Fall of Dhaka and India-Pakistan Relations with Zubair Umer | Podcast #35
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 07. 2024
- Clips Of this Podcast : www.youtube.com/@daniyalsheik...
Daniyal Sheikh Instagram : / daniyal.sheikh1
Daniyal Sheikh Facebook : / daniyal.sheikh123
Daniyal Sheikh Tiktok : www.tiktok.com/@daniyal.sheik...
Zubair Umer.
0:00 - Intro.
1:49 - How was your childhood?
2:52 - What were the conditions like when Bangladesh was partitioned?
13:05 - What General Yahya was doing at the time of Partition of Bangladesh?
19:25 - Isn’t it fascinating, that we are now able to openly discuss our history without reservation.
22:00 - Why women empowerment is important in our country?
24:29 - Do you think that relations with India should get better?
31:38 - We have approached the IMF, a total of 23 times.
34:22 - Why didn't PML-N try to improve its relationship with India?
46:39 - Is it possible for us to openly discuss the establishment being a resident of Karachi?
48:55 - Your political history.
1:03:56 - 4 things that are important in Politics.
1:08:48 - Do you feel the difference between Podcasts and Mainstream Media?
1:11:24 - What were the root causes of the issues in Karachi?
1:23:09 - Operation in Karachi.
1:26:54 - What are some effective strategies for addressing the security challenges in Karachi?
1:29:09 - Football in Pakistan.
1:36:38 - Closing words.
1:38:35 - Outro.
It's not the Fall of Dhaka, it's a Rise of Bangladesh❤
Brilliant
Actually! And I don't know why he still hasn't changed the title yet, to a neutral one.😂
🎉P🎉p🎉p🎉p🎉p🎉ppp🎉🎉oppp🎉0🎉🎉🎉❤😊😊😢😊😢😅😂😊😊😊😊😊
🇧🇩❤️❤️🇧🇩❤️
thanks brother love from india
What is fall of Dhaka!! It's rise of Bangladesh ❤
Hell yes ❤
Its fall of Islamabad, actually.
Yes yes yes NOT fall of Dhaka. It’s Freedom & Rise of Bangladesh !!
It's the removal of beggers from Dhaka.
@@soumibanerjee1731 don't compare them with beggars... beggars beg they looted
I am from Odisha (a state in India) not directly connected to Bangladesh, but very close via sea. My grandfather had retired from the Indian army in 1960s. At that time, many people used to come from Bangladesh as refugees by boats. They were mostly either Hindus or Shia muslims. My grandfather and his army mates had set up a refugee camp for them, and they used to feed them, take care of their medical treatment, education of kids, etc. Suddenly by 1969-70, a lot more refugees began to come, and this time Sunni Muslims started coming too. It reached it's absolute peak in early 1971. There were too many people to take care of, and my grandfather's group wasn't able to arrange supplies, so they asked the Odisha state government for help. Odisha govt told them that many more people are coming and we will give you everything, you just have to manage the whole camp and learn to speak Bangla. Everyday, many people were being pulled from boats in the Bay of Bengal. Most of them were hungry and very thin. Some of them used to attack the Odia fishermen who would rescue them, out of sheer hunger. Many of them were women who would jump into the boats, not knowing how to steer or sail, and they would be drifting at sea until some fishermen would find them, if they were very lucky. God knows how many of them just drifted away in the sea forever.
Some of the stories that they told were so painful to hear, that my dad starts weeping even today when he remembers them. Every one had some kind of medical problem or injury. Some of them had missing body parts. The lesser I talk about the condition of women (and children), better it will be because otherwise youtube will block this comment. Girls as young as 12 were with-child. It was scary. My dad was a small boy back then, and he used to help my grandfather in the camp. He made a lot of Bangladeshi friends. Eventually, after things got better, some of them went back to Bangladesh, some took Indian citizenship and some went abroad. The camp was finally shut down in 2002.
Even today my dad is friends with some of the kids that were in the camp. He has visited Bangladesh 3 times, and it makes him very happy to see Bangladesh succeed. That is why I always say, no matter what happens, India will always have a soft spot for Bangladesh. I have not seen the story of Bangladesh with my own eyes, but my father has, and I have the same sentiment. I will always have a soft spot for Bangladesh.
Dear friend vary very best regards to your grandfather and his work in those days working for humanity hatsup
Greatful to ur grandfather. ❤ From Bangladesh 🇧🇩
As a Bengali who went as a volunteer to the camps, bless you and the other people of Odisha who helped. My pranaams to your father.
I love you man,,from Dhaka.
I am also from odisha ..but dhaka main 6 saal raha hun .people are nice no doubt but kuch log india ko itna hate karte hain wo dekh ke mujhe abhi tak samajh nai aaaraha
Yes,there is a problem when sahid Afridi makes fun of indian culture on tv and misbehave with old politician
those who folllow a aarrabic guy who in his 50s had a ding dong with a 9 yyr old and he also involve in londa londiya business in local language it is known as bhadwagiri .. giving lecture to a 10000 yrs old civilization.....good joke.
All Pakistani celebrities are Hinduphobic
he is anti-hindu
Afridi is an example of uneducated, thick, barbarian, takfiri Pakistani.
@@jamestabi2032 he is a rreal mmosslim so he believe in bachcha bazi , londa londiya business ( i.e. in local language it is bhadwagiri)
My grandfather was a civil servant during the liberation war. When reminiscing about his time during and leading upto the war, he would always say it was inevitable, not because of us Bangalis, but because of the Pakistanis. Every time a West Pakistani would say something about East Pakistan, they'd say, - 'Your country' this and that. Never 'My country' and never 'Our country'. They never saw us and our country as their own. That's why we never became their own.
@@raven-dl3xobangladesh has the largest rohingya refugee camp, how many camps does pakistan have?
Pakistan still has millions bengolies living in pakistan they have no interest in going to Bangladesh and don’t accept Bangladesh. Not all bengolies ware traitors .
@@nissarashraf3075 dont you know about the Bengali camps in Karachi or the stranded Pakistani camp in Dhaka? How about the Afghani refugees in Pakistan? Having refugees isn't a bad thing, it means one is accommodating even with limited resources.
Your statement is more about negligence by the West Pakistanis. But the root of problem remains in the fact that, you chose Punjabi Muslims & Jinnah as your masters, when you could have pushed for independence in 1947. The surprising fact is that, after laying so many lives for Independence from the Britishers, and leading Independence struggle in all respects, all leaders from Bengal vanished in thin air, and started looking as hopefuls towards Jinnah & Gandhi. Both of them were not interested in Bengal, except for sqeezing them as Britishers in 1942. Bengal in fact was storage and backup during emergencies and nothing else for the Britishers. You must be always indebted towards "God sent" Sheikh Mujib, for successfully fighting and gaining Independence.
@@bkashim Hindsight is 20/20. Would we have known how our union with West Pakistan would go, of course we'd choose otherwise. But there's no point bemoaning this lapse in judgement now. There was real hope back then that our Islamic ties will bind stronger than our cultural differences. We could have been trapped in an oppressive regime in many other ways. A united Bengal with East and West bengal together (Which some see as an alternative option) could have similarly broken down because of religious differences. A united Indian subcontinent could have been a long and grueling oppression of the Hindu majority. The alternate histories are endless, and there's no way for any of us to know how the future will go.
As it stands, the only way one *should* look is forward.
Please Talk About "Fall Of Pakistan"!😂
And change your caption!
"it's Rise Of Bangladesh"🇧🇩
Pakistanis finally acknowledging the racism & genocide. Thank You & Respect 🫡
Don't forget the "great" US, who tried to stop India from liberating Bangladesh
Genocide, atrocities was committed by uncivilised barbaric bengolies who raped and killed millions behari people and pakistan had to take action .
Don't get fool .. understand the hidden intentions
@@nahidfarzana8711never trust muslims
Alhamdulillah so proud to be Bangladeshi and so greatfull to our leaders who created opportunities for people of Bangladesh! We are so grateful to our 3 million freedom fighters who's sacrificed their lives ! 😊
Without India's help it was impossible but now you guys hate India 😅😅
Ha bhai india ko bhuljgaye
@@inform568 galti hmari h bc.
@@inform568 who told you that Bangladesh forget India and Russia for their contribution in 1971 ? It was secular great India in 1971 not current Modi's hindu Pakistan or modern India.
Grandfather ko bhul gya..
1971 was not civi war , it was the liberation war of Beloved Bangladesh. World know that. Thanks
From the Pakistani point of view, it was a civil war
@@solidsnake6302 Pakistani point of view is full of lies. Only Pakistani people and also in Pakistan these sort views are existed not in the rest of the world. We know for these lame views they feel bit of happiness over the shame though Pakistani people are shameless which is extremely acceptable through the world! Thanks
@@solidsnake6302 From the Bangladeshi point of view it was the liberation war.
bangladeshis became free after winning this war. the rise of a new country.
that's why it's not a civil war.
@@truthisbitter7086
So? Still does not change the fact that it was a civil war between two internal parts. One part won and got separated!
@@ieditedmyname289 yeah kind of.
That was rise of dhaka.
The mighty bengal to be honest it has more rich culture than pakistan which withwashed thier true culture /language /ethinicty .
All ok but Sir Indians can't forget and forgive Mumbai Attack... People who died are not only Indians..there were our Guests also! Indians feel more peaceful when we don't talk to Pakistani politicians/elites
Pakistani's can't also forget APS Peshawar attack in 2014. What was the fault of those poor school children??
@@burwaand dta was done by ttp not india
@@burwa It was by TTP which is Pakistan's own snake... If you say it was India till today can't help
not only that they still teach hate to kids to radicalize them against india
czcams.com/video/5jP8St_LBno/video.html
czcams.com/video/dtmjRJ3-Cqk/video.html
czcams.com/video/ohuP6sTJED8/video.html
czcams.com/video/ckwDEKh76mw/video.html
czcams.com/video/iUN_PWA9gNg/video.html
czcams.com/video/93EGBUFjo1s/video.html
czcams.com/video/BujVAfEtjaY/video.html
Don't answer him ... he has been fed this information tht india was the reason behind peshawar attack ...
25:56 "The Kasoor of Pakistan" : 1947 Kashmir Jihad war , 1965 war , 1971 war , 1998 war , 1990 Kashmir Jihad , Parliament Terrorist attack , Mumbai Terrorist attack , Pulwama Terrorist attack , Pathankot Terrorist attack , Uri Terrorist Attack ,Khalistani terrorist insurgency etc.
There are so many more which you dont know
1993 Mumbai train blasts, parliament attack, akshardham temple attack, ayodhya attack, sarojini market bomb blast.........its Uncountable........
Propaganda 🤢
@@whatevertrends3627 now they want to forget nd move on......aab hamari batting aa gae to bowling karne se mana kar rhe hain
@@mujtabamuktar oh nope there's a reason why you have a point 8/10 on terror
From the inception of Pakistan, Bengalis of East Pakistan had faced discrimination. Islam teaches the equality among all human beings as well as fraternity and sorority among all Muslims. We, Bengalis, despite being the majority of the population of Pakistan as well as despite being a Muslim majority, were neither being treated as brothers/sisters nor being treated as equal. West Pakistan used to look down upon Bengalis because of our darker skin tone. Bengalis were NOT given equal opportunity to good education and respectable jobs, despite having intelligence and talents. Furthermore, resources of East Pakistan were being used for the development of West Pakistan and our people used to starve. On 1970, a cyclone hit in the coastal areas of East Pakistan, causing a lot of casualties. Pakistan Government didn’t bother. That’s the time we’ve realized that we need a leader from our own community. In the beginning of 1971, there was an election and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman won the maximum votes. West Pakistan couldn’t digest the fact that a Bengali (someone from an inferior race) would rule them. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was arrested, but was released later. On that moment, the whole Bengali nation felt the need of becoming an independent nation. So the war began. From the night of March 25, 1971, Yahya Khan and Tikka Khan pounced upon unarmed Bengalis in the name of “Operation Searchlight” and started killing our innocent people as well as picking up our women for rape. During those days, Pakistan Army proudly declared in the newspaper, “We will leave a nation of bastards and idiots.” About three million (3,000,000) Bengalis were being killed mercilessly (including our bright professionals) and two lakh (200,000) Bengali women were being raped repeatedly in the concentration camp by Pakistan Army and their local collaborators (Razakars). Women, who were being raped, got pregnant. Many women terminated their pregnancy. Those who couldn’t, delivered babies and abandoned them. These abandoned kids were given away for the adoption. Most of those babies were adopted by foreigners and were taken away to foreign countries. Others were adopted by our local people.
Dhaka didn't fall but actually Pakistan politically and militarily both way fall down and surrender in Dhaka but Dhaka didn't. It was the rise of Dhaka. Don't worry and don't be emotional because it's fastest growing mega city of South East Asia. Thanks almighty Bangladesh has been saved from colonial setup of Pakistan in 1971. Otherwise Bangladesh would have been situation like as baluchistan or Afghanistan. Still same unhuman injustice and atrocities going on against baluchi people in baluchistan
you really need to improve your english before anything else, and as far as the atrocities are concerned, you better be talking about the situation of biharis, hindus and shia muslims of bangladesh.
@@AnnieZehraol! Great that you know good english but thats not helping your country to fight against the odds anyways also there’s no such problems here regarding religion no matter if someone’s hindu or sia. Bangladesh has always been liberal & very secular. Just because you are having trouble with your own system doesn’t mean you have to force false accusation to others just to feel good about yourself. Rather work on your problems so that things get resolved in the near future
@AnnieZehra stop your nonsense. Pakistani panjabis are good at oppressing Pakhtun, Baloch, Sindhi etc.
How about you speak about treatment of Shia, Ahmadi and Christians? Throwing stones at others when you live in glass houses is weird
@@AnnieZehrahe knows enough to Express himself
@@bempowered138 you clearly dont know much about pakistan, oppress pashtun? say that in KPK and id like to see you walk out alive. baloch? try that there aswell. Pakistan is a country of martial races, we cannot be contained or controlled that easily, ask usa how they managed for 21 years. We are not like you, british empire hint hint. stop reading propaganda, maybe you should know pashtun people are the most patriotic people in pakistan. Did you even know that ethnically pashtuns are the largest ethnicity in pakistan. Punjabis ethnic punjabis are only jatt, dhillon, rana these tribes they dont even make up more than 35 million or so. pashtuns are well above 40-50 million. most tribes in punjab are western muhajir tribes who came along with the empires, for eg ghaznavid, khilji, mughal, afghan, durrani. stop reading indian propaganda and look at facts. yes we have problems like any country but we have also been fighting wars that no one in the subcontinent has and yet we stand.
Good to hear that some Pakistani person belongs to an army family finally accepted the barbaric act performed by Pakistani army in Bangladesh..More strength to our Bangladeshi brothers🇧🇩🇧🇩..
I am an indian muslim and my grandfather from maternal side fought the 1971 war, these days when i see Bangladeshi folks hating india and loving pakistan (obviously because of ummah) i feel bad for indians who sacrificed their lives for ungrateful Bangladeshi citizens.
No one hates Indians . There is this thing and you know it, how indian people insult and make us feel inferior, you know not everyone is same . Brother we are one ummah . We love our indian muslim brothers and sisters and love our hindu brothers and sisters too but mainly if you make us feel inferior, what would anyone do ? .
Indians will come up saying WE ARE YOU DAD We are this and that.
Stupidity is global brother !!! Never mind !!!
@@Mrnobody-x6s true
@@Taher__905 nope, hate is evident, and it is what it is, you guys have sided with Pakistanis, the same country that did atrocities on your land which I don't wanna even mention, but anyways, we indians did stupidity of helping you guys, should not have trusted the snakes
I guess there is a huge gap between Cricket and International Politics
26/11 …… I am not forgotten
ja na Lauda
Na kar😅
Karne wale toh kar ge😢😉😅
@@uknowguy3531 kaha Jaa , teri begairat behaya ghasti mughaliya ammi khala ki ghazi 🍑 mein ki teri begum ki haji 🍑 mein rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool 😂😂😂
@@manu.ba374Haan aur karne wale ki country abhi 2 ghaas aane ke liye bhik maang rahi hai. Usi me khush rahe.
His Father was Major General in east pakistan his father is main responsible
Yes I think he didn't read Hamoodur Rahman Commission report that recommended his father General Ghulam Umer Court Marshal
Sir jee.. 26/11.. only the families can understand the pain who lost their own people. with due respect to you, you have no right to say India should FORGET it.
When it comes to 26/11.. never forget.. never forgive.
Well said
Someday people will forget Pakistan's existence
@@technological1401 they should go into the history books, not before repaying for the evilish acts done till date, with time past raised exponentially.
yeah.
that was a very scary,sad and painful event.
unforgettable.
what about RAWs involvement in balochistan and their double joint union mission into KPK? What about the funding to TTP which led 70,000 civilians losing their lives?
Pakistanis cry for Islam... Hussain who died long back ..how can we forget it so easily our people... Their pain.. all the Best to Pakistanis but don't want them .. anymore!
Why you are here Gobbar bhakt??
For Islam??
Kuch toh baat hai es qoom mein jo tum loog es se itna chirrtay ho😄🇵🇰
Islam Zindabad
Pakistan Paindabad🇵🇰
@@manu.ba374 isiliye aallla janna main 130 feet transparent hoooris ka maal supply karta hai ....in local language it is known as bhadwagiri....
@@manu.ba374 pakistan se chirtey nahi hai
Ham tumlogo se nafrat karte hai.
Agli baar agar tumlogo ki taraf se koi hamla hua to apni patloon bachate firma
Thanks to Allah, we are separated and got freedom n Independence from that "Napak" country, otherwise our identity today would be as a "Beggars or Terrorists". Stiil they are keeping arrogant mentality , don't want to accept their criminal behaviour attitudes towards on Bangali peoples since 1947 - 1971. We are absolutely happy now. ❤️🇧🇩💘
Fall of Dhaka or Fall of Humanity? That was 1971 Genocide.
2008 was a watershed moment for India that completely changed the way India and Indians look at Pakistan, just saying that it happened in 2008 and we should move on while the preparators were roaming freely in Pakistan is not good enough....An average Indian has no appetite to normalise relations with Pakistan as long as Pakistan will not change its policy on terror....
Tricks to gain more views - add title India in it 😂
Endia.
@@AdityaJape hum mmusalmaan hai , paapistan iislamb ka khila hai , hum main jjazbaa hai ... yeh bhokchodi hai inki....
Same goes when Indian channels mentions Pakistan in title
#pkmkb
@@sheikhabdullah2337 #pkmkb
Some Pakistani thinks they are Superior than Bangladeshi people according to their skin color,food habit,height etc.its a racist act..🍂
Superiority only decides by Allah..not people..🍂
A good muslim cant be a racist..🍂
Allah Doesnt love injust people..
may Allah protect all muslims from that kind of behaviours..🍂
From Bangladesh🇧🇩
Now we Bangladeshi are ahead in most of the sectors.
Bengalis were SDRE, small, dark, rice-eaters.
Sorry. You are equally as biased as West Pakistanis by using the name of Allah. What about people who do not believe in Islam, which is the vast majority of the world. No body decides anything. You become what you are on your merits. Not because of some higher power.
Kash india. Se sare musalman pakistan chale jate partition waqt 😢
Hello! It’s not fall of Dhaka, it’s a RISE of Bangladesh and also free from looting,discrimination from Pakistan.
Let me tell you a reality, Daniyal. I have been watching Pakistani CZcamsrs like you for a while now, I am surprised how the ARMY comes up all the time. I am 70years old and a newspaper and news freak. I have never heard of or read anything about the Indian defense forces anywhere. People can and do talk about anything and everyone but talking about the defense forces is a taboo. Not because of any pressure but just because of the immense RESPECT people of India have for our jawans.
Not fully true. Indian forces committed brutality in Sri Lanka during Ipkf. The discussion happens in Tamil so many in delhi don’t hear it. It’s out there.cases of rape and loot is also there. Not saying anything for the heck of it. War is never nice. Not everyone fights for nation alone. Many do it just to make ends meet and make a living
@@bodhisattva6308 same has happened in india as well
@@garryrulz yes. The trust is not everyone joins forces to serve country. Most want a job. It’s a truth thst most of the world is not ready to see it thsr way
lol, seriously? You've perhaps not seen your own news channels and social media....some very toxic guys claim to be ex Indian army officers and give their opinion on everything.!
What the hell he's saying 🤬 "2008 mey Mumbai attack ho geya nah, abb chor dey". For them killing people is a normal thing. Bass jabb pocket khali hota hey tavvi inka emotion jag utta hey, "talking about good relations". First understand the value of life
As a Indian no we can't forget 26/11 it's a scar which will always hurt us. And you can't have both have our money and hurts us on our back no thanks.
“It is much safer to be feared than loved”
-Machiavelli
Safe to say, Pakistan isn't loved by any non pakistani, nor is it feared anywhere😂
Question is, what percentage of Pakistanis are watching this. Most the comments I see are either from Indians (Bharatiya) or Bangladeshis.
Title should be "Rise Of Dhaka"
Zubair Umer is a serious thinker, Pakistan needs more citizens like him!
Unfortunately still people of Pakistan think that they lost half of the country in1971.Basically Pakistan lost his colonial part in 1971 that was East bengal. so east bengal was never a part of pakistan but a colony of pakistan .when you never respect someone or any specific area as equally. Claiming that colony as a own part then it does not make any sense or make any change The actual relation between Pakistan and East Bengal was like owner and slaves ,Boss and Servants. Pakistan & people of pakistan treated Bengal and bengali people as 3rd class people & burden of pakistan from the first day. People of pakistan loved to use some racist word against bengali people like Kala Bengali and Bukha Bengali. Even after 1971 still today people of pakistan love to use some word like ""daw take ki aurat"" to devalue the currency of Bangladesh. But now that two taka equal to almost 6 pakistani rupee. so pakistan did not lost his half of a country but lost his colony in 1971. its a harsh reality of the history. people of pakistan should not claim that lost half of the country in 1971 and should stop claiming that it was a part because it does not make any sense or any change. that's why pakistan has never take a lesson from 1971 because it was not part of pakistan . its a real fact that state like pakistan never take a lesson from colony.If the Grass look greener on the other side, Stop staring, Stop comparing ,Stop complaining, and Start watering the grass you are standing on
We Bangladeshis are so grateful to this episode of your show, and we're glad that you chose you speak facts publicly without spreading lies and you people are aware, acknowledged and regretful for your previous deeds, we don't wanna hate you or consider you civilians as enemies except your country's previous and present rulers
Bangladeshi people personally love Pakistani people
But yet we're honest towards our state, nationality and history, we're patriots, not traitors, self interests would only prioritized depending on our national aspects between the relations of Bangladesh and Pakistan
May Allah bless my country and nation🇧🇩 and yours too🇵🇰
Joy Bangla!!!
Disagreed. We Bangladeshis never got over the wounds that have been given by Pakistan. My question is, do you consider yourself Bangladeshi? If so, how can you make this statement saying, 'Bangladeshi people personally love Pakistani people'? If you love them, it certainly means you love the people who killed our forefathers, who raped our mothers and sisters. You are basically shitting on the face of the people who have fought and sacrificed their life to get us freedom, independence, dignity, and most importantly our own language. Nowadays, I see a lot of Bangladeshis saying 'I love Pakistan' and what not which disgusts me. I am a true patriot and I shall never accept those assholes who did wrong to us!
So these guys want us to forget 2008 terrorist attacks (and many more) and allow your cricketers to earn from IPL. At the same time, the persons who planned countless terrorist attacks on us are freely roaming in Pakistan.
You should get your minds check and analyse your statements.
Most terrorist attacks in pak over last 15 years were carried out by India FYI
Pakistanis misidentified Bengalis. They did not know that the ancestors of the Bengalis had been fighting for the motherland for ages. Fed up with the oppression of the Bengalis, even the British moved the capital from Calcutta to Delhi 😊. Bengalis had shaken the fear of an entire colony, there was no greater example for the Pakistanis to know the Bengalis.
take it easy bro, the only people to held back the british were the pakistanis, specificaly our FATA area. More soldiers were killed in FATA than the whole subcontinent. The british ran through india like a sugar cane machine.
Yeah I agree Shahid Afridi didn't do 26/11 but they guy who did it Hafeez Saeed is in pakistan right now, and the pakistani government refuses to give him to us, what about that?
🇮🇳❤️🇧🇩 never forget the contribution of INDIA in the liberation of BANGLADESH.
Official apology will not make Pakistan small but will make them appear big . Acknowledgement of wrong doing will clear path to better and healthier tomorrow for the relations of both nations.
Can an apology reverse the evilish acts of Pakistan. Why you people can't see Pakistan reaching it's doom
IBM India has more employees than ibm, US.
About 1,40,000 Employees work across India.
Well is it so hard for you guys to just accept your brutality towards the people of Bangladesh without making negative comments on our father of the nation Sheikh Mujibur Rahman?
Pakistani should search youtube about Bangladesh Liberation war.
We don’t think its fall of Dhaka..... Its the rise of Dhaka,,,, A new future
Dr Manmohan Singh did not need to study Pakistani reforms under Nawaz Sharif to fix India's issues. Dr Manmohan Singh got his doctorate degree in Economics from London School of Economics, one of world's most prestigious school in that discipline. It is a sick joke to suggest that he needed to get clues from a Pakistani PM who could only speak English reading from a Parcha.
Our leaders invested in the Education and science n technology and Pakistan leadership invested in building mosque and madrasa .
It was not fall of Dhaka it was liberation war of Bangladesh.
It is rise of Dhaka🔥🔥🔥🔥
Kudoos to Daniyal for bringing in the guests from different backgrounds!
Let me also remind all the Bangladeshis that while India helped Bangladesh in its liberation from Pakistan, the U.S. tried to threaten India with nuclear missile for doing so.
So, don't forget the U.S. which for its own interests, didn't care about the plight of Bangladeshis.
we read about it in our social science book in primary school.
Russia also got involved in this matter.
A great analysis. Bangladesh is still going through growing pain, a democratic government and stability are key ingredients for success. People are not lazy, they need opportunities.
ppakistan is incomplete unless or untill ppakistan take every single mmoslim from iindia ..... then only ppakistan can become superpower.
shutt up yrr Bangladesh are doin great.
As a indian i see bangladesh more stable then pakistan but their is in stability in current time but all goes well not worry. Yours leader not like pakistan leaders😅😅
Islamic country and democratic government what a joke😅
@@roopalisarkar8802 RSS and Pakistanis are same culprits like you
If we were to be attached to Pakistan now we would not get enough respect for ourselves.....and we rise ourselves every single time...... so i think Islamabad now in Falling position..... on other hand Dhaka is far better and developing....
45:05 Bro literally no one wants pakistani players in IPL or people are not interested in pakistani players. For you people Mumbai attack is like ho gaya na hum kya kare ,this is disgusting as hell to talk like that . 4 bar war start kiya ,pulwama ,uri ,kashmiri pandits genicide etc aur bolte hai ki ho gaya hum kya karen
31:04 Manmohan Singh copied Nawaz Sharif's development model 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Oh Bhaaisaahab Kuch Zyaada Lambaaa nhi fekk diya yeh
These guys will keep discussing about their past, history, origins for the next 100 years - by which time rest of world would have moved on !
Rise of Dhaka ❤
Allah is with us
Allah give us power we made Pakistan for you
And Allah give us power we make Bangladesh for us
Add one more line: God help us (India & Bangladesh) to strike Pakistan with power & venom, and finish their race......
Even Narendra modi appreciated nawaj shareef's policies publicaly that's why he met with him.
26.00 Pakistan waged war against four times, 1947, 1965 , 1971 and 1999 , but your guest is saying that India messed up with Indo Pak relationship..
And look how India is suffering 😂😂
Bohat ala bhai, yeh Zubair sahib tau bohat qabil bandee lag rahee hain, I was under the impression k politicians ko kuch pata nahi hota :) but he has ample amount of knowledge.
If India becomes a friend, they will ask for money 😂
Rise of BANGLADESH 🇧🇩 🇧🇩
Hello respected sir
Can you please elaborate how there is India's contribution in all these mess between India pak relations?
You attacked us 3 times each time we tried to establish peace. Your establishment started a proxy war in India with all those terrorist groups.
It's an irony how your country calls TTP, BLA terror groups but not lashkar, jaish e muhammad.
India had been investing in development of industries and the people that ultimately caused bankruptcy. But the land was fertile for development when economy opned up. There were indigenous local industries and skilled people. And that's why after opening up the economy india became an economic powerhouse.
Pakistan never developed it's industries and professional ability, except for armed forces, spy games, mercenary activities. Because it received free money for exactly those activities from the west.
Opening up Pakistan economy will never be the same as India.
If Mujibor Rahmen was given power after 1970's election, Pakistan will never divided
Mr Zubair doesn't want to quote that until India retracts Artical 370 and 35, Pakistan would not talk to India. Pakistan has strangulated its own neck with its both hands firmly but plays a victim card that 'hands' are of somebody's else.
Never seen any host so clueless about each and everything. Should have done homework before inviting a knowledgeable guest Like Zubair Umer
Very informative podcast and Zubair Umar bold knowledgeable person 👌👌
Pakistan 1971 ko lekar apologize kare aur na kare, magar Bangladesch hasn't forgotten 1971. Very sad to say, every Pakistani is very nice and friendly minded except Pakistani army 🪖.
talk this talk to the british then, they did far worse than anything pakistan could have ever done. bengal genocide ??? you are very quiet on that front, just on pakistan. yet 650,000 people from bangaldesh live in uk.
The separation of East Pakistan from Pakistan resulted from the imposition of Urdu as the national language. It is surprising to observe that individuals from non-Urdu speaking regions of Pakistan, such as Sindh, have embraced Urdu as their native language. This raises the question of whether Punjabi, Balochi, and Sindhi share more similarities with Urdu than with Bengali.
I would like to kindly request a gentle and informative response to this inquiry, as it is not intended to offend or make any assumptions.
Most still don't speak Urdu as their main language, especially in the countryside. It is now used more to communicate with one another but still prefer our own languages
it is the lingua de franca yes, but urdu/farsi has been part of the region that is now pakistan for centuries, so it was a smoother switch for pakistan. Plus urdu has alot of similarities to the local languages punjabi and sindhi. Pashtun people are known for being versatile with languages, the average pashtun already speaks 3-4 languages (urdu, dari, farsi, pashto, some even punjabi, balochi, tajik, english), many kashmiris also speak punjabi so urdu isnt far off, so it was in general an easier switch for pakistan than it would have been for bangladesh
If this is the intel level of pakistani politicians then no wonder Pakistan is on verge of default. Hafiz Sayed comes out of so called jail and roams in pakistan and threatens India and this bugger wants to play cricket. We will never forget Mumbai Attacks and we will punish the perpetrators in Pakistan.
Pak has lost all wars with India. India is a superpower
16:30 Why did not Mujib set foot in West Pakistan? Because he would have been killed!
Fall of Dhaka🤔 where now whole Pakistan is falling down and begging around the world😅
This man is real. Respect 🫡
*44:45** bhai g kisne karwaya tha, hamare logon ki Jaan gayi h to dukh v hame hi hota h, cricket Jaan se jada nahi h, tumne apna faisla 1947 me hi kar liya or hame usse koi dikkat nahi h, aap v khush rahe hame v rahne de* 🙏 🙏
Pakistan close border not india. South asia prosperity only with Open borders. Dr. Manmohan singh ji world top economist this time india stands here due to him.
It is very good that Bangladesh has been freed from the bloody hands of Pakistanis by the infinite mercy of Allah
Pakistan needs to punish the perpetrators of 26/11 and also stop cross border infiltration. Actions speak louder than words! Pakistan and only Pakistan can solve it’s problems both domestic and international!
I invite the anchor, Danial vai to visit Dhaka, please have a tour & let your people know about us, from one of their voices💚
Pakistan also has to make efforts. Extradite Hafiz Saeed, Lakhvi, Azhar, Salauddin to India. Then you see normal Indians will also see the benefit of improved relations.
True
Even the arabs are scared to keep Pakistani employees in their homes and offices. Pata nahi kab kiska fatwa aajay.
This person is so genuine in his words...
U don't want to trade but want to play to in IPL ...sb $ kaa khel hai bhai...
Rise of DHAKA,BANGLADESH
2008 me hogaya kab tak leke beithe rahoge??? 😒 WTF
Wo hum kabhi nehin bhul sakte aur jo bhul Jaye wo Indian nehin hai..
Kyu rakhni hai relation aap ko? Rahon na apne jeise..Hume nehin chaiye dusht insan se dosti rakhne se jyada dosht hin rehna jyada better hai 🙏
It was FALL OF PAKISTAN not DHAKA.
I don’t have any idea of who this person is but I must say, Zubair umer is a definition of a literate man. You must know histories related to your country, and not bias history.
Zuber ji, is a true well-wisher of Pakistan. Good podcast 👏
One of the few authentic podcast! He has a true concern for Pakistani.
My siblings and I are 1st Gen Bangladeshi citizens. Papa is colonial, mom is Pak Bengal born. I leave my comment because of reasons below-
1. The guest spoke so eloquently on this CZcams [1 of it’s 3 developers’ father is Bangladeshi-born btw] suggested episode that kept my attention.
2. I’m glad that I listened through the part where he covered his experience because I never had a Pakistani-born speak of the disintegration with such healthy attitude.
4:52- I am so glad man mentioned Germany. If German civilians had the slightest clue their neighbors were burnt alive because of their faith, highly-assertive Hitler would not have had the luxury to operate.
6:57 - 2x I got unnecessarily aggressive comments from a bi-racial and a Pak-born peer [“Tum log humare zameen per reh raho ho”] just as I mentioned my area of origin that I never needed any further understanding of what extent one might go to defend self-identity.
9:59 - Mrs. Hasina Wajed’s husband headed the Nuclear Commission of Pakistan in the 60’s, if I am correct to my information. Ever heard of the man is dead/alive? Nobody does! All thanks to her good relationship with Mr. Modi now, woman dared to not allow Bangladeshi citizens get to voting polls during Dec, 2019’s election. Is she a European or W. Pakistani in Bangladeshi lead now?
10:05 - I thought it was a positive gesture from Gen. Mosharrof to write a note of apology in the guest entry at Savar national monument during the first Pakistani Presidential visit since splitting up.
10:55 - Now this, I call wealth. One who’s worth is not diminished by acknowledging a wrongful act. Man was a 10 year old himself!
13:26 - Not submitting to one’s needs/not risking good relationships because of someone else is an unfortunate trait among the Sapiens. I never understood what a class valedictorian of Dehradun would have against a Bengalis! Frontline soldiers generally come from working faction. Lesser the financial solvency goes, higher the degree of nationalism is. It was the frontline soldiers who went rogue on March 25, 1971, and their General never reprimanded them how none of the Western officers ever jeopardized their relationships with their subordinates over generating the bi-racial bloodline resulting from the sex-tents in Afghan region over 2 long decades.
16:20 - My elementary education was at an institution named after a civil war martyr. Believe me when I say that seeing his baby face etched on the grounds EVERYday still keeps the anti-Pakistani spirit alive at Dhaka Cantonment, but never wondered why the electoral victor never bothered setting foot in the capital town. Man did get pretty dominant over keeping national affairs restricted to central Gov’t that finally triggered his assassination.
17:17 - The bread earner was one among the 5% of the বাঙালী participants of Pakistani defense forces. Till date, I have 0 clue how was that civil war of 1971 was survived. ALL I ever got from him was, “They laughed at my struggle with the temperature.”
22:04 - Mass loss of skilled male lives during wars all over the globe demanded female participation in raising respective national GDP. If female participation in Pakistan is not as large as Bangladesh, is it not an evidence that the scale of atrocities has not been exaggerated?
💛
Urdu was not language of any part of Pakistan. Not fall of Dhaka fall of Islamabad Pakistan and defeat of pakistan military.
Bhai Indian football is very much on the Rise
Today our Fifa rankings Is 101
Also Our Football history is considered the Golden period
1950-1962
Indian football was considered The " Brazil of Asia"
We played the 4-2-4 formation way before Brazil Popularised the free flow and samba if football
India has the oldest football club in Asia formed in 1892 called " Mohun bagan "
They defeated the east Yorkshire regiment which Gave uprising for Independence
It is known as Immortal eleven
Also The FIFA president at that time said that We are the best in Asia
And that we were almost on par With
European countries
We won Asian games twice and finished fourth in Olympics
We even qualified for World Cup in 1950 , after few teams withdrew
But never went which still today is our greatest mistake
We had different priorities
Also we played barefoot just to note
We made Hungary ( the best Team at that point )
And made them Pull our indian players shirt
They were so tired 🔥🔥
Right now after inaugration of ISL in 2014
Indian football is on a slow Rise
We qualified for Asia Cup in 2011 ,2019 and 2024
🙏🙏🙏
Hope ❤️❤️
Alhamduliahlla I proud to be Bangladeshi and I am Muslim. ♥️🇧🇩☪️☪️
Stop Calling it Fall Of Dhaka.
It Is Rise Of Dhaka.
It should be named Fall of Islamabad!
Danish Akshay here from Bombay amazing interview so engaging
Very light hearted nice conversation... Love from india
if this is the intellectual class of Pakistan then I'm afraid your country is beyond saving you may keep stalling your collapse but will never crawl out of this mess.
Remember: partition of India was coined in Bangladesh not pakistan..they are more kattar than pakistan.
Very true......Indians seem to forget that......
Love the sensible point of view 💜