Lol I thought something was off when we got to 2:05 and then I heard "when the gospel penetrates hearts and changes lives some cultural change always follows"...... if you are getting an actual education just dislike and never look back.
Me too, just trying to study and didn't read the channel name lol I wouldn't leave a dislike though... the channel clearly has an intended audience and is educational for what it is
You have to side on absolute truth, the example there is the Bible alone, yet in this dark world it is stated as just a fairy tale book. If it's just a fairytale, then why is it band in 17 countries or more? The 21st centuries are sided to liberalism, that's no wonder, cuz it's already prophesied in the sign of the last days. And in this world, relativism is highly accepted.
you could just leave and go to the next video, the vid explained the title and emphasized what their channel name is about, nothing wrong with that, you hating the Bible does not mean you should advice disliking.
Listen, I'm a Christian. But when I heard that iconic Christian music melody, even I said "Oh...Shoot" I believe there are right and wrong places to sow the seeds of faith. In a video speaking on cultural relativism, suddenly switching to the Christian agenda is somewhat ironic. Don't get me wrong, I'm overjoyed that you're using your platform to spread the good news. But in an instant you go from speaking about "Complete cultural neutrality" to "Here's why we as Christians are right." To non-believers, this video just looks foolish. To put it frankly, you've sown your seeds in shallow soil.
no he explains what it means then he gives solution because social reletivism is silly, and he shows it by talking about how social reletivism justifies human sacfrafice. people just need to wathc better.
I just want to clarify that Islam doesn't imply that killing is good and doing jihad is not about being radical or extremist. I think you need to dig deeper on Islam before spreading misinformation.
Yo thought it was about Human rights and cultural relativism 😅 it is so unnecessary to put ur religious belive in the end of a video where people start to play without having any idea of that
Maybe for you as a person, because you hold different moral norms, believs, etc. But would you come to some other´s nation/culture and tell them that what they are doing and are completely okey with doing is "not right"? And thats the cultural relativism.
@@vojtechkolar1657 Yes, they are "not right" because their cultural practices could be anathema to the human organism (like human sacrifice for superstitions). Also, those making the judgments come from cultures that used to engage in barbaric cultural practices, thus have evolved out of them. Should the cultures abandon their barbaric practices without intervention? Of course, and we should not force them to give up their practices/norms/beliefs, but rather advise & inform.
@@malvane8061 I would not even advise or inform. If they have barbaric practices, then they have barbaric practices - none of our business. They are welcome to copy our values if they find them attractive. Nobody likes to be given advice on what to do when they do not ask for it; that's how we start making enemies. And I do not like making enemies unless it's a matter of self-defense..
I didn't know why the video was so heavily biased to misrepresent the topic, then I realised it's a christian channel trying to push a narrative. It lacks the neutrality and impartiality required to engage in academic discourse.
comparing killing human with fireworks is unjust, comparing the bloodshed in Ukraine with the Palestinians' bloodshed would be better and precise example. Apart from that, mentioning a terrorist group of people who are paid and trained on the money paid by united states with the specification of the term "radical Islam" which actually is a term coined by American propagandists, is again a wrong step. Based on the examples, i believe that this video is for propaganda and not for knowledge. As a Muslim I would say that this video is totally propaganda.
00:09 Cultural relativism is the view that all beliefs, customs, and ethics are relative to the individual within its own social context. 00:47 Cultural relativism considers all cultures equally legitimate. 01:20 Cultural relativism sees no inherent good or bad in any cultural expression 01:54 The cultural relativist beliefs on understanding radical Islam instead of fighting it. 02:29 The necessity of jihad is just as valid as any belief in Western civilization 03:02 Ending cannibalism is a good thing 03:34 Diversity of culture should be preserved and appreciated, but not all practices are godly or beneficial 04:07 Christ brings social reform through the gospel message
Cultural relativism seems right to me at the surface, but once you get deeper into the practices of other cultures, I can't say that something is right when it is incredibly wrong in my culture, so I can't defend cultural relativism. For example, in America, human rights are argued to be given at birth or conception, which means that a baby/fetus has the right to live and it would be illegal to take that life away (the timing of that varies from state to state), but in other cultures where infanticide is normalized, human rights would be applied in different ways. Maybe a culture that practices infanticide can believe that human rights are something collected over time, so a baby does not have as many compared to an adult, which then allows that adult to exercise their power and kill that baby. Or maybe that culture says that human rights should be applied in ways that ensure the prosperity of the culture, so getting rid of extra mouths to feed, or the sick is the right thing to do so that the healthy live on and resources don't become scarce. And as a cultural relativist says, we can't judge those cultures for applying their rights in that way and having those morals. At the surface, cultural relativism seems agreeable, a culture (like America's) believes and enforces that children must get an education, that's okay, and when someone from another cultures says their culture believes that education is secondary, that's also okay. Or when a culture values a certain animal and sees it as a religious symbol, that's okay and vice versa when a culture eats that meat on a regular basis, that's still okay. But as you start to evaluate cultures more and more, and learn about practices that are normalized and defended that go against everything your culture says on the deepest level, cultural relativism loses its appeal. Though I understand the point of cultural relativism, I can't get behind it because in my culture, killing a living, breathing, birthed baby is wrong as it is murder of the most innocent humans. Cultural differences are beautiful, yes, but when it comes down to cultural practices that promote selling girls to be married to older men, killing infants, valuing a man's life over a woman's, forcing gender roles onto boys and girls, etc... That is where I stop agreeing with cultural relativism as those practices are harming innocent people and, from my view (which I know is influenced by the morals of my culture, and me using that to deny another culture's morals goes directly against cultural relativism) making victims out of those innocent people. Great video! It was really educational and it was also interesting to see religion being tied in at the end to further elaborate on cultural relativism, though I wish there was more up to date information on certain religious beliefs!:)
I do not consider "all cultures to be of equal value", I consider my own culture (Western culture and values) to be superior in most respects. However I do not believe in actively interfering in development of other cultures, trying to get them to adopt features of my own culture. If they like features of my own culture, that's great, they are welcome to learn about them and copy them to the extent they see fit. But I am opposed to trying to force my own culture upon others, or even use certain kinds of peaceful influence. All societies are on some kind of historical track of development, and some societies are lagging behind others, or might be on a different track altogether - and that is perfectly fine with me. I am happy to live in a culture that I consider superior - and if others like it as well, they are welcome to copy it. Unless some society (like religious terrorists) poses an active threat to my society - then it becomes an issue of self-defense, and no longer of cultural differences!
@@hunjuli5245 there are LOTS of things about Western culture that I like better than any other cultures. The list would be too long. I am a great fan of the West, period. But if you're not, that's fine with me. Feel free to develop your own cultural track. I do not believe in any kind of cultural coercion.
@@Moneefinallyfamous I don't know. "Ethnocentric" has a negative connotation associated with it, for example aggressively promoting your own culture over others. I do not support promoting anything, by force or other types of influence. I'm simply happy that my own culture is quite good compared to other cultures I've encountered. It translates only to my own personal choices - for example if I considered moving to foreign country for work or retirement, I'd probably strongly prefer another Western-culture based society. It is a personal preference, and not a desire to oppress anyone. I don't see anything negative about it. We should be allowed to have personal preferences - where we choose to live, how we choose to dress, what food we choose to eat, what music to listen to, etc. etc.
this video contains a lot of irony, no?
no.
Well that escalated quickly
Lmaooo I thought the same thing 😂
well in way
he just used his culture to deny all other cultures.. when he said sin.
No the point is that he is explaining the view, this is a christian channel so morals are based of the commandments of God. not america
@@goodbug53based on beliefs of Christianity is a better way of saying it
What started good, ended very bad.
Lol I thought something was off when we got to 2:05 and then I heard "when the gospel penetrates hearts and changes lives some cultural change always follows"...... if you are getting an actual education just dislike and never look back.
Me too, just trying to study and didn't read the channel name lol
I wouldn't leave a dislike though... the channel clearly has an intended audience and is educational for what it is
You have to side on absolute truth, the example there is the Bible alone, yet in this dark world it is stated as just a fairy tale book. If it's just a fairytale, then why is it band in 17 countries or more? The 21st centuries are sided to liberalism, that's no wonder, cuz it's already prophesied in the sign of the last days. And in this world, relativism is highly accepted.
Im just trying to pass my midterm 😭😭
@@SeanCav I misread it as miniseries so many times before I finally figured out why this video seemed so off
you could just leave and go to the next video, the vid explained the title and emphasized what their channel name is about, nothing wrong with that, you hating the Bible does not mean you should advice disliking.
Listen, I'm a Christian. But when I heard that iconic Christian music melody, even I said "Oh...Shoot" I believe there are right and wrong places to sow the seeds of faith. In a video speaking on cultural relativism, suddenly switching to the Christian agenda is somewhat ironic. Don't get me wrong, I'm overjoyed that you're using your platform to spread the good news. But in an instant you go from speaking about "Complete cultural neutrality" to "Here's why we as Christians are right." To non-believers, this video just looks foolish. To put it frankly, you've sown your seeds in shallow soil.
no he explains what it means then he gives solution because social reletivism is silly, and he shows it by talking about how social reletivism justifies human sacfrafice. people just need to wathc better.
the christian shade at the end was very unecessary
it was necessary to explain ethical objectivity exists outside culture, and sometimes it leads to cultural change.
Trying not to fail my ethics exam, get looped in to some Christian bullshit
lol SAME lol
HAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHA
Food and clothing are shallow examples of cultural differences, but this is a helpful video for explaining cultural relativism.
Thank you for this clear explanation
Son study
I just want to clarify that Islam doesn't imply that killing is good and doing jihad is not about being radical or extremist. I think you need to dig deeper on Islam before spreading misinformation.
'Ideas have people.' - Carl Jung.
Clear polarization reflected here.
Also you have some really bad knowledge & view about Islam.
Yo thought it was about Human rights and cultural relativism 😅 it is so unnecessary to put ur religious belive in the end of a video where people start to play without having any idea of that
Human sacrifice is not okay and it's absolutely okay to make moral judgements.
Maybe for you as a person, because you hold different moral norms, believs, etc. But would you come to some other´s nation/culture and tell them that what they are doing and are completely okey with doing is "not right"? And thats the cultural relativism.
@@vojtechkolar1657 Yes, they are "not right" because their cultural practices could be anathema to the human organism (like human sacrifice for superstitions). Also, those making the judgments come from cultures that used to engage in barbaric cultural practices, thus have evolved out of them.
Should the cultures abandon their barbaric practices without intervention? Of course, and we should not force them to give up their practices/norms/beliefs, but rather advise & inform.
@@malvane8061 I would not even advise or inform. If they have barbaric practices, then they have barbaric practices - none of our business. They are welcome to copy our values if they find them attractive. Nobody likes to be given advice on what to do when they do not ask for it; that's how we start making enemies. And I do not like making enemies unless it's a matter of self-defense..
@@markrcca5329 I mostly agree with you, but I wouldn't mind offering unsolicited advice once, with a take-it-or-leave-it attitude.
Remember when the Bible used to require literal sacrifice?
the last part has no good scientific studies done on it
I didn't know why the video was so heavily biased to misrepresent the topic, then I realised it's a christian channel trying to push a narrative. It lacks the neutrality and impartiality required to engage in academic discourse.
It is not my opinion that the Nazi's weren't good. Edit: as a Christian I proudly don't support Soviet Nazi diversity.
А концовка хороша, Слава Христу!
comparing killing human with fireworks is unjust, comparing the bloodshed in Ukraine with the Palestinians' bloodshed would be better and precise example. Apart from that, mentioning a terrorist group of people who are paid and trained on the money paid by united states with the specification of the term "radical Islam" which actually is a term coined by American propagandists, is again a wrong step. Based on the examples, i believe that this video is for propaganda and not for knowledge. As a Muslim I would say that this video is totally propaganda.
I have a question sir
Kinda confuse😕
So in cultural relativism, why must the majority always be right?
but isnt cultural relativism all about no right no wrong and that every culture is true in their own way?
ethical utilitarianism
They are invariably wrong.
THANK YOU GOT QUESTIONS MINISTRIES, GOD BLESS YOU, STRENGTHEN YOU AND CONTINUE TO SPREAD TRUTH TO THE WORLD. ❤
00:09 Cultural relativism is the view that all beliefs, customs, and ethics are relative to the individual within its own social context.
00:47 Cultural relativism considers all cultures equally legitimate.
01:20 Cultural relativism sees no inherent good or bad in any cultural expression
01:54 The cultural relativist beliefs on understanding radical Islam instead of fighting it.
02:29 The necessity of jihad is just as valid as any belief in Western civilization
03:02 Ending cannibalism is a good thing
03:34 Diversity of culture should be preserved and appreciated, but not all practices are godly or beneficial
04:07 Christ brings social reform through the gospel message
When in Rome......do as the Romans do........when in Batley, West Yorkshire......do as the Muslims do. Is this the right thing to do?
❤
Well understand
Thank you for that final part ; spreading the good news.
God bless you
I don't think it was required though!
These are just opinions....something which is good for you might not be good for others.
One correction dear, Islam has nothing to do with terrorism of course it is a peaceful religion.
cultural relativism exists:
Twitter: Imma pretend that doesn't exists
Cultural relativism does not work
Amazing.
Cultural relativism seems right to me at the surface, but once you get deeper into the practices of other cultures, I can't say that something is right when it is incredibly wrong in my culture, so I can't defend cultural relativism. For example, in America, human rights are argued to be given at birth or conception, which means that a baby/fetus has the right to live and it would be illegal to take that life away (the timing of that varies from state to state), but in other cultures where infanticide is normalized, human rights would be applied in different ways. Maybe a culture that practices infanticide can believe that human rights are something collected over time, so a baby does not have as many compared to an adult, which then allows that adult to exercise their power and kill that baby. Or maybe that culture says that human rights should be applied in ways that ensure the prosperity of the culture, so getting rid of extra mouths to feed, or the sick is the right thing to do so that the healthy live on and resources don't become scarce. And as a cultural relativist says, we can't judge those cultures for applying their rights in that way and having those morals. At the surface, cultural relativism seems agreeable, a culture (like America's) believes and enforces that children must get an education, that's okay, and when someone from another cultures says their culture believes that education is secondary, that's also okay. Or when a culture values a certain animal and sees it as a religious symbol, that's okay and vice versa when a culture eats that meat on a regular basis, that's still okay. But as you start to evaluate cultures more and more, and learn about practices that are normalized and defended that go against everything your culture says on the deepest level, cultural relativism loses its appeal.
Though I understand the point of cultural relativism, I can't get behind it because in my culture, killing a living, breathing, birthed baby is wrong as it is murder of the most innocent humans. Cultural differences are beautiful, yes, but when it comes down to cultural practices that promote selling girls to be married to older men, killing infants, valuing a man's life over a woman's, forcing gender roles onto boys and girls, etc... That is where I stop agreeing with cultural relativism as those practices are harming innocent people and, from my view (which I know is influenced by the morals of my culture, and me using that to deny another culture's morals goes directly against cultural relativism) making victims out of those innocent people.
Great video! It was really educational and it was also interesting to see religion being tied in at the end to further elaborate on cultural relativism, though I wish there was more up to date information on certain religious beliefs!:)
Keren
kerennn
this is spreading the gospel with lies
💀
cultural relativism might be true, but the negative results are always the same
I do not consider "all cultures to be of equal value", I consider my own culture (Western culture and values) to be superior in most respects. However I do not believe in actively interfering in development of other cultures, trying to get them to adopt features of my own culture. If they like features of my own culture, that's great, they are welcome to learn about them and copy them to the extent they see fit. But I am opposed to trying to force my own culture upon others, or even use certain kinds of peaceful influence.
All societies are on some kind of historical track of development, and some societies are lagging behind others, or might be on a different track altogether - and that is perfectly fine with me. I am happy to live in a culture that I consider superior - and if others like it as well, they are welcome to copy it.
Unless some society (like religious terrorists) poses an active threat to my society - then it becomes an issue of self-defense, and no longer of cultural differences!
Why do you consider western culture superior?
@@hunjuli5245 there are LOTS of things about Western culture that I like better than any other cultures. The list would be too long. I am a great fan of the West, period.
But if you're not, that's fine with me. Feel free to develop your own cultural track. I do not believe in any kind of cultural coercion.
@@markrcca5329 I am Latina lol, I just wanna se the aspects that you think that are better. (I also agree with you premise)
That is a very ethnocentric view to have; would you agree?
@@Moneefinallyfamous I don't know. "Ethnocentric" has a negative connotation associated with it, for example aggressively promoting your own culture over others. I do not support promoting anything, by force or other types of influence. I'm simply happy that my own culture is quite good compared to other cultures I've encountered. It translates only to my own personal choices - for example if I considered moving to foreign country for work or retirement, I'd probably strongly prefer another Western-culture based society. It is a personal preference, and not a desire to oppress anyone. I don't see anything negative about it. We should be allowed to have personal preferences - where we choose to live, how we choose to dress, what food we choose to eat, what music to listen to, etc. etc.