Maharashtra Mandal - Singapore : When did the Mahabharata Yuddha happen?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 08. 2021
  • 15 August 2021

Komentáře • 98

  • @vilas1951
    @vilas1951 Před 2 lety +13

    ग्रेट!!!बऱ्याच वर्षांनी अभ्यासू व चिकाटी असणारी व्यक्ती बघितली. ईश्वर तुम्हाला उत्तम आरोग्य व शक्ती

    • @vilas1951
      @vilas1951 Před 2 lety +2

      देवो. असाच अभ्यास सुरु ठेवा आणि आम्हा सर्वाना ज्ञान द्या, धन्यवाद

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +2

      @@vilas1951 🙏🙏🙏

  • @ajinkyayadav1428
    @ajinkyayadav1428 Před rokem +3

    तुमच्यामुळे मला प्रेरणा मिळाली आणि मी मुळ वाल्मिकी रामायण वाचण्यास सुरूवात केली आणि माझे डोळे उघडले.
    तुम्ही अस्सल मराठीपणाचे उत्तम उदाहरण आहात
    तुम्ही तुमचे काम असेच सुरू ठेवा
    धन्यवाद

  • @myopinion5038
    @myopinion5038 Před 2 lety +6

    निलेश जी ,नमस्कार .
    आई जगदंबा तुम्हास उदंड आयुष्य देवो हीच आईच्या चरणी प्रार्थना 🚩…..🚩
    🚩जय महाराष्ट्र .🚩

  • @satishkanade9507
    @satishkanade9507 Před rokem +2

    अतिशय सुरेख आणि शास्त्रोक्त विश्लेषण

  • @rohitpanat6489
    @rohitpanat6489 Před rokem +2

    तुमच्या संशोधनाला मनःपूर्वक नमस्कार

  • @umalele2770
    @umalele2770 Před 2 lety +6

    धन्यवाद
    ग्रेट सर
    किती सखोल अभ्यास आहे तुमचा,💐

  • @tushitis
    @tushitis Před 2 lety +5

    दीड तास उत्तम गेले आजचे :) फारच छान

  • @milindmighty
    @milindmighty Před rokem +1

    क्या बात है ! निलेश सर खूप छान

  • @manishkulkarni4207
    @manishkulkarni4207 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Wonderful and interesting

  • @prachidandavate
    @prachidandavate Před 2 lety +4

    Atishay sundar lecture .....
    Thank you so much .....
    Marathi aslyamule sagle chan samjle . Same topic English madhe baghitla hota pan aaj nit akalan zale.
    Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏

  • @amitdixit2362
    @amitdixit2362 Před rokem +1

    🙏🕉️ हर हर महादेव 🕉️🙏

  • @PS29797
    @PS29797 Před 2 lety +4

    Wonderful scientific explanation. Also loved the Q&A especially some of the witty answers

  • @arunade1168
    @arunade1168 Před 2 lety +3

    खूप खूप धन्यवाद
    💐🌹🙏🌹💐

  • @charujuikar3333
    @charujuikar3333 Před 2 lety +5

    नमस्कार निलेश सर,
    खूपच छान. तुमचा अभ्यास तर आहेच, पण सांगण्याची हातोटीही उत्तम! शिवाय मायबोलीतून असल्याने दुधात साखर!!
    धन्यवाद!

  • @enjoyparents
    @enjoyparents Před rokem +1

    @24.38 - project - खटाटोप

  • @pushpakglobalutilities7715

    Nilesh sir,
    Is there any female warrior mentioned who took part in Mahabharat war?

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +9

      Great question. Thank you. I do not know. Shikhandi comes as close as it gets, based on my limited information.

    • @dushyantnetam7609
      @dushyantnetam7609 Před 2 lety +1

      Bhisma made it clear that no women will participate here

  • @SandipBajwa
    @SandipBajwa Před 2 lety +1

    Thank you

  • @jjagasetty2413
    @jjagasetty2413 Před 2 lety +2

    Seems the introduction music is inspired from History channel's Ancient Aliens. But it's Good

  • @axelj2027
    @axelj2027 Před 2 lety +3

    👍👍👍👍👍

  • @enjoyparents
    @enjoyparents Před rokem +2

    @1.06.58
    Male : female diversity
    1: 16 after mahabharat war , explains why men / kings were having multiple wives &
    This must have also happened after king Sudas's - 10 kings Dashraj war thus to maintain social order this might have being the natural human response to sustainability

  • @harshpatil4593
    @harshpatil4593 Před 2 lety

    Nilesh sir plss clear my doubt that, where the ramsetu was made by Lord Ram's army exactly? Because most of people says that ramsetu was build between rameshwaram to sri lanka and according to your research exact ravana's lanka was in different location. Plss clear my doubt sir.

  • @jayantkulkarni4085
    @jayantkulkarni4085 Před 2 lety +5

    I think hindi translation will be available soon

  • @Don38586
    @Don38586 Před 2 lety +2

    आनंदाने नाचावस वाटतयं

  • @nileshkharade3363
    @nileshkharade3363 Před 2 lety +1

    महाभारतात बाहलीक यांच्या विषयी माहीती सांगा.

  • @beingwarrior
    @beingwarrior Před 2 lety

    Which language are they talking in?

  • @vinodtrivedi8079
    @vinodtrivedi8079 Před 2 lety

    Jainism or Buddhism or charvaks don't believe in gods and said every atma means a normal person can achieve bhrama pad.
    But in our religion it's like that everyone is in a race to declare their God as a supreme. And now purusha and prakriti made me confuse.
    Please clarify this sir.

  • @harshpatil4593
    @harshpatil4593 Před 2 lety

    Nilesh sir kumari kandam was really exist or not.. What is the mystery about this kumari kandam...because many southern people or researchers of india talk about kumari kandam existence..,plss do research on this topic and provide some knowledgeable information, it's humble request nilesh sir. 🙏

  • @natyabhushanakalakendra7723

    Nityananda mishra in face book, had raised many questions about your research dates.....
    I am admirer of your research & following your videos from one year.....
    What's your answer for this ?

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +2

      Can you state the most impressive question from that list? What makes you think of it as most impressive?

    • @natyabhushanakalakendra7723
      @natyabhushanakalakendra7723 Před 2 lety

      I just read first question only - sun setting at pushya nakshatra at hemantha Ruth....
      Further did not want to get confused.
      I am very impressed with your speeches about getting understanding to your research & to question YOU with much more evidence & to update your research.
      I have updated your CZcams channel to all my friends & contacts yesterday on janmasthami.
      Lots of msgs were in social media yesterday that krishna was born in around 3,500 B C E....
      I commented to every msg I seen with your details......

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +4

      @@natyabhushanakalakendra7723 Thank you
      Let's explore this observation of Aranyakanda 16:12 of Valmiki Ramayana.
      I have translated it as (also by Vartak, Satavalekar) "Sun of Hemanta sets near nakshatra Pushya"
      Nityananda Mishra (and many VR translators) have translated it as "Hemanta season occurred during lunar month of Pushya"
      1. Per my translation/interpretation, it leads to 11,500 BCE through 17,500 BCE as the time interval for Ramayana.
      And based on additional testing of 500+ astronomy observations of Valmiki Ramayana, I arrived at 12209 BCE as the year of Rama-Ravana Yuddha.
      This inference is further corroborated by the evidence of hydrology, morphodynamics of rivers of Northern India, oceanography, climatology, geography, paleontology, agriculture, evolutionary biology, Surya Siddhanta, Parashar Tantra, Mahabharata dating (5561 BCE), Purana genealogy, and more.
      2. Per Nityananda Mishra translation/interpretation Valmiki Ramayana occurred sometime between 500 BCE through 5000 BCE
      Nityananda Mishra added one more observation from Aranyakanada where per his interpretation 'Vasanta was during the lunar month of Chaitra. i.e. during 2000 BCE through 2500 CE.
      If one takes the common interval between these two observations, this means that according to Nityananda Mishra Ramayana happened sometime between 500 BCE and 2000 BCE.
      To the best of my knowledge, he has not tested 500+ other astronomy observations.
      I do not know if he comprehends (and accepts) the inference for the timing of Ramayana (500 BCE - 2000 BCE) based on his translation and interpretation.
      Hope this helps.

    • @natyabhushanakalakendra7723
      @natyabhushanakalakendra7723 Před 2 lety +2

      Thank you, I will put the screen shot of your answer , in the comment box who posted the Fb link......

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +2

      @@natyabhushanakalakendra7723 Excellent. Thank you.

  • @7RAJA1
    @7RAJA1 Před 5 měsíci

    it happened over 5500yrs back...but according to oak...taking refrences from mars it happened over 7500yrs back

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 5 měsíci

      What happened 5500 years back?

    • @7RAJA1
      @7RAJA1 Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@NileshOak thats why i said ...it was said up to this time its 5500yrs old...but according to your mars proof its 7500yrs old..so we were missinformed

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@7RAJA1 correct. Only a small correction. Not according to me. It is not an opinion. And it is not a claim. Mahabharat evidence,empirical scientific and multidisciplinary...decisively points to 5561 BCE as the year of the Mahabharat war.

  • @vinodtrivedi8079
    @vinodtrivedi8079 Před 2 lety

    Sir, why there is a contradiction in our religious text ? Some says vishnu is supreme some says shiva is supreme and some says shakti is supreme.
    Sometimes, it feels like a joke and purans have so, many contradictions even they couldn't decide who is the supreme?

    • @induvats4720
      @induvats4720 Před 2 lety +1

      There are many contradictions in Puranas not in our original religious texts (Vedas,Ramayan,Mahabharat and many more). Read Vedas.

    • @Gentleman_108
      @Gentleman_108 Před 2 lety +3

      Shiv hi vishnu hai aur vishnu hi shiv
      Shiv ji ke dil mein vishnu ji aur vishnu ji ke dil mein Shiv ji
      Nothing is Shiv and everything is Shiv. Om namah shivay

    • @vinodtrivedi8079
      @vinodtrivedi8079 Před 2 lety

      @@Gentleman_108 to fir shakti kya bhrama vishnu shiv se badi Hai aur parbhrama male Hai ya female.
      Kya shakti hi real creator Hai?

    • @Gentleman_108
      @Gentleman_108 Před 2 lety

      @@vinodtrivedi8079 bhai jitna main jaanta tha Maine bata diya

  • @udayohale
    @udayohale Před 2 lety +1

    Have you ever thought of answering Jayashree Sarnathan?

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +3

      What question is she struggling with?

    • @udayohale
      @udayohale Před 2 lety +1

      I found her video. I am giving here a link. Found it very naive. In the comments of the video someone asked why she isn't debating with you and like many left liberals she has given a long irrelevant answer. She doesn't claim to be leftist but a vedic indologist. You may be aware of this video but still sharing here. czcams.com/video/x8LDXDdgg5k/video.html

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +6

      @@udayohale Thank you.
      I am aware of her videos and a book she has written about my book. My name appears in the pages of her book 500+ times (this is when the CTRL-F stopped counting).
      She is indeed a Dharma warrior and a hard-working individual and I do admire her energy, passion, and enthusiasm.
      Unfortunately, she has taken it upon herself to falsify the Truth of 5561 BCE.
      All we can do is wish her well.

    • @udayohale
      @udayohale Před 2 lety +2

      @@NileshOak Thank you.

    • @udayohale
      @udayohale Před 2 lety +2

      🙏

  • @murarikumar4459
    @murarikumar4459 Před 2 lety

    Please include hindi language sir

  • @jitendrasaverker
    @jitendrasaverker Před 2 lety +1

    Don't understand please tell in Hindi

  • @jitendrasaverker
    @jitendrasaverker Před 2 lety +1

    Please Hindi mai

    • @Don38586
      @Don38586 Před 2 lety +3

      Seek for it, it's there already,..... Now let us enjoy in our mother tounge..

  • @choudhurysaheb8326
    @choudhurysaheb8326 Před 2 lety

    Horse driven chariots for warfare were not available before 2500 BC in India. So any archaeological evidences rather fancy software graphs ?

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +5

      Wow! I did not realize that such evidence existed that shows unavailability of horses prior to 2500 BCE.

    • @choudhurysaheb8326
      @choudhurysaheb8326 Před 2 lety

      @@NileshOak Show then if you really have.

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +3

      @@choudhurysaheb8326 Indeed!
      Read and watch
      subbupublications.com/nilesh-oak/

    • @choudhurysaheb8326
      @choudhurysaheb8326 Před 2 lety

      @@NileshOak I downloaded your book and there was nothing to support the question I asked you.

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +5

      @@choudhurysaheb8326 In that case, why are you wasting your time here?

  • @ritesharora6032
    @ritesharora6032 Před 2 lety

    Dr Raja Ram mohan roy has written articles that refutes your work. Kindly check for errors

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +3

      Who is he?

    • @rishavbarnwal7155
      @rishavbarnwal7155 Před 2 lety +3

      He was a British agent

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 2 lety +3

      @@rishavbarnwal7155 That makes sense.

    • @ritesharora6032
      @ritesharora6032 Před 2 lety

      @@rishavbarnwal7155 no. He is not that reformer. I m talking about scientist

    • @ritesharora6032
      @ritesharora6032 Před 2 lety

      @@NileshOak he has written articles where he shows your dating of Ramayan is wrong..check it. He says you are not repying

  • @jamepaul6153
    @jamepaul6153 Před 2 lety +2

    👍👍👍👍👍