Dolores Keane - Caledonia (With On-Screen Lyrics)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 03. 2013
  • Beautiful version of this Scottish love song by Irish singer Dolores Keane.
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 488

  • @user-yy1on8hm7c
    @user-yy1on8hm7c Před 4 měsíci +24

    Only after burying our beautiful daughter 2 days ago 33 yrs old,she played this song on her travels to Vincent's hospital fr treatment,left behind broken hearted mother father 2 brothers a little 3 year old,,,liver cancer.,this song guts us all here listening to it,beautiful song.

    • @tombermingham4800
      @tombermingham4800 Před 4 měsíci

      Sincere condolences 🙏

    • @World_of_Oasis
      @World_of_Oasis Před 3 měsíci

      Sorry for your loss. Be strong ❤

    • @jtb1245
      @jtb1245 Před 3 měsíci

      Sending you Love ❤️

    • @therealdeal5319
      @therealdeal5319 Před měsícem +2

      💚🙏🇮🇪 someday you'll be reunited with god life is just a journey
      Sure she's watching down and wanting you to be happy everyday until you meet again
      Gbless🙏

    • @user-yy1on8hm7c
      @user-yy1on8hm7c Před měsícem

      Thank you.

  • @cionnaithoriagain8836
    @cionnaithoriagain8836 Před 6 lety +630

    I'm drunk, so I need to get this off my chest, I heard I was gonna be a dad for the first time while listening to this song in a Killarney traditional Irish pub, sadly we lost the baby but I end up here every time I'm drunk, I've since been blessed with 3 beautiful children and I know I'm so lucky ! But it still kills me, first time commenting, ignore me

    • @Donalob
      @Donalob Před 5 lety +35

      I love comment's like these, telling a story. Glad that you're happy now lad.

    • @padraigcassidy9129
      @padraigcassidy9129 Před 5 lety +17

      Yeah you got to know tragedy early but credit to you both you never gave up, know Blessed with three beautiful children, hope your all in good health n enjoying life, I'm just a bloke, listening to our Mary. Happy life, little Angel in Heaven n I'm a family guy no religion.

    • @michaeldelaney9845
      @michaeldelaney9845 Před 5 lety +10

      Ya be sound lad life can be shite at time but look at what u have many would love to be u

    • @darren62750
      @darren62750 Před 5 lety +10

      Congratulations on your 3 beautiful kids . I’m heading to Killarney tomorrow night. What a great town

    • @aidenoleary7406
      @aidenoleary7406 Před 5 lety +12

      Beautiful story. As a new dad i feel it

  • @marionlong1561
    @marionlong1561 Před 3 lety +228

    My husbands favoutite song played at our wedding and 14 months later at his funeral he took his oen life and the words now mean so much 2 me

    • @achimpfefferkorn3019
      @achimpfefferkorn3019 Před 3 lety +22

      Dear Marion, I am very sorry for the loss of your husband. I lost one brother the same way. Our loved ones are always with us in our hearts. Stay healthy. Achim from Zurich

    • @williemobrien
      @williemobrien Před 2 lety +10

      ❤❤❤

    • @eoinm5758
      @eoinm5758 Před 2 lety +12

      Wow sorry to hear that

    • @marionlong1561
      @marionlong1561 Před 2 lety +6

      @@eoinm5758 thank u 💓

    • @eoinm5758
      @eoinm5758 Před 2 lety +15

      @@marionlong1561 gave me goosebumps on my arms reading your comment and listening to the song

  • @elizabethmorrissey-gh9ru

    My mother sang this at my Grandmothers funeral, every time I hear this gorgeous track I immediately think about my beautiful grandmother and I love her so much ❤

  • @lauraduggan6073
    @lauraduggan6073 Před 4 lety +119

    My brother died 7 years. This was his favourite song, not so much mine because I was fed up of him singing it day in day out. Caledonia was played at his funeral and everytime i heard it since he died it made me burst into tears. I just couldn't listen to it :( So many times I got up and walked out of a room if it came on and 7 years of family gatherings without him, someone/everyone got up and sang his favourite song. A few weeks ago it came on the radio while i was driving and I didn't cry. I guess that means after 7 years I'm after coming to terms with the loss of my brother.
    Let me tell you that I love you and I think about you all the time ❤

  • @World_of_Oasis
    @World_of_Oasis Před 3 měsíci +9

    Anyone 2024 ❤listening to this

  • @pennyarnold1484
    @pennyarnold1484 Před rokem +60

    When my daughter aged 29 took her own life in 1993, I was devastated as anyone can imagine. But, immediately after her passing, a song came into my mind which wouldn't go away and it was .. 'Caledonia. ' I didn't want a song in my head, but it wouldn't stop and at that time I had no idea that my daughter was communicating with me from spirit. The piece that came to me was just the chorus - 'Let me tell you that I love you and think about you all the time....' (I often say to folks now that when anyone passes into the spirit world, they go home....) Now, I am aware that spirit communicates with me by songs. Music is definitely food for the soul .

  • @SiunJK
    @SiunJK Před rokem +31

    Love this song & Dolores Keane sings it so beautifully, I played it for my dad on my phone when he was in a nursing home (with cancer & early dementia), he loved it too as the words had a deep meaning of how he felt...'if I should become a stranger...' he passed about a week later 2yrs last Mar
    RIP Dad 💙 xxx

    • @user-dw2zr7ft5w
      @user-dw2zr7ft5w Před 6 měsíci +1

      So sorry, thinking of you and your dad ❤

    • @SiunJK
      @SiunJK Před 6 měsíci

      Thank you Pat, appreciate that ❤️

  • @davidmcmorrow3850
    @davidmcmorrow3850 Před rokem +10

    This song makes me so sad after loosing the most beautiful lady I really loved.i miss her every day and I will never forget her and her beautiful smile.xxxx😢😢

  • @maurahennessy9049
    @maurahennessy9049 Před 4 lety +21

    Love Dolores singing Caledonia, superb rendition.

  • @avalasingidunum2157
    @avalasingidunum2157 Před 5 lety +11

    Beauteful song and fantastic voice of Dolores,best version of Caledonia.

  • @nicoladuggan6742
    @nicoladuggan6742 Před 3 lety +36

    I'm here listening to my brother's song 7 year's after his death and my emotions are still the same 💔 as the day he left this world 💔💔

    • @KK-zb3xc
      @KK-zb3xc Před 2 lety

      Very sorry for your loss. Is your sister Laura in the above comment ?

    • @denishourigan3610
      @denishourigan3610 Před rokem

      Love ur way and wat u said 💯💝

  • @Fellwander
    @Fellwander Před 5 lety +12

    This song is so brilliant because it’s universal. It captures the longing we all have for a place we call home, wherever we’re from. There’s nothing chauvinistic about it - a national song that is international in sentiment - we all have our own personal Caledonia.

  • @bustybadapples
    @bustybadapples Před 9 lety +27

    My 7 year old daughters name is Kala and she lives a hundred miles from me, i think about her all the time, my version is called Kaladonia.
    This amazing song took ten minutes to write. Well done Dougie Mc and to the voice behind this beautiful cover. Wow

  • @JohnScott-yq2bj
    @JohnScott-yq2bj Před 5 lety +8

    Many of us can relate to the this special song Delores adds so much since ive heard her sing it in my eyes its her take on living life and getting through it Its not a song any more its an Anthem to surviving our ghosts Thank you Delores for your version

  • @roytheboy68
    @roytheboy68 Před 5 lety +30

    Makes me think of my Scottish Mum, whom I lost in January. Let me tell you that I love you, that I think about you all the time. RIP Mum xxx

  • @jimmyreynolds5074
    @jimmyreynolds5074 Před 5 lety +18

    I would listen to this song all the time 😍

  • @davidbrennan3613
    @davidbrennan3613 Před 3 lety +6

    A brilliant song sung by a lady with a golden voice

  • @lindaflynn68
    @lindaflynn68 Před 6 lety +85

    Love this version of Caledonia! One of Ireland's Top 10 female vocalist is Dolores Keane.

    • @rayhoward8188
      @rayhoward8188 Před rokem

      TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU LINDA RAY TWELVE STRINGS.

  • @megastardave
    @megastardave Před 8 lety +39

    Just perfection.. What a beautiful voice

  • @lucyokeeffecurtis5585
    @lucyokeeffecurtis5585 Před 2 lety +5

    My beautiful mother's favourite song ❤️❤️

  • @PadraigBreen
    @PadraigBreen Před 7 lety +3

    My aunt sings this a lot and she is absolutely beautiful singing it. She sings it perfectly and it's brilliant hearing her.

  • @pixiefairy4918
    @pixiefairy4918 Před 8 lety +14

    Fantastic voice beautiful tune ♡☆♡☆

  • @shamshams8961
    @shamshams8961 Před 4 lety +9

    My wife sang this song at her father's funeral he was out having a laugh and few pints Guinness in our country Irish he fell into shannon off a bridge pure freck Accident he died b4 he hit water my sang this Trimbleing that awful day in church and instead of people crying they stood up sang it with her I held her shaking hand body everything it was like a 100 Angles came from heaven and sang this amazing song his favourite song the church was shaking with pure love iv never experienced god love like that it changed us for life this song RIP FATHER

    • @lhsclizdonnelly
      @lhsclizdonnelly Před 3 lety

      How great! Our Lord and His Mother would have enjoyed it too!

    • @aileenrooney7254
      @aileenrooney7254 Před 2 lety

      Sorry 😔❤️

    • @emmamcdonagh
      @emmamcdonagh Před 2 lety

      Sobbing 😭

    • @John-fq2io
      @John-fq2io Před rokem

      God is good all the time.
      Thanks for sharing your wonderful story of love and appreciation for God and one another.

  • @kenrozmislowicz9456
    @kenrozmislowicz9456 Před 4 lety +4

    Every time I hear this song I cry like a baby 6 years ago I lost my Mother and Father and I miss them every day.

  • @TheGEMMA5
    @TheGEMMA5 Před 10 lety +12

    just fantastic..what a voice she has.

  • @JellyBeanGer
    @JellyBeanGer Před 7 lety +4

    Amy's favourite song to sing, now since she has passed it has a whole new meaning. 💕

  • @randybailin4902
    @randybailin4902 Před 3 lety +4

    Beautiful, brilliant vocal. The phrasing and the changes of pitch are amazing.

  • @aneta5747
    @aneta5747 Před 3 měsíci

    po raz pierwszy usłyszałam w radiu Wnet, znalazłam i jestem zachwycona i... wdzięczna :)

  • @padraichorgan
    @padraichorgan Před 6 lety +9

    What a song this!Beautiful well done the Scots again......We Irish seem to have an extraordinary love for your music....but sure thats not a bad thing....

    • @cecircinn2908
      @cecircinn2908 Před 4 lety +1

      I think you will find its mutual appreciation of each others music :-)

  • @jamesmcdonald9753
    @jamesmcdonald9753 Před 4 lety +20

    Best version I've ever heard .

  • @sarahtaggart8028
    @sarahtaggart8028 Před rokem +3

    it is the most beautiful song

  • @nicolasdelaforge7420
    @nicolasdelaforge7420 Před 5 lety +3

    Dolores is the kind it takes time to come to love and then you fall in love and her versions of oft-recorded songs are always best. 'The wind that shakes the barley,' for example. Of course 'You'll never be the sun' is in the pantheon of songs.

  • @christylynch4266
    @christylynch4266 Před 4 lety +6

    A lovely red head and beautiful voice all in one pure magic

  • @siobhanmcallen3506
    @siobhanmcallen3506 Před 4 lety +7

    My fav version of this song ,I think it's the Galway west of Ireland accent ,love it

  • @jamesward3753
    @jamesward3753 Před 6 lety +6

    This is by far the best version

  • @maymalone1505
    @maymalone1505 Před rokem +1

    This is lovely❤❤ i had a great loss my self and know that in spirit they are with us especially when we meditate on ❤

  • @fridayballright
    @fridayballright Před 8 lety +21

    I think everyone has their own version they like of this song and everyone can relate to caledonia as home even if it's not Caledonia. Wicklow Lassie here!

    • @leahotoole7648
      @leahotoole7648 Před 6 lety

      fridayballright I’m from Wicklow too ha

    • @keithlogan8923
      @keithlogan8923 Před 6 lety +2

      Yes indeed. In Scotland's war of independance against England many English fought on the Scottish side.

    • @niallyshere
      @niallyshere Před 5 lety

      Up Wicklow!

  • @aoifeginnane4568
    @aoifeginnane4568 Před 7 lety +6

    Beautiful comforting song❤❤

  • @johndowling9379
    @johndowling9379 Před 5 lety +10

    The great Dolores was the one who brought this brilliant Sottish song to prominence. We Irish seem to have great PROes, and I have no wish to denigrate our lovely music, but there is great Scots, and English, music, and we all know what great singers the Welsh are. When I was trying to teach music to youngsters I used to tell them to try everything from Traditional to Classical, and not get bogged down in one genre.. There is some great Pop music out there also.☺☺☺☺☺☺

  • @ritaduran2754
    @ritaduran2754 Před 6 lety +19

    my Irish mother's Song Margo may you rest in The Arms of Jesus's arms always to this day her Irish accent I hear

  • @owenhanrahan8541
    @owenhanrahan8541 Před 8 lety +67

    God bless mighty Scotland, from an Irishman. People you guys should of takin your chance to go it alone, we had to fight and still are for Irish freedom..,,

    • @TheDevtone
      @TheDevtone Před 5 lety +6

      well said

    • @emilymcguire8404
      @emilymcguire8404 Před 5 lety +6

      Owen Hanrahan I'm not old enough to vote yet but if I was I would've voted yes. It's like Scotland's identity has been ripped away from us😭

    • @roddyrodrodrod
      @roddyrodrodrod Před 5 lety +8

      John Woods you sounds really stupid.

    • @allyis5187
      @allyis5187 Před 5 lety +5

      @@johnwoods7703 can you not just enjoy the song without being a tw@!

    • @MrGarvo27
      @MrGarvo27 Před 5 lety +3

      We r all cut from the same cloth literally with the scots

  • @coradoonan1231
    @coradoonan1231 Před 9 měsíci +1

    Such a beautiful song.
    Dougie Maclean also sings it so well.
    Well sung by Dolores Keane.

  • @martinfagan8404
    @martinfagan8404 Před 9 lety +6

    Proud 2b Irish listening 2 Dolores. Scotts love her 2 Brilllllllllllll

  • @carolmorgan2706
    @carolmorgan2706 Před 7 lety +43

    Caledonia was 1 of my mother's funeral songs n it brought so much comfort 2 all her children n grandchildren n place in my heart also by Delores was played 4 my father she gave us such peace in her songs although it was 17yrs ago I still listen 2 her lyrics n it gives me so much comfort

    • @leahmcmenamin1233
      @leahmcmenamin1233 Před 7 lety +4

      Carol morgan sorry for ur loss r.i.p

    • @rihannaward1303
      @rihannaward1303 Před 7 lety

      Carol morgan sorry for ur loss 😙😙 xx

    • @KOKINGWAYNE
      @KOKINGWAYNE Před 6 lety

      GOD Bless your Mother, Carol! x

    • @kenrozmislowicz828
      @kenrozmislowicz828 Před 6 lety +1

      Carol, I had the song Caledonia played at my mom and dad's memorial service four years ago everytime I hear this song I just start crying like a baby cuz I am part Irish and Welsh and Anglo-Saxon and I'm very proud of my heritage in this song really touches my heart like it did at my mom and dad's memorial service four years ago God be with you

  • @davidtoomey8438
    @davidtoomey8438 Před 6 lety +2

    This is the most beautiful song of all times...

  • @debramason2233
    @debramason2233 Před 10 lety +17

    I love this song really makes you think about not just where you come from but other places you've been to and fell in love with and had to leave all the places you'll miss the most

  • @barrymoore7887
    @barrymoore7887 Před 4 lety +4

    Tonight I lost 1 of my best friends I came home from Australia in 07 and she heard dis on a cd I had an she loved it we always use to play dis over and over, Fly high now hun I'll never forget u biddy xxx.

  • @nicoroche7818
    @nicoroche7818 Před rokem +18

    My mom sadly passed away in September she always played this as we drove from tralee back to dingle and now she rests fully in dingle over looking the west coast love u mom and this song and everyone that can relate to it ❤️❤️

  • @DeJaMo42
    @DeJaMo42 Před 6 lety +3

    What a voice!

  • @jesselou1983.
    @jesselou1983. Před 4 lety +1

    My little sis sang this the night before i went away for 4 yrs in 2016. Shit so mad has happened since then that a book about it would be censorsed. Im just out now nd listening to this version of this song for the first time since then. The lyrics are up there with the best of all time. Dolores voice is incredible. time to get back up nd kick the fuck out of life nd its bullshit.

  • @aidanfinucane3932
    @aidanfinucane3932 Před 8 lety +4

    always a delight to hear this ... not sure that there is a better version

  • @swinderby
    @swinderby Před 2 lety +4

    The best version I ever heard of this song was sung by the barmaid in the Sir Colin Campbell, Kilburn High Road about ten years ago.

  • @anneoconnor6221
    @anneoconnor6221 Před 2 lety +1

    A lovely song lost my son just over 3 weeks 😢 my song tullamore you are calling me x

  • @davidcunningham84
    @davidcunningham84 Před 6 lety +4

    I think this is best version of this song that I heard and it's easy to follow with the lriyc. I heard celtic thunder sing this song it's nice but,I prefer this one.david cunningham.

  • @terrypaul551
    @terrypaul551 Před 5 lety +3

    Excellent from Edinburgh

  • @maryharnett471
    @maryharnett471 Před 8 lety +35

    Best version of this song - well done Dolores

  • @laurentiusotanhermanto8423

    WOW...,beautiful song...

  • @dtown3210
    @dtown3210 Před 6 lety +2

    Great tune 👏💚💚

  • @user-hg3wr8fb2n
    @user-hg3wr8fb2n Před 10 měsíci +1

    One of my favorites 💝

  • @guitarchoonz
    @guitarchoonz Před 8 lety +6

    when I hear this tune it reminds me of my mother making Sunday dinner blasting this out on the hi fi

  • @ReJoKi1
    @ReJoKi1 Před 2 lety +1

    A beautiful song, well rendered.

  • @user-tl3hu2lh6u
    @user-tl3hu2lh6u Před 3 lety +1

    I heard this song on Radio 2. Such a lovely song.

  • @MICHAELCAMPBELL69
    @MICHAELCAMPBELL69 Před 8 lety +3

    Simply the best Dolores better than all the rest .Great Scots song

  • @idontbelieveyou
    @idontbelieveyou Před rokem

    Used to go to the Crane Bar in Galway in the 80s... heard Dolores singing this... them were the days...

  • @chrisfalconer6033
    @chrisfalconer6033 Před rokem +2

    Beautifully done. Thx for putting up the lyrics.

  • @johnmelmer8606
    @johnmelmer8606 Před 3 lety +13

    i lost my son many years ago as my then wife kidnapped him and took him to canada. i never saw him again but God has lifted me up and i know i will see him on the far banks of the river jordan! His peace to all

  • @flower888888888888
    @flower888888888888 Před 10 lety +4

    Just love this song.........

  • @sophiebrouder3734
    @sophiebrouder3734 Před 2 lety +5

    This was my dads favourite song. We played it at his funeral. Every time I listen to it I love it but it breaks my heart.

    • @SheilaMitchMitch
      @SheilaMitchMitch Před 2 lety

      This was also my Dad's song at his funeral . The man! 👌

  • @beautifulskull78
    @beautifulskull78 Před 6 lety +3

    rest in pace godfather tommy mac and granddad McManus my grandmother and grandfather went to her house and sang songs with the hearts content along with my wee mammy love you all xx

  • @doodymay9915
    @doodymay9915 Před 8 lety +13

    Love Dolores' voice so much!!

  • @tippspur
    @tippspur Před 7 lety +2

    Just brilliant.

  • @richarddavis2107
    @richarddavis2107 Před 6 lety +1

    RIP and thanks for your talent

  • @breigedougan6612
    @breigedougan6612 Před 8 dny

    Beautiful ❤️ song one of my favourite s

  • @aoifeginnane4568
    @aoifeginnane4568 Před 7 lety +6

    beautiful 😘😘

  • @willoshaughnessy7719
    @willoshaughnessy7719 Před 6 lety +1

    loves Delores Keane singin this.beautiful delores

  • @doreenpowers4634
    @doreenpowers4634 Před 6 lety +1

    What a beautifulsong.

  • @barbaratraynor6422
    @barbaratraynor6422 Před 6 měsíci

    You never forget the one you lost I lost one and I have been blessed with 3 beautiful daughters it's just a part of you

  • @user-dw2zr7ft5w
    @user-dw2zr7ft5w Před 6 měsíci

    Listen to her sing the Holly and the ivy with her husband John faulkner, blows my mind, wishes I was so young again, what an amazing lady xx

  • @gordoneighan2106
    @gordoneighan2106 Před 2 lety +2

    There is beautiful place for us all beyond this fallen realm, our real home!
    For Jesus says, I go now and prepare a place for you, according to your fruits, the good deeds you've all bore, they are all written in your book of Life. Be of Good cheer this is not where it all ends, but just a beginning for our young souls.
    Shalom

  • @falutak
    @falutak Před 2 lety +2

    I don't know if you can see
    The changes that have come over me
    In these last few days I've been afraid
    That I might drift away
    So I've been telling old stories, singing songs
    That make me think about where I came from
    And that's the reason why I seem
    So far away today
    Oh, but let me tell you that I love you
    That I think about you all the time
    Caledonia you're calling me
    And now I'm going home
    If I should become a stranger
    You know that it would make me more than sad
    Caledonia's been everything
    I've ever had
    Oh and I have moved and I've kept on moving
    Proved the points that I needed proving
    Lost the friends that I needed losing
    Found others on the way
    Oh and I have tried and kept on trying
    Stolen dreams yes there's no denying
    I have traveled far with conscience flying
    Somewhere with the wind
    Oh, but let me tell you that I love you
    That I think about you all the time
    Caledonia you're calling me
    And now I'm going home
    If I should become a stranger
    You know that it would make me more than sad
    Caledonia's been everything
    I've ever had
    Now I'm sitting here before the fire
    The empty room, the forest choir
    The flames that could not get any higher
    They've withered now they've gone
    But I'm steady thinking my way is clear
    And I know what I will do tomorrow
    When the hands are shaken and the kisses flow
    Then I will disappear
    Oh, but let me tell you that I love you
    That I think about you all the time
    Caledonia you're calling me
    And now I'm going home
    If I should become a stranger
    You know that it would make me more than sad
    Caledonia's been everything
    I've ever had

  • @raymondmurphy2364
    @raymondmurphy2364 Před 4 lety +1

    Unique and very special

  • @patrickbuckley861
    @patrickbuckley861 Před 4 lety +2

    Hi deirdre and paddy love this song so much

  • @ronniedaddario
    @ronniedaddario Před 5 lety +3

    The GREAT Delores Keane!

  • @KOKINGWAYNE
    @KOKINGWAYNE Před 6 lety +1

    Beautiful Tune!

  • @anthonyhubbard3312
    @anthonyhubbard3312 Před 7 lety +2

    BEST SONG EVER this is my favourite song

  • @deplorablemn7979
    @deplorablemn7979 Před 10 měsíci +1

    I am sorry for your loss, it’s so sad. Praying for God’s eternal Love and Blessings to surround & comfort you. Take good care. :)

  • @robcoyne8969
    @robcoyne8969 Před rokem

    Great song one love keep the chin up . This song reminds me of my mother

  • @bettyburke8653
    @bettyburke8653 Před 8 lety +1

    Great song many memories from overseas

  • @johndaniels2819
    @johndaniels2819 Před 3 lety

    Heartfelt and undeniably true. You're not alone. Keep stepping brother.

  • @amykissane4913
    @amykissane4913 Před 7 lety +3

    I'm learning this song in school. I love this song

  • @carolinehyland5988
    @carolinehyland5988 Před 6 lety +1

    caladonia a song I love to sing one of my old time favourites that gives me real meaning with my life my home is a special place I call it my caladonia a very true song from my life

  • @saranacharles5207
    @saranacharles5207 Před 8 lety +4

    best version

  • @Flounder1XO
    @Flounder1XO Před 11 lety +5

    Thankyou for this! It was beautiful!

  • @EZbasser1
    @EZbasser1 Před 6 lety

    Shes Fantastic for sure. That song is a Heart touchin song.

  • @janescully5264
    @janescully5264 Před 6 lety +1

    Beautiful song💗

  • @pokegamergames704
    @pokegamergames704 Před 7 lety +3

    I love this song it's sweet

  • @roisinneylon177
    @roisinneylon177 Před 9 lety +37

    This is the definitive version of this song. Dolores is brilliant.

    • @MerleHeidi
      @MerleHeidi Před 7 lety +7

      Dougie Maclean's version is absolutely the definitive version. This is a lovely version, but Dougie Maclean's version is truly heartfelt and deep.

    • @StrathpefferJunction
      @StrathpefferJunction Před 5 lety +2

      @@MerleHeidi Absolutely. You can't have an Irish person singing this song with the same passion, feeling and deep-felt love as a true Scot.

    • @MerleHeidi
      @MerleHeidi Před 5 lety +1

      @@StrathpefferJunction I appreciate your response, Strathpeffer Junction, but I don't agree. I think anyone from any background who has a true heart and a true soul can sing any song with passion, feeling, and deep-felt love. I once responded to someone who criticized the great singer/actor/humanist Paul Robeson's singing of the Hebrides Isles song "Eriskay Love Lilt", because Paul Robeson was American and Black. Paul Robeson sang songs in many languages from all over the world. His singing of Yiddish songs was truly done with passion, feeling, and deep-felt love. I think Dolores Keane sang this song with true feeling, and yes, I do like Dougie Maclean's version the best, not because he is Scots, but because it is his song....

    • @StrathpefferJunction
      @StrathpefferJunction Před 5 lety +3

      @@MerleHeidi I'm not arguing that other renditions are not well sung and with feeling and emotion, but unless you feel the real connection to and emotional relationship with the land, I just don't believe it has the same meaning. I did not feel the coonection listeniing to her as I do listening to Dougie MacLean, or even Paulo Nutini or Amy MacDonald. There's still something missing for me. There are a number of Irish and American songs that are truly awesome on all counts, and I think they're sung best by those who can relate on all levels. You have your opinion, I have mine.

    • @adamdunn2325
      @adamdunn2325 Před 3 lety

      Fuck up Merle ya fucken tart. Mon the Scotland. Dougie all the way

  • @dylanmeehan5802
    @dylanmeehan5802 Před 3 lety +1

    Good song great voice

  • @sylviedelaforet1809
    @sylviedelaforet1809 Před 5 lety +3

    Just perfect !