India vs Nepal Border Dispute | Explained by Dhruv Rathee
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2020
- Few days ago, Nepal published a new political map of their country that includes a small stretch of land controlled by India. It is approximately 300 square kilometers of land located between Limpiyadhura, Lipulekh and Kalapani which Nepal believes to be a part of its own country. In this video, I take you through the history of this land, how borders were divided between India and Nepal through the Sugauli Treaty and how this dispute has arisen. I also explain role of China's influence in this geopolitics.
Special thanks to Kanak Mani Dixit & Tika P Dhakal for their research on this issue. They have written a detailed piece in Scroll Website, which I have used as the primary source in this video. Here's the link to their full article, highly recommend to read this for more information -
scroll.in/article/962226/terr...
Support my work and join as a member to get exclusive stuff:
1. On Patreon: / dhruvrathee
2. On CZcams: / @dhruvrathee
----------------------------------------------------
For more informative videos and discussion on important Indian and world issues-
Telegram channel to receive instant video updates: t.me/dhruvratheechannel
More videos by Dhruv Rathee
- Financial Education: czcams.com/users/playlist?list...
- Ground Reports from across the World: czcams.com/users/playlist?list...
- Indian Politics Videos: czcams.com/users/playlist?list...
- Educational Videos: czcams.com/users/playlist?list...
- Interviews by Dhruv Rathee: czcams.com/users/playlist?list...
Support on Patreon: / dhruvrathee
Subscribe: / dhruvrathee
Facebook: / dhruvratheepage
Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
Instagram: / dhruvrathee
----------------------------------------------------
0:46 What is the Issue?
3:30 History of India-Nepal Border
7:00 History after Independence
9:04 Who is Right?
10:56 My Opinion
13:26 China’s Influence
Make a video on Israel west bank annexation claims. What will UN do?
Mast h bhai maza aagya ab m gyan batuga😂
Bhai💥💥you really right that we want friendly
Your hands always be like👌👌👌these
Make bus issue .....who was correct
काे काे हनुहुन्छ याे video हेर्ने नेपालीहरु
m a hu
Ma
Ma❤
Ma xu hai ketaharu.❤❤❤🎉🎉
Ma
Nice analysis. The only thing I would like to correct is that it was not after 1860 that we claimed the territory. But we have records till 1960 when Nepal collected Taxes and conducted census in those area. Rest of it is on point.
Random Nepali Daju, La Yesbareyyy ni eutaaa detailed analysis video banaidimm vo ?
yesle kurai kurama India lai dinu parxa vandai xa daju k bichar xa hajur ko
You are absolutely right bro
bro nailed dhruv should read this one
everything is right but DHRUV RATHEE was wrong when he said THERE IS NO CHINA ANGLE....KP OLI saved his govt after talking to CHINESE DIPLOMAT recently.....thats why KP OLI is behaving like puppet of china..he needs to do more research on internal politics of Nepal.
btw INDIA WILL NEVER LEAVE THAT STRATEGIC POSITION.
I'm Nepali I🇳🇵 think Nepal is right in this explation India and Nepal is friend ❤
jaba British gaye taba tyo jamin firta lina sakinxa vanya thiyo diyena india le
The way you explained is very good than indian media,
Love from Nepal 🇳🇵
"If two fishes are fighting in a river,an Englishman must have passed by."
-Native American saying
Ye sale britishers ne sb gdbd kr rakhi hai... 😂
@razael deathbringer suitable for both
"If two Fishes are fighting in Indian subcontinent, Chinese must have been passed by."
-Me
This is what i was thinking
@@laughtale1181 h
I’m from nepal 🇳🇵 you’re way better than whole indian media. Thumbs up man
मीडिया वाले चुतीये है
India Nepal ki Dosti kabhi bhi khatam nahi honi chahiye yah dosti bahut hi sundar hai
@@messiko2ndid132 kis liye
@@messiko2ndid132 😚😚
y nepal licks china
I'm Nepali 🇳🇵The way you explain is absolutely right.. Fully Satisfied with your explanation ❤❤
dont think you a nepali
Rajput aur nepali??
@@user-vh2ed6rq2t i mean i belongs from Nepal.. Brother 🙂
I am from india but i am a nepali so i am a cocktail of nep-ind 😂 therefore my mother and father are nepal and india . If there is clash between my mother and father i don't like to support both .I WANT THAT THEY SHOULD BE TOGETHER.than iam happy ❤❤
Who is good?
1)ABP News= Comment💬💬💬
2)Dhurv Rathee= Like👍️👍️👍️
⬇️
Dhru Rathi is best
2) Dhurv Rathee sir.
@CRISTIANO RONALDO abhe apni g dho un ki kon dhorha hai
@@xyz-se7us yaar tum log itne bade kab ho jaoge jab mazak samjh sako
Nepal
You missed one thing that many indians are also working in Nepal not only Nepalese are working in India.I am from India but I work in Nepal.
Why are you working there come back go Uae , Saudi , usa why defaming india
Yes bro you are right.....
Comparing to nepalise living in India ,it's very less.
@@rahulkrishna1657 😂😂
Nepali may be poor but are happy....
@@rahulkrishna1657 If you go by just the number of people working, Yes (however, the number is lot more than what you are likely thinking of). But if you look at the remittance each country receives, India gets 3 times more money from Nepal than Nepal does from India. In fact, Nepal has long been among the top 10 sources of remittance for India (Just look at official sources of the Indian government). So, the relation is more of interdependence, contrary to what general Indian tends to believe or is made to believe!
This is not a full truth, because Nepal helped India during the war with China for Indians soldiers for their shelter but Indians insisted that they own this the majority reason of the disputes, this must belong to Nepal.
I am Nepalese citizen .we want whole greater Nepal back because british said while ruling india that all of the land taken while sugauli territory must be given back to Nepal .
I am from Nepal.
You describe issues better than the Indian media. 👍👍
The media is under control of politicians bro. Don't bother about it.
indian new media is usless as shit all they want is a TRP
good
K boleko vai 😂
Molai tw eautai man parena yo Muji ko kura
You are the only indian who believes nep-ind relationships is more important than this dispute. Love from Nepal 🇳🇵
I am also want peace.
I also love Nepal
Jai hind jai nepal
Not only Dhruv R. But maximum Indian believe in nep-Ind relationship......
We also love nepal don't listen to those critic people who abbuse nepal .from India.
I'm from Nepal but fully satisfied with your video.
Better than Aajtaak media.
We love india ❤🤝
Your Explanation And Analysis Towards The Nepal India Border Is Far Better Than Other Medias Of India🙏Dhruv Rathee Hats Off👍
Nepal and India always been shared brotherhood relation. As a person, I love Nepali people & found really hardworking. This border can not divide us. Such a beautiful culture and religion we share in between us. Love from ❤India to all Nepalis
I think britishers played well
Even after independence still we face a lot of conflict with our neighbors as well as our own people
inta bada tumra mulk hai, sirf 1 samajhdar Banda Nikla....ye sab plot Englang Ki hai...They never want rest of the world to be stable
@@tripmcfly10 bro what u saying.... I am an Indian.
This is their policy. first thing they create divide within, then sell their fear and protection insurance and then rule that has been their chronology and then they do not want to leave but they had to for some obvious reasons and when they do they do not let people live in peace that is why we have fought 4 wars with pakistan due the maps and then in africa and even in middle east and far east and even in parts of south america and the islands. There is an urdu proverb " hum toh doobe hain sanam- tumhe bhi le doobenge" i will translate in english for you even though it would be a vague one according to their strategy " we are going out of here but we will never let you live in peace".
@@1101smartkooldude quite agree to what u said.... Though the Urdu proverb itself was sufficient ✌️
Of course you are Indian, I am saying that someone from India finally understood the plot...England is the root of all the conflicts in this world.. from World war to Middle east...they couldn't rule India forever that's why they created a divide ..
Obviously, Nepal is right. Respect small countries.
This is the difference between a educated indian and Uneducated Indian ,,,,
Dhruv Rathee is the most intellectual Indian CZcamsr i have ever seen ,,, Love From NEPAL 🇳🇵❤ 🇮🇳
सयौं थुँगा फूलका हामी, एउटै माला नेपाली
सार्वभौम भई फैलिएका, मेची-माहाकाली।
सयौं थुँगा फूलका हामी, एउटै माला नेपाली
सार्वभौम भई फैलिएका, मेची-माहाकाली।
प्रकृतिका कोटी-कोटी सम्पदाको आंचल
वीरहरूका रगतले, स्वतन्त्र र अटल।
ज्ञानभूमि, शान्तिभूमि तराई, पहाड, हिमाल
अखण्ड यो प्यारो हाम्रो मातृभूमि नेपाल।
बहुल जाति, भाषा, धर्म, संस्कृति छन् विशाल
अग्रगामी राष्ट्र हाम्रो, जय जय नेपाल
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵❤❤❤❤✔✔✔
👌👌👌💕💕💕
jay nepal
Jai nepal
Jaye Nepal 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
We can asume that both side have logic and evidence and the only solution is peaceful table talk and mutual re-search.🇮🇳🤝🇳🇵
Who Agree?
⬇️
Right
Hindu-Hindu nahi ladte...
Land is always b disputable .And no one wants to loose it. So talk is not a good option. I think the matter should solve in court and by that time no county has to take access of this area. Neither india , china or nepal
.Well m working with land disputes matter . 25 saal se jyada bina agreement k agar koi land par kisi ka adhikar ho to wo uska ho jata hai .Isi base pe kai logo ne sarkari jameen pe adhikar b prapt kiye. Or yaha is lihaj se bharat ko milna chahiye .
Under no circumstance we need more border dispute with Nepal. Nepalis are our brothers.
Is that an Indian law or international law?
Actually it doesn't matter whose land it is untill Nepalese and indians can work together.
I'm from nepal but you describe that issue as a side of india but sugauli trity explained that these land belongs to nepal country.huge respect for you to research that issue .but as a whole nepal will win in this conflict .😢
60 lakh indian working in Nepal
So once again we have to blame the British for the border dispute
Only a fool will live in da past..
@@maitshaphrangsyiemlieh9063 we will destroy uk
@@sutopapatra960 no uk will destroy u
@@sutopapatra960 be real you sucker. No one will destroy anyone. And even if anyone can destroy another you sucker will be long dead. So let's not get ahead of ourselves.
@@yashbhandaree6800 You know Hindi.???
Once said ,
*If two fish fight in The Tigris River* , *British are behind it* .
Most land dispute around the world caused by britishers ..
Truth.
@@amandeepsaini9912 Aur tu ye bata ke tu Lukkha hai yaa Hijada 🤣🤣
Im from nepal and by viewing this video i have huge respect for you dhurve
“I think in any case Relationship between India and Nepal should n’t be ruined....Our Nepali brothers have sacrificed their life for our beloved Country!”
No Need any Non-Sense Contravercy. Sit and Talks avoids boarder Wars.
Fir Dalmia ko safety de rkhi
Vishal Behera There’s a saying.. even after studying Ramayan for 12 years, knowledge is still nil!
He lies about no role of China.
Nothing is ruined it's suddenly Nepal changed tone when China got aggressive on border.
It's not a mere coincidence
Thanks for support and understanding the value of our peoples sacrifices for your nation.
He does more research than Indian media like ABP news ...
Godi media
Didn't knew that ABP news also does research 😂😂
@@spetsnaz_2 haha zee news also
Tum log yese media ko kese jhel lete ho?
All news channels combined
Ye fakiri hai
I am from Nepal 🇳🇵
Aap Indian Media se achha explain karke video banate ho
ITS BELONGS TO NEPAL, BUT INDIA IS TAKING CONTROL.
This issue can be solved through table talks so easily man. Indian media is creating so much Anti Nepal Anti Indian sentiments. 🇳🇵❤🇮🇳
Nepal k pm ki statement kabhi suni bhi h?
@technical khatrid500 Meri kidneys bhi apke pm ki Hain😂😂
Dear DOCTOR D can b but believe me India media talking about Nepal PM thoughts... aur kuchh Indians n Nepalese ko bhi dikha rahe h jo chahte h k Indians ya Nepalese politicians 1-2 k bare m galat bolkar bhai chara khatam na kare...
Aur vese bhi hum Indians ab samajh gaye h k kisi media ya politicians k baton ko 3 filters kare
1. Jo hume bata raha h uska swarth.
2. Uski sachchai k proof.
3. And finally Desh ya Dunia par uska asar...
India and Nepal relationship ko sahi se wahi bata sakta h jo dono taraf k aadmio se mil chuka h... jese m... aur mujhe pata h Nepalese bahut aobhagat karne walon m se h... unka dill saf hota h... bass darr is baat ka h k m 20 years pehle gaya tha ab udhar nafrat ki fasal uga di ho toh keh nahi sakta...
Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳Jai Nepal 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
Our Indian media is sold
@@psychobgmi7648 dear koi 5 countries k naam batao jo bike ya dabao m news nahi dete... and unko har news ki permission h unke koi limited area nahi h...
Politician's should act with even more maturity! Love to Nepal from India.
🇮🇳🤝🇳🇵
Rice Bag spotted
@@ajay87938 what's the meaning of rice bag?
@@ajay87938 brother of Arnab goswami spotted...
@@ajay87938 gobar bhakt of IT cell BJP spotted
@@prajeshrajsingh998 he means Christian. If a hindu got converted to christianity for rice bag then it is problem of high castes hindu like him . I f they have converted for rice bag they can leave christianity after getting money and whatever. Gobar brain will not understand even if he is educated they become become illiterate like their pappa Modi. You can check all the ministers in BJP
Why no one talks about the treaty of 1950 where it is clearly mentioned that all the treaties between nepal and East India company is not valid
i am from nepal
thank you bro ! you give very relatable answer
We can asume that both side have logic and evidence and the only solution is peaceful table talk and mutual re-search.
Who else feeling same?😍
⬇️
Shai
Indian region hai
Yes we love Nepal from India❤❤
We LOVE Nepal
🇮🇳❤🇳🇵
हा ये वक़्त है आमने सामने बैठ कर इस समस्या का हल निकालने का ना कि लड़ने झगड़ने का
Respect bro, young but responsible, non bias facts, thank you from Nepal. True Yuwa of India. Jai Hind! Jai Nepal!
What a comment.. Really I appreciate.
It's really appreciating.... Dispute is between our borders not in our hearts.. ❤️
India Nepal bhai bhai ...kya bolte neta bhai
Salam
Nepal is always family ..lakhs of nepali brother and sisters are in india from decades..
I am from Nepal.The way you explainabsolutely right.
Dhuvra, thank you for the excellent presentation, Not as a Nepali, But as per the agreement of Sugauli it's ours. to keep the army, the Indian Government asked the Monarch to keep them for a certain period. See we have shown our brotherhood, for keeping our friend's army in a sovereign region.
Whenever there is a dispute between countries it is always British who got involved 😂.
Not always, but only within british empire.
Sometimes USA or russia or china
Yea lol
Just wait, America is on it's way 🤣
Obviously..
Don't know about others but I've weed, daru, cigarettes relationship with my indian brother as ive spend 6 year in banglore 10 +2 and BE.. love from Nepal 🇳🇵 jai Nepal 🇳🇵jai hind 🇮🇳
Tumhare yahan se sasta maal aata hai yahan.
Loads of love from Indiamy friend
@@KunalKeshav-dq6ty because India me hiv wala jyada hae
Nepal aur hindustan bhai h .....government kharab ho sakte h but people nhi ... I always respect nepal...love u brother..love from india...
India Nepal have always been friends but due to govt. agenda, friendship is being affected. I am from Bihar and Nepal is 6hr drive from my home. Never thought this situation would arise. We love Nepal🥰🥰
it’s not us Nepalese, it’s all about politics and only politicians
and i’m concerned about Dhruv sir that he knows how media are in our countries
Thanks to your opinion dhruv brother in my country nepal a totally made better friendship with india and we are Nepalese love and respect indian and india❤
Bro i wish INDIAN MEDIAS were as humble as you, indian medias are the one behind every issues related to conflicts
thats all talks aside, we will not suceede an inch of our territory
Paid rathee 🤣🤣
Don't give gali to nepal. & nepal don't give india
Sahi ho sathi
Bro not only the media but the actions of Andhbhakts of both the countries can't be denied
love and respect from nepal🇳🇵🇳🇵I have been watching you since I watched arnab goswami show on border issue ...how irrelevantly he host the show without any facts and any research ....you are the best presenter with fact and good research ....yes I also want my government and Indian government to resolve the issue with bilateral talk.... jai Nepal 🇳🇵🇳🇵jai bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Yes friend.I am from raxaul ,birgung border our relation is too good with nepal .both gov will resolve this issue soon.
Bhai we should live with peace I have spent most time with my nepali freind Ashish in India but now he gone to nepal . At least we should live with peace not like porki pak.
Brother don't trust on china just learn from history like Tibet srilanka and Maldives be aware bro
Love Nepal. Most beautiful nation
You know what is the worst thing India has it is our Media. They are doing their best to divide us, put us in a war, fill us with fake news and they are trying their best to repeat the history of Rawanda in India.
Wherever there is conflict, british exists there.😂
Fine analysis bro keep it up you describe more correctly then any other indian media..
SOON AMERICA WILL SAY "WE CAN INTERFERE IF INDIA AND NEPAL WANTS"......
😂😂😁
America will give us freedom 😭
NIPPLE NOT NEPAL
It is not possible,if America wants to interface in Indian border issue then it will already interfered in p.o.k issue but they hadn't
Yes,,Because we rule the world
It's our duty to establish peace
. Western Christian civilization will act
As they say "If two fishes in the same pond are fighting, British were there."
How???
@@MKCC_BOYS policy of divide and rule of british
Ya and if the two fishes in a pond aren’t fighting then Americans were there cuz they genocided then all.
Today every country is adopting this formula son of Britishers,
Can anyone tell me weather update of laddakh and pok?
Seems like a logical analysis with no biasedness.
Yr analysis is very fair,brother.
Indian Govt is not friendly for Nepal.....Encroaching the land of Nepal is not good for India.
So The British started this as well.😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Because of British people now our head full of confusion
@@everythingnew9618 😂
Hindu muslim भी उन्होंने ही शुरू किया था 😂😂
Yes bro....you are Right.....👍🇳🇵🇳🇵👍
You have researched a lot and your thoughts are Right....
I wish every Indian and Nepalese People know the actual situation before talking and spreading Hate.....
Love from Nepal🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
Ha lekin wo area tumko nhi milega fir bhi🤣
@@PrakashShrivastav41 abe mat kar yaar tum Government hai
@@akashtripathy1334 Kahe negotiate agr china beech me nhi aya to 1 day me nepal ko india acquire kr sakta hai..
@gulpreet singh gulpreet singh are uh Pakistani?? Bhot jagah comments dekhe h tumhare🤣
Ye region mujhe belong karta hai. Mai sabko waha se hata k apna ghar banaunga.
I'm nepali and you're excellently defined it 💯✅
I salute you for creating such videos.
11:42 Hello Dhruv, Nepal had its first elections (under monarchy) in 1959 AD. Our government has the voter list from these disputed region so this is not a 100 years old issue. Also the person who conduced the census in 1961 AD (2018 BS) is still alive. We have the tax receipts as well.
Before 1962 this wasn't an issue for both Nepal and India. But after 1962 Sino-Indian war this region got all the attention. We used to have Indian Military check posts in our Northern frontier (even Indian Ambassador used to sit in the cabinet meetings), all of those check posts were removed but one, Kalapani. This is where the issue starts.
So going by your logic, if your grandfather gave his land on a lease to someone else for farming and he built a house and lived there, your father didn't cared about it and now when you claim that land with all the legal papers and instead got a thrashing from the tenant, how does that feel?
exactly what i was saying. according to legal documents it's nepal's land, means it's nepal's land
That is the point We wanted to make
Exactly I agree with dhurv but he missed exactly these core things. I think he have not researched properly in this topic.
Legal things not based on feeling dear.. Sad but true
Can you share some proof to back this up
10:25 Clarification
Nepal is trying for official bilateral agreement for more than 20 years but India has not given time to any of Nepal's foreign officials for proper discussions. Instead India relaesed it's new map covering all the disputed areas without bilateral agreement.
Thanks for clarifying that brother
There has already been bileteral agreements in past . Everything is sorted out .Nepal keeps comming with new stuff new arguments despite being India such a peaceful country. Thats is not acceptable!
India&Nepal is biggest friends but this problems is responsible Only KP Sharma Policy not My brother Nepal...
If your agreement should have loud enough dude?
@@gauravmoral7986 India released it's map unilaterally! We protested this, the government called India for a meeting not once but twice giving a certain date! Indian officials overlooked twice, then Nepal even asked them to choose the time for a meeting, then also Indian government showed no response!! If the land was disputed, India had no right to unilaterally publish a map including the territory which has always been ours as per the evidences!!! I hope you understand that things were not sorted out bilaterally!! We have been protesting for this issue for many decades now, but now our voices have been louder and stronger!! Peace
Good explanation. Agree with you
And I'm From Nepal 🇳🇵
Wow you are always nice brother ❤! Druve rathee love you and well educated person.❤. 🇳🇵!
Thankyou Dhruv for the factual Information. Let me add some more points.
- During Indo-China war, India asked Nepal's help to grant some space in Nepal's territory for the establishment of Indian military camps so that it can stop China expansionism. The then King of Nepal gave permission and 17-18 military camp were established. After the war was over and the situation calmed down, the king asked for the withdrawal of those camps because there was no need of one. 17 or so camps were taken back to India. One in the Kalapani region, border near India-China-Nepal was not taken down because it was strategically favorable and important location for India to keep an eye on Chinese soldiers. Being located in quite a remote location, there were not may Nepali presence, so Nepal didn't objected that time because of the good relations and let India protect it's border for some more time.
- As the time passed by, Indian Military was growing strong, deploying more soldiers in that location. Now, Nepali couldn't get access to that location anymore because of the heavy military presence and made us stay back to the eastern side.. The land was then formally isolated from Nepal because we couldn't get access to it.
- Why Nepal didn't objected this many years then??
We objected, but our voices were very low because of the bloodiest civil war and various Internal political conflicts. Now, the government is stable and is democratically elected from the people, though it's communist. This is one of the most powerful government that Nepal could ever get. It has 2/3 majority support from the people and cannot deny or neglect people's voice because we've struggled for decades to form such stable government. It should do what people demands else get swiped out in next election.
- We've only demanded for what is rightfully ours and nothing much. Hope you understand. Hope the diplomatic dialogues from both side resolve this issue as soon as possible.
miley miley aarey tum hog v jao hamara desh se. Chal bhag
@@chandakumari5089 shut up ...Don't be so rude ...
Still Dhruv Rathee has not clearly mentioned why Nepal has made the new map. There are 2 other rivers joining the tributary of kalapani river. Nepal until now has only claimed never made the map including the west of large stream of Kalapani but when the Indian government claimed another tributary of west kalapani as the main kalapani river then only the Nepal has claimed its whole part up to Limpiyadhur which is rightfully and legally correct !!!!
@@rajshitalcreation why are you so rude? Agar wo jayenge to apni gurkha regiment bhi lekar jayenge pata hai unka kitna bada hath h hindustan ke itihas me? Sharm karo.
I dont think that you will be getting the land now. Its highly unlikely.
I'm from Nepal, I salute your honest review... I have been following you and Ravish Kumar sir since years...!! Thanks!
Plz stop following rabbish kumar
@@kamleshjakhar155 what you have authority to tell people who to follow or not
Great to hear that man, Lots of love
@@kamleshjakhar155 ya who are you tell him that not follow RAVISH KUMAR, Infact he is the best journalist in the indian media! He also speaks truth and he doesn't care about anything like dhruv does so mind it!!!!
@@kamleshjakhar155 u follow Sudhir. 2000₹ mein GPS chip my foot.
Clear analysis of boarder dispute. Your opinion is remarkable...
Yes, you are 100% right.
ABP news is worse.
Who Agree?
⬇️
Wo to muje bhi lagta hai chor hai sale bbc hindi news accha hai or us se bhi jayada dhruv raathu
Bas abp news nhi yrr zee news v
@@ravikumarkhadka8831 dhruv rathee anti-national.
Only speaks against India😡
@@ayush4565 loudaa
@@ayush4565 Telling the truth doesn't mean speaking against your country.
🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
✊✊✊✊✊✊✊✊
Britishers after extending border be like : Haa apun ne cheating kiya, jo ukhadna hai ukhad le 😂
Most neutral comment 🤣
@@Sinra364 bhai thoda kam racist ho sakta hai tu?
@@Sinra364 tere ko pata hai Nepali log kitni racist ho sakte hai Indians ko lekar like paan Wala ,dhoti,Pani Puri chatpat wale, vegetables wale, construction main Kam karne wale labor,Nepal k mandir main bheek magne Wala bheekari,Khali bottle kagez Wala,street magicians wala
Angrejo ke najayaj aulaad ke comment padne aayatha padliya 😂😂😂
@@Sinra364 - and with due respect they started encroaching the land with "chatpat thelas" and "cycles with empty bottles" :(
Hatts off to your research and facts ...
the real honest educated person from india Dhruv rathee
far more well explained and researched but still few more things you have left that
1. In 1959, ppl from that area voted in Nepali election.
2. In 1961, Nepal included ppl from that area in its first census ever held.
3. In 1962, when Indian army retreated after indo-china war, they asked permission to stay there.
Undoubtedly that area belongs to Nepal...
After Indo-Chine war, indian army staying that area with permission of Nepal Govt.
That time india dominated Nepal govt. That’s why the indin manage to hold that area.
3rd point mentioned sir
Yep yep yep
These facts needs to included
@@mamunrashid5794 there is difference between taking permission and having conversation.
They cant take decisions anything after so many years.
both Gov should solve this matter in friendly way. But they using it for their politics.
I m not a Nepalese but I have visited Nepal various times. There are beautiful places. I don't know who is right but I love both countries.
THANK YOU BRO I M FROM Nepal
ya it is beautiful until u visit popular place like kathmandu(capital city) and other mainly kathmandu is polluted sooo much
Love u
@@user-ho3un1vu4w that is very rude comment😤😡
❤❤❤
I am from Nepal 🇳🇵 I totally agree with your opinion ❤ you are better than whole Indian godi media ❤❤ hame Indian Bhaiyo s koi problem nahi hai h to bas godi media walo s Jo ulta sidha bol k Bhai Bhai ko ladana chahate h
भाई जी आप लोग भारत में क्यों नहीं मिल जातें,नेपाल को भारत का एक स्टेट बनाया जाएगा, इससे भारत और नेपाल दोनों की ताकत बढ जाएगी
never ever...@@kingofthetable1430
Disputed land belongs to Nepal for sure...
dhruv my friend, i am putting all my trust in you and so you have officially become my only means of truth and unbiased information. keep it up. love your work!
dont believe everything blindly he is unbiased but 1/2 videos has wrong information about Statue of unity video...watch is carefully and calculate the total he shows...else than this he is truly unbiased and a neutral
@@syedmohammedzubair4656 he expected on his first video about statue
On second video he repent on his earlier views on statue
Watch both video for clearance bro
Same Here 🙏
@@NoorAhmed-ql1dh but he was only told to talk about first video then why he (Syed) need to mention about second video?
to talk about second video is nptt part of his propoganda, you know.
Boundaries are made for poor people n poor minds we all are global citizens but we also have right to fight for country like everyone does we belong to small country don't mean we have to be afraid of big ones
I am glad that I have been following this channel from some time back and after this i am very happy towards ur neutrality. As all media are after a single point of China influence without any background study.
I am from Nepal and I feel India as my second home as I have been there for long for my higher study.
In my point of view this matter is to be discussed by two government and not by these aggressive media
Lots of love and respect to u sir please continue ur good work 😊
@@harishsingh5230 .
mistake is of nepali monarch.
are you insane. from
1860 this region is in india
@@harishsingh5230 ok no problem! Get out of India
Feel the same
Don't talk shit.have u any Idea of china influence in your communist party.China embassy is controlling your internal matter.every one know this
@@harishsingh5230 kya bhai etna jahar lekar dusra pakistan bnana hai kya hamare pyare padosi desh Nepal ko.
Iam from India nepal🇳🇵 go back india long live❤
kati class ma hoo bachha? 😂😂
Nepal is right.
Love Nepal from India ❤️🇳🇵🇮🇳💞💞
Who loves India 🥳🥳
♥️♥️♥️from Nepal
I have a big backyard which I never had to use it.
My neighbour started drying their laundry at my backyard - I did not have a problem!
Then, they started vegetable gardening there - I still did not have any problem!
This continued for years and years.
Today, my neighbour not only claimed that MY backyard is their property but also started to build a house there without my consent - Here I have a HUGE problem!
This is exactly what has happened with Kalapani, Limpiyadhura and Lipulekh issue. Nepal stayed quiet for so long doesn’t mean India can claim they are their land now!
correct
This is exactly what’s happening
true! even high journalists also stated the same.
They why you were not showing your backyard in the Map of your house for a century. Neighbor has invested so much money and time in maintaining and protecting your backyard for more than a century. Stf and thank god that you are sharing your border with India not with Pakistan or else there would have been no Nepal left by now.
Exactly.bro
We want greater Nepal back
We Nepali and Indians have a very friendly relations from Ancient time. Just now because of these once sided greedy politicians the relations is detonating. We should never forget who we are. We are and will be alwayz brothers. Jai Nepal Jai Hind
Well, not ancient times but now,yes
Yes bro agreed...such minute disputes should'nt affect much to the actual relations between both of the countries🇮🇳❤️🇳🇵
INDIAS 98℅ are Hinduism 🕉️ and Buddhism.
NEPAL 99 ℅ are Hinduism 🕉️ and buddhism.
yes we nepali respect india
@@markly5400 india mein lagbhag 80% hindu rehte hai na ki 98%
Moral:
* IF YOU EVER SEE FISHES FIGHTING IN A POND THERE IS A HIGH POSSIBILITY THAT AN ENGLISHMAN(BRITISH) HAD JUST PASSED BY FROM THERE *
Lmaoooooo
Deep
Haa bhai sahi
🤣🤣🤣
Sala conterversy kada kardiya
मैं उत्तराखंड पिथौरागढ़ से ही हूं ये हिस्सा अंग्रेजो ने तय किया था ठीक बाद मैं वापिस लिया ठीक अगर नेपाल कहता है की डेमोक्रेसी 1999 में आई तो तब भी भारत आजाद भारत नहीं था। और ये हिस्सा एक देव भूमि के रूप में उत्तराखंड का ही होना चाहिए।
1. कैलाश मानसरोवर मार्ग
2. आदि कैलाश, ओम पर्वत (हिंदू धार्मिक )
3. उत्तराखंड को देवभूमि दर्जा दिया हुआ है। पिछले बिंदु के अनुसार
3. तिब्बत के साथ भविष्य में कोई समझौता हुआ तो
4. अभी का बॉर्डर भारत के अनुसार सही है।
5. नाबी या वहां रहने वालो की राय ले तो वो भारत का हिस्सा ही बना रहना चाहते है।
6. ये हिस्सा खासकर उत्तराखंड के पिथौरागढ़ जिले के लिए बहुत ही महत्वपूर्ण है।
बांकि नेपाल और भारत का रिश्ता अच्छा है और अच्छा ही बना रहे। 🇮🇳 🫴 🇳🇵
Nepal Is Right.
I am a Nepali and have been watching you for a year now. I am confident that with this video you will gain a significant amount of Nepali fans too.🙂
I have been following this India-Nepal border issue for a long time and all I can say is the accuracy and honesty with which you have explained the scenario has gained more respect for you.
Things that should have been included are the election of 1959 where the people living in that area have voted in Nepali election and the census of 1961 where Nepal Included people from that area which favours Nepal Historically too.
One thing I don't understand is how Indian media are misunderstanding and misinterpreting this issue. They have not done any research on the geographical and historical point of view and all they are doing is blaming China for interfering. I am totally shocked by the fact that the Indian media have so many resources but also do not focus on research.
I find your research more accurate than most of the media houses of India. Finally, Thankyou for making things clear for all. Love From Nepal ❤️
Me too
how loooooooooong time?
Indian media just show what they want to show despite knowing facts. NEPAL is 100% right here, I am not supporting Nepal because I m from Pakistan but because they are fully justified here. Peace and regards
@@hackerbhau1709 bhau tu idhar vi naak main ungli daal raha hai
British kon hota hain border decide karne waala
Nepal and india are like twins brother.we will solve it diplomatically ❤️
हां सही कहा
इसके ऊपर ऐसी वीडियो बनाने के जरूरत नहीं है।
♥️
That's better for Nepal when comparing Military power. 😎
@@dhruvrathee ♥
Lots of Love from Nepal
You're right ✅️ Jay Nepal 🇳🇵 Jay India 🇮🇳
Thank you for the video. I just wanna share few more facts with you all.
1. When Nepal joined UN back in 19's, Nepal has shown the disputed areas as territory of the Nepal.
2. The population of that region has been considered in determining total population of Nepal.
3. The residence pays tax to Nepal Government
4. Most importantly, the residence of disputed areas proudly want to recognize themselves as Nepali.
Long live India - Nepal cordial relationship.
I also want to add one point to your facts that Indian government reserves special govt jobs and scholarships to people of that region and asks them to call themselves Indian citizen. Which doesn't show good intention.
Very True Nirvana Budhathoki. You missed this points Dhrub Rathee.
@@JitendraYadav-nb4tw
1. Look different map issued by British, India itself, maps issued by different organization from 1816 to now. There are more than enough you can find. All the maps show the real KALI river mentioned in treaty and where is Kali river that India is arguing? Analyse them. If you cannot find one, i can give you source. Do experience survey, take idea from Hydrologist, take idea from cartographer, read your own map history first. Don't try to be expert without having the knowledge.
2. Look Sugauli treaty (1816 Mar 4), it says east to kali river is Nepal.
3. Analyse the map of Nepal issued by India in 1857
4. Look agreement from 1860 Nov 1 , where British returned some parts of Nepal which was given to British during Sugauli treaty
5. Look map of Nepal from 1875 Jan 7, which was created during marking Dubuwa region of Dang.
6. Look original Tax invoice, which was paid by people of Limpiyadhura to Government of Nepal, search if you also have the same.
7. People from Limpiyadhura were enlisted in Nepals Voter List in 1958, search if they were included in any Governmental list of India, if any then analyse.
8. People from Limpiyadhura were enlisted in Census of Nepal in Census year 1961.
9. Ask the historian, when for the first time Indian Army created camp in Kalapani Area. Simple logic, if Kalapani was territory of india, there should be administration of India before 1962. The same applies for Nepal also however we have evidence that people there used to pay tax to Nepal. Infact, King Mahendra from Nepal showed a great heart for India and permitted Indian Army to do business in Kalapani(Nepals region) giving them advantages during Sino-Indian War in 1962. Since then, they are camping there. Nepal has been asking them to leave in different time however India is capturing the land illegally.
10. When China and India did agreement in 2015, Nepal objected to India-China trade pact via Lipulekh pass. Government of Nepal sent diplomatic note to both the government of India and China against the trade pact which includes Nepals Land. Government of China reacted the diplomatic note and said they would review it on contrary, Government of India showed no respect.
11. Government of India has been accepting there is some boarder issue in Kalapani however they included the parts in their map issued in late 2019. As far as I know, they must have discussed to GON before issuing their boarder map. Consequently. Government of Nepal has no option but to issue its map consisting its own territory.
12. It is not that Nepal started protesting only after the road has been completed but Nepal has been warning India to construct boarder road to Kailash Mansarovar in Kalapani region but surprisingly, Defence minister of India inaugurated the link road to Kailash Mansarovar.
13. Government of Nepal has sent diplomatic note and has been sending to seat in table and talk for this issue my friend.
There are much more evidences with Nepal which can be shown in the table talks. I request you to collect the same before claiming the land. I believe India is truly democratic country and we can resolve it peacefully in table. I also believe this will make no differences between everlasting relations of ours.
Don't fights you guys are brothers
This issue arise now because Nepal have two third majority government now, which is stable. At past years Nepal government have to make decisions according to India's interest.
I liked your research very much. This is called young and talented Indians. Love frm Nepal🇳🇵👍
Exactly, people (specially our elders) and the government, definitely need to understand this and give it a second thought from each others pov.
Dost share garnu parxa sakey samma FB ma yo .
Thanks bro ❤❤❤
Abey ye toh ghar ka jhagda hai bhaiyon ka aapas me, sulajh jayega. I think India must pay some compensation to Nepal and keep the territory in return.
Please note that India also protects the interests of Nepal and Bhutan very actively in the region
I don't know why Nepal has started bargaining with us.
NIRAJ KARKI ARE U DHOTIOR UR FAMILY FROM DHOTI
Because this is a legal document is in favor, of whatever is in practice. Land belonging to Nepal may support in peace controlling the India and China conflict.
❤Thanks from Nepal
BEST LINE- "Logically soche to india & Nepal ke beech me Border naam ka hi hai. Indians aur nepalese bina kisi passport visa ke border cross kr skte hai, to fir ye controversy kyu...mtlb sirf political map pr ise present krne ke liye.."
That is not true. Nepalese are not allowed in that region without prior permission from Indian side. Get your facts checked.
Sir agar wo area india mein hua to Indian policies, laws, aur baaki cheeze waha implement hongi..aur agar nepal mein hua to waha ki cheeze waha implement hongi.. isliye ispe baatcheet karni zaroori hai!!
Yeah that's sounds good but clamming other land is not good.
Kumar Bhandari Nepalese are not allowed in that region but Overall nepalese can enter india & indians goes to nepal without any visa passport...
Think from broader sense..☺
@@akshaykhurana1954 that doesn't matter... Permanently Indians honge wo ya Nepalese... This is important
Representation of Good Journalism. Love from Nepal.This type of journalism will rank up the world press freedom of India.
But unfortunately this doesn't include in journalism 🥺
Love from India. We all know today's indian government is very foolish and aggressive. Land goes to anyone, but India and nepal should remain friend.....
@@SandeepVerma-bf1ry listen u naive woman mind your tone .
Who the hell u think you are to talk shit about our govt.
I hope things get sort out in peaceful way & good relationship with each other continue forever.
Just because unke ancestors ne object nai kiya (there could be several reasons like Nepal was not strong enough to object) that doesn't shun their(Nepali's) rights, legally that is their land cos their ancestors didn't make any treaty after sugauli treaty regarding the new boundary...just because India has been using that land and nobody objected doesn't make the illegal capture legal...Nothing can justify India's act.
India afterall has been illegally using that land
And if Nepal claiming their land doesn't look practical to Indians then so should India claiming POK land its own.
im from nepal thanks bro all are equal in every situtation
Real and critical analysis, a lot of respect from Nepal
main thing: the friendship should prevail forever.. Mutual respect is very important
Diplomatic opinion.
Diplomatic opinion bcz nothing is perfectly perfect nor perfectly wrong.
Every decision of a human, government etc. has got positive and negative effects and this is law of nature.
Jai Hind 🙏
Jai Bharat 🙏
What about momos man???
Nepal and indian should share common ownership and continue the friendship
Mr. Dhruv you are right NEPAL IS RIGHT
I am Nepali and now living in India qk mere father bhi Indian Army mai hai n proud to be daughter of Indian army.
So I love my janam bhoomi(Nepal) and karam bhoomi(India).
I totally agree with you sir.
But in my opinion (Dono country ke sarkar ko bethak kar leni chahiye ese aps mai lad k koi faida ni..
😍🥰
Aam also lndian Gorkhay I love my India go U go back Nepal.
@@henrygurung2136 but your ethnicity is Nepali, your blood is Nepali and your culture is Nepali except for your nationality.
Anime Nation
Ethnicity does not define nationality and patriotism. First consider madhesis of Nepal as a Nepali
First of all thanks to your braveheart father...I salute him...
I wanna say one thing that is you go through history then Indian boarder should touch Iran...but it's not possible... therefore History k hisab se Jane se nhi hoga na...
We love Nepal...Love from Assam,India
Nepal is right
Both China & India are sky rocketing in development where in Nepal is Sandwiched, in the brink of deep dark dive downwards !!! Explain that Good neighbours.
What a explaination !
Never expect from today's indian media.
Ravish kumar ko mt bhula
Same thought
Ravish kumar is nice anchor.
@@ezio1896 Yes bro... ravish sr mean literal news rest of all are propoganda
I m an Indian Nepali , love to hear ur all analysis, god bless to Nepal and india