Protestant Compares Going to Latin Mass and Novus Ordo
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- Recently I attended a Latin Mass for the first time, and many of you responded that I should really try a Novus Ordo because it would be easier to understand. Additionally, many of you pointed out that Low Latin Masses are very different than High Latin Masses, and if I wanted to really get the full experience, I should try a High Mass. Well, I did both of these things!
On Sunday, August 30th, I attended the Latin Mass (Extraordinary Form, High) at the beautiful St. John of Cantius Church in Chicago, Illinois. Thanks to the incredible hospitality of many people in the church who had watched my videos, I was provided with a missal and a tour guide who kindly explained the parts of the mass as well as the significance of every part of the church. It was truly an incredible experience, and I hope to share some more of that with you soon.
Additionally, on that same evening, I attended a Novus Ordo mass at Holy Name Cathedral in Chicago, Illinois. This was my first time going to a Novus Ordo mass, and as a Protestant it felt much more familiar.
In this video I compare and contrast the two mass types through Protestant eyes and share my thoughts on mass. One thing I learned is that the mass is saturated in Scripture, and there is intentionality in every detail. My hope is that this video will inspire fruitful, healthy dialogue between Protestants and Catholics so that we can work with one another rather than fighting against one another.
Support this Channel:
Patreon: / gospelsimplicity
Buy Merch: teespring.com/stores/gospelsim...
About me:
Hey! My name is Austin, and I'm a 21 year old guy with a passion for people. I believe the good news is that God is better than we could've ever hoped, and I love sharing this message of grace and love with anyone that will listen. I'm the former Digital Marketing and Video Production Coordinator at a large, evangelical church in Frederick, MD, and I'm currently a student at Moody Bible Institute in Chicago, IL. When I'm not writing papers or making CZcams videos, I do freelance work as a Wedding Photographer/Videographer and social media consultant. On any given day you can find me with my nose in a book or a guitar in my hands. Want to get to know me more? Follow me and say hi on Instagram at: @austin.suggs
Video Stuff:
Camera: Canon 80d
Lens: Sigma 17-50 F2.8
Edited in FCPX
Music:
Bowmans Root - Isaac Joel
When the Rain Comes - Tide Electric
Friendly reminder: kindness is cool. Really cool. Or, in the infinitely more eloquent words of Jesus, “By this all people will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.” John 13:34.
I’m all for healthy disagreement if it’s done in love, but I have no interest in this becoming a battle ground.
You are setting an excellent example. Thanks!
Greetings! While I agree that checking out these things, especially the Latin Mass, is cool for a one-time adventure, would you like to go to Latin Mass for a month, or a few more times, to have a more in-depth experience about it? i think we both agree, that Latin Masses cannot be fully comprehended, or maybe even more important than that, experienced fully by visiting it just once.
@@voxpopuli8132 A thousand times, yes. Th Mass is of infinite richness and significance. A once-off visit will not have the impact a regular attendance would. I speak from experience
You are very eloquent and articulate. More peace and power to you 😊
If you would like to know more about what happened in the Vatican 2 council, and this issues us traditional Catholics have with the council, I highly recommend the book Infiltration by Dr. Taylor Marshal.
Also, there are many books out there by Archbishop Lefevre.
God bless you.
The Latin Mass was said on the front of a Jeep in war zones. It can be said anywhere and it is still just as beautiful.
That’s incredible
Look up Father Emil Kapaun, he served during the Korean War.
@@dylanfluet8205 AHHH I love Fr. Kapuan! He is from my diocese, and I cannot wait until he is a Saint
Yes sir
Not quite a simple as you put it, Dylan. It may be said anywhere as long as some basic attributes of an altar are fulfilled, such as having an altar stone with saintly relic present, as well as various cloth coverings, the crucifix and candles present.
In France, most people going to Novus Ordo Masses are over 70.
Most people in Latin Masses are under 50.
Interesting!
Merci Abp. Lefebvre.
Tu es d'où ? Je suis de Paris
Is it real?
@@leonardushadisurya1721 here in Philippines too, much of Latin mass goers are millennials and under 50
Novus Ordo may be a starting point but Latin Mass is just so much more rich, beautiful and transcendential.
Interesting way to put it!
Indeed!
@@GospelSimplicity - If you follow what is going on with 'Pope Francis" the reason for the.conflict will become e apparent. The differences in the Masses are further explained in the documentary Mass of the Ages, but also by a very good video by Fr. Ripperger (Traditions OF the Liturgy - not AND). Conflict is sometimes necessary, as even Jesus said that staying faithful toHim and His teachings will cause conflicts. Blessings.
Dude, whether or not you convert, I'm thrilled you're willing to engage us as fellow Christians. We're so used to being called really nasty names that it's truly wonderful to be able to actually engage in dialogue.
So glad that you’re enjoying it. Thanks for the encouragement, and I’m sorry that you’ve had negative experiences with Protestants in the past. It really shouldn’t be that way. Hopefully videos like these are a small step in the right direction
@@GospelSimplicity God bless you, sir! Spread love and kindness, brother - I sincerely appreciate it... We really appreciate it🙏🏼❤️💯
@@GospelSimplicity Outside of The Catholic Church there is no Salvation. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
I’m a born and raised practicing Catholic. I grew up in the Novus Ordo and recently started going to the Latin mass. The more I read about the changes in the mass post Vatican 2, the more I realized the problems with the Novus Ordo mass. The biggest problem I have is “extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist” and receiving the Eucharist on the hand. In the Latin mass, Our Lord is received kneeling and on the tongue, as our hands are not consecrated and should therefore not touch the Host. Girl altar boys, holding hands during the Our Father, immodesty and inappropriate dress code at mass, lack of sermons teaching about the reality of Hell and instead most people believing “we are all going to Heaven” and happy clappy hymns are just a few of the problems I personally have with the Novus Ordo Mass. Mass is not about the people, it’s about God and his sacrifice at Calvary. The Latin mass is about that. Anyways, these are my views. God bless you all ❤️
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! God bless
Even in Novus Ordo you may receive on the tongue, and you can dress yourself and your family modestly. I also, though, agree with the liturgical music being nonliturgical. My favorite mass is at the Carmelite retreat house, El Carmelo in Redlands, CA. Although Novus Ordo in general style, much of the mass is in Latin, including the hymns. Almost all of the masses conclude with Salve Regina. This is one of the things I love about being a Novice in the Order of Carmelite Discalced Seculars. (Check out a secular or tertiary order of your choice if you are so led. For me it is coming home, and captures my heart in ways indescribable.) Daily Liturgy of the Hours, Lauds, Vespers and Compline can be found chanted in Latin on CZcams, if you prefer. We use English, though in our Council. The chapel is small and beautiful, with newly installed altar rails. These are situated such that a participant in the mass step up to the opening in the gate, as Mary is the Gate to Jesus in the Sacrificial Bread and Wine, which become the precious Body and Blood. And those of us who wish to kneel may step to the side to kneel on a small cushion. Very often, though, I notice the friars kneeling on the hard marble. The silent retreats are wonderful, and are clearly not open tp the public during this time of isolation. We DO have Latin Mass in Ontario, CA, with a sign outside before entering the chapel saying (not suggesting) that veils (which will be provided if a woman does not wear her own) and modest skirts, etc., must be worn... with no other immodest or irreverent features.... No pants or slacks are accepted for women. No jeans or t-shirts either. You simply will not be admitted at all. Many love the mass there, and I know these may be found all over the country. The Carmelite mass I described is Novus Ordo, but without the loose and irreverent clapping and nonsense. I'm with you on all of that stuff.
Went through this process 5 yrs ago. We’ve been going to the TLM now for 4 yrs.
I am really late, but I recommend reading some Patristics. Receiving the Eucharist on the hand has been perfectly licit since the Early Church.
What’s wrong with alter girls? I’m new to Catholicism and I don’t see the problem with the alter *boys* being girls?
I can tell you what converted me to Catholicism was finding the real presence in the mass. It was an ugly and not well done ordinary form. I had been around such services having been a Lutheran. What I was shocked by is the absolute presence of the divine. The real presence was like some kind of beacon to my heart. How could I turn away from it? It doesn’t matter the mass type, Christ is truly present. What a wonderful gift God has given mankind.
Thanks for sharing your story! I really appreciate that. It seems that for many people the real presence in the Eucharist is what causes them to convert.
Yes, I hope you are given the opportunity to know Christ first hand through the real presence. Without that the mass is an archaic ritual or ugly variant of the Lutheran service. With it even the most base mass becomes a unification between heaven and earth. Oh, by the way, the real presence is in the Eucharist of the Orthodox Church. I find their liturgy beautiful. Eastern rite Catholics do the same liturgy. Liturgy is like a love poem around the true presence of Christ. There are many ways to say I love you.
@@ChristopherWentling "liturgy is like a love poem around the true presence of Christ." That was beautiful! Well said, Christopher.
You didn’t believe in the real presence as a Lutheran?? That’s a critical Lutheran doctrine...
Paul Thiele I do know Lutherans do believe in the true presence but I never felt it there nor at the time did I probably believe in it (I was a child and our confirmation preparation was truly horrid). This is besides the point that I now believe that the Lutherans do not in fact have the true presence and their communion is invalid.
High Mass is actually not that hard to pull-off. You just need a few talented people, and it's not long before others are asking, "teach me how."
Thanks for sharing this perspective! I guess I’m just biased because in my head I equate high mass with Cantius where everything is so ornate and beautiful. In a way, so many of the things I liked about high mass coincided with the incredible physical space. All together it created a really interesting experience.
@@GospelSimplicity The space is important for context, but I've seen high Masses on porches, under tents, in gyms, in circular churches. The movements of the rite have the power to generate an ordered sense of space, even when the space is void.
Fr. Thomas Herge I remember the Mass in the movie The Lillies of the Field with Sydney Poitier. In the parking lot of a dinner out in the middle of nowhere.
'...pull off...' ☺ no offense but that makes it sound like the Presence of the Holy Spirit wasn't involved at all!.
lovelett knight haha, fair point, but I was specifically referring to the need for bells, candles, incense, etc
I've been a Roman Catholic since baptised as a infant. Its been 2 years since I found the tradition and beauty in the Extraordinary Form (Traditional Latin Mass) and I have not gone back to Novus Ordo since. I am now a practicing Traditional Catholic because of it too.
I’m glad that you’ve found a rite in which you can grow in your faith!
@@GospelSimplicity Out of Church there's no Salvation. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
This is "Thank You" from a Catholic religious sister. "That they may be one" is the heart felt desire of our Lord. All the fights within breaks my heart. And for this truth to be captured by a visiting protestant brother brings me hope that there are people still listening to the heartbeat of Jesus. Your mission is but a mustard seed now but it is destined for great fruitfulness. God bless you.
Thank you so much for your kind words. I greatly appreciate you taking the time to watch and leave encouraging feedback. God bless
@@GospelSimplicity Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus. Outside of The Church There is no Salvation. Understand The Catechism of The Catholic Church and The Athanasius Creed. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
You should watch The Veil Removed’ it’s a video on CZcams that shows what is really going on during the mass. Very beautiful and will hopefully help you to understand the true beauty that Heaven is really coming down to meet earth during the mass. 🙏🏻😊
Thanks for the recommendation!
Thank you. A blessing to receive your suggestion. ❤️
I forget which saint saw this in a vision..but I always think about it during the consecration....what they saw was angels knelt down all around the Altar adoring our Lord at the time of consecration...what a beautiful vision to have!
To understand Jesus in the Eucharist (Holy Communion) as a Catholic then I highly recommend you click on the link and watch the video! Viva Cristo Rey!!! ✝️🙏♥️
czcams.com/video/OOLZDaTgIaM/video.html
@@hummingbirdee9389 Thank for the link.
It’s been a blessing to watch as God guides you on this journey to deepen your faith! As a Catholic, it has been a breath of fresh air to see kind and truthful words from the Protestant community. Thank you for having this conversation!
I’m so glad you’re enjoying it! God bless!
Read “the lamb’s supper “ by Scott Hahn and it really explains the mass in depth. Also Steve Ray’s book “crossing the Tiber”. Search you tube for Brad Pitre’s videos on the gospels and the mass.
@@GospelSimplicity Out of Church there's no Salvation. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
I was raised in the Novus Ordo mass and it discouraged me and then in high school I turned to being a non-denominational Christian. But then my home catholic parish began to offer the Extraordinary Form (traditional Latin mass) and that CHANGED MY LIFE. I am happily a Trad Catholic ☺️☺️
I’m glad that it had such a profound impact on you!
What sucks for me is that the closest TLM to me is through the SSPX, which is not in communion with the Catholic Church. If I want to go to a TLM that fulfills the obligation, I have to go about an hour
@@williamrichmond814 I would disagree, brother. You can fulfill your obligation there easily. There is nothing like "beeing not in communion", that is just buzzword. There are just two options: they are catholics or they are not. So the question is, are they catholic?
@@williamrichmond814 I would recommend You this vid: czcams.com/video/A8_kpLmC24M/video.html
@@GospelSimplicity Outside of The Catholic Church there is no Salvation. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
Note to my fellows Catholics: we couldn’t for once, not fight in front of company? Sigh.
You know, for what it’s worth, I was worried it would be worse than it’s been
What makes Catholicism so great, for me, is our belief that the bread becomes Christ. That it’s Jesus, the God of the Universe, right there. And I believe that Jesus can transcend all things, even a particular rite. I’ve been to Latin Mass and attend a NO. But it’s God that does the work for a sinner like me. He do it what it takes for the creature He loves. Thanks, again for your work. It’s a blessing to watch.
That is the beautiful trouble of a unified Church. In protestantism these factions would be in entirely different churches - in Catholicism we need to make it work.
conger1977 I see people explaining our different Catholic points of view regarding understandings and approaching the same God, through the Body and Blood of our sameJesus Christ in the same unity of the Holy Spirit. I don’t see fighting, but apologetics between Trad Cats... Traditionalist Roman Catholics, and post Vatican II Roman Catholics, magisterial Catholics. I see no reason that our Catholic conversations should be “hidden” from nonCatholic Christians. I think as Church we’ve hidden the scandalous. These conversations are not scandalous. I see us as having respect for the personhood of each other, respect for the different charisms we are called to, and appreciation for how deeply we each love God. One of the great problems of today is that few know how to discuss counts of view. Let it not be a lost art. If the implication is that we are airing “dirty laundry,” then our conversations are misunderstood. Pax et Bonum. 🥰☕️📚📖🙏🏻💕
@@pixadavid errrm you do know Protestant Catholics are a splinter group to which we can add various other splinter groups from Roman Catholicism? Essentially you have split up more than any other denomination. What happens is your dogged insistence that if you do not follow our Supreme Patriarch aka Pope then you are not Catholic. Protestant Catholics always then either say bah we are Catholics just not Roman Catholic or okay we are small c Catholics then. Lol
Vatican I caused splits so did Vatican II and many others in between. Lets stop trying to promote false imagery. We need to come together in Faith and Faithful Love. We don't need to be exactly alike to be One in Christ. I always admire how Muslims would often not speak evil of rival denominations with a non-Muslim.
Austin goes to more Masses than most Catholics
See vatican II.
No. You’re wrong
😂😂😂😂😂😂 IK
'Different strokes for different folks'..... Oh, how very progressive of you.
Oof. That one's gonna leave a mark
I cried on how humble this man is. I'm catholic but I hope to follow your example. God bless you brother.
Wow, so glad to hear it impacted you in this way. God bless!
Recently found your channel and have enjoyed your videos. I'm Catholic so this subject is dear to my heart. I grew up only knowing the Novus Ordo Missae and only heard about the Latin Mass from my parents which they experienced in their youth. I started attending TLM last year and it's deepening my faith and I won't turn back. I struggle to go to NO mass now as there is just a general lack of reverence towards the Eucharist and most of the priests preach liberal ideology in their sermons. It's always refreshing when a Protestant treats the RCC with respect in dialogue so nice work as that is commendable. Some of my favorite Catholic CZcams content is from former Protestant converts, they always seem to make great Catholics :) Be warned, the more you seek truth and study Church History, you'll be attracted to either the RC or EasternOrthodox Church. God Bless Brother!
I'm glad you're enjoying the channel! I'm glad to have you as a part of the community here. Thanks for sharing your experience with TLM and NO!
Christopher Grillo I think there are wide variance in the NO. Like your parents I grew up with Latin and I love it. But my NO parish is very reverent and about as traditional as one can be with NO. The church I attend when visiting my son in Ohio makes me crazy! No kneelers even How can you not kneel at the consecration. They even have a separate chapel not in the sanctuary where they keep the Eucharist when it’s not Mass. Say what? Makes me nuts. Also along with a few others I now wear a head covering at Mass. Yes we need reverence in the Lords presence.
@@janpetsch620 Hi Jan. I feel the frustration about your son's parish. I definitely agree that the NO can be celebrated reverently. For example, Saint John Cantius where Gospel Simplicity went does just about the most reverent NO mass I've seen. Unfortunately, the vast majority of NO parishes practice liturgical abuse.
Christopher Grillo yes, the novus ordo can be done reverently. Makes me wonder where churches are spiritually when they care so little about the liturgy. We should act like we are on our first date with our dream girl, our soul mate, who is way above our hopes, who for some reason still agreed to a date. Do we come to the date 30 minutes late and unshowered? Do we just kind of wing things? Or do we show her we respect her? How much more the church as the bride of Christ should respect the bridegroom. And, to be not miss understood it doesn’t mean a strict formalism and rigid conservatism. If you were poor and having to go on this date with your dream girl maybe you only can afford the street food from your neighborhood and you buy it and walk with your beloved along the ocean, even such a simple date can be done reverently and impress. Why do we expect the lord to chase after us like we are some prize? The fact that he does only shows he sees more in us than we see in ourselves.
LCC is less common. Latin Catholic Church which is not common naming.
I was confirmed only a little over a month ago after a whole year of being a catechumen. I did a lot of discernment forehand, and went straight into attending Latin Mass.
Thanks for sharing your experience!
Ave Maria!
@@GospelSimplicity Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus. czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
Im stroke by how sincere he talks and express all his thoughts about not having all the answers but wanting to search and find solution to union ❤️ 👍👍
Way to go of put this together 💯 🙌
Thank you so much for your kind words
czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
This is going to be so interesting coming from someone who’s not already in the middle of the Latin Mass VS. Novus Ordo wars lol
Haha, I hope so! It may just land me in the middle of the cross-fire, but hey, we'll find out.
@@GospelSimplicity Peace. I'll not rag on you for not knowing the true reasons for the differences between the two rites. It's a sad reality that the great majority of Catholics don't understand it either
@@ClassicPhilosophyFTW sadly, they are both the Latin rite, just different forms.
@@GospelSimplicity check out Taylor Marshall's book Infiltration in order to understand where the Novus Ordo came from www.goodreads.com/book/show/45266302-infiltration
@@oggiep3915 I'll agree they are both Latin Rite, and that *legally speaking* they are both Roman Rite. However I do not think the NO is objectively the same rite as the traditional Roman one, on account of all the differences it has. Rather, it is, to use Msgr. Klaus Gamber's expression, "a modern Papal rite" that has some points of commonalty with the preceding tradition. What the NO is in reality is a new liturgy, crafted by a committee and animated by the pure will of a Pope. This in sharp contrast to all other Eastern and Western rites, which have been organically made in the womb of the Church from her beginning. That is why, ultimately, it is dying and must die. Avmetal branch grafted onto a tree cannot but eventually fall off, because not being actually a part of the tree, it is not sustained by its life, and is necessarily left behind in the long run.
50$ says he becomes Catholic by the end of the year 😅
Given that I'm a college student that could use the $50, I feel it would be a little unfair for me to take you up on that.
@Ian and rite of cathechumen etc.
@Ian Exactly what I was thinking. Can't wait for Kyle to make a $50 donation to Gospel Simplicity on Jan 1st 2021 lol :D
Well, boys, I guess I played myself.
@Ian 8 months sans COVID, our catechumens just entered the Church, the delay was from Easter!
I’m so excited for this video! I have a deep love for both NO and Latin Masses, as well as the Divine Liturgy of my Eastern brethren. They are all miraculous, from the simple to the ornate, because Jesus humbly appears at every single one. I’m sorry you have to be a witness to the in-fighting. Please keep in mind that we are a giant family eating the Heavenly Feast at a giant table, and like many family meals you will find a mixture of love and opposition, beauty and pain. We are a huge group of sinners sitting down together. The beauty is that regardless of form, we are all together with the saints and angels when we are in the Mass/Divine Liturgy. My long-distance friends and I, when parting, like to say, “I’ll see you in the Eucharist.” God bless you!
Thanks for sharing these thoughts!
This comment made me smile. Thank you☺
This is the most beautiful comment. ❤
@@WyldStallion-bs9oo there are countless people who have never been exposed to TLM and have reverence and belief of Christ in the Eucharist.
Did you know that St. John Cantius Church was voted the most beautiful church in America? I love that church!
I've heard that! It doesn't surprise me. It's stunning
I went to a Catholic Church for about a year or two before converting. Every single time I went, I felt glowing, accepted, warm, just generally where I should be. ❤️❤️❤️ Props to the priest who passed away after he helped me when I was homeless and he was the only one from any church that would even try. Everyone saw me as a lost cause. I was kicked out of a Lutheran Church. The priest believed in me and I failed him. But what he did changed me and it was a slow burn, not a total engulfing. I hope God blesses him a lot for making me feel worthy of some mercy. I became responsible. I went to college. I had kids. I have a house now. Thank God he sent me Fr Hughs. Never count anyone out.
Thank you so much for sharing this beautiful story. This was a privilege to read. God bless you!
czcams.com/play/PLUcjoO2Bj8AsiGYdzfqZyXae1lhMw_p2s.html
People: The Latin Mass isn’t the place to start.
Actual Saints, standing with God, from the last 1500+ years: Are we a joke to you?
OK but for one thing, 1500 years ago, Latin was the vernacular
Interesting perspective
fair point
David Watson this is true. It was the vernacular 1500 years ago. However, it was not the vernacular 1300 years ago. Or 1000 years ago. Or 700 years ago. Or 300 years ago. Yet, countless mystics and saints and converts write with an endless vigor, one that carried them to heaven, about the objective fruits of the Mass of the Ages. We take for granted just how old the Mass is, and just how much history it holds. It is the Mass of the Saints, and developed naturally. The Novus Ordo Missae is, as a matter of historical fact, not in continuity with the Tridentine Rite.
@@logicallyfallacious4151 I'd disagree with that, a lot of 'innovations' in the OF are a part of the EF but restricted to the choir or clergy.
Would you be OK with an EF translated directly to the vernacular, and with the choir responses allowed for the laity?
This was one of the most incredible videos I have seen on Catholicism/Christianity.
As a Conservative Catholic, I thoroughly love having open discussions with other Catholics, Protestants, and people of other religions and non believers.
I love that you opened up the discussion and went to 2 Latin Masses and a novus ordo mass.
Your experience is really spirit lead. To be introduced to the Latin mass and have such an understanding is quite enlightening and encouraging, especially for a young person. There is a reason the Latin mass is making a strong come back, its truth, beauty, and richness of spirit, amazing!
Thanks for being so open and honest.
Thanks for your kind words. God bless!
Novus Ordo was easier for you because it is in fact very much protestant mass. In Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) you are not partcicpating you are a witness to Holy Sacrifice of Lord Jesus. You sense supernatural in this Holy Mass.
Thanks for sharing this perspective!
Our priest is that good that the Novos Ordo is sung with incense, facing the altar, and ends with the singing of Salve Regina. That's when you know you've found a home parish.
That’s great! That’s how they do it at Cantius
I'm a former Evangelical Protestant who went to Novus Ordo (orthodox Franciscan parish) and I've been attending TLM (Traditional Latin Mass) at an FSSP Parish which is just so beautiful. I HIGHLY recommend TLM, and definitely definitely go with a Missal in hand if you can (Latin with English next to it so you know what's going on) and I'd recommend the St. Andrew Daily Missal strongly. Good to see more Protestants being open to TLM. So beautiful!!!
Thanks for the recommendations!
Timestamp 11:31: I listened to this video in July, 2021. I was taken aback by your comment about mixing politics with the Mass when a patriotic song was sung at Mass on Labor Day weekend. As a life long, cradle Catholic, the song “America the Beautiful” is typically sung during all Masses on Memorial Day weekend, the weekend closest to Independence Day, and Labor Day weekend. Singing this song is not mixing politics with the Mass. It’s honoring our nation and praying that God will continue to shed His grace on it. It’s not political, rather, it’s very appropriate and necessary to ask for God’s blessings on our country and to be grateful we were born in it. 🇺🇸
Catholic Theologian Scott Hahn had a very interesting interview on "Mass of the Ages", which is a very traditional group, talking about what is so good about both the Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo. The interviewer seemed to want to emphasise the TLM and clearly disagreed with the positives about the NO, but Scott Hahn has so much wisdom on Catholicism and what we need for unity
I've heard nothing but great things about Dr. Hahn
Gospel Simplicity you should check him out, CZcams is full of his talks. He is a great theologian and communicator.
Also I want to thank you for your beautiful approach and openness towards the Catholic Church. CZcams suggested your first video on Catholicism and I’ve watched your journey. God bless you
I don't know why, but I couldn't stop crying during your video. I feel deep in my heart that God is calling you to great things. This is the Spirit moving through you! God bless you...
Wow, it’s incredible to hear how this impacted you. Thank you for sharing that. God bless you too!
One Faith, One Shepherd, One Church. Jesus said to Simon Peter, “Simon son of John, do you love me more than these?”
“Yes, Lord,” he said, “you know that I love you.”Jesus said, “Feed my lambs.” Again Jesus said, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” He answered, “Yes, Lord, you know that I love you.” Jesus said, “Take care of my sheep.” The third time he said to him, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him the third time, “Do you love me?” He said, “Lord, you know all things; you know that I love you.” Jesus said, “Feed my sheep. Jesus said to Simon Peter, “Simon son of John, do you love me more than these?” “Yes, Lord,” he said, “you know that I love you.”
Jesus said, “Feed my lambs.” Again Jesus said, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” He answered, “Yes, Lord, you know that I love you.” Jesus said, “Take care of my sheep.” The third time he said to him, “Simon son of John, do you love me?” Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him the third time, “Do you love me?” He said, “Lord, you know all things; you know that I love you.” Jesus said, “Feed my sheep.”
There's just something about you that's so genuine and kindred! I attended Novus Ordo Mass since early 70s! I prefer it because it's more inclusive💜 Latin Mass to me is a once in awhile treat. Mass at our church is reverent and beautiful! Good luck on your voyage little brother🙏
Thank you so much! I really appreciate you sharing your experience as well. God bless!
This is an awesome video. In the part when you say that the Latin Mass seems hard to pull off you need to take in consideration that this was the same mass said by Fracis Xavier in India, Malaysia and Japan. The same mass said by Bartolome de las Casas in Puerto Rico and the Caribbean. This is the mass that converted thousands of people to Christianity despite being in a totally alien language. The fact that the Latin Mass is "hard" makes it easier for the priests to perform because there aren't many exceptions unlike the Novus Ordo. The Latin Misal of 1960 is easier to figure out in the calendar than the 1970.
Thanks for sharing this perspective! For clarity, when I was speaking of difficult to pull off, I didn’t mean difficult to understand, just logistically difficult with the choir, candles, altar servers, bells, incense, etc. Glad you liked the video though!
@@GospelSimplicity That's a legitimate concern, there isn't always incense available, a choir, little missals.But what's most important to catholics is not the splendorousity of the mass but the belief that Jesus himself is present in the bread and the wine. Without that nothing else in the church makes sense.
Ironically there is basically only 1 Latin mass offering church in the entire island of Puerto Rico (Una Voce Puerto Rico)
@@reggiestickleback7794 Thank God you have one and not ZERO like Venezuela.
In Miami we used to have like 15 and after the pandemic there are only 2 parishes offering it. (1 FSSP 1 SSPX)
So true, Vincenzo. That's why it is called "catholic" which means "universal". You could go anywhere in the world and the Mass was the same. Not so now.
You are very truthful and insightful. May I suggest something of great importance you may have missed. The TLM focus is not on us but on God. We go to TLM firstly to honor and adore our God. In novus ordo, man is the center, and the importance seems to be on what we get out of the Mass. The altar is moved away from the wall, and the priest faces the people. In TLM the priest faces God, not the people, and he prays to God for the people.
Thanks for sharing this!
Dude I totally understand you on the Novus Order vs Latin Mass thing, it's a shame people argue about it all?! Again as a faithful Catholic I truly believe it's a sneaky tactic by the enemy to attempt to devide God's church. Luckily I take full comfort in what Christ told Peter - in Matthew 16:18- Anyway, stay up and keep up the good work 👍
Glad I’m not alone on this! Thanks for the support
I so agree with you. We should not fight about which language we use at mass. I have travelled overseas when we were allowed. And attended mass in French, German, Turkish and of course English. Because there is a set of different prayers and routines( don't like that word but can't think of a better one) that means you can feel at home no matter where we are. I love our English mass and find it so reverential while accessible as well. And the depth and amount is scripture used at each mass just feeds my heart.
If I could make a comparison I have found my h more human input and much less scripture in the protestant services I have attended.
We do concentrate on words of scripture over human words as a matter of priority. That's why our homilies should be short not too long.
Um yeah, "the smoke of Satan that infiltrated the Catholic Church" was the modernization changes from the ecumenism of the 1960s in the Second Vatican Council. THAT is the source and reason for the ongoing 'infighting' as you call it. Luckily, by the grace of God, the American bishops nowadays aren't nearly as militant to lie and intimidate parishoners who asked about the Latin Mass and a demand for it. For example, in the 1980s (especially) and the `90s, the bastardization of even the Novus Ordo showed that modern Catholicism was off the rails -- clown and polka masses, placing statues of Buddha on the central table during public meetings in the sacristy, etc. The bishop our our diocese was so liberal and anti-traditional Latin Mass that he lied publicly about it's validity and said it was "outright unlawful" by John Paul II. It was only after this deceitful old coot passed away that the new bishop allowed more of the writings and word from Rome to prove this was never the case. It's really disturbing what 1 'evil' person in power can do, let alone what a room of 600 modernists can do to destroy so much of the Roman Catholic Church (the Second Vatican Council). Thousands of priests worldwide saw the ambiguity and ecumenical BS that came out that council and rather than succumb to practices and beliefs they knew were wrong, those priests simply avoided the blasphemy and heresy and retired (walked away) from it all.
The Vetus Ordo Mass does not look the same today as it did in the 1950s, thank God. In the years since Vatican II, both forms of the Roman Rite have drifted closer together, even among the most arrogant liberals and stubborn traditionalists
Thank you for being so open and honest about all of this. God bless you!!
You did it you actually did it! Definitely looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this :)
Agreed, looking forward to hearing about the experience(s)
Hope you like it!
I would definitely recommend Brant Pitre’s books. He brings the Jewish roots of christianity which is mind blowing!
His and Scott Hahn's seem to be at the top of the list!
Try Edward Feser, Alexander Pruss, Deitrich von Hildebrand, JRR Tolkien, St Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas!
'Salvation is from the Jews' is a great podcast.
Yes! Yes! Yes!!!
currently reading that book and yes! it's "MINDBLOWING! "
I’m very excited to hear your input on this! God Bless you! 🙏🏻❤️😊
I'm so glad! God bless you too
I want to start by thanking you for your openness to giving Catholocs a fair shake. Too often, we are assailed with prejudice, so your perspective is a breath if fresh air, and it is appreciated.
I have been assisting at the Traditional Latin Mass for a little over a year, after exclusively Nivus Ordo for more than 20 years. It is the richness and beauty that you mentioned that appreciate so much about the TLM. It certainly does take some getting used to, and it does require some effort to learn a bit if Latin. But, in the end, for me, it such an enriching experience that I can't fully describe.
Your description of your experiences are great. I think you really hit on some very important factors of both Forms, and the tension you find between the two groups is really spot on. I prefer to evangelize in a more positive way that will, hopefully, attract people to the beauty and reverence of traditiinal Catholic worship, but there are many traditionalists who maybe aren't as kind or gentle.
Either way, thanks again for approaching us with openness and without the common prejudices.
I'm so glad you enjoyed the video, Joseph! I also really appreciate your perspective on evangelism. For what it's worth, I think you're on the right track there. God bless!
I love videos like this. Thanks for your charity and openness!
You are so welcome! Glad you liked it!
Whoa! I’m really impressed with your efforts and willingness to experience Mass! I am a convert and love everything about the catholic faith. So much history and beauty!!! I can’t help but feel you’re on the path of conversion ✝️ God bless you sir 🙏🏼
Thank you so much! God bless
Austin, thanks for your videos; I just hit Subscribe.
My conversion from Evangelical Protestant to Roman Catholic began with an interest in church history. I agree with John Henry Newman: "To be deep in history is to cease to be a Protestant."
Another quote I like: "There are not one hundred people in the United States who hate The Catholic Church, but there are millions who hate what they wrongly perceive the Catholic Church to be." -- Fulton Sheen
Thanks for subscribing! I’m grateful to have you as a part of this community. I look forward to interacting more in the future
To be deep in history is to cease to be a Protestant - is actually a quote from a Saint who was Anglican and converted to Catholicism
Austin I love your videos and approach in fostering dialogue between Protestants and Catholics. The tour of St John Cantius church was magnificant. I’d“ “CZcamsd stumbled” upon this church during the COVID-19 lockdown- watched the Mass and Rosary/Vespers broadcast from there. I now esp after seeing your beautifully-done video to do a road trip:/make a pilgrimage from Boston to Chicago. You’re in my prayers as you continue your Faith journey
Thanks for the encouragement and support, Sheila! It's a great church. Well worth the trip.
Wow I'm so excited for you! Welcome home in advance 🙏🏻💛
Thanks for the encouragement!
I am really glad you went back and were able to look into the Mass a little more. I am looking forward to hearing your thoughts. Please ignore the online nastiness. These battles only seem to play out on semi-anonymous social media. The internet is not real life. I can only speak for myself but I've never gotten into a nasty fight over liturgy in real life!
Also, don't give up on your quest to attend an Eastern Catholic liturgy! They are beautiful and while I am truly a Westerner at heart I split time between Latin Masses and Eastern liturgies. The beauty of the Catholic Church is that we have all the traditions of the Apostolic faith. The East still has a strong spirituality that was once prevalent in the West as well but needs to be recovered (I really think the lack of spirituality is a cause of the fighting.)
I hope you enjoy it! People do seem to take on a different persona on the internet often times, and unfortunately for many it isn't a more kind one. Thanks for the recommendation!
Good on you! Thank you for getting to know your sister church. God bless you❤️
My pleasure! God bless
I really appreciate your openness and objectivity! You are a good roll model.
Thanks! I really appreciate that
U r doing a great job🤗👍👍👍may god bless you and you channel😇
Thank you so much! God bless
I am 25, and a cradle Catholic. Grew up in a normal sized family with devout parents; the NO was all I knew. Only in the last 3 or so years have I become more traditional, and I have been exclusively TLM for about 2 years. What caused me to change to where I am now? When I first encountered so-called "radical traditionalists" I thought they were crazy, or at least disloyal to the Church. Yet, I found repeatedly that I could not answer their criticisms of the Novus Ordo (this they did without denying its validity.) I began to read about the history of both the 1960s reform that produced the NO and the history of the liturgy in general. I found that in actual fact, the TLM goes at least as far back as the 3rd Century, and that the NO was composed specifically with a view to placating Protestants. It's certainly not a bad thing to try and accommodate our separated brethren like Austin, but the solemn worship of God is also certainly not the place to do it.
For any who are just curiously scrolling the comment section and read this, understand: it's not about "liturgy wars" or "divisive Catholics" quarreling as ridiculously and pettily as sports fans do. *Rather, at stake is the very identity of the Church; what it is to be Catholic.* If you are patient enough to do the reading required, you will come to see that the allegedly rad trads are right (*not the sedevancantists*), and that we should all return to the Traditional Latin Mass, the Mass of the Ages.
A fantastic book to read about the TLM and why you should attend it if you are able to is "Reclaiming Our Roman Catholic BIrthright: the Genius and Timelessness of the Latin Mass" by Dr. Peter Kwasiewski. Can't recommend it highly enough
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, experience, and the book recommendation!
I would also like to add that, despite being someone who attends Novus Ordo, the TLM is superior in splendor simply because it is more uniform in rigid in execution, thus liturgical abuses are less common and unity of worship is maintained.
Ideally, I would prefer the Novus Ordo simply be amended with stricter guidelines towards reverence. The Novus Ordo is very practical, it’s the type of mass that would work even under persecution, and thus I think that it is ultimately best suited for the Church in response to the hostility of the current secularized world.
Proponents of the Latin Mass are upset over liturgical abuses that happened in the 60s onward due to the ambiguity of the documents on the celebration of the Novus Ordo. They see this as the reason for not only the fall in Church attendance and apostasy, but also for problems within the Church (priests and lay people going strictly against doctrine, many not even believing in the real presence).
The same problem is happening in Protestant churches, like the Methodist church. With those churches, schism happens and doctrine is changed. With the Catholic Church, doctrine does not change. This means that people simply schism because we see doctrine as revealed by scripture and taught by the magisterium as eternal. After all, Christ is the Truth, and Christ does not change, therefore Truth himself shall never change.
Great explanation. Your story sounds very similar to mine. When I first attended the Latin Mass during advent last year, it was like meeting a long lost relative I'd always heard about. The connection was immediate, it all made sense. I now attend my local FSSP parish which follows the 1962 Roman Missal exclusively, and it's truly deepening my faith.
The tlm also called tridentine mass goes far back to after the counsil of Trent, not the 3rd century, it's literally in the name.
Finally, some one who puts things into a more clear perspective, thank you. Most people who accuse me of being divisive or a
TLM fanatic dont really seem to understand their own faith, and just want a faith that goes along with what they want in life instead of what God wants for them in order to lead their souls to eternal life.
Beautiful video. I was born and raised Catholic but, had no defense for why I was Catholic so in college I went to a variety of different Protestant churches and engaged with some truly wonderful Christians. I love them, their enthusiasm and dedication and always will. I later married a Catholic man and out of respect and love for him, agreed to attend Mass with him, since he would attend the Protestant services for me. Then I read a book by Matthew Kelly and it dawned on me that I was looking for God to conform to a mold I had created for him. I wanted to worship God how He wanted to be worshipped as He revealed to us through scripture. This sent me on a spiritual journey involving the study of the early church and the early church fathers which landed me back into the Catholic Church with “a solid defense for the hope I have within me”.
I’m very touched by your desire to encourage dialogue that would unite all Christians. Because we are ALL Christians who love and believe in Christ as the son of God. And that should draw us together! God bless you and what you are doing.
Thanks for the kind words and sharing some of your story! God bless!
This is so awesome! It's so refreshing to see someone talking so respectfully about the Catholic faith. Praying for you! ❤
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for your prayers
I looove this!! Everything’s you said is soo true!! Wow I pray brother in Christ that the Lord May Guide you on your journey! Beautiful!
Again, I so love your videos, your openness and vulnerability. More of this in the Body of Christ!
Thank you so much for the encouragement and support!
God bless you for trying to bridge the gap between denominations! Important work!
Thanks for the support!
Great video! Your perspective is very much appreciated.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I enjoyed your previous video on going to latin mass. Looking forward to it.
Hope you enjoy it!
Catholic infighting *sigh* was literally one of the things that I went and talked with my priest about. As a former protestant I literally said "I thought y'all were all united" 🤣 He laughed at me......but his perspective was interesting he told me: "Debate and disagreements are healthy for any family as long as everyone knows when to draw the line put differences aside and come together as a family. The important thing is we work it out, we recognize there can be many right ways and we don't break apart, we are all Catholic." That really hit me hard, and convicted me a bit since I have church hopped because I didn't like this or that. I am shocked at how many different schools of thought there is on various subjects.
As for Mass there really is so much good in both ❤ and each church has it's own cultural flare which is so fun considering how many different cultures are under that "catholic" umbrella.
Thank you so much for sharing that story! That was really helpful to read.
Tyte Life A summary of your statement is "Catholics fight over worship" (the Mass), and Protestants fight over the meaning of the Bible.
The reverence of the Tridentine Mass seems to me to be a very important aspect of the purpose of the Mass, which is to worship God. I grew up in the novus ordo, but once I saw the Tridentine Mass, there was just no comparison and no going back.
Thanks for sharing!
Wow! That was fast! So excited to watch this when this premieres!
Hope you enjoy it!
Gospel Simplicity loved it! To paraphrase Pope Benedict XVI, both forms of the Mass informs the other. The Novus Ordo informs us about the basics of the Mass and the Extraordinary Form informs about its grandeur and its sanctity.
Thank you for sharing your Mass experiences. You do so in such a loving and reverent way. I hope and pray all who view your videos strive to do the same. Peace be with you.
It's my pleasure! Thanks for your kind words. God bless!
@@GospelSimplicity He has already-with your video AND kind reply.
Love watching your videos as I try to decide between remaining a Protestant or converto Catholicism. In the meantime, what is your daily profession?
I'm a full time theology student. CZcams ads and patreon support make up my spending money
You are a saint in the making...you are going to be instrumental in changing the world!!!
Oh, if only you knew that I am nothing more than a beggar living on the bounty of God's grace, a mere struggling apprentice to the way of Jesus. However, by his grace, I am a new creation. Apart from him, I can do nothing.
I’m really enjoying these videos. I’m so happy I’ve stumbled across them. As a cradle Catholic I have not really had much meaningful conversation with Protestants until recently where I changed jobs and I’m now the only Catholic on the team. I have loved the discussions I have been a part of. I think we can all learn from each other and I love that you have taken the time to witness the beauty of the mass and to speak about it with such respect and open mindedness. We could all learn something from you. Particularly about the division and judgement going on in our own church. We all need to re-centre ourselves and remember that we’re all stronger together. All Christians! Thank you for these videos and I look forward to checking out the other ones on your channel. Peace!
So well said, Danielle. Thank you for taking the time to watch and leave such an encouraging comment. God bless!
Austin, I appreciate your demeanor, approach and how you carry yourself so much! You seem to be so genuine, sincere, charitable, kind, organic, natural, curious, honest and thoughtful. I'm a Catholic who has felt stuck in the middle of the TLM and Novus Ordo. Its fascinating to hear your thoughts, opinions and experience.
Thanks!
Having attended Byzantine (one form of eastern) Mass while being a seminarian in the Roman Rite, you were on the right track trying to find one. The building is different as well as the Mass, just be prepared for a lot of standing, no kneeling, and longer; it's from a different culture. As St. Pope John Paul II said, we need both the left and right lungs of the Church.
Thank you for your hard work in this, I truly appreciate it. BTW, have you read or gotten "The Fourth Cup" by Scott Hahn, or "Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist" by Brant Pitre? If not, I'd love to send you those.
Thanks for the recommendation! I'd really love to see a Divine Liturgy. I've heard such great things. THat's a beautiful quote.
I've had both books recommended, but as a college student with limited funds and perhaps even more limited extra reading time, I haven't been able to get either. You certainly don't have to, but if you really want to you're welcome to send one or both! I would certainly make it a priority to read them in that case. My address is:
820 N La Salle Dr.
CPO 123
Chicago, IL 60610
Great video! I converted from Protestantism to Catholicism 7 years ago. Maybe you've already done this, but I think a good next step for you in researching Catholicism would be reading the early Church Fathers, especially the seven letters of Saint Ignatius of Antioch. They're a good read and super enlightening on what the early Church was like. By the way, you hit the benefits of the Traditional Latin Mass as opposed to the Novis Ordo on the head perfectly!
Knight Of Mary glad you enjoyed it! I did a research paper last semester that had me interact with Ignatius a bit (his letter to the Romans) and I’m currently reading The Four Witnesses by Rod Bennet. Perhaps after the semester is over I’ll have the time to read more of his letters
You are pleasant to listen to. Very calming. Thank you and God Bless you.
Wow, thank you so much! God bless you too
Thank you for sharing in the Mass. Good luck✌️
Thanks!
I'm more worried about Catholics fighting Catholics on this video and if any catholic brothers or sisters see this comment remember there is enough conflict without a Latin Mass VS. Novus Ordo war, be prudent in what you decided to comment. Thank you, Austin for your faithful witness to Christ and authentic journey.
You know, when I first had the idea for this it felt so innocent, "I'll just share my experience going to two masses, surely Catholics will be delighted!" I worry it will become a battleground for infighting. Nothing would please me more than to see love between both parties
@@GospelSimplicity you've sadly uncovered an area in catholicism where we are truly struggling, internal conflict. However, I commend you as it could benefit catholic's to see how futile this is and learn from our protestant brothers and sisters. Your video hasn't aired yet but I can see it fostering love between both parties as I know your insight and experience will shed light on a new perspective maybe the perspective we need.
@@GospelSimplicity there are few things more [outwardly] divisive in Catholicism than TLM vs. Novus Ordo Mass. But it's good that went to both. Reverent Novus Ordo can be quite good, as can Ordinariate Mass, and Eastern Catholic Masses (the latter two which are also different).
@@MM-ku8jm The answer is simple. If we are Catholics, and we claim with great zeal that Mary is the new ark that will carry us to the New Jerusalem, both traditionalists and modernists must take a clue from the first ark very seriously in understanding that God demanded Noah to bring into the ark both clean and unclean into the ark. All living creatures that sought to be preserved. Vatican II was an answer to Masonic Communism which seeks to pervert and divide all things. Vatican II was the flag on the hill that said, Everyone come together. Everyone come in. EVERYONE. So now we must enter together and weather the storm of our age there. This is a call for humility and mercy. Bare with the jests and ridicule. Consider it a cross for Our Lord and maintain devotion by proving your own circumcision of your heart by walking before God blamelessly, just as The Lord told to Abraham.
The Latin mass cannot change what has caused the horrors and the anguish of our generation. If trads are honest, they will admit that contraception and abortion could have brought all of this about alone. Trust and wait patiently. The infiltration of the clergy by Masons will prove it was the devil's biggest mistake, for his tail will get caught at the doors as he crawls his way out thinking that his work is finished and there will his head be crushed by the woman. When all is exposed, his filthy shedding will be the trail that leads back to the foxes holes, who have brought ruin to the garden since the beginning.
Blessed be all those who enter in and partake of Christ, whose flesh does war with sin within us. No one can continue to receive and remain in sin, for God is a jealous God. He desires all the space in your heart. Open wide your mouths. Open wide your hearts. Busy yourselves in bringing them in, rather than counting yourselves better than others and being the petulant brother that waits outside because his brother was dressed in clean clothes and was given a new ring.
🙌🙌
Trust me. The in-fighting is very off-putting for Catholics as well. My experience as a Catholic convert in Denmark, where Catholics are a tiny minority, is that the issue of extraordinary vs. ordinary form is something that mostly happens online. There has always been different forms of the Mass, so why it has to be such a divisive issue is beyond me. From what you describe, the Novus Ordo Mass (or Mass of St. Paul VI as I believe its proper name is) at my parish is somewhere in-between what you have experienced: Lots of altar servers, big procession, incence, bells, the whole thing, but using the Novus Ordo form.
Thanks for sharing your experience! That sounds like a neat combination
Its because in the novus ordo, the Mass was decreased, or things were taken away.
In the changes that occurred over time in the Traditional Latin Mass, were to add in the reverence and glory to God.
Thoes changes also carried the mark of infallibility from the Church councils, while the new Mass that followed the Vatican 2 council, explicitly did not hold the mark of infallibility.
The only changes that took place in the Church history, that are even close to V2 and the new Mass, have gone down in history as the great heresies of the church.
Wow, spoken with such sincerity. God bless you bro. We need more people like you in the world! The infighting is definitely something that needs to be worked on sadly. However so happy for you, that you had a positive experience. Will be praying for you.
Thank you so much for your encouragement. I so appreciate your kindness in leaving this feedback. God bless you too!
Glory be to JESUS and MARY, great video you made! I just discovered your video and your channel, because i always watch st john cantius Traditional latin masses online, and i am from germany. You are always welcome in the catholic church . God bless you and your family.
Glad you enjoyed the video!
Haha liked your video a lot, but had to laugh when you said you couldn’t imagine the Latin Mass not in a beautiful church. I wish everyone was a lucky to have a Latin Mass at place like St. John Cantius, but for decades the TLM survived in basements and rented out hotel conference rooms.
Even today, in many if not most Dioceses, Latin Mass parishes are treated like the black sheep of the Catholic community. They are given parishes in the worst part of town, often in closed churches or converted Protestant churches. One day, I am sure that the TLM will return to the glorious churches, but even in the most austere setting, the Latin Mass is a beautiful, holy sacrifice.
It in many ways is humbling to witness the beautiful rites in sparse conditions. It is a reminder that the Mass has always and will always survive.
You know, I guess I really hadn't thought of that. Obviously my incredibly limited experience is playing into my bias here. It would be interesting to experience it in some place so radically different.
@@GospelSimplicity Even on battlefields and in bombed out churches.
This is interesting but i cant watch you tomorrow for i will be working, i will watch the video later in the evening. I grow up with Novus Ordo Mass and I still love it and attend on weekdays, I also go to Latin Mass every wednesday afternoon and I love it too but I am now attending regularly every Sunday the Byzantine Catholic Divine Liturgy not because of the "type" of worship but the Eastern Catholic spirituality drawn me into them.
No worries! Thanks for the interest in any case. I appreciate you sharing your experience!
I know what you mean. While I was in seminary, one of my professors was a dual-rite priest, and he pastored a small Ruthenian Byzantine parish about 2 hours away that he invited us to once a month. I'm grateful there's a Byzantine monastery only an hour from me now!
Nice job. Thank you for your very kind statements and observations.
It's my pleasure!
This is a really beautiful video, well done.
Thanks for the support!
I am a traditional Catholic and I agree, no patriotic music at Mass. It’s not about nationalistic pride, it’s all about God our Creator in every way.
how is a patriotic song political? shouldn't everyone be patriotic?
As one who’s searched many different religions looking for where I belong I want to say thank you. You’re the first person I’ve met that’s shared my view on getting to understand something before deciding on it, that we all need to first and foremost love each other and thank you thank you for giving an honest review without bashing other religions!!! This is how we all come together and communicate by listening not pointing fingers. I’ve found there is some beauty and truths in all religions I’ve studied.
Thank you for sharing this is very helpful.
Glad it was helpful!
Hi! Amazing video, thank you for your insight!
I'm a baby catholic, having converted less than 3 months ago, but just wanted to say, if you are going deeper into studying Catholicism it is good that you know that we can be divisive as well and that we have our family fights. But don't let the weird dividing lines destract you from the beauty of Catholicism. There aren't "traditionalist" and "liberal" catholics, thought some may dissagree, but we are all catholics, which means universal - we are one huge family!
I personally am ony dreaming to attend a High Latin Mass, and there is no doubt in my mind of its deep beauty and tradition. Just don't get too mixed up in the Novus Ordo vs Latin Mass fight. It still kinda freaks me out and I never liked when converting, because it is sadly often discussed without charity. Like you said, very off-putting, it was for me as well, so I try to either not watch that content or at east both "sides", because I tend to slip to the very conservative and traditional side by temperment.
But do research into the Catholic Church, we have a huge intelectual, artistic, literary treasury of beautiful traditions, writings, doctrines, dogmas, saints and so much more! God bless you in your journey! I will be praying for you and your channel!
It's my pleasure! Thanks for your prayers. They are greatly appreciated. God bless!
I must say I appreciate your honesty, and your openness. It is very rare to find somebody who keeps these things at their core like you do.
The biggest difference between the Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo is not the reverence, the beauty, the politics, or even the language they are said in. These are all the results of what is at the core of the Latin Mass and the core of the Novus Ordo that makes them different.
The core of the Latin Mass is all the focus is put on God, the Eucharist. We pray towards the Eucharist who we believe is God in the tabernacle. We sing songs about God like Come Most Holy Trinity. All the beauty and the reverence is put in to increase the focus on God. The rubrics of the Mass ( directions) are strictly followed with no room for change, which requires people to humble themselves before God.
The core of the Novus Ordo is most, and sometimes all, the focus is put on the people. The priest faces the people, the homily is directed towards the people with things like social justice, the people sing about themselves with songs like "we are the light of the world" and the people are encouraged to change the Mass around to whatever they are most comfortable with, so it further puts the focus on themselves and by doing only what they are comfortable with, they do not need the humble themselves before God.
The Latin Mass focuses on God, the Novus Ordo focuses on the people.
The results of this is the Novus Ordo parishes are closing down at the rate of 15 to 50% a year depending upon which diocese we look at. People lose their faith in God if they are always encouraged to think about and focus on themselves.
At the Latin Mass parishes, they are growing at the rate of 50 to 100% every year, this is because the faith grows when people are encouraged to focus on God.
There certainly is currently a debate/fight between those who support the Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo, I'm not concerned with the fight or debate taking place because it is kind of irrelevant when in a few more years all the Novus Ordo parishes will be extinct, so to me personally, the debate is silly, like debating the best way of arranging the chairs on a sinking ship.
I'm glad you long for Christian Unity, I too long for this. I could be wrong, but I don't think it will ever happen without Divine intervention. The reason is that though we have some things in common like we all love Jesus, what we have in common pretty much ends there because no one can agree on how to interpret the gospel. Everyone has their own way, and since they disagree, they split up.
Everyone agrees there is only one correct Eternal Word of God in the Bible, but no one agrees on what the context of the Bible is saying.
Catholics believe that only the Church can correctly interpret the Bible, Martin Luther disagreed and after fifteen hundred years of Christian Unity, he decided that he could decide what the Bible meant by himself and broke away from the Catholic Church, and of course Christians who disagreed with Martin Luther broke away from him. And now there are over 50,000 different denominations of protestantism.
So there cannot be unity, until all Christians decided they cannot interpret the Bible for themselves, and come back to the Church. Until then, every time somebody disagrees with somebody else, they will simply break away and come up with their own interpretation for the Bible.
Lastly, don't be too concerned about patriotic songs sung in a Church. Patriotic songs are pleasing to God because patriotism is love of neighbor. ( I would say the patriotic song is good as long as it is singing about praising God, and not praising ourselves)
Politics is important to God because politics determines what the laws of man will be, and God wants the laws of man to reflect His own laws, for our own good.
Thanks for sharing all these thoughts! It's interesting to hear about the decline of NO masses and the growth of TLM. That's not something I was aware of.
@@GospelSimplicity yes, it is happening at an exponential rate. I just subscribed to you because you are open and honest and I want to see where you go on your journey and where it will take you. ( not going to lie, I hope you become Catholic!)
Steve I appreciate you subscribing! Grateful to have you as a part of the community here at Gospel Simplicity
I really enjoyed this video, thank you very much!
My pleasure! Glad you enjoyed it
I really appreciate your honesty and I know much of us do. Hope the best for you. God bless.
Thanks! God bless you too
I know a lot of Catholics that only go to the Tridentine Masses and criticizes a lot the Novus Ordo Masses and the II Vatican Council. I'd say that both Masses are good and have their own target audience. And I'd agree that the Novus Ordo Mass is theologically less strong, and that many the reforms done by the CVII have backfired since church attendance only dropped since then and the ones that stay have a weaker theological background. I myself was raised in the Novus Ordo Mass and ended up leaving the Catholic Church (first to no religion at all, then to Islam, then to Pentecostalism then to Protestantism). But I recently came back to the Church thanks in great part to the Tridentine Mass. But where I live it's not available, so I go to a Novus Ordo Mass (with Charismatic Renovation tendencies, which is not my thing, but it's ok). So I go to both Masses with no problems. And I also have things to say about CVII and Pope Francis but it was still a valid Council and he is still the Pope, so they should be treat as such. But also try going to a Coptic Orthodox Church, I find it very interesting. Ten Minute Bible Hour just made 4 videos about them.
Thanks for sharing your story! It was really interesting to read. Sounds like quite the journey. I love TMBH! One of my favorite channels
We are called to be united in one body in Christ, the Novus Ordo mass does not created unity, as priests are free to change up many parts of the mass, any type of music is allowed, desecration occurs. Missals change every few years, there's projector screens now above altars.
The tridentine mass goes back to the earliest times of the church, it unites us to the past, and made saints. Saints died as marytrs to avoid going to a protestant mass in the vernacular.
I'm going to agree with the sentiment of going to Divine Liturgies from the eastern churches, but why go Coptic Orthodox when one can go Coptic Catholic, Syro-Malabar Catholic, Greek Catholic, etc.... I had a good laugh when The Minute Bible Hour went to the Greek Orthodox cathedral in Denver, and the priest, when explaining theological matters, always went to the default, “but we're not Catholic” so as to distinguish itself in separation.
@@noahsolomon726 I think he should to to each and everyone of the masses, then he'll have a bigger picture...
It might be cool to do a series of videos on Protestantism and their views on Advent. I'd be really interested to see that and especially more about Moody Bible Institute.
Interesting!
Thank you. I learned so much about my Catholic faith through your protestant eyes. What I take for granted, I see as new in your experience.
I'm glad that I could help in that way!
You display a great deal of humility, maturity and most importantly, love. People like you are very inspirational and I can definitely see you becoming a Catholic in the future. I found my way back to the Church after my conversion to Christianity in 2015.
Ilkka Thank you so much for your kind words. I really appreciate your support. God bless!
I don't know if anyone has suggested that you read some Scott Hahn books. He does explain different aspects of Catholicism.
His books come highly recommended it seems!
@@GospelSimplicity If you haven't heard his conversion story from protestant pastor to catholic layman, it is fascinating and so impactful. I have listened to it several times and it never gets old. czcams.com/video/DCD6QF1jCyg/video.html
Good evening, some of the differences from latin tridentine mass to novus ordo are the following: the latin tridentine mass, the priest and the people are facing together to the Lord which is the Eucharist in the tabernacle who is the center of the mass while the novus ordo, the priest is facing to the people, while facing back to tabernacle, where the Eucharist is there. Onother differences, the Latin Tridentine mass offers the sacrifice of the Lord in the Calvary as the reinactment of the sacrifices of the Lord in the Calvary, while the Novus Ordo offers the fruits of the land.
DELFIN ROMBO thanks!
Just happen to be in this channel last night. Thank you Austin for your awesome channel. God bless you. Hope you will become Catholic.
Glad you’re enjoying the channel! I appreciate your support
13:10 "Brothers and Sisters in Christ." Very well put. Please share this sentiment with all fellow Christians--Catholic and Protestant alike. We need more of this. God bless you.
For me, the Latin vs Novus Ordo debate is interesting. Both are valid forms of the Mass and accepted by the Vatican, but what draws me to the Latin side is the fact that this is the mass of our ancestors and the early Church. For centuries, our Catholic brothers and sisters have been attending Latin mass, and really, if it's not broke, don't fix it.
I can understand that perspective
Physiel, the early church celebrated the Holy Mass in greek not latin.
Actually, if we study the existing historical liturgies that are older than the Tridentine mass, we might end up thinking that the early church eucharistic celebration prabably was more like Novus Ordo than the Tridentine mass.
I literally only became a Catholic, well yeah by the grace of God, but also because of the openness of Vatican II, i saw the love of God in so many people as a protestant that i just refused associations that claimed only they would “get saved”, well, cults. This view in the Church changed by Vatican II and is the right approach to Church, thanks to the Holy Spirit for moving the magister’s heart on this. I can testify the sacraments are 100% true and the graces received by Mary and the rosary are as well, i wish everyone was a Catholic but i know this probably cannot be anymore, we should just join Christ in his priestly prayer that we all might be one.
Thanks for sharing your story! I agree that Vatican II seems like a step in the right direction.
Catholic means universal Jesus wanted one church, so should we but we have so much work to do on both sides and videos like this help that cause. That's beautiful.
Thank you for Your honesty and for encourage us to love each other! Love is the base of all this journey! and it would be amazing to talk protestants & catholics like brothers and sisters, and not as enemies.
It's my pleasure! Amen
THANK YOU !!!
Thank you for this video, thank you for your openness and for stepping out this way!!
FWIW, I was a lifelong Protestant before making a very serious examination of my Faith several years ago. That lead me to converting, and it has been a huge Blessing in my life!!!
But I cannot begin to tell you how many harshly negative experiences I’ve been through, not in face to face interactions! But online with Protestants who have massive misconceptions about Catholicism.
So let me commend you!! Both for your openness and FAIRNESS, but also for getting things pretty dang right for a “first blush” encounter!!
GOD Bless You! I look forward to seeing more videos from you!
It's my pleasure! Thank you so much for sharing your experience. I'm glad that it has been a positive one for you that seems to be leading you to grow in your faith. That's wonderful to hear. However, I am so sorry about your negative experiences with Protestants online. The internet seems to bring the worst out of many people. I wish the relationships between Protestants and Catholics weren't so strained. Hopefully videos like this are a small step in the right direction. God bless!