to engage in the path. Why? Because the practice is really not easy and it requires confronting our own conditioning, mental habits and fetters. Then that requires energy and effort from heart which must be fueled by this motivation.
The real objective is to EXPERIENCE directly the reality beyond our conception and our subjective point of view. It's a spiritual travel and not a mere a manipulations of ideas or conceptions like the philosophy.
Once you find truth in Islam then there is no point looking into other religions including Buddhism. I thank Allah from bottom of my heart for choosing me to the right path of Islam.
Wkwkwkw..nobody ask you..this kind of mentality is the reason why world cant be peaceful, christiants claim they are at right path, Muslim also claiming the same not to mention Hindu..
@@ncov-1948 bcs islam is truth
And others haven't realised their creator
@@afrdthzna3851 hahaha ignorant like you is a living example why we have religious extremist and narcisist in the world.
@@ncov-1948
The difference between Muslims, Christians and Hindu is that Muslims speak with proofs and evidence from Quran but Christians and Hindus only follow their religion blindly without any evidence or proof to prove their religion is right. Islam is the only true religion on earth.
@@najban2922 wkwkw..yes. like ISIS.
Please don’t try to make the two religions same, they are two different religions, as a Muslim, in Islam we believe in one god which cannot be seen, but I know that the Buddhist believe more than one gods and they worship idols which they believe can see or talk, which is totally different from Islam, we don’t worship idols because they are just made of stones, they can’t speak or listen they don’t have life, prophet Muhammad SAW pbuh said that worshiping idols is not the right way of life the right way of life is to worship only one god 5 times a day and prophet Muhammad SAW pbuh are god’s last messenger. So in conclusion the 2 religions doesn’t match each other in anyway so please don’t try to match these two religions together.
Buddhist believe more than one gods?? You dont know about buddhism.. buddhism never believe god or gods..
Buddhist believe in Caste-system and Reincarnation... So basically it's same as Hinduism...
Buddha was born in Shakya Vansh who were Kshatriyas... Shakya Vansha are descendants of Ishkavaku dynasty (same as Rama of Hindus)
it's mainly about you and your mind
there is a quote " a buddha will be misunderstood always because, he talks about stuff u cannot comprehended based on isolated beliefs
That's right. Bcos mere words cannot cover the reality. Words are bound. misinterpreat
The Buddhists Have lost their Essence of Philosophy being confused about God as like as mad causing barrier of peace
Ok explain 4noble truth about desire and suffering
Put hungry instead for suffering
Desire instead for want to eat
When you already full your stomach then not hungry anymore.
But enlightenment is not like full the stomach but it is understanding. And understanding eliminates the desire that cause suffering.
Let’s have some pizza and pasta we don’t need logic🙂
❤
He said scholars say not all scholars.
It isn't really a contradiction really to desire the eightfold path. It will definitely cause one suffering when one desires to follow it because one will finally reflect on one's shortcoming. So it does allign with the truth that desire will lead to suffering. And eventually after following it, you learn to cast that final desire.
If you don't have desire, how are you gonna have a better life? Excessive desire is bad but desire itself isn't. That's what Islam teaches to its follower.
@@adlan1823 desire makes you justify things just because of one's belief and teaching. It's impossible to not have desire, we are humans. Buddhism is just merely a vehicle that can help remind which desires are good and bad. There is the story of Angulimala who's desire was to impress his teacher. However, his teacher hated him and convinced him that Angulimala must cut off the little fingers of people and make a garland with it. Angulimala's blind faith made him kill multiple people who crossed his path so that he can make his garland of fingers.
the rest is from wikipedia
Surviving villagers migrate from the area and complain to Pasenadi, the king of Kosala.Pasenadi responds by sending an army of 500 soldiers to hunt down Aṅgulimāla. Meanwhile, Aṅgulimāla's parents hear about the news that Pasenadi is hunting an outlaw. Since Aṅgulimāla was born with bad omens, they conclude it must be him. Although the father prefers not to interfere, the mother disagrees. Fearing for her son's life, she sets out to find her son, warn him of the king's intent and take care of him. The Buddha perceives through meditative vision (Pali: abhiññā) that Aṅgulimāla has slain 999 victims, and is desperately seeking a thousandth. If the Buddha is to encounter Aṅgulimāla that day, the latter will become a monk and subsequently attain abhiññā. However, if Aṅgulimāla is to kill his mother instead, she will be his thousandth victim and he will be unsavable, since matricide in Buddhism is considered one of the five worst actions a person can commit.
The Buddha sets off to intercept Aṅgulimāla, despite being warned by local villagers not to go. On the road through the forest of Kosala, Aṅgulimāla first sees his mother. According to some versions of the story, he then has a moment of reconciliation with her, she providing food for him. After some deliberation, however, he decides to make her his thousandth victim. But then when the Buddha also arrives, he chooses to kill him instead. He draws his sword, and starts running towards the Buddha. But although Aṅgulimāla is running as fast as he can, he cannot catch up with the Buddha who is walking calmly. The Buddha is using some supernatural accomplishment (Pali: iddhi; Sanskrit: ṛddhi) that affects Aṅgulimāla: one text states the Buddha through these powers contracts and expands the earth on which they stand, thus keeping a distance of Aṅgulimāla. This bewilders Aṅgulimāla so much that he calls to the Buddha to stop. The Buddha then says that he himself has already stopped, and that it is Aṅgulimāla who should stop
Honestly, nothing against Abrahamic religions but sometimes monotheists like christian evangelicals can have too much desire to spread your own beliefs that you unwittingly insult and find fault in others (just like this video) instead of finding your own spirituality and your own connection with your God. I'm not saying Buddhism is perfect. It can still be brainwashed by dictatorships who want to use religion. But its a bigger problem in the Abrahamic religions like how most churches are now MAGA trump supporter bases and also how Islamophobia started with the retaliation on 9/11 and also Muslims supporting the Taliban when the Bamiyan Buddhas were dynamited. There is too much desire that they justify as faith and too little control because each group think they are in the right because their higher power or holy book said so.
@@crewmatewillthrowthesehand7600 What a story. Much like how noble Jesus and Muhammad were. No idea why you put the story by the way.
That's a way to look down in Abrahamic religions. Then again, Buddhism isn't much better considering they did support the genocide of Rohingya.
You see, the religion isn't the problem. I can't say about Jews and Christians but, in Islam you Don't make fun/ mock other religions even if it's unwittingly. Even if you wanna preach it, just preach. No need to offense other religions. Just do it moderately.
But of course, the followers of the religions have desires. Be it Abrahamic, Buddhism, Hinduism etc. And they tend to go overboard with their desire.
@@adlan1823 u see. I don't look down on the Abrahamic religions. And I even put it in my comment that Buddhism isn't perfect and can be used by dictatorships like Myanmar. You jumped to your own conclusions because of your desirr to love your religion. Myanmar is ruled by a dictatorship just like Taliban and no where in Buddhist doctrine says that non-believers deserves conversion or killing just by not believing. Plus, Myanmar only has 50 million put of 500 million Buddhists Worldwide. And Buddhists across the world, do not agree with what the Burmese dictatorship is doing. In fact. The Burmese resistance against the regime has a high Christian and Muslim population because the Myanmar people finally realised what the Military was doing. Meanwhile, the same Zakir Naik in this video frequently supported the practices of Taliban including a video on why Muslims should support the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas. That's what I'm referring to when I say that Abrahamic religions can get carried away when trying to push for their "own truths". Before the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas, Buddhists generally didn't have an issue with Muslims. In fact, in Very very Buddhist countries like Thailand, you can hear the call the Prayer everyday and Eid is allowed to be celebrated even though killing animals as part of a ceremony is considered a sin for Buddhists. Compare that with the Middle East (especially Saudi Arabia where non-believers can't practice their religion freely outside). And yet, instead of focusing on their religion, people like Zakir Naik are more obsessed with criticising other religions instead and frequently using the word "infidels". And Muslims who watch him start believing his views and then wonder why Islamophobia exists. I could understand if he's under a dictatorship and is made to say this stuff, but he's not. It's the same for American evangelicals who keep hating other religions, including Muslims. (plenty of evangenitals making videos about how other religions are bad and I'm done with them tbh) That's what I'm saying so pls stop jumping to conclusions bub.
finally, someone who knows their stuff, [arable of the raft and all that
these gotchas are getting tiresome when they've been refuted 2500 years ago by the buddha's disciples themselves
I don't think it's fascinating philosophy.
even the second great truth is illogical. no one can say sorrow and misery is caused by desire alone. many sorrow and misery is caused by diseases, natural calamities and accidents.
The Buddha would term the later as suffering caused by Uttha Niyama, Bija Niyama, which are universal causes.
I first thought he is smart but he doesn’t have common sense than me. Bro you already have desire and he is taking about how to remove desire.
What seem sound good doesn't mean it 100% true.!
Verily Buddhism is a very much confusing & complicated Concept that has no logic// Purpose of life// Goal// Target. But Digha Nikaya Says God Has Exist. Why shall we follow with out an aim in life ???????????????
The died person never came back to tell about God.well as alive person never saw god, it's just only believe that there is god nothing else.Buddha knew if he talk about god than people will make there own god and will demand that our god is bigger there's other god are small.people will fight in the name of god.that why's he reject. Buddha epi
☸️🙏🛐
Budhism मे कम्प्लीट रास्ता नहीं है
I am craving for rice, if i don't eat rice per day i would go dizzy, you mean i have to remove this craving? Irrasional
Suffering is one of the test ...
Then enjoy.
57 Muslim on who war ??
Ok, so for the first thing he said, what is the person doing for God the Almighty to help them? Are they truly worshiping Him? Are they helping others? Why don’t the people who He gave everything to help is the real question. God doesn’t have to come and help people that don’t worship Him.
This video EK Dil hai with Life's
let me explain to you budhism, i'm a scholar: the one who get the pizza is the one who eat the pizza but they are two persons(where did i hear that before ? ) and finally pizza is tasty.
???
dukka nirodha arya satya -noble truth of eradicating suffering.
it dosent talk about eliminate desire. it acknowledge suffering can be eliminated and for that you have to destroy avidya ( arrogance. which is the root cause of suffering described in 12 steps of paticcha samuppada) not desire. when avidya is eliminated desire wont happens.
and in the forth noble truth one will learn how to eliminate avidya by following 37 bodhi parshavika dhamma. eight fold path is just 8 out of 37. we use it because its easier to site and it contains essence of all 37. just as we use desire or avidya as root cause of suffering when there is 12 well described steps by buddha in paticcha samuppada.
so there are no contradictions in 4 noble truths but intentional or genuine arrogance by dr. zakir naik for what ever reason
No. You dont desire to follow the eight fold path. You just follow it.hes over conceptualising
If god creates all things including human ,why are all human's faces,hair and arms and etc different? If god did like that, god is not justice.
😂 correct. They cannot answer it