Unused Achievements [Cut Content] - The Binding of Isaac Repentance

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 24. 08. 2024
  • In this video I'm going to showcase all 24 unused achievements in The Binding of Isaac Repentance. Some of these were never finished, while some were cut from Antibirth. It's quite possible that some may make it in Repentance one day!
    The full list of unused achievements in the video is as follows:
    0:31 - Apple of Sodom
    0:59 - Beth's Heart
    1:59 - BFF Baby
    2:15 - Blank Bombs
    2:37 - Turbo!
    3:09 - Ghost Babel
    3:46 - Dimension Red
    4:04 - Divide and Conquer
    4:42 - Donkey's Jawbone
    5:22 - Duplex Baby
    5:41 - Edith
    6:20 - Evil Charm
    6:47 - Illusion Heart
    7:11 - Lot Baby
    7:28 - Pawn Baby
    7:46 - Psy Fly
    8:04 - Rune of Fehu
    8:26 - Rune of Gebo
    8:48 - Rune of Ingwaz
    9:26 - Rune of Kenaz
    9:47 - Rune of Othala
    10:09 - Rune of Sowilo
    10:42 - Salt Shaker
    11:06 - Salty Baby
    Join my Discord: / discord
    Follow me on Twitter: / isaacguruyt
    Support me on Patreon: / isaacguru
    #thebindingofisaac #tboi #repentance
  • Hry

Komentáře • 730

  • @IsaacGuru
    @IsaacGuru  Před 3 lety +365

    Post-upload notes:
    1) It turns out there's another achievement stored in the main folder that was left unused, for an item called "Keeper's Rope". The popup for it can be seen here - i.imgur.com/7zRbrm1.png

    • @Mooshi_Mooshi
      @Mooshi_Mooshi Před 3 lety +33

      transcendence already exists, maybe that’s why it went unused

    • @PaperMario
      @PaperMario Před 3 lety +26

      @@Mooshi_Mooshi im guessing it was probably something related to the strawman item, probably a floating hanging keeper instead of a grounded keeper.

    • @Flowery0
      @Flowery0 Před 3 lety +2

      Maybe fly orbital+ flying

    • @RealFurSwapChara
      @RealFurSwapChara Před 2 lety +2

      Hey, I have a take on divide and conquer. I think it could have been based on what you said, but red locusts could have also worked, with abyss being a pocket active. you'd start with some red locusts as well, with my take on it.
      edit: pawn baby could have had an effect similar to the bishop enemies.

    • @sablesalt
      @sablesalt Před rokem +1

      I think this wouldn't be a new item but just an alter to the transendance unlock itself since keepers are associated with Isaac's dad and the hanging keepers are of course an implication of something that may have happened after he left as it is normal for friends and family to be informed of such event's.
      That and how in the game flight is associated with moving from the moral world and isaac hearing his dad in beast ending since isaac's soul still lingers on earth post death as implied by death certificate and isaac's tomb.
      Though of course isaac imagines what will happen after he dies as he likely doesn't literally linger as he thinks he will since the game is more or less a psa to tell people to be caring for one another in life because we don't know what happens after death.

  • @Flygoniaks
    @Flygoniaks Před 3 lety +1210

    It should be mentioned that "Blank Bombs" were likely a reference to _Enter the Gungeon,_ where "Blanks" were used in place of bombs and cleared enemy bullets.

    • @alonso1841
      @alonso1841 Před 3 lety +50

      I am fan if the both games, it be realy cool

    • @christophertyler7509
      @christophertyler7509 Před 3 lety +7

      Yeah, I figured.

    • @multicatkid
      @multicatkid Před 3 lety +31

      Well enter the gungeon is crossing over with four souls so maybe we’ll see them in repentance later too

    • @cloudy772
      @cloudy772 Před 3 lety +6

      @@multicatkid
      That’s not confirmed

    • @atendentedomarket7545
      @atendentedomarket7545 Před 3 lety +11

      I was hoping they would add some EtG easter egg to this dlc.

  • @yasscraftx21._.
    @yasscraftx21._. Před 3 lety +689

    That "You unlocked Edith" would've been on of my fav things to see in repentance

    • @toan.2764
      @toan.2764 Před 3 lety +38

      same but that psy fly should be locked away as we cant have both robo fly and psy fly for free at the same time

    • @FrostyTheSnowPickle
      @FrostyTheSnowPickle Před 3 lety +33

      @@toan.2764 Psy Fly is getting nerfed, unfortunately. So it won’t be as OP anymore.

    • @Quantzzz420
      @Quantzzz420 Před 3 lety +3

      The runes tho:(

    • @WitherLele
      @WitherLele Před 3 lety +7

      Edith got reworked as t. Forgotten

    • @toan.2764
      @toan.2764 Před 3 lety +17

      @@WitherLele Uh any confirmation, It's only thought to be as i'm aware

  • @erikoliver1332
    @erikoliver1332 Před 3 lety +1442

    Beth's heart was going to allow other characters to use Beth's soul heart mechanic

    • @shybandit521
      @shybandit521 Před 3 lety +94

      Like a dark bum for soul hearts instead of red hearts and instead of random drops after random number of hearts, every 6 hearts it does something specific.

    • @springfox4124
      @springfox4124 Před 3 lety +12

      But ??? With that item?

    • @shybandit521
      @shybandit521 Před 3 lety +46

      @@springfox4124 I doubt it would activate your active item I feel like it would give you a full ring of wisps

    • @plotylty
      @plotylty Před 3 lety +23

      By the charge bars connected to it and the 6 levels of animation i'm pretty sure you're right. You would be able to spend soul hearts as charge

    • @jebacpenis
      @jebacpenis Před 3 lety +5

      @@springfox4124 red hearts?

  • @Xilore25
    @Xilore25 Před 3 lety +105

    *You unlocked Ultra Derillium*
    A horrible chill goes down your spine.

  • @staswalle
    @staswalle Před 3 lety +776

    As for the Lot Baby, that probably had something to do with Edith too, as Lot was Edith's husband in the bible.

    • @Mechadude32
      @Mechadude32 Před 3 lety +119

      Probably her "get all marks on hard mode" unlock, since those are all co-op babies.

    • @mr.cobbweb1624
      @mr.cobbweb1624 Před 3 lety +38

      @@Mechadude32 Except with The Lost, you unlock Godhead when you do that.

    • @lukeblaker8009
      @lukeblaker8009 Před 3 lety +10

      @@mr.cobbweb1624 oh really

    • @soyzsoy
      @soyzsoy Před 2 lety +14

      @@mr.cobbweb1624 It's probably because getting all hard achievements on the lost is really hard to do, especially in repentance, so a co op baby wouldnt be fair. Anyways, godhead got nerfed to were sacred heart is actually better

    • @sablesalt
      @sablesalt Před 2 lety +1

      @@soyzsoy just to follow up on the statement of sacred heart being bettter than godhead now that it got nerfed I want to note that previously godhead could often end up being worse due to shot speed being so high that the aura didnt do much before the tear passed or hit the enemy.
      Overall godhead did tend to be better though so I agree, also with the new buffs to homing tears being more aggressive tracking down enemies sacred heart also gets better while godhead sorta ends up semi nerfed some more, allthough in all honestly it is still a run winning item majority of the time.
      Currently I'd say godhead is about one boss item's dps up away from being on par with sacred heart, Id say the halo+ blue cap+godhead is pretty much same in strength to just halo+sacred heart is what I mean.

  • @coiledAgent
    @coiledAgent Před 3 lety +514

    Heads up: Rune of Fehu, when turning pickups into coins, turns them into their shop price worth of coins (red hearts -> 3 coins, soul hearts -> 5 coins, etc.) It would also turn items into 15 coins. Essentially, it would "sell" anything you used it on. It's also the only rune to have been ported to Repentance proper, except now instead of a rune it's the reversed Hermit card.

    • @parchmentengineer8169
      @parchmentengineer8169 Před 3 lety +44

      I've got a feeling a lot of the runes were reworked into the reverse arcana.

    • @tiddly5
      @tiddly5 Před 3 lety +27

      @@parchmentengineer8169 nah, rune of fehu is the only antibirth rune that got ported into repentance afaik

    • @Fresh_Knight
      @Fresh_Knight Před 3 lety +8

      Ingwaz I can see being the inspiration for Stars? and Kenaz into Strength?

    • @tiddly5
      @tiddly5 Před 3 lety +1

      @@Fresh_Knight what is ingwaz? it's not on the antibirth wiki

    • @Fresh_Knight
      @Fresh_Knight Před 3 lety +5

      @@tiddly5 It's unused in Antibirth and doesn't function at all besides it's description just being treasure and while it's not much to go on idk I just have a gut feeling in it

  • @randomenafan8187
    @randomenafan8187 Před 3 lety +463

    I think pawn baby is an edith unlock, it would probably move like edith.

    • @RealityMasterRogue
      @RealityMasterRogue Před 3 lety +64

      I think Pawn Baby would have the wiz because pawns can only attack on diagonals

    • @randomenafan8187
      @randomenafan8187 Před 3 lety +5

      @@RealityMasterRogue huh, i didn't think about it that way.

    • @Breadward_MacGluten
      @Breadward_MacGluten Před 3 lety

      @@RealityMasterRogue you mean bishops?

    • @RealityMasterRogue
      @RealityMasterRogue Před 3 lety +37

      @@Breadward_MacGluten no, i don't.
      Pawns can move forward, but only attack diagonals. Look up chess rules.

    • @sebadksebadkovich9120
      @sebadksebadkovich9120 Před 3 lety +2

      @@RealityMasterRogue But there is a harlequin baby that have wiz

  • @huntermansam2006
    @huntermansam2006 Před 3 lety +540

    For divide and conquer I can’t really see the hemopytitis in it because if your are talking about the spread of “bullets” those are conquests horses when he does his multiple dash attack

  • @peein_gas
    @peein_gas Před 3 lety +167

    rune of fehu seems to be just an early version of the reverse hermit

    • @camillo3887
      @camillo3887 Před 3 lety +7

      I suppose all of these runes were supposed to be in game instead of reverse cards

    • @safeforwork8546
      @safeforwork8546 Před 3 lety +9

      Reverse hermit was modeled after rune of fehu from antibirth

  • @Tofukatze
    @Tofukatze Před 3 lety +225

    edit: this theory makes no sense anymore, but it was a fun one tbh
    Wait...
    24 unused achievements.
    Repentance currently is at 637
    637 + 24 = 661
    Edmund recently stated on stream with emphasis that 661 is the actual number of the beast, not 666
    What is seen on the icon of the Dead God achievement?
    The skull of none other than the final boss itself...the beast.

    • @PavelC.
      @PavelC. Před 3 lety +14

      Ey hol da faq..... big brain

    • @ExplosivePine
      @ExplosivePine Před 3 lety +6

      Arg time

    • @Tofukatze
      @Tofukatze Před 3 lety +15

      @Kubito 03 oh was it? Damn, if thats true my comment doesnt make any sense anymore :c

    • @Tofukatze
      @Tofukatze Před 3 lety +26

      @Kubito 03 did some research and i guess you are right. big brain move feels stupid now. Thought i saw him opening a box with "661" on it and connected the wrong dots

    • @PavelC.
      @PavelC. Před 3 lety +7

      Nah there is 637 achievement i checked now

  • @jaceinspace
    @jaceinspace Před 3 lety +177

    "I don't know what this does, don't wanna guess it, but have a planetarium being unlocked during a review!"
    Me: *Happy he did it again*

  • @SekruTheGreat
    @SekruTheGreat Před 3 lety +192

    The Ghost Babel challenge just sounds super interesting...
    I hope it makes into the game some day.
    Also, that Bloody lust+box is just perfect.

    • @alexandersuschena4776
      @alexandersuschena4776 Před 3 lety +31

      Its like metal gear but a small crying boy in his basement dying

    • @diegordi1394
      @diegordi1394 Před 2 lety +2

      Ghost Babel is actually the name for a Metal Gear game for the Game Boy Color.

  • @angelascanio1148
    @angelascanio1148 Před 3 lety +182

    4:14 i think it would be with the 7 seals item (The item that spawns lil version of famine,war,etc) , 9 volt and the white pony

    • @Puffman728
      @Puffman728 Před 3 lety +23

      And illusion hearts probably. But since those don't exist the challenge wouldn't be "finished". That's my theory at least.

    • @nereid942
      @nereid942 Před 3 lety +12

      @@Puffman728 maybe the challenge would unlock them?

    • @samuelbarker6755
      @samuelbarker6755 Před 3 lety +3

      I think it could have also used either the Locust set of items based on the art; or a Tinytoma effect on all your familiars (hence the divide and conquer name) or possibly a variant of Meat Cleaver that affected friendly characters instead of enemies.

    • @Supreme_Stalt
      @Supreme_Stalt Před 3 lety

      This

    • @Lexxxxiii
      @Lexxxxiii Před 3 lety +1

      @@samuelbarker6755 what if you started blindfolded with
      H o r s e and m e a t cleaver
      And a friendly conquest that you could divide into smaller ones with meat cleaver(+1 each floor)

  • @firebobert9546
    @firebobert9546 Před 3 lety +97

    11:06 4 year olds when you kill them in a game

  • @Quack-hh1fj
    @Quack-hh1fj Před 3 lety +49

    I mean, I feel like if Edith is implemented into the game, she's going to be a complete nightmare to play as.

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety +6

      Nothing can be worse than Tainted Lazarus...no way in hell.

    • @Quack-hh1fj
      @Quack-hh1fj Před 3 lety +2

      @@NerdTheDemon Try tainted Jacob.

    • @ianasipenko4572
      @ianasipenko4572 Před 3 lety +2

      She wasnt added cause she was too op

    • @jameor8500
      @jameor8500 Před 2 lety +1

      @@ianasipenko4572 she was super good in normal rooms but in boss rooms she fucking sucked

    • @Azxcon
      @Azxcon Před rokem +2

      @@Quack-hh1fj tainted jacob is fun and balanced tho

  • @baileybeatrix
    @baileybeatrix Před 3 lety +85

    8:50 Rune of Ingwaz
    I’m not sure if someone already made this theory or if it’s been proven by the community to do this, but I believe that (based on what you said, the translation being related to angels and the description of “treasure”) that the rune would change all chests in the current room into eternal chests.

    • @MysticMocha
      @MysticMocha Před 3 lety +6

      or could possibly act like the Justice? card, iirc that one spawns tons of golden chests in a room. My guess though that Ingwaz is reworked into Justice? card

    • @pixelo4747
      @pixelo4747 Před 3 lety

      that would make a lot of sence

    • @joelhoon1707
      @joelhoon1707 Před 3 lety

      I was thinking it would just spawn a single Eternal chest because I connected "Treasure" to chests.

    • @InsertFunnyThingHere
      @InsertFunnyThingHere Před 2 lety

      Or it could have been an early reverse justice card

    • @BLITZZZZZZZZZ01
      @BLITZZZZZZZZZ01 Před 2 lety

      I thought it would work like the reverse stars

  • @theflyingtoaster7414
    @theflyingtoaster7414 Před 3 lety +35

    Jacob and Easu's "Illusion baby" unlock makes alot more sense with Illusion heart.

  • @1BlueYoshi
    @1BlueYoshi Před 3 lety +58

    Maybe divide and conquer involved literally dividing the enemies with Meat Cleaver or something?

    • @samuelbarker6755
      @samuelbarker6755 Před 3 lety +12

      Or possibly a Cleaver variant where you divide yourself and your familiars for more coverage at the cost of less health and damage?

    • @arklypurple99
      @arklypurple99 Před 3 lety +1

      the unused illusion heart could be involved

  • @FrazzleFlib
    @FrazzleFlib Před 3 lety +48

    I think Divide and Conquer would instead be White Pony, 5 Lil' Harbingers and you're blindfolded like Conquest. Thatd be a nice, cute challenge actually

  • @Seth-lt7st
    @Seth-lt7st Před 3 lety +67

    Even though it’s a very hopeful thought due to Edmund basically turning the soul of Edith into Tainted Forgotten it would be neat to see these unused unlocks be turned into Edith’s postet unlocks if for some reason one day she becomes the beyond secret character that seems to show up in every major Isaac update.

    • @Lexxxxiii
      @Lexxxxiii Před 3 lety +1

      Imagine if edmund hated us (even more than he does) and makes us get dead god in the three save files, then wipe them all and get 3 dead gods again just for edith

    • @slob5041
      @slob5041 Před 2 lety +4

      @@Lexxxxiii edith wasn't really that fun tbh :/. I played one of the initial builds in 2015-ish? and each one was kind of a slog. the reworked character is WAY better.

  • @coolbugfacts3953
    @coolbugfacts3953 Před 3 lety +61

    1. beths heart would probably charge your active item from picking up soul hearts
    2. pawn baby would probably just act like a friendly bishop enemy in familiar/co-op baby form

    • @mrsmartypants1987
      @mrsmartypants1987 Před 3 lety +7

      𝘱𝘢𝘸𝘯 baby maybe it stomps enemys like edith

  • @PaperFlare
    @PaperFlare Před 3 lety +26

    The co-op babies are definitely all Edith's. You unlock one for clearing mom's heart on hard mode, one for clearing mega Satan on hard mode, and then one for getting all completion marks in normal and all marks in hard.
    They even follow the trend of 1 having little to do with the character (BFF baby) and then 3 that are very obviously about the character (Lot is Edith's father, salt being her mechanic, and the pawn mimicking her movement limitation).
    With the exception of Beth's heart, I would also guess most of the item unlocks would also be associated with Edith's various completion marks.
    Interesting stuff.

  • @muffet1536
    @muffet1536 Před 3 lety +56

    The interesting part about edith also is, she has a locked tainted door in the files as well
    Meaning they probably were so close to omplementing her, to plan a tainted version...only to scrap her anyway

    • @inarbysno7505
      @inarbysno7505 Před 3 lety +23

      Iirc T. Forgotten is basically what Edith was turned into. They even share a similar look.

    • @monte8901
      @monte8901 Před 3 lety +2

      How her Tainted look like?

    • @goronberry
      @goronberry Před 3 lety +30

      @@monte8901 It's just the door that shows up when the character isn't unlocked so we don't know what they would actually look like but the door had a salt shaker pouring salt on the ground inside

    • @monte8901
      @monte8901 Před 3 lety +1

      @@goronberry I wonder if the devs had something planned on her gameplay or not.
      Sure is the 2nd knowinf that TForgotten is inspired or is the concept of Edith playstyle

    • @vethenoir
      @vethenoir Před 3 lety +4

      Who knows, maybe shes in game

  • @EdenVix
    @EdenVix Před 3 lety +74

    The things i miss the most from antibirth are the mausoleum second part of the floor, the big witness room and the runes :(

    • @UsualCreator
      @UsualCreator Před 3 lety +26

      2nd part of mausoleum was my favorite part of it.

    • @enigmafiresup4658
      @enigmafiresup4658 Před 3 lety +28

      I can't understand the people who miss the witness big room. The fight is SOO much better in Rep, and thats something Kil personally believes too

    • @richardwatson1254
      @richardwatson1254 Před 3 lety +9

      @@enigmafiresup4658 Exactly. The only reason I could speculate why people want a 2x2 room is because Mother is an end game boss, but that's about it.

    • @UsualCreator
      @UsualCreator Před 3 lety +25

      @@enigmafiresup4658 i played antibirth few days ago and can somewhat aggre it is insane bullet spam.
      But i find antibirth version more fun to fight because it is just more satisfying when you manage to dodge all of those tiny bullets.
      Also corpse in antibirth is way way better than in repentance. They got rid of so many cool enemies from there and replaced them with more powerfull existing enemies.

    • @EdenVix
      @EdenVix Před 3 lety +8

      @@enigmafiresup4658 Imma be honest i don't remember the original fight lol it's been a long time. I don't miss the fight itself just the big room (and the chests before the fight) bc it was really cool, it really made you feel like you were tiny and helpless against the big bad final boss and i miss that. It was scary going in for the first time and seeing that bc you don't expect it (kinda like the chase sequence in rep now).

  • @MissWampirita
    @MissWampirita Před 3 lety +39

    there's one cool mod available for repentance that adds Edith and she's really well made there, she's crazy hard to play, but it's still cool that someone didn't give up on her

    • @computerkillthisman2917
      @computerkillthisman2917 Před 3 lety +8

      The mod author (lambchop_is_ok) is actually working on an altered Edith with a tainted variant that acts like a grudge.

    • @Raine_Walker
      @Raine_Walker Před 3 lety +17

      Edith wasn't given up on, she was recycled into t forgotton

    • @altaica3522
      @altaica3522 Před 3 lety +9

      Edith is tainted forgotten, edmund confirmed this in his isaac lore stream

    • @gasolina8000
      @gasolina8000 Před 3 lety +1

      @@altaica3522 I would have rather had edith than tainted forgotten :/

    • @altaica3522
      @altaica3522 Před 3 lety +1

      @@gasolina8000 They're literally the same person 👁👄👁

  • @Grafii2198
    @Grafii2198 Před 3 lety +4

    Psy Fly was supposed to be unlocked in Antibirth by completing Isaac's Awakening but it was bugged and it didn't give the unlock. Now in Repentance, that challenge unlocks the Spirit Sword which was unlocked by default in Antibirth.

  • @thebiolibrary5572
    @thebiolibrary5572 Před 3 lety +3

    a bit of context for Edith:
    Lot's wife, known in certain translations as Ado or Edith, was a biblical character who was turned into a "pillar of salt," as she disobeyed God's will and watched the destruction of Sodom.
    The salt theme is due to Edith being turned into a pillar of salt, Lot Baby would likely be a familiar who had a unique effect if picked up by Edith, and the Apple of Sodom likely references the city becoming overrun by sin, thus forcing God to destroy it in fire and brimstone. The fear effect from the salt could possibly be fear of following Edith down her path and being turned to salt.
    Here are some guesses as to if Edith ends up in the game:
    Edith's Birthright will have something to do with her movement. Maybe she can lightly move like with Chariot?.
    Tainted Edith will have something to do with Brimstone. Sodom was destroyed in a blaze of fire and brimstone. Maybe she ditches the salt related effects for Sulphur in her consumable slot.

  • @TarlukLegion
    @TarlukLegion Před 3 lety +5

    Edith was never planned for Repentance, Kilburn's stated that in the Discord a lot. It's only a leftover from Antibirth.

  • @dumbprotogen
    @dumbprotogen Před 3 lety +2

    Ok so I found out from Kilburn that divide and conquer had you start with book of Illusions and unused book that gave you an illusion heart hence divine and conquer and you also started with Mars (not just white pony)

  • @justacat2318
    @justacat2318 Před 3 lety +18

    I swear Edith is gonna be in Repentance+

    • @leodonaghey9143
      @leodonaghey9143 Před 3 lety +4

      Edmund said on Twitter that the team didn't want to add Edith, and the idea eventually became Tainted Forgotten.

    • @RiderOfPeppers
      @RiderOfPeppers Před 3 lety +1

      And there is no repetance + edmund is working on mewgenics

    • @justacat2318
      @justacat2318 Před 3 lety

      @@leodonaghey9143Mybe not the mechanics, but the sprites and animations are still possibilities

    • @Ghostel3591
      @Ghostel3591 Před 3 lety

      @@RiderOfPeppers well technically Edmund is game designer and artist not a gamedev - so whether or not there will be new content depends more on Kilburn and NotSaggitarus and other members of AB- team.
      Devteam for coding and stuff for mewgenics is completely separate.

    • @atendentedomarket7545
      @atendentedomarket7545 Před 3 lety

      @@Ghostel3591 And the Nicalis team.

  • @kalko8209
    @kalko8209 Před 3 lety +3

    3:15 also worth mentioning, Ghost Babel was a Metal Gear spinoff

  • @mr24coja
    @mr24coja Před 3 lety +22

    Tainted Forgotten is what Edith became, pretty sure it was confirmed somewhere.
    (If anyone wants to dispute this Im willing to look for the clip)

    • @N0CTAN
      @N0CTAN Před 3 lety +9

      It was confirmed by edmund himself on a stream he did pretty recently

  • @The_Dev_175
    @The_Dev_175 Před 3 lety +1

    It’s crazy for me to see Edith actually having an unlock achievement paper. Cause at some point during Repentance’s development, Edith WAS actually considered to be an actual character for Repentance before going straight back to being scraped.
    However, there is an Edith mod in the works that plans to rework/rebalanced Edith and give her her own unlocks and even a Tainted Version. The same creator also made a classic Edith mod which is an almost carbon copy of Edith from Antibirth in the meantime.

    • @IsaacGuru
      @IsaacGuru  Před 3 lety +1

      What's even crazier is Edith having a locked tainted version icon for the character selection screen.

    • @The_Dev_175
      @The_Dev_175 Před 3 lety +2

      @@IsaacGuru Yeah, crazy. That and the fact there are items considered to be Edith’s unlocks, it really makes you wonder how far the Repentance devs were into brining back Edith before eventually scraping it all again.
      And yeah, Tainted Forgotten is a rebalanced version of the character but it isn’t the same. Glad Edith “sort of” made it in the end though.

  • @theconquest1496
    @theconquest1496 Před 3 lety +9

    I think that pawn baby was supposed to be Edith's all completion marks on hard co-op baby, as a pawn in chess is kind of an statue

  • @cookier995
    @cookier995 Před 3 lety +2

    The community: Repentance for console!
    Fix delirium!
    Edith!
    Ed: hehe so how about four souls

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety

      It's funny because Four Souls Requiem is only in its Kickstarter phase, and will release AFTER Repentance comes to console.

    • @cookier995
      @cookier995 Před 3 lety

      @@NerdTheDemon ye but we don't even know if it's coming to Xbox, which is what I play on

    • @cookier995
      @cookier995 Před 2 lety

      Damn. 5 months of waiting

  • @firebobert9546
    @firebobert9546 Před 3 lety +12

    “Rune of fehu was a cut rune”
    Soul of Cain: dude I’m right here

    • @huntermansam2006
      @huntermansam2006 Před 2 lety

      Soul of Cain is just red key you might be thinking of one the reversed cards tho

  • @happiness2031
    @happiness2031 Před 3 lety +13

    this video made me really hope that Edith will be an official character

    • @shythespider5126
      @shythespider5126 Před 3 lety

      I'll admit if I'm wrong a couple months down the line but if I could place money on Edith not being added I would

    • @emmota7717
      @emmota7717 Před 3 lety +4

      @@shythespider5126 Tainted forgotten is Edith

    • @emmota7717
      @emmota7717 Před 3 lety

      One of the developers revealed that, thats why tainted soul has edith's robe

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety +1

      @@emmota7717 That'd explain why the Hot Potato challenge exists. It's to make it clear that there's something salty about them!

    • @altaica3522
      @altaica3522 Před 3 lety

      @@emmota7717 Edmund himself said so in his isaac lore stream too

  • @D_Dupa
    @D_Dupa Před 3 lety +3

    The Lot baby is a reference to Edith’s husband. She is commonly referred to as “Lot’s wife”
    So it was probably unlocked by beating it lives on hard mode as Edith

  • @Raine_Walker
    @Raine_Walker Před 3 lety +8

    Lot baby was probably edith's mom's heart unlock because in the bible Edith was Lot's wife until god pulled a sick gamer move and turned into a pillar of salt

    • @BalsamicJeebs
      @BalsamicJeebs Před 3 lety +2

      "sick gamer move" is the most accurate description

  • @szeplevente88
    @szeplevente88 Před 3 lety +6

    I really hope the Nightwatch enemy gets added, they could add a lot of interesting rooms to the game, like you can't be seen by them or they spawn enemies for the room, really cool ideas could be done with those enemies

  • @kakarecenzjasmietnikow3441
    @kakarecenzjasmietnikow3441 Před 3 lety +13

    maybe rune of ingwaz with desc "treasure" was supposed to delete treasure room on the floor but giving higher chance for angel room on the floor, i think its a good concept

    • @Jpx0999
      @Jpx0999 Před 3 lety +1

      Count you Just get the treasure and then use the rune

    • @Someone72663
      @Someone72663 Před 3 lety +3

      @@Jpx0999 probably it would no longer work then

    • @roetemeteor
      @roetemeteor Před 3 lety +3

      My guess was that it would actually take you to an angel room, and you'd be allowed to take from it. Kind of like how the Joker works, except this always gives you an angel room, and would overwrite the devil room if it has not been spawned yet.

    • @insertnameherexddd7079
      @insertnameherexddd7079 Před 3 lety +4

      What if when you use it...it would change the tresure room into an angel room that you need to pay 1-2 soul-red hearts

    • @insertnameherexddd7079
      @insertnameherexddd7079 Před 3 lety +2

      Big brain idea
      When you used it it would convert the devil deal chance into angel deal chance and the angel deal chance couldnt go down

  • @AbsinthedeLaRochefoucauld

    I hope that we still get updates in Repentance to include some of these :D

  • @Ryusuta
    @Ryusuta Před 3 lety +3

    I hope they bring the Antibirth runes back someday. I miss all of the cut Antibirth content, but those in particular were fun.

  • @m1bl4n
    @m1bl4n Před 3 lety +2

    Hold up, I've never seen the Evil Eye item yet, altough I haven't stopped playing since Repentance's launch.

    • @IsaacGuru
      @IsaacGuru  Před 3 lety +1

      If you mean Evil Charm, it's probably because it spawns only in the secret room which is rare by itself.

  • @MattHew-rq8zw
    @MattHew-rq8zw Před 3 lety +2

    Imagen blank-bomb with Doc. Fetus... you can make hush a sad boss there by nullifying his tears.

    • @Winasaurus
      @Winasaurus Před 3 lety

      Ocular rift and nearly any damage/tears/luck up already does that. Poor hush got power creeped hard.

  • @MAXI2006O
    @MAXI2006O Před 3 lety +2

    We are talking about the same Syncer (the one in the photo of the forgotten that makes Review of all the items of all the isaacs and mods)

  • @MattisticStatistic
    @MattisticStatistic Před 3 lety +3

    Honestly, Illusion Heart being remade into an item would be cool.

    • @abicto
      @abicto Před 3 lety +1

      it already kinda exists as Strawman, Soul of J&E and Soul of the forgotten

    • @MattisticStatistic
      @MattisticStatistic Před 3 lety

      @@abicto Yes, but those don't last between rooms, or they're an item that doesn't come back after death. So they're bad.
      plus who actually wants keeper for an ally like fr he'll just steal money

  • @Toetoeba
    @Toetoeba Před 3 lety +2

    5:45 This is literally EXACTLY how I imagined Edith working before I even saw this gameplay!

  • @aleflippy1997
    @aleflippy1997 Před 3 lety +15

    I really don't get why everyone is so crazy about Edith... Would you REALLY play a character that can only move by teleporting? Because I know she'd drive me mad more so than Jacob & Esau.

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety +2

      Because it's a new character. It's a cool gimmick.
      And also, if Jacob & Esau drives you up the wall more than Tainted Lazarus does, you're either really bad or you're really good. I don't actually know how to think about that one.

    • @aleflippy1997
      @aleflippy1997 Před 3 lety +3

      @@NerdTheDemon I don't like content for the sake of content. Feature-creep is definitely a thing, and while it keeps the people playing... I'm not really into "forcing" myself to play. Hence why I still haven't unlocked everything for both versions of Lost... Sure it caters to a certain crowd, but I really don't like that gimmick, as you put it.
      I can tell that Edith will be just as frustrating, even more so with Repentance being harder than previous versions. You actually need to dodge much more this time around. Can you imagine Delirium, Mother or The Beast as Edith? I already shivers at the thought of beating them as T.Forgotten without recall.
      And worry not, I hate T.Lazarus just as much. More so even. I feel like I'm slowly getting the hang of J&E. But still... Having two hitboxes and two health bars to take care of is tense.

    • @altaica3522
      @altaica3522 Před 3 lety +2

      Edith is tainted forgotten, its confirmed by edmund.

    • @aleflippy1997
      @aleflippy1997 Před 3 lety

      @@altaica3522 Everybody knows that by now bruh.

    • @altaica3522
      @altaica3522 Před 3 lety +2

      @@aleflippy1997 clearly not because tons of comments still say otherwise

  • @exxelsetijadi5348
    @exxelsetijadi5348 Před 3 lety +3

    7:12
    i think that's a reference to Lot, Abraham's nephew (so that means he's Isaac's cousin)
    *Edith* was his wife, btw

  • @toast8086
    @toast8086 Před 3 lety +1

    god i really wish all the new stuff is coming and not cut permanently, having a unique character like edith be gone forever would be devastating

  • @shylar763
    @shylar763 Před 2 lety +1

    Considering we very recently finally got an unused boss in the game, I feel like there's a good chance we'll see some unused enemies come back too

  • @ASCII-RBLX
    @ASCII-RBLX Před 3 lety +2

    The illusion hearts one of the best concepts I've ever heard of

  • @skapaloka222
    @skapaloka222 Před 3 lety

    Corrections and observations that I am making:
    -Divide and conquer probably used the White Pony wisps, or tiny horsemen somehow, not Hemoptysis
    -Lot was edith's husband, so was probably Edith's Hard mode Mom's Heart coop unlock and might not do anything special.
    -Duplex baby might have been some early Jacob and Esau coop baby? Idk
    -Illusion heart is cool and I'm sad that its gone :(
    -Pawn baby was most likely another special coop baby that had Edith's movement, because pawns would hop up and down like edith does
    that's all, this is all speculation

  • @Hephaestus_God
    @Hephaestus_God Před 3 lety +11

    Blank Bombs is a reference from "Enter the Gungeon" where you use blanks to remove all enemy projectiles from the screen.

  • @im_tem
    @im_tem Před 3 lety +2

    man, did you not even look past "unused" folder or check tcrf? literally one folder above there is unlock for a brand new cut item "keeper's rope"

    • @IsaacGuru
      @IsaacGuru  Před 3 lety +1

      Huh, that's definitely not an easy one to notice. Good catch!

  • @vexhilion6815
    @vexhilion6815 Před 3 lety +1

    In the rare chance we do get Edith and she functions more or less the same as Antibirth, imagine a 4 player co-op run of Ediths.

  • @timmyreobed5043
    @timmyreobed5043 Před 3 lety +3

    I really hope we get the runes, albeit with a change to Fehu so it isn't just Ace Of Diamonds. The co-op babies can stay on the cutting room floor for all I care though.

    • @alexandersuschena4776
      @alexandersuschena4776 Před 3 lety +3

      Fehu isnt even an ace of diamonds clone
      Reverse hermit just stole its identity and purpose

    • @inarbysno7505
      @inarbysno7505 Před 3 lety +2

      @@alexandersuschena4776 I wouldn't say "stole". They just turned the rune into a reverse card.

  • @lauti255yt
    @lauti255yt Před 3 lety

    The psy fly actually had its own unlock method in antibirth, and it was by completing the "isaac's awakening" challenge, but it was bugged and the challenge couldn't be completed in any way. Fortunately, it's free in repentance and it's way more op than I thought

  • @TheShut1
    @TheShut1 Před 3 lety +1

    I think people want Edith as character just because she wasn't added, but if she was in Repentance, they would hate her guts and say "How can you play as character that can't properly move in a game that's all about dodging?". Just like there would be a huge rebuke if they didn't add Jacob & Esau, without acknowledgment of how it's really tough and sometimes not fun to play as them. I mean I am glad they are in game but I also notice frequently quite strong hate on them from certain part of the BoI community.

  • @T1_Tilapia
    @T1_Tilapia Před 3 lety +1

    Blank Bombs might also be a reference to Enter the Gungeon and their mechanics are also very similar.

  • @paradox4627
    @paradox4627 Před 3 lety +2

    man i'd do anything to have edith in the game

    • @sipsip4006
      @sipsip4006 Před 3 lety

      don't you think T. forgotten replaced her?

  • @Mantafirefly
    @Mantafirefly Před 3 lety +2

    That "Turn items into coins" rune did basically make it into the game as "The Hermit?"

    • @Winasaurus
      @Winasaurus Před 3 lety

      @Siper Not exactly. Ace of Diamonds converts 1 pickup to 1 coin. The rune 'sells' the item for it's worth in coins, 3 for a heart, 5 for a key, 15 for an item, so on.

  • @PavelC.
    @PavelC. Před 3 lety +6

    Man i want edith so much so interesting character design

    • @ikmor
      @ikmor Před 3 lety +4

      Interesting for about two rooms..

    • @aydenmoens175
      @aydenmoens175 Před 3 lety

      Lamb chop is working on Edith, Edith classic, and tainted Edith for in the workshop

  • @joseGuzman-bj2mi
    @joseGuzman-bj2mi Před 3 lety +2

    Blank bombs sound like blank bullets from gungeon..... nice

  • @parnoian
    @parnoian Před 3 lety +2

    Finally a man who goes into the planetarium

  • @CompetitiveGlueSniffer
    @CompetitiveGlueSniffer Před 3 lety +2

    For the rune of Ingwaz my best quess is that it would create an additional free pedestal item in angel rooms

  • @ssthetique
    @ssthetique Před 3 lety +2

    I was so upset when I realised that Book of Despair and Menorah aren't in Repentance
    These were kinda cool... at least for me

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety

      Damn, never thought about that.
      Paschal Candle made it in, but not Menorah. Ouch.

  • @uncledeath2246
    @uncledeath2246 Před 3 lety +1

    Pawn Baby can either do with chess, the horse items(horse being a chess piece) or the shop(like a pawnbroker, maybe it made one more item be on sale as it "negotiates").

  • @mrtopper930
    @mrtopper930 Před 3 měsíci

    For the runes, I had pickup Description ideas 😂
    Here they are!
    Fehu: Weath at a small cost.
    Gebo (I pronounced it like the G is like a Y so Yebo): Untouched Interaction.
    Ingwaz (I reworked its description): A heavenly gift.
    Kenaz: Toxicological Repertoire.
    Othala: One gift, of random owned.
    Sowilo: May your life be offered to you.

  • @joelrauch9884
    @joelrauch9884 Před 3 lety +6

    i mean the fehu rune exists, its just called the "hermit?"

  • @theshypuppet
    @theshypuppet Před rokem +1

    I hope they one day readd Edith as a playable character with other cut content as her unlocks, but I doubt this will ever happen 😢

  • @slob5041
    @slob5041 Před rokem +1

    I helped create the original concept for Edith (uncredited) and it was cut because it wasn’t fun. Still a cool concept in theory.

  • @your_computer_guy8106
    @your_computer_guy8106 Před 3 lety +6

    It would be neat if there was another ARG, but related to Edith. It’s highly unlikely due to what’s going on and Requiem currently being made, but it would be cool if the unused character could finally be in the game instead of being a Easter egg with the Chariot? Card

  • @BIG_JUMBLE
    @BIG_JUMBLE Před 2 lety +1

    Edith or illusion heart should get a chance to come most of these should they all look so cool and the night watchers look so cool

  • @urifrid6767
    @urifrid6767 Před 2 lety

    the fact that two unused bosses entered the game is making me hopeful towards edith and skinless hush

  • @PruneauYT
    @PruneauYT Před 3 lety

    Love the @AccidentalGrenade shoutout! I sure miss his Isaac videos.

  • @richardwatson1254
    @richardwatson1254 Před 3 lety +5

    You forgot to mention that Rune of Fehu is in the game in the form of the Hermit? card.

  • @nolanhock8888
    @nolanhock8888 Před 3 lety +4

    I hope we get the cut runes someday. They look really fun.

    • @ehwa6780
      @ehwa6780 Před 3 lety +1

      they were changed into the reverse cards

    • @tragedyplustime8271
      @tragedyplustime8271 Před 3 lety +1

      Fehu and Kenaz became Reverse Hermit and Strength, respectively. Gebo and Othala were too broken in some cases. Sowilo may have become Reverse Empress.
      Ingwaz, to me, seems like an extra Angel room. As such, it probably got reworked into Reverse Moon.

    • @nolanhock8888
      @nolanhock8888 Před 3 lety

      TragedyplusTime I mean, there are plenty of items in the game that have similar functions/ weaker or stronger versions of an item, an example of the top of my head being that the soul of Judas is just a one use dark arts, whose to say that the runes can't be added?

    • @tragedyplustime8271
      @tragedyplustime8271 Před 3 lety +1

      @@nolanhock8888 You're comparing two identical consumables to a soul stone being a one use active, which is what they're meant to be. Most Soul Stones exist to act like the character's active/passive abilities but one use, to allow you to keep your active and get their benefits (Only exceptions are Soul of The Keeper, Soul of The Forgotten, Soul of J&E and Soul of Apollyon).

  • @copperheadchris2807
    @copperheadchris2807 Před 2 lety

    Blank bombs are likely a reference to enter the gungeon. In that game, blanks are basically a get out of jail free card. They create a room wide blast that destroies all bullets, pushes enemies back, and does a small amount of damage. They are also the only way to open hidden walls in that game.

  • @user-mz1fe3yj7e
    @user-mz1fe3yj7e Před 3 lety +1

    the small spots in divide and conquer look more like small horsemen

  • @danteweber9301
    @danteweber9301 Před rokem

    The devs should've made edith a character with tower defense mechanics which involves edith (as a spirit) spending an amount of "her" own unique pickup to place familiars, turrets, blocks, etc to defend "her" salt body.

  • @honeybuzz601
    @honeybuzz601 Před 2 lety +2

    For some reason.. Some strange reason..
    I want edith in the game. Imagine edith was unlocked by standing still for 30 minutes.

  • @the7screw
    @the7screw Před 3 lety +6

    Lot was Edith's husband, when they escaped the city of sadom and amora before God destroyed it.
    Edith looked back on the way out so God turned her into a pillar of salt for gazing at his true form.

  • @moronribbons5774
    @moronribbons5774 Před rokem

    Ghost babel challenge actually looks pretty interesting, since it seems like it would've needed custom rooms in each floor that the nightwatches would be in. But a special stealth-based run would be a really fun idea.

  • @DeebiousGaming
    @DeebiousGaming Před 3 lety +1

    the rune of ingwaz might have been a rune that rerolled any items into angel room items

  • @edenengland1883
    @edenengland1883 Před 3 lety +1

    pawn baby probably would've functioned like Edith, jumping around instead of walking

  • @saltymilk2972
    @saltymilk2972 Před 3 lety +1

    There's a chance that edith might be like the forgotten and come in a booster pack update

    • @Beyersdorff
      @Beyersdorff Před 3 lety

      @Siper what's up with those reworks? what are they changing?

    • @Beyersdorff
      @Beyersdorff Před 3 lety

      @Siper oh, reading your comment I thought it was going to be a void item rework
      thanks bro, good info

    • @saltymilk2972
      @saltymilk2972 Před 3 lety

      @Siper yea probably

  • @NooB-Celica
    @NooB-Celica Před 3 lety +1

    Those runes are awesome! With blank card getting the nerf I can't see why they didn't add these runes to the game. It's not like they are over powered.

    • @NerdTheDemon
      @NerdTheDemon Před 3 lety

      I agree. Sort of.
      They added 17 other runes in the form of Soul Stones. And also 21 additional cards.

    • @NooB-Celica
      @NooB-Celica Před 3 lety

      @@NerdTheDemon oh. Well I haven't got that far yet.

  • @rogueliker2484
    @rogueliker2484 Před 3 lety +1

    Pawn baby - may shoot Terra tears as pawns can be made out of rock or marble?

  • @HalfMajor890
    @HalfMajor890 Před 3 lety +2

    This would probably be the best DLC I have ever purchased if everything was finished

  • @Amsel_616
    @Amsel_616 Před 3 lety +1

    "Cut runes from Antibirth (ft.Psy Fly and Edith)"

  • @haazmat
    @haazmat Před 2 lety

    That nightwatch challenge actually looks fire.

  • @scarfbit7354
    @scarfbit7354 Před 3 lety

    You always have something interesting about Isaac to tell.

  • @PoggerFoxy
    @PoggerFoxy Před 3 lety

    Knowing Ed, Edith is probably a red herring for dataminers
    BUT, in the case where it's not, it's either cut because they couldn't balance it, like in antibirth, or we'll get to see it in the future
    I do hope we get to see most of the things in this video being added

  • @DamageMaximo
    @DamageMaximo Před 3 lety

    The ghost babel challenge sounds amazing, fun and interesting!

  • @DeciDeci_
    @DeciDeci_ Před 2 lety

    The term blank for the blank bombs is most likely a reference to enter the gungeon as "Blanks" are a crucial item to remove bullets in that game.

  • @captaintaggart6523
    @captaintaggart6523 Před 3 lety

    I think Beth's Heart would be kind of like a mix between Book of Virtues, Isaac's Heart and one of the sack items. My guess is that it would spawn a wisp every 4 rooms, and wisps are now immune to damage unless Beth's Heart is damaged, like Isaac's Heart for Wisps

  • @yuvalshimshon3518
    @yuvalshimshon3518 Před 3 lety +1

    i have an idea: maybe instead Edmund will nerf psy fly in the future , he could change it so only if you get all completion marks in hard mode with all tainted characters, you will get Psy fly and his achievement, just like mega mush with all the non-tainted characters.

    • @alexandersuschena4776
      @alexandersuschena4776 Před 3 lety +1

      they could just make it a tlost unlock

    • @katiequeen7225
      @katiequeen7225 Před 3 lety +1

      i mean we all know that psy fly is so strong it should be harder to get than mega mush