That's pretty much what I did when I was looking for a new brand of colored pencil when the Prisma breakage got too annoying-- bought some colored pencils open stock to compare them. I bought a Coloursoft Pale Brown and the Polychromos Cinnamon, hoping to find some good skin tones on the way. I wasn't pleased with either of them as skin tones, but when coloring a Charlene Tarbox Floral Bouquet picture I decided to use the Cinnamon for the basket. When I saw how smooth and grainless the Polychromos went down, I became an instant convert to Polychromos. It's kind of overpowered for hobby coloring, but I don't care. ;-D BTW, with Polychromos it works better to put the lighter color down first, because they're more translucent than Prismas, Just sayin'. I'm not trying to convert you from your preferred brand of colored pencil. ;-D
oh no I love polychromos too, i have got them for my mum as when I tried them I felt they would suit her better being soft but not so soft as a beginner too soft might have been hard I thought, but now I keep using them too as they are great. :-)
Thank you for this comparison. I've been getting 12-24 packs of a few different ones lately. I haven't tried Polychromos or Prismacolours yet. I was looking at Polychromos. I like a few of Derwent's ranges, Stadler's and F-C Blacks. I really liked your green blend on the Polychromos. It kinda looked like all 3 sets went to a muddy brown mix in the red/purple blends, still nice to know. Thanks.
I think the muddiness is probably part my colouring and in part the camera. It doesnt always pick up the blends so good. I am better with it now > As for these three I would say prisma are very soft and waxy, good to blend, not dissimilar to the Derwent coloursoft but the Derwent are a bit firmer and a little less waxy. the polychromos are really nice, a little harder than the rest but still colour lovely. I think all of them are good but it really is a personal thing on how you like to colour. I personally like the softer pencils so first for me is the prisma then the coloursoft. but that is why I suggested before in comments get one of each in similar colour and try them. That way you get to see which works for you. I use the colursoft and prisma as I say and gave my mum the polychromos. she doesnt really do any blending etc so it worked for her, another one that I was surprised by if you like the harder type like polychromos was the crayola pencils. They actually were very nice pencils. I always thought of them as kids pencils but I got some for mum as she liked the colours and they were really very nice. Anyway enough chatter, enjoy your colouring, Amanda
Don't stop talking Amanda, it's the information that's important and can be the decider between products. I only have a small set of inexpensive watercolour pencils , but your tutorial has given me food for thought and probably for others!! 😊
Thank you that means a lot, as a couple of videos now I have had a number of comments (to be fair these videos are ones that often expand out of the crafting community and I suspect that may be the issue) saying basically stop talking. In fact some have been so nasty, and very rude words that I actually removed them. But even though I believe that these are not people from our crafting community it does still make you second guess yourself and worry. So i really do appreciate you saying that to me xxx
Excellent video. However you got a little confused with complimentary colours on the second lot of circles. The two greens were Actually analagous colours, next to each other on the colour wheel. The last lot of circles were actually complimentary colours, colours opposite each other on the colour wheel. Please don't take this as a criticism to a very helpful video, but colour understanding is very important in any form of artwork. Please keep up the good work
Oh no not offended at all grateful for the information. I think I was not being prob as literal as that but actually it is still a good point because using that wording is potentially misleading so I will indeed be more careful in the future so thank you xx
The bottom ones weren’t complimentary either. The opposite of violet is yellow (and green is opposite to red). But that’s alright, the message got across.
That's not why prismas break. The reason is the lowered production quality. They never used to break. The reasons boil down to this: thinner leads than before, centering issues in the barrel, cheaper barrels, and not gluing the leads in the barrel like other soft lead brands do to protect them.
For beggingners in colored pencil, what is the best between these? I'm from Brazil the price of pencils is so expensive and prismacolor isn't accessible only Derwent and Polychromos
Personally either the derwent or the polychromo’s. but prob not the prIsmacolor. The reason I say that is that the prisma’s are very soft and so can be harder for a beginner although that’s why I like them as I can really blend a lot with them. However the derwent I also use personally and they are really really nice and a nice medium between being blendable but not so soft as to be difficult to use. Also same with polychromo’s, my mum is a beginner and she uses these and they work reapply well for her. I have tried them as well and really liked them too. Hope that helps xx
I'm confused between coloursoft and polychromos... Btw prismas are very expensive in my country, so I'll not buy it... But pls suggest me.. Whether to buy coloursoft or polychromos
That really depends on your colouring preference. What I did when I started was buy one pencil from each company that I thought I might like, of a similar colour to help comparison and then I could try them and see what suited how i like to colour. I would say prismas are the softest, then coloursoft (which I love) and then polychromos if that helps at all. x
I got a colorsoft 36stk set almost two years ago, I did a portrait but i found them way too waxy and i couldn't really layer them so I dont like them much. Maybe the problem was the paper tho, i don't really know what kind of paper i should be using with these kind of pencils :/ I'm considering about getting the polychromos ones since they are oil based, but after watching your video, i think i have to try a different paper first for my colorsoft and then try the polychromos What do you think? Also, can you suggest me some paper that i can use please?
The paper I found is key and the softer and waxing the pencil the more important it becomes if you want to later. In order to layer the paper has to have some tooth to it so that you can gradually build up Layers before completely flattening the tooth. Once flattened you simply cannot add more layers. I use a good quality pencil paper (I will look up the name tomorrow for you - it’s currently 5am I don’t sleep well!) and since I have done that it has made a massive difference. This brand comes in different sizes too which makes it helpful although I tend to go for a4 size as either I can chop it up or if I am doing a slightly bigger image it gives me space around the edges to test my colours as I work. I am terrible at pre planning 😂 hope that helps and if I forget to tell you the name of the brand I use then just please do remind me as bear in mind that as I say it is early right now so my memory is not the best xx
@@lollilulucrafts omg thanks for the fast reply! Good to know that it's probably the paper that wasn't good enough for the pencils Also, yeah i wrote the comment when if was something like 3am where I live, so same😂😅
I’m looking at purchasing the polychromos in the 120 set from amazon uk for around £137. But I’ve just found the 72 set of the polychromos in the tin for around £155. Which out of the polychromos and the prismacolors do you prefer?
amber franklin in all honesty they are all great but it comes down to personal choice as to the type of thing you like to colour with. The prismas are much softer, prob have a higher wax content. The polychromos are still creamy but not as soft - less wax content. A nice midway pencil are the Derwent colour soft pencils. For me because I like a very soft feel to my pencils my favs are the prismas but despite that I seem to end up using the derwent the most, but I suspect that is lore to do with the fact that they are so easy to transport in the box. It is hard to give you advice on this other than explain why I personally choose the ones I did (which were the prismas, the polychromos were mums and mum chose the derwents as a gift for me) But a tip for you, which is what I did to choose, because as I said at the beginning it is such personal thing. Purchase one polychromo, one prisma and one derwent (and can I throw another name in the ring for you, it might surprise you it did me. A friend of ours had crayola pencils and they are so lovely!) and any others you might want to try. Get them all in a strong colours, and similar colours too so that you can compare like with like. See how you like the feel of them, does the wax bloom bother you (btw use a feather to dust that away and you won’t get the bloom marking your drawing) what’s the coverage like, how does the colour build up. I then thought I knew which I preferred so I got a second colour in that brand and then tested the blending. I know it might seem a waste of money to order these but one it’s more expensive to buy a whole set and then think 💭 umm not so sure about these, secondly when I chose the colours of these single pencils I picked a strong colour yes but also one that I would use more of so that then it wouldn’t be wasted cos eventually I would need a replacement. And the other couple of pencils from the brand I didn’t end up choosing are now in the top of the prisma box and do get used too. I hope that helps a bit, I’m sorry it’s a long essay of an answer lol! Let me know what you decide to do, I would be interested to know, big hugs Amanda ps check out amazon for individual (and the sets too) if you haven’t already xx
Lolli Lulu Crafts. I’ve used the coloursofts and I really like them but I would like to try the prismacolor premier and I was wondering what size set I should go for as I have a tin of 24 polychromos, a tin of 24 coloursofts and a tin of 24 procolours. And my mum also purchased me a tin of 72 arteza pencils
@@amberfranklin4499 If you want my honest opinion I think you need to choose which are the brand for you and then stick to it, Im not being funny promise but I mean it literally cos you will find it better to invest in one brand getting more colours in the same brand that you know will work nicely together, rather than having a few from many brands that may or may not blend together well. Here if you had one brand you would have 60 pencils of the one brand and that is not including the ones your mum purchased. Get a couple of the prisma and see what you think _ literally like I said before just a couple so as not too waste money if you dont like them and then choose one brand that you are going to invest in and build up the colours in. Yes later you can always buy into other brands like I did (but it is different in that I am doing that cos its my job to have different things to show and use) but right now I would def do some trying and then decide which your fav is. Hope that helps and again would love to know what you decide xx
I have a feeing I have some somewhere but I think where they are? do they come as watercolour ones? I just cant remember and with the clear out I just cant think where I have put my watercolour pencils - AND if I have the inkrense they would be with them . I will have a hunt and let you know. It will prob be something completely different when I find them lol!
Ahh thank you for that, it makes me feel better that I was thinking watercolours when they were mentioned, so the questioned is, in all my new organisation where the heck did I put them lol! I will let you know if I find them, I know they must be here somewhere - unless they were one of the million things I sold ( and I still have loads to sell too but have had to put it to one side as it was getting me so behind on videos etc, so will continue that later.) anyway thanks again for the info xxx
Than you glad you enjoyed and hope it answers any questions you might have. Do check out the website post as I have laid the information out for everyone in a little table type thing so you can see it side by side. Plus photos of the blends too. :-)
That's pretty much what I did when I was looking for a new brand of colored pencil when the Prisma breakage got too annoying-- bought some colored pencils open stock to compare them. I bought a Coloursoft Pale Brown and the Polychromos Cinnamon, hoping to find some good skin tones on the way. I wasn't pleased with either of them as skin tones, but when coloring a Charlene Tarbox Floral Bouquet picture I decided to use the Cinnamon for the basket. When I saw how smooth and grainless the Polychromos went down, I became an instant convert to Polychromos. It's kind of overpowered for hobby coloring, but I don't care. ;-D
BTW, with Polychromos it works better to put the lighter color down first, because they're more translucent than Prismas, Just sayin'. I'm not trying to convert you from your preferred brand of colored pencil. ;-D
oh no I love polychromos too, i have got them for my mum as when I tried them I felt they would suit her better being soft but not so soft as a beginner too soft might have been hard I thought, but now I keep using them too as they are great. :-)
Thank you for this comparison. I've been getting 12-24 packs of a few different ones lately.
I haven't tried Polychromos or Prismacolours yet. I was looking at Polychromos.
I like a few of Derwent's ranges, Stadler's and F-C Blacks.
I really liked your green blend on the Polychromos. It kinda looked like all 3 sets went to a muddy brown mix in the red/purple blends, still nice to know.
Thanks.
I think the muddiness is probably part my colouring and in part the camera. It doesnt always pick up the blends so good. I am better with it now > As for these three I would say prisma are very soft and waxy, good to blend, not dissimilar to the Derwent coloursoft but the Derwent are a bit firmer and a little less waxy. the polychromos are really nice, a little harder than the rest but still colour lovely. I think all of them are good but it really is a personal thing on how you like to colour. I personally like the softer pencils so first for me is the prisma then the coloursoft. but that is why I suggested before in comments get one of each in similar colour and try them. That way you get to see which works for you. I use the colursoft and prisma as I say and gave my mum the polychromos. she doesnt really do any blending etc so it worked for her, another one that I was surprised by if you like the harder type like polychromos was the crayola pencils. They actually were very nice pencils. I always thought of them as kids pencils but I got some for mum as she liked the colours and they were really very nice. Anyway enough chatter, enjoy your colouring, Amanda
Don't stop talking Amanda, it's the information that's important and can be the decider between products. I only have a small set of inexpensive watercolour pencils , but your tutorial has given me food for thought and probably for others!! 😊
Thank you that means a lot, as a couple of videos now I have had a number of comments (to be fair these videos are ones that often expand out of the crafting community and I suspect that may be the issue) saying basically stop talking. In fact some have been so nasty, and very rude words that I actually removed them. But even though I believe that these are not people from our crafting community it does still make you second guess yourself and worry. So i really do appreciate you saying that to me xxx
Excellent video. However you got a little confused with complimentary colours on the second lot of circles. The two greens were Actually analagous colours, next to each other on the colour wheel. The last lot of circles were actually complimentary colours, colours opposite each other on the colour wheel. Please don't take this as a criticism to a very helpful video, but colour understanding is very important in any form of artwork. Please keep up the good work
Oh no not offended at all grateful for the information. I think I was not being prob as literal as that but actually it is still a good point because using that wording is potentially misleading so I will indeed be more careful in the future so thank you xx
The bottom ones weren’t complimentary either. The opposite of violet is yellow (and green is opposite to red). But that’s alright, the message got across.
thank you very much for the comparison!.
my pleasure :-)
That's not why prismas break. The reason is the lowered production quality. They never used to break. The reasons boil down to this: thinner leads than before, centering issues in the barrel, cheaper barrels, and not gluing the leads in the barrel like other soft lead brands do to protect them.
well if that is so are you suggesting this is a problem that occurs across brands because I have breakage issues across the brands? 🙂
For beggingners in colored pencil, what is the best between these? I'm from Brazil the price of pencils is so expensive and prismacolor isn't accessible only Derwent and Polychromos
Personally either the derwent or the polychromo’s. but prob not the prIsmacolor. The reason I say that is that the prisma’s are very soft and so can be harder for a beginner although that’s why I like them as I can really blend a lot with them. However the derwent I also use personally and they are really really nice and a nice medium between being blendable but not so soft as to be difficult to use. Also same with polychromo’s, my mum is a beginner and she uses these and they work reapply well for her. I have tried them as well and really liked them too. Hope that helps xx
Hi Laura, which did you finally chose? :D
I'm confused between coloursoft and polychromos... Btw prismas are very expensive in my country, so I'll not buy it... But pls suggest me.. Whether to buy coloursoft or polychromos
That really depends on your colouring preference. What I did when I started was buy one pencil from each company that I thought I might like, of a similar colour to help comparison and then I could try them and see what suited how i like to colour. I would say prismas are the softest, then coloursoft (which I love) and then polychromos if that helps at all. x
Hi Sai, which did you finally chose? :D
I got a colorsoft 36stk set almost two years ago, I did a portrait but i found them way too waxy and i couldn't really layer them so I dont like them much. Maybe the problem was the paper tho, i don't really know what kind of paper i should be using with these kind of pencils :/
I'm considering about getting the polychromos ones since they are oil based, but after watching your video, i think i have to try a different paper first for my colorsoft and then try the polychromos
What do you think? Also, can you suggest me some paper that i can use please?
The paper I found is key and the softer and waxing the pencil the more important it becomes if you want to later. In order to layer the paper has to have some tooth to it so that you can gradually build up Layers before completely flattening the tooth. Once flattened you simply cannot add more layers. I use a good quality pencil paper (I will look up the name tomorrow for you - it’s currently 5am I don’t sleep well!) and since I have done that it has made a massive difference. This brand comes in different sizes too which makes it helpful although I tend to go for a4 size as either I can chop it up or if I am doing a slightly bigger image it gives me space around the edges to test my colours as I work. I am terrible at pre planning 😂 hope that helps and if I forget to tell you the name of the brand I use then just please do remind me as bear in mind that as I say it is early right now so my memory is not the best xx
@@lollilulucrafts omg thanks for the fast reply!
Good to know that it's probably the paper that wasn't good enough for the pencils
Also, yeah i wrote the comment when if was something like 3am where I live, so same😂😅
@@lollilulucrafts heyyy, can you tell me the paper that you used with the derwent colorsoft pencils please?😊
This was what I was looking for!! thanks for the comparison, it helped me a lot!!😃
glad it was of use :-)
Have all of those pencils all great to use.
I’m looking at purchasing the polychromos in the 120 set from amazon uk for around £137. But I’ve just found the 72 set of the polychromos in the tin for around £155. Which out of the polychromos and the prismacolors do you prefer?
amber franklin in all honesty they are all great but it comes down to personal choice as to the type of thing you like to colour with. The prismas are much softer, prob have a higher wax content. The polychromos are still creamy but not as soft - less wax content. A nice midway pencil are the Derwent colour soft pencils. For me because I like a very soft feel to my pencils my favs are the prismas but despite that I seem to end up using the derwent the most, but I suspect that is lore to do with the fact that they are so easy to transport in the box. It is hard to give you advice on this other than explain why I personally choose the ones I did (which were the prismas, the polychromos were mums and mum chose the derwents as a gift for me) But a tip for you, which is what I did to choose, because as I said at the beginning it is such personal thing. Purchase one polychromo, one prisma and one derwent (and can I throw another name in the ring for you, it might surprise you it did me. A friend of ours had crayola pencils and they are so lovely!) and any others you might want to try. Get them all in a strong colours, and similar colours too so that you can compare like with like. See how you like the feel of them, does the wax bloom bother you (btw use a feather to dust that away and you won’t get the bloom marking your drawing) what’s the coverage like, how does the colour build up. I then thought I knew which I preferred so I got a second colour in that brand and then tested the blending. I know it might seem a waste of money to order these but one it’s more expensive to buy a whole set and then think 💭 umm not so sure about these, secondly when I chose the colours of these single pencils I picked a strong colour yes but also one that I would use more of so that then it wouldn’t be wasted cos eventually I would need a replacement. And the other couple of pencils from the brand I didn’t end up choosing are now in the top of the prisma box and do get used too. I hope that helps a bit, I’m sorry it’s a long essay of an answer lol! Let me know what you decide to do, I would be interested to know, big hugs Amanda ps check out amazon for individual (and the sets too) if you haven’t already xx
Lolli Lulu Crafts. I’ve used the coloursofts and I really like them but I would like to try the prismacolor premier and I was wondering what size set I should go for as I have a tin of 24 polychromos, a tin of 24 coloursofts and a tin of 24 procolours. And my mum also purchased me a tin of 72 arteza pencils
@@amberfranklin4499 If you want my honest opinion I think you need to choose which are the brand for you and then stick to it, Im not being funny promise but I mean it literally cos you will find it better to invest in one brand getting more colours in the same brand that you know will work nicely together, rather than having a few from many brands that may or may not blend together well. Here if you had one brand you would have 60 pencils of the one brand and that is not including the ones your mum purchased. Get a couple of the prisma and see what you think _ literally like I said before just a couple so as not too waste money if you dont like them and then choose one brand that you are going to invest in and build up the colours in. Yes later you can always buy into other brands like I did (but it is different in that I am doing that cos its my job to have different things to show and use) but right now I would def do some trying and then decide which your fav is. Hope that helps and again would love to know what you decide xx
Very good, have you tried the Inktense as well?
I was wondering about them too and how they would compare.
I have a feeing I have some somewhere but I think where they are? do they come as watercolour ones? I just cant remember and with the clear out I just cant think where I have put my watercolour pencils - AND if I have the inkrense they would be with them . I will have a hunt and let you know. It will prob be something completely different when I find them lol!
Lolli Lulu Crafts they are a Derwent production too and react with water. But once dry, they are permanent. Hope you find yours 👍🏻🤓🌞👏🏻
Ahh thank you for that, it makes me feel better that I was thinking watercolours when they were mentioned, so the questioned is, in all my new organisation where the heck did I put them lol! I will let you know if I find them, I know they must be here somewhere - unless they were one of the million things I sold ( and I still have loads to sell too but have had to put it to one side as it was getting me so behind on videos etc, so will continue that later.) anyway thanks again for the info xxx
ps love the emojis x
I’m so confused!! Derwent is much cheaper but I kinda want to have prismas... but I think I know I won’t buy polys.... anyway lovely video thanks!
Tfs!
My pleasure xx
Thanks xxx
pleasure lovely xx
Thanks for that very helpful xxx
Than you glad you enjoyed and hope it answers any questions you might have. Do check out the website post as I have laid the information out for everyone in a little table type thing so you can see it side by side. Plus photos of the blends too. :-)