DIY Roof Rack Wind Deflector using PVC Foamboard

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 6. 08. 2024
  • I realized I didn't post the link for the follow up video. See it here:
    • Diy Wind Deflector - 1...
    I built this wind deflector (fairing) using PVC foam board. Same stuff I used for the interior panels of the Wagoneer. I used the brackets from an old Thule I had, but may end up going with some aluminum stock instead.
    Painted with bedliner.
    Saved about $200 over a AEV or Rhino Rack one. I also cod find any cheap ABS or Poly sheets big enough that didn't cost over $100.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 59

  • @FOURWHEELTRENDS
    @FOURWHEELTRENDS Před 4 lety +7

    Now you have me thinking of all kinds of useable applications for that kind of board.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 4 lety +1

      Super easy to work with. I can't say how durable it will be as it won't take a lot of impact, but I think this is a good application. Interior trim like door cards. Use it as a base structure for fiberglass projects... I'm going to play around and see what else it can do.

    • @FOURWHEELTRENDS
      @FOURWHEELTRENDS Před 4 lety

      Comfort in Discomfort - I have used thick ABS for similar projects and it has held up well.

    • @raymondclark1785
      @raymondclark1785 Před rokem

      I used it to make slats to replace the glass in my daughters jalocee bathroom window

  • @alexitosonixx8737
    @alexitosonixx8737 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Very Creative we can save more than 100 bucks great Idea thanks

  • @laggardly6201
    @laggardly6201 Před 3 lety +1

    Thanks man !
    I was really struggling trying to find the right material and this is it ! I have a home made rack system for solar panels on a Dodge Sprinter . This will do nicely.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +2

      Take a look at my follow up video. It didn't work, but I know why. It warped badly after a year in the sun. I think it would work if it's supported better. Maybe a c-chamnel aluminum.

  • @FOURWHEELTRENDS
    @FOURWHEELTRENDS Před 4 lety

    First, awesome find on the rack. Second, great job building the wind deflector.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 4 lety +1

      I got lucky for sure. The ad was only for the platform which I wanted an was going to use with gutter mounts. But the guy had brackets and he didn't know what they were for. I told him but he had no use for it... I have about 500mi with the deflector on so far. Makes a noticeable improvement. I may redo a few things, we'll see. Curious how the material will do in the heat in spring and summer.

  • @diel1764
    @diel1764 Před 26 dny

    nice work mate

  • @bryansprenger
    @bryansprenger Před 9 měsíci

    Thank you for the material description and where to purchase. I need to make one and been looking around for what material to use.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 9 měsíci

      I'm glad you found some value in it. After a year, the coating looked great, but structurally, the deflector warped badly. I think if I used an aluminum channel or maybe just one layer, it would have been better.

  • @BilleEliott
    @BilleEliott Před 7 měsíci

    Good custom work!

  • @isshinryu11
    @isshinryu11 Před rokem

    Thanks!! I will do this! Slick idea!

  • @FOURWHEELTRENDS
    @FOURWHEELTRENDS Před 4 lety

    Since you already know about 001. I have to admit. It feels REALLY odd having an empty garage to park in at the house. I have a buddy who’s bartering labor with me working on the brakes, power steering and few other odds and ends. Hopefully I will have it at the house soon before it gets too cold to enjoy being in the garage. Also have a 94 YJ on the horizon. I had a 93 that I sold to buy my wife’s wedding ring. Thought I should get another one for nostalgia.

  • @wepopcreative
    @wepopcreative Před 3 lety

    Great job man 😊 wish I had those skills

    • @mjremy2605
      @mjremy2605 Před rokem

      Wishing never made anything happen. You are not born with skills. Start doing it. That is how you learn.

  • @liverenders
    @liverenders Před 2 lety

    Awesome. Exactly what I was thinking of building

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 2 lety +1

      It worked great in terms of noise reduction. Watch the follow up video. The material wasn't durable enough for heat and UV. Warped badly.

    • @liverenders
      @liverenders Před 2 lety

      @@comfort_in_discomfort ohh gotchya that's good to know

  • @yasfam3700
    @yasfam3700 Před rokem

    Cool. I need to make one like that also but higher. I went 5000km going and return from uae to saudi arabia. Open space and high wind in desert area will mess cargo on the roof

  • @VANESSASVANLIFEJOURNEY
    @VANESSASVANLIFEJOURNEY Před 3 lety +1

    *love this idea*

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety

      I made a follow up video. The material wasn't suitable for the heat / Uv. Or maybe it was the way i glued it or mounted it. But after a year it was badtyd warped.

  • @RENTFREEVANPLAN
    @RENTFREEVANPLAN Před 3 lety

    It looks great. I think I'm going to try this, although I don't think I have a way to make the angle brackets.
    My thought is I can use a long aluminum door hinge and use VHB to tape it to the roof and tape the other half the of the hinge to this foam board material.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +2

      Don't do it. Check out the follow-up video after a year. It didn't hold up to the sun. Warped badly.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +1

      Don't do it. Check out the follow-up video after a year. It didn't hold up in the sun. Warped badly.

  • @jorgehuamanmusic
    @jorgehuamanmusic Před 3 lety +4

    You really have me thinking about what I can do with this material. I'm thinking adding fiberglass to it and making it the roof of my roof top tent project. I also wonder if sealing it with epoxy would have helped as far as durability/rigidity and protecting it from the elements? Anyway, awesome idea!

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +2

      I think the fact I laminated two pieces together was a problem also. Having one expand more in direct exposure while the one in the back was cooler...maybe. But I think it would be great as a middle layer. I may have to try that.

  • @OldManHuggins
    @OldManHuggins Před 2 lety

    Thank you.

  • @mjremy2605
    @mjremy2605 Před rokem

    Wow, this is very innovative! Looks strong and light, perfect for RVs! I have a couple of questions:
    1. If its too short lengthwise, how can you glue two segments together to make it longer? My Class C RV is about 8 ft wide.
    2. 3:17 - what are those curved latches/hardware attached to the fairing? I missed that bit. Where did you get those supports? That is the key to success.
    Love that final finish you gave it! Looks solid and very attractive.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před rokem

      I had high hopes for the material. Regrettably, it warped badly in the sumer heat and UV. The finish was fine, but the substrate looked very bad (look for my follow up video). I have since used marine grade plywood and used the same spray on finish. Doing this allows for longer length as well.

  • @yrebrac
    @yrebrac Před 3 lety

    nice job

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety

      Thanks. I wish it had lasted. I posted a follow-up. It warped badly. I think because I glued two pieces and they expanded at different rates and because I didn't support them well. I think the next one I'll use a piece of angle channel and it should be good.

    • @yrebrac
      @yrebrac Před 3 lety

      @@comfort_in_discomfort Good to know! I'm currently using a piece of pine as a POC which has also warped, I suspect due to water. Did you consider plain PVC/polycarb flat sheets?

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety

      @@yrebrac I think the next one will be a polycarbonate sheet. Thus happened to be material I had as I used it to make door cards for my wagoneer and it's perfect for that.

  • @febsie
    @febsie Před 3 lety

    You think I can use something like this for the roof top tent fitted to the roof rack? The tent is a bit boxy so the drag is unreal and so is the noise!

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety

      If you watch the follow-up video, you'll see that the material didn't stand up to the heat/UV. Got about 6 months out of it and it warped to hell. However, the concept should work with a roof top tent for sure. Polycarbonate, plexiglass, metal... but sadly this material isn't suitable.

  • @functionalvanconversion4284

    Nice video! I am thinking of increasing the size of my Yakima fairing from 48" x 5" to 69" x 8" to match the width of my roof rack. Do you think sandwiching two pieces of this board will work using the old brackets like you did? I will need to make two additional brackets for the extra width of mine. Your thoughts? Thanks for sharing!

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +1

      Unfortunately this design didn't work long term. It warped pretty badly (follow up video on my channel). I think that the concept is good, but I think the material needs a C-channel on the long ends to keep it rigid.
      I tried to find plexiglass or polycarbonate that was wide enough, but only big sheets. I'm going to try again with a different support system. The spray on rubber coating was great.

    • @functionalvanconversion4284
      @functionalvanconversion4284 Před 3 lety

      Thanks for letting me know. I originally had a challenge finding a material a few years back which is why I bought an undersized fairing from Yakima. I'll check out your other video. Thanks for your time!

  • @bradmelvin7187
    @bradmelvin7187 Před 4 lety

    Thanks, awesome job!

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 4 lety +1

      I'm glad it was of some use. It's been holding up well. The tips are curling slightly so I may put a small aluminum channel and rivet it.

  • @miguelcintron6595
    @miguelcintron6595 Před 4 lety

    ANY UP DATE OF THE WIND DEFLECTOR SO FAR - GOOD IDEA

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 4 lety +2

      The coating is holding up great. The wind deflector tips have warped only slightly. I may put in a small C-channel behind it to reinforce, but it's been good.

  • @user-gj8mn4ce8d
    @user-gj8mn4ce8d Před 4 měsíci

    Just one question, doesn’t having that half inch or less opening on the bottom cause any issues with whistling on the highway ?

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 4 měsíci +1

      It was much quieter than before. I didn't want contact with the roof for fear of vibration and damage. So while I had it it was great. Unfortunately, as you'll see in the follow up video, it warped badly. Could be my construction technique as I laminated two panels. One expanded in the sun, while the other didn't.

  • @allencoin
    @allencoin Před 3 lety

    Looks awesome. Is it still holding up for you over a year later?

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +3

      No unfortunately. I made a follow-up video. It warped badly, though I think it's because I laminated two pieces and didn't support it well. I think this material is great, but the next version needs an aluminum C-channel. The rubber coating did fine.

    • @allencoin
      @allencoin Před 3 lety +1

      @@comfort_in_discomfort Thanks for the reply! Sorry, I didn't see the followup video. I'm researching building my own DIY wind fairing for my roofrack. This is extremely helpful info. Thank you.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety +1

      @@allencoin Good luck. I will likely try again, this time with a bit more support, and planning...

  • @DanielMiller82
    @DanielMiller82 Před 2 lety

    How is this holding up nearly 2 years later?

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 2 lety +1

      Not well. I made a follow-up video. 12 month failure. Warped badly. I think laminating two sections was a mistake as one gets direct heat, the other does not. And I should have supported the whole length with a c-channel.

  • @jaybeeflorendo466
    @jaybeeflorendo466 Před rokem

    What kind of roof rack do you have?

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před rokem

      I still have a Baja platform rack on my son's JK jeep. Unfortunately the material for the deflector is really not as stable in uv and heat as I had hoped. The follow-up video shows that it really warped after 2 yrs. I may re-do it with some aluminum reinforcement.

  • @JoseGonzalez-jt1tt
    @JoseGonzalez-jt1tt Před 2 lety

    Nice work 👍, maybe should have gone a little bit wider.

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 2 lety

      For sure. The Jeep roof is 52" wide. Unfortunately the panel I had was only 48. Next time I'll use a different material as well as making it bigger. This material warped badly (see follow-up vid)

  • @kconatymd
    @kconatymd Před 3 lety

    would have been nice if you provided a link

    • @comfort_in_discomfort
      @comfort_in_discomfort  Před 3 lety

      To the pvc board? It's a ceiling tile I bought at Lowes. However, the follow-up video of a year later shows a compete fail. Wouldn't suggest it for high UV exposure.

    • @travato1592
      @travato1592 Před 3 lety

      @@comfort_in_discomfort ha! OK thanks!