John Lee’s uphill battle to secure Hong Kong’s future | Talking Post with Yonden Lhatoo

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
  • Subscribe to our CZcams channel for free here:
    sc.mp/subscribe-youtube
    Two years after taking office as Hong Kong's chief executive, John Lee has shifted his focus from enforcing national security to improving the lives of residents and rebuilding the city's economy. But he faces formidable challenges, stemming from geopolitical tensions between China and the West with Hong Kong caught in the middle. Lee discusses all this and more with the Post's managing editor of content, Yonden Lhatoo, in this episode of Talking Post.
    Support us:
    subscribe.scmp.com
    Follow us on:
    Website: www.scmp.com
    Facebook: / scmp
    Twitter: / scmpnews
    Instagram: / scmpnews
    Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
    #scmp #TalkingPost #TalkingPostwithYondenLhatoo

Komentáře • 229

  • @joefernandes87
    @joefernandes87 Před 7 dny +41

    The future of Hong Kong is not Hong Kong, but the Great Bay Area Metropolis.

    • @rayngmelb
      @rayngmelb Před 6 dny +2

      Hince there is no need for a “Hong Kong Government”

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 6 dny +3

      Actually other cities in GBA are competing with HK for consumers and tourists.

    • @rayngmelb
      @rayngmelb Před 6 dny +3

      @@TeeHee-vo1bn Exactly, and Hong Kong is losing, what is John Lee and his team doing about it? Welcoming conman from the Middle East? Or Getting in Mainland "Tourist" that sleep at McDonald's to have a "Cheap Tour"?

    • @user-hc3kk7qv7o
      @user-hc3kk7qv7o Před 6 dny

      ​@@rayngmelbYou promoting anarchism?

    • @jchung5265
      @jchung5265 Před 5 dny

      @@rayngmelb fine as long as the local hk gov doesn't take on the separatist course

  • @Sgscouser
    @Sgscouser Před 3 dny +3

    Your chairman Xi set a target of 5% growth and you only delivered 3%?😂😂😂

  • @vincent49654
    @vincent49654 Před 6 dny +10

    The interviewer definitely softballed this interview. Letting John Lee dodging all the questions that truly matters.

  • @MarkYeung1
    @MarkYeung1 Před 7 dny +22

    I disagree the narrative that Mr. John Lee has no control over the geopolitical factors. He does. Mr. Lee spent the last 2 years supporting "one country", the next 3 years should be demonstrating "two systems". If the first 2 years are about defending national security, then the next 3 years will be defending freedoms and democracy under the Basic Law of Hong Kong.

    • @canto_v12
      @canto_v12 Před 7 dny +8

      It’s really as Lee said, make people know Hong Kong so well that the myths propagated by malicious privileged parties are busted by personal experience. I certainly wish Hong Kong this success as well.

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 6 dny +1

      He has no control over anything. His bosses in mainland tell him what to do.

    • @kevinschultz1024
      @kevinschultz1024 Před 4 dny

      Lets see all the truths. All opposition parties have been eliminated and not allowed to participate. Many are in jail for years awaiting a tri with hand picked judges and no juries. Over 250000 HK people have fled. All opposition press has been shut down. Bounties placed on opposition. And you are not a totalitarian state?
      All western money is gone and will never come back. Go play with Pakistan, North Korea, China, Russia, and all your new buddies.

    •  Před 3 dny

      HK never ever had a democracy

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 3 dny

      It certainly did under Britain.

  • @robezy0
    @robezy0 Před 3 dny +1

    Whatever your views may be, this is an undeniably shallow interview. Probably because Lhatoo was waiting the entire time until he can start throwing punches at the US 😂

  • @zhenminliu
    @zhenminliu Před 7 dny +12

    Lhatoo asks penetrating questions about the war of narratives. He is right in suggesting that HK is losing the war. John Lee, sadly, is not a great communicator who can change the balance of power in this war.

  • @beanmanbutchina
    @beanmanbutchina Před 6 dny +4

    I’ve been to Hong Kong, and I went there via land border through Shenzhen
    While Shenzhen was a beacon of progress, Hong Kong felt like a underdeveloped backwater not even having HALF of the mainland’s consumable and product diversity and still managing to be overpriced

  • @jimwhite1756
    @jimwhite1756 Před 7 dny +23

    He is a HUGE improvement over carrie lam

    • @MarkYeung1
      @MarkYeung1 Před 7 dny +6

      Absolutely agree

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 6 dny +4

      He's a better puppet.

    • @user-hc3kk7qv7o
      @user-hc3kk7qv7o Před 6 dny +2

      ​@@TeeHee-vo1bncongratulations you just discovered what a regional government is

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 6 dny +1

      @@user-hc3kk7qv7o Unfortunately, you don't know what "One country, Two systems" means? Deng is rolling in his grave.

    • @user-hc3kk7qv7o
      @user-hc3kk7qv7o Před 6 dny +1

      @@TeeHee-vo1bn only if the EAA would ask such an easy question like you
      The SAR status means high degree of autonomy, in executive, legislative and judiciary. While the prerequisite being that HK remains a territory of China.
      A regional government is a government which governs a territory within a state,with its powers in administration and law granted by the central/federal government,with some countries having regional laws
      Read a book, please.

  • @danielgoh2479
    @danielgoh2479 Před 7 dny +27

    The best years of HK is truly OVER. The outflow of talents and their replacement with Mainland Chinese means gradually, but surely, HK will become more like a mainland chinese city, hence losing its uniqueness, culture and characteristics that made HK … HK. The continuing reliance on land sale as the govt’s primary source of income means more and more HKers face high housing costs (both purchasing and renting). John Lee is an improvement over Carrie Lam. But the stone is set for him and I feel his hands are tied and his legs shackled.

    • @vitaluna1568
      @vitaluna1568 Před 7 dny +7

      Yep, it's just going to be another soulless city.

    • @nightwng
      @nightwng Před 7 dny

      Hong Kong - China's backyard.

    • @albback8176
      @albback8176 Před 7 dny +5

      To the contrary, HK is actually expanding, as additional areas within the greater bay area are adopting aspects of HK society. In fact, HKers are moving out because it is far more affordable to live on the mainland than in HK itself.

    • @leealex24
      @leealex24 Před 7 dny

      Is it that bad? I know retail is bad, but how about other industries?

    • @nightwng
      @nightwng Před 7 dny +1

      @@leealex24 also kinda bad. Mixed with short videos about budget travelling and fear of national security

  • @ChopSuey-Dish
    @ChopSuey-Dish Před 4 dny +4

    I live in China. Everything is miserable here, but no one dares to complain.
    We Chinese hope that the Hong Kongers, Tibetans and Uyghurs won't live hopeless like us any longer.
    Seriously, if there is next life, I wish to be born in any other country, except China.

    • @ethanchen8936
      @ethanchen8936 Před 4 dny +1

      u r not Chinese, do not pretend to be Chinese. U r so funny, I have live in Vancouver for 8 years, I can say no country r so as convenient and safe as China. If u don’t like China, move another country plz. Chinese ppl don’t need the ppl who r not respectful to their country.

    • @sandponics
      @sandponics Před 4 dny

      I live in Australia and we believe that our politicians are all idiots, and we tell them so. We envy China because they are so wealthy, even if they are miserable. Personally, I have reached the conclusion that all humans are crazy, but they are each crazy in different ways.

  • @alvindurochermtl
    @alvindurochermtl Před 7 dny +3

    Cut the nonsense. Send a pragmatist from the mainland and directly govern Hong Kong. This city does not need self rule for its own sake if at the end of the day those who lead locally aren’t up for it.

    • @TeeHee-vo1bn
      @TeeHee-vo1bn Před 6 dny +2

      HK has been under the communist control for years. Where have you been?

    • @thankqwerty
      @thankqwerty Před dnem

      Just look how great the Chinese economy is going!!! 🤣🤣🤣
      What happened to the last CCP pragmatist?

  • @MrFryguy1981
    @MrFryguy1981 Před 7 dny +1

    💔💔💔

  • @Hkchinese888
    @Hkchinese888 Před 7 dny +19

    Yoda should ask John Li where is Dubai Prince, Sheikh Ali Rashed Ali Saeed Al Maktoum, and his $500 million investment.🤣🤣🤣

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny +4

      Say hello to your Sinophobic bot farm bots for me.

    • @taiwanstillisntacountry
      @taiwanstillisntacountry Před 7 dny

      Where are the HSR of little-India?
      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
      Where are the 500 airplanes that a little-D-boi's company would purchase from Boeing?
      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @Rav01508
      @Rav01508 Před 7 dny

      𝗣𝗠 𝗠𝗼𝗱𝗶 𝘀𝗰𝗼𝗿𝗲𝘀 𝗮 𝗵𝗮𝘁-𝘁𝗿𝗶𝗰𝗸
      👉June 27: Jabalpur Airport, Canopy Collapses
      👉June 28: Delhi Airport, Roof Collapses
      👉June 29: Rajkot Airport, Canopy Collapses

    • @xTsubasaCrossx
      @xTsubasaCrossx Před 2 dny

      Fun to see hongkong people going to Shenzhen every weekend

  • @rayngmelb
    @rayngmelb Před 7 dny +8

    I have no idea why he still has a job; he is totally redundant. All the major decisions are made by the Central Government anyway. He is just there to take orders from the central government. Why doesn’t the Central Government cut out the middleman and administer HKSAR directly? It’s pointless to have a team of useless ‘politicians’ who haven’t done a single thing to improve Hong Kong’s economy or living standards. Hasn’t this ‘Hong Kong Government’ made enough mistakes to give the Central Government reason enough to get rid of them?

    • @L110508
      @L110508 Před 7 dny +1

      Well last time major decisions were made by the central government in London, but you were ok. You just hate China, don't you?

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny +1

      Please collect your PHP Peso for your post, "rayetc".

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny

      @@ToiChutGongWu And you’re fifty cents 🤔

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 6 dny +1

      @@wynn3077 Hello to “Mohammed Kumar”/“Hkchinese”/”wynn”, the Sinophobic bot farm bot.

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny

      @@ToiChutGongWu😂 3-0 loser 😂

  • @xTsubasaCrossx
    @xTsubasaCrossx Před 2 dny

    There is no future for arrogant kids

  • @Hkchinese888
    @Hkchinese888 Před 7 dny +8

    A recent coup attempt in Bolivia highlighted the use of Chinese-made military equipment, specifically the PRC Tiger 4×4 armored vehicle.
    The incident brought attention to the vehicle’s vulnerabilities when the steering tie rod broke after hitting a curb, leaving soldiers struggling to repair it by kicking the damaged wheel.
    The Tiger 4×4, produced by Baoji Special Vehicles Manufacturing in Shaanxi Province, China, is designed to transport infantry with enhanced armor protection. It can be adapted for various roles, including command post, law enforcement, riot control, and ambulance.
    🤣🤣🤣

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny +3

      Hello to “Mohammed Kumar”/“Hkchinese”/”wynn. Pat Heung, Chan Fat & I are still here. Not going any where. Time for you to report me 🤣

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 7 dny +4

      @@ToiChutGongWu 😂 Are those your other fake accounts.

    • @Hkchinese888
      @Hkchinese888 Před 7 dny +2

      @@wynn3077 Se7en is boring 😂

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 7 dny +2

      @@Hkchinese888 Now he only posts spam and then deletes it later , maybe out of shame or embarrassment.

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny

      @@wynn3077 Hello to “Mohammed Kumar”/“Hkchinese”/”wynn. Pat Heung, Chan Fat & I are still here. Not going any where. Time for you to report me 🤣

  • @freddieluke2086
    @freddieluke2086 Před 5 dny +1

    fifty or fifteen percent? You need to learn and correct your spoken English. What a shame to be the CEO of Hong Kong exposing his weakness in English but to run an international city like Hong Kong.

  • @simonleung1184
    @simonleung1184 Před 5 dny +5

    He is just a puppet

    • @peternjoyce
      @peternjoyce Před 4 dny

      Ever heard of the Deep State? Having lived in the USA for 40+ years I can see strings attached to and pulled from most politicians.

    • @xTsubasaCrossx
      @xTsubasaCrossx Před 2 dny

      Just like you Let's meet in Shenzhen this weekend

  • @lulus1030
    @lulus1030 Před 5 dny +4

    Oh indeed Lee has achieved and changed the culture of the HK government's approach to enhanced and synced with mainland CCP as one of the authoritarian rule's city. I'm surprised the host can keep his composure after what Lee had said, even use of the word "ludicrous" referring the statement from the resignation Judge!? It seemed now they pretty much adopted the capabilities of mainland how to manipulates the polls and projection results as well

    • @jchung5265
      @jchung5265 Před 5 dny

      you should listen to wise Americans like Jeffrey Sachs and drop your sick biased stance towards chynese!

    • @lulus1030
      @lulus1030 Před 5 dny +1

      @@jchung5265 You should NOT based on people's opinion, but rather looking at the FACT!!

    • @jchung5265
      @jchung5265 Před 5 dny

      @@lulus1030 time for you to visit chynahhh, 144 hours transit visa! Stop your consumption of western media and stand up for Palestine!

  • @Tan92lfc
    @Tan92lfc Před 7 dny +1

    He can speak Decent English for a former Policeman, high bar will be Carrie Lam for me

    • @andrewchin2626
      @andrewchin2626 Před 7 dny

      Carrie Lam was so weak that people thought they could just walk all over her without consequences. John Lee has restored order for Hong Kong.

  • @anthonylai3276
    @anthonylai3276 Před 2 dny

    Twelve normals!!!

  • @shaoyin76
    @shaoyin76 Před 7 dny +8

    Hong Kong is dead 😢

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 6 dny +4

      Hong Kong is thriving. Unlike its former colonizer, the dystopian UK 🤣

    • @jchung5265
      @jchung5265 Před 5 dny +1

      @@ToiChutGongWu thanks , that's what I was about to say!

    • @xTsubasaCrossx
      @xTsubasaCrossx Před 2 dny

      No, it's going better since people are leaving haha

  • @chewy_shortz
    @chewy_shortz Před 7 dny +1

    hi chat :3

  • @godzillamothra5983
    @godzillamothra5983 Před 7 dny +8

    the only way for HK to move forward is to integrate fully with Mainland China, get rid of the border. Let HK people to buy houses and live in Mainland China while working in HK. Make it easier and smoother for both sides to travel to the other side. HK prosperity was and is always depend on its connection with Mainland China. So what if HK end up being just "another Chinese city"? Even among Chinese cities, there are 1st tier, 2nd tier, and 3rd tier, and HK can be among those 1st tier cities in China, and there are not many of them, rather than like HK today, having identity crisis, not sure what it is and where it want to go. HK and Shanghai together should be the financial centers of China.

    • @robezy0
      @robezy0 Před 3 dny

      How exactly is Hk gonna profit from their residents moving to the mainland and them removing their last advantages they have over Shenzhen etc?

  • @Souchirouu
    @Souchirouu Před 7 dny +4

    After the media being flooded with the clown show that is American "democracy" it is nice to see some people actually understand their job, achieve what they promised and through hard work get even better results than expected. It is something many nations, governments and leaders can learn from.

    • @sandponics
      @sandponics Před 4 dny

      I understand that he is something of a successful capitalist, which may possibly become something of a political hindrance in 'communist' China.

  • @shin4655
    @shin4655 Před 7 dny +5

    "我今日,好高兴。终于可以含著“屎”主席條柒講話.."

  • @eddy5380
    @eddy5380 Před 7 dny +8

    Emperor Xi will decide for HK, John doesn't need to worry at all!

  • @freddieluke2086
    @freddieluke2086 Před 5 dny

    Again, he is speaking in wrong English - although.....but. HaHa. LOL.

  • @tylerd8245
    @tylerd8245 Před 7 dny +5

    Great job in ruining the great city of HK, Beijing Talking Head.

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny +2

      Say hello to your Sinophobic bot farm bots for me.

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny +1

      @@ToiChutGongWu😂 Hello

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 6 dny

      @@wynn3077 Yes, nice of the Sinophobic bot farm bot “Mohammed Kumar”/“Hkchinese”/”wynn” to follow menand say hello 🤣

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny +1

      @@ToiChutGongWu😂 3-0 😂

    • @user-hc3kk7qv7o
      @user-hc3kk7qv7o Před 6 dny

      ​@@wynn3077no way you are mentioning likes 🤡

  • @chitototoy176
    @chitototoy176 Před 2 dny

    #CCPdog

  • @kickass7104
    @kickass7104 Před 7 dny +5

    I don't understand why he is so worry 😂😂😂 everyone knows everything in Hong Kong is decided in Beijing 😂😂😂

    • @sandponics
      @sandponics Před 4 dny

      Everything that happens in the west is decided by the CIA in Washington.

  • @taiwanstillisntacountry
    @taiwanstillisntacountry Před 7 dny +2

    HK SAR of the PRC FOREX : $500B.
    little-India's FOREX : $600B.
    7.000.000 population.
    Claimed 1,44B population.
    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    HSR connected to 45.000km HSR network.
    0km HSR.
    What are the sources of this article/subject?
    Bollywood movies?

  • @Vladimirleninputin
    @Vladimirleninputin Před 7 dny +1

    Hong kong is CHINA 😊😊😊 Perhaps usa want it ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @lokesh303101
    @lokesh303101 Před 7 dny

    Yes!
    Should make a Visit to Russia 🇷🇺.

  • @dreamadventure8220
    @dreamadventure8220 Před 7 dny +6

    Free Hong kong !

    • @L110508
      @L110508 Před 7 dny +2

      Lol

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 7 dny +3

      Hong Kong is free. Free from Western colonialism and now free from Western interference. Any Hongkongers who wish to contribute to Hong Kong by leaving and going to live in the UK are welcome to do so.

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny

      @@ToiChutGongWu Poor Hong Kong.

    • @ToiChutGongWu
      @ToiChutGongWu Před 6 dny

      @@wynn3077 My, my you are earning your PHP Peso today, or is it INR Rupee?, “Mohammed Kumar”/“Hkchinese”/”wynn”

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 Před 6 dny

      @@ToiChutGongWu 😂3-0 loser 😂