Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
IKEA Idasen Electric Sit/Stand Desk Review
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 08. 2024
- SAVE 55% OFF RETAIL: Refurbished Steelcase Chairs www.btod.com/r...
Watch Next: I Picked The Best Standing Desk at EVERY Price • I Picked The Best Stan...
The IKEA Idasen launches after a less than stellar Bekant product has been available to the masses for close to four years. With numerous electronic failures, poor reviews across the web and even on their own site, there was a bit of hesitation to believe the Idasen would be better.
Much to the delight for the customers that are IKEA faithful, they made a major upgrade in OEM to global leader Linak. With a shot in the arm (or leg), the IKEA Idasen instantly had an opportunity to improve over its predecessor. In this video, we take a closer look at the things I liked and didn't like about the IKEA Idasen desk.
Full Disclaimer: We are an office furniture dealer and sell some of the products we review. To learn more about the products we sell, our review process and why you can trust us, please visit: bit.ly/2LsiXIy
Watch Next: I Picked The Best Standing Desk at EVERY Price czcams.com/video/tuWw8L2tIBA/video.html
You forgot the å! But dont worry i got it on my keyboard so i can type it for you! 😂
Hi BTOD, I suggest you to add an alternative metric measurements alongside the imperial ones, because as someone who lives in Asia, I find it's annoying if I have to keep mentally converting the numbers. Thanks
@@dny4469 I second that
Wobble at maximum height was my primary concern when buying a standing desk for a gaming setup; this comprehensive review was the video that finally helped me make my purchasing decision. Over a year later I have no regrets about buying the Idasen--it's my favorite IKEA product.
Wow, incredibly professional and comprehensive review. I was floored when you guys pulled out the wobble meter, didn't think there was a proper way to measure wobble. Amazing videos guys
Appreciate the kind words! Glad we could help -GK
+1 on the detail and quality of this review.
Bought this desk 1 year ago after I watched this review. The desk still works flawlessly. Thank you 😊
I got mines on my birthday last November. Glad we got it when it was cheaper! only $600 back then.
@@aceTL87 hope you like it!
No BS to the point review. Loved it.
The wobble meter was the cherry on top :D
Thank you for the comment! Glad we could help -GK
If anyone like me is watching this in 2023, be aware that this desk is now up to $200 more expensive than it was at the time of this video. $749 for the 47" and $799 for the 63". Not nearly as competitive at those prices, in my opinion.
This is such an impressive review. Great job!
Thank you! -GK
There might not be physical buttons for various heights, but via the App you can program 'favourite positions'. The desk will make a stop when coming by the favourite position height. Not exactly a physical button, but it comes very close! This is enough for me. Anyway, I realise after a year of use, i do not stand a lot. Mostly use the desk sitting.
Can you also show centimeter? It always so annoying constantly translating it
DarioAM And kg!
Just learn freedom units
As I'm typing this right now the 27.5" x 47.25" is $699, the 31.5" x 63" is $749, and the frame is $569. 20%, 25%, and 27% increase respectively.
Just a heads up. I know there's been inflation and Ikea upped their minimum wage, but still it's something to keep in mind. I've been waiting for the smaller desk or the frame, so I guess I'm waiting a while longer.
just discovered your channel, and I just want to say thank you for creating such wonderful and honest content
You’re welcome. Thank you for the kind words -GK
i never comment, but this was a really useful review! Thank you!
You’re welcome. Thanks for watching! -GK
I ended up returning the base and kept the table top to use it with a diy base from another brand. The issue I had was that the collision sensor was not working and it would go all the way down crushing the pc and a cabinet. Also, the weight limit was overwhelming. Rated at 150 lbs but that’s including the tabletop so the weight limit is probably less than that. One thing I really liked about this desk was the fact that it’s well made and super sturdy. Other than that, I think it should cost less than what I paid for. And last it doesn’t have an electronic control unit so you have to rely on the app using Bluetooth to choose your predefined height. I wanted to give it a chance, but it didn’t work for me.
Hi, may I know which brand did u get? I'm in market right now.
@@saulw5969 I ended up getting a standing base from Fully. It’s called Jarvis. The one I got can hold up to 350 lb. I’m still using the ikea tabletop but I will switching it to one Fully sells.
6:51 not sure about 4 years ago, but you can set saves positions on the desk with the app. When the desk reaches one of these positions while using the lever on the table it will pause momentarily.
Low weight capacity?
I have an iMac 27", 2 * 27" monitors a desktop PC(a pretty heave one), loads of accessories and a 4ft plant as well the desk top is 10kg heavier than the standard one that comes with this table and still absolutely fine. The weight is not an issue unless you're planning on putting things such as a guitar amp and pro audio mastering setup on it so I really can't understand why this is said. For those European watches 165lb converts to just under 75kg. I could quite easily put twice as much weight as I have on it already and wouldn't be a problem. In the UK and probably Europe I think this is the best sit stand desk for this price and you have to go a lot more expensive to meet this ones quality.
Robert Review thanks for the comment. I was also questioning why low weight capacity was mentioned. Most desks will never see close to 150lbs so it doesn’t seem like a major issue. Great review though !
I think he is comparing the weight capacity to its competitors in the similar price range. For this budget, most of them, if not all, have better weight capacity
Thanks for this comment! So it seems the hollow honeycomb tabletop can withstand all of these. You are using it with the default Idasen tabletop right? I'm planning on putting an 48" OLED TV on it (19kg = 42lbs) with a pair of monitor speakers and a mouse and keyboard. It should be fine, right?
super late, but nw starting some research. This is a solid review. Will go look at the older IKEA stranding desk you reviewed and their issues. Thanks for this. Top shelf review.
Very informative and comprehensive review. Certainly answered all the questions I had as I research sit-stand tables.
Hi Greg, thanks for the very helpful review. In your opinion, is it ok to clamp a monitor arm with dual 24" monitors onto this desk? Since the weight would be focused on the small area that clamps onto the desk. What kind of weight do you think the desk can handle in this way?
I noticed that the idasen isn’t entirely honey comb, it’s particle board in some areas, is there any way to find out which parts are particle and safe to drill/screw at
Would have liked to see a "wobble test" for stability. Where you push against the table and see how much it wobbles as its up high.
That moment when you're in Europe and you hear 01:19
My name is Jeff 😅
Could I use a clamp on dual monitor mount on this without damage? (63'x31.5' version)? Thanks in advance :)
this desk is the best. the only gripe I have is the finish. It's a little bumpy and is not good for writing..
I agree, the texture for the wood grain is very pronounced -GK
Buy the ikea gerton tabletop its amazing
@@t.j.detweiler305 I want to buy it and stain it walnut
Thanks! Would be nice to see how or if any of these desks cares about cable management.
The idasen desk has a mesh under the top to hold cables, ikea also sells a cage upgrade
I think you did an error on your video at 7:53. The price of the 47inch and the 63 inch are mixte up.
great info! thanks By far the best sit-stand desk review. subbed!
Thanks for watching and subscribing! -TK
Am I the only one that hears the motor running (it is a very soft motor sound when desk is not being lowered or risen - standby)? It is a bit annoying when I am sitting quietly reading with no other sounds to cover it up. Can this be dangerous? Can this be fixed?
uhh it might just be yours. mine makes no sound at all when idle
On future reviews, please see just how much the desk actually can lift...Keep adding weight, until it won't raise up anymore. I was hoping, you would try to sit on it, and raise it up. Another question, is uneven loading. Would the desk go off-level, if a 50 pound weight were placed on one end? Most quality actuators are servo controlled, and would indeed raise and lower evenly, even with off center loading. What about a "cheap" one like this?
Did you find out about the uneven load? This is actually my only concern for this desk.
Your review has helped me return my Bekant to get the Idasen. Question could this desk be upgraded to a stronger Linak external power supply system?
Great choice! It is a much better desk, IMO.
We haven’t tested that, but it is something to consider reaching out to Linak directly for more information on -GK
Enrique Reyes how is your table? Better than the berkant?
@@TheSpiritOfTheWest The Idasen is working great. I never opened the box for the Bekant so I can't comment but from the reviews of it on this channel I am glad I returned it. Seems to be very wobbly / unstable and weak lift motors.
Does it make a mild sound from the motor wile moving up and down?
A year ago i bought this for 449€, now it's 649€. 200€ more expensive?! "It's inflation" No bruh it's greed
Now it's 579€.
Free market bro. Don't like it? Make your own and sell it cheaper.
Great Review! Touched on everything I wanted to know.
What would be a good top to replace the IDÅSEN (pronounced I-DOSEN) top? Or do you think the "hollowness" of the honeycomb design (sigh...) is fine to mount heavy monitor and monitor arm to it?
I bought this desk a week ago and today I noticed that the collision sensor stopped working. It almost crushed my pc tower that I had underneath the desk. Is there a way to reset the sensor? I watched your other video about doing a reset when the desk only goes down but it didn’t help fixing with collision sensor. Without this functionality, I see this as a safety issue. I would appreciate any help or recommendations on what to do. Thanks.
What did you do about it? Could you solve the issue?
Great review. I had a strange question. Could I swap the control panel for another one from Linak? One that has a memory and LCD display? Hoping maybe the connection is standard
Thank you! Not strange at all and someone else has asked this same question. They reached out to Linak and the factory said it didn't work. I think it might be time for us to take a closer look -GK
@@btodtv I'd like to know as well, let us know if you find out
Reportedly, all DPG* line control panels are compatible. The usual upgrade is DPG1C that you can get on Amazon for 100 USD currently. I'm considering ordering it for my Idasen as an upgrade, thought after reading this (from a review on IKEA website) I'm not sure yet whether I really need it (maybe for the app only, need to try first): "In conjunction with setting favorites, if you use the paddle to move the desk up or down, when it reaches one of the set 'favorite' heights, it will stop for a moment at one of said heights as a courtesy. It can make getting to a preferred sit or stand height more convenient, without even having to pull out your phone. "
Does anyone know if it works with different table tops such as a BEKANT tabletop
It would works with any table top as long as you have the right length screw and some handyman skills 🫡
Thanks. How many motors does it have?
I've been waiting to buy this desk for almost a year now. It's been out of stock FOR-EV-ER
Great review. Does the wobble test indicate it stable enough to use with castor wheels? If so, any recommendations that will not damage wood floors and have a locking feature?
Maybe use felt furniture pads?
Would have been nice to include metric units.
Ikr
Hey @BTODtv 👋 I am buying the non motorized underframe of idasen. And I mean to use it as a sitting desk exclusively. Does this make the underframe stable enough for say 250 lbs
Would be useful if you added metric units on the side :/
Thank you for the suggestion. This has been a common request and we will try to work this in on future videos -GK
@@btodtv The video overall is very informative but I had to do a lot of conversion to understand.
6:09 I might get the fixed height version, then, considering that I had been planning to have at least 2 monitors on custom mounts.
Whichever version you feel will work best for your specific needs is the route to go! -GK
I have a triple monitor setup mounted with a single arm on an electric BEKANT table, it's rock solid and moves up and down without any issues. I tried a SKARSTA before but that leaned backwards and made the table bend. I'd go to a store and apply pressure and try out any table you are interested in.
Note: 70kg is a lot, monitors do not weigh that much.
@@Slamdoxicalz
That's what I did! It's currently sold out at the nearest store to me as of this reply, but I will get it.
@@Slamdoxicalz How is it holding up now? I want to use a dual monitor arm on mine but I am worried that it would focus too much weight on the area which clamps to the desk. Considering that the desk is mostly made of paper with a very thin fiberboard frame.
Hello Sir, Will you be able to ship to India ? Ikea ran out of these days since 6 months.
Thanks for the review. I just bought this table.
Hope you enjoy it! Glad we could help! -GK
The hollow core desk top can also be viewed as a plus from an environmental "green" perspective, not just in terms of possibly using recycled material and not using lumber, but also the lighter composition requires less energy to ship versus a solid wood desk top, and I am not talking just about shipping from store to your house, but shipping thousands of these from start to finish. These products are very green. I suppose the question would be, well how durable are they, a solid wood table top could last 500+ years. I'd say, barring any major catastrophe there is no reason the ikea desktop can't last as long...the only exception will be water damage and knicks or dings which could be buffed out of solid wood and even out of wood laminate. Ha, anyways, with how much I have typed, maybe I should start making my own videos and talk about pros and cons! Thanks for your reviews I have found them useful.
Monitor mounts are a problem on such desks (heavy monitors or multiple monitors). Interesting thing is that 140x70 idasen is not hollow core table top. It's chipboard. 160x80 and 120x70 are hollow core.
@@arekx Apparently, the 140x70 is not compatible with the stand. You will have to drill the holes yourself
@@arekx Do you know (roughly) how much weight is safe to place on a monitor arm clamp when using one of the hollow desks? Thanks.
@@adiands850 I'm using heavy 14kg (monitor) + 6kg (arm) on such hollow desk BUT with metal reinforcement plates. No problems so far. I wouldn't use such heavy weight without the plates. Google for monitor mount reinforcement plate.
@@arekx Thanks, that's helpful. I am looking at a dual monitor arm, where the total weight of the arm and both monitors would be 10kg.
Great video, Thanks. Looking at getting one in Australia :)
Thank you. Enjoy! -GK
Great review, thank you! One technical question. Is it possible to replace the stock control panel (2-way Bluetooth button) with other LINAK desk control panel from DPG family? DPG1C seems like a perfect upgrade (4 programmable heights, double tilt feature and LCD display), as long as it's technically possible? Is it the same standard LINAK connector for desk control panel used in IDASEN and in other LINAK buttons?
It could be possible, but we haven't tried it. I would recommend reaching out to Linak support to see what their suggestion is for this. Because it is an IKEA Idasen, I don't believe you will be able to turn one one touch functionality. This programming is designed for the IKEA product. Alternatively, the bluetooth DeskApp already comes with three programmable height options. This is available at no extra charge when you purchase the desk.
-GK
@@btodtv Thank you for the insight. I've reached LINAK directly and they told me that pilot (control manette) alone could not be switched to other LINAK solution. The reason in that IKEA IDASEN is provided with custom set of LINAK electronics. Too bad! Still IDASEN frame stole my heart :)
@@btodtv In another review of this table, there is comment which says that Linak DPG1C control switch does work. You might want to investigate. Link: czcams.com/video/LEXQOhEzVhE/video.html&lc=UgzfdWxXljHxSRccTzB4AaABAg
@@qiangduo47 it's actually compatible with DPG1C. Check out reviews on Amazon and mentions about this in BTOD review's comments section. I'm considering ordering one as an upgrade to bring one-touch functionality (auto-drive).
One of the legs of my IDASEN desk is locked in a specific position, and the other one (master) has moved all the way down (it won't move up). Now I have a desk at a 45 degree angle which is not very useful. The engine tries to start, but it seems like something is blocking it. Resetting methods found on the internet aren't working. Has anyone had such a problem and knows how to solve it?
you have a 10 year warranty supposedly
If you are unable to get it to reset, slowing bringing down both legs, then you will want to start a warranty claim -GK
Anyone know the maximum width? The various jiecang desks can go as wide as 72".
Please put metre and centimetres in for non Americans.
Hi Greg, any chance in finding the electrical cord for the table, I recently moved and misplaced the electric cord. :-( I cannot find it anywhere, don't even know where to start.
The review itself is a 10/10 :D
That power cable...
How does this compare to the flexispot?
how long are the 2 feet that touch the floor in cm? thanks
Is it gonna hold up a 43" monitor?
At 7:44, why is the smaller desk more expensive then the larger desk?
Great review. Do you think the butcher board or alternate tops could be used as an alternate with this base?
Yes, absolutely -GK
I know this is old, but do you know what screw size uses the original feet?
Great review!
Thank you! -TK
What is the microphone used on the presenter? please share the details
7:00 in that bluetooth app, it does look like you can change the height to a fixed position with 1 button, under "favorite positions." Also, "the wood veneer finish doesn't hold up to everyday use." What does this mean exactly, that the table starts to crack or the paint chips with everyday use? Was it possible to customize the top in store?
You can save favorites, but you have to press and hold the button until the desk reaches the preset height. This is not as convenient as press and release, then desk moves to position.
The wood veneer surface isn't very durable. The first thing we noticed was how easy it is to leave scratches in the surface. If you're careful with the surface, it might not be an issue
If you are at the store, you can pick any of the different surfaces that IKEA offers (that fit the frame) and pair with the frame only option. Note the pre-drilled assembly holes won't align with these other tops, but that is a minor issue IMO.
-GK
Awesome video thanks
You're welcome! Thanks for watching - GK
i cannot open any of this links > it's directly blocked ? what the reason ?
Im attempting butcher block countertop, 6' 115lbs...
Shame every where is sold out.... But yes got this on my wish list.
so helpful!
I bought one yesterday. It's super stable but loud as all hell....
that's funny cause it didn't sound loud at the store. I love these legs especially in the beige color. Im trying to decided between these or autonomous/uplift
@@aguiremedia which one did you get eventually? I’m also deciding between idasen and autonomous desk
@@abigailyang39 I got the uplift. I actually bought both and sent the Jarvis back even though I wanted that to win cause it was cheaper lol. But the Jarvis was too wobbly at higher heights. I will say that the uplift customer service is terrible. I got sent a bad control paddle and never got refunded the difference. Plus they took forever to respond to second emails.
@@abigailyang39 also the ikea one is expensive but it has a 10 year warranty. The table top is made of cheap material but looks gorgeous. You can also get a different table top from ikea, depending of they’re in stock. It’s also cool that ikea has an app to move the desk.
Great review! I suppose the low weight capacity is related to having only one motor.
Thank you! There are two small motors. The bigger issue is the power supply used with this version of the frame -GK
@@btodtv so the legs can hold a lot more than 165, they just can’t lift it? I need to put weight on it that’s around 450. I’d hate to break a stand up tables “gears” due to weight. I’d of course have a real wood top.
Great review. Can you please review the Herman Miller atlas standing desk and the humanscale float desk? Thank you
Thank you for watching! We have the eFloat in our office and plan to review it soon. We don’t have immediate plans for the HM Atlas, but will make sure to include it on our list. - GK
Pro tip. Buy the non moterised one, it looks cleaner, its lighter and hastnt got cables
It depends on what your needs are. If you want to be able to move from sitting to standing often and 'fast', then you should actually go for the motorized version.
Very helpful thanks!
You’re welcome! -GK
do top sky standing frame its popular on amazon
Does it make sense to mount the Idasen tabletop on any other underframe or will the cardboard filling be a problem?
I probably wouldn't recommend that surface unless you're pairing it with the Idasen. IKEA has other options like their hardwood or bamboo that are nice alternatives. -GK
Can adis legs handle the weight of this table top?
cm?
Actually, the negative reviews are just BS, try to lift 25 pounds free weight vs 50 pounds and see how slowly you would perform. Even car hydraulic lifts take less time to lift a car than a truck, It's just common sense! I could continue but the rest is more BS.
Why... why, oh god why does no e-desk review talk about how wobbly the desks are?!?!?!? I‘ve watched like two dozens of reviews and no one ever wobbles the desks!
More people need to talk about it. Since we started to talk about it in 2017, it has become a greater focus in the industry. Thanks for watching! -GK
@@btodtv thanks for replying! I ordered a Jarvis Fully now. i hope i don't regret it.
Marc Hermes Nice! Hopefully you enjoy the option to stand! -GK
@@deady6yeca how is the Jarvis?
@@DR19X Hi!
The Jarvis is awesome. i only ordered the mechanism, and went to buy the wood plate in the local hardware store. this saved some money. cut out and installed a usb hub myself which also saved some money.
The installation is as easy as it gets, everybody can do that. it wobbles a little, but not in a bad way. when you have a desk at 150cm height, you expect that little wobble. but it really is not much. it's surprisingly stable and solid. the up and down mechanism as well. runs smooth, anti-collision does it's job too. it's great.
it's not only healthier, but it also increased my productivity. definitely worth the investment!
So i am able to use my linnmon tabletop instead of buying another tabletop? Thats what your "frame only" means?
Yes. You just want to verify the dimensions of the frame and top, to ensure they fit together -GK
@@btodtv awesome, thank you for replying! Didnt want to have to buy another desk since mine is perfectly fine.
I asked the customer service if it is possible to mount custom tabletops(wanted a 180x70 linnmonn top) because of the extra 20cm in length but they replied that the custom tabletops need to match the dimensions of the original ones otherwise the warranty will be voided. bummer...
@@AGVersace100 I would mount any size top you prefer, so long as it is within the weight capacity of the desk. They wouldn't be able to void a warranty claim based on that unless your top was excessively heavy and they found you were misusing and/or abusing the product -GK
@@btodtv How about Ikea's Karlby tabletop? is too heavy for Idasen?
Mine won’t go up or down. Help :(
Try to do a desk reset! We have a video on how to reset standing desks. czcams.com/video/LRcx7WwWkyM/video.html Hope this helps! -TK
would be much nicer if this channel would also provide units that the the whole world uses..
Never in stock UK
shipping here is like 3 dollars :)
This desk is $200 more expensive now 😭
HOW. WHY.
Prices have gone up in the 3 years since this video was made. -Ryan
If you added metric measurements to your reviews it would open up your audience to the rest of the world. All these pounds and inches are pretty meaningless to most of the modern world, guys.
$799 for 63" in 2024...
lol @ imperial measurements. jesus it's 2020
We are based in the USA -GK
@@btodtv But still, please include SI measurements in the brackets
"It is a much better company to work with" - looking at the reviews of the Desk Control app, it seems like most people would beg to differ?
I am referring to Linak as the OEM for the desk frame itself vs. ROL Ergo for the Bekant. This is not so much related to their Bluetooth App from Linak -GK
@@btodtv I see, fair enough.
Expensive
Bought to you by Linak®
This desk was purchased from a physical IKEA store location and we paid full price. We have no affiliation with IKEA or Linak. -RB
Really thought this was going to be Billy Mays reviewing this table. Pretty disappointed ☹️
Sorry to disappoint! - GK
lol
well since Billy Mays is DEAD... for several years, you were setting yourself up for disappointment from the start.
Totally useless review using the imperial system, focussing only on the USA. Even the addition in the side specs of the metric system would have increased your potential viewers to the rest of the world.
Typical American centricity
Thanks, bud -GK
Have you ever heard of the metric system? The entire world is using it. Are you living in a cave where you use your foot, inch and the rest of the archaic measurement units? 😄
feels like a hit job
Not sure why, I really like the Idasen desk -GK
Hey! What is the distance between the edge of the right side of the table and the beginning of the right leg tube ? And how thick is the tube at the bottom. I am trying to see if I can wiggle the leg through a tiny space in my apartment.
Ikea sucks - They need to put all that money they invest in infrastructure and store glam and glits, and invest that money into better quality in their products.
This desk is $709 now. Thanks Biden!