Noam Chomsky: Newton, Mechanical Philosophy and Unintelligible Universe

January 31, 2023
Noam Chomsky: Do We Have Free Will?
• Noam Chomsky: Do We Ha...
Clockwork universe
en.wikipedia.o...
Mechanical philosophy
en.wikipedia.o...
Mechanical Philosophy | Noam Chomsky
• Mechanical Philosophy ...
Noam Chomsky on René Descartes
• Noam Chomsky on René D...
Noam Chomsky - "The machine, the ghost, and the limits of understanding"
• Noam Chomsky - "The ma...

[@MassDefibrillator]

I think the key point here, is that, general relativity also is not able to reduce gravity to mechanical means: something that could be reproduced by a skilled artisan. An artisan cannot grab a hold of space time, and modify it to produce gravity. There is still no contact force between observable matter that produced gravity. That was the mechanical philosophy: the idea that everything in nature could be reduced down to the motions and collisions of matter; introducing this new entity called spacetime, that is itself not directly observable, is not a reduction to the mechanical philosophy. So while GR technically does away with non-contact force, it introduce entities that are equally if not more "absurd".