This feels like if it were to have dialogue, it would probably be something like "The game's over, Spinel. You won. *We* won. It's safe to come and play on Earth now."
Yea I was wondering if Rose were to ever return and get Spinel, I highly doubt she would return back to PD. Instead she would probably state a line that would let Spinel know she was PD from a past conversation, in this case probably the game. It makes sense that only in Spinel's mind she would want PD to show herself again to get her.
Imagine Spinel as a part of the Crystal Gems. She was bad ass in the movie so I would imagine the heat of battle would have made her bad ass enough to fight but still charming and goofy enough to be a good playmate for Steven growing up. Spinel would have also provided comfort when it's needed most. A good example of this would be when Rose decided to give up her form for Steven to exist, Spinel would be there for the others as a source of comfort.
I don't know if Spinel being part of the Crystal Gems would have ended well since she, unlike Pearl, would have ended up revealing Rose's real identity considering how naive she was at that time.
@@eduardoaguilar3421 I personally think if Pink told Spinel not to tell, Spinel would have listened. I mean, she obeyed when Pink told her to stand still for 6,000 years right? If Pink made it a game, then I feel Spinel would have played along. I also feel like once the diamonds tried to destroy earth and Spinel witnessed so many Crystal Gems get shattered, poofed and corrupted, Spinel's nativity would have considerably lowered. She would have talked to Pink about it and Pink would have told Spinel the truth and since Pearl was in on it, she would have been a part of that conversation too. Granted, Spinel would have been upset at first but she would have begun to understand that this isn't a game anymore, this is truthfully life and death going on. This is war. She'd be a good playmate for Steven growing up and would have understood Pink's choice to have Steven later on as Steven grew up. That's just how I feel personally. :)
I'm afraid she would probably be furious and devastated if Rose wanted to dissapear again this time forever, even more as she could be jelous of Pearl. She could want revenge or to keep Rose forever and threathen to reveal her secret and this would escalate to a fight between everybody ending either in the Big reveal or Spinel sharing Bismuth's fate (or them being suspicious this time - finding out about Bismuth & Spinel and even bigger FIGHT and eventual breakup of the group) or/and Spinel trying to kill/hurt Steven for real even as an infant to get Rose back. So as much as I wish for the good scenario to be the true and real one I have a feeling that Spinel was cut off from the picture by Rebbeca not without a reason 😔... but hey, we don't know for complete 100% so maybe there still exists a chance ? 😅
Ya know, a Spinel is made to be the best friend, confidante, companion for a diamond. Six thousand alone was probably tortuous for a gem made for companionship. This made it so much sadder, I love your animations.
I really enjoyed this. Not a single line was uttered here and I think it made this all the more enjoyable for me!! I wish Pink went back for Spinel because she deserved so much better.
I think she would came back for her, but as long as she had to hid her identity and the homeworld teleported being broken, and though she didn’t want it fix, you guys know why.
@@bingolinging Pink couldve sent a false report to the diamonds saying something like "Guys my spinel has gone haywire and is now rebelling with these crystal gems!" and they would eat that right up
You're right, without mentioning that she(Spinel), unlike Pearl, would have ended up revealing Rose's real identity considering how naive she was at that time.
Spinel and pink diamond reminded me of Roxie and Ramona. “ I was too afraid to face you “ “ so you left without a word!? You made me feel like nothing! You were ‘ afraid ‘? Good for you! All I wanted was for you to see me! “
Something tells me that if Rose ever came back for her, she’d lie about who she truly was, and recruit her to the Crystal gems. Just to realize she was the hurtful diamond who had abandoned her long ago.
I thought it actually happened. But the end..just made me feel so sad and made me feel bad for her..she didn’t deserve to feel or think like this at all. If Spinel was to be brought with Pink. I would be glad. Seeing Spinel as a Crystal Gem seems epic! :))
Goddamn, what a stunning animation. I've already seen it said in the comments but so much can be said without characters saying a single word and it broke my heart (in the best way possible). Lore talk, what kills me about this is that I'm sure Spinel had crossed Rose's mind many times, and as much as Rose's actions have caused me frustration and second-hand pain for the ones she hurt, I feel like I kind of understand her position. There are plenty of reasons she couldn't go back to get Spinel; the galaxy warp being destroyed, warps in general being monitored, risking her identity being outed and probably more. Could she have found a better way to go about these problems? Sure. Would I have loved her to think of literally any better way to get Spinel back? Absolutely. But if she truly thought she couldn't do anything about it (as crappy as that is for both her and Spinel) then I can only imagine that adding to the trauma she's already been through. And this is coming from someone who's been in situations like Spinels (not exactly of course but you know). And I don't want to make excuses for Rose but goddamn- I can't help but feel bad for both her and Spinels' messed up situation with the universe's worst case of generational trauma. I have... lots of thoughts lol. Anyway, this short and beautiful animation made me feel a lotta things.
I think it wasn’t Pink/Roses fault that Spinel was abandoned. I think the diamonds probably told her she had to finish her colony first to see Spinel again. And when the rebellion started she couldn’t really sneak back to get Spinel.
A Espinela acordando do "sonho" me quebrou,foi muito triste ver que ela não conseguiu ter um final feliz como ela desejava, realmente o sonho da Espinela..
That was actually a very emotional ending, as much as I love your AU stuff I think you did a really good job with this kind of storytelling. Keep it up!
Your newest video is age restricted but I just wanted to say that I loved it!! Pink and White honestly have my favorite swap designs ever and they’re genuinely really cute. Yellow and Blue aren’t really too much changed unfortunately, but they don’t look bad. I thought the animation was amazing, and I love how Pink had a bunch of nature around her, especially the puppeting moment. Super great work!
I just realized why PD may not have went back to get Spinel. I doubt she forgot about her, but I think she didn’t go back for her was because of the fact that Spinel definitely would’ve accidentally spilled the beans about her being PD. Which isn’t a bad thing in a sense, but for Steven’s sake we might’ve not had him.
You know I wish spinel got to see pink diamond one more time just so she can see her. It felt unfreeze how sue got to see pink 1,000 years ago but waited so many years so she can see her again but only to find out pink is gone. Spine deserves more.
This entire video is awesome. Everything was just perfect and it was enough to make me shed a tear, which I never do! I remember getting back into my Steven Universe faze when my friend mentioned it. It was incredibly difficult to really understand Spinel as I relate so much to her. We share so much in common and this video sure does remind me of that. Especially 1:25, this was the worst. It’s a dream that you know that will never come true. Like my dreams. This video is amazing and I hope you get a ton of likes and views on this post. It’s insanely depressing, but I like it.
This hurts, I’ve done this exact same thing in this exact same situation. I relate a lot to Spinel, You make up situations in ur head of that person who you love more than anything actually showing up to surprise you and proving that they love you as much too, only to come back to reality that it’s not real, and it’ll never happen.
People can't seem to understand that if Rose did this, everyone would know she was Pink Diamond, cause how could a quartz know exactly the location of a Diamond garden?
Okay but why does everyone forget that the portals that connected to space were literally broken? Like even if she remember spinel she wouldn't be able to go with her
This is why the end of every Steven universe episode that song plays like ‘I always thought I might be bad now I’m sure that it’s true’ cuz she left her😢
Amazing great job. love this, looking at your older videos you can see the growth.. amazing happy to see these creative videos. What do you use to create these masterpieces?
i honestly cried for this, i feel so bad for spinel because pink diamond got tired of her its honestly not fair because spinel is obidiant but only comes to relization shes never coming back when its to late...
Pink couldn't get Spinel after the Diamonds attack because the transporters from Earth to Homeworld or across the galaxy were destroyed, if it worked Spinel could have been rescued because the Diamonds didn't even know she had been left there, when Blue says " One of Pink's LOST treasures" that is, they didn't watch the garden and Rose could YES get Spinel, but she chose not to do that, not because she didn't care, but because she didn't want to be found out or for something to get in the way her plans, That was a war, Spinel wasn't a serious Gem, she was only aggressive in the movie because she was betrayed by the person she had spent her whole life wanting her to be happy, she had reasons to attack everyone in the movie, Pink was starting to get sick of Spinel because she is clingy, and if she became a Cristal Gem the Diamonds would be suspicious because she was created to LOVE Pink, and out of nowhere her staying with the Gem who "was her rival" would be extremely suspicious, so in parts the Pink was getting sick of Spinel, and like Rose, she didn't look for her so as not to spoil her cover and not to cause suspicion, yes, Rose could not have taken Spinel after all that precisely because she didn't care, since she's always been trying to get it right , she didn't realize that it hurt the people around her, but Rose stopped being childish over time, and changed from a childish and tantrum diamond to a leader who thought she would never be enough for anyone, Rose was transitioning from Pink for Rose during the Rebellion, as we can see when she bubbled up the bismuth and lied to her friends without a care, she still wasn't Rose at all.
I think there was no way for Pink to return for her since all the galaxy warps were broken. She might have also thought Spinel probably left on her own.
![What If Pink Diamond Never Left Homeworld? | Steven Universe RP [Roblox]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lkm-gZ9WsCs/mqdefault.jpg)
This feels like if it were to have dialogue, it would probably be something like
"The game's over, Spinel. You won. *We* won. It's safe to come and play on Earth now."
i hear her say that
I combined it with the video and it fitted perfectly
This one line would have fixed A LOT for both Spinel and PD's character
Hooooo jeez my heart
Mm no…
Yea I was wondering if Rose were to ever return and get Spinel, I highly doubt she would return back to PD. Instead she would probably state a line that would let Spinel know she was PD from a past conversation, in this case probably the game. It makes sense that only in Spinel's mind she would want PD to show herself again to get her.
That was really sad
I feel like she 100% would’ve returned if the warp pads got fixed when she was alive, but remember, in the show they were broken.
Can you do rose survived au
Honestly I'd think rose would lie to spinel and convince her that P.D abandoned her and convince her to join the rebellion or something.
But that's just my opinion, nothing more
The ending was so sad and chilling. I can't imagine how many years of just pure silence must have felt like for Spinel :'(
Frr
Imagine Spinel as a part of the Crystal Gems. She was bad ass in the movie so I would imagine the heat of battle would have made her bad ass enough to fight but still charming and goofy enough to be a good playmate for Steven growing up. Spinel would have also provided comfort when it's needed most. A good example of this would be when Rose decided to give up her form for Steven to exist, Spinel would be there for the others as a source of comfort.
I don't know if Spinel being part of the Crystal Gems would have ended well since she, unlike Pearl, would have ended up revealing Rose's real identity considering how naive she was at that time.
@@eduardoaguilar3421 I personally think if Pink told Spinel not to tell, Spinel would have listened. I mean, she obeyed when Pink told her to stand still for 6,000 years right? If Pink made it a game, then I feel Spinel would have played along.
I also feel like once the diamonds tried to destroy earth and Spinel witnessed so many Crystal Gems get shattered, poofed and corrupted, Spinel's nativity would have considerably lowered. She would have talked to Pink about it and Pink would have told Spinel the truth and since Pearl was in on it, she would have been a part of that conversation too. Granted, Spinel would have been upset at first but she would have begun to understand that this isn't a game anymore, this is truthfully life and death going on. This is war. She'd be a good playmate for Steven growing up and would have understood Pink's choice to have Steven later on as Steven grew up.
That's just how I feel personally. :)
I'm afraid she would probably be furious and devastated if Rose wanted to dissapear again this time forever, even more as she could be jelous of Pearl. She could want revenge or to keep Rose forever and threathen to reveal her secret and this would escalate to a fight between everybody ending either in the Big reveal or Spinel sharing Bismuth's fate (or them being suspicious this time - finding out about Bismuth & Spinel and even bigger FIGHT and eventual breakup of the group) or/and Spinel trying to kill/hurt Steven for real even as an infant to get Rose back. So as much as I wish for the good scenario to be the true and real one I have a feeling that Spinel was cut off from the picture by Rebbeca not without a reason 😔... but hey, we don't know for complete 100% so maybe there still exists a chance ? 😅
@@liwkaosmaek9874What was Bismuth's fate?
@@mr.incognitoyt2235 being bubbled for thousands years without telling everyone of her fate.
I love how you drew Spinel and Pink Diamond uniting with each other. Both of them are so lovely together and not abandoned. 💖💖💖💖💖
Ya know, a Spinel is made to be the best friend, confidante, companion for a diamond. Six thousand alone was probably tortuous for a gem made for companionship. This made it so much sadder, I love your animations.
💔
poor Spinel looks so exhausted 😭 i need to hug her so bad omg
I thought this was like an au drawing where they actually reunited, I was so happy for spinel. Plot twist at the end actually left me in tears.
x2 i though "this gona be my headcanon, but the end did it canon" :(
I really enjoyed this. Not a single line was uttered here and I think it made this all the more enjoyable for me!! I wish Pink went back for Spinel because she deserved so much better.
I think she would came back for her, but as long as she had to hid her identity and the homeworld teleported being broken, and though she didn’t want it fix, you guys know why.
And also because spinel would be super attached to Rose if she knew she was pd and it would be suspicious because spinel is solely loyal to pink
But bringing pearl would make sense because any gem can get a pearl, and of course, the pearl rebelled. But that's unlikely for spinel
@@bingolinging Pink couldve sent a false report to the diamonds saying something like "Guys my spinel has gone haywire and is now rebelling with these crystal gems!" and they would eat that right up
You're right, without mentioning that she(Spinel), unlike Pearl, would have ended up revealing Rose's real identity considering how naive she was at that time.
@@blueblizzardwolf6751 well pink is kinda dumb and got her rebellion idea from pearl so lol
Spinel and pink diamond reminded me of Roxie and Ramona.
“ I was too afraid to face you “
“ so you left without a word!? You made me feel like nothing! You were ‘ afraid ‘? Good for you! All I wanted was for you to see me! “
If that was an act good job but I have no idea how you found these lines tbh
It would’ve been so incredible to see rose come back to mend PD’s mistake and give Spinel a chance to live🥺
0:58 look at this eyes dude, she's so tired, damn now i'm crying.
Your effort is so well shown in your animations! They look fantastic, keep it up.
Omg I was so happy then I seen the end and I actually wanted to cry😭😭
This animation is really good tho❤❤
Me too l cry so much 😢😢😢
Man, that ending just kills. Incredible animation by the way, wow! 💖
Something tells me that if Rose ever came back for her, she’d lie about who she truly was, and recruit her to the Crystal gems. Just to realize she was the hurtful diamond who had abandoned her long ago.
UGGGH THE LUMA LULLABY KILLED ME😭💗
You know I'm kinda sad Pink didn't go back for Spinel.. Would have been freaking cute to see Steven grow up with her in his life.
That looked so beautiful and at the same time it hurt so much that I could feel her pain
I'd belive this is cannon tbh
You should totally make an animation of an AU where this happened! I love this idea, and it's so adorable.
Hubiera sido genial ver esto en la peli
You’re amazing. This is so heartfelt and well made
I thought it actually happened. But the end..just made me feel so sad and made me feel bad for her..she didn’t deserve to feel or think like this at all.
If Spinel was to be brought with Pink. I would be glad. Seeing Spinel as a Crystal Gem seems epic! :))
Theres an au with spinel as a cristal gem, but its just spinel replacing pearl and pearl replacing spinel
Extremely painful, well done
This is so incredibly well done and so heartbreaking 💔
Goddamn, what a stunning animation. I've already seen it said in the comments but so much can be said without characters saying a single word and it broke my heart (in the best way possible).
Lore talk, what kills me about this is that I'm sure Spinel had crossed Rose's mind many times, and as much as Rose's actions have caused me frustration and second-hand pain for the ones she hurt, I feel like I kind of understand her position.
There are plenty of reasons she couldn't go back to get Spinel; the galaxy warp being destroyed, warps in general being monitored, risking her identity being outed and probably more. Could she have found a better way to go about these problems? Sure. Would I have loved her to think of literally any better way to get Spinel back? Absolutely. But if she truly thought she couldn't do anything about it (as crappy as that is for both her and Spinel) then I can only imagine that adding to the trauma she's already been through.
And this is coming from someone who's been in situations like Spinels (not exactly of course but you know). And I don't want to make excuses for Rose but goddamn- I can't help but feel bad for both her and Spinels' messed up situation with the universe's worst case of generational trauma.
I have... lots of thoughts lol. Anyway, this short and beautiful animation made me feel a lotta things.
Aawn is beautiful, as expected ✨🌹❤
I think it wasn’t Pink/Roses fault that Spinel was abandoned. I think the diamonds probably told her she had to finish her colony first to see Spinel again. And when the rebellion started she couldn’t really sneak back to get Spinel.
I do wish Pink would actually do that.. Spinel would be happier, and Steven would have one less problem to deal with that once again Pink created.
A Espinela acordando do "sonho" me quebrou,foi muito triste ver que ela não conseguiu ter um final feliz como ela desejava, realmente o sonho da Espinela..
🫂💔
It’s finally here I got tears fallin
ME PARTE EL CORAZÓN, AY ME LO PARTE 😭😭😭😭😭
I got teary and the smg theme was also one of the best choice are used in this video
The ending broke my heart bro 😭
En fin, todo era un sueño. 😢
Year 8 English GCSE endings 😪
My heart can't handle this agony
Bro, Pink had one job ! How hard could it have been to just come back for her ? 😭
The warps being broken, her risking her identity, wanted to grow up, etc, etc.
That was actually a very emotional ending, as much as I love your AU stuff I think you did a really good job with this kind of storytelling. Keep it up!
It looks so touching! 😭
I’m gonna cry 😭😭😭 this is amazing!! I wish it actually happened
It's just heart breaking when she realise its a dream , maybe another version without it being a dream?😢
Cut the end out
Your newest video is age restricted but I just wanted to say that I loved it!! Pink and White honestly have my favorite swap designs ever and they’re genuinely really cute. Yellow and Blue aren’t really too much changed unfortunately, but they don’t look bad. I thought the animation was amazing, and I love how Pink had a bunch of nature around her, especially the puppeting moment. Super great work!
Wow nice animation but the video so small 😢
you mean short?
@@AniJSon this just a video clip not short
a
“Aaah! I hate my dumb heart for making me feel things! (Punches heart) Cut. It. Out. Heart!”
-Grenda, gravity falls
This made me cry two different ways one bc that was reuniting each other, and then because she was alone and it was only a wish 😢
I love how pink is faceless the whole time
I love how at the end you made spinel close her eyes as if she’s trying to get back to that dream
THIS LITERALLY BROKE MY HEART GOOD JOB, THE EXPRESSIONS ARE AMAZING!!!!
I just realized why PD may not have went back to get Spinel. I doubt she forgot about her, but I think she didn’t go back for her was because of the fact that Spinel definitely would’ve accidentally spilled the beans about her being PD. Which isn’t a bad thing in a sense, but for Steven’s sake we might’ve not had him.
Honestly, u could start the show up again just with these vids, they are great
I started tearing up! This is so beautiful, and so sad! Poor Spinel!!🥺🥺😢😢😭😭😭😭
I was about to comment “And then the “Crystal Gem Spinel” AU plays out.” Then the ending happened and shot it down.
Nice touch with the Mario Galaxy music in the background
I'LL PRETEND I DIDN'T SEE THE LAST PART THANK YOU
You know I wish spinel got to see pink diamond one more time just so she can see her. It felt unfreeze how sue got to see pink 1,000 years ago but waited so many years so she can see her again but only to find out pink is gone. Spine deserves more.
This is so heart-wrenching why would you do this T_T Hella talent though!!
This got me thinking of what would’ve happened if Rose/Pink really came out when Steven split from his gem.
Omg, this is making me emotional, I love ur vidds❤❤
This thing aches my heart...poor spinel
Aight by y'all, time to cry
This is genuinely beautiful
why did I cry over this
I crying with 7 days
Omg I want expecting to cry tonight, this is so sad. You are so amazing at everything you do with these videos!
Beautiful Animation, @BlooZStella! ❤❤
"Today right here right now…….I’ll love again I found pink again.."
THE HUG AND TIRENESS LOOK ON SPINEL DURING IT 😭😭
NAHH I JUST FINISHED.. THATS SO SAD
This entire video is awesome. Everything was just perfect and it was enough to make me shed a tear, which I never do! I remember getting back into my Steven Universe faze when my friend mentioned it. It was incredibly difficult to really understand Spinel as I relate so much to her. We share so much in common and this video sure does remind me of that. Especially 1:25, this was the worst. It’s a dream that you know that will never come true. Like my dreams. This video is amazing and I hope you get a ton of likes and views on this post. It’s insanely depressing, but I like it.
Really love how you draw it like the actually show is style !
this like legit made my tear up its so sweet
This hurts, I’ve done this exact same thing in this exact same situation. I relate a lot to Spinel, You make up situations in ur head of that person who you love more than anything actually showing up to surprise you and proving that they love you as much too, only to come back to reality that it’s not real, and it’ll never happen.
Finally something that is not dead
People can't seem to understand that if Rose did this, everyone would know she was Pink Diamond, cause how could a quartz know exactly the location of a Diamond garden?
Amazing job I so wish she had came back for her!! I also think it'd be cool to actually see Spinel turn evil and find the Rejuvenator and everything.
Okay but why does everyone forget that the portals that connected to space were literally broken? Like even if she remember spinel she wouldn't be able to go with her
NOT THE ENDING
AGH MY HEART
Spinel:pink, you're back, I miss you 🥲🥲🥲😭😭😭
This is what Pink WANTED but she had no way to get to the garden without risking everything and everyone left GRAAAA
Why did you do my heart that dirty that was uncalled for 😭😭😭
Muy bonito y conmovedor! Quería decírtelo primero.. ¡Ahora tengo el corazón roto desde el final!..
This is canon in my heart and you’ll never convince me otherwise
same...
for me it is canon, but it is not a spinel dream, but real, and spinel turned into a crystal gem
the luma music! love it
this was so sad and so beautiful at the same time
That broke my heart when I watched the whole thing 💔
poor spinel… loved the animation tho, good work :D
This is why the end of every Steven universe episode that song plays like ‘I always thought I might be bad now I’m sure that it’s true’ cuz she left her😢
In which app do you make these animation it looks so good ❤🤩
Era tam dificil fazer isso Rosa?!?
That was super cool and fits what would happen in cannon.
Amazing great job. love this, looking at your older videos you can see the growth.. amazing happy to see these creative videos. What do you use to create these masterpieces?
Oh man this is so beautiful... and sad...
THIS IS SO GOOD IMMA CRY
i honestly cried for this, i feel so bad for spinel because pink diamond got tired of her its honestly not fair because spinel is obidiant but only comes to relization shes never coming back when its to late...
why am i not surprised that this is an amazing animation
IM crying 😭😭😭 and when spinel open her eyes I cried more😭
it's beautiful I LOVE IT
GODDAMIT beautiful.
Good job❤
Damn, it hurt
Pink couldn't get Spinel after the Diamonds attack because the transporters from Earth to Homeworld or across the galaxy were destroyed, if it worked Spinel could have been rescued because the Diamonds didn't even know she had been left there, when Blue says " One of Pink's LOST treasures" that is, they didn't watch the garden and Rose could YES get Spinel, but she chose not to do that, not because she didn't care, but because she didn't want to be found out or for something to get in the way her plans, That was a war, Spinel wasn't a serious Gem, she was only aggressive in the movie because she was betrayed by the person she had spent her whole life wanting her to be happy, she had reasons to attack everyone in the movie, Pink was starting to get sick of Spinel because she is clingy, and if she became a Cristal Gem the Diamonds would be suspicious because she was created to LOVE Pink, and out of nowhere her staying with the Gem who "was her rival" would be extremely suspicious, so in parts the Pink was getting sick of Spinel, and like Rose, she didn't look for her so as not to spoil her cover and not to cause suspicion, yes, Rose could not have taken Spinel after all that precisely because she didn't care, since she's always been trying to get it right , she didn't realize that it hurt the people around her, but Rose stopped being childish over time, and changed from a childish and tantrum diamond to a leader who thought she would never be enough for anyone, Rose was transitioning from Pink for Rose during the Rebellion, as we can see when she bubbled up the bismuth and lied to her friends without a care, she still wasn't Rose at all.
I think there was no way for Pink to return for her since all the galaxy warps were broken. She might have also thought Spinel probably left on her own.