Islam or the Muslims Need Reform? - Syed Ali Tawfik Al-Attas
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 09. 2020
- Thank you for your continuous support. Do share and spread the word if you find it beneficial.
If you wish to send questions or share your reflections, write to: satalattas (please introduce yourself when you do so).
Also do like and subscribe this CZcams Channel and the aforementioned FB page.
#engagingtheyouthseries
Brilliant ..Worth watching..very right not Islam is to reform.muslim should be reform...God bless you...
People need to be allowed to think for themselves and discuss these ideas openly without fear
GRATEFUL thanks, Sir... I am a non-Muslim, listening and learning from all your profound videos and sharing with others so that Malaysia can be a better place. We are different but we find our similarity for humanty. Yes the Youths are very IMPORTANT. I work with youths on remand in the asrama akhlak since 2016 till covid19 in 2020. The government needs to put more effort to nurture the youths and not just lock them up at such a young age. My message to the youths they are not bad children but mislead.
Awesome Sir, respect your wisdom.may Allah bless you always.
Terbaik Dr. Syed Ali. Semoga sentiasa dirahmatiNya...
نفعنا الله بعلومك يا أستاذنا الفاضل.
Your words regarding the man and the office are straight to the point. May Allah bless you Sir
Thank you for your answers and explanation for the second question. It does give some glimpse of ideas to me to pursue what I should achieve after this. Be patient while seeking knowledge, knowledge that can make you a better person and to give good impact to our civilization. Thank you,Dr.
That first question is indeed alarming. I have felt till now that at least on a superficial level that my fellow young peers have quite a good grasp of islam at least compared to our granparents and even parents who grew up with quite openly secular education due to being colonised etc etc. But it seems like our islamic education has proven to be cursory at best. This is worrying.
Regarding the second question- perhaps the Dr can recommend a couple of basic books/resources to start on how to understand what knowledge is.. I personally found reading the book ‘How to read a book’ by Adler helped to open the doors to reading other books.
Thanks for the videos.. always great insights
Alhamdullilah. Mashahallah You are so knowledgeable
Muslims need to reform.
The best of presentation need reform exercellanc education is to realize All that's been done,🗝️❤️
Aku tk pernah kerha harta.biar harta yg mengaja aku
Very well said sir....Some times I wonder what had happened to a nation, when her ppl lived happily & harmoniously ( before the 80s) but now looking each other antagonistically & suspiciously calling & using deragatory terms ...need not mention here those terms as I guess...we have half-baked ones in the helm just like the adage, "the blind leading the blind ' ...looking for more discourses sir..immensely appreciate your thought provoking ones..tq again sir
Absolute truth. This man speaks it well.
All religion are use to control human behaviour in the past before law had been enforce. All religion are teach to be good and kind to people but we do had a small group of people using religion to controlling those weaker mind people. Education is the only choice to make people to be smarter and think correctly and not blindly follow on others.
I really respect what he said...
PAS holds higher authority and followers than our official bodies. Worst is when the official bodies seem to be silence and helpless against self definition and self interpretation made by PAS from time to time in fulfilling their political agenda. This has to be stop, immediately.
Well said because of pas one day the goverment will go bangkrupt
Thank you
Thanks for this.
Our ulemas claim that you need an 'Ijaza' to talk about Islamic rulings and sharia. Any ijtihad involves 1. Factual analysis and 2. Understanding of Quran & Sunnah. One of the major problems we have is our fuqahas are not capable of doing factual analysis though they may have a lot of information on Quran & Sunnah. This problem can be appreciated when we look at fatwas the grand mufti's and ulemas have been giving favouring the Muslim rulers or western powers in the matters of politics and economics about which the fuqahas got little idea.
Over hundreds of years, the Ulemas have been used by Muslim rulers and western powers to cause division within the Muslims. All these happen because, as appropriately identified in this video - we Muslims allow such ulemas and fuqahas to take the pedestal as we do not know much about the 2nd part of the Ijtihad process.
If you read books on how the western powers colluded with ulemas and radical Islamists over the 20th century and still ongoing, you cannot help but think - is the concept of 'unity of ummah' so difficult to appreciate? Yet you have Muslims fighting Muslims and both sides got ulemas to back them up.
This idea somehow resonates well and reminds me of some of the discussions in "Crisis in The Muslim Mind" by AbdulHamid Abu Sulayman.
Thanks Sir for the great info...
❤❤
MashaaAllah 👍
Respect! So Owesome.. mlays are rasis I respect every religion!!
Seek into the "Definition of Morality" . learn to live ! The learning power is the key ! Basic knowledge, language ! The power of knowing others knowledge. In Short, Yes ! Wisdom. Governor should prove a good record (10yrs) to society before serving nation.
i suggest a good book to read is ' The mind the Quran Builds' by Syed Abdul Latif
Hukum hakam islam wajib ditegakkan dgn lebih tegas. Ibadah wajib diutamakan. Islam sudah sempurna. Kesedaran dalam kalangan muslim di negara kita yg perlu diperkasa. Perlu dididik. Disemai dgn ajaran islam yg sempurna. Perlu kembali mengenal islam dan fahami makna menjadi muslim..
Nak reform muslim, ilmu dan pendidikan agama perlu diutamakan. Pendidikan kita nak kejar semua ilmu tapi tak capai kualiti utk mencipta insan
Would it be possible to recommend a number of books that you think would be beneficial for people so that they may gain the correct knowledge and understanding of the subjects you have mentioned, or even what you think would be beneficial to read as a muslim so that we may move forward, maybe some books from Al Ghazali or any other scholar.
I want to know the "melayu baru"
As salam. Can anyone explain me more about what does fuqaha supposedly need to be. Are they not allowed to interpret the hukm based on new problem arise such as smoking cigarette? Thank you in advance.
In between two dominant, they fight to each other. Another one group is watching, prepare to give a hand to both right and left. Bcs right and left is a wing. A wing cannot use any weapon. Therefore a hand is well equipped to destroy those the 'given weapon'.
May I know, does Syed Ali teach in the university?
Yes.
All Religions are the same and that's follow the Rights. Sir, you should lead the Muslim in Malaysia and return them to the rightful ways of Islam.
Ban Islam is the most right decision, if you ask my opinion. Why do we need that kind of religion to impose bullshit rules, aggression against disbeliever, intolerant of other ideologies that are not suitable with Islamic doctrine. We don't need to reform Islam or whatnot, just ban it for the sake of humanity
Hi Dr, can you talk about some Malays claimed this is their land and indian and chinese are pendatang
No need to talk further. There is no truth in their claim. The Malays are also pendatang, no different than the Chinese or Indian.
@@mandalion6709 there is a need to talk further.. when someone from their society talk the truth, than the rest of malay will zip their mouth
@@mandalion6709 what truth ?before british came Malay government already exist in this land
if you read history..same thing in US or anywere the pendatang when they got no point, they reverse it and say the american is pendatang and red indian is true original people. old tricks., malay in general never provocative..only chinese is talk malay this n that. Dont even have basic and no adab..then wondering why malay never vote for dap. self proclaiming clean but so many among dap in penang involve in 1mdb.
@@mandalion6709 whether there is a truth in claim or not, need someone to talk from their society for their awareness and to zip their mouth. So that next time they don't dare to call us PENDATANG
waiting for the next video.....
someone wrote "Allah said..." . Was this verified? How?
People in power are the cause of calamity on our beloved country.
Can the human mind, even if it is a Prophet's mind, capture the fullness of the mind of God. If the Prophet (created) knows the mind of God (creator), is the Prophet not equal to God. Therefore all sacred texts cannot capture the mind of God, in my humble opinion. I would appreciate your views on this, Sir.
Revelation of each religions is tailored to suit for a specific period or dispensation as the knowledge of God cannot be shuffled into mans mouth as
With due respect Sir to u n all malays in general n no offence intended.... i hv mix with every top to bottom malay meaning from the intellectuals to the uneducated to even the religious scholars etc.....i see most of them hv the tendencies to explode emotionally or perhaps physically when race or religious issues r debated or question. Thus althought i hv seen melayu baru n lama in their speech n perception which is impressive at times but the above explosive attitude are somehow ingrain in both of them. So personally i feel their obsession with Islam especially those fanatics at times restrict them of transcend boundaries .....look at the history of China n why Chairman Mao turn a religious China then into a Communist state. Bcos the religious chinese then wete too obsessed with their religion. Pardon my ignorance, just hoping everyone comes to a better discourse n progress. Tqvm
In China, it was the Communist and Socialist banishing the empire and kingdom system of China
god has no human helper. keep the religion to oneself. there are many verses similar to these. I called them not to witness the creation of the heavens and the earth, nor (even) their own creation: nor is it for Me to take as helpers such as lead (men) astray! Aku tidak memanggil mereka menyaksi atau membantuKu menciptakan langit dan bumi, dan tidak juga meminta bantuan setengahnya untuk menciptakan setengahnya yang lain; dan tidak sepatutnya Aku mengambil makhluk-makhluk yang menyesatkan itu sebagai pembantu.
(Al-Kahfi 18:51); Say: "Praise be to Allah, who begets no son, and has no partner in (His) dominion: Nor (needs) He any to protect Him from humiliation: yea, magnify Him for His greatness and glory!" Dan katakanlah: "Segala puji tertentu bagi Allah yang tiada mempunyai anak, dan tiada bagiNya sekutu dalam urusan kerajaanNya, dan tiada bagiNya penolong disebabkan sesuatu kelemahanNya; dan hendaklah engkau membesarkan serta memuliakanNya dengan bersungguh-sungguh!"(Al-Israa' 17:111)
those Muslims who said that Islam needed to be 'reformed' r those Muslims who want to cherry-pick Islam and to justify what they want to be haraam to halal....one of them is trying to champion lgbtq.....
Be more tolerant. When the afghan destroy the bamiyan buddhas, did any buddhist protest ?
Put on some footwear man