Eren begins the Rumbling but it's Light and Shadow
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 02. 2022
- Added the classic Light and Shadow from the Motion Manga to the manga scene. Also changed a lot of the scene ordering (mostly because I had to fit the music in) I hope you like it.
Probably the final Shingeki no Kyojin edit? Who knows.
After Effects
Sony Vegas
FL Studio 20
#shingekinokyojin
#attackontitan
#aot - Krátké a kreslené filmy
The Mappa version: the Marleyian perspective
This version: the Eldian perspective
Light and shadow is the most attack on titan song Sawano has ever written that wasn’t used in attack on titan
It's unfortunate. That light and shadow lyrics would've fit so good in multiple great aot moment
Don't forget Shadowlord
@@acclimatized8838 except the first line "how does it feel got no one on your side"
@@jayvhoncalma3458 what’s shadowlord?
1hunded knight too
I don't even associate Light and Shadow with League of Legends anymore. This will forever hold a place in my heart as Ymir and Eren's theme.
It's a song by Sawano himself so it's natural
@@nausheensiddiqui8745 yes hiroyuki goatsawano
Zeke has same VA with Sett
Sawano: Ah what a masterpiece composition. I think I'll let League of Legends have it.
AoT Fan base: *kicks down door and steals Light and Shadow*
It's so sad the Ymir-Eren duo was dropped in the manga ending. They complemented each other perfectly.
This is the perfect ost for this scene. Im glad someone make it.
Once the show end you'll know it's not
Everyone: yo this scene was amazing.
Harrenysk: "Yes, but it can always be better."
2:40 to 3:08 Put your earbuds/headphones on max right around here. You can practically feel and hear Ymir's 2000 years of pent up rage finally getting unleashed here.
Y'know, I never really thought about it, but when you have this song over it all...that bolt of lightning sounds like Ymir screaming. Two thousand years of imprisonment, turned into fury.
Beautifully worded, liked
I think this captures the moment of the manga better. Hisayama ended the original chapter on the shot at 3:20 of the skull of Eren's new titan above Gabby. The moment is essentially the culmination of Eren's entire character arc and his ultimate moment of triumph in the series (I'd argue this is the best written moment in the whole manga, nothing feels as impactful as the rumbling.)
Isayama allows the reader to enjoy Eren really defeating Zeke simply because he chose Ymir's humanity, wheras Zeke saw her as a Slave.
He doesn't really allow you to absorb the full impact of how horrible the Rumbling is till the next chapter where you see the shot of Eren's face at the end.
honestly that is why i ended the scene with a abrupt cut to silence! you could put in the horror atmosphere and music immediately after, which in turn whiplashes the audience around
@@harrenysk we could have a post ending scene with the original ost that was used, showing us the apocalyptic aspect of the rumbling then ending the scene with Eren's speech idk
@@Blackbirdiiie dang that gives me chills just thinking about it. Perfect end credits scene
@@yoush3599 yeah it could have been a lot but Mappa did really well too so it's okay but yeah there were so much ideas
I'am deeply saddened
Our Eren, he broke the literal "Chains of Fate" he was bound by to save Ymir and give her a choice
What a beautiful and powerful scene this is, I will never forget this
The author made Eren say he is an idiot with power in the last Episode
I cannot take this misery
>I'm here as well because i hated the line i am an idiot. What a waste
@@reemalhalbouni Our Eren had indomitable will, they took it from him
Check this out I like your uke covers
czcams.com/video/IdPLTeNpBgQ/video.htmlsi=7uORQYfbrR9MXJcz
lmao. Profile pic checks out.
@@Net_Flux go back to watch you netfux slop
this happened cz of the toxic fandom,,whom are hating the manga ending!! in manga eren never said this line!!
THE ABRUPT CLIFFHANGER IS PERFECTION THIS MADE ME TEAR UP NO JOKE
Yeah, it's perfect
But the way the lyrics apply to Ymir so perfectly-
How does it feel
Got no one on your side
It isn’t how
It is really meant to be
As light and shadow
The sun and the moon
Torn between love and hate
I’ve gotta get it somehow
Gaining by losing
Always haunts us
To our dying day
Stuck in the haze
How did it ever come to this
I thought I’ll never see you again
Once the stars been scattered in
Pieces all over the galaxy
Eyes on eyes
What d’you wanna regain
After all I wonder how
You feel about this madness
There’s no way people listen and watch this and think the song is cheery or hype. It’s a sad and empathetic song. The somber tone and soft buildup that plays as Eren breaks free of his chains and runs towards Ymir (the biggest victim in the AOT universe). Then it stops, Eren speaks and begins to show he cares. Giving hope to Ymir that there is someone out there that cares about her and that she doesn’t have to forsake her life for others. This moment represents that Eren is the freedom that Ymir has always yearned for and never knew until it finally hits her through a tear showing her humanity.
she is NO GOD, NO SLAVE, she is a HUMAN BEING.
I mean that’s from her perspective but imo doesn’t fit ymir being free she will be free once everything is over Imo it’ll fit with the final chapter just not this , foot steps of doom shows that the end of the world has just started, millions are going to be part of genocide and there’s nothing you can do to stop it
Yea but the song literally used in the league cinematic shows the character being saved. It is obviously somber in the beginning, the pay off is the overcoming. It’s sad, but with the huge drop it is what makes the song uplifting. Maybe aspects of bittersweetness, but it’s certainly hype as well if you pair it with the reveal of reiner and bertoldt’s transformation
Yeah we all watched the same thing you did. You're not telling anyone anything new
@@luisgomez8635 you must be so fun at parties.
Emotional and sympathetic... till they bust out light and shadow by last guardian while founding titan eren transforms having that played in the background!
Thoughts on this scene and usage of ost in general:
this exercise in editing really let me appreciate the importance of music in conveying the intent and purpose of the characters.
When I read the manga, my mind put a large emphasis on the fleeting relationship between eren and ymir, and my view was that eren approached ymir primarily with a sense of empathy for her plight as a slave of fritz. in that moment, the focus was on ymir's freedom, not really the rumbling. thus, i felt that the song showcased eren and ymir's empathy (i am doing this for freedom), and not their rage (i am doing this to kill my enemies).
in contrast, the tv version focuses more on eren's rage. there is a certain amount of malevolance in the TV version due to the lack of music and the grim tone of the music when it eventually starts playing. Of course, this hits harder on the apocalyptic aspect, but i feel that it strips away the emotional momentun of the scene which was the relationship between eren and ymir (in my view). at the same time, the apocalyptic aspect of the rumbling could come later; after the commercial break we get a perspective of the sheer sense of destruction wrought by eren.
Well said man. Eren being the first person to actually recognize Ymir's plight after two thousand years of being used by others hit me so hard when I first read it.
I liked the music and atmosphere when Eren transformed in the anime, but I feel like it really brought down the impact of that moment and made it seem like he was still just using her like everyone else. I don't know, it just felt underwhelming, especially in comparison to your edit here, thanks for making this.
the tonal whiplash of a cheery ost and an apocalyptic scene gives me an end of eva vibe - definitely feel like something similar could be done for aot, but i highly doubt it
@@mcbaws21 Where in the world is this a cheery ost? It literally sounds like a sad song??
you deserve so much more credit than you get, every single edit you make is good enough to be considered a masterpiece
i did an amazing version of this but youtube banned it if u want i can share at least the name of the song which also belongs to hiroyuki sawano
Fuck the ending, this is the true Eren, this is the true Ymir, they both desire Freedom, they are not Slaves, this is their breaking down their chains and saying they had enough.
Exactly mikasa is nowhere near important enough to be the answer to everything
Completely agree.
pretty much everyone agrees that AoT peaked here.
Even coming back to this scene hits hard.
When I read it for the first time in the manga (122) it felt like a masterpiece. It will always be my favourite scene in all anime history.
LMFAO
Tell me, if the Eren in the ending isn’t the ’true Eren’, why do they desire freedom?
Because both of them are enslaved by something. And both of them desire freedom from that enslavement. That is the whole point of this scene.
You’re right. This is the moment when they tried breaking down their chains. That is literally what happened here. And that’s not changed by the ending.
This is when Ymir first tries to rebel against her enslaved existence. After this moment, she used the Paths to go back in time and set up the events that lead to Mikasa’s choice, where she chooses of her own free will to kill Eren, thereby proving to her that she could rebel against the toxic love that enslaved her, creating a closed loop. That’s how she succeeds in breaking her chains.
Meanwhile, this is Eren’s final rebellion. This is the moment when Eren once again denies that he is enslaved by his own desire for freedom. This is when Eren tries to wipe out the entire world, even though he knows that Mikasa will kill him at 80%. Here, he chooses to deny the truth of his beloved ’freedom’ one last time, even though he knows he’ll fail. Because even that rebellion was simply one more link in the chains that enslave him to his desire to be free. Therefore, he fails to break his chains, whilst Ymir succeeds. That’s the whole point.
There is nothing different about Eren in this scene and Eren in the ending. The only difference is that the Eren in the ending openly displays his sorrow over the truth of his enslaved existence, instead of trying to angrily deny it. You just didn’t like it because Eren was human in that moment, rather than a merciless chad that slept with Historia.
Dude. You can quit it. The ending is good. That’s not just an opinion. That’s an objective fact. Opinion polls, rating websites and the most relevant anime reviewers on the Internet show that at least 90% of the fandom likes the ending. In entertainment, when you have that high amount of people liking an ending, then that means that that’s not just a good ending. Most would call that a perfect ending.
“It was Mikasa all along”
If you see this scene it's obvious that Eren is talking about himself but no, Isayama decided it was Mikasa xD
@@Lumigle It's not "Isayama" who decided it was Mikasa. It's Eren who thinks Mikasa was the most important piece. That is Eren's POV, not the narrator's.
@@Net_Flux Isayama is the author, he decides everything and Eren freed Ymir right there. There was no real reason for Mikasa being essential at the end
@@Lumigle A lot of things like Ymir still building titans wouldn't make sense if Ymir was "freed right there".
@@Net_Flux A lot of things make 0 sense at the end. For example:
- Annie's return was bullshit, straight up from a sitcom.
- The jaegerists were unable to sink the boats or the airplane (only vehicles that let the alliance stop Eren), but they waste 50 thunderspears on Pieck and miss every one. xD
- The alliance surviving a battle against THOUSANDS of intelligent titans (and this titans appear without any real reson or rule that is in this world too because they are empty shells).
- When Armin and Zeke were talking in paths, a random leaf appears in from of them. Armin sees a leaf and Zeke sees a baseball. Thanks to this random shit, for whatever reason appear all the past inheritors of the past titans (Kruguer, Bert...) and Armin convinces Zeke to leave paths and gets killed because potato.
- Reiner can stop the Hallucigenia itself, and is maybe 10 times or more bigger than him.
And more random shit that happens
I can’t thank you enough for this. This is exactly in line with what myself and many of those who read this scene years ago felt. That sense of liberation as Eren shows Ymir the first bit of kindness in 2,000 years. That she is neither slave, nor God, but a human being.
The anime focuses on the horror of the Rumbling itself, which I think is a waste of one of my favorite moments from this story. But I guess MAPPA’s take is more in line with Isayama’s vision, so I’ll have to settle for your edit(s).
and yet... it was mikasa all along, fml
@@victorhugo127 you don't get it, it was always about love, aot isint that deep bro /s
@@victorhugo127 it was the trio
Eren , Mikasa and Armin
It was more than 2000 years cause time really don't exist in that space it's probably way more than that cause they said the Titan powers been passed down so for ever transformation for 2000 Ymir had to make the Titan by hand so let's say someone takes Titan form 10 times on average per year it's way more than that but let's say 10 now there is 9 Titan forms so that's 90 transformation per year that multiplied by 2000 years is 180000 years that's the bare minimum and we didn't add ymirs time to make the Titan form with the size I'm pretty sure a short girl like her takes atleast 2 weeks minimum to make one Titan so 180000*2 weeks = 360000 weeks which is 7500 years which is relatively short 🤔 again this is bare minimum time
@@aryanchakraborty5956when someone says aot isn't that deep i just know they braindead
You can actually pinpoint the moment AoT was good the last time: this moment right here
Erens pov also. Rest of the rumbling arc was shit tho
Idk how you do it but the roar you use for Eren when he's transforming sounds so powerful it's honestly perfect.
I've been replaying this for the past 30 minutes and I still can't get over it, this is amazing. 💀
This song should’ve been used on Attack on titan, it fits perfectly of the world
So this... is the power... of having a competent director
If I think of the Rumbling as a way for Eren to bring peace to the world, then I'd say it wasn't worth it.
But if I think of the Rumbling as a catharsis for Ymir for being humanity's greatest slave for 2000 years, then I'd say it was worth it.
80% is a LOT of innocents who wouldn't even know who Ymir is, but 2000 years is also a heck of a long time to spend in a sand castle hell.
that's how I see it
damn the world for daming you case
This just hits different!
Hits like it did in the manga!
This music choice perfectly embodies the mood I felt when reading the manga, this is supposed to be a moment of catharsis for Eren and Ymir, this moment is literally what everything in the story has been leading up to: the destruction of the walls both literal and metaphorical that kept them trapped in a birdcage, the end of Fritz's world, the end of the king's binding on the Eldians, the result of 2000 years.
2:59 that parallels Reiner n Bertold betrayal scene really well
I really did cry to this.
It was that powerful.
This is just… art. Your editing made this scene perfect, and I already thought it was originally.
I feel like it would be more make sense and emotional if eren's intention of freeing ymir was because he wanted to end the never-ending slavery rather than love to the first king fritz
both are the same thing for Ymir
That’s literally the point. Her love to King Fritz IS her enslavement. That’s why Eren was trying to free her.
This in of itself could be considered a perfect ending because it captures the hope for a better future for the Eldians who are being prosecuted and discriminated by the governments of the world, who plotted to wipe off the people of Paradis, as well as the horror and cruelty that must happen in order for the Eldians to survive and finally be free from their bondage.
A beautiful cautionary tale in a world of grey where no one is truly right or wrong but simply doing what they believe is right. It is exploration of the railroad scenario in where what would someone do in a scenario where they are cornered by the world and the sacrifice that must be made just to be able to live without fear or prosecution just for being born.
I'm not gonna watch the original episodes anymore, I'm just gonna wait for your edits to come out.
If i was trapped in this hell for 2000 Years i too would do anything to be free and i coudn't care less for the world.
Remember time works differently in path realm.
One second in real world equals to years in the path realm.
Just imagine how long Ymir has been trapped in there this whole time......
THANKS, beyond this world.
Wow! I'm impressed, expected some fan tiktok edit style shit, but you've edited it pretty good, even voices with echoes sounds really good here, good job. With this song I felt that it was only about Ymir, it adds something personal to her emotions, not like in original - "oh, Ymir finally opened her eyes, now Eren has the power to destroy the walls so he does and HYYYYPE, so let's forget about Ymir for the entire show", no, here it feels like "what could have been..." type of shit, and I liked that!
I like this better than the anime version because it focuses on the emotions between eren and ynir instead of just the horror of the rumbling. Good shit man
I fucking kneel, my knees are dust
Such a breathtaking edition with all the soundtrack and flashbacks!
"So long as my world last, until the end of__"
"IT ENDS NOW!"
I don't know why but him saying "It ends now" instead of "I'll end it" sounds a lot better
I absolutely love how he edited the way Eren shouts it, it's so powerful compared to his sudden "I'll end it" in the original. And the silence that follows it adds more emotional impact.
Wrong translate, the king said his reign will be forever, and “it ends now” will make sense
This really illustrates that while the world didn't deserve the Rumbling, Ymir certainly did. After all that suffering, all that self-denial, all those years serving and caring for everyone else, Ymir deserved someone who'd destroy the world for her and let her have her catharsis regardless of how immoral it truly is.
Wonderful, I always read this chapter with Call of Silence because I had the same reasoning as you. I thought it was more emotional than anything when Eren talked with Ymir after 2000 years. I don't think MAPPA did anything wrong is just that this was my favourite chapter because of the development of Eren and the bond between these two characters. Both seeking for freedom even after 2000 years. Thanks for giving this direction it's more close to what I thought when I read chapter 122.
Right? After I read this part in the manga, it really seemed as if the series, for the past 122 chapters, truly was leading up to this singular moment. The ultimate reflection of Eren's character as someone who desires freedom. This desire would bleed over to helping people like Historia and Ymir, who suffer and are shackled through no fault of their own, trapped in walls created by tyrants. It's important that Eren has this empathy, because only then he is able to sympathise with the Warriors, and yet come to an understanding that not every problem in the world can be fixed.
This matches the feelings that I had when I first read this part. The kindness that Eren extended to Ymir and the fact that for the first time in her life someone offered a choice and the flow of emotions that she felt and expressed for the first time in 2000 years. The flashbacks really made the edit so much more and the weight of Ymir being free is really felt. I still wish that they didn't do part of Eren and Ymir's talk as a background thing when Zeke started to call to Ymir but that was a choice of the studio. Also I am interested to see if there is a way to break the music between when Ymir is free and when the Rumbling actually starts.
时隔一年再看，又一次惊艳了我，完全超越原作👍
This is amazing, brought back so many memories of early AoT, I cried really hard from hapiness watching this, thank you.
Thanks so much for this edit, this one's way better than what we see with the original. THIS IS pure emotional and make me tear up everytime I watch it. That's all I was expecting of this scene and you delivered.
This is a thousand times better than the original. This is the feeling I was hoping to feel for this scene. Thank you so much for editing this, not only the music are so great and fit so well. But your editing make the power of the transformations and explosions are so much stronger and satisfying.
Idk to me it doesn’t fit , Ymir might be free at last but at the same time she is allowing Eren to destroy the world and kill innocent children, imo to much hope for the wrong purpose , it’s like playing this song during ch 131
@@Requiem0139 Well, at least I think they should add a background music when Eren's talking to Ymir it would've been so much more emotional. I don't like the fact they did that scene completely silence and make the whole scene so ... bad
@@stormgaming9640 oh yea when he was talking to Ymir they for sure should add a background ost like this or like when historia freed Eren , both girls were freed , I just can’t see it during the rumbling as it is the end of the world
@@Requiem0139 and if they do'nt do the rumbling they allow to kill innocent children in paradis, what is your point?
@@slayser7179 read
Your edits are mind blowing. You could honestly make a career out of this, these edits are magic. I watched this video at least 10 times today and back when you were editing declaration of war I was literally hooked on every video, love your work.
y'all know this man fire when your looking forward to his edits more than the actual scene being animated
CANT STOP WINNING
Thank you for making this edit. This song reflects perfectly how Eren empathizes for Ymir and the sadness of this situation. Violence against violence. Violence in order to solve this conflict.
2:59 good timing,the music and the transformation
100/10 Just epic, a good ost really does changes a lot!
Everyone talking about how it fit better meanwhile me thinking both songs enhance different feelings of the moment and they're both great
The pacing and editing of the video is amazing!! And the ost tells you that finally Ymir is free!
who tf would ever watch this and think to side against eren. lmao
People with basic moral principles of knowing genocide is wrong. Especially when your ancestors caused the conflict.
The emotional aspect is what lacked from the anime imo, when i read the manga it really felt like a "finally freedom for both ymir and eren" so an emotional ost would have been preferred for the paths scene. Nothing wrong with the anime version it just didn't hit as much as the manga did
Yeah, the anime was epic but more like “Eren is evil”
@@APsGTG i guess each studio pushed their own ideas, eren being evil and wit making mikasa a hugeeee simp and removing so many of character development scenes
@@Requiem0139 *ahem* plenty of historia and levi scenes *ahem*
By far the best edit with this song
This edit is INSANE. Thank you very much.
The lightning sound effect and the drop work so fucking well! Amazing edit
"I thought I'd never see you again..." Just as Eren transforms back in front of Gabi after she thought she'd killed him...Why does this fit so well? That's not even to mention how the entire theme and feel of this song encapsulates this whole scene. C H I L L S
It felt like this moment was basically glossed over in the original version. This feels like it has a much more fitting and appropriate emotional weight to it. Thanks for doing what you could to clean up one of my favorite moments in the whole manga, and for me, possibly the manga's most simultaneously beautiful and tragic moment. It's a shame that it's mostly downhill from here. At least once the anime is over, the disappointment train will finally reach its final station and I'll be able to forget about the ending.
AOE is coming, get ready
@@adrijiyuda better be. How do u know
@@rubendw8316 I can drop you a discord link and all the theories are in there
I don't like the end. I wished Eren had succeeded in it.
As an anime only ii never understood your comment but ii get it😪😪 Aot still top 15 for me tho. EASILY
holy shit!!!! you made it so perfectly! You even repleaced the order of some shots to make it just like in the manga. take my like!
I loved the anime and this version!!! You're the GOAT!!!
I can't thank you enough for this. It's just... so fucking beautiful.
I love the comment section on these videos. Seeing that others care as much about this show as I do is all ive ever wanted.
This edit is so SO good, kino work as always
the editing is fucking impeccable, i love how you kind of mixed up the scenes a bit to give the song more impact. awesome video!
with light and shadow as bgm for aot gives me chills. It really fits as a theme song for Ymir
FUCK THIS FITS EXTREMELY PERFECT SHITTTTTTTT
This is exactly how i thought the scene would play out, thank you very much for this.
You earned a sub an an eternal following from me.
So intensive and emotional
I swear to god I saw a rumbling manga edit with this same ost two or three years ago which got me to read the manga and get excited for S4 but yeah I can see and understand how most of the fans including me would've wanted an absolutely epic ost and wanted this to be portrayed as an epic moment but I also like how Mappa went a bit creative and portrayed this scene as complete horror and apocalypse like bro that ost which they played can be used in a good Conjuring or Insidious movie
Bro I got goosebumps at the "to be continued"
First, I already know this is gonna be a good edit.
I rewatch your edits all the time. They give me so many chills. I just wanted to let you know, if you read all of these comments, that you make AOT so much better for me. Thank you.
what a nice edit, well done… this ost fits so much better 💔
this is so beautiful, you've done a way better job than mappa here
I can’t with how well edited this video is
MY GUY, THIS IS AMAZING! THANK YOU
what a masterpiece, i get goosebumps even after seeing it many times.
The fcking rage in ymir eyes scary
This is so perfect! :)
who else watches this daily
Me
holy jesus the part where gaby sees eren transform hits hard with the music
Maaaa god this gave me chills !!
So perfect
Didn’t expect
SUCH A MAGICAL AND WORKED OUT
!!! EDIT !!!
Wow! I really do like this version of the Rumbling! So terrifying yet sad. Great work!
This is very well made! Great job!!!
This is such a MASTERPIECE!
That song is wasted on league of legends lol
I disagree
true sadly
Nah it fits perfectly you guys just salty as fk haha
@@death2ablenah he's rigtht
It fits if you read the star guardian lore
Everything you make is amazing
Am I the only one or is Eren’s skull at 3:30 reminding Hirudegarn’s first form from DBZ: Wrath of the Dragon?
Fantastic edit, saving this
I would like to edit like this. Thank you so much for make this, that scene was amazing :O
If perfection exists It will be this
Nice editing bro, the direction WOAAAAAH
okay, I stop for a moment on 2:40 , im already in tears now.. Oh Boy Its Going To Be Chill On My Spine Wasnt It?
Pure Kino, god bless you
A M A Z I N G E D I T !
Im glad aot ending so well right here. Peak
Idk if this is sarcasm or not, but I agree, am not watching any more aot eps after this and just settle for edits like these instead😔
Stunning, superb editing, it's more involving than the original.
Perfect!
This is insanely good!