Story of Ancient India: From the Deep South to North | Dr. Raj Vedam |

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 24. 09. 2020
  • Dr Raj Vedam in his talk on 'The Story Of Ancient India: From The Deep South To North' mentions the evidence of knowledge systems and Pan India cultural similarity.
    The speaker deep dives in ancient southern history and demolishes the Dravidian claims in favor of a pan-Indian identity. He analyzes the latest available papers on genetics, archaeology (2019), and roundup along with past evidence of what they imply for the ancient history of India.
    Dr Raj Vedam mentions how the astronomical model is common to India. He states that the names of the Nakshatras in the Northern and the Southern India are not much different and even if there are regional variations, the similarities are more. He talks about how the Max Mueller dates can be demolished using the Astronomical model.
    Dr Raj Vedam talks about his approach to Genetics and argues that genetic results cannot be globalised as it requires models, methodology, data, samples and claims.
    Dr Vedam talks about similar cultural practices across time and geography and emphasises on the theory of cultural continuity of civilisation. He reiterates that India is united by its ancient culture and heritage and its identity is that of Dharmic civilisation. According to him, the destruction of Indian identity by malicious forces must be contested and neutralised with evidence-based claims.
    About Speaker:
    Dr. Raj Vedam, MSEE, PhDEE, works at the confluence of applied mathematics, engineering, algorithms, and computer science. Using tools of Archeo-Genetics, archeo- astronomy and archaeology, and evidence of knowledge transfers from ancient India, the speaker has put forward a strong thesis with verifiable facts, on the antiquity of the Indian Civilisation, and the many discoveries made my the ancients.
    Dr. Raj Vedam is a co-founder of the think-tank, Indian History Awareness and Research, and resides in Houston, Texas. He can be reached at rajvedam[at]yahoo[dot]com and on Facebook at / raj.vedam.1
    Subtopics:
    0:00
    1:34 Five forces allied against Indian History
    3:08 Why was Indian history distorted?
    4:34 Model based approach to evaluate different narratives
    5:50 Implications of Linguistic model
    7:20 Why Indian history chronology was distorted
    10:28 European search for homeland
    12:10 Proto-Indo-European: Quest for western identity narrative
    12:32 PIE reconstruction example: the wheel
    16:24 Kurgan / Steppe Hypothesis
    16:54 Aryan Invasion Theory (AIT)
    17:23 Marxist Ideological Offensive
    18:35 What is the story of Indian Civilization?
    19:24 The story of the deep south
    23:26 The manufacture of Kumari Kandam
    27:55 Reality of Kumari Kandam
    28:33 Agastya in the extreme south
    31:56 Southern Archaeology - Keeladi
    37:25 Archaeological site Adichnallur
    39:52 Are Dravidians connected to Elamites
    41:09 Story of scripts - Harappan and Brahmi scripts
    43:35 Indus script is like a rebus
    44:53 Indus script dictionary
    46:39 Relation of Brahmi to Indus Script
    49:28 Relation of Modern scripts to Brahmi
    50:51 Bet-Dwarka Marine Archaeology
    51:41 Oldest Brahmi script: Palani: 500BC
    53:46 non-Harappa references to writing
    55:27 Conclusion from Southern Archeology and Scripts
    56:37 Language
    57:00 Origin of the word Dravidian
    57:47 History of Sanskrit - Dravidian Split
    1:00:03 G.U.Pope
    1:01:14 Robert Caldwell
    1:07:01 Dr. R. Nagaswamy
    1:08:05 “Dravidians” native to South?
    1:10:09 Bayesian Phylogenetics: Proto-Dravidian: 2500BCE
    1:11:12 About skin tone of Indians
    1:13:54 Conclusion: Deep South
    1:14:55 Pan-Indian Astronomy
    1:22:11 Pan-India Astronomy antiquity roundup
    1:22:49 Relative chronology: Max Mueller
    1:26:45 Confidence level with Genetics Methodology
    1:33:33 Rebuttal: Issues with Genetic Ancestry Estimation
    1:37:16 Closing remarks
    Subscribe to our CZcams channels:
    CZcams English: / sangamtalks
    CZcams Hindi: / sangamhindi
    Follow Sangam Talks on social media:
    Telegram: t.me/sangamtalks
    Twitter: / sangamtalks
    Facebook: / sangamtalks
    Instagram: / sangamtalks
    Website: www.sangamtalks.org
    Donate: www.sangamtalks.org/donate

Komentáře • 662

  • @hemanag1020
    @hemanag1020 Před rokem +25

    Raj, you are a great man. I am a Maori from New Zealand, we have an author here called James Belich, he re wrote our military history. Where british, colonial forces claimed victory over Maori tribes, but they lied. Raj has a much bigger task, not just military.

  • @sudheertcs
    @sudheertcs Před 6 měsíci +3

    Dr. Raj Vedam. Please keep up the fantastic work. We all got wrong history in school books. Namo government will definitely look and bring change to our Historical curriculum.!

  • @johndavis6119
    @johndavis6119 Před rokem +9

    Thank you sir for standing up and speaking truth to power. I’m not an Indian but as part Native American I can empathize with anyone who fights to get the truth of their culture out to the world.

  • @saffrondominic4585
    @saffrondominic4585 Před 2 lety +90

    I'm an overseas Tamilian, this talk is so inspiring Sir. I would request if you could kindly provide the reference list at the end of your talk so that we young scholars could explore this further; many thanks

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety +5

      Indian civilization, a Tamil civilization. Land of the Tamils !!!

    • @kaceobrwa7039
      @kaceobrwa7039 Před 2 lety +5

      @@StarPlanet56789 lmao

    • @JPVillalobos27
      @JPVillalobos27 Před 2 lety +13

      @@kaceobrwa7039 This Jupiter guy trolls all of Raj Vedam’s lectures lol.

    • @saloni2244
      @saloni2244 Před 2 lety +4

      @@StarPlanet56789 Stop !

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      @@saloni2244 Listen to indian mystic Satyaguru on aryan invasion of India. It can be Google.

  • @MarvinMonroe
    @MarvinMonroe Před 2 lety +18

    Raj Vedam is one of the speakers that automatically watch on this channel. Love these talks. Love from Ohio

  • @RajuN
    @RajuN Před 3 lety +106

    Raj, means a king.His name itself contains VEDAM, the immense knowledge. No words to describe his greatness. 'The king of Vedas' is my title given to him. A Modern Rishi. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

    • @asifanwar2391
      @asifanwar2391 Před 3 lety

      Because they are fully biased .

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety +5

      @Devvrat Mishra lol 😂😂 Too much bias in his work for example around 1:06:32 the southern indian and northern indian never saw themselves as separate group of people, Which is not true at all. In manu smriti, manu describes a region from himalayas to vidya mountains in central India as Aryavatta (Land of Aryas) and ask people to not visit south of the vidyas.
      So then people who lived south of vidyas are not seen as belonging to same group of people.

    • @arabindasatapathy8949
      @arabindasatapathy8949 Před 2 lety +1

      @Devvrat Mishra bro leave it. Uske baat mei 1rs Ka logic nahi hai. Bas yaha aake gandh macha raha hai. Uske naam ko hi Dekh lo.

    • @arabindasatapathy8949
      @arabindasatapathy8949 Před 2 lety +1

      @Devvrat Mishra baat mei toh dum hai. But ye log mote dimag walle hai. Kuch bhi baat ghusta hi Nahi hai. Har jagah pe Ye ek hi comment copy paste marke rakha hai.

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety +1

      @@arabindasatapathy8949 I have posted the comments everywhere to engage with people and let them know about this particular piece of information

  • @payasumprakashreddi7733
    @payasumprakashreddi7733 Před 2 lety +16

    What a cool person, no diversity no negativity no controversial words. I love this personality.

  • @RanjitGodbole
    @RanjitGodbole Před 3 lety +111

    I’m just short of words after trying to understand and make sense out of what the speaker has been trying to explain. All I can say is that we are lucky to be a part of this amazing diverse culture that’s filled with knowledge of humanity.

    • @sarojinichelliah5500
      @sarojinichelliah5500 Před 2 lety +6

      Me too

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety +1

      All Tamil civilization

    • @RanjitGodbole
      @RanjitGodbole Před 2 lety +6

      @@StarPlanet56789 explain

    • @michellelafaye2721
      @michellelafaye2721 Před rokem +1

      We generally have a difficult time of understanding anything new that has been lacking from our background experiences. Being an English Speaker I have a very difficult with the names of things and places. Language is a photo. If we can't see a picture we just don't grasp all of the concepts. Add that to the fact that a lot of Indians talk very fast. I just try to watch some of these videos more than one time.

    • @VijayKumarIITSrExecutive
      @VijayKumarIITSrExecutive Před rokem

      Interesting alternate perspective. Would also recommend following work of Dan Davis and David Anthony on CZcams. Read "The Horse, The Wheel and The Language" by David Anthony. The archaeological and linguistic evidence there is mind boggling. Now, that's genuine scientific inquiry to understand history of mankind. This is also accepted by most historians of the world except for a few in India (whose national pride has been hurt by earlier foreign rule and believe its a conspiracy, with no scientific proof).
      I used to feel hurt too by Aryan Migration Theory but later realized that such migrations were a norm in the world then (refer "Sapiens"). We can't judge what happened then by today's moral standards. My respect for Maryada Purushottam Ram doesn't go down one bit because of this. By this logic, even Americans should feel so much hurt about their European Aryan migration to Americas (and killing of native tribes) that they should deny it ever happened?
      What our Indian historians don't understand is that if intention was to undermine India, then European historians would have never unearthed Indus Valley civilization and give it global fame for immaculate planning. Sapiens book on page 333 says that Guptas and Mauryas never gave these ruins a second glance and no Indian before the British was aware of them. They also made Buddhism and Yoga popular, deciphered Brahmi Script, Learned Sanskrit and deciphered meaning of Vedas (when hindu brahmins were just saying it by rote and had forgotten its meaning) etc. These historians unearthed other civilizations in Middle East and Egypt and brought them fame as well. Couldn't they have instead just let it all gather dust and said "You Indians and Middle Easterners have inferior history!)."?
      Having an alternate view point is always welcome. If current Indian historians are so sure, they should go ahead and publish their work in international journals which is peer reviewed with evidence. Instead what is happening is armchair conspiracy theories with no archaeology involved. OTOH, David Anthony travels around the world doing archaeology as well, in many cases with money from their own pocket and tight budget.
      Our Indian historians should also feel free to travel the world and gather evidence. With quest for true academic inquiry that helps us understand the history of our humanity. Who's stopping them? Instead there is politics to advance "we are superior" ideas. They stand uniquely isolated in the world today with very little credibility.

  • @NoRiceToEat
    @NoRiceToEat Před 2 lety +6

    I am not a professional linguist but what I am is a very observant person, I have always looked at things more deeply than other people my age and I have always had this feeling that the southern culture is very in line with the marathi culture in Maharashtra where I currently live and then marathi culture is deeply connected to Gujarat and sindh.
    My ancestors were from rajasthan but I have been born and bought up in Maharashtra and I have seen the way the ladies cook food in the south, mud and manure based yards of the houses and the way the society functions and family systems and language..we are all very deeply connected.
    Also for the people who assume things by skin colour, I am a student of science so i can say without a doubt that if you were to cast a northern man into a darker skin tone he would have no difference in appearance from a south Indian and if you took a dark skinned man from south and lightened his skin colour a shade or two you will see no difference between him and another light skinned north Indian.
    Skin colour darkens as a community spends more time living in a geographical region where there is an abundance of sunlight, the skin colour starts changing to avoid sunburn and you get melanin production at high levels turning the skin darker and the southern parts have been inhabited since thousands of years while the north receives lesser sunlight and has a milder climate some parts are extremely cold so they need less melanin in order to absorb whatever sunlight they can get for Vitamin D.
    also if you go to rajasthan and see the nomads and other such tribes you will see that they have some of the darkest skin colours because they live under the sun alot and you will see no difference between them and the south Indians.

    • @NoRiceToEat
      @NoRiceToEat Před rokem +1

      @t s Muthuraman the gene for skin colour is linked in south Asia and Europe.
      The skin colour of a population depends on one such gene and this gene over a period of time gives the population the colour of their skin due to the closeness to the equator and tropical zones.
      It's melanin production that determines skin colour and the gene for it is common between Europe and south aisa.

    • @nikitajha6500
      @nikitajha6500 Před 4 měsíci

      My brother who used to stay in Bangalore, was often confused as the native but we are north Indians. He would often say when I tell people I am from North they won't believe me. The north Indians won't believe until I speak Maithili.

  • @susanfennimore3152
    @susanfennimore3152 Před 3 lety +10

    Not interested as a formal student,just interested . And wow this makes so much sense and easy enough for anyone to understand. I’m so grateful.

  • @pushpajankandan785
    @pushpajankandan785 Před 2 lety +16

    Wonderful attempt. Amazing knowledge in Indian and Vedic history.... He shatters church and Christianity and missionary intention to devide the country using history, language, caste and creed... Etc.
    Iam proud to hear this speech to update my knowledge

  • @janardansingh5926
    @janardansingh5926 Před 3 lety +49

    Raj Vedam ji is always refreshing on important issues of our ancient wisdom

  • @virgiljjacas1229
    @virgiljjacas1229 Před 3 lety +34

    Professor Vedam, there not enough space and to praise your insightful work.
    If you ever come to Colorado, regardless the location, PLEASE, notify in advance to patronize and assist to the lecture.
    Thank you and keep on !!!

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      lol 😂😂 Too much bias in his work for example around 1:06:32 the southern indian and northern indian never saw themselves as separate group of people, Which is not true at all. In manu smriti, manu describes a region from himalayas to vidya mountains in central India as Aryavatta (Land of Aryas) and ask people to not visit south of the vidyas.
      So then people who lived south of vidyas are not seen as belonging to same group of people.

    • @Badrn100
      @Badrn100 Před 2 lety +6

      @@stalinsampras It's this type of BS he is bursting. Please note Manu is not the sole Hindu narrator. There were many Law makers like Parashara, Yagnavalkya etc.

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      @@Badrn100 Yeah but Manu was the first and well know by the masses. There were around 40 million copies of manusmriti found in British occupied india

    • @HarshSharma-jk5hv
      @HarshSharma-jk5hv Před 2 lety +1

      @@stalinsampras first of all ......what is the dating of manusmriti......it's not more than 15th to 16th century alright...... manusmriti don't only contain shlokas by manu but also shlokas by Gautama. It might be possible that guatama might be multiple person or might be a single one but one thing is sure that he is wicked. Gautama is the one who writes things like "put molten lead in the ear as punishment"

    • @kaceobrwa7039
      @kaceobrwa7039 Před 2 lety +2

      @@stalinsampras first go and learn the difference between smriti and shruti , there are thousand of people like you , but trust me , you can do nothing, commenting here won't fulfill your goal, no matter how much you bullshit , truth will always prevail , and truth has no bias

  • @achalanand2213
    @achalanand2213 Před 2 lety +7

    From Himalaya to great ocean it was , it is and will be one Bharat and One people.

  • @ketutdonder4198
    @ketutdonder4198 Před 3 lety +11

    Namaskar, Thank you Dr. Raj Vedam, from your sharing I think it become the Hindu youth interest to understand about Vedic science or Indian Ancient knowledge.

  • @aniruddhbahuguna5462
    @aniruddhbahuguna5462 Před 3 lety +12

    After seeing him I still accept India are very intelligent in the field of education. And we still say no scientific invention and discovery happened now days in India. But recently our army invented gun. And person like Raj Vedam changing positive page of our history

  • @thenu0817
    @thenu0817 Před 3 lety +18

    The trajectory of Dr Raj Vedam's work will soon include a total revamp of Indian history textbooks at all academic levels. Eagerly waiting for it.

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      lol 😂😂🤣🤣

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      lol 😂😂 Too much bias in his work for example around 1:06:32 the southern indian and northern indian never saw themselves as separate group of people, Which is not true at all. In many smriti, manu describes a region from himalayas to vidya mountains in central India as Aryavatta (Land of Aryas) and ask people to not visit south of the vidyas.
      So then people who lived beyond the south of vidya mountains are not seen as same people.

    • @aryanchakraborty5175
      @aryanchakraborty5175 Před 2 lety +3

      @@stalinsampras Talk about Rig Veda . Rig Veda says Manu's ( North indians ) and Druyhu's ( South Indians ) are both Arya's

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      Indian civilization, a Tamil civilization. Land of the Tamils !!!

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      @@stalinsampras Indian civilization, a Tamil civilization. Land of the Tamils !!!

  • @CdABarreto
    @CdABarreto Před 2 lety +10

    I can only express my gratitude to Dr Vedam for his (always) excellent talks. Not only makes justice to the Indian History and culture but most importantly acts as a really serious scientist. Thanks 🙏 again!!!

  • @inviolablegeo2783
    @inviolablegeo2783 Před rokem +3

    Extraordinary compilation. Considered all sorts of evidences to establish the antiquity of Dharmic civilisation.

  • @narasimhanramarao211
    @narasimhanramarao211 Před 2 lety +4

    Simply wonderful. Full of facts. How can one talk non.stop for more than an hour. Gods grace

  • @rishabhawasthi2180
    @rishabhawasthi2180 Před 3 lety +38

    Why are nt these people being promoted to good high class universities and syllabus and committes

  • @CSL075
    @CSL075 Před 3 lety +15

    Enjoyed each and every word !!! Thank you sir for your wisdom. Bharath needs more intellectuals like you. Jai Hind . Vande Mataram.

    • @yarlagaddasatyanarayana4072
      @yarlagaddasatyanarayana4072 Před 3 lety +3

      Thank you for your deep study and knowledge and exposi
      sion

    • @sarojinichelliah5500
      @sarojinichelliah5500 Před 3 lety +2

      @@yarlagaddasatyanarayana4072 the intellectual talk needs to be followed up by taking a deeper look at the claims with more evidence and DNA samples as a follow up without which it will die a natural death.

    • @gravewalker34
      @gravewalker34 Před 2 lety

      @@sarojinichelliah5500 only dna study that can prove something is the origin of R1A1A and subclates. Oldest swastika found was in ukraine till they found one in jaora caves in india from 11000 years ago. Swastika in Indus and haryana is 6-7000 yr ago. Swastika in iran is around 7-8000 yr ago. So any migration happen into india was wayyy long ago around 12000 yr ago or vice versa where they found common ancestor of indian and central asian. And only indian and iranian kings had the title of arya or airya. So its slowly started to show indians went to central asia not the other way around.

  • @gitachakrabarti1107
    @gitachakrabarti1107 Před 3 lety +6

    Dr. Vedam please carry on. Your discourses are mathematucally correct and in sync with our Vedic civilisation. Southern Indian brains are amonst the most brilliant in the world. May Lord Vasudeva and Lakshmi protect you from ALL harm. You are simply brilliant sir.🙏

    • @SatyaSanathani
      @SatyaSanathani Před 2 lety +4

      As a South Indian, I can tell you that all Indians from North to South and from East to West are intelligent. Most top IIT entrance exams are aced by North Indians. Most Indians migrated across regions freely. Shree Adi Shankaracharya travelled to Kashmir, Puri, Gujurat, and South. We are all one

    • @gitachakrabarti1107
      @gitachakrabarti1107 Před 2 lety +2

      @@SatyaSanathani Thanks.👍 for your reply and I totally agree with you here.

    • @SatyaSanathani
      @SatyaSanathani Před 2 lety +3

      @Vinita Narayan I agree we have a great history. Raj Vedam is brilliant. I did not know he is a south Indian. I disagree, that we south Indians are smart and brilliant that north. All great leaders came from North Indians. North was constantly invaded and plundered. As a result, the mindset of people living in the north changed. South was not colonized as much as north. Top candidates for IIT entrance exams are always from the north. Rajiv Malhotraji's work towards the protection of Sanatana Dharma is beyond words. Please check his videos on CZcams. We need someone like him in every areas of dharmic study. I have observed that some south Indian's who oppose Hindi claim to be smarter. But true smart and brilliant people never claim to be smart and brilliant.

  • @JanardhanPrasadDVS
    @JanardhanPrasadDVS Před 3 lety +11

    Great work. Sincere salutes to Shri Raj Vedam. Ved means Knowledge. Vedam means pool of knowledge. So Shri Raj Vedam is living upto his name in all respects. He is a voracious reader. But reader with a purpose. And he is revealing his knowledge to the public like this. So he can be called Acharya. And he is telling the Truth. So he should be called a Rishi.
    I have been watching his videos for long and enriching my knowledge every time. Thanks Sir.

  • @clp2149
    @clp2149 Před 2 lety +5

    It is irony of this nation that the truth and the brilliance of research has not reached the schools and colleges where it is now needed the most.

  • @krithikagokulnath4160
    @krithikagokulnath4160 Před rokem +3

    My perspective has changed after this lecture, Dr.Raj Vedam. I was also firmly believing about the Kumari Kandam. Now I am confused.. seems to have sunken too deep into the ocean, conceptually. I still feel there's some natural cataclysm that we are unable to place, since all texts have referred to 'Ravana's Lanka ' corresponding to the Kumari Kandam area. I have however understood how the "Dravidian" label was the British way of 'divide and rule'...

  • @tysyzygy
    @tysyzygy Před 11 měsíci +3

    Thank you for taking the time to present this lecture in English. I think you provide solid evidential thinking towards a growing common problem in all of the world's cultural history studies. Simply, historic 'facts' often don't 'fit' with an actual and often local worldview record. Do you have a link/contact for your academic writing?

  • @The_Rude_French_Canadian
    @The_Rude_French_Canadian Před 2 lety +7

    In my mind India was either one of the surviving groups of humans after the younger Dryas or were one of the advanced civilizations that trived before the catastrophe…

  • @christianlammers7675
    @christianlammers7675 Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you. Its a very enlightning story. Peace Peace Peace. Now i feel much older.

  • @ganeshts8272
    @ganeshts8272 Před 2 lety +6

    Sir amazing, it's great that Tamil is soo old language .. we want do more research. And we love it

  • @rajendersandadi9730
    @rajendersandadi9730 Před 2 lety +4

    Just outstanding evidence dismantling the Linguistic model.

  • @sushilgupta6548
    @sushilgupta6548 Před 3 lety +18

    Absolutely convincing and scientific. GoI must start doing something about establishing the whole of India, Pakistan etc as a single ancient civilisational unit and correct our text books accordingly

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      Indian civilization, a Tamil civilization. Land of the Tamils !!!

  • @sanjayshenoy2686
    @sanjayshenoy2686 Před 3 lety +10

    Wow! Just fantastic analysis and why we as the people of India are one. My sincere appreciation of the depth of knowledge presented here with an incredible amount of research behind it. 🙏
    This needs to be in the mainstream narrative in India.

  • @vikramrazdan5680
    @vikramrazdan5680 Před 3 lety +13

    Outstanding rebuttal by Raj Vedam of the Western Indologists papers and theories on inward migration of race and language into India. The time has come to work on the 'Out of India' theory by using the same rebuttal examples (saraswati drying up/famine/migration with cattle/vedic gods in Mittani such as Indra/sanskrit origin words in coastal Europe/genetic markers. etc.). Need to study archeological sites in Iraq/Central Asia to start with to look for clues.

    • @MM-dh3wr
      @MM-dh3wr Před 2 lety

      There is no Brahma(aryan GOD) inside temples that clearly shows Aryans came later and could not push Brahma inside.

    • @vikramrazdan5680
      @vikramrazdan5680 Před 2 lety

      @@MM-dh3wr - Stupid people pray by kneeling down (instead of standing up) towards Allah in the sky! The same goes for stupid people calling Arya (noble person) as Aryans.

  • @gillkara
    @gillkara Před 2 lety +6

    Raj Vedam is good at synthesising evidence

  • @sanatanidotnetdharmaplatfo3991

    All youth of India must watch

  • @v.n.gopalakrishnannair1066

    Excellent presentation. Convincing views. Demolishes the theories of Orientalists. V.N. Gopalakrishnan.

  • @rkowlagi
    @rkowlagi Před rokem +2

    Fantastic 🎉❤ No words describe the breadth and depth of his knowledge 🤗

  • @iagreewithyou4328
    @iagreewithyou4328 Před 2 lety +7

    1:31:37 This part is one of the most important as far as I'm concerned.
    You can never find the truth when you are working with a psychological barrier.
    1:36:48 as a kannada native speaker, I can confirm that the sandhi rules are not similar but are exactly the same. Infact the rule itself is called Samskrutha sandhi. Nearly all of kannada grammar is Sanskrit grammar.

    • @menacinghaven
      @menacinghaven Před 2 lety +4

      We are one, brits divided us. Left with only small wars because they planned to colonialise india for long term.

    • @aryanchakraborty5175
      @aryanchakraborty5175 Před 2 lety +7

      Same with Bengali too , I have studied Sanskrit , and I can say , Bengali is just the same as Sanskrit with only difference in Phonetics

  • @avadhootkharade146
    @avadhootkharade146 Před 2 lety +7

    It was very inspiring. Great knowledge. Hats off to you sir.

  • @gahlowtvks8012
    @gahlowtvks8012 Před 3 měsíci +2

    Superb, parallel to Ayodhya, a Pan indian narrative is the need of hour despite being complex

  • @meham6954
    @meham6954 Před 3 lety +26

    Plz shed light on 'Macaulayism' too and our ancient gurukul system. How they distorted n concocted falsehood?..

    • @choudhurysaheb8326
      @choudhurysaheb8326 Před 3 lety +3

      Nobody stopping you to live in a jungle and do tapasya. Why are you even using CZcams ? Raj vedam is a US citizen for your information.

    • @meham6954
      @meham6954 Před 3 lety +5

      @@choudhurysaheb8326 @Tintin Deb shut up dude.
      U think I didn't? That was an old comment. Just ppl hav a good way of speaking n communicating. The way sm ppl communicate n put forth points is impressive. Every speaker is different. So requested. Was new then hence requested. I didn't not put a gun to his head. And u n him had every right to ignore the comment/ request/ idea.

    • @navneetkaur5436
      @navneetkaur5436 Před 3 lety

      U can c Vedveer Arya work on Gurukul system in CZcams chl. The Jaipur dialogues or Sangam talks of India or search for Dharampal books on Indian educational system

    • @navneetkaur5436
      @navneetkaur5436 Před 3 lety

      The book of Dharampal is The beautiful tree 🎄

  • @seamusmoose122
    @seamusmoose122 Před rokem +2

    anyone interested in a description of 3000 years ago by a greek trader that found india while sailing look up voices of the past youtube channel titled greek description of india describing many races of people all considering themselves indian and the caste system in its true form and how impressed they were on ancient indian society which is considered huge looking at how high cultured the greeks were at thaat time though northern india was as great on the architecture and farming.

  • @rajanikant83
    @rajanikant83 Před 3 lety +8

    Great learning Sir, you make me even more proud of me being an Indian.

  • @ankuraagarwal
    @ankuraagarwal Před 3 lety +14

    Most scientific and well researched talk. Best Regards 🙏🙏🙏

  • @kssam5867
    @kssam5867 Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you for you thorough and logical discussion. Clearly one cannot remove all gaps in the analysis. However, in Sanskrit, milk is पयस् (Payas) and breast is पयोद (Payodha). So Tamil's பாலு (paalu) could be closely related to milk, as in பாயசம்(payasam), while दूध (Doodh), I believe is Urdu دودھ , also derived from Sanskrit for something that is milked.

  • @DaOPhETKaH
    @DaOPhETKaH Před 2 lety +6

    MAKE INDIA GREAT AGAIN. From: LAO. WE NEED PEACE AND PROSPERITY. AND THE TRUTH.

  • @BharatUIMe
    @BharatUIMe Před 3 lety +6

    Eye opener. My 🙏🏽🙏🏽 to Shri. Dr.Raj Vedam.

  • @mohanasrao
    @mohanasrao Před 3 lety +15

    Respected Dr.Raj Vedantam, I'm eagerly waiting for your next session. Interested in learning more about the contribution of the Hindu Upanishads part of the CHATURVEDAS. The contributions of Brihadaranyaka, yaCHhANDHOGYA, KATHA, and Iwasaya must be discussed in-depth and their contributions to the world of Ancient Knowledge must be brought to light from the perspective of Hindu- minds and not the western-minds as they have no clue how the brilliant Ancient Rishi-Muni sampradaya, and had perfected the processing of thoughts strict adherence to master by the sheer strength of their brilliant conception and eager minds.

  • @alokKumar-hg6oy
    @alokKumar-hg6oy Před 3 lety +9

    Raj vedam should have been seen by indian government.

  • @PVSBhargav
    @PVSBhargav Před 2 lety +2

    While reading the book "Early Indians" by Tony joseph. I had quite a lot of questions about the authenticity of the claims that were made in the book. This talk has addressed quite a lot of red flags in that book. Done my research and found that there are a lot of masked content and improper interpretations of the data from different sources, and now I am suggesting a lot of my friends to not buy such books with false claims and even if you did, please do your research before believing the claims made in the books. I'm very thankful to have stumbled upon this video.

    • @rakeshraghu7656
      @rakeshraghu7656 Před rokem

      Atleast we can puncture holes in the claims like they are moolanivasi aryan/brahmins captured them by telling thier own data that they came from iran by 7000Bc and aryan came by 1500 bc.even though thier claims are wrong we can puncture thier claims by thier data only. Another is they claim brahmins bought idol worship to tamilians/ south indians ,according to Caldwell there is no cognate for word image/ murthi in tamil but recently they are claiming after success of kantara those are indigenous gods / bhoota which were worshipped before aryans/brahmins came with vedic gods they change thier history like chameleons according to situation we must puncture those things.Aryans invasion Theory atleast in academia is reduced aryan migration but the vicious ideas of the theory is still in circulation for political purpose to fight BJP and they have come with Buddha + basava + ambedkar tripatriarch combinations to suggest forces fighting against brahmincla tyranny ,but reading of ambedkar/ basavanna can destroy the claims.

  • @ShivamKumar-ef1ve
    @ShivamKumar-ef1ve Před 3 lety +6

    Very informative. But, the government hasn't changed or even amended a word in history books. Even NEP isn't clear on correcting the mischief does by NCERT in the past.

  • @mohanasrao
    @mohanasrao Před 3 lety +41

    I am ever so impressed and grateful for A great eye-opener, an all-compassing brilliant presentation. Thanks a million for fully researched nuggets for the uninformed/ill-informed too.

    • @santhakumariamma4443
      @santhakumariamma4443 Před 3 lety

      Let all the bharatians know all these

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      @@santhakumariamma4443 lol 😂😂 Too much bias in his work for example around 1:06:32 the southern indian and northern indian never saw themselves as separate group of people, Which is not true at all. In manu smriti, manu describes a region from himalayas to vidya mountains in central India as Aryavatta (Land of Aryas) and ask people to not visit south of the vidyas.
      So then people who lived south of vidyas are not seen as belonging to same group of people.

    • @aryan.kapoor
      @aryan.kapoor Před 2 lety +7

      @@stalinsampras cope as much as you want, but Manu was himself South Indian 😭

    • @rajeshkandukuri1042
      @rajeshkandukuri1042 Před 2 lety +5

      @@stalinsampras cope as much as u want...there is a sloka in the Bhaghavatham which states that Satyavata Manu, the ancestor of Lord Rama was a Dravidian.
      That saintly king and ruler (king) of the Dravida Countries who was known by the name of SATYAVRATA, at the end of the last kalpa (before the Pralaya) .. received knowledge by service to The Purusha, he indeed was Vaivaswata Manu, the son of Vivaswan, his sons have been proclaimed as the kings, famous as the Ikshvakus.
      Dravida is a regional identity nd not a racial identity😭

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      Fraud

  • @iaanish
    @iaanish Před rokem +2

    Really good research and you had me going till you had your conclusion slide. Glad you proved the claims of Tamil(with all their existing Archeological proof) as inconclusive. You did not use the same scientific temper to prove or disprove claim of eminence of Sanskrit in Indian culture. My personal belief is SamaKritham was celebrated and adopted by Tamils as much as other parts of India. I like the scientific temper you used. Agathiyum and Tholkapiyum are tamil words and have meanings in Tamil, please explore these as well. Loved your presentation.

  • @ganeshdeo
    @ganeshdeo Před 3 lety +6

    Superb talk by Raj Vedam ji

  • @premprakashjauhari2751
    @premprakashjauhari2751 Před 7 měsíci +2

    I will like Mr. Raj Vedam to write a comprehensive book on ancient India and all wrong narratives associated with it.

  • @peacockLife
    @peacockLife Před 7 měsíci +2

    the -isms which divide, the west is so divided that from time to time i have to come back to ancient Indian history for a breath of wholesome beingness.. Marxism is a threat to the long term survival of humanity. happy that i had the opportunity to work on the SLC gene.. that was an exciting project..

  • @QuaaludeCharlie
    @QuaaludeCharlie Před 2 lety +3

    Dr.Raj Vedantam, You must keep going with this investigation , rather than Language , We need artifacts from the sea . Thank You :) QC

  • @rkssah
    @rkssah Před 3 lety +10

    This is really excellent research and lot of analysis put together. Thanks for invaluable education, at least now we should identify ourselves with our true history and facts.

  • @sreenivasulureddyp546
    @sreenivasulureddyp546 Před 3 lety +9

    Extraordinary factual content sir, keep doing it 🙏

  • @sudeeprajkirodian6499
    @sudeeprajkirodian6499 Před 3 lety +2

    1.38.43 minutes of enlightenment. Really blessed to hear your talk

  • @katyarkhukri7003
    @katyarkhukri7003 Před 2 lety +4

    Shocking ng to hear about manipulations in keezhadi excavations. How much religious ideology can affect objectivity

  • @lalitmulay2851
    @lalitmulay2851 Před 3 lety +11

    Raj Vedam sir needs 21 gun salutes . what a deep study and research . mind blowing

  • @yogiyogi3677
    @yogiyogi3677 Před 3 lety +11

    Dr. Raj Vedam, thank you for the amazing research work and this easy to understand talk.
    I would like to know, why so many languages were formed in India? What was the basic reason?

  • @kohlersudesh3726
    @kohlersudesh3726 Před 2 lety +18

    Dr. Raj Vedam, it is a humongous task, to decode and debunk western, leftist thoughts with multi dimensional data. Hope more Indian scholars probe deeply into these claim and set right the Indian History and be taught every schools in India,..

  • @Rohit12fs
    @Rohit12fs Před rokem +2

    Ultimate........................

  • @judek-cj7xl
    @judek-cj7xl Před 11 měsíci +2

    If we do need to be respected... Its the wealth that needs to be generated or transffered from India. Power today is to control mass thoughts. You r going the right way.... Friend dont get lost in noise... Only people here can ensure that

  • @kohlersudesh3726
    @kohlersudesh3726 Před 2 lety +4

    Very scholarly approach, debunking earlier distortion of the History. We need to replace evaluate, what are in history books and update to the truth!

  • @kaushikapatel3862
    @kaushikapatel3862 Před 2 lety +4

    Thank you very much Raj ji for providing us incredible knowledge , we have morden Rishi like you.

  • @philipdawes2661
    @philipdawes2661 Před 2 lety +3

    Superb presentation, thank you.

  • @tomandjerry9516
    @tomandjerry9516 Před 3 lety +10

    Very informative & eye opening 🙏

  • @sarasadiq9470
    @sarasadiq9470 Před 3 lety +3

    Hallo 💖Raj vedam sir💖 .. I love you. I am also a researching student .

  • @NETKINGSHUBHO
    @NETKINGSHUBHO Před 3 lety +5

    excellent talk by Raj Vedam ji

  • @nandhinim2676
    @nandhinim2676 Před 2 lety +4

    Sir thanks for the eye opening lecture. 🙏🏽🙏🏽

  • @manoranjandutta989
    @manoranjandutta989 Před 2 lety +2

    Great synthesis to provide a holistic and science based history of Indic civilization.

  • @nobody..8040
    @nobody..8040 Před 3 lety +7

    Pls, it deserves a documentary...

  • @navaneethamvemula3864
    @navaneethamvemula3864 Před 2 lety +3

    Absolutely brilliant talk

  • @dmajumdar2059
    @dmajumdar2059 Před 3 lety +24

    Brilliant video. We learn a lot from these. Keep going 👍

    • @StarPlanet56789
      @StarPlanet56789 Před 2 lety

      Indian civilization, a Tamil civilization. Land of the Tamils !!!

  • @atul1024
    @atul1024 Před 3 lety +7

    As usual Crystal clear

  • @vagishnaganur3607
    @vagishnaganur3607 Před 3 lety +4

    Great eye opener for all distortion we were exposed to.

  • @Dheepa
    @Dheepa Před rokem +1

    Very interesting ideas. I am so glad that now we are truly beginning to examine our history and unearth our common identity

  • @hellogamer95
    @hellogamer95 Před 5 měsíci +2

    History text books need to be changed. Indian History definitely dates back more than we know

  • @saffronpanda1735
    @saffronpanda1735 Před 3 lety +13

    Such a mesmerising talk. Raj Vedam ji has systematically demolished Aryan Dravidian narratives.

    • @mscreationworks5787
      @mscreationworks5787 Před 3 lety +2

      He is RSS or BJP member telling lies

    • @saffronpanda1735
      @saffronpanda1735 Před 3 lety +9

      @@mscreationworks5787 we would appreciate if you pointout the flaws in his argument rather than accusing him as RSS or BJP. 🙂

    • @mscreationworks5787
      @mscreationworks5787 Před 3 lety +2

      @@saffronpanda1735 Go to this video and see the hard works of him to tell the lies

    • @mscreationworks5787
      @mscreationworks5787 Před 3 lety +2

      @@saffronpanda1735 The Rakhigarhi Male skeleton DNA has more similarities with Irula people in the Nilgiri mountains of the kerala and Tamil Nadu

    • @saffronpanda1735
      @saffronpanda1735 Před 3 lety +5

      @@mscreationworks5787 first of all, it's laughable to say that a gene matches a tribe 😁 genetics doesn't work that way. Even if it does, so what? What are you suggesting?

  • @dasmahodya4799
    @dasmahodya4799 Před 3 lety +4

    Sir please accept my humble obeisance.

  • @arunpatel4029
    @arunpatel4029 Před 2 lety +4

    wonderful knowledge , superb presentation and ...........

  • @manashbarthakur8881
    @manashbarthakur8881 Před 3 lety +3

    So beautifully expxplained

  • @wcfields7354
    @wcfields7354 Před 3 lety +7

    Wow. Why do these ideas try to suppress India history. I believe India’s history to be the absolute truth of man kinds past.

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      lol 😂😂 Too much bias in his work for example around 1:06:32 he says that southern indian and northern indian never saw themselves as separate group of people, Which is not true at all. In manu smriti, manu describes a region from himalayas to vidya mountains in central India as Aryavatta (Land of Aryas) and ask people to not visit south of the vidyas.
      So then people who lived south of vidyas are not seen as belonging to same group of people.

    • @aryan.kapoor
      @aryan.kapoor Před 2 lety +1

      @@stalinsampras bullshit Manu was himself south Indian. Stop embarrassing yourself 😂🤣

    • @stalinsampras
      @stalinsampras Před 2 lety

      @Sai B U fool if manusmriti is edited by some outsiders why stop at manusmriti, they can edit vedas too and make them the way they want.
      Lol idiot know this there was no one copy of manu smriti to edit, during British rule 40 million copies of manu smriti in india

  • @tresajessygeorge210
    @tresajessygeorge210 Před 3 lety +4

    THANK YOU DR. RAJAVEDAM...!!!

  • @mihirshah7695
    @mihirshah7695 Před 2 lety +2

    This is a extremely informative video.
    Appreciate the work. 😎

  • @saratchandraprayaga6930
    @saratchandraprayaga6930 Před 3 lety +4

    As of today there are nearly five generations of a family in India. The first of these would have been of the knowledge of some of our ancient history but were too busy making a survival from the rut left from independence. The next are the confused lot knowing not whether to believe his ancestors knowledge or what he started learning in Convents. The rest of the generation hardly care or know anything of this ancient Indian history as no one influenced them and were getting corrupted with western ideas. I would very much like to know demography of the types of youngsters watching such videos, if any!!

  • @krishnareddysaripalli7361

    Good explanation. Thankyou.

  • @rahulpsr94
    @rahulpsr94 Před 3 lety +5

    Detailed review about Tamil ❤️👌

  • @raghunadharao9973
    @raghunadharao9973 Před 3 lety +2

    Bhaasha is a Sanskrit word. The language is called "Nudi" in Telugu.
    Most of us do not know the difference between Andhra Language, Telugu Language and Sanskrit.
    Andhra language is a combination of Telugu and Sanskrit.
    Sanskrit is a wonderful language. The vocabulary in Sanskrit is infinite.
    Telugu is vowel ending "Ajanta" language ..no language could beat and surpass Telugu in beauty.
    Telugu is considered Greater than Sanskrit in this regard.
    For example to know the feature of Ajanta language
    "రాముడు ఒకడు ఉన్నాడు అని అనుకున్నాను అని అనుకున్నావేమొ......."
    can be written in one stroke as
    "రాముడొకడున్నాడననుకున్నానననుకున్నావేమొ................................"
    This can be written without stopping anywhere in a single piece.
    Hundreds of thousands of words can be written in a single sentence.
    If you add infinite vocabulary to it (that vocabulary belongs to Sanskrit) it is even more wonderful.
    This Wonder is the Andhra language that we think is "Telugu" today.
    Example:
    In English In Sanskrit In Telugu(classical) In Andhra
    Language Bhaasha Nudi Bhaasha
    Wheel Chakram Gaanu/Tiragali Chakramu
    Mind Manas ullamu Manasu

  • @rajashekarka4286
    @rajashekarka4286 Před 2 lety +3

    A great, grand n good subject analysis with the available data ..... Astroarcheology, etc ......
    Regarding Aryans invasion, settlements, transfer of literature by them from central Asia to India and downsouth the Indian peninsula pushing the Dravidians .... Doesn't hold good ... If so where is the archiological evidence of literature in central Asia which is brought by Aryans to indian ..

  • @ashoknairkunnath8249
    @ashoknairkunnath8249 Před 10 měsíci +2

    Great work!
    Many Thanks.

  • @santhoshrider9474
    @santhoshrider9474 Před 2 lety +3

    I want a video on Vakkiya(vakya) Panchangam and Thirukkanitha (Drik) Panchangam with scientific explanations. That would be great.

  • @Galaxy2431
    @Galaxy2431 Před 3 lety +7

    Dr Raj Vedam, you are BRILLIANT!! My best wishes to keep doing such scholarly work.

  • @srikanthvudya8773
    @srikanthvudya8773 Před 3 lety +4

    Really a great, intellectual video

  • @ms55761
    @ms55761 Před 3 lety +11

    Raj vedam always presents facts with deep understanding of the subject. Always wait for his presentations.thanks

  • @umakantjoshi3314
    @umakantjoshi3314 Před rokem +3

    Excellent explanation