Everything Wrong With Frosty the Snowman
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 12. 2020
- Merry Christmas! And what better way to celebrate the season than sinning one of the classics? Here's everything wrong with Frosty the Snowman. Happy Birthday!
•TVSins website: www.tvsins.net •
•Channels•
--CinemaSins: / @cinemasins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy and Chris about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book - Zábava
Teacher: "I've hired a magician"
TVSins: "On a teacher's salary?"
Narrator: "Now, this was the worst magician in the world"
Me: "Yes, on a teacher's salary"
You just made my night, THANK YOU VERY MUCH!!!
I said that in my mind too.😄
He was the worst magician. So basically the cheapest
I cannot believe after all these years, it’s come to this. Even frosty has sins
No movie is without sin.
Be honest, do you think frosty the snowman song is annoying?
@@christianparrish6647 no
@@ScottKorin including the princess bride somehow
@@braydendidden721 when you're older, it's actually annoying.
Frosty: You took everything from me
Olaf: I don’t even know who you are
"What's a traffic light?" "'New Yorkers."
As a native of the state, I can confirm 😂
As a Floridian who now has to deal with them as they all flock down here I can also confirm
I live in LA and this is true
I'm a Long Islander, there seems to be a 3 second grace period when it comes to traffic lights.
In Maryland; people don't care.
It never occurred to me to think Frosty the Snowman could even have 'spoilers'. I feel so unimaginative.
it’s impressive how the kids built a perfectly round snowman like that, everytime I tried to build a snowman it was always not smooth, covered in dirt, and has one arm bigger than the other
Well it is a cartoon
I am more concerned about how they gave him legs with a gap between them supporting that massive ball of snow that is his body.
I was expecting an outtake where frosty screams "I'm melting" using the wicked witch of the west's voice.
*OPEN A WINDOW! IM DYING!*
I usually don't like the videos with this guy's voice because I prefer Jeremy's more sarcastic and quick banter, but in this one he really stepped up the comedy and pretty much took the distinction away from me. Very well done.
I was going to say the same thing.
Fun Fact: Frosty the Snowman was the beta version of "The Incredible Melting Man".
Stupid
@Jonah Bryan wow. Brutal retort! Must’ve taken you forever to come up with that one!
@@jaystreet46 bruh you say that like "stupid" is a good insult
Hinkle: “And just what are you going to do about it?”
“Santa: *”I’ll hUnT yOu DoWn AnD gUt YOu lIkE A FiSh!!”*
I was pissing my pants with laughter on that part.
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!!
This is canon now.
These are always the best part but that one was extra good.
"merry christmas ya filthy animal "
You bring up the fact that Karen is wearing a dress while it's winter, yet not the fact that there are kids wearing shorts
Yeah but guys do that.
@@kaisercortex4115 not when theres 2 d
Feet of snow!
@@kaisercortex4115 my brother is the only one I know who does that.
@@chandlerwright5460 my brother and my ex husband both would still wear shorts lol
What about the other girl not having a coat on at all?
What about the fact that Karen said she'd go as long as she was back in time for supper?
The girl clearly has no sense of distance or time
Ikr 😂😂😂
I like that the cartoon glosses over this kid having to watch Frosty melt to death in the greenhouse.
She was sobbing over his corpse. What else does she need to do?
My son was crying his eyes out when he finally realized what happened to frosty
Frosty: Don't look, Karen. Don't look.
Karen: *Looks*
Or the fact that a grown man blew out a campfire which was the only thing keeping a young child from freezing to death.
Or what about the fact that putting the hat on the puddle of water magically transforms him back to normal?
I can only assume the lack of pants is due to Karen feeling oppressed by them and making her wear pants goes against her constitutional rights to be pantless and if you challenge her she will demand the manager and then call the cops claiming she is being threatened
"I hAvE tHe RiGhT tO wEaR wHat I wAnT"
DOWN WITH THE PANTSRIARCHY
And then she'll freeze to death and another Karen will come to take her place, ignoring all the people who have frozen to death due to not being able to have warm clothing
😂😂😂
Well said my friend.......well said
Even as a child I wondered how Karen didn't freeze to death going to the North Pole so under dressed...not to mention she traveled there in a refrigerated box car...lol! 🤣🥶☃️
She was warmed by her plans to talk to the manager.
@@jb888888888 Lmao 😂
Do you know what wardrobe malfunction there was? Cause I don’t.
And then one year, it stopped snowing on Christmas, preventing Frosty from coming into existance. Global Warming has claimed another soul.
It's snowing in several places today. New York City could get up to 14 inches of snow.
Oh the folly of posting on videos before you see the weather report of the day it's actually being posted for normal people.
If global warming is real why is New York supposed to get at least 12 inches?
@@dtell3424 *inhales* uuuuuuuuuuugggggggghhhhhh
Nope, he now lives in your local grocery store freezer.
@@dtell3424 idk, but I can tell you this: it hasn't snowed in my town because of it. Edit: OF COURSE it would snow right after I say that. Oh well, I'm happy about it
I was going to remark that where I grew up (Maryland), girls weren't allowed to wear pants to school unless they were under a dress until I was junior in high school (1970-1971), but she should have been wearing pants under her dress.
You know what's REALLY wrong with Frosty? It wasn't even originally intended to be a Christmas story (please don't hate me). Frosty was a snowman yes, but that didn't automatically make him a Christmas decoration. And I know what everyone would probably say here: "but Ghosty, Jimmy Durante said at the beginning of the special that this takes place on Christmas Eve, there was also the presence of Santa and the greenhouse full of poinsettias where Frosty was cruelly melted to death (seeing Karen crying over his lifeless puddle always got me as a kid, not gonna lie) and they even finished it with Frosty saying "I'll be back on Christmas Day!"".First off, by implying that he would be back on Christmas Day he may as well have said "I'll be back tomorrow" (seriously, think about it) and secondly, the whole Christmas thing was blatantly forced in order to automatically make this a Christmas special. Frosty has about as much to do with Christmas as Jingle Bells and Sleigh Ride, which are also meant for the season of winter, not Christmas.
Merry Christmas anyway. ⛄
Side note: I've always wondered about that scene at the end myself, with Santa leaving Karen on the roof. Does this mean that he could be brought up on child endangerment charges? No one is above the law, Mr. Kringle, so why did you leave the kid above her villaige?
Totally agree. The song came out in the 50's and as far as I can remember (singing it my head) it doesnt mention Christmas
@@justincovert6943 Nope. In the original version he said "I'll be back again some day", but in the special he said, " I'll be back on Christmas Day", which was literally the very next day. On top of that, Frosty was already aware of how freakishly warm it was that year, did he really want to melt himself all over again? I could tell just by watching him that he was kind of dopey, but I didn't think he was THAT dopey.
@@ghostchaser1631 Frosty was voiced by Jackie Vernon, a popular comedian of the 1960s. Check out his material from Ed Sullivan, and you'll see, he was just that dopey. And considerably more bashful than when he played Frosty.
That was wrong of Santa, but I'm pretty sure that he has some form of diplomatic immunity, granted to him by the United Nations.
The majority of Christmas songs are actually winter songs. If they aren't singing about Jesus, they are singing about winter.
4:27 on the leap fog sin, you forgot that the same ginger kid leaps over frosty 2 times in a row.
I never noticed that 😂😂😂😂
I'd remove a sin for them making the main child protagonist a girl, rather than a boy. That was really rare before 1969.
Why are these kids in school with 2 feet of snow on the ground - *laughs in Canadian*
On a Teachers salary?!?! - *laughs in Canadian*
Isn't " *laughs in Canadian* " racist? It sounds racist to me.
Wait, Frosty the snowman is in Canada?
Wait, what language is Canadian??
And growing up in Upstate NY, 2 feet of snow was just fine for school. Cinema Sins team is in Tennessee, so I guess that sounds bad or something. The real winter problem was cold temps and blizzards. If it was just heavy-ish snow, we walked our butts thru the 3ft of snow to school. If the temp was below a certain threshold, we got to stay home. Or if it was to be a legendary blizzard, we stayed home.
But I remember one time, the snow was INSANE and they didn't close schools. They waited until we got all the way to school soaking wet, coated in snow, and freezing, then an hour or 2 into the school day they declared that the amount of snow expected to fall was too much and we had to turn around still all wet and cold and freezing, and walk back home! Its been like 15yrs, but if I knew who that superintendent was right now, I would mail him a bag of dog poop.
But why would you be in school on Christmas Eve and Day?
@@Klm49 Canadian English is more similar to British English, especially when it comes to spelling. We also have our own terms and dialect. There is also Newfoundland English, look it up haha.
Could also refer to Canadian French which is completely seperate from European French. If you ever look at subtitle and language options, you will notice a lot of the times there is two french. "French" and "Canadian French." While there is a lot of similarities, there is a lot of differences. When I took a trip to Montreal, the person in my hostel from France said it is easier for him to speak English to the bilingual people than to speak French as they are too different.
I went to Elementary and Middle School in Winnipeg and High School in Alberta. Both cities would keep schools open when the Wind Chill was -50 degrees C (-58F). I've gone to school with snow at my knees.
I would say that is more of a "MASSIVE night sun" than a "bruce almighty moon".
Can someone tell me what the well-documented issue with the girl's clothes is? I googled it and just found a bunch of people confused they were all wearing shorts.
She's not wearing pants. Karen 's gotta be extra
Her mittens when pointing look phallic
@@Sarahonwheels Does the clip he chose show the phallic mittens? I rewatched it, and I _guess_ it could very vaguely look phallic, but it doesn’t seem so obvious that a bunch of people would notice...
There's a frame where her dress comes up and she looks completely naked underneath even though later in the movie she is wearing red shorts/some type of garment underneath. I had to google it also.
I looked it up too, and found the same shit you did. I came to the comments to find my answer.
Sooooo, phallic mittens, no pants, and red shorts is apparently the answer. Okay...😕🤔😕🤔 I still don't feel like that's it.
TvSins - "Why are the kids in school with 2 feet of snow?"
Me - Hahahahaha Southerns! There has to be enough snow to lose a toddler before schools cancelled where I'm from
My school only closed if there was black ice or if we got into the negative teens, not counting for windchill of course
Where I'm from, the concern was less about the snow itself and more about the condition of the roads. If they were dangerously icy, then we'd have a snow day, or perhaps a one or two hour delay, while the city laid down salt and cinders.
5:17
He’s literally responding to the last sin you just gave.
I’m actually impressed that TVsins managers to criticize legitimate problems with the movie instead of just cracking pointless trendy jokes every few seconds.
Fun fact: Frosty the Snowman was animated by the studio of the Great grandfather of Anime and Manga, Osamu Tezuka!
Does that make Frosty the Snowman an anime!
Rankin and Bass knew what they were doing when they hired this man.
@@everlenaoliver6912Another Oliver
Show requires us to believe children built convincing arms and legs on their snowman
Do everything wrong with Rudolph the red nosed reindeer.
I love that TV movie, but I'm sure it has sins. DO IT, TVSINS!!!
@@Eeveeismypatronas same!
I think they did already, or maybe that was an Honest Trailer.
@@timwoods2852 No, that was a Fanmade version of Cinemasins.
DO IIIIIT. It deserves it. Just as much as Rudolph going postal
4:13 "Person distracted by a curvy passerby, runs into something"
Did... did he just call Frosty curvy?
Frosty: You cold Karen? Well that's a silly question.
TVSins: Frosty would be a genius at TVSins.
Everything wrong with SpongeBob Christmas who please
Yes
Mugman 😅🤣
And Family Guy: Road To The North Pole
YES!!!!!!!!
I am pretty sure the magician didnt even throw the hat away in the first place. It looks like the rabbit just took off with it and then Karen snatched it. I mean, morally speaking he probably should have left the hat with Frosty after seeing it bring him to life, but legally speaking what happened was theft.
I've always loved how the antagonist says: "BI-ZEE, BI-ZEE, BI-ZEE!!!". 🤗
Bizee, bizee, BUZZOO-O-O-O!!!
That was actually his voice actor Billy Dee wolfe comic stick repeating words, comically
That was Billy DeWolf comic stick he would reputation of words and phrases and say those comically
2:51 anyone else have no idea what he's talking about
Apparently theres a brief flash of her clothes all the ay up making her look naked despite her having like red shorts underneath later in the movie
Some say when she points, the shape of her mitten looks phalic.
Like Jessica rabbit , she flashes skin under her jacket up to where her bellybutton would be ..
I didn’t know but after watching this sin video and rewatching frosty the snowman I figured it out
“Why are they they in school when there’s 2 feet of snow?!”
*laughs in canadian*
No sin for a grown ass man following an elementary school girl past state and country lines to rob her?
Actually, according to the TV special, Frosty's Winter Wonderland, Frosty can live without his hat. Love is shared between Frosty and his wife, Crystal, and their love sustains eachother every year.
2 feet of snow cancels school? Someone needs to tell Minnesota that...
and Montana. and the Dakota's.
Please. They never canceled school. We were two hours late.
@@TherealDanielleNelson I felt like the diocese was purposely being cruel cancelling school one to three hours after public schools cancelled
@@dagonvaldez2878 Aww. :-(
I only remember once when we didn't go to school. We lived in a rural part of the country and our road was one of the last roads to get plowed if we got snow, and one day it was so deep that my mom couldn't even get down the road to go to work so my dad called in saying that the road was unsafe for the bus to go down.
No sin for the freakishly low voiced kid who suggested the name "Ruth" when they were trying to decide a name for Frosty? That always bothered me.
😆😂😂
*O A T M E A L*
I always thought that kid said 'Bruce' but yeah, his suddenly lowered voice caught me off guard.
Sin 41 should have been preceded by at least ten sins for the scene in which Frosty tells the kids that he hates thermometers, because when they go up, the temperature rises.
I was six or seven years old when I saw this on TV and even I was like: *”Pfft... WHAT?!”*
Um, I think that was the joke, that Frosty thought that. . . oh never mind.
One thing you missed, by 1969 virtually no railroads still used steam engines.
And one sin you made, the train was on a siding to let the express pass. That is why it looks like the express went behind the train.
Oh, so that's how multiple trains can travel on the same track at the same time.
6:18 Fuck the fact that he blew out a campfire, I'd sin that for blowing out a campfire, KEEPING A CHILD FROM FREEZING TO DEATH
Another sin: The train that Karen, Frosty, and Hocus get on whistles three times before it pulls forward. If an engineer blows the horn or whistle three times, it means that they are going to back up, not pull forward.
The "Happy Birthday" part always puzzled me, even as a kid. None of the kids mentioned that December 24 was their birthday. Yes, December 25 is a birthday (or, at least, a birthday observed), but unless a Christmas special involves telling the story of the Nativity, the birthday boy in question doesn't show up, so the fact that it's his birthday isn't relevant to the story.
It's Frosty's birthday. He was just born. But why would he wish himself a Happy Birthday? Ding.
Also, never, ever mock Jimmy Durante. He was not just a legend, he was one of the nicest guys in show business. A dozen Dings for that, alone.
I saw on Wikipedia that when this cartoon was made, it was indeed common for schools to still have class on Christmas Eve Day.
I live in a town with Grill, Restaurant, Hotel AND Mechanic.
Hope this means you'll be doing Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer
gosh, I hate that overplayed piece of shit.
Can we talk about how frosty drops off the girl on the roof !!!!. How is she supposed to get in her house
santa/frosty dont understand that everyone cant enter houses through chimneys.
@@josephdedrick9337 Yeah, she’s gonna get frostbite up there !
I still hope there was a ladder nearby!
@@yoshig5278 spoilers: there’s not.
Do a Super Mario jump off the roof and onto the ground. If Mario can survive a fall from an airship, then Karen can survive a fall from the roof.
0:47 someone didn’t grow up in Minnesota...
So Frosty knows what a thermometer is, but not a traffic light? Frosty's sentient knowledge is quite arbitrary.
Please do Everything Wrong With A Charlie Brown Christmas
Yes
That would anger me so much...but deep down I am wanting it too!
No, some things are sacred.
@@johnharris6655
No movie is without sin
@@insertmemorableusernameher6795 Charlie Brown Christmas is. If you knew the history behind the production, what they made with such a small budge is a miracle.
I love this i couldn't have asked for anything better for Christmas.
I like streaming and Blu ray and DVD's. But there was something magical about being a kid and waiting for these specials to come on.
4:32 - I mean....he isn't wrong. But can you really blame us for how drivers in new york can be though?
either way, I can't laugh at how true and accurate this was.
Accidentally exposing your deck and balls. ROFLMAO. Damn this video was hilarious I am trying so hard not to laugh out loud in my office. Kids sled has a propulsion system.
Everything Wrong With “A Charlie Brown Christmas”
I'm surprised they didn't point out how the magical hat was able to differentiate between the snow for frosty and the snow on the ground if it couldn't than that means that frosty should have grown in size untill all snow that's connected to the hat has been absorbed by frost being as tall as the marshmallow man from ghost busters and if the hat can differentiate between the snow used to make frosty and the snow on the ground HOW is it conscious did it somehow see the general shape of frosty and thought "hmm ok I'll add fingers and legs" how smart is this hat in this scenario because it clearly can both understand the general shape of a human but also can replicate body parts and use them properly it also gave speech to frosty so It can hear people and understand what there saying and understands there meanings
All in all this hats powers doesn't make sence
Frosty carrying Karen would do far more damage to her since he is pure snow.
You have no idea how much I enjoyed sending this to my kids because I made ALL OF THESE POINTS every year! Thanks for the validation!
okay for people wondering about the animation weirdness at 2:57: you can see it in the actual animation but basically her dress blows up and she isn't wearing anything underneath bc apparently the animators were incapable of animating pants
It was handrawn so I can see why.
They must of forgot
Thanks, I was curious
2 things you forgot to point out: there are 2 trains traveling on the same track in opposite directions, and then leaving Karen on the roof at the end.
One thing people seem to miss when they see Professor Hinkle as the villain. IT WAS HIS HAT!! Maybe he did throw it away - it never hit the trash can! He needs his hat to make a living! I'm sorry the kids wanted it to make Frosty come alive - but it still wasn't theirs!
My sentiments exactly.
Today, the only surviving cast members are Suzanne Davidson (who took over voicing Karen from June Foray beginning with the 3rd broadcast), and Greg Thomas as the two unnamed red haired boys
This is my favorite holiday special
As someone born in and who lived in Maine a snowy state all my life, schools can very easily send kids to school with two feet of snow, it takes a special snow storm to cancel school, if the winds aren't blowing and visibility isn't ruined and the snow isn't up past your knees, school isn't canceled
But generally we did have winter break for about two weeks around Christmas, so they should have the day off not because it's snowing but because holidays
Sin for you for making me look up what you're talking about with the girl's outfit.
I’m curious what he was talking about!
@@holasnic3937 Apparently there's a scene where her coat flies up and people think it's a nude scene because they don't know what clothing is or how cheap Rankin Bass were and how they would definitely put her in a skintight snow suit to save a dollar.
hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/1963-model-on-slopes-of-courchevel-france-wearing-pink-ski-pants-and-pink-and-red-checked-sweater-both-by-petri-1544221276.jpg Clearly what the crappy animators were going for.
"You hired a magician on a teacher's salary?" He is a BAD magician. He was probably cheap.
Did he actually just ignore Karen saying "the head is the most difficult part, ask anyone"...
As a child, I used to watch the part where Frosty comes to life and says Happy Birthday over and over again because I thought it was so funny
My daughter thought "No money, no ticket" was the funniest thing ever.
0:45 Two feet of snow? Haha you've never lived in northern areas have you.
As we get older we do notice certain things but SO WHAT?!? When you are a child you just enjoy and don’t PICK-A-PART a great classic like this. If anything……the imperfections ADD to it. LOVE YOU, FROSTY!!!!! ❄️❄️❄️❄️
Now that we have Frozen, let's make it actually useful and have Elsa make it so Frosty doesn't melt just like she did for Olaf. Well, unless she has bias towards one snowman over another.
Since that movie ran on Protagonist-Centered Morality, that's totally possible.
This... might be the best TV Sins to date.
Couldn't frosty have just rolled karen into the green house and stayed outside until she recovered. Lol
You missed one - the kids made a snowman using two big snow balls, and somehow before the magic happened, the snowman turned into a humanoid figure with arms and legs.
Another missed one: When the kids named his Frosty, you missed Roll Credits.
I've noticed the glitching scarf since I was like five years old, and it still bothers me to this day. :D And how Santa just left Karen on the roof of her house. How did she even get down? :D
The window on the roof, probably. It still would be dangerous with all the ice, but she would probably be able to knock on it, at least.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who noticed that the special makes Professor Hinkle out to be a villain just because he wants HIS OWN HAT.
I was expecting a "He Survives This" when Hinkle jumped off the train, plus how was Frosty able to walk into the train station just fine without melting but can't last in a greenhouse?
No reference to Woodland Critter Christmas when they find the Animals having Christmas in the woods "Hail Satan"
5:35 It could be a side track for a train to stop on and then cycles back onto the track after another train passes.
The next one will probably be called: Everything Wrong With The Song “Frosty The P*rvert”.
The "box car" Karen refers to is INDEED what is known as a "reefer" It also has another meaning that "Karen's" ALSO know about.
She's an elementary school student in the 60s. They weren't allowed to wear pants to school yet.
The bonus round reminds me so much of the button consistency from "Death Has A Shadow".
Seasonal greetings from Amsterdam
Okay that bonus round genuinely made me laugh. That was great.
Shout out to CZcams putting an ad 1:26 in to the video after showing 2 unskippable 9 second pre roll ads that I know for a fucking fact aren't being paid to be there under the new terms of service
I've noticed that on some scenes when the kids are building Frosty, the fence from the background isn't visible.
They really gonna do my boy Frosty like this?
7:24 Well......There was one special where they made a snow bride for Frosty and he gave her flowers and that act brought her to life, then Jack Frost stole Frosty's hat, then the bride kissed Frosty while he was lifeless but he was sprung to life by the kiss so really does he ACTUALLY need the hat always?
0:46 Christmas vacations and snow days are a relatively new thing, starting in the 80s or 90s. Kids weren't so coddled in the old days.
2:57
Ok, now I’m curious. What weirdness?
@@dragonkitty5578 oh.
Please excuse me while I cleanse my eyes with bleach then go pray.
@@dragonkitty5578 what a horrible day to have eyes
Holy crap the quality of this is insanely good. How in the world did they manage not to screw up the transfer? I've seen a lot of really terribly preserved animation from this era that they tried to upscale to blu ray and this... If you pause it it looks like you are looking right at the cell it is amazing.
Sinning Frosty? Have you no soul?!
And there's no sin removal, too...
Speaking in my professional capacity as an old(er) person - snow used to have to be much deeper for there to be a snow day. You kids and "snow day because there's a dusting!" In my day there were over a foot of snow and we still went to school! And we liked it!
We had snow days when it was only snowing in part of the school district. It hardly ever snows at my house.
Dubbing the Grinch over Santa was the best. Nuf said.
That was fun! Aaron is getting VERY good at this!
Oh my poor childhood! End clips still a treasure as usual
OMG I'm a Magician and YES, when I goof up, the kids are in hysterics and really enjoy it. It's called the Magician in Trouble and obviously the writers of FtS did NO research!
A bad magician is basically a clown, so you can't lose.
And to think, there is LORE centered around these old Christmas specials! (Seriously, you should cover the rest of the old Rankin/Bass specials)