Rogue One: Hammerhead Corvette Attack - with music by John Williams
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 04. 2017
- ROGUE ONE: THE BATTLE OF SCARIF is an upcoming fanedit from Maple Films. This video explains the work involved with inserting a classic music cue by John Williams into the hammerhead sequence.
For more info, visit / maplefilms or www.maple-films.com/rogue-one-.... - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Imagine getting the order to ram a god damn star destoyer.
.....say again please Gold Command?
yes it's just occurred to me ramming is exactly what that ship was designed/built to do. it's like a space tug boat.
LMAO
for sure, they all have balls of steel, this sequence is reallyyyyyy great !
"Damn... battle must be going hella bad..."
Fun fact: in the Rogue One novelization (which is canon), Captain Kado Oquoné -the guy we see commanding the pilots of the ship- was angered by the order since it was suicide mission but he then agreed and evacuated all non-essential personal, leaving him and a skeleton crew on board. He and the remaining people on board did not survive.
To show you the power of flex tape, I sawed a star destroyer in half
Fliyo MB *rammed one into another
THAT`S A LOTTA DAMAGE!
This is underrated.
With Flex Tape, the Star Destroyer works like new. No air escapes, and the vacuum of space stays outside. Even the guns work again. KABOOOOOOOM!!!!!
empire should've used flex tape
I enjoyed Rogue One for its choice of characters and the way they did their story. These are no Jedi, these are no overpowered bounty hunters or some other bs that needs plot armor. These are hard working soldiers, they get their hands dirty on the battlefield and win and lose some on the way to victory. This movie shows losses from both sides, the battles make sense, they aren’t to one sided and the sacrifices made are necessary. There is no “happy ending” in this film and that makes it unique, no war is without losses, struggles or sacrifices and Rogue One understands this. By far one of the greatest Star Wars films from Disney
I would say Rogue One is the best from Disney era and one of the best overall
So agreed..rogue one is the best star wars movie..the storyline the characters
THE only great sw film by disney...
Guy 1: Let's build a ship to be a battering ram, in case we have to push another ship.
Guy 2: So Okay maybe add chairs and seat belts for the bridge crew?
Guy 1: Um, Why?
@@bradleyrex2968 because it’s cooler if they’re standing holding on like they’re on the metro or like my grandmother took the wheel and is about to jump the curb for the 4th time on the same I-95 on-ramp.
Sadly, the Hammerhead Corvette "Lightmaker" commanded by Kado Oquoné crashed together with the Prosecutor and Intimidator. He and his crew didn't die in vain and because of them, They contribute to the destruction of the shield, help capture the Deathstar plans in the diskette which include it's weakness and was destroyed in the Battle of Yavin.
I'm pretty sure you can see it jumping away from Scarif after the battle, though
@@risingsun9595 Different Hammerhead
I'm pretty sure they were running on a skeleton crew, IIRC. It was a suicide mission.
@@risingsun9595 The novelization states that all nonessential crewmembers were evacuated before the maneuver and the ship was destroyed in combat.
@@Aquilarden that is good to hear!
"I Used The Star Destroyer To Destroy The Star Destroyer"
Amiral thanos
So should we call you the STAR DESTROYER DESTROYER
lmao 😁 😂 🤣 😃 😄 😅 😆
I used the space dorito to destroy the space dorito*
AKA I hit a mother fucker with another mother fucker XD
1983: ''It's a trap!''
2016: ''I have an idea.''
If you mix them around.... The idea is a Trap!
Holy crap this got a shit ton of likes quick. Thanks guys!
TheMarionick I have a trap! All wings, fall in!
TheMarionick Nice comment
Thanks
"Rogue One: Everybody Dies" was the most impactful new Star Wars film because actions had meaningful consequences; losses were felt. Your edit to the score added to that in a great way.
First the droid died and I was like that sucks but you can kill a droid, then that guy blew up and I was like wait you can't do that too, then the monk died and I was like oh shit none of these characters were in the original trilogy which means everyone there is gonna die.
When I watched the movie the first time my daughter, who had already seen it, sees what I am watching and calmly says "Do not get attached to any of the characters." What sound advice that was!
If only they fleshed out the characters more so we actually cared about them.
To be fair, it had meaningful consequences because the future was pre-determined, so we know what happened because Rogue One sacrificed themselves.
I remember watching it for the first time, about halfway through I realized "All these people HAVE to die."
No matter what TFA tried, this is the closest Disney has ever gotten to true classic Star Wars
Imagine being the kitchen staff on the star destroyers
T3.O1F5 dang it that just ain’t right
The kitchen staff is trained combatants too. I spoke with an army cook in the Canadian army and he had an RPG fly through his kitchen at one point. Needless to say, he refused to go back to work until the threat was dealt with. They are well aware of the danger they are in when they are cooking on the front lines.
czcams.com/video/xxX7QCll3oc/video.html
XD
There's not that much cooking in Star Destoyers, they get only that blue milk as food. Thye coulg get solid, but it was discouraged and seen as a weakness
That corvette shouldn't be able to move that fast, the mass of the balls on the crew should make it really slow😂
Not all heroes wear capes
In advanced space travel, you have to think it's space that is moving... Not the balls!
Well since objects in space are weightless, the added mass of their balls actually added to their inertia and momentum, propelling the star destroyer even faster into the other one
And that ship taked hit by ion missiles so no power they could do anythink
Only wrong thing is, the physics is a lil bit off. Such a crash should kill everyone on board except those 2 pilots, just smashing them against front walls everywhere. Humans simply don´t have grip strong enough to prevent that from happening. It´s the same as if you crashed a car while not strapped with seat belts, but several times stronger. That´s also why most of the ships in almost any sci-fi universe don´t make sense, there are always some big and bigger corridors, created mostly for scenarios and not actual real utility.
0:47 1:05 1:17 1:47 I love these shots of the battle from inside the ships. Really adds to the authenticity and sheer scale of these massive ships blasting at each other.
The work to add the original John Williams score in was excellent, hearing the classic cue over this amazing scene gave me chills.
Rogue One: You have to take down the shield gate, it's the only way to transmit the Death Star plans through!
Admiral Raddus: Call up a Hammerhead corvette, I'm going to do what's called a pro gamer move.
The Mandalorian is cool, but Rogue One remains the only thing by Disney worthy to be called Star Wars
@@buddhistandcatholic The Mandalorian is worthy aswell
@@begobogo2583 It's only sort of star wars. It's cool but not entirely star wars esqe
LMAO
Why don’t they do that to every star destroyer lmao
The little corvette that could
This tiny ship can move a behemoth
There is no gravity so it could..
There us, but speed or thrusters of some kind keep them 'floating'.
Ajourus not to mention that ship is likely 4000 years old!
The main thrusters on a corvette would definitely exceed the pushing power of the lateral manoeuvring thrusters on the star destroyer, so I don’t think it’s unreasonable. Plus hammerheads are designed as tough front-facing ships right?
"Sublight thrusters. Full power!"
"Reverse engines. Full power!"
"Flush the toilet. Full power!"
One of if not my favourite moment from the SW films. No stupid, non-sensical lightspeed run taking out an entire fleet. Just a great idea from Raddison that looked stunning and got people thinking "That's such a clever plan" as opposed to after Holdo and people saying "that was fucking stupid".
Exactly my thoughts. That was out of the box thinking and actually taking advantage out a normally kida useless corvette. Didnt break any rules and actually looked cool
@@Klanosek But, it's absurd that that tiny ship crashed into the star destroyer and it was as of they were bumper cars....So he bumps the one star destroyer into the other and these enormous ships don't "bump", instead they cut through each other like a hot knife through butter. How the fuck is that possible?
@@saintadolf5639 Conservation of energy.
@@Klanosek How does that explain the wildly different result from the 2 collision?
@@saintadolf5639 Small ship with dense and thick hull can ram itself into enemy with low speed without critically damaging itself. When it starts to push the ship, it doesnt really give much resistance as they are in space.
Then the Imperial ship, already flying fast due to smaller ship pushing him, crashes into another ship. Now we have momentum and gigantic mass which does NOT want to stop and another big ship which does not want to move. Therefore, they crash.
Like, when you pull up a car to a truck in space and start slowly ramming into it you will push it. When said truck will later crash with another truck with given speed, they will obliterate each other.
"We should take an IMPERIAL STARDESTROYER and push it somewhere else"
-Patrick Star
lol
1...2..3...puuuusssshhhhhhhhhhh
Frank Matthes THE ALASKAN BULL WORM!!
PUSH IT PU PU PUSH IT REAL GOOD
Patrick Star WARS
Hammerhead Captain:
Well it's a good day to die. RAMMING SPEED!!!!
DAMN IT WORF!
You have been nominated human of the year
czcams.com/video/PhQHZ7EyEHo/video.html They did it better, and first. O:-)
Tough little ship...
LiTtLe!?
@@Atoronz You do remember how to fire phasers?
I'm 51. I saw A New Hope at the Fox Theater in my hometown when I was 7. There's more signifcance to that film than there's time to discuss here. The original score and sound effects over the modern scene literally gave me chills. This is amazing.
Casual Star Wars fans: Hey, it's the hammerhead ship from Rebels!
Die hard Star Wars fans: Hey, it's the hammerhead ship from Knights of the Old Republic!
Actually it's not though. The Hammerhead-class Cruiser is about 2.5x bigger, and has much more firepower than the Sphyrna-class "Hammerhead" Corvette we see in Rebels/Rogue One.
It is, however, canon that the Sphyrna was inspired by the Hammerhead.
@@masterdude9419
Aaron Vallis: Wait a minute how did this happen I’m smarter than this
That's clearly a tugboat
Hey it’s the hammerhead ship from Star Wars Tie Fighter video game
There was the ghost there too.
I'm so happy that the disabled destroyer didn't just start falling when it shut down. That's an error a lot of filmakers would have made.
Dadko It was close enough to the planet that it would’ve been believable for it to have started going downward
@@colbyh.4933 That's honestly debatable.
Colby Hurd it wouldn’t fall that quickly, look at satellites and the space station for exanple
Gravity exists
@@Yukiyak0 Gravity does exist in space, just weaker. The destroyers had enough forward momentum to keep going on their course, but unless it was a stable orbit, gravity would eventually have taken over and pulled it down. Of course, this takes quite a while, much longer than the time shown here.
Garett Edwards should get his own trilogy.
It just looks so realistic. Not just the graphics but how crews deal with it. Actually embracing for combat.
Love the touch of the air rushing out as the interior of the two ISD's gets exposed to the vacuum of space
Star Destroyer: *exists*
Corvette: *IMA RAM THIS GUYS HOLE CAREER*
Okay I'm glad that the word "career" was in there
*LITERALLY!*
I loved the scene with the Hammerhead corvette. First time i saw one was in KotOR, which would technically make the ship in Rogue One an incredibly old museum display piece.
Knowing the Alliance, that Hammerhead could very well be just that old. They had to steal or be giving almost any ship they had in their fleet.
Don’t wanna break the best part of that idea, but actually the corvette was only based on an older ship in cannon, and the ship your thinking of is a cruiser class ship, so much bigger, but they went out of service I want to say about 1000 years BBY (before battle of yavin, most of legends uses that designation system) in legends. That said, it’d be hilarious if it was the same ship xD
@@gilbryn And to be honest, the cruiser version would actually make a bit more sense in this scene. As much as I love it, the Corvette always seemed a bit too small for how fast it shifted an entire Star Destroyer. One of the larger cruisers would have made more sense and had way more mass on impact.
That's a little nitpicky though, still an awesome scene.
Andrei Lanuza Hate to break it to you, the Hammerhead corvette is NOT the same ship as the Hammerhead cruiser, the difference is in the engine design and how long the neck is. The hammerhead cruiser’s engines are two oval like engine nacelles that slope down under the ship towards the rear, where the corvette has 3 circular engines placed in a triangular pattern around what could be assumed would be the center of mass.
Hyperspace tech has been available for thousands of years...and the Empire still be usin’ floppy discs XD
1:48 Reverse engines ! FULL POWWA !
I love the music from John Williams inserted but I wonder how much comes from it actually being fitting better and how much is pure nostalgia
I loved this movie when does the next part come out?
1977
2000 subs without a video challenge haha
@@pixelsarea hes close
A.k.a Rogue 2
@@aceidk6392 Are you dead certain you want a Rogue too? They can be quite a handful. Always making up their own orders, mis-appropriating vital supplies, absconding with necessary war material (hard to come by ships), writing cheques they can't cash (because they're dead, unfortunately), etc, etc, etc...... = - )
*_blyat,u mean 1977 in next Universe Restarting?_*
*_I tired of those restarts after #82929484918374838193985848292928473828384868582829295060681615384070375859274758492673927474929385838274 restart 🅱️RUH_*
Who would win?
2 Imperial-I Star Destroyers, the symbol of the Imperial Navy
or
one 4000 year old boi
@@benxy3034 stfu
Riccardo Müller Stfu Ricardo
Red Sauce one pushy boi
Riccardo Müller stfu
@@benxy3034 who asked you?
1:00 the source of the interference was revealed: His goggles.
The Hammerhead Corvetter is one of my favorite Star Wars ships now. I love the idea behind it where it can be used to push other much larger space craft. Its so cool! It almost like a tug boat pulling (rather pushing) a big ship. Wish we had some more of the Hammerhead in the newer films.
Tug boats are small but very important ships.
The Hammerhead is essentially a weaponized tugboat... And it's quite effective considering it's long service history in universe.
@@chaz706I hate the fact your not wrong the hammerhead was actually meant as a tug boat like how the class of Ships the millennium falcon is from were cargo haulers for larger ships
@@lordchungus4744 In universe: the Corellians were already making ships for the purposes of conversion jobs into combat ships. The Millennium Falcon being a prime example.
@@chaz706 combat or smuggling ships again the millennium falcon being a prime example
These scenes have more emotional impact then all of Rise Of Skywalker
for that stardestroyer the impact wasnt just emotional
I mean it isn't really hard to have it more than absolutely nothing
You know a movir is more emotional when you watch it in theaters instead of pirating it
@@EternalEmperorofZakuul WTF are you even talking about
@@irgilligan because i enjoyed this movie over that mess, hence why i didn't watch 9 in theaters
What I love about the Battle of Scarif is how much of a make it or break it moment it is for the Rebellion. Despite the fact that we know they managed to get the plans long before the climax, none of that knowledge takes away from the tension of this mission. Because there was literally no turning back or second chances for the Rebels at this point in time. Before the Battle of Yavin 4 the Rebel Alliance was on the brink of collapse. But the destruction of Alderaan, and the Death Star's destruction later on, gave those that opposed the Empire the true rallying cry they needed to get their second wind for the future conflicts.
So then it’s good for evil to prevail over good?🤨
@@theeamericanempire2279 no, it’s just good not to end every single movie with the good guys winning. it makes the franchise more complex
@@theeamericanempire2279 There are no good or bad guys in this
@@commandandconquer6303 their are literally good and bad guys in this according to the makers of thees movies
@@theeamericanempire2279 Just cause the makers say there are good and bad guys doesn't mean there are truly good and bad guys. Leia is responsible for the death of millions of innocent civilians.
Getting harder and harder to convince me that this isn't the best Star Wars movie ever made.
1:36
Nope, I'm totally smitten.
When Giacchino's score played, I thought, "What's wrong with this? It's fine." Then Williams' score played, and it's crazy how much MORE like Star Wars it felt to me.
Graphics team- how much debris for the two ships colliding?
Disney- Yes.
For real
I think yiu mean VFX team
That was probably a nightmare for them to create.
@@sonofjack6286 But it was worth it
F for the CPUs that died rendering this
Superior to the bombing run scene & the disintegrating-a-star-destroyer-by-going-into-hyperdrive scene in The Last Jedi.
The hyperdrive scene was the first instance I have ever seen of Hollywood actually UNDER doing a scene. Having done the math myself and having seen the same thing on multiple science channels, an object the size of 1 of these ships and more than enough kinetic energy to destroy our planet. There would have been NOTHING left of those ships but dust.
the hyperdrive scene from the last jedi was really badass though, it always gives me goosebumps; but it defeats the purpose of space battles if you can just sacrifice a small ship to take out an entire fleet
@@Blackwind_Legacy Makes you wonder why they needed the freaking Death Star to blow up planets. Hell, it'd completely change fleet tactics for any civilization with access to a hyperdrive and make most other weapons completely pointless. Big cap ships would be a massive liability if you just designed torpedoes with hyperdrive engines and a little extra mass. And yet Holdo is somehow the first to actually think of using a hyperdrive this way? The writers really did not think that particular idea out.
@@theholyduck5520 it's been a massive plot holes in space sci fi in general for a long time.
@@Blackwind_Legacy Yeah, I feel like if we ever develop FTL tech it'll be weaponized within a week. It's hard to work around in sci-fi where FTL is so ubiquitous, which is why I think most writers just leave it alone to keep the suspension of disbelief. And then there's the Last Jedi, that ends a movie-long slow speed chase with it.
I definitely prefer Giacchino's score in this scene, but this was an impressive edit and great homage to William's OT score
Yes. Since nobody survives, it is better to have different musical cues.
nothing memorable about it though... no hooks anywhere
@@matycee Are you kidding? You must not be listening very well
Williams's score is perfect for a pulpy space opera adventure movie. That is not what Rogue One is.
@@jeffreyv8306 What are you talking about?? There's no leitmotif, nothing there but bland scoring. Go ahead, hum the score played after you heard it. It's not memorable in the slightest sense.
John Williams score gives goosebumps, such iconic music
Rogue One is the best star wars film since the empire strikes back.
Cap
its treason then
True
The prequels were amazing.
*Revenge Of The Sith
1:30 “All right rebels, lets do this. . . LEEROY JENKINS”
"Oh my god, he just flew in."
I died laughing here....But that would have been ONE hell of an easter egg: "Gimme Captain Jenkins from that corvette"
@@thegreenreaper6660 that would have made rogue one even more epic......the adventures of captain Leroy Jenkins and the 4000 year old corvette.
Hahahahahaha I’m dead 😂😂
I always like the way in this that the ion torpedo launch at 0:35 sounds like it did in the old XWing and Tie Fighter games. Little details like that made this film very good.
Nobody:
Imperial naval command: “remember to keep our two star destroyers close together for this engagement. it will looks super cool and won’t backfire spectacularly at all.”
To be fair, this normally doesn't backfire at all.
Imagine if Admiral Holdo was in command at that time
Holdo : I have a plan, but I will not tell you guys
Crew : ............
Holdo : Hey, have you guys done loading the transport ship??
Generson Bryantheart
now call up a hammerhead corvette. We’re gonna lightspeed into those destroyers
Or better yet the strategic bombing campaign was actually more inept than holdo light speed kamikaze attack
Rogue One director: I made a super cool ramming scene
Ruin Roundhead Johnson: OH YES?! >:C I CAN DO BETTER, WATCH THIS *breaks lore and does a shitty scene with a shitty character*
Everyone with an IQ over -5: Likes the rogue one scene better
RRJ: *Surprised pikachu face*
@Emperor It was a shitty scene, on a shitty movie, on a shitty trilogy, in my opinion. Disney really needs to change how they run star wars
@Emperor Exactly, it breaks not only the lore but the very basics of how this universe's war works. Now every battle will seem stupid because of that. Either that or we'll have to suffer a ton of hyperspace ramming which is boring and stupid
The difference between the two scenes featuring each score is staggering. This gives me a new appreciation for the masterful work of original scores
Giacchino's score makes the battle feel more grounded and intense while William's being optimistic which is why I can see that needed to change as the battle of Scarif was the most important battle that lead to a new hope.
Great editing work, this was awesome! Rogue One is ranked #2 in my book right behind Empire Strikes Back. It tied the original trilogy and prequels together so well, but also had more realism in terms of war and loss than any of the movies. You really felt it when these heroes died.
0:47 this is 100% the medic from tf2!!
haha it does sound like him !
lol
MEDIC!
Indeed
Both are voiced by Robin Atkin Downes.
Anyvay, that's how I lost my pilot license.
Williams' music fits very well with this scene (as his music tends to do for most scenes out there, haha), but I think the mood it conveys is much more light-hearted and adventurous than Rogue One's intent.
Still, I can't help but appreciate the amount of work you put into making this - great work! If I hadn't seen the original movie I probably wouldn't even have noticed anything was amiss.
I agree with you , i was thinking how awesome it was that it reminded of playing Rogue squadron on the 64 but the light heartedness (or since we associate it with that mood) takes away from stakes and sacrifices being made. Still awesome either way cant wait for the finished product
less light hearted than that damn ridicolous triumphant rebel theme when the star destroyers wreck eachother.
Pretty strong reaction there, friend. Did I ever say that the original score was the only other choice for this scene? Using John William's score wasn't a bad idea at all - I'm just saying that a different track would have been a better choice.
Although I agree with your light hearted remark for the first half of the sequence - when the Star Destroyer crashes, Giacchino plays a triumphant fanfare which I felt was VERY inappropriate considering the message of the film and the fact that thousands of people just died on those two ships. The Williams soundtrack doesn't do this, instead it keeps the tone neutral through sequence
htmlman1 I
The "thud" of dudes head when it hits the counsel... perfection.
Rogue One was really a masterfull movie. It really showed what fighting against an empire means...you have to sacrifice yourself...not to win, but to be a small part of a puzzle dedicated to achieve a victory....
1:24 lmao, god I'm never gonna unsee that again.
"prepare for impact"
check out buddy in the back when he said that, lol
- Prepare for impact!
- My body is ready, daddy.
- Damn you, Carl, not that kind of impact!
I was like I dont get it. Replay 7 time, then I loled so hard.
"Prepare for impact."
*"Repeat that last part, captain. I swear you just said- OH SHIT!"*
It looked like they had been expecting that very order for years.
"Captain of Lightmaker, I need you to ram that disabled Imp!"
A tear develops in the captain's eye.
"I've waiting my whole fucking life to do this."
I enjoyed this movie a lot more than I did the force awakens , and it actually had I s own original storyline
Just a Typical guy a handful of things from TFA were original, like Finn being a defected stormtrooper, A group that warships Darth Vader, etc. It was an okay movie, it wasn't as good as Rogue One Tho.
Again with this stupid argument. Literally nothing from The Force Awakens is recycled, only the super weapon shit at the end, besides that it’s completely original
Eradicated Noodle You comment makes me questions if you saw any star wars movie. ever
+Eradicated Noodle
Dramatic confrontation between good freedom fighters and oppressive bad guys. Dramatic reveal of masked bad guy who interrogates someone. One of three main characters sends important information with an astromech droid who escapes into desert world. Young dreamer/main character on desert planet wants to leave planet and do something exciting. The main character encounters droid and decides to try and get info to freedom fighters. Escapes bad guys using Millennium Falcon with fellow main character. Meets an elderly mentor figure. Bad guys have big death station. Hero is trapped on big death station. X-wing assault on big death station's weakpoint. Mentor figure dies to someone they were once close to. X-wings destroy big death station and escape with nifty explosion in the background.
Yup, completely original.
finn defecting and having force sensitive would have been nice with rey being something different of a profession and on another planet or helping finn searching for luke to train for jedi.
Since no one else is commenting on it, well done on the video! The OT music fit fairly fairly well with the mood of the movie.
Hey thanks! I wonder how many people are just watching this for the original scene, not knowing the alterations that were made lol
When the original soundtrack hits I get goosebumps man, just hits so well. You can almost hear the hope in the music.
0:19 Ghost
tako たこ ;
It sure was!!!
Yep
Wow
Lol wow
I don't understand. What should I be looking at?
I like this. Its a perfect demonstration about how the music can really affect the mood of the scene.
it's not really accurate since it's missing some sound effects when without music. For example: You can clearly hear that there are sound effects when the corvette is hitting the destroyer and when without music it's missing it probably so can it shock more people how much more impact music has inpact in scenes than in reality but still it has a lot if they added all sound effects and voices when without music.
Youre right, on the first one the impact of the two star destroyers feels like a moment of relief, of victory, while in the last one is more shocking, the scale of the destruction sinks in more. I personally liked the first more, but is easy to see how good the last style could be if the proper resources were put into it.
If you play Your Father Would be Proud. It's actually quite depressing despite the fact it's the good guys beating the bad guys in this instance.
The "fixed" version with the John Williams music feels so much more like a Star Wars movie instead of a generic "space action" movie. There are just some John Williams musical "hooks" that make Star Wars, Star Wars. As someone who saw the first 3 Star Wars movies in the theatres when they came out, that music is so completely integral to the Star Wars experience for me, I just can't get that "star Wars Feelin'" without it. Thanks Maple Films!
I really loved how you added John Williams music over the scene. Good Job 👏👍
I love how no one is actually talking about the point of this video lmao
To that end, I didn't like the edited score. To me it didn't fit the scene.
@Stella Hohenheim it is cool when its fiction.
Why fix what wasn't broken, even if you're trying to put Williams in? I will admit the edited version worked, but the original was better.
another happy landing
Well, whaddya knowww
Maple Films subscribed😊
You should have left the triumphant sound as the two star destroyers hit each other, that fit much better than this, though the old music fit the rest of the battle pretty well.
*After half of the lower Star Destroyer gets cut off
Imperial Pilot: We lost something.
Imperial Captain: Don't worry, we're still flying half a ship.
TheRedSlayer327 xD
Just a spectacular, and magnificently executed Star Wars space battle! As a huge fan of the design, it was so very satisfying to see Y-Wings get to show what a dangerous vessel they can be!
Well fucking done! I remember the amazement I felt when I saw the super star destroyer slam in to the 2nd death star and that whole final space battle in Jedi. I would have been about 9 at the time when I saw it in the theater. This scene actually gave me the same feeling when I saw it as well. Your editing really nailed the nostalgia for me here. great stuff.
I guess that Hammerhead Corvette didn't survived, goes to show you that these rebels are desperate willing to sacrifice themselves like that .... I like this whole tone of the movie, about knowing that they're not going to come out of this alive, and yet still fighting the good fight.
knessi ng it did
knessi ng I haven't read the novelization of "Rogue One" but heard a summary of that portion and that all non-essential personal were evacuated but the bridge crew stayed on as the maneuver was too complex for auto or droid-piloting.
You can see that all the Escape Pods have been jettisoned right before it hits, and in the last shot of the remains of the Star Destroyers falling through the Portal you can see the Hammerhead Corvette still wedged in where it struck. The Captain and Bridge Crew did indeed go down with the ship.
yeah, that Hammerhead looked pretty wedged in there. did the book also tells what happens to Admiral Reddas, wonder if Mr. Vader tortured him and the other Mon Cali.
I read somewhere that hammerhead crew all died during crash with barrier station.
I add that I meant bridge crew died to last member.
This is admiral Raddus rogue one, we hear you!!!
I have never seen a more poignant example as to how good Williams is. The new score made the scene give me chills
0:47 that's how i lost my medical license
Great respect for John Williams, his edit while does add nostalgia for the die hard fans, the original edit serves its purpose.
Yeah, I don't really see the point of going to all the effort to edit the SFX just to sub in music we've heard a million times. I mean, I can respect the effort, but I was perfectly fine with the original. If they wanted to do edits of 7/8/9, on the other hand...
For anyone wondering "How could a few Y-Wings take out a Star Destroyer?", if you look at 0:42, you can see that one of the shield generators was destroyed, making it a lot easier to disable.
I can't see really any comments talking about how this edit makes the scene infinitely better so I'll say it; this edit makes the scene infinitely better. The music fits perfectly and is appropriate and the sound effects are better as well. Well done.
Probably my favourite scene in all of SW
good old KOTOR era ship
I was sitting here thinking "Where TF did they dig one of those up"? Lol
If you watch Star Wars Rebels, Leia provides them to the Lothal Rebel Cell in season 2 as part of building up their fleet.
Right! "EU is dead", my left nut.
+Rhsims
It is dead, but that doesn't mean the new canon can't grave-rob it to improve its standing.
Really, anything good from the new canon is just stuff they nicked from the original canon.......
You people can't ever let it go. You're so hellbent on convincing others that your tunnel-vision view of anything post-Lucas is awful that you'll say anything to that end.
The Mon Calamari are expert tacticians
I Love Ion Torpedoes !
2 for the price of 1
stardude2006 expert tacticians? Perhaps. Crazy bastards? Absolutely
Until this happened I never knew Ion torpedoes existed; I always knew the Y Wings and B Wings had Ion cannons that worked wonders in the Xwing/Tie Fighter games...but anyway, those Y Wings just smothered that ISD with torp hits-it must have taken 20 or 30 hits
Personally, this movie was the perfect mark between Andor and the other movies.
I’m a prequel fan but I loved this movie just as much.
More films such as this would be great.
This is the SW we love. One of the best moments in the Saga. Gareth Edwards, please, come back!
Gareth EdwardsTHE GOAT
Alright the empire has some major flaws,First it was the goddamn out of control A Wing
And now its a freaking Hammerhead Corvette
Goes to show you that the Tarkin Doctrine is a crock load of shit.
@@MR.LMR1996 yep
The exact same thing happens on earth, NATO warships costing a billion a piece struggle against Iranian fast attack craft, the Bismarck was took out of action by some outdated bi-planes
@@scottwhitley3392 Which The Bismark inspired The Malevolence arc in the clone wars
@@scottwhitley3392 lol nato ships totally dont struggle against a small shitty craft, who told u that bullshit?
Hammerhead Corvette: "leeeerrrooooy jeeeennnkkkiiinns!"
The difference is amazing. WOW! Thank you for doing this!
Really excellent job with the sound design and making everything blend! I wish people like you had been directing the new trilogy!
Pretty well put together, and I love John Williams but I think the music selection here is to bombastic for the suicide mission battle taking place.
So it should be bombastic? Because it's the suicide mission.
Bombastic? Obviously you don't know the meaning of that word. The music in that part is a fast building staccato of woodwind and strngs with some brass for building tension (the brass coming in on the release of tension). Usually bombastic is heavy percussion with a massive brass section all playing full on, THAT'S what's usually referred to as "bombastic" in orchestral type music. Btw, the music here is taken from Return of the Jedi space battle which is kinda the same (even in purpose) so your argument really doesn't make sense.
I mean the soundtrack playing originally was way too upbeat for this huge collision between star destroyers
The original choice of music was highly insensitive to the thousands of brave Imperial sailors whose lives were taken in a horrific act of rebel terrorism. A moment of silence for fallen heroes
You see... when a mummy star destroyer and a daddy star destroyer love each other very _very_ much.. 2:00
Neuro 55 They make a Mega Star Destroyer, which can be destroyed with one rebel command ship going at light speed :/
Um...I like the cut of your jib sir...
You made me laugh....lol
Damn, that's funny.
They nuzzle up against each other so hard they RIP each other into pieces?
Everyone talking about the scene, this guy made an amazing and pretty extensive job putting that music into the clip, very well done sir!, you are very talented i loved this version!!
Thank you!!
Wow suddenly so much better. John Williams is a legend. Nice work
1970 sound effects over modern cgi?
You sir, are a legend
70s
B for Thigh even better
I feel bad for the people who hated Rogue One
CaptainNemo G Indeed. I love this movie.
same espechaly since i thought the force awakens was good but the more i watched the less i liked it which allot of people agreed with, and now we get a great star wars film, so it's sad for them to miss out on greatness.
CaptainNemo G i feel bad that you need to feel superior to others who don't like what you like
Great story, and very well-casted. I understand that people have different opinions, so it's OK. I loved it.
R1, the only somewhat decent Disney SW film. The rest are complete SJW trash
Love this stuff.
Wow the Williams score goes absolutely fantastic with this scene, well done!
0:19 Ghost doing Ghost things.
Yap
Clean shot on a TIE fighter
God imagine if they can do a fleet size battle of this quality on the scale of Episode III's opening. Hope they do in Episode VIII
Looks like there will be a good space battle in Episode 8, according to the trailer that dropped today!
Maple Films nothing will top ep3
HunHarcos Surely. This one for example. Or the battle over Endor
not in terms of numbers .. but ep III battle felt caotic ..and it just was left "unresolved" .. the heroes come down to Coruscant and thats it.. you never found how the battle ended (the separatist fleet was pulling out ..but you would never know unless reading the novel and stuff)
Because Coruscant battle was only the background battle not the main part of the film. Plus the battle was indeed literally chaotic due to the fact that it was a surprise attack and all Separatist and Republic ships a jumped to Coruscant to join the battle thus creating a mess.
Star Destroyer: "You can't beat me!"
Admiral Raddus: "No, but he can."
Points at other Star Destroyer
For some reason, I like the fan edit more than the original!
John Williams starts at 3:48
Alex Soetekouw productions thanks
Movie: Rebel forces
Me an Intellectual: Space terrorists.
Space Jihadi*
When the rebels speaking Arab
It ain’t terrorism when you got strategy
@@Krone0k cough cough 9/11 was a planned.out
@@clentonium alderaan was an inside job
This is one of the main things I love from this movie and honestly, even if the rest was worse than the new sequels, Id still love it more. Damn, this is how you return the feel of A New Hope or RotJ
Not Empire though?
Thank you very much for making this. ❤️
We have two large and immobile battle ships.
We will fly 10 meters apart, it will be fine.
They seemed to be surprised by the fact that their engines went out
to be fair this was probably necessary to avoid friendly fire. by being close you avoid having firing arcs that could lead to friendly fire (for example if a bomber decided to sit right between both ships).
it probably also reduced the strain on the tie fighters. the rebellions strength lies predominantly in their fighters. mon calamari capital ships were exceptionally good at taking fire, but were ultimately unable to hold their own against star destroyers. having your star destroyers close to each other means your available tie fighters were able to keep a tighter/denser defense cordon around them than by having two seperate defense spheres
Sounds like tlj bombers
Star Wars starship tactics are based on the old idea of the battle line. Flying like that lets them focus more firepower on a single target.
But, what if we did this... but with MORE ships. then, if one or two falls, the others can catch them and nothing will go wrong right?
I heard somewhere that due to the constant re-shoots and production problems that Rogue One had, Michael Giacchino had far less time to compose a score than is typically given. Which is noticeable. I'm a big Giacchino fan, but his score for Rogue One (while by no means bad) doesn't stand up to his other work
Yes, originally Alexandre Desplat was the composer for Rogue One. They even had early posters with his name still in the credits. It wasn't until the reshoots that his score was jettisoned and Giacchino was brought on. However, he only had 3-4 weeks to write and record everything. So I don't blame him for how the score turned out- he should get another shot at a Star Wars film.
It was less of a 'his score was jettisoned' and more him quitting and the stuff that he made being unusable.
After listening to the terrible Jurassic World and Dr. Strange scores, and reading that he only had 4 weeks to compose, I was very pleased with how Rogue One turned out. It wasn't great like some of his other scores but it could have been much much worse.
Yeah, I admit the Dr Strange score was terrible haha
I thought he nailed it.
0:47 That crewmate sounds like medic from tf2
Yeah you're right
It is.
@@suspiciouschicken does it list him in the credits?
Why is this coming up in my feed now? Nonetheless, it's a fantastic exercise in seeing the power of music in film. It really does change the tone of the scene. While the movie as a whole is fairly gritty and sombre, William's score here definitely makes it feel like the tides are turning for the Rebels and would potentially make their losses that happen later feel much more impactful. Well done on this edit!