Stephen has a point. Back in the old days people would hear new music on the radio and if they liked it they would buy the album. As a result, royalty rates were kept very low for radio (performance rates), while higher / market rates for albums (mechanical rates). This was seen as fair because radio acted like an advertiser for the songs and the real money would come via record sales. Streaming changed everything because the listener does not own the music (or mechanical like a record, CD or mp3). As such, streaming was given the low radio perf. rate as a model - even though streaming offered no benefit towards record sales. The MMA seeks to readjust the rates to today’s market. The US Constitution allows Congress to pass Law in context to copyright.
@@keithjagger8095 Radio for the most part still functions the same. Internet however has degraded that. Radio can still advertise your music, the actual issue with radio is that it is setup to be bias to whoever pays what station to play. Hence why pop stations will play Lady GaGa's new song three times in one hour. And they claim it's only a top hit because most people will listen to pop stations that happen to play three times per hour. It's an inflation device to claim your hit is "famous and big" but with that said, it doesn't change the fact that whatever radio stations genre can still by concept, advise your song.
Joe is an extrovert who doesn't know when to shut the fuck up and LISTEN. This is why I hate extroverts and NT's in general, they talk wayyy too fucking much without letting other people get their point across.
Nobody said he was wrong. Musicians have been complaining about this since the business began. Prince at least was a very rich man. Many great artists didnt earn a penny.
What prince was basically saying was artists nowadays arent making the money that they used to. Ppl tend not to value things they can get for free. For example there’s a thing called the compulsory license law which allows artists through the record company’s to take music at will w/o permission. Which doesn’t exist in any other art form. Intellectual copyrights.
The problem, IMO, and speaking as a FORMER professional musician myself, is based on one basic confusion. When people use the term “The Music Business”, what they’re actually referring to unknowingly is The Record Business. A hundred years ago there was no record business. Musicians only got paid for playing live. Songwriters had it better than the musicians back then since they owned the publishing rights. But when musicians started making records - physical objects bought in stores - that’s when the potential to make serious money started. It might just be that the “Record Business” was kind of an anomaly in the music biz; and so far as I can see, those years are over. And the days of musicians having to “play for their supper” have returned.
@@JokerzGallery it’s not the good old days though. Musicians have been around forever but serious mansion money really only started in the 60’s ( of course there are a few exceptions), it peaked in the 90’s and then started declining with illegal downloads and now streaming. Musicians have to make their money with shows which is how it’s always been the golden era where bands could sign a record deal and buy a mansion and 10 cars is a weird trend in the grand scheme of things. Obviously a lot of money for a few pop singers and rappers etc. but other artist have to make their livings with merch and live shows.
Play for supper unless your rich as shit already and can jack ticket prices through the roof because the dumbass masses have their pocket tv recording device they were programmed to purchase and live in a mostly false reality due to social media; so they can't budget their finances or their time worth a fuck to see they are being controlled to buy crap they don't need. All we got now in the "record business" is old troubadours unwilling to care about cutting new records for another yacht and up and comers who are controlled to be unheard unless they sound like everyone else in the establishment.
EpyonRoyal Jamie is such an idiot, when he was he getting all heated on the nukes with Eddie he was like ya I got an a. Then Eddie was like so you went to nuclear physics class? And Jamie was like no I didn’t go that class. Eddie is just to crazy of a dude to sound logical sometimes
This showed everyone (well, me atleast) the different side of Steven way more than American Idol. Cool to see someone that is a big of a rockstar as can be, also be really cool and down to earth
The service provider (comcast) owns Media companies like movie studios. So they have a personal interest in going after people stealing their content through their network. Even I've gotten emails from comcast telling me to stop watching movies online (before vpn).
The problem is that streaming allows for more competition and artistic freedom whereas a sales focused mentality sort of forces the artists to create something that will appeal to the masses. I think the best solution is to limit free streaming to selective songs from albums, or EP's/singles. Listening to Spotify these days feels like you're listening to musicians the same way you watch people in the Hunger Games.
you probably live in the moon Lunarsatellite lol competition and artistic freedom dont matter f if the same greedy pigs controls the streaming medias or the distribution. At the end of the day its all about money..and you cant give labels any power on that besides who decides what songs to limit ?? who can have authority on that besides the artist?.. btw..listening to musicians nowadays on spotify is shit, same as HG
My Dad‘s friend has a house next to Steven’s house in Mass. My Dad told me a story earlier today about a time when his friend hosted a party at the house, he was drunk and decided to go take a piss in a bush in Steven’s backyard. As he’s taking a piss, Steven walks up to him and says “What… are you doing??” The friend said “Oh, I’m just looking for my wallet.” Steven patted his ass saying “You mean this wallet in your pocket?” The friend said “Oh yeah! That wallet!” My Dad’s friend went back to his house and Steven came along and hung out for a bit. The friend said he was very nice.
Ppl might confuse this & say “why is he complaining he’s rich” or something like that, but the point is someone else who didn’t do shit is taking their music to the bank not them. It would piss you off too.
Steven's point is profound. Yes this is a small issue. Yes we're all going to go to bed happy healthy and alive at the end of the day. But no lies/cheats/steals even half as hard as the music business does
No he's not he finally signed with them when he got a deal that made sense. For a long time the deal was way skewed toward the service. He finally got the deal he wanted that made financial sense for him.
Why haven’t you got any music up for people to listen? What makes you so sure that you’re so talented and are writing the right songs? There are a lot of professional female musicians out there who are killing it... If you’re as talented as you think then it’s time to commit to it and work as hard as you can to push your music out to people. For instance, Ed Sheeran played more than 300 gigs in a single year when he was trying to make it. That is a serious work ethic... Just think about all the time he spent travelling/networking/setting up shows to achieve that. If anybody offers to hand it to you on a platter, they’re very likely deceiving you.
Who remember About 20yrs ago Michael Jackson was protesting against the record companies "sony" that they steal from the artist and if the artist stop touring they go broke and at that time media made fun of him. The thing is record companies are nothing without the artist
Yep. That's who came to mind and how the record companies and MJ financial managers screwed him. Mike was bigger than the industry, influence wise. They destroyed a genius.
Scariest part is, the money is just the first thing the Execs/managers want from the artist. There are too many depraved people in the industry, mostly men who abuse their power criminally and with impunity!
Why doesnt the music industry get all its affected or agreeing people to form their own "spotify" or "iTunes" where they can distribute the money amongst their own committee i.e. directly to the artists.
Record labels own the master rights of the recording (in most cases) so artists have 0 say if their music gets added to Spotify or any streaming service.
It is criminal what they are doing to artists these days. How long before nobody is interested in writing and performing music? Greed is ruining the world.
The prick at 7:27, I think Steven is referring to is Lars Ulrich, drummer from the band, Metallica. He went after Napster and took them to court. He fought the fight and lost. Steven said it best, " it's become the norm.".
The music business and the music makers is such a huge gigantic problem that not body cannot actually imagine! It's a problem that unfortunately will be not resolved for maybe another 20 years or so...
Cant blame Jay for saying this and taking the $100Mil bc he actually got/is getting paid a stupid amount which changed the game for all “artist” on digital platforms, let alone what he did for podcasters!
Streaming & Record labels absolutely killed music but the audience is to blame partly as well. Music was never supposed to be "readily available for free".
Hmmmm,curious to see steven tyler so concerned about other artists getting credit..... Isn't this the same guy that would unplug equipment from opening acts if the crowd was too enthusiastic about them?
One of the things that pisses me off about Aerosmith/Steven Tyler is they always focus on Joe Perry, who is overrated in my opinion. Brad Whitford is the better guitar player in the band hands down.
as one of many poor 80's kids growing up in eastern europe I didn't have neither the means nor the money to legaly buy Aerosmith's music. If there were no P2P Networks I would have never found out how much Aerosmith sucks!
Damn that Spotify rant did not age well.
yikes
He ranted even harder during Billy Corgan.
They finally offered him some serious money evidently.
Aged perfectly... The bloke held out & got PAID
Steve have 130M... I think he is ok...
I am from the future.
Joe Rogan moves exclusively to Spotify.
Kinda sorta
😄
you are in the wrong future
yeah cuz they paid him a 100 million, the rant he is making here is still completely valid
How did you know!? 🥺 😭
Stephen has a point. Back in the old days people would hear new music on the radio and if they liked it they would buy the album. As a result, royalty rates were kept very low for radio (performance rates), while higher / market rates for albums (mechanical rates). This was seen as fair because radio acted like an advertiser for the songs and the real money would come via record sales. Streaming changed everything because the listener does not own the music (or mechanical like a record, CD or mp3). As such, streaming was given the low radio perf. rate as a model - even though streaming offered no benefit towards record sales. The MMA seeks to readjust the rates to today’s market. The US Constitution allows Congress to pass Law in context to copyright.
El Jefe Scientist Old days? Shit, it wasn’t that long ago that radio was the medium to promote your band’s album. Obviously, not the case anymore.
@@keithjagger8095 Radio for the most part still functions the same. Internet however has degraded that. Radio can still advertise your music, the actual issue with radio is that it is setup to be bias to whoever pays what station to play. Hence why pop stations will play Lady GaGa's new song three times in one hour. And they claim it's only a top hit because most people will listen to pop stations that happen to play three times per hour. It's an inflation device to claim your hit is "famous and big" but with that said, it doesn't change the fact that whatever radio stations genre can still by concept, advise your song.
Holy shit did you figure that out yourself man aaaahahaha
I've listened to several clips from this podcast tonight, I've really enjoyed listening to Steven Tyler.
Dude, let Stephen talk!
Agreed! Joe has interviewed a lot of music people, so now he thinks he knows more than the one he’s talking to.
Irritating!
Fuckin seriously
Joe is an extrovert who doesn't know when to shut the fuck up and LISTEN. This is why I hate extroverts and NT's in general, they talk wayyy too fucking much without letting other people get their point across.
Joe just went to Spotify dude
who is stephen?
wasn't prince talking about this for long time and people where saying that he was wrong to want to protect his art
Yes indeed, that's why he wrote Slave on his face and changed his name. He was so obsessive about his Art and music.
Nobody said he was wrong. Musicians have been complaining about this since the business began. Prince at least was a very rich man. Many great artists didnt earn a penny.
What prince was basically saying was artists nowadays arent making the money that they used to. Ppl tend not to value things they can get for free. For example there’s a thing called the compulsory license law which allows artists through the record company’s to take music at will w/o permission. Which doesn’t exist in any other art form. Intellectual copyrights.
Stephen showed great respect for Smoky Robinson. Even made a great example of true richness.
The problem, IMO, and speaking as a FORMER professional musician myself, is based on one basic confusion. When people use the term “The Music Business”, what they’re actually referring to unknowingly is The Record Business. A hundred years ago there was no record business. Musicians only got paid for playing live. Songwriters had it better than the musicians back then since they owned the publishing rights. But when musicians started making records - physical objects bought in stores - that’s when the potential to make serious money started. It might just be that the “Record Business” was kind of an anomaly in the music biz; and so far as I can see, those years are over. And the days of musicians having to “play for their supper” have returned.
Comparing anything modern time to the good ol days is pretty pointless.
@@JokerzGallery it’s not the good old days though. Musicians have been around forever but serious mansion money really only started in the 60’s ( of course there are a few exceptions), it peaked in the 90’s and then started declining with illegal downloads and now streaming. Musicians have to make their money with shows which is how it’s always been the golden era where bands could sign a record deal and buy a mansion and 10 cars is a weird trend in the grand scheme of things. Obviously a lot of money for a few pop singers and rappers etc. but other artist have to make their livings with merch and live shows.
Play for supper unless your rich as shit already and can jack ticket prices through the roof because the dumbass masses have their pocket tv recording device they were programmed to purchase and live in a mostly false reality due to social media; so they can't budget their finances or their time worth a fuck to see they are being controlled to buy crap they don't need. All we got now in the "record business" is old troubadours unwilling to care about cutting new records for another yacht and up and comers who are controlled to be unheard unless they sound like everyone else in the establishment.
This is so needed. Management takes everything not just money they take life they take souls and happiness
Steven Tyler Tells It Like It Is. Period.
Jamie: "I studied Lil Tay in college. I got an A!"
Lol yeah, I feel like Jamie says that in a lot of his arguments. Must've taken general studies for four years and not focused on a career path.
EpyonRoyal Jamie is such an idiot, when he was he getting all heated on the nukes with Eddie he was like ya I got an a. Then Eddie was like so you went to nuclear physics class? And Jamie was like no I didn’t go that class. Eddie is just to crazy of a dude to sound logical sometimes
This showed everyone (well, me atleast) the different side of Steven way more than American Idol. Cool to see someone that is a big of a rockstar as can be, also be really cool and down to earth
lol Rogan talkin about Spotify aAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHA
This was 5 years ago. I swear it feels like I just watched this live. 😂😩
Mr Tyler m..he is been through everything!my guru !!🙏🙌
This shit makes me not want spotify anymore. If I listen to your music you deserve my money.
The service provider (comcast) owns Media companies like movie studios. So they have a personal interest in going after people stealing their content through their network. Even I've gotten emails from comcast telling me to stop watching movies online (before vpn).
Love JRE. Had to chuckle at a little after 5:11 when Joe said he was not on Spotify. Listen to him daily on Spotify currently. What changed?
the money.
The problem is that streaming allows for more competition and artistic freedom whereas a sales focused mentality sort of forces the artists to create something that will appeal to the masses.
I think the best solution is to limit free streaming to selective songs from albums, or EP's/singles.
Listening to Spotify these days feels like you're listening to musicians the same way you watch people in the Hunger Games.
you probably live in the moon Lunarsatellite lol competition and artistic freedom dont matter f if the same greedy pigs controls the streaming medias or the distribution. At the end of the day its all about money..and you cant give labels any power on that
besides who decides what songs to limit ?? who can have authority on that besides the artist?..
btw..listening to musicians nowadays on spotify is shit, same as HG
My Dad‘s friend has a house next to Steven’s house in Mass. My Dad told me a story earlier today about a time when his friend hosted a party at the house, he was drunk and decided to go take a piss in a bush in Steven’s backyard. As he’s taking a piss, Steven walks up to him and says “What… are you doing??” The friend said “Oh, I’m just looking for my wallet.” Steven patted his ass saying “You mean this wallet in your pocket?” The friend said “Oh yeah! That wallet!” My Dad’s friend went back to his house and Steven came along and hung out for a bit. The friend said he was very nice.
Ppl might confuse this & say “why is he complaining he’s rich” or something like that, but the point is someone else who didn’t do shit is taking their music to the bank not them. It would piss you off too.
Steven's point is profound. Yes this is a small issue. Yes we're all going to go to bed happy healthy and alive at the end of the day. But no lies/cheats/steals even half as hard as the music business does
Hearing Joe Rogan saying the reason why he's not on Spotify.... Yikes considering he just signed up with them.
He's full of shit.
No he's not he finally signed with them when he got a deal that made sense. For a long time the deal was way skewed toward the service. He finally got the deal he wanted that made financial sense for him.
@@tituscrow2402 Except elements within are trying to fuck with his deal but so far Spotify has been cool about it.
Love in an elevator, Livin' it up when I'm goin' down...
Joe rogans lil tay number 1 plugger
Im a musician struggling w/ discrimination in this field men can break thru noooo problem w half my talent. Screw the industry I am stuck with......
Why haven’t you got any music up for people to listen? What makes you so sure that you’re so talented and are writing the right songs? There are a lot of professional female musicians out there who are killing it... If you’re as talented as you think then it’s time to commit to it and work as hard as you can to push your music out to people. For instance, Ed Sheeran played more than 300 gigs in a single year when he was trying to make it. That is a serious work ethic... Just think about all the time he spent travelling/networking/setting up shows to achieve that. If anybody offers to hand it to you on a platter, they’re very likely deceiving you.
Steven Tyler is sooo freakin awesome!
ever since Napster had came out that's when the music industry changed alot
This aged lovely.
Who remember About 20yrs ago Michael Jackson was protesting against the record companies "sony" that they steal from the artist and if the artist stop touring they go broke and at that time media made fun of him. The thing is record companies are nothing without the artist
Yep. That's who came to mind and how the record companies and MJ financial managers screwed him. Mike was bigger than the industry, influence wise. They destroyed a genius.
Scariest part is, the money is just the first thing the Execs/managers want from the artist. There are too many depraved people in the industry, mostly men who abuse their power criminally and with impunity!
Hi Joe!
Would you check out Terrance Popp and have him on your show?
Steven Tyler underrated singer.
He's such a beautyfull soal. Never change!
Why doesnt the music industry get all its affected or agreeing people to form their own "spotify" or "iTunes" where they can distribute the money amongst their own committee i.e. directly to the artists.
5:09 😅 not on Spotify
Tyler looks more like 40 than 70.
He looks a lot better now than he did in the 70s -90s
More like 50
Joe better hopes Spotify doesnt see this.. wow, wonder if he will or if he has talked about this at all on his show.
360 deal, Jared Leto did a good doc about his bands deal and how much the label took from them.
What’s it called? Is there a link?
"in there f*cking pockets" that look on his face was priceless
If every artist stopped giving music to labels and streaming services what would happen?
Record labels own the master rights of the recording (in most cases) so artists have 0 say if their music gets added to Spotify or any streaming service.
Joe “ I know everything “ rogan
Funny how that’ Spotify thing that made no sense to be on is the only way to watch JRE now!
I love his tone when he says things like in their fucking pockets.
It is criminal what they are doing to artists these days. How long before nobody is interested in writing and performing music? Greed is ruining the world.
Hes talking about NOT being on Spotify. That's hilarious. As he's rolling in Spotify money now.
Stanhope wanted comedy bookers to stop getting cuts from standups, too. Less lawyers=less leeches.
The prick at 7:27, I think Steven is referring to is Lars Ulrich, drummer from the band, Metallica. He went after Napster and took them to court. He fought the fight and lost. Steven said it best, " it's become the norm.".
What are you even talking about? He’s obviously talking about Sean Parker. Why would he have any ill will toward Ulrich? You’re an idiot
Well well, how the turn tables.
How did Smokey know exactly how much he was owed?
5:08 - Jamie, fast forward a few years
2:50 ????? 🎶
Wonder what changed
Just give these artists the money theyve earned they deserve it
The music business and the music makers is such a huge gigantic problem that not body cannot actually imagine! It's a problem that unfortunately will be not resolved for maybe another 20 years or so...
Steven is a genius and totally right, love you forever baby ❤❤❤❤❤
annnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnd joes on spotify.
5:10 oh yeah Joe?
“It’s called a 24/7 or summin like that.”
I knew what he meant.. 360 deal. They are the devil.
3:55 deep
Zappa would be proud of you Steven!
A lot of young artists these days get stuck in 360 deals 👎
I only buy music from Apple. I believe the artists should be paid for their work 100%
So many artists in the 50s 60s and 70s got royally screwed $$. You'd be surprised how many barely get by...
Isn’t joe on Spotify?
This clip was before the Spotify deal.
This ages funny with the Spotify comment
That's why you don't sign anything without you owning your own publishing rights.
"Fuck all this sick swinging contest. We all gon be dead in 100 years. Let the kids have the music." - Ye
Google says smoke robinson's net worth is $100 million. I think he could afford the legal fees
Joe “I’m not a reptilian overlord, but how do I know you aren’t one?” Rogan
5:10 this aged like real milk
Funny how Joe talks about Spotify here.
Cant blame Jay for saying this and taking the $100Mil bc he actually got/is getting paid a stupid amount which changed the game for all “artist” on digital platforms, let alone what he did for podcasters!
Streaming & Record labels absolutely killed music but the audience is to blame partly as well. Music was never supposed to be "readily available for free".
Steven Tyler and Russell Brand would make a cute lesbian couple
Stephen: "beautiful blonde lawyer...she's smart, she's my lawyer..." Dude we're not in the 80's anymore.
What's wrong with that?
Haha! Joe totally bashes Spotify in this cast. My, how 3 years can change things.
Where’s Joe. now...?????
they rethunked it
As good an idea as this is, this will never happen. If it is digital, it is free. It has been this was since the advent of the CD & the computer.
Hmmmm,curious to see steven tyler so concerned about other artists getting credit.....
Isn't this the same guy that would unplug equipment from opening acts if the crowd was too enthusiastic about them?
I don’t think I can think of a single artist I know that hasn’t at some point pulled some extreme shady stuff tbh, but I do see your point.
Joe 'i constantly interrupt guests' Rogan
So funny joe rogan said that about Spotify who would have known
100 mil is a great motivator
Shut-up Joe let Steven do the talking
Dude he went to Spotify
Spotify cutting checks now I guess
The problem is the whole streaming platform. It’s an insult to the artist.
Gee i hope they don't come after me for recording songs off the radio with a cassette tape back in the 80s lol.
“David Israelite.” I wonder what his ethnicity is.
Joe let him just tell it
5:10 say what?
5:10
smokey robinson worth like 100 million
This didn’t age well.....
One of the things that pisses me off about Aerosmith/Steven Tyler is they always focus on Joe Perry, who is overrated in my opinion. Brad Whitford is the better guitar player in the band hands down.
Didn't Spotify give Joe.. 100 mill.?? ..😂
How the hell did Liv come from that!
Joe let the man talk ! You interrupt a lot of good stuff
How the hell DO you make it in the music business? It seems like you, the artist, need to do everything yourself...
as one of many poor 80's kids growing up in eastern europe I didn't have neither the means nor the money to legaly buy Aerosmith's music. If there were no P2P Networks I would have never found out how much Aerosmith sucks!
Like you never used , stole inspiration, or parts of earlier artists lyrics. Why don't you pay them a piece of the pie?