Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
What Bridgerton Should Have Learned from Brandy & Paolo Montalban’s CINDERELLA
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 08. 2024
- Following the release of Bridgerton Season 3 focusing on Colin Bridgerton (Luke Newton) and Penelope Featherington (Nicola Coughlan), it was finally time to revisit the most iconic 'Blasian Solidarity' trio of the Y2K era: "Cinderella" (starring Brandy and Paolo Montalban), "Rush Hour" (starring Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker), and "Romeo Must Die" (starring Jet Li and Aaliyah).
Credits/links/references:
→ "Bridgerton" (2020-present): Netflix
→ netflix.com/bridgerton
→ "Cinderella" (1997): ABC / Disney
→ "Rush Hour" (1998): New Line Cinema / Warner Bros.
→ "Romeo Must Die" (2000): Warner Bros.
→ MORE SOURCES IN THE PINNED COMMENT!
0:00 Bridgerton Introduction
9:45 A Brief History Lesson
13:47 THE ONLY Cinderella (I said what I said!)
21:55 Rush Hour (THE ONLY copaganda film still invited to karaoke)
28:06 Romeo Must Die (UNIRONICALLY GOOD, it’s not up for debate!)
36:56 What did we learn on the show tonight, Craig?
Fair Use Act Disclaimer:
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
DONATE TO THE MIDDLE EASTERN CHILDREN'S ALLIANCE TO SEND AID:
www.mecaforpea...
DONATE TO THE 🍉 CHILDREN'S RELIEF FUND:
pcrf1.app.neon...
www.pcrf.net/a...
DONATE TO THE ANIMAL FRIENDS SHELTER (🍉):
paypal.me/samer563
www.gofundme.c...
/ animalfriendsaf
DONATE TO ESIMS FOR GAZA:
www.gazaesims.com
DONATE TO PIOUS PROJECTS TO GET FEMININE HYGIENE KITS TO GAZA:
piousprojects....
DONATE TO CARE FOR GAZA:
gofundme.com/f...
DONATE TO SALAM ANIMAL CARE:
paypal.me/SalamAnimal
/ rescuecare
DONATED TO CAMPUS BAIL FUNDS:
campusbailfund...
DONATE TO NON-PROFIT GLOBAL HEALTH PARTNERS TO SEND MEDICAL AID TO LATIN AMERICA:
ghpartners.org...
STREAM "HIND'S HALL" by MACKLEMORE and all streaming proceeds will go to UNRWA.
MORE REVIEWS & INTERVIEWS
- Anyone But You (Starring Glen Powell & Sydney Sweeney): The Perfect Rom Com for Shakespeare Girlies
• Anyone But You (Starri...
- Anyone But You, Natasha Bedingfield, and the Art of the Rom Com Musical Needle Drop 🥰💋🎶🎞✨
• Anyone But You, Natash...
- Benedict Bridgerton is the BEST Bridgerton (A Closer Inspection)
• Benedict Bridgerton is...
- Charlie's Angels (2000) is PEAK CINEMA:
• Charlie's Angels is PE...
- George Chakiris INTERVIEW on West Side Story, Gene Kelly, and The Art of Dance on Film
• George Chakiris INTERV...
- Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery and The Art of Hiding in Plain Sight (Netflix Review/Video Essay)
• Glass Onion: A Knives ...
- Glass Onion & Knives Out: The Archetypes of Rian Johnson Whodunits
• Glass Onion & Knives O...
- Glass Onion Revisited: Yo-Yo Ma’s Cameo and Bach’s Little Fugue in G Minor (Review/Video Essay)
• Glass Onion Revisited:...
- Glen Powell & Sydney Sweeney's "ANYONE BUT YOU" and the Modern Literary Adaptation (Video Essay)
• Glen Powell & Sydney S...
- Glen Powell + Sydney Sweeney ANYONE BUT YOU Interview on Rom Coms and Shakespeare! (+ Will Gluck!)
• Glen Powell + Sydney S...
- Knives Out is the PEAK Whodunit (Video essay split in 4 pieces):
• Knives Out is the PEAK...
- The Love Story of Kate and Anthony’s HAND STUFF (Bridgerton)
• The Love Story of Kate...
- Only Baz Luhrmann Could Make An ELVIS Biopic ✨CINEMA✨ (Video Essay - Starring Austin Butler)
• Only Baz Luhrmann Coul...
- Rizzo and Kenickie Were ALWAYS the Superior Couple | Grease 1 Video Essay
• Rizzo and Kenickie Wer...
- Why Daphne, Violet, & Lady Danbury Can See The Not-So-Hidden Feelings of Kate & Anthony (BRIDGERTON)
• Why Daphne, Violet, & ...
PATREON:
/ ladyjenevia
Follow me on social media:
linktr.ee/Lady...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
#Bridgerton #Brandy #PaoloMontalban #Cinderella
27626
Watch my new interview with Karen Fukuhara from THE BOYS so I can book more interviews here on the channel! 🫶🏻
czcams.com/video/EsFvRcsv8u0/video.html
Support me on Patreon so I can make more videos like these!
www.patreon.com/LadyJenevia
Research Sources:
→ Descendants: The Rise of Red: Brandy and Paolo Montalban’s REUNION (Exclusive) | Entertainment Tonight
czcams.com/video/FOAcaL6rptA/video.htmlsi=c69y3YeSTnnJ2ABA
→ Race-baiting, queer-baiting, colorism, featurism, and performative diversity | Khadija Mbowe
czcams.com/video/zYPB5nJV3h8/video.htmlsi=BftKbZjKXmvE8j2E
→ The Liberal Escapism of Bridgerton | Broey Deschanel
czcams.com/video/F_CAK_yj5JM/video.htmlsi=J5dpFWk0OUU8b-YB
→ Bridgerton’s Ruby Barker Slams Netflix After Suffering Psychotic Breaks | E! News
czcams.com/video/20UeYaacWnY/video.htmlsi=fKawlLt2wkKAU1_Y
→ How the Gleeful Aesthetic of L.A.’s 1984 Olympics Unified a Sprawling City | PBS SoCal
www.pbssocal.org/shows/lost-la/how-the-gleeful-aesthetic-of-l-a-s-1984-olympics-unified-a-sprawling-city
→ NOLYMPICS LA
nolympicsla.com
→ FLASHBACK: With Whitney Houston on the 1997 Set of 'Cinderella' | Entertainment Tonight
czcams.com/video/03WD8jgljWY/video.htmlsi=IfiE3eO87rcj957y
→ Brandy - I Wanna Be Down (Official Video)
czcams.com/video/PzpLkcfBe-A/video.htmlsi=tgGu6JMJEmgoQWdA
→ 'Extra's' Lost Video! Brandy and Whitney Houston's Meeting in 1995 | extratv
czcams.com/video/IJUlNtMYAaU/video.htmlsi=rSw7To54mTypuTl8
→ Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella Reunion w/ Brandy, Whoopi Goldberg & More | Entertainment Weekly
czcams.com/video/EGhoilw7NPs/video.htmlsi=aumA87goNrmZjG0s
→ Debra Martin Chase and Paolo Montalban talk ‘Cinderella’ l GMA
czcams.com/video/e8lmAnmnHk4/video.htmlsi=g0HPbOhQkrxXA_0T
→ 10 Things You Didn't Know About Disney's Cinderella | Cosmopolitan
www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/movies/a13150017/10-things-you-didnt-know-about-disneys-cinderella/
→ Jackie Chan’s Plan to Keep Kicking Forever | GQ
www.gq.com/story/jackie-chans-gq-profile-2017
→ Aaliyah & Jet Li - "Romeo Must Die" Interviews & BTS [AaliyahPL]
czcams.com/video/AowVx4SikuA/video.htmlsi=wiZSmAhfr2UmssaF
→ Aaliyah Romeo Must Die Junket Interview
czcams.com/video/jeDY_MREecU/video.htmlsi=iNNlpN7o4VWi4s3I
→ Bridgerton Season 3: The Puppy Interview | Buzzfeed
czcams.com/video/CZK0IRWj_nk/video.htmlsi=D5CV_1mvO93mYFwI
Music:
→ Rina Sawayama - XS
czcams.com/video/TO2c06p6m5w/video.htmlsi=IwsvY1xIPk65NiBv
→ Brandy - Right Here
czcams.com/video/vzwoJ10UyO0/video.htmlsi=ScDjJ5Sxi8k8s7lJ
→ Mariah Carey - Fantasy
czcams.com/video/qq09UkPRdFY/video.htmlsi=RT0FjbCxv9tGjTeS
→ Aaliyah - Are You Feelin' Me?
czcams.com/video/EB_lq1fRqnc/video.htmlsi=LhQxAImUtF-s_Bsb
→ Aaliyah - Try Again
czcams.com/video/qTA0RuZoIxM/video.htmlsi=ASunIq3mAJpa0rno
I am scared to watch the crow video because I don't want to be spoiled for the movie
I was happy for Bridgerton to be racially diverse and set in the 1800s with no explanation because I thought of it as a fantasy. The minute they brought race relations it became something else entirely. When it became evident that the writers had no range to discuss these issues it took me out.
Reading your “had no range” line made my brain transport to Tiffany Pollard saying her “unqualified” / “nothing of the sort” rant from Big Brother 😭😂😭😂😭😂
I am done with Bridgerton anyway. I will never watch another second because the Michael mess....it is just a step too far.
@@LadyJenevia omg😭😭 why is that the perfect comparison
I 2nd this! I was blissfully and happily suspending my disbelief until the show brought it up so clumsily! I hope future showrunners learn from that mistake!
@@LadyJenevia I thought of the Little Britain skit where Matt Lucas plays an artfully reclined Shirley Bassey, who dismisses other singers with “She doesn’t have the range! I’m sorry darling, but she doesn’t have the range!” Which apparently Bassey really did say about Tina Turner when Goldeneye came out lol. But in this case it’s true, Bridgerton doesn’t have the range. “We were two separate societies until a king fell in love with one of us” is sure a weird way to suggest systemic racism underpinned by hundreds of years of the transatlantic slave trade was solved overnight by the love of a single rich (mentally ill) man. 😬
🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯 Making Brigerton like Brandi's Cinderella would have been absolutely perfect.
Truly, Whitney made the blueprint in the 1990’s and too many industry people are ignoring it! 😎
I truly think there needs to be more people of color directing, and being the show runners and writers.
I love Brandy's and Paolo's Cinderella. I hate how Disney change the whole storyline of this Cinderella movie to fit the Descendents agenda.
@@lilianaledesma7254I'm almost afraid to ask what changes they made. I'm already pissed off at the idea of them messing with that perfection.
@@IjeomaThePlantMama I know I was. They changed the whole story of how Cindrella and Charming meet. Cindrella's childhood home life is changed too. It's like they were thinking if we get Brandy and Paolo back it will draw that demographic of audience into this Disney franchise. It doesn't matter if we disregard the original story we still got the viewership numbers higher. I mean it worked. I'm a grown woman. The only reason I looked into that new movie is because I was excited to see the two reprise their roles ( even though they didn't really because now they have whole new storyline that don't aline with the old one).
Brandy and Paolo are the OG couple I shipped as a child 😊 love this
AND THEY'RE STILL ONE OF THE BEST LOOKING (fictional) COUPLES AROUND 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
@@LadyJenevia 💯
I think of H.E.R.'s Belle as their spiritual child
As a black woman, I just can't bring myself to watch bridgerton fully because I know that I am going to nitpick it because of the diversity problem. I watched season 1 and after THAT scene with Simon and Daphne I was done because that scene was too much on the surface. But when I thought about it some more....it kinda exemplifies the whole race dilemma and I started to unpack all the ways that Bridgeton fails it bipoc cast because there isn't enough bipoc people behind the camera.
For examples:
- THAT SCENE with Simon and Daphne (imo) kinda subconsciously veers too closely into the feitshzation of black bodies in the 1800s for the pleasure of white people and the lack of agency to say 'no' for fear of punishment.
- how all of the bridgeton women besides Eloise has been romantically linked to black men (it kinda giving Kardashians and we loved mixed children lol.)
- most of the women of color on bridgeton (including lady danbury, marina, Edwina, the dressmaker, Charlotte etc) always has a bittersweet ending to their stories. They can't never seem to get a true happy ending. Queen Charlotte is the most powerful woman on the show, but her husband has gotten sick and can't remember her most of the time. And I suppose to say 'Yass queen. wear that wig.' No it's truly sad that on a romance story that we have to watch a powerful woman see her husband become mad and the only time we see her happy is like 50 years pior and the fact that lady danbury doesn't have a lover most of her life like Lady Tilly with Benedict is mind blowing.
- the fact that most of the dark-skinned black men meet horrible fates (John, Simon's father, lord Danbury)
- the fact that we didn't have Kate's wedding to Anthony WHEN she is marrying the head of the main family on the show. The show is called Bridgeton and Kate is becoming the Lady of the entire family. But we get the wedding of the two white heroines.
- the desire of keeping Will and Alice on the show because they are the only black ppl on the principal cast but not giving enough of a storyline to justify their inclusion.
Im Black and I think, that's why I enjoyed season 2 better. It's hard to watch the Black characters in Bridgerton and not notice the blatant colorist/anti-Black tropes: Simon's dad in the flashbacks was an "interesting" choice, to say the least. I didnt finish the season after that and I didnt bother watching Queen Charlotte either.
😕
@@moustik31 Season one really rubbed me the wrong way upon 1st watching, Which is why season 2 is what redeemed the show for me and made me a fan. you should definitely watch Queen Charlotte though, because it also shows the suffering that the King endured because he loved Charlotte (and that suffering had nothing to do with racism)
@@Willow-cw9te You are missing the point Willow: I want to see a Black woman have a happy ending similar to Daphné and Penelope's. I wont settle for less, so no, I wont be watching Queen Charlotte.
You should add "A lack of diverse couples" to this list. You mean to tell me that for all Bridgerton's bragging about being diverse and using an interracial royal relationship as a lazy excuse for desegregation, there aren't more diverse couples in the show? Why is every romantic lead couple between a POC and a white person? Don't POCs date and marry each other too? The Black relationships we get in the entire show (Lady Danbury's marriage, Simon's parents) are also usually terrible. But between Penelope and Colin's dynamic dumpster fire, and Cressida's parents' bad marriage, I guess it "balances out". I agree with all your points 100%, and I haven't even watched the show. I've only seen clips of the shows, press tours, and watched video essays about Bridgerton. But I have no interest in watching it, and I'm glad cause I'd be nitpicking too.
@@Jiinx123 To be fair, the show is about the Bridgetons and since they are a white family, all marriages would have to be with a white person. But I agree with you on everything else.
As a black woman I have always been attracted to attractive men regardless of “race” and learned more and more from society as I grew older that I was not “allowed” to think white, Asian or Hispanic men are attractive. Cinderella with Brandy as the lead justified my feelings as a child. I feel a bit ashamed that societally we still have to tell black women that they can date any men they want that also want them. It is also so nice to see a non black woman cheering for positive and equal black representation without jealousy, bitterness or bigotry…❤
I think society does telll black women you’re allowed to think non black men are attractive. I think every woman is suppose to praise white men in particular because they have control over their own image and they paint themselves as the most manly and desirable. What is not taught, what’s taboo even, is finding black women attractive. Non black men, and even some black men, are taught to not allow themselves to find black women attractive. Like it’s wrong and I think that’s what leads to fetishization.
I legit thought as a kid that Black + White = Asian, but I didn't question it. I adored that the step sisters were different races from each other, and having a black step sister made it clear that the step mother wasn't just racist against Cinderella. Having grown up with all 3 televised versions of Rogers and Hammerstein's versions of the story, this is the one I enjoy revisiting most. EDIT: We 100% need a JJ Field cameo. Between Northanger Abbey and Austenland, that man has my regency heart in the palm of his hands.
Oh man, yes!!
@@soundgal_sine_qua_non this is exactly my thought as a kid, immediately got me briefly thinking I was a black + white asian biracial child back then, despite my family all being asian lol
Omg, that's an adorable misunderstanding for a little kid to have haha
Brandy’s Cinderella still means so much to me ❤
SHE'S AN ICON, SHE'S A LEGEND, AND SHE IS THE MOMENT
When the advertisements for Bridgerton first aired, I thought it was inspired by this version of Cinderella. I wonder if color blind casting will ever truly take off in Hollywood.
The director of Warcraft, Duncan Jones, is David Bowie's son and he said to me on Twitter that he had to battle the higher-ups/studio/whomever to be able to cast Travis Fimmel (white Australian) and Ruth Negga (Ethiopian Irish) as brother and sister because 'middle America won't understand that' (or something like that) and Duncan had to outright remind them that he himself is a white man with a Black sister (David Bowie's wife for many decades until he died was Somalian supermodel Iman). Even then they were still making an issue out of it. Warcraft came out in 2016!!! 🙃
The press surrounding Season 2 was foul. So many people tried defending it, using the COVID excuse, but Nicola, Claudia, Charithra and Luke N got a photoshoot, while Jonny and Simone did not.
And Phoebe and RJP got a photoshoot during COVID too so that’s a sh*t excuse.
Right, and my issue is not that the other couples shouldn't have had what they got. It's that Jonny and Simone should have had MORE to match the other couples, and more of that should have showcased them TOGETHER AS THE MAIN COUPLE OF THAT SEASON. 😎
@@LadyJenevia Idk the validity of it, but I heard rumors that several journos asked for access to just J&S for interviews and were denied. I 100% believe it.
@@mrskvall1 I can't speak from my own experience because all I asked for in the lead-up to season 2 was press screeners for reviewing purposes and I got them. I didn't even THINK to ask for interviews at that time because I just assumed I wouldn't have enough status to get in for a show as large as Bridgerton. I was fine with just getting the screeners. I didn't even become a FAN of Bridgerton until after I watched those season 2 screeners because I didn't watch season 1 until immediately before my first watch of season 2. 😂
@@mrskvall1do we know why they were denied access to J&S? I doubt it was Johnny and Simone turning them down, so my guess is it was the show denying access? Which circles back to WHY
Brandi is the prettiest Cinderella and Barbie ever. Also Keke Palmer on Broadway was an excellent casting....and I love Lily James but the throne is still occupied in my heart.
Thank you for bringing up the vast disparity of press for Kanthony. Everytime I bring this up I get attacked by fans that I’m jealous and I’m not. I am Tamil South Asian and I get emotional seeing Simone Ashley as a lead in the season. She and Johnny didn’t get the same measure of press or photo shoot for Season 2 or Season 3 which had massive promotion. And then for their characters ,Kanthony, have had NO milestones on screen and have ultimately been written off the show. Additionally (if I’m not mistaken) in Season 2 fans were told that they didn’t shoot or plan a wedding for Kanthony because it’s not possible to film two weddings in one season but then they turn around and do that exactly in Season 3!
It’s honestly soured my outlook of Shondaland and Bridgerton because why aren’t they good enough to get any of that but the white leads are? It seems like POC’s get all the coverage for suffering but when it’s time for celebration there’s all of a sudden no room.
So Glad u exposed these horrible choice's by the writers and show runner even. In their season they left off the marriage.honeymoon now season 3 we hear about a baby and never see it shame on them I agree 💯 thank u we Simone and Jonathan Kanthony deserve better!!!!!!!
I 100% forgot they said that bullshit about not having the budget for 2 weddings in season 2. But they went ahead and did it in season 3. Actually, even in season 2 we saw one of Peneloe's sisters wedding if i am not mistaken. They were a cute couple, but we all came to season 2 for the Kanthony wedding and love story.
@@soundmind174 You hit the mark.
I don’t know how people can chalk these opinions and observations to jealousy when people are just pointing things out. I’m not South Asian so I cannot relate to anyone who is but it still rubbed the wrong way when I realised that there wasn’t going to be a wedding. The entire promotional campaign for S2 prided itself on providing representation for South Indian people but when it was time to deliver on that there were crickets. It makes no sense that the show runners and writers for this show would spend time on a fake wedding with Anthony and Edwina when they knew that it was not gonna go anywhere. On top of that we don’t really know much about Kate compared to Anthony and she’s marrying into the family the show is about😭
It makes no sense that we don’t see any of their milestones onscreen like the other 2 couples. No wedding/wedding night, no honeymoon or the baby, despite that being their whole storyline for S3.
The promotion on its own was so bad. It looks like they didn’t believe that a South Asian woman would be able to carry her own season. All the promo was about that stupid ‘love triangle’ and they didn’t even try to make it about our main couple or give memorable promotion that highlighted the main couple.
In the same vein, I also found that the mistreatment of the actress who played Edwina, charithra chadran really put me off. It was bad enough that she was given a sloppily written part. But then to have fans also attack her for defending her own character was awful.
Oh! Have you seen 'mississippi masala'? I only ask because I find the film way too underrated. It's another blasian romance film starring the beautiful Charita Choudhury and Denzel washington. If you haven't seen this film I really recommend it, not just because, in line with kanthony, it features South Asian representation, but also because it's perhaps the best film to explore the topic of interracial love I've ever seen.
Lets be real, Bridgerton season 3 was the least diverse season. Diversity isnt just a check box, its giving diverse actors meaty storylines and importance. All the characters of importance were white and PoC only revolved ariund their white counterparts
I felt strongly that the show missed an opportunity to do better for the Mondriches and Madame DLC. I really thought that there would be more exploration of the Mondriches so that we as the audience would get to know them (and love them even more as a result!) and Benedict would learn something meaningful from them that would better set him up to be the (hopefully) leading man of season 4. And for Madame DLC, I thought we could learn more about her love for fashion and creating, the dilemma of having to make things she might not necessarily love but it’s what the paying customer wants so she has to do that, and then Penelope could also have her exploration running alongside that as it applies to Operation Lady Whistledown. Instead we got SCRAPS for both of those concepts. 🙃
@LadyJenevia I'm not going to lie, I enjoyed the featheringtons in season 1, but I need them to go so we can focus on other characters in season 4. I also need the Lady Whisteldown plot to be over and done with. Because you're right, we need to explore more of these side characters we have seen for years but barely know anything about. And I'd also love for Lady Danbury to finally have a plot that doesn't revolve around white people next season.
Amd don't get me started on how Bridgerton clearly only sees value in Kate when Anthony is around. Simone was free to film so many scenes to build her character as viscountess but NOPE! No Anthony means no Kate, which is pretty insulting
@@wonder-wall1914 Omg yes.
I need Lady Danbury to have a meaty plot in the next season. The one with her brother this season was so forgettable and didn’t feel like it was important. I just want one that would be about her specifically and not about her playing the magical black person that helps these white rich kids find true love. I feel like it’s such a waste of a very iconic character and makes her feel like she has nothing important keeping her rin the show.
Also with Kanthony, these writer need to give Kate a proper story that doesn’t just revolve around her husband. She feels like a love interest when she is the head of the family that the show is about. We can get more of her backstory, bonding with other people in society like Alice. I just want her to be more than just Anthony’s wife.
That version of Cinderella meant everything to me as a kid. Thank you so much for speaking about its impact!
Not nearly enough people talk consistently about the level of impact this film had on the culture at large. A whole generation of children who grew up watching it see that world as normal which is probably at least part of the reason why we're now inclined to nitpick if you underdeliver compared to the standard Whitney (and DMC) set with their vision! 🥰❤️🔥
When I tell you I rewatch this version of Cinderella a couple times a year because of how timeless it truly is. I think Mr Malcolm's List did a good job of casting diversely too. I wished they did the same with Bridgerton.
I never made a video dedicated to Mr Malcolm’s List but I’m pretty sure it did get a mention in my 2022 video ranking my favourite films of the year. I don’t remember where I put it but I think it was somewhere in my top 15 of that year. It was good!!
@@LadyJenevia Not enough people talk about this movie. It's also an adaption of a book and is actually better than book because of how it fleshed out the characters. So good.
Mr. Malcom’s list was a lovely film!
It’s my comfort movie!!
The way I screamed "Yassss!!!" when you featured "Romeo Must Die." I was just listening to the soundtrack last week.
I LOVE THAT MOVIE!! Jet Li was asked about it during the live action Mulan press tour and the interview blew up because that’s how iconic Romeo Must Die is. 😍😍😍
And the way you pronounced Aaliyah correctly. Girl. Chile. Please. You just got a new subscriber. 🎊 🎉
Sometimes I get stressed out not knowing how to say someone’s name but people really have no excuse for Aaliyah because there’s multiple clips of her explaining it. 😭😂
You were like, “Before you come for me, here are the receipts and the clip.” Thank you for pointing out the importance of music in Romeo Must Die. You can see the Asian influence in hip hop music and culture during that time. Wu-Tang Clan anyone?
@@KerraBolton I actually did the press junket for one of the seasons of the Wu-Tang series on Hulu. "Method Man" (specifically referring to the song here) is a BOP! 🥰✨
About Brandy’s and Paolo’s appearance in Descendants spin-off Rise of Red: They’re in a couple scenes together. The rest of the movie, they’re in separate scenes.
I recommend watching the press tour videos instead.
I wasn't ever really planning on watch the film; I assumed that if there were any good clips of them, they'd pop up on my CZcams feed. 🤭
@@LadyJenevia Okay.
I think that I may be able to offer some more context to the tensions between the Black and Asian communities that during the LA riots. 13 days after the video was released of the police attacking Rodney King another travesty of justice occurred in LA, specifically between the Asian American and African American communities, where a Korean woman who ran a convenience store fatality shot a 15 year old girl named Latasha Harlins for supposedly shoplifting. The Korean woman, Soon Ja Du, was sentenced to 10 years in prison for voluntary manslaughter but the sentence was suspended to community service and a measly $500 fine. The injustice of this case added to the emotions that boiled over during the riot and is said to have contributed to so many Korean owned businesses being burned during the riots. A short documentary about Latasha Harlins was made into an Oscar nominated film in 2019 which is how I first learned about this part of history.
I think that it was imperative for one of her spoiled stepsisters, Minerva in particular being black like Brandi, to show her blackness wasn't the motivation for her oppression and exploitation by her stepmother, played by Bernadette Peters who is white. In addition to showing Black women of high status, like Queen Whoopi and Godmother Whitney. Bc it also would have been questionable if Minerva who is part of the comedic slapstick and physical humor duo, was the only other core character bc it could feel like black cast members and characters were subject to abuse or the butt of the jokes.
100%! And in general I think that if any of them had been THE ONLY Black lead, there would be a way to interpret that material/casting negatively as something potentially stereotypical. But since you’ve got all of them in there, you can better understand that no one is saying that that character represents the entirety of their ethnic or cultural identity/experience.
Yeah and also the wonderful Bernadette song that explains her feelings on love. You can tell her hatrid of Brandy comes because of her father and her falling out.
Which while wrong is relatable because so many abusive parents are because they hate the ex and so they take it out on the innocent child.
im now noticing that for my entire life ive been comparing every fantasy romance to Whitneys Cinderella and honestly i will continue to
the timing for this is soo perfect bc even a new star wars show (the acolyte ) has some blasian solidarity! i wish so badly that briderton would've done colorblind casting for every character
The way I would have died for an Asian Eloise and and Latina Featheringtons you don't GET IT
We have two Asian male leads and a female black lead. I’m loving it!
Shondaland had a truly colorblind TV show called Still Star Crossed, and it got canceled before the end of the first season. Maybe the writers thought people wouldn't like it.
The blasian fans are finally getting some real food! And while you're mentioning acolyte, 'Mr and Mrs smith' with Donald Glover and Maya Erskine is also another show with blasian representation that came out earlier this year.
I've been thinking about this topic a lot lately. So many of Bridgerton's problems could've been solved if they had just did colorblind casting. I don't need for my fluffy historical romance to attempt to solve racism or explain why there is no racism. I just want the main couple to have a happy ending and some fun banter between the Bridgertons. If the Bridgertons/Featheringtons had been casted without race in mind, then we wouldn't be at the point where we are now where the love interest has to be a certain race in order to check a box.
romeo must dle and brandys cinderella were my favs growing up and im excited for benedict and sophie with their rendition next!
THOSE TWO COUPLES WERE ICONIC THEN AND ARE STILL ICONIC NOW! 🥰❤️🔥
You are so right about how vibes are important for romance stories, and how a lot can be forgiven if the vibes are right. I feel like this is the case for a lot of genres; horror, romance, and comedy movies don't need to be perfect to be memorable, but they definitely need to have the right vibes.
Also thank you for pronouncing Aaliyah's name correctly, it's so annoying when celebs tell people how to pronounce their names and everyone just runs with a different pronunciation.
When Henry starts making heart-eyes at Catherine within three seconds of meeting her in Northanger Abbey 2007, THAT'S IT, I'M INVESTED. Are they wealthy parasites who do nothing of substance to try to overthrow the colonial empire in which they reside? Probably, but I'm not thinking about it while I'm watching because THE VIBES ARE VIBING! 😆
I justify my Disney+ subscription by watching Whitney/Brandy's Cinderella at least twice a month. The songs still get me in the feels 🥰
@@JaiTheFaeBae Me too! It's one of three things I always watch on it.
Cinderella and Romeo Must Die really did something to my brain. Speaking of the kiss I think they also did the same thing when Ninja Assasin came out.
The lady that plays Lady Danbury said the diversity was always there in UK history really proudly. Yes but not quite the way Bridgerton is presenting it. In a time when new money was resented, I have no doubt that black people that did gain wealth, freedom, independence etc but I don't think they had the easiest time. I quite liked the film Belle for representing that.
For me it gets even more complicated with Bridgerton saying Anthony's off to visit India. Is this a fantasy version of India with no colonisation? Are they travelling by ship while she's heavily pregnant? I love the diverse casting, they should have just kept it simple like you say. No explanations.
WE'RE HERE FOR THE VIBES and I need the people in charge to understand that. Anthony being completely obsessed with Kate, always wanting to cuddle her (and other NSFW things), just obsessed with how much he loves her, being completely unhinged with excitement over her being pregnant, THAT is what we want to see (and more, obviously, but that's the correct vibe). Also Anthony screaming during trivia. HILARIOUS.
@@buffyslyth1517 This!!!! This right here is why I can’t watch the show, have my cake and enjoy it! Cuz at the back of my mind is always “but, colonialism!”
Also a reading rec: the interesting narrative of the life of Olaudah Equiano
This is why the scene where Anthony tries to instruct Kate on how to correctly hold an "English gun" (because apparently the Indian ones were different enough to require unique positioning) made no sense to me... So in this universe, the gun wasn't a European invention that helped colonize the subcontinent?!
I agree with everything you've said, but particularly the VIBES. I did not enjoy S3 - it was stressful, paced badly, the balloon nearly gave me a hernia because I was laughing so hard at how cringe it was, and it was missing the fun Bridgerton family scenes and the fun feel I expect from a fun frothy show. It was neither fun nor frothy and other than some Kanthony scenes that I can get from youtube, I have no desire to rewatch S3.
The vibes were so far removed from what I want from Regency Romance fiction. I was honestly baffled because Nicola and Luke N have had YEARS to build a genuine banter and friendship so in theory, they could have done SO MUCH with that and it didn't feel like they fully embraced the FRIENDS part of the "friends to lovers" concept. I will say though that I've had fun poking around the Polin tag as a 'fix it' to give them the cute vibes that I wanted to see for their season. If they don't fix the vibes for season 4 I will need to see what sort of renewal announcement is given (for how many seasons, which couple is season 5, etc.) to determine how much or how little I will cover the show. Right now my plan for the hiatus is only to do AT MOST 1-2 Bridgerton videos per month. It's really more so like 1 video per month (originally the July video was going to be Francesca's book but that video is taking a lot longer to finish than I thought it would which is why this video came out first 😂).
But also, there are plenty of Bridgerton video topics I have on my to-do list that are not about season 3. I feel like I've made more or less all the points I want to make about season 3 (and my issues with it) that if I'm going to carry on talking about the Bridgerton series I would rather put the energy into topics from the show that I LIKE. 🤭
@@LadyJenevia Thank U Jonathan Simone Kanthony. and their fans deserve better. No wedding Honeymoon real outward courting and plot of this season they trying for baby Kate pregnant but never deliver the baby for us to celebrate their continued love story What u say about a spin Off for them CALLED Kate Anthony Milestones A Bridgerton Un interrupted Love Story
I know how you feel. I've decided that I'm going to try and rewatch season 3 after I forget what a disappointment it is and see if I feel differently towards it.
I have never had anything I have said featured in a video before, and I am so honored to have my first time be a video of yours. I don't always comment, but I have loved your content for years. It is true that Jonathan and Simone paid for the season 2 wrap party. They called it boozy bowling. There are some pics and there was an article about it, but I can't for the life of me find it. I wonder if it was srubeed, but, it is true. I really enjoyed this video. I wish more creatives would talk about this subject,not only for Bridgerton, but all shows that claim diversity in appearance, but the actual stories and plots for the show fall short. I love the concept of Bridgerton, but if season 4 doesn't do better, I don't see myself continuing to watch.
Bravo.
Obviously Black viewers are not a monolith and there will be plenty of variety in the opinions about any number of Black characters in different works but you were making valid points so it made all the sense in the world for me to share them.
I don’t really like to overly nitpick Lady Danbury’s on my main channel (though I DID share more opinions in my Queen Charlotte review for Patreon only 😆). I just felt as though it wouldn’t be productive for me to overly nitpick LD’s material for this video when I can just as easily redirect the train of thought to “You do realise if there was a strategy from the beginning of being suuuuuuper multiracial like Whitney’s Cinderella, this would probably be a much less heated discussion” 😂🤷🏻♀️
@@LadyJenevia What is exciting about your statement that Black viewers are not a monolith is that Black viewership/audience now includes Black people from all over the world from France and Germany, to the US and Canada to the Caribbean and to Africa and the Near East and beyond. Nigeria and South Africa have a budding film industry and increasingly the importance of themes, character development and the semiotics of the camera image is enlarging the conversation. Because of the racism and colorism, featurism and texturism in America, Black viewers may not be in agreement with certain conclusions, but we do, I believe, recognize patterns. So I fascinated by what Africans think when they watch Bridgerton or what Black Parisian or Brazilian thinks. Black people are not a monolith. But Black people need to understand how we are perceived through the power of images and storytelling.
Everytime I think about Jonathan and Simone having to pay for their own party it pisses me off. Because this season compared to their season Nicola and Luke got nothing but promo and parties yet Jonathan and Simone could barely even get any interviews of just the two of them alone because it was always with Charithra. That’s no hate to any of them I just feel like Jimone weren’t treated the same way as everyone during their own season. People love to bring up the fact that it was during covid and yes I can see how that would’ve been an issue, however, people who weren’t even the main cast (the side characters) got an entire group photoshoot together and Jimone could’ve even get one together for Vogue.
I would love to see Lady Danbury rebuild her relationship with her kids and have her own adventures.
Thank you for saying it's not fun to watch bridgerton season 3. I've been meaning to go back and watch it but just don't wanna😭
We were watching season 3 on my Patreon watch parties and were supposed to do part 2 when I got back from my trip but I was so over the overblown melodrama that I just scrapped that and we got back to rewatching Derry Girls 😂🇮🇪
Black Americans knew who Jet Li was in 1996. That fight scene in Once Upon A Time In China II was legend.
'Ninja Assassin ' also had BW/AM leads that didn't share a kiss at the end when they should have.
@@teewhyemm1130 That was irritating... Love that movie...
That movie is my guilty pleasure. Rain (AM) has always been fine. They had so much chemistry too.
@@prettynpetty8342 I love the part where he says, "Oh Mika, Mika." So cute.
@@teewhyemm1130 When I tell you I was screaming, crying, throwing up, and fainting at that part. Like not this butterflies feeling 🦋. I need to rewatch that movie now.
@prettynpetty8342 LOL, I watched it after I made my first comment. 🥰🥰
Regarding the wrap party that Jonathan and Simone paid for, it was published by Daily Mail. For seasons 1 and 3, Netflix/Shondaland paid for those seasons wrap parties but for S2 they only paid for sandwiches after wrap.
I am also glad you pointed out the discrepancy between the press for the all white couple of S3 vs past seasons especially S2. People love to blame covid but they had all the supporting actors doing photoshoots and press all over the place, covid cannot be used as an excuse. Heck they had Rege and Phoebe do a photoshoot for British Vogue few months before the first season's release in 2020, literally the first year of covid when there were no vaccines available. It's very clear they just didn't want to promote Kanthony thus Jonathan and Simone as the main leading pair of the season. And I can't help but see how it is most likely due to racism (since Phoebe and Nicola seem to have gotten so much more press as the romantic female leads unlike Simone) and homophobia with them not caring to promote Jonathan and Simone since they can't push the pr dating agenda that the Bridgerton pr team seems to have pushed for Nicola and Luke. Like for a romance show, you would think that the leading actors would have gotten at least one photoshoot together but nope they couldn't even bother doing that for them. They just didn't care to promote Simone and Jonathan as the leading couple and it stinks of bigotry especially when Netflix/Shondaland have a history of treating their non-white and queer actors unfairly.
Jonathan and Simone don't need fake-dating rumours to sell the show! The chemistry was simply THAT GOOD that all you need to do is put them together. Also, they can still look good together in a photoshoot, what does that have anything to do with fake-dating for PR? Dress them up in some exquisite fashion and have them pose! I still want someone with SENSE (and a whole lot of money and influence) to pair them together for another rom com/romance story. If Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks can do two Rom Coms together and Julia Roberts and George Clooney can play married couples 20+ years apart, WHAT MORE IS THERE TO UNDERSTAND? 😂
@@LadyJenevia Exactly! They both looked absolutely gorgeous together in season 2 and 3, they have that spark and charisma that is often rare to find nowadays on TV or even in movies. I truly hope they can work together in a romcom or so, cause their chemistry is just that amazing. They both also have had great photoshoots done individually and are extremely photogenic, they would have looked amazing together in a photoshoot for sure.
I also felt that the writers did not play fair with the storyline in season 2. I love season 2 and I adore Anthony and Kate. Their chemistry is electric. I wasn't too keen on the Viscount in his book - I think Lady Jenevia called him a toxic caveman, which summed him up and Kate was just too compliant. Their show characters were much more suited. However, the story itself was rather bland and too much like Season 1 (forced marriage). It certainly needed some changes to liven it up, but why did the writers make it SO complicated. It really did require careful watching and judging by many posts on Facebook and on CZcams a great many people totally misunderstood the story and thus misjudged the characters, turning Kate and Anthony into villains, which they certainly were not. It saddens me that so many viewers became haters and I blame the writers for that, Those of us who took the trouble to follow the storyline carefully, were treated to a beautiful love story, superbly acted.
@@AuntieM27 I agree. I think that main issue with the storyline in S2 is that the writing paints Kate and Anthony as villains when that is not what is supposed to be happening. I am not a book purist so when I saw them change some storylines I wasn’t fazed. I do feel like they didn’t have to drag the love triangle when they could’ve focused more on their PTSD as individuals and their inner conflict that comes with choosing your heart over everyone else.
Even though its still my preferred season out of all 3 its still disappointing to see how the writing made our leads look selfish and inconsiderate.
I agree! By trying to give a logical explanation to the racial diversity, they pull you out of the story and it only ends up highlighting all the points that make it illogical. Even their in world explanation doesn’t work because do we really think that in a single generation all backlash of interracial relationships would just be gone? Violet was almost a teenager when society removed segregation, and yet her children have zero backlash, even from the older member of the ton, for intermarrying? As a white woman married to a black man in America, where society has been integrated for considerably longer than a generation, and who has faced a lot of backlash for my choice of spouse, their explanation is illogical. I would much rather they took the Cinderella approach and just cast people who were fantastic actors and let us really enjoy the story without explanations
aaliyah said in an interview that they had screen tested a kiss but it didn’t bode well with the focus groups
Pity.
They should’ve done it anyways. That’s what Star Trek and it pissed people off and made millions of minority children and adults scream, “hell yes!” 😂 I’m mixed myself. My dad is black and my mom is white. Sci-Fi has always been more inclusive IMO.
16:18 can I just say how gorgeous Bernadette still is!!
In the theater I saw it in, there was communal yelling at the screen that there was no kiss. The collective "WTF" at the end was a moment. 😂
Wow! The timing is amazing. I just rewatched Whitney’s Cinderella with my niece so she could experience how amazing it truly was and still is even after all this time❤✨ and when we watched the new Descendants movie she was so happy to see them back together as the parents! It was so cute and moving! Bringing it all together!
I feel the sudden need to rewatch Mr Malcolm's List.
Yesss, definitely rewatch it! 🥳🫶🏻✨
OMG, I LOVE Mr. Malcolm's List. One of the few movies I have actually purchased so I can watch it as many times as my heart desires.
The historical deep dives in this video are actually so fascinating! Also... the Cinderella casting makes me think of theatre where they really _do_ often cast in a colourblind way. They probably should have done so with the Bridgerton family too to avoid some of the unfortunate connotations the show sometimes has.
36:57 also the cutaways to "What did we learn on the show tonight, Craig?" and Eames' "you mustn't be afraid to dream a little bigger darling" 41:09 had me screaming... the editing is too good!
Love this video! When they put Cinderella on Disney+ I cried it brought back so many memories. I played that vhs OUT.
When Brandy and Paolo do their meet cute I just DIE from how good they are together. It’s just ICONIC 😍🤩🥳
Here for all the Blasian content - more please ❤
NGL my mixed race kid self thought this being as multi cultural as it was was normal. Like the royal family not looking alike but being related made total sense to me because that is my family
Season 2 of Bridgerton is the best for me, I will not be rewatching season 3 and I highly doubt I will watch season 4 because how they wasted Benedict in season 3, and kind of jacked up Francesca and John’s story.
I love diversity and Whitney Houston’s Cinderella, Romeo Must die( it annoyed me that they didn’t kiss!) and Rush Hour are three films that I enjoyed and still enjoy!
A great video essay Lady Jenevia! 😊
I am curious how the really casual audience is responding to season 3 because I’m assuming they don’t have THAT many complaints if they’re still tuning in to watch it. TBH I think the 2 year gaps between seasons are more harmful than the issues I addressed in this video. People grow, evolve, and move on to newer things. I don’t mind doing ONE video per season whenever a new one drops but if seasons 4 onward stick with the melodrama angle I won’t be emotionally invested anymore. 😅
@@LadyJenevia taking 2 years for each season is gonna be insanely damaging for them. if you do the math there’s 8 seasons and for each season it takes two years in between to film. that’s 16 years of production plus when the season is releasing. by that time florence (hyacinth) will be in her 30s playing whatever age she’s supposed to be when she gets married 😭.
The article is Daily Mail, “After all those Regency balls, Bridgerton stars revel in booze-up at the bowling” from Nov 27, 2021, author Katie Hind
I cant lie. I wanted John & Michael to be East Asian or SEA. They didnt even need to be the same race as they are cousins not brothers. The actor who plays John is great i just remember being a bit disappointed that we still only have EA & SEA actors playing idiots or simpering bg characters.
Also, it's definitely a...choice...to keep the Queen alive when only the first book or two are set during her lifetime.
sophie is going to be east asian
Why can’t she be Latina?
I was hoping for that too.
I’m not surprised or excited about Sophie being SEA/EA. I don’t want to expand on why.
@@madelion24 I must have responded to a comment to a comment here, but I don’t see it.
@@rosedalinevaletine6931right I personally don’t know how to explain it but I’m not
There was another Shondaland series that came before Bridgerton that did the colour blind casting ala Cinderella called Still Star Crossed it was sooo good but it got very little promo and I'm convinced ABC wanted the show to fail
The shirt looks like you've just lifted it off the bed of the husband you just killed and you are on your way to give your alibi to the police. Honestly, a perfect look
THIS SOUNDS LIKE THE PLOT OF A MOVIE I WOULD WATCH AND LOVE 😂
I love how Cinderella offered no explanations because it didn't need too. It's a fantasy, a fairytale. Anything can happen.
I literally just listen to your vids regarding bridgrerton and I love every angle you explore this show with one can see the love and labour gone into this !!! Lots of love 🤍🤍
I actually had the ‘Blasian Solidarity’ video in my head for YEARS but I kept feeling pressured by CZcams to put it off “because algorithms” and then I found a way to thread it into Bridgerton and I jumped at the excuse. 😂
I need the Blasian solidarity movies to have a comeback! There’s been more Blasian couples in shows and movies as of late, but I need more stuff on the big screen featuring us together!
Wow. I couldn't believe I just agree with every single thing you said and also got a "small history lesson" at the same time
Also, I have something else to say. That's all I've been thinking for a few years now and not enough people talk about it.
Especially the "marrige ends racism", most of my friends have either both or at least one parent black and more than one has spoke about suffering racism from their own grandparents who don't accept their children married a different skin color. If imeddiate family can be left unconvinced in situations like these, how do you want me to believe a whole country would be ok with it? They claim "fantasy", but it's too close to home to suspend disbelief. And mind you that my country's history tells that black people were incentivated to marry white people so the next generations would be "less black"(no need to say that it backfired), so even being common to see interacial couples everywhere prejudice very much still exists centurys later, one couple, the very same year of their marrige in a vrry white england, fixed it all?
They use the "it's a fantasy" card for everything and never really laid out their worldbulding properly, which shoved them to corners they didn't antecipate.
Other races families (asians, indians, blacks)are valued because a black woman married a white man even if other races had nothing to do with it, because fantasy. But gay people are closeted because "the time period".
The aristocracy living of taxes and exploiting other people to live very superfulus lives is not talked about, and they talk like we talk today, because fantasy.
But women suffer sexism because "time period".
They don't draw a line where it ends, they don't know the rules of their own world, they keep contraditing themselves, all because they want to explain everything when they could've just go with stuff and let people enjoy being creative as well (and yes, a real colorblind cast would be a good way to go no questions needed), that goes from the ton itself to the costuming, the formal situations and manners (practically inexistent at this point). They lack solid ground.
Literally the more they try to explain things the worse it gets. All you have to do is Jane Austen except in Elizabeth Bennet’s family, everyone is a different ethnicity/culture a la Whitney Houston’s Cinderella. THAT’S IT. And crank the romantic yearning and banter up to an 11 out of 10, add some NSFW scenes (that only appear after enough emotional / relationship buildup) and you’re good!
I'm so glad you made this video!!! I was saying to friends just last month that Bridgerton casting should have gone the same route as Whitney Houston's Cinderella, and I absolutely ate up this video!
I think some people are averse to the use of the word "colour-blind" because they associate that with people in charge being exclusionary by going "anyone can audition" but then they don't think enough about diversity in the sense that you do need to keep it in mind so that you proactively pursue being more diverse, inclusive, not falling into tropes/stereotypes that could have easily been avoided, etc. When people say they want "colour-blind" casting like Cinderella (1997) we mean that we want it to go SO FAR FORWARD that you break new ground towards creating a truly multiracial ensemble at every level of the story (main characters, supporting leads, extras, etc.) and creating multiracial families without explaining the reason why the family is multiracial because the explanation really ISN'T NECESSARY for the story to play out as is.
@@LadyJenevia yes! When I was super young, I lived in the Middle East, and as a small child, I didn't register that I was "different" (I'm white), until the adults started pointing it out to me. And like, that's what I want in shows like Bridgerton and why I fell in love with Whitney's Cinderella. Worlds where people don't feel the need to point out "oh you're white/black/Asian/Arab" and instead everyone is just human. Because we are!
Which is not to say that we don't need shows and stories that do tackle systemic racism. We absolutely do. But we need to present a vision for a world where race is not a defining feature of how we perceive and treat each other, as well as challenge the ways in which we currently do perceive and treat each based on race.
Have you watched Space Sweepers? I don't know if sci-fi is your thing, but I adored the way the universal translator was depicted: everyone got to speak their own language, and they all understood each other. Like, the "solution" to differences (cultural, linguistic, racial, etc) is not to make everyone the same, but to not let those differences become barriers. Plus, the villain is a white capitalist, which I appreciated.
Oh, and to follow up, just thinking of Star Trek: I loved that in OG Star Trek you had Nichelle Nichols, George Takei and a character who was meant to be Russian in such prominent roles without their races and heritages being A Thing™️. And I hated when Discovery came out that the marketing made it A Thing™️ that Michael is black. They should have just let Star Trek continue to be a world where race was irrelevant to the roles characters could have, either within Star Fleet or in the story-telling.
Did earlier Star Treks get it all right? No, of course not, but isn't the point to always be learning and growing? And, with Star Trek, to again be creating a vision of a world where systemic racism has been undone.
I always love watching your videos, and a point I would like to add on is their choice for the “explaining diversity in the period drama” leaves questions/opportunities they are not willing to answer or follow through on. For example, I think you’ve mentioned on your season 2 review the issue of these British ppl going to India, and how colonization is still probably happening but we the audience are supposed to ignore that. As someone who studies ethnic studies, it’s hella jarring to ignore that a lot of these wealthy ppl including BIPOC would’ve gotten their wealth from slavery/colonization. Another is we don’t get more into was cultures these characters come from besides the Sharma family and that’s because Simone pushed for it. For the Black characters i asked my friend what is the culture for Black Brits as I understand that it is not the same for Black Americans, and she explained it’s the mixture of African and Caribbean cultures due to majority being from immigrant families. This made me think of other cultures like what does different Asian cultures in Britain are like. I would like to see that on my screen if I’m supposed to understand that racism is not an unheard thing in this universe and from Queen Charlotte is actually a plot point. I also need them to hire more writers of color for these stories. And I agree with your opinion on how they should’ve went with the Bridgerton/Featheringtons being a multi-racial families because I think it would eliminate the scarcity mentality of which race/ethnicity gets to be leading lady/man. It allows for everyone to get a chance to see themselves on screen. Sorry for the long comment, I really enjoy your videos, they are always so engaging with the topics you introduce. Thank you for creating them.
Yes to soooooooo much of this. The Regency Romance setting was always riddled with privilege stemming from especially dubious origins but we love to get into those stories because it’s just about viiiiiiiiiibes. I remember being a child and hearing Mrs B go on and on about “5000 a year” and “10000 a year” for Mr Bingley and Mr Darcy’s income and thinking “What is their job? I’ve never seen them go to work ONCE” but then I just didn’t prod it further because it was ultimately about the romantic viiiiiiiibes and hilarious family banter (only the 1995 version had that, to be clear, the whole family was hilarious). 😂
All we need to love the Bridgerton characters are romantic vibes and hilarious family banter (and heartwarming moments too). It doesn’t need to be overcomplicated, it’s not the right premise to tackle those topics the way they would need to be addressed.
@@LadyJenevia EXACTLY! I just wanna watch these folks fall in love, like don’t force me to now question the merits of their wealth and society lol. I feel like Bridgerton wants to have its cake n eat it too you know? Like I know shondaland is known for its drama but I’ve always felt that even Shonda’s other productions i.e Scandal, Greys Anatomy etc don’t do a good job in tackling the themes of race and class. And for a romance show like Bridgerton adding in those elements that the show runners are not entirely comfortable with telling or and let’s face it, can fully authentically understand will just make your viewers more upset in my opinion.
Love 1997 Cinderella Brandy perfect Cinderella
TRULY ICONIC, THE BLUEPRINT, THE STANDARD, NEVER BEEN OUTDONE
Firstly, yes, love romeo must die and Whitney's cinderella. Go to happy films from my childhood. Thank you for talking about them and also give me more passion projects. Also hell yes to S4 giving me more vibes. The actors have beautiful friendships and chemistry as a family, I want that on screen!!!!
So the bridgerton discourse. You are right Jonny and Simone paid for their season wrap party as netflix wasn't throwing one. But that was Nov 2021 in UK, we were still dealing with covid issues (I know my work was hampered by an outbreak following a team gathering at that time) and I suspect due to the production shutting down apparently 3 times during filming due to outbreaks, netflix probably thought (wrongly) that it was irresponsible to promote a social gathering by throwing a wrap party in case it caused a superspreader event (those were fun).
Regarding the lack of press and tour for S2, Jonny Bailey was involved with a westend play from Feb 2022 through till June 2022, doing 8 shows a week over 6 days. This massively limited his availability for press. Throw in the drama surrounding his play co-star catching covid then ending up dropping out the play, he probably didn't want to do too much press dodging questions about that. This was at a time people wanted to get back to in person appearances rather than zoom ones. Why him and simone didn't do the junket alone I don't know, the show seemed to push the unnecessary triangle between the sisters.
In both situations there is more to it than it seems initially but netflix do not get off scot free, in both cases they could've done better (reimbursed Jonny and simone for the party, even if they had organised it, they shouldn't be covering the cost, done more to give Jonny and Simone some promo or where jonny couldn't do promo e.g. in America, let's have both Simone and Charithra talk about being sisters)
We will have to see what happens when we eventually reach promo for S4. We know Luke Thompson, likely lead of S4 doesn't do social media and is guarded when it comes to talking about anything other than his work (good for him) will be interesting to see who his costar is and if the 2 of them agree to undertaking a press tour or have the opertunity to do so. I'd love to know how much of press is in actors contract and how much is them willing/agreeing to do it. Also will netflix go all out for press following S4 when in some ways this press tour could've been so big to ensure the numbers stay up so they guarantee the S5&6 renewal. If that renewal comes soon after they get the final 91 day viewing figures, we'll know why they promo'd the hell out of it, they needed numbers for the renewal guarantee
I really enjoy how thorough this video was. When I first started watching Bridgerton I wasn't even thinking about race until they mention it. Honestly, I thought it was going to be like Brady Cinderella where in that universe that fantasy world race didn't exist. I love how you brought up one of my favorite movies. Hearing of all this reminds me of a book that turned into movie the sun is also a star. I personally prefer the book but yes, I love that you mention ways to properly executing cross culture friendships whether it's in a form of blasian solidarity or other interracial relationship. I love a good movie or book that knows how to allow the character to be a character without restricting them because they form their own conclusion or fear that it would not be receive well in the real world. Or because of their close mindedness and bias falseness. It reminds me of a character I love in a show but since the writers had a biased opinion of their race, they didn't allow the character to be a character. Someone did an essay video called The "Updateable" BIPOC CO-STAR. Which goes more into depth on topics like these. But it does rise an issue later down in the storyline and cause the character to be singled out, which no longer makes sense not only for the character but for the whole plot of story.
This is exactly right. This is something I have been saying for years not just in Bridgerton but in Hollywood in general that they feel like they have a need to explain why people of color are on screen. like you can't just have a POC in a show or movie without explaining to there audience why they are their in the first place it's rude and I feel more racist then not putting use there in the first place. Bridgeton bated us into believing there was going to be true diversity, but all we got was 2 main white family's every season and interchangeable people of color for every season except Queen Charlotte and lady Danbary. If the Bridgeton or and Featherington where also diverse it would have meant so much more. The only other show I feel like came even close to Brady's Cinderella was " Still star crossed " from ABC that sadly got cancelled after 1 season, that didn't even get completed. Surprisingly it was a Shandland show as well. It had true color blind casting with no explanations as to why people look how they look and are related to each other, in that time period. It just was what it was.
Mind reader! I was about to go on a rant about this, so excited to hear your perspective!
@@jamdoe6486 Rant away, the comments section is open (within reason, of course 😂)
I work in tv production and the wrap party happens at the end of filming and includes talent and crew. Typically factored into the “expendables” part of the location section for a show’s budget, they can be super expensive ranging from a couple of thousand to tens of thousands of dollars for an evening party at a restaurant or on location with catering. Talent usually don’t fund these parties because they usually host their own but showrunners tend to pay for them more often. It’s a tax write-off for them. I have no idea how many people work on this series but wrap parties tend to only include crew on site for filming and not post production, so 2/3 of the crew participate. Hadn’t heard the rumor about Bailey and Ashley paying for it but when episodes cost $7mil (average) to film, that’s wild to know they possibly didn’t have enough budget for a wrap party.
Your videos are so great! I appreciate how you set media into the historical and cultural context and the world of business. Art is ALWAYS a product of its time and that is so often lost in the discussion of media. Please keep reminding us of the connection between the world at large and things the things we love to watch/ read/ listen to. 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿 Also, love Brandy Cinderella 🫶🏿. I still sing the songs to this day!
Some works of art are more/less political than others but all art is influenced by the world and circumstances surrounding it! ❤️🔥
Thank you for your support! 😊
Aaliyah was such a talented woman. It makes me mad that we’ve all been pronouncing her name wrong for decades.
Oh I LOVE this video. I distinctly remember getting Cinderella on VHS for my birthday after it came out ❤. If they would have built Bridgerton this way it would have been SO much better. As usual, another amazing video from you.
PLEASE MAKE A FULL VIDEO ON BRANDY'S CINDERELLA 😭 I need that in my life!
Also as a side note I found it really funny when the whole controversy with The Little Mermaid happened and in the back of my mind I kept thinking y'all would absolutely fume if you knew about Brandy's Cinderella😂
You did this video well. Brandy’s cinderella deserves her own video. But you made some excellent points about the casting choices. They should have taken a page from Whitney’s (Queen mutha) creation.
Lady J, I love that shirt on you. It looks super chic 🥰
P.S. It didn’t escape my attention, as a woman of colour, that the couple that was given the most press was the one couple in Bridgerton that was entirely white.
Thank you! I more or less NEVER go shopping recreationally unless I’m back in 🇯🇵 because it’s where I can find clothes that actually fit me AND that I like the style of so now while I’m filming videos I get to try out different things I got there! 🤗
Finallyyyyy!!! Not enough people talk abt the BEST Cinderella movie ever made the songs arent even on spotify its a DISGRACE
Whitney Houston's Cinderella is the GOAT production period. The fact that the production team was so on point and made sure the background actors also relected the level of diversity we saw in the lead cast, it just felt natural, and as a Bay Area native (shoutout Oakland) it reflected the world in which I grew up.
It would've been amazing if Shondaland's production team had "dreamed bigger" and went with the Brandy style colorblind casting, with Black, Asian, Indian, etc. actor's making up the Bridgerton family. But hopefully this is a jumping off point instead of a foot note.
Also here for the Blasian movie trifecta, Romeo Must Die and Rush Hour were some of my favs growing up. Would've also loved to see a mention of Mr. Malcolm's List, tangential representation and a delightful movie.
I'm about a minute into the video, but I just had to stop to let you know the cool shirt and awesome makeup combo makes you look like a fabulous vampire on vacation 😍
So… Morticia Addams? 😂
I LOVE HER BTW 😎🌹🥀
@@LadyJeneviaomg yes, i love her too! I also really loved the thoughts you shared in this video, definitely will be checking out the rest of your content ❤🌹🥀
That diverged wildly form where I initially assumed we were being taken, but I appreciated the journey, in the end. Thanks.
Yay, I'm glad you appreciated it! I just really wanted an excuse to talk about those movies because I LOVE THEM. 😊
I will always check with you first Lady J before I watch any entertainment media. You are so intelligent. Thank you for sharing your great insights!
Thank you so much for watching, every little bit of support helps! 🙂↕️
I am so in love with this take! I have always held Whitney Houston’s Cinderella on a different level than anything I’ve ever watched that tried to “add” diversity. I first watched it when I was 4 years old and think about it always! 10 minutes so g and sequence lives rent free in my head. Thank you so much for talking about it and the mark it made for so many people and the movie industry. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
There’s people saying that Whitney’s Cinderella casting the way it did only works because it is for children and truly what a WILD take. It’s not only children that watched and loved it. 😂
@@LadyJenevia 🤣 absolutely a wild take!!! My mom loved that movie and would watch it with me if it ever was on abc movie night or when I would break out the vhs 🥰 it was a family sing-along-long ( she is a Whitney fan and musical fan) ❤️
Loved this video. Thank you for this! I remember recording and rewatching Cinderella on repeat as a kid. Truly amazing & completely disappointing it’s not been done again in other media. Also I loved the segue with the Late Show with Craig Ferguson meme thrown in there.
If I randomly think of a reference that makes sense at a particular point I will try to get the clip I need to make it happen. 😂
Also the news source I’ve seen regarding the wrap party of Season 2 with Johnny and Simone is found by the Daily Mail. The Article is titled: “After all those Regency balls, Bridgerton stars revel in booze-up at the bowling”
I must subscribe now. Loved all of your takes. If we could just get Disney to remaster the 1997 Cinderella version so its at least 1080p and has dolby because that movie is a masterpiece.
When I first started season 1 I thought they were doing Cinderella casting and was so shocked when it wasn’t that! Would have been so easy
How funny,I just rewatched this Cinderella a few days ago!
It’s always a good time to rewatch it! 🤗🫶🏻✨
I really do like this video that you made. it brings up the conversation that writers and other people making movies and TV shows need to be having.
I remember as a 90s kid watching Brandi's Cinderella and similar to you, I wasn't analysing the diversity. I don't think I even processed it as, 'she was a black Cinderella'. I remember thinking she was someone who looked so similar to me without linking it to her being black. I think kids are very good at embracing the effects of something without knowing/understanding why it has that effect.
In the reunion panel there was mention of a “before” and “after” of watching that movie but if you grew up watching it as a child? There wouldn’t really be a “before”. It would simply go into SHAPING how you understand the world and humanity itself, and what’s possible. 🥰
Thank you for this video, it just took me back to my childhood! I watched all of these hundreds of times I absolutely loved them all. You are absolutely right when it comes to Bridgerton s3. There are on a few scenes I would go back and watch. This season was just different and not fun. I think I will go back and watch these movies though 😊
Yessssss, always fun to go back and watch some classics! Enjoy your movie marathon!
Ohhh, "Romeo must Die"☺️☺️☺️ as someone who isn't American I didn't know Aaliyah was a singer and who Jet Li was. But, girl... after watching that movie, I was obsessed with both!
The chemistry was of the charts, Jet Li became my top action man next to Van Damme and I wanted to grow up and look like Aaliyah.😅😅😅
You didn't know Aaliyah was a singer? 😢omg I don't know what music you like but please listen to her 3 albums. She was, and will always be ICONIC
One in a million is my favourite! Album and song by her. Rock the boat is her last music video
That press tour couples thing - could it be that Bridgerton might be losing steam, and the producers are trying to ramp up the appeal to the more traditional romance *novel* audience? Just a random thought. Frankly, I love the first season and was willing to suspend disbelief and enter this alternate multi-cultural universe, probably because Regé-Jean Page was so watchable. His chemistry with Pheobe was excellent, and I found the characters compelling. Seasons 2 and 1/2 of 3 (yeah, I never made it to the second half of the third season) struck me as overblown and less interesting. I dropped out. They are not taking the necessary time to develop the characters as interesting in their own right. Getting worse for me as the series wears on. (Sacrificing character development for soap opera level 'plot'.) Boring. (to me)
EDIT: Cinderella -- YEEEEEESSSSS! "Love plus love equals love."
Season 2 had an entire subplot that could have (SHOULD HAVE) been scrapped but the chemistry and vibes of Jonny and Simone truly carried it to where it’s still the season I revisit the most. Romance fans just want the main couple(s) to VIBE, there is zero need to over complicate that. 😆❤️✨
I clicked so fast seeing that someone is talking about my favourite version of Cinderella since i was 3 years old. Nothing! Comes close
Time to watch Romeo must die! I feel like I watched it before maybe it’s been too long?
Definitely recommend going back and watching/rewatching it! ❤️🔥
I always love your passion project videos. I just listened to your Elvis video on a drive the other day! SO good! Everyone should go watch - it gave me a greater appreciation for a film I already enjoyed.
I LOOOOOOOOOOVE THAT MOVIE and myself and another stan of it (and all the geniuses involved like Baz Luhrmann, Catherine Martin, Austin Butler), we have been miffed seeing everyone bully the movie and Austin only to start to tiptoe back towards them… NO, WE’LL BE GATEKEEPING NOW CAUSE WE REMEMBER ALL THE NASTY THINGS YOU SAID (though this is a cycle Baz has with literally every movie he’s made where people talk trash and then you fast forward a certain number of years and then people correctly acknowledge it’s a classic 😭)
@LadyJenevia My spouse was listening to the Elvis video, too, and he was absolutely floored to learn that Baz has been snubbed from the Oscars! I feel the same way where I really only want to gatekeep when I felt like I had to *rightfully* defend something repeatedly. Like, you don't deserve this greatness now.
Very interesting analysis co paring Bridgerton/Cinderella/RomeoMustDie/RushHour.
3:40 So I actually looked into this because i was very curious when the press tour started and people began complaining. The earliest i could find is a pretty recent Reddit post linking to a Daily Mail article with picture of the cast leaving the party and there was a screenshot of a tweet but I can't find it anymore. All I could find after that was an interview where Johnathan Bailey and Simone Ashley said they had another wrap party that they organised at a bowling alley but there were no mention of Netflix (and why would they during promotion). Then I couple days ago i was listening to with Nicola and Luke with the BBC where they were talking about the press tour and how extensive it was she mentioned that it was their first bridgerton season post covid restrictions and that Jonathan Bailey had been doing a play during the season 2 roll out (like Luke Thompson this year). That all i could find after that it's not much and i doesn't really change the optics.
P.S: I was going to say your shirt is giving Romeo + Juliet and that not a bad thing at all.
I fully believe that if there is hard evidence publicly available about this, online teamwork will track it down. 😂
As for my shirt, aaaaaaaaaah, I’m assuming you’re referencing the 1996 Romeo + Juliet I’m taking that as the absolute HIGHEST compliment because that’s a Baz Luhrmann film, he’s one of my absolute favourite directors, and his wife Catherine Martin does the costumes for all his movies and she is an absolute icon, truly, a legend in her field! 😍🔥
Lady Jenevia you had me cackling and appreciating your insights. Thank you for this, very enjoyable! Forever Brandy as Cinderella, period and the love nostalgia for the Y2K's Blasian classic movies.
Fantastic video!!! Not sure why YT recommended it to me, but Im glad they did.
Sidenote: In my experience as an American black woman in America, Rush Hour has not aged AT ALL!!! The jokes HIT...ALL of Them.
Great video. Thanks for sharing!
i know for a fact this was served to me by the algorithm because of brandy and paolo's names and the fact that've been watching descendants 4 videos lmao, and i am thankful!
Istg this is all the things I like and hits all my favourite nostalgia notes, only way it could’ve been better is if it somehow included the interracial love story featured in The Golden Child (1986)
Love this video! These films were my favorites; I used to watch Romeo Must Die a lot when it came out. Way before social media and the K-pop boom was these films.
Brandy is my favorite Cinderella😭😭 ugh the music is so good toooo
Honestly only reason I clicked is because I saw my favorite Cinderella. 😂❤
💯💯💯💯 % I agree with everything you said. And I see our love is mutual for one of the BEST Cinderella movies ever made. Thank you for showing it love! ❤
Firstly, your giving bad b with that outfit. Love you in that new top! Now, onto the video! LOVE your analysis of what Bridgerton is getting wrong with their leads, the episode count and CINDERELLA. I'm a 80s baby, so you KNOW I was obsessed with Brandy and Whitney Houston their version of Cinderella. I mean Whitney Houston as godmother? Perfection. Thank you for giving an interesting historical landscape. It's crazy how much the LA riots are misremembered (due to media mostly). Interesting from my end was being a little girl watching it on TV and later on VHS it felt normal to see the cast and nothing felt pandering or confusing. It just felt like the community I grew up in. I feel like you make a compelling argument about actual diversity and over explanation.
Thank youuuuuu, I love how the shirt looks!
And Whitney Houston produced the hell out of her projects! Cinderella, Princess Diaries, Cheetah Girls, SHE WAS DELIVERING! 🥰🥳🫶🏻
The “Try Again” music video!!!! YES!!!!!!!!!!!
THIS VIDEO. So good, I wish I could give it multiple thumbs up!
That's soooooooo nice of you to say, thank you kindly! 🥰
Loved Brandy's Cinderella as a kid. It was my favorite version for the prince. Funny enough I ended up marrying an Asian man (from India)! I do like how Bridgerton doesn't have inexplicably mixed families. My grandparents were Latino and Caucasian, so my mom is biracial. It was a big part of her identity growing up and definitely had an impact on me as well. My dad is a white man from Wyoming, but my mom's brother married a Mexican woman. I'm extremely fair skinned and have red hair. My cousins look Latino and are fluent in Spanish and English. My kids are biracial. In all of these interracial relationships, appearance, culture, and country of origin have had a huge impact on how our families function, hold values, and impact our choices. I like that the Bridgerton families actually look like their parents and the show interacts with racial content. It's much closer to my actual life experience. The way Cinderella approached race seems more appropriate for a kid's show. I can appreciate them both in their contexts.
3:40 I saw a post on reddit! There’s no way I can find it now, but I think JB mentioned it in an interview and I saw a screenshot of his comment posted on Reddit. But yes, I can confirm, at least, the post does exist somewhere on the internet.
Let me know if you manage to track it down! 👀
@@LadyJenevia fs!
I just made a comment about this, but that they “had to” pay for it is really not a big deal.
@@LadyJenevia hey, i was able to find that post after all! but how do i share it if links are disabled??
My mom used to show me Double Platinum all the time when I was growing up, but I’ve never seen the 1997 adaptation of Cinderella before! I definitely want to check it out now. And I love the explanation given for the casting of the prince and his parents (love + love = love ❤). Bridgerton missed out on great opportunity to be more diverse by making the main cast more multiracial. They may not be able to remedy this now, but the show is making steps toward being more inclusive by making members of the Bridgerton family queer. I’ve seen criticisms of Benedict’s S3 storyline following certain stereotypes. I’m hoping that the writers’ room is diverse enough that Benedict’s queer identity can be written with the respect and care it deserves for S4. Additionally, now that it has been confirmed in the show that Benedict is queer, I think this would be a great opportunity to introduce multiple queer characters into the supporting cast for his season. Benedict did say to Eloise on the swings that the next thing he learns might change him entirely. It’s hard to discover new facets of your identity in isolation. Have Benedict find a community where he feels safe enough to explore, to question, and to grow. Because he certainly won’t have the freedoms to do that around some of the more bigoted members of the Ton.