Journalist reacts for the first time to 마마무 (MAMAMOO) - Where Are We Now
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- Ciao guys! Welcome to Queenship, the perfect place for you if you love kpop girl group. My name is Berry, an italian journalist living in Lisbon. I'm not a Kpop guru, I'm just a guy who enjoy this kind of music.
Many of you have asked me to dedicate some videos to Mamamoo, but to be honest I have never listened to their music. So you advised me to catch up by watching [MV] 마마무 (MAMAMOO) - Where Are We Now for the first time.
To be honest I didn't have huge expectations on them, but Solar, Moonbyul, Wheein, and Hwasa pleasantly impressed me. The song is a very romantic ballad and their voices, really powerful, are perfect for this style. It surprises me to see that in an era of autotune and various effects, there are still artists who fortunately know how to sing.
[MV] 마마무 (MAMAMOO) - Where Are We Now is definitely a pearl of kpop music that all lovers of the genre should listen to.
#mamamoo #solar #moonbyul #wheein #hwasa #wherearewenow #moomoo
Don't forget to subscribe to my channel to stay updated on more reactions and insights!
JOIN ME ON INSTAGRAM AND TIK TOK:
✅Instagram: / queenshipkp. .
✅Tik Tok: / queenshipkpop. .
Credit song: Chillpeach - Dreamy Mode : • [no copyright music] '...
this was mamamoo s 7 year point and lot of fans at the time had not resigned and felt like a disband song. But they are now 10 years and are all doing solo tours. Love mamamoo. They are so diverse in music. Recommend piano man and egotistical .
Thank you for your suggestions!
I second BOTH Piano Man & Egotistic!
@@V3actions Add it on the list, thank you!
I recommend Mamamoo's Immortal Songs medley performance. The live performances are where Mamamoo shines most
thank you so much for your suggestion!
The ending refers to two of them sharing the same dream...that's Hwasa and Wheein who have been best friends since they were in middle school. To debut together in the same group was like a dream come true for both of them.
Omg, so cute!
Mamamoo was created by RBW specifically to have the best vocalists, complete focus on vocals and live performance in an era where choreography is the focus of pretty much every group. Mamamoo is known in korea as basically the best live vocals kpop group, top tier with the few other groups who can claim to be the best of the best like BTOB(who are friends with mamamoo). These women started older than typical for Kpop idols as well as from the start being lyricists, composers, musicians and choreographers, they are not like other groups with having everything done for them and backed by a lot of money for production and advertising. They had to be part of composing and producing their music, Busk in street performances early on and really work hard to get their fame. I saw them live in los angeles last year and they really sing as well live as they do in recorded studios, very very few singers can do live and they do 3 and 4 hour concerts, singing that well to the end along with other fun, comedy skits during performances for example. They have over 400 videos to watch, pretty much every song ranges from great to unreal, always go for live performances, this song has a live performance video for example. BUT also watch the MVs as these are well produced as you saw here, ranging again from beautiful and stunning to hilarious. Yes Purple Kiss is the new group from RBW, in fact there are videos of mamamoo members helping purple kiss during training, camping(they all have youtube channels, I suggest Solarsido first because Solar the power belter you heard has a whole lot of covers that are unbelievably good). Purple kiss follows a similar model of composing their own music and choreo, they too focus on vocals and performance but not as extreme as Mamamoo did for vocals. Most people watch the Immortal Songs, Dingo Killing voice and the Hwasa TV show(yes mamamoo does TV and other stuff not music related) Episode 8, Mamamoo Live Hits collection. All 3 of these are live performances. Each of the members, Solar(powerbelter), Moonbyul (rapper), Wheein (honey vocals), Hwasa (sultry vocals) all have solo albums as well. Each member can rap and sing by the way, and they sing every genre, mamamoo has a whole lot of jazz, big band, retro styles, reggaeton, rock, pop, R&B and more. They also have a subgroup Mamamoo+ which has some awesome songs, tons of OSTs which are amazing and covers which sound sometimes better than the originals. You cant go wrong with this group, no other group has 4 top tier female vocalists who sound this good together. You cant go wrong with purple kiss either.
Thank you for your precous comment! You make me even more curious to recover their material! I follow Purple Kiss since their debut, I hope to see them live one day
“Where are we now” and “I miss you” are my favorite songs vocally. Next level! These girls can sing. In my opinion they are the best female singers out there right now.
I will also hear "I miss you", thank you!
These are also my favorites!
@@queenshipkpopthe live performance of this is exquisite. I highly recommend it, so you can hear what talented singers they really are.
Purple Kiss tells people they are from the same agency as Mamamoo. One thing you can count on from all RBW groups is great vocals. They are also more likely to use real instruments.
it's really interesting how they work. I have to recover others songs from them
Mamamoo is an extraordinary group with an impeccable 10-year career to date. It is a very talented group where none of its members are left behind, all four have impressive voices, they all play at least one instrument (most play more than one), they are the female group with the most accreditations in the history of kpop with more than 200 songs under their names and Moonbyul, the rapper, is the most credited female idol in history with over 120 songs to her name. Their discography includes almost any genre one can think of, from funck, jazz, blues, bosanova to Latin, regge, ballads, hip hop, R&B and more. It is a group that not had an easy journey, especially in its beginnings since they are the first group that their company debuted, so they were the ones who practically built the company from the economic point to the prestige. Not having the budget they themselves had to do everything from wearing their own clothes, putting on makeup, doing their own choreography and even doing street performances to gain an audience. At the level of talent, Mamamoo is already a show and if we add to that their personalities, how much they love and respect each other, their strong characters (believe me, this is not the group that can be forced to do something, they always have the last word) and how funny they are, then it's the group you totally fall in love with.
Thank you for sharing this with me. In this way I can appreciate their music even more!
The members are:
- Hwasa: the girl you recognized from the other song
- Wheein: the girl with the sweetest voice
- Solar: the girl with more power in her voice
- Moonbyul: the rapper
Thank you! So I was right about Hwasa. She had a face that was familiar to me😂❤️
@@queenshipkpop Her face is very recognizable because she very unique and beautiful 💜
@@MBella123 I am totally agree with you. She is the first member that captured my attention
You are right, Hwasa is the one who does I Love My Body. They all four have very successful solo careers along with being a group with the best vocals in kpop (honestly I'll put them up against any pop vocalists anywhere). The Killing Voice will give you a notion of the variety of styles and genres that done over the years. Their ultimate flex is The Immortal Songs Medley, this is a concert clip from 2017. The Immortal songs is a Korean competition show where the contestants cover songs by famous Korean artists. They had a tendency to look down on idol groups but Mamamoo won them over with their fantastics vocals and performances. They were the first female idols to win and the first idol group to win more than once. They appeared 14 times and won 3. Anyway, the actual episodes of the show will be blocked, but the medly is fine to react to.
And Purple Kiss is my second favorite group after Mamamoo. So glad you like them as well.
Now you made me even more curious to recover the material on them. In particolar the Killing Voice becaus everybod talks so good about that performance! I follow Purple Kiss since the debut, I love them!
I love Mamamoo. Their songs are great and even their commercial songs are my favorite. Their medleys of covers of other songs are perfect. Their live singing is impeccable, flawless performances! Check out their Dingo Killing Voice for a sampler medley of their hits and Immortal Songs Medley for a sample of their live performance! They are all currently doing solo activities and world tours, but they are still together.
Thank you for your suggestions! I want to check the Killing Voice, I am very curious to watch it, after that I will recovered some others songs from them so that I can appreciated it even more
Their Dingo Killing Voice is a CLASSIC! Radish Queens overflowing with talent and showing both charisma and playfulness during the performance!!!
@@V3actions I will watch also the Killing Voice. Before I want to recover some others songs about them
thanks for reacting to MMM, all members are all rounder, they are the 1st group to have all members chart on Billboard as solo artists while the group is still active.
Mamamoo live is just as good if not better than MMM on record, esp when they've got an audience. You'll hear people say they eat cd's for breakfast and you can't beat their stage presence and joy in performing as they feed off the audience's energy and work the crowd.
enjoy !
Thank you for watching the video! I will watch also their live performances because I'm so curious to hear them live
@@queenshipkpop that's why many suggest you watch the dingo killing voice video. it's live vocal
@@alicealiencat Yep. Thank you. It's already on my list but before to watch it I want to hear others songs from them so that I can appreciate it even more
Thank you so so much for this, they are real queen.
Thank you for watching the video!
I'm not sure wawn is the best song to start Mamamoo. This song was a turning point in their career. It happened at their 7years (when contracts have to be renewed for the first time). One member didn't renew (Wheein) and left for another company for her solo activities but stayed for group activities. Then Hwasa did the same. 1 group, 4 solo artists and 3 companies. A mess. One of the first time members left companies without leaving the group and still be successful.
They had to assess their needs, wishes and will as solo artist and as a group (Result : Where are we now). It's when they decided to go at their own pace. Taking time to do solo and group activities not carrying for pressure from companies, industry, fans. Their are a 10yo group now. They have been criticized since the beginning for so many reasons but, thanks to their talent, they are now respected by all. They don't feel the need to rush albums and content like before this song. They want to enjoy they careers.
Even if they have important solo career (2024 for exemple is full of solo album, concert, fancon, world tour for each member) they never go against each other. Their album release never happen at the same time not to compet or outshine each other. As solo artist they work along each other, supporting each other. When they will do group activities again no member will be pressure into it.
There is so much to say about Mamamoo... The important thing is, they are vocal and harmony queens
Thank you for all these info about them! Their story look so interesting and particular. They told me that a lot of fans tought that this was a goodbye song but I am glad that they continued with their journey. I will recover other materials about them because they are so talented. I was so impressed during the reaction. Which song do you suggest me to hear?
@@queenshipkpop There is no song that can sum up Mamamoo. They have more than 300 songs, covers, OST... Their songs go from jazz to rock through rap, pop, balads, fun songs, kid songs, OSTs or commercials better than some title songs.
Many will recomand their live stages (Their live performances are a must to see) : MMA awards, MAMA awards, Queendom, 4seasons 4 colors concert, Immortal song medley (I don't recommand the medley. The songs should be watched individually)
I always recommand The Killing voice to start.
And if you really want to understand them ? (I can't even fit everything that is a must to listen in that list.................)
Debut : Mr Ambiguous
Jazz : Piano man (and their Gaon performance)
Pop : Um Oh Ah Yeah or Yes I am (Them owning the fact they are not beauty standard )
Vocal performance : I miss you (Debut : The way to Sampo)
Rap : Taller than you
A song that nobody can cover because you have to be them for the song to be incredible : Decalcomanie (the MV is great until that part we all hate at the end)
Latin vibe : Egotistic
Melancholia : Wind flower
Commercials that sounds like a title song : Gleam
Statement against Kpop toxic culture : HIP
Them and their fans : Decalcomanie from the 300 show (300 fans are called and without the group help they have to plan a performance to match the chosen song. The group doesn't know anything about the fans plan or how many will show up among the 300)
Worth mentionning : You are the best (MMA performance), Woo hoo, My everything (OST), I love too (emotional song), Star Wind Flower Sun (composed by all members), No more drama, Gogobebe, My Star, Destiny (Queendom live performance), Wanna be myself (other commercial), Dingga, Illella (being relevant even in 3 different companies)
And there is so many hidden gems...
Solo
Solar : Blues (From a recent album), Fire cover performance (4seasons 4 colors concert)
Moonbyul : Eclipse (MV is so great), Congratulation (from Second world)
Wheein : D-Day (underrated song), 7 rings perfomance (4seasons 4 colors concert)
Hwasa : Maria (Her baptismal name), Orange colored sky cover (2023 version)
I'm a little to passionate...
@@nowlimira5868 thank you, your comment is so precious! I wanted to recover some others songs before to watch the Killing Voice to appreciate even more the show
EXID has now managed to have at least 2 comebacks in the post-agency phase of their career, releasing 2 music videos and one album (or maybe two, I'm not sure about the timing, one may have been produced in agency then released after?). They've been focusing more on acting. Post-agency MV's are "B.L.E.S.S.E.D." and "Fire", and one member, Hani (one N), is now engaged to be married. SNSD has 3 of current 8 members in agencies other than SM, but since SM can barely keep its act together even when they control everything, I'm not holding my breath for an OT8 comeback any time soon. The 5-member in-house subunit, "Oh! GG" just doesn't quite have enough juice to be popular, Taeyeon and Hyoyeon are better served by their solo careers.
They are the vocal queens of Kpop
They are so good, I was so impressed by them!
@@queenshipkpop they are amazing!!
@@MBella123Por isso insisti para que assistisse, elas são rainhas e o canal é queens!!! Tudo certo!!!
@@queenshipkpop Please, Killing Voice!!!
@@khristinacruz9107 Hahahhaha Faz sentido!
This is the best vocal group in Kpop ❤
They ara amazing!
Moonbyul (the rapper) can sing as well. React to Moonbyul's absence - refugee - ddu ddu ddu and without
Crazy talented group when even your rapper has amazing vocals! 🌜⭐
Omg I tought ddu ddu ddu was a cover of Blackpink 😂 I will check everything, thank you!
they are amazing!
@@queenshipkpop no, is a Moonbyul song.
pls react to mamamoo on kiliing voice on dingo or mamamoo on immortal songs both great showcase of their vocals and stage energy.
Yass! I want to recover before the Killing Voice others song from them so in this way I can appreciated it even more ❤️
Well if you are searching for artists that can really sing, you have came to the right place. I suggest you check out their live performance next
Killing voice is already on my list. Can't wait to watch it!
More Mamamoo, please react to their mv KILLING VOICE - Perfect Harmony ❤❤🦋❤
Yep! I want to recover some others songs before to watch it, so I can appreciated it even more!❤️
YESSSS MAMAMOO, THE BEST VOCAL GIRLGROUP IN KPOP!!!! PLEASE KILLING VOICE!!!! Foi Mamamoo que me fez gostar de kpop... Eu estudo música e, com exceção de BTS, eu via muito efeito, playback, exagero de apêlo sensual, muito financeiro, letras fracas e pouquíssima qualidade vocal e harmonização. Mas elas são incríveis! Elas são ótimas principalmente ao vivo e Solar na apresentação em poledance e depois ainda cantaram muito. Obrigado pelo react!!!
Obrigado por ver o vídeo! Ainda bem que gostaste. Tens mais alguma musica das Mamamoo para sugerir?
When it comes to vocals I have to say mamamoo is one of my favorites along with the older group bigmama I would recommend both killing voices if you haven't checked them out yet.
I was so impressed by them, they are amazing!
The MAMAMOO members are among some of the most-credited idols in K-Pop as of Aug 27/23
- Moonbyul actually has the most songwriting credits of all 3rd generation female idols at 117(2nd most credited famale artist overall... Yoon Mirae at 139), since she writes her own raps(and more) in almost all of the group’s songs. As well as contributing to the songwriting in many of them as well.
- Solar has 41 credits to her name. She wrote the lyrics and composition for her solo song, “Spit it Out”. Composer on "Honey".
- Hwasa has 46 credits. The lyrics to her solo song, “María”, were praised for its inventive and meaningful wordplay. ("Somebody" w/Loco).
- Wheein has 10 credits (that I can find, maybe more)
COULD use an Update, as this is 9ish months ago LoL... if anyone has the info (TY)
I love that they put so much effort into creating their music, it makes me appreciate them even more!
@@queenshipkpop Currently all of those numbers have increased and Moonbyul is now the most credited female idol overall.
@@janygonzalez2262 Thank you for the clarification!
@@janygonzalez2262 What are the #'s... I did say that I could use an UPDATE.
@@wj6782 Moonbyul has more than 120 and the rest have increased, because of the date you gave here, they have released new solo albums where they have several songs written and composed by them, but I don't know the specific number.
This is the only girl group I listen to. BTS keeps me too busy but sometimes I need Mamamoo. I recommend the Killing Voice medley live. Ty!
Thank you for watching the video! I'm so curious to watch the Killing voice, everybody suggest me to watch it so I have high expectations on it
I love your reaction, it’s really attentive and engaged. You don’t really have to apologize for stopping, it’s your channel. It’s actually better to stop to say what you want to say than to talk over the music, no?
Thank you so much!
Mamamoo are the TRUTH! ❤💙🤍💛
❤️
I present you the best vocal in Kpop, it's even better live, I give you all the certainty in the world.
They are so good, I was so impressed!
One of the best group in kpop of all the time! Their lives are legendary and they singing in real time.... never playback as many others!!!! 👑 pick any songs by luck and as they said about mamamoo is ''the group that we trust and believe''!
I'm so curious to hear more songs from them ❤️
Everyone that wants to know mamamoo should watch "How mamamo plays on the car"
Add it on my list, thank you!
I love this song, but their discography is huge and varied. This was also at a time when Moonbyul was not always fully included in purely "vocal" arrangements; she has since deservedly eon many plaudits for her singing. If you like "singers", kpop is a wonderful treasure trove. I prefer MMM and BTOB live (for the latter Killing Voice they struggled to record them all, as they were so loud!) Again, most groups have truly stand out vocalists and ensemble skills, but I return to these two groups frequently for the variety of genres and their genuine team dynamics.
I'm so curious to watch the Killing Voice. Everybody talks so good about that performance
These are LIVE.
MAMAMOO IMMORTAL SONGS MEDLEY czcams.com/video/h3YCi0qBMzs/video.html
MAMAMOO's KILLING VOICE with perfect HARMONY/Egoistic, HIP, Dinga, AYA | Dingo Music czcams.com/video/WvkTcNQsxzc/video.html
MAMAMOO(in 2023) joined the ranks of Destiny's Child, The Spice Girls, and TLC as the ONLY girl groups to sell over 70,000 tickets on their FIRST tour in the USA.
This makes MAMAMOO the ONLY girl group to achieve this milestone AFTER a 21-year gap.
AND the ONLY Non-English speaking girl group to accomplish such a feat.
Thank you so much, I will recover everything! ❤️
I second all of the other comments, but if you want a stunning example of just how crazy good they are, look up Mamamoo Baby Goat. It's just them fooling around and singing a children's song in front of a green screen, and they knocked it out of the park.
Thank you, I will check it!
Mamamoo tiene muchas buenas canciones te recomiendo mucho que sigas reaccionando a ellas, muy buena reacción ❤
Thank you so much!
I don’t if i have to write in English or Italian cause I'm italian too, but I chose English. The list of songs you could react is so long and it's difficult to choose, Mamamoo's: Paint me, Hip, Aya, Starry night...
Va benissimo anche in italiano, grazie mille per i tuoi suggerimenti. Li aggiungo alle cose da recuperare ❤
I highly recommend you watch their Dingo Killing voice performance ti get an idea with their discography. It has an English subtitle.
My next reaction about them will be The Immortal Songs Medley and after the Killing Voice
As the local Moonbyul stan (the group's rapper), I can say a lot of fans were also a bit disappointed that she was relegated to the rap section here. Not because it was bad, I don't think Byul knows how to give a bad rap, but because she has improved so much vocally and it seemed a shame not to show that on a title track (and especially one as meaningful as WAWN).
If you want to check out her vocal skills, I recommend her Second World stages (though I think the TV network that aired the show can be a bit happy on the copyright claims?), as well as the comeback stages for their b-side of Ten Nights, and her most recent solo comeback of Touchin' and Movin'!
All the girls have solo careers on top of their group activities so there is a HUGE backlog of songs you can check out, spanning all sorts of genres. But if you're liking the vocal, ballad styling of this, I would recommend checking out the WAW mini album. It's only 3 more tracks and they're all ballads.
Thank you so much for your suggestions! My next reaction about them Will be The Immortal Songs Medley. I'm so curious to hear them live!
My KPop Group Trifecta... Mamamoo, BlackPink, and SHINee.
SOLOISTS... Bae Suzy, IU, and Kim SeJeong(who is an Huge IU fan girl LoL), ALL of whom are Very good actresses as well.
Sejeong is the Reason I got into KPop
Mamamoo intro You should react to
INTRODUCING MAMAMOO! Part 1 Solar & Moonbyul ( reupload from Purple Hawke) czcams.com/video/W6r-JC1fHHA/video.html
INTRODUCING MAMAMOO! Part 2 Wheein & Hwasa ( reupload from Purple Hawke) czcams.com/video/h5nRacz6w8w/video.html
Thank you for these info! ❤️
Hope you react more to Mamamoo.... They are known as the Vocal Queens of Kpop and are also called Beagle-dols... You will love them.
* Mamamoo Best Vocal Moments - czcams.com/video/H8Wi3vzDmdo/video.html
* Introduction Guide 2022 part 1 - czcams.com/video/c5VpPrwjziM/video.html
* Introduction Guide 2022 part 2 - czcams.com/video/UYRzCrh4avs/video.html
* Mamamoo Best Live Vocals (Acapella Queens) - czcams.com/video/_2GUSP0PQIY/video.html
* Mamamoo randomly harmonizing with each other - czcams.com/video/3y3ldyY4IYE/video.html
* Mamamoo Immortal Songs Medley - czcams.com/video/h3YCi0qBMzs/video.html
* Mamamoo Killing Voice - czcams.com/video/WvkTcNQsxzc/video.html
Thank you so much for your suggestions! I will pubblish 1 video at week of them. The next one is the Killing Voice. I already reacted to Immortal Songs Medley 🥰
Parla pure con me. Sono una moomoo da quasi 7 anni. Ho tutte le informazioni che vuoi, le ho viste anche dal vivo. Ciao!
Ciao! Quale canzoni mi suggerisci di recuperare? Se vuoi dirmi com'è stato il concerto, sono curiosissimo di sapere come sono live
@@queenshipkpop detto questo, ho studiato canto per 4 anni, ora canto in un coro gospel quindi ho qualche competenza per giudicare vocalmente.
Hanno 4 timbri unici.
A livello vocale, come potenza e colori Solar copre diverse ottave e ha un ottima stabilità collocandola come mezzosoprano/soprano
Wheein ha una voce armonica e melodiosa potrei definirla un soprano
Hwasa è un mezzosoprano con note rientranti nei contralti
Moonbyul è un contralto puro con note molto basse, sta attualmente studiando per accrescere il suo strumento vocale.
Cantano SOLO live. Mai in playback.
Hanno un'armonisità che non senti spesso.
Sono perfette insieme
i love delcacomanie
Thank you, I will hear it!
Groups like Mamamoo and Exo always bring vocals and kill it everytime. Mamamoo are Vocal Queens and Exo are Vocal Kings. Check out Exo, by the way if you haven't already. For me, best 2 groups from 3rd gen😊😊😊😊❤❤❤
I have to recover also Exo! I know only one song from them because I heard a cover in a tv drama
@@queenshipkpop check out their Killing Voice performance. 2 members are not there seeing Kai was already doing his Military Service and Lay (Chinese member) has not been able to perform with them because of tensing between South Korea and China.
You'll love them. Sadly, it seems some kpop companies have put choreo and catchy beats before vocals (which is not the artist's fault) However, Exo and Mamamoo put vocals first. Even Xiumin (Exo oldest member said vocals were the most importance. Check out Tempo by Exo. Their lives, like in Mamamoo, are even better than studio version.
@@Ming3484 Thank you for the info! Killing vocal only by one of them or are you talking for both the groups?
@@queenshipkpop They have their own Killing Voice performances. Mamamoo's came out in 2020 and then Exo in 2023.
"Can anyone still sing?" [Dreamcatcher - JUSTICE enters chat] 🤭
Their main vocalist is taking a hiatus so the other members have to step up and cover for her doing the high note and they're knocking it out of the park!
@@OoMASEoO I know Dreamcatcher and they are very talented. Mine was a thought regarding younger artists where in most cases (not all, for example Babymonster are very talented) they focus more on visuals than on talent. Maybe I didn't explain myself well in the video🙏
Exo and BTOB - 2 other groups known for their amazing vocals.
No matter what group it is that someone is reacting to, as soon as it's mentioned that the group in question has good voices there is always some dreamcatcher fangirl/fanboy that has to pipe in about how amazing dreamcatcher is.
You like Dreamcatcher. Fine. Enjoy
BUT please stop pushing the narrative as if Dreamcatcher members are fantastic vocal talents.
In the entire group you have 1 member that is doable. And even she isn't anywhere near on par with the members of Mamamoo or Red Velvet. Let alone with actual live performances.
Dreamcatcher is talented in CGI, wailing guitars, looking pretty and being droned out by the beat and instruments and audio effects in the vast majority of their songs. Not my fault you can't figure out when things aren't 'live' or you can't hear autotuning. I've seen fans point to video's of 'live' performances and how superb their singing abilities are while when you watch you can see that one of the girls is supposedly singing while not one girl is moving their mouth, or that that sync of the video is correct for the instruments of the band behind them (e.g. seeing the drummer hitting it) while it's off for ALL of the girls mouths. And that is when they sound okay.
No, I'm not saying that Dreamcatcher members can't sing but just trying to make you see that believing that they top rated vocal talents just makes you look silly.
I just looked at their 'live' performance of Justice on MusicCore | MBC240713
*sigh* yeah, some (not all) members were singing live, that much was clear seeing that clearly there was no autotune active, at least not active enough to hide them being flat or sharp almost constantly, although there was still lots of effects involved.
Oh wait, you think that autotune can't be done in realtime in a 'live' concert. Oh sweet summerchild.*smh*
heck compare the rap in that number with anything that Moonstar has done 'live', Moonstar is still in key while I don't know what that was except some girl talking.
look up the following on youtube and learn a thing or two. Heck it even puts Siyeon in the top 10.
Brutally Ranking Main Vocalists Of Kpop Girl Groups
@@khristinacruz9107 Não sei o que aconteceu... O_O
@@PDVism Please go touch grass🙏 or take an anger management class if a comment complimenting a group is enough to make you throw this kinda temper tantrum. Jesus thats pathetic