Will the Gaza War Bankrupt Israel?
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 02. 2024
- Sign up to Brilliant (the first 200 sign ups get 20% off an annual premium subscription): brilliant.org/tldrglobal
Israel's invasion of Gaza is having serious repercussions for its economy with it receiving its first ever credit downgrade. So in this video we'll explain what's happening, why it was under pressure before the war began and whether they can recover.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
🗣 Discord: tldrnews.co.uk/discord
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahEFmsW1yGTNEYXA
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk/funding
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
//////////////////////
1 - www.bloomberg.com/news/articl...
2 - www.timesofisrael.com/almost-...
3 - tradingeconomics.com/israel/c...
4 - www.bloomberg.com/news/articl...
5 - thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/...
6 - fortune.com/2024/02/20/israel...
7 - www.france24.com/en/tv-shows/...
8 - www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-6...
9 - www.washingtonpost.com/world/...
10 - www.reuters.com/world/middle-...
11 - www.ft.com/content/90cb26d2-f...
12 - www.bloomberg.com/news/articl...
13 - ratings.moodys.com/ratings-ne...
14 - www.jpost.com/arab-israeli-co...
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Netanyahu government:
- Has long corruption charges running against its figurehead.
- Proposes new laws that undermine the rule of law, which leads to destabilization of the country and mass protests.
- "Not only tolerates, but encourages" Qatari cash payments to Hamas in a ill-advised divided and conquer strategy and because the Hamas threat helps the Israeli right wing win elections.
- While posing as the defenders of Israel's security, actually underestimates security risks and neglects intelligence that a massive terrorist attack is about to take place.
- Responds to this attack with disproportional brutal violence that brings the local economy to a stillstand and damages the international reputation of the country.
- Has cabinet members who constantly say extremely racist stuff, the finance minister being one of, if not the, worst
- Only complains, complains, complains and complains about being treated unfairly and never admits any wrongdoing, not even when quite logically the country's credit rating is downgraded a tiny bit.
As an Israeli who took part at the protests , completely agree
Both cases in the icj can lead to Israel having to pay reparations to Palestinians .
As an Israeli, I absolutely agree - except for the violence one. This is a consensus here in Israel and something that is harder to understand for people who do not live here and did not experience October 7 themselves. Netaniau needs to find a replacement for Hamas, a thing which will help end the war and avoid more casualties in the long term, but the IDF's response is absolutely proportional. It keeps a 1:3 terrorist to civilian casualties ratio, which is 3 times better than the UN's recommended ratio in urban areas which is 1:9.
@@IlaiShoshanithere is no UN recommended Ratio on Carpet Bombing, wtf are you talking about. A 1 to three Ratio has not been seen since the Vietnam War, even in the Iraq War and the War against Isis the Ratio was more like 2:1 or 1:1. The Violence has been disproportional, as Deaths in the West Bank due to settler Violence combined with Civilian Deaths in Lebanon in Syria are already as high as Isreali civilian Casualties on 7 October. Calling 20000 to 1000 Civilians a Proportional Response is utter delusion
@IlaiShoshani 😂😂😂😂 you've outdone hitler in 4months on records set. You've destroyed everything in gaza if the genocide was to end tomorrow because of lack of food, shelter, disease etc you would wipe out way more. You are killing a significant amount to classify it as genocide, but you have destroyed everything to ensure it is permanent, the world sees israelies for what they are
*For reference the UK is now at AA3. When the UK was handed to the Tories in 2010 it was AAA. They have wrecked our economy.*
wdym y'all did this to yourself just like most of europe
Notice that almost all "modern" British institutions that the Tories claim to hold dear, the BBC, the NHS and such, are all fundamentally "socialistic" concepts. A news broadcast everyone pays into and everyone gets. A health system the government funds and everyone gets to enjoy. The reason for this is of course that these are generally "British" institutions and or beloved by the British people. When was the last time the conservatives managed to make something like that?
@@cesruhf2605the conservatives have never achieved a majority of votes, so no *we* haven’t.
I know right. I wouldn't worry about Israel, they can take care of themselves (despite being at war). But our own state of affairs here in the UK is very worrying...
Brexit ? 😹
The Americans will pick up the tab. They can always find the money for overseas wars (but can't find the money to spend at home for universal healthcare, support for the poor etc).
You can find the money, but one of your major parties doesn't want to do so, and the other one doesn't care enough to force it.
It's True❤
find money either A) increase debt B) print more either way leads to more debt please stop the cap. @@Bradley2806
The Americans will find the money because congress is lobbied more by Israel than by all other groups COMBINED.
American aid only goes to Israeli weapons and represents 1/10th of Israel’s defence spending
you missed mentioning the ultra orthodox economical problem that the government is only increasing.
Thank you
What's that ?
A Population that doasnt work and get special economical privileges.
Also dont serve in the military@@shivanshna7618
@@shivanshna7618 the government gives free money to orthodox Jews
Some g
roup of people is fully funded by government but not working or joining te army
Bibi will never end the war, he knows he'll be vulnerable if the war end or enter a prolong ceasefire.
Yup the far right wingers are holding him tightly, he know if he stops it they will break the coalition, His survival as PM depends on keeping those far right Jewish nationalists happy, and that by continuing the war
He made his 6th proposal to Hamas this month saying he will stop the war and return arrested Palestinians if Hamas returns the hostages and Hamas rejected the proposal outright again.
Yup if he stops his coalition partners will pull out of the coalition, his political survival is dependent on keeping his coalition partners happy and that will only be by keeping what he is doing in gaza
@@FlipflopflopperYes, obviously, hamas hates Jews more than they love their children. The war will end the second they surrender but why would they do that?
Just to remind : he was elected before any war and just after leftist losers
I'm surprised Israel didn't accuse Moody's of antisemitism.
I swear I thought the same, in fact, i was waiting for it!!!!
Well we arent palestinians, we know how economics work xD its ok its a hickup, we will grow stronger out of this and H just made palestinians weaker... so good job i guess?
Oh, but we nearly did, the minister of finance is an absolute sham 🤦♂
😂🤣😂🤣
@@vladxp1100knowing how things work doesn't make a difference. The Israeli government says nearly anything which is against them is antisemitism
War tends not to be very good for your economy...
Not so sure about that - it was ramped up defense spending in the US after Pearl Harbor that finally broke the back of the Great Depression.
Dependent for whom. Many will be happy if the creasy real estate prices will return to normal. At least a little bit.
Unless you are America
@guydreamr the US also immediately went into a depression after ww1
@@willjapheth23789More like a recession, which wasn't nearly as long nor as pronounced as the mother of all downturns of the 1930s. In fact, soon after ww1, the US would experience an economic boom known as the "Roaring 20s."
Isreal will never go bankrupt as long as US and it's people are there to support them unlimited
A lot of us Americans do not support israel but it’s our politicians that are perverting the will of the people.
Nothing is unlimited in our reality
U.S. aid to Israel is not even 15% of their Defence Budget.
they have the best Economy in that region despite all the wars and being a new Country, that's culture.
You mean the US using the rest of the world as fools to bankroll any shit?
❤Exactly well said and well OBSERVED. That is the TRUTH of ALL Middle East politics.
us tax payer will fund and help build israel while us citizen cant even get basic health care
Americans blaming their govn for not having money are idiots. Immigrants from poor country going to US having a betterlife working their asses of and americans complaining about unpaid 5 mins overtimes lol.
American taxpayer only arms Israel, not building it.
The US spends 1.7 trillion on healthcare. Yearly and that's just government spending
Yes but isreal gets universal healthcare united states doest that all go's to hmos
@@willjapheth23789
Absolutely - the United States knows how to waste vast amounts of money on health care while having worse outcomes and lower life expectancy than developed countries that have universal health care.
Let’s not forget that people around the world are now boycotting Israeli goods and services.
Not having any effect at all...look at the Muslim countries...mark Zuckerberg could pay for the war and still have change left over douchebag
As a private citizen, I have increased my purchase of Israeli goods, and have quite a list of Hamas-terrorist supporting businesses that I am boycotting. I am sure I am not alone.
Am Yisrael Chai
The only thing they boycott is Macdonalds and Starbucks which are American brands. The BDS have been going on for a while and haven't do shit while Israel economy only increasing
@valerieurquhart3133 good, you're on your own. As a black woman, I will never support you and have zero empathy for Izrahell
Well said, no McDonalds, KFC, Subway, Starbucks and many more. I refuse to even buy dates now. Any country that could destroy generations of Olive trees are not indigenous to that land and does not deserve it.
Why do they need to worry about funding or their economy, The US would literally just bail them out or send them another multi-billion dollar a package. Or maybe Netanyahu will go to the US Congress again and demand that the US just send him a blank check.
That's not how US aid money works.
US aid is like 3$ billion a year... Israel's economy is around 500$ billion a year... no US can't send enough money to save Israel's economy... it will be up to us how to do it.
@@ravidlivne7317 have you ever seen how Israeli Prime Ministers talk to American Presidents?
3 billion in peactime, in wartime it would naturally be more@@Darktemplar99999
@@Darktemplar99999 And 2.7 billion has to be spent on US products...How many jobs would disappear from the ole US without the government and their overspending...Meanwhile Israel economy and stock market is outperforming the US YTD even with a war...
Thanks, TLDR team, for such insightful news! I'm thankful yo have discovered your channel where all you truly do is simply present the facts and allow us to make our informed judgment. Keep up the good work! Looking forward to more videos!
... Dafa [Great Law] offers salvation, the truth is spreading
"Who Will Enjoy Such Blessings
Gods descended to the world, pledging their lives
Becoming human, they’ve been awaiting the Creator
Reincarnating time and again, who is who
A dream lasting a thousand autumns, suffering life after life
At the end times, the red demon dances crazily in the messy world
Good and evil indiscernible, the world has lost the ancient way
Dafa [Great Law] offers salvation, the truth is spreading
The great Dao leads to heaven-who will enjoy such blessings
September 7, 2018"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin V, from Falun Dafa teachings)
commercial?
Problem is that you should be looking at other site for news, how do you know this is all correct? Because you like and agree with what is said?
Uncle Sam will always come to help its baby daddy no matter what
It knows who prints the US dollar 😂
The U.S. is equivalent to a vassal state of Israel.
Exactly what I thought! So sad that the Americans need money themselves for healthcare and stuff yet their taxes are spent on another country.
@@SeyyidPalta u shld look up how much money usa gives to palestine via UNRWA...
@@SeyyidPalta even more hilarious seeing how the USA is the biggest Palestinian donor.
I discovered the other day that I had a 0.5% stock equity in an Israeli company that was posing like a US company. I sold that shit faster than I usually pull out.
I sold my google stock two days ago after i discovered their cooperation plans with israel on AI. Sold at a loss and still glad i did so.
U gonna be a baby daddy soon
Norway has divested $500 million from Israeli bonds.
Proud of you buddy bless your soul🙏🏽🙏🏽
do you enjoy reading someone talking about withdrawing their organ from a womans/mans organs/rectum before excreting his reproductive juices in to her/him?@@wotermelon_
Love this !!!
Israel stock market is up 10% YTD...Seems it's the opposite of bankrupt, or as the Americans say outperforming...
Wonderful objective job! Bravo! Thanks!
Council on Foreign Relations, January 23, 2024
"Israel has been the largest cumulative recipient of U.S. foreign aid since its founding, receiving about $300 billion (adjusted for inflation) in total economic and military assistance"
The idea that this polity can continue to exist, when it's a bottomless money pit, is absurd
That's... three months of US military expenditure? One Saudi megaproject? 2/3 of one year of Israeli GDP? Not that much my bruh.
Does the US have any other such reliable ally in the Middle East?
In non-war times it’s about 3.8 billion dollars a year, almost the entirety of it can be spent only in American defense industries (F-35s for example). This benefits the US more than people realize, giving them not only soft power, but a sustainable defense industry.
@@amitsharon8858 Imagine if Israel were selling rival technologies on the international market !!!
@@Michael-do2xf thats... your entire networth times a million? not too much my dude
I did find describing the city being levelled as 'businesses closing because of security concerns'
Like my house burning down and my not living there being attributed to the EPC rating.
As an Israeli, the elections cannot come soon enough....
As an illegal immigrant there I fixed it for ya
@@handsomegrinch6279what do you feel about illegal immigrants in the UK? I assume you are pro the Rwanda plan?
@@handsomegrinch6279 easy there kiddo, we go where we please. Either way it's none of your business so stick to your own sh*t.
@@handsomegrinch6279You decide who is legal and who is not in foreign countries?
I have a question, if snap elections were to take place, which party will win (just asking)
That’s a good analysis
Israeli government: "Moody's decision is based on theoretical speculation, not on the current economy".
One sentence later: "It will improve when we will win the war".
I didn't know whether to cry or laugh. Are politicians really without shame?
Wars are political decisions. Politicans takes desicions that ensure their survival. Admitting defeat especially in far-right means complete failure to get re-elected. This means left groups fail to hold onto political influence by avoiding confrontation and conforming to other groups. Much like politicans ignore and downplay all wrong doings in the hopes of not taking the brunt of the damage.
The question is how Gaza will get by with no economy.
Gaza never had an economy they live in an open air prison not allowing sea or air access
@@adelalmohtaseb5261 nice IQ, forgot that the UN funded their economy lmao
@@adelalmohtaseb5261 'Bout time they got one. Reliance on international welfare cannot continue.
@@adelalmohtaseb5261"Open air prison" is every poor country. Not just Gaza. And they could have productive economy. But their leadership did not want it. For them the aid of UNWRA was enough.
@@marksimons8861 mate, a full blockade of the strip usually doesn't help economy
I'll just say it, people always put a wedge between them and the leadership that is elected. here's the uncomfortable reality, our horrible, short sighted, incompetend leaders are a reflection of us.
they represent us, they show us what we have become, all the ignorance, all the chaos, all the uncertainty and fear. it begins with us, leaders like Netanyahu are what we DESERVE, because this is who we are, and the same can be said about the plethora of imcompetent populists worldwide.
sorry I'm bit out of hope, but truthfully, I don't see it getting any better... our only undoing is our infinite stupidity.
Totally agree with you. Prophet Mohammad peace be upon him said "However you yourselves are, you get your leaders".
Maybe you shouldn’t have tried to establish a country in a region you don’t belong. The only “western” bit in this region is Israel, surrounded by Arabs.
Any normal person sees that you do not belong.
Yes, in the same way the hamas represents all palestinians, but I don't think it's the case
❤Precisely .well said and well REASONED. The EVIDENCE supports your argument COMPLETELY.
@@user-iz2hj3bn8mMay Allah reward you ameen. When TRUTH comes FALSEHOOD VANISHES according to the QUR'AN
I genuinely wonder what Netenyahu means by "when we win the war"? What does it look like?
glass
Judging by his and his cabinet's words, probably Gaza emptied, bulldozed and re-settled.
What did Hitler mean? That’s what he means
Israel will never win. Sadly that's the reality. Even if they manage to capture the full area which I doubt, the Arab nations will always keep Israel in check through various organisations.
As an Israeli I'm pretty sure he means "when the polls no longer suggest that my coalition will lose the next election by a landslide"
People getting triggered over TLDR saying an occupied territory is occupied 😂
The same prople who say "facts dont care about your feelings"
@@user-op8fg3ny3jThey don't and feelings don't care about facts 😂
They argue that the land is disputed, not occupied, as they conquered it from Jordan who later relinquished their claims to the land, making it... disputed.
But don't let facts get in the way of ideology.
Objective truth superiority moment
Getting triggered by untruths is not 😆 it's 😬
Gaza and the west bank have been annexed. Occupation's temporary. After multiple decades, we need to acknowledge it's an an annexation!
N.B. Yes, I know that's not what you were refering to, but still gonna poke at your anyway 😜
Credit ratings are always based on theoretical situations rather than the actual economy.
Mainly the theoretical situation of a government being able to repay loans. Decreasing credit ratings after the government is unable to pay defeats it's whole purpose.
Haters are idiots. Same people who thinks afgans are thriving cause they have higher exchange ratio
Well, credit ratings are supposed to reflect the probability of lenders getting their money back. Which very much depends on what happens in the future, which is all theoretical scenarios. Like, would you lend money to a government whose economy was doing great today but the country going to be bombed to the stone age tomorrow?
AMERICA WILL HAVE TO PAY OF COURSE 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Correction: the us taxpayer. The rich elites wont pay a penny
Orrection, as the world's reserve currency, the whole world pays when the us prints money 😅
America has done, nothing but restrain us and prevent us from resolving the issue. You seem to forget Israel is a nuclear power 🇮🇱
Nah they only give us aid as 3 bilion a year to the miltary(just like they give egypt and pakistan).
And as israeli this aid need to end because comment like this we don't need american help if some of their pop don't want to give us this.
@@user-mg3ur7bj9mIsrael has free healthcare and free education funded by our tax money , so no, no it’s the same 😒
Calling this a “war” is like saying “special military operation” - call it what it is.
Because according to you Israel didn't invade Gaza? What kind of idiotic comparison is this?
@@gubruikertjeOn the contrary, it's because what's happening in Gaza is a genocide against Palestinians.
Genocide cannot be tolerated
@@gubruikertjePeople are well aware that Israel didn't start the war, but the way Israel is conducting this war is overkill and many countries around the world are taking note of that, which probably doesn't help the economic situation.
There's self-defence and wanting to respond to what happened, but clearly in the eyes of many around the world, Israel is taking it too far, which could escalate the war into something much worse in the region or it could damage Israel's economy longer term.
Either way, the longer the war drags on, the less investment is likely to happen in Israel, the higher the chances of the war escalating in the region, it's not doing Israel any favours the longer it drags out.
It's a British channel. Brits are not known to be truthful with words.
A prolonged economic crisis is a danger to the existence of Israel than any other threat it has ever faced ,and given the current situation and the carnage in Gaza ,Israel is headed for exactly that ,a prolonged economic crisis.
Barring any significant concessions from the Israelis this war in Gaza will not and can not be just swept under the rug like the previous wars, it is so glaringly publicised and so atrocious and has had the effect of focusing much of the world's attention on the Palestinian issue (think the effect the Soweto uprising had on Apartheid South Africa) ,now this may not be apparent in the immediate as changes in international geopolitics take time to reflect ie Israel's main allies may not immediately sanction it but there's a general consensus that Israel is becoming a liability among it's allies i.e they are starting to lose more than they gain and this will trigger a gradual divestment from Israel over the coming years as these allies seek to form new partnerships to circumvent Israel's use. Apartheid South Africa faced a similar problem towards the end ,previously the US and it's allies in Western Europe supported the Apartheid regime in it's military adventures in Angola, Namibia and Mozambique but as the international outcry against Apartheid grew ,South Africa became a net liability to the West and from the mid 70s onwards they started divesting culminating in 1985 when they placed sanctions on the Apartheid regime. South Vietnam suffered a similar fate, when after tet ,Vietnam become a political liability to the US and this forced the US to divest and start reconsidering it's China policy.
Israel is in a very similar position today but it faces an existential threat if this were to happen, the first casualty of this war economically is the tourism industry which has all but collapsed in the wake of this war, and will stay so for quite a while as it doesn't make alot of business sense for tour companies (with the BDS movement in full swing ) to offer packages to visit a country accused of (that g word) ,they may gain a handful of religious tourists but will lose alot of customers who will not consider them for other destinations. That's the tourism industry gone. Also don't expect any state visits from leaders from the Global South, Israel is effectively in isolation from here on out. Now tourism contributes to a good portion of the economy but it's what comes next that may prove the biggest threat. Being in Isolation means the country won't attract as many investors and slowly over the next 5 or so years the economy will start shrinking, now this is an economy heavily reliant on it's tech industries and technology as an industry is very human resource reliant, now as the economy shrinks these tech companies may find themselves in a position whereby they cannot compete with global tech companies and this may trigger an outflow of human capital as these techies go to better paying ,less isolated countries (read about capital flight in the latter stages of Apartheid and early post Apartheid era in South Africa) , this has the overall effect of making Israel less competitive in the tech sphere in the world and crucially one of it's biggest exports ,which means a tanking economy and loss of significant diplomatic leverage .
Now with a tanking/stagnating economy and Isolated that's when the demographics kick in, in a country with so many dual nationals (with citizenship from developed countries) as soon as economic woes begin they will start fleeing to these countries, which means the economy tanks even more ,which results in more people leaving ,by the time we are getting to this stage (in about a decade or so) Israel will have lost so much diplomatic leverage due to the factors listed above that it will probably now be sanctioned and this will further exacerbate the crisis..and it is in this stage that Israel will most probably agree to serious negotiations ,but what happens to the probably 1mn settlers in the west Bank ? Are they to be expelled? Realistically this would be a disaster so we may have a situation where one state, with two autonomous regions (See Bosnia & Herzegovina) is declared ,problem is equal rights also means equal rights for Palestinians which means right of return and trust me they will flood back ,flood back to a state which has already lost significant amounts of its Jewish population and Palestinians may edge out the Jews in Israel in terms of population resulting in a state with 60% Arab 40% Jewish population and in that situation can it really describe itself as a Jewish state . Btw the name of this state will most probably be Republic of Israel and Palestine.
My suggestion to the Israelis, get rid of Netanyahu and get someone who is willing and serious about a political settlement with the Palestinians while you are still on top ,because it will only get harder from here.
The US wont let the israeli economy tank, their sugar daddy is more important than their own people
Israel doesn't have allies they have puppets and they own EU and USA unlike apartheid south Africa
It's true that Israel is a liability for them but their aid is Unconditional and unlimited
There's also no way to satisfy Palestinians now without a state based on at least 67 border which means giving up on the west bank settlements and eastern Jerusalem for good
Great analysis
Israel leadership will hold similar position as that of BB. Unless a peace treaty is signed I am not sure any leader will sanction a change in current status
Tourism accounts directly for 2.8% of Israel's GDP...no Israeli will elect a government that will allow a palestinian state, 92% are now opposed.
Who knew choosing to continue a war with no clear ending in sight while threatening to attack another country wasn't great for investor confidence?
may be Israel should surrender instead?
Hamas has rejected all peace plans saying they don’t want peace, they want to continue the war
what point are you making, should israel act differently?
@@pogadolindeed, their one week operation is now in its 5th month and the Palestinians are not surrendering
@@philipusarabus5561 give me an alternative
The only real question is how the population of Israel weighs this economic downturn against the national security issue. Money isn't everything.
If they are reasonable they will blame both Zionism and the current government as that is the case. Hamas would not exist if there was no oppressive regime that literally helped prop them up for their own agenda.
It is rather consistent that a major conflict or war causes the GDP of a country to drop significantly in the first year, but a nation would need to already be in an abysmal condition before the conflict for its economy to collapse this quickly.
War _increases_ GDP as the government goes into massive spending. Unless your country was actually hurt. Like Israel was. This is an existential threat to Israel. Money be damned.
T’essaye de mettre de la pommade à une jambe qui a le cancer en espérant la soigner . L’entité sioniste c’est engagé dans un massacre à but génocidaire. C’est pas deux armées proprement dites qui s’affrontent. Et maintenant le monde entier attend que les États Unis du malheur de cette planète s’écroule et la ça sera une autre histoire.
You think it's a war?
Nah mates the Israeli war will just bankrupt the average Israeli civilian, talking to you as an israeli citizen from tel aviv
Imagine there being consequences to war
Yup
i wont be going on holiday there thats for sure
They are many Chrisitian pyligrims that will go anyway.
Why not?
@@ChinnuWoWi don’t maybe the the apartheid and subjugation of the native Palestinians. That’s a pretty big one issue I would say .
@@Tarz2155 jews are the natives, arabs are from arabia and not native to the levant
you mean native Jews. during the ottoman empire rule there were less than 280k Arab Muslims, you think after the "natives" palestinians lived there for 1200 years there would be more, but suddenly after the European Jews started buying land and finally were allowed to go back to the land they were expelled, and developed it the Arabs started mas immigrating from the Arab countries like Lebanon Iraq Syria Jordan Egypt as farm workers for the Jews.
now fast forward from 1914 to 1948 suddenly there are more than 800k "native" Palestinians that don't even view themselves as Palestinians. [Palestinian leader even said they will use the term Palestine (late 60s) to counter the Israeli identity]
As for the "nakba" you can learn that it was their leaders that told them to leave before the WAR THEY STARTED and lost. and they also spread lies like Jews raping and killing every Arab they saw which increased the panic among the Arabs to flee Israel.
You can find interview of Arab leader admitting they lied about rape and it resulted in opposite reaction they wanted.
And what apartheid? do you even know what apartheid means, we gave them Gaza they elected their leaders guess what they voted for Hamas, guess what hamas did killed all their competition and said they would destroy Israel and kill every Jew on the planet.
you may say thats Gaza and not "West Bank" but if you pay attention to West Bank you will know that there almost terror attack every day coming from there, just yesterday in the morning 3 terrorist started shooting at Jews that were at traffic going to school or work.
You can watch videos of corey asking Palestinians how to solve the conflict guess their answers, all of them said to open the border and for every Palestinian to live in peace but the Jews to either kill or kick them from the country.
he also asked about nuking Israel and all of them supported the idea of Tel Aviv being nuked.
You cant have peace with people that being indoctrinated since birth to hate and kill Jews.
@@Tarz2155
According to Wikipedia's article about Israel's economy (so, take this with a grain of salt) their economy grew 8.6% in 2021, 6.5% in 2022, 3.1% in 2023 and 3% in 2024. In 2022 inflation was 3.1% and grew to 4.3% in 2023. So, already the economic prospects weren't looking good.
It was looking great until netanyahu got reelected and tried to make Israel a dictatorship
LoL the americans will be forced to pay for all the economic losses taken by Israel and defend them at great cost as usual. 😂
*tax paying americans. The rich elites won't
Lol the Americans aren't forced to do anything. They obsessively poke their nose into everyone else's business then complain that all this nose-poking costs money. 🙄
While Americans live paycheck to paycheck and survive off of foodbanks
I am American.
If only you knew before speaking out.
This support represents… just 0.6% of Israel’s GDP!! 😅
And this support needs to be entirely spent INSIDE the USA supporting our economy!!
What costs money to American taxpayers is my country’s enduring support to protect Europe: 60,000 American soldiers! Which costs way more than anything.
Furthermore, my country provides the palestinian economy around 600 million of dollars which the tunnels can spend freely … to build terrorist tunnels below Gaza 😅
@@Xavi297I am an American. You type like an Israeli.
War is not always good for the economy
Only if you are America
@@oussamabekk1108 think through your brain not through emotions
@@oussamabekk1108America lost Vietnam war and got out of Bretton wood because they lacked payment mean. 😮
@oussamabekk1108
Iraq hurt our economy
@@ReallyRandomMe Just a joke Bro
Would not be surprised if there was some pressure from US Gov to lower the credit rating. It would be their back-door way of getting Netanyahu to limit the scale of his war without directly telling him "No, you can't have that thing"
I wouldn't be surprise at all! Biden admon is a chaos! One day basically supports overthrowing Netanhayu, later after the attacks supported him, now attack attack him again. One day they send billions of dollars in Ukraine and later they cut gas exports to Europe because climate change. And later they promotes oil imports from Venezuela all of places.
US wouldn't hurt their own dog
The US government is basically a branch of the Israeli government by now...
Moody has downgraded it, S&P has changed the outlook to negative. It's not like nothing has happened here
@@prohacker5086 keeping the rating artificially high would hurt US investors and thus indirectly the US economy. Is that in their interest?
This is nothing compared to famine in Gaza.
When did the far rigth take over tdlr News comment section?
It's just the hasbara machine doing its work
I think that the process is still in early phase, thought Netanjahu is kind of helpful. If what he is doing is OK, then Western nationalists look timid. Alternatively, if what he does is not OK, then criticizing them is no longer a taboo...
When i see his video early most of the comments are supporting Israel but if i wait for 4-5 hours it becomes more balance
You mean normal people who dont want genocide?
Far right is when people oppose far-right unity governments hell bent on ethnic cleansing of the Gaza Strip 😂
*good*
Let me dispute your analysis by stating that you completely missed the macros, which are:
1. 1nis was worth 4.08$ a week into the war, now 1nis equal 3.6$. Israel's currency strengthened. Which both shown the economy strength but also affected its exports ("it costs more to buy israeli merchandise in dollars")
2. Israel foreign reserves got up from 190$ billion to 204$ billion. In fact, thanks to Houthis red sea crisis, which doesn't affect Israel but wracks Egypt/Jordan economies - Israel exports more gas to Egypt and Jordan ships more goods through Haifa port. More foreign money coming into Israel.
3. Inflation went down to 2.5% (less private consumption) and interest rate is 4.5%. Positive.
4. Services (software, hardware, medical) exports are actually up 23% last quarter, but they are negated by losses in construction and tourism. Both loses are due to reserve forces enlisted. So, actually - the only slumping part of the economy is the one related to internal consumption (as seen by lower inflation). When reservists will return, these part will prosper.
cope
@@thotslayer9914 רק ל 3 חודשים. הייתי בעזה. ומאז שחזרתי, שכרתי 4 מהנדסים, ויש מחסור.
בתחום שלי, מיכשור רפואי, יש המון השקעות מחו"ל.
ואתה, אתה בארץ?
@@thotslayer9914כן בטח, וליהודים בחו״ל יש עתיד מזהיר, כל היום מחבקים ומנשקים אותם. אם כל כך קשה לך לחיות כישראלי או אפילו כיהודי, תעבור לאירופה ותתאסלם. ככה תוך 50 שנה אתה תהיה חלק מהרוב באירופה.
how is this a cope. average 3 year old on the internet@@faisalislamchowdhury5183
@@faisalislamchowdhury5183
your cope refers to your pro-palestinian side coping??? hahahahhahahahahahhahahha
This isnt war, its genocide
This is so out of topic
7:37 lmao "Likud party falls back"
In my language likud means your back so 😂😂😂😂
LOL
what language is that?
@@benpalacios9231 bisaya and tagalog from philippines
..
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
are you a filipino trying troll?
In hebrew Likud means unity(it isn't a commonly used word) but it is similar to trap, which is what the likud is
@@benpalacios9231its tagalog/bisaya from the Philippines
Calling this a "war" is like a heavyweight champ decking an infant and saying it was a "fair fight."
Okay maybe not an infant, but like..a disgruntled teenager lol
So the Iraq war or war in Afgahnistan aren't wars cause one side is much stronger?
@59 Basically. Name one god damn thing we did there that didn't involve killing people.And wars are fought OVER something, we already know WMD were a lie. What was that "war" about? And don't you dare say "terror" lol
Started by the "infant"
Cope IDF is losing the war
There is still a big amount of support for Netanyahu, wev'e seen many media sources around the world getting this impression for years now and he still got elected, part of it is due to the fact that the more religious parts of Israeli society don't get platform nor in mainstream media nor in social media.
In my opinion Netanyahu needs to go but be mindful when you try to analyze public opinion in israel as much of your sources come from the declining demographic secular left.
There is hardly any support for him, he's on the lowest he's ever been. Every place I go I only hear content for him and even long time liqud voters calling for elections.
There's more to that than just demographics. He lost the before last election and barely managed to get a coalition this time by teaming up with lunatics, and by doing so tarnished his image a bit more. Not to mention, this war starting on his term shutered his "Mr security" image, that was the only thing keeping some people's support amid corruption allegations and whatnot. He's a sly mf but hard to see how he manages to get out of this one.
All polls but channel 14 (which is 100% a rightwing propaganda channel) show Likud on ~20 seats. Current coalition is currently 20 seats down according to every poll not from propaganda channel
@@yuvalba9879
The so called lunatics in the coalition support him, so he, for now has the majority of the Knesset, even now after October 7 polls shows that he is suitable for pm almost if not more than any other candidate in the eyes of the public, so hes still quite popular.
I sincerely hope he will not rum again but if he will i would not be quick to bet that he will completely lose he's power in government (something that will cause serious civil unrest and rightfully so)
Lets hope he will choose not to run again
At the end there is one aspect that matters more than anything else - is the population productive and is the workforce highly skilled. The answer to both of these questions is yes. So once this war is over, the economy will get better too. Not to mention all the arms deals Israel is going to sign after this war after proving absolute technological superiority.
ROTFLMAO 🤣
sounds like delusion to me
@@thinkingtoomuch7974 We'll see who's laughing in the end.
With the US bankrolling Izrael, they have unlimited financing.
What's another trillion or two between friends eh?
Yep, there ain't no economic crisis there with foods on the table and roof over the head and Big Bro Uncle Bison giving free green money and ammo for plundering
Seriously. What a ridiculous title
That’s really not how it works, I encourage you to actually look into it
US aid to Israel is about 3% of Israel's budget. Even with the aid for the war, it's like 20% of military spending. The idea that Israel is bankrolled by America is delusional.
Since the human body is mostly made of water, and water came from outer space, I therefore claim Jupiter to be my rightful land of return.
Yooo, I'll take Pluto
But Muslim can have Pakistan and kosovo, right???
@@joaquinescotoaleman4320 tells a lot about how smart islamophobes are. islam isnt an ethnicity. muslims in pakistan are native to their land and speak their own language.
Jews have had a presence in Palestine for thousands of years
@@rizkyadiyanto7922according to Muslims Islam is an ethnicity
Short answer no
Money doesn’t fall from the sky nor does it grow on trees
@@philipusarabus5561 so what? Israel’s got great economic power it’s not that big of loss. In a year or 2 it will be the same as before the war.
Why have you drawn golan hights as par of Israel?!
Because they are a part of Israel
When Syria had the high county, they shot at farmers below. They fully attacked Israel in 1974 and had to retreat.
Imagine if Syria with recent atrocities had the Heights.
That’s because it is 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
"Israel" will collapse for the same reason Apartheid South Africa did. Apartheid is really expensive, and when the settler entity can't afford to offer the colonists a European standard of living the colonists start to leave.
Judging from how SA looks after lifting apartheid, it was rather that either way local non-European population was quite expensive...
@@useodyseeorbitchute9450 The problem South Africa has was that the settler population never redistributed their property, which maintained and absurdly unequal, and hence completely dysfunctional, society.
A liberated Palestine will probably be more like Algeria. The settlers will mostly leave, and the native population will be left to their own device (though presumably with some hostility from the West).
@@domtweed7323You mean that property of Whites should have been redistributed like in... Zimbabwe? I think that's a rare case when your hypothetical solution has been tested and you can analyze whether it works...
In Palestine it would be like Algeria (or Syria) as that's roughly level that this ethnic group tends to achieve, unless they are lucky with oil.
@@useodyseeorbitchute9450 It's up to the native population to choose their economic policies.
Look at China. They spend decades experimenting with different economic systems until they found one that worked. But eventually they did.
Countries can only start that process once they're free to colonialism. Because colonialists will always build an economy that channels wealth to the metropol.
@@domtweed7323" It's up to the native population to choose their economic policies." So Zulus (newcomers like Europeans) should also not make part of this decision in South Africa, while it should be left to tiny minority of indigenous Xhosa?
"Countries can only start that process once they're free to colonialism." Again, have you thought it through. Like USA vs Canada? Or Hong-Kong? Or let's say East European countries under German or Austro-Hungary rule?
I look at China. When they partially dumped communism, their economy inexplicably started working. While that was indeed local decision, it looked as if they needed to just learn hard way capitalism (with authoritarian and mercantilism undertones)
700 000 young men in 10 % of the population and 20% of the workforce. The economy dropped by 20%.
Some of those soldiers ain't coming back. Forever. 🤣
Israel will be completely fine, they are incredibly intelligent people and have backing from big players.
You mean they are fine they have US taxpayers money ?
Gaza has EU tax money
@Truhno4 compare israel and gaza aid. Gaza is also a prison
American tax money am i right🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑
Even intelligent people can lose grasp on reality and that''s clearly happened.
No US taxpayers will "donate " as much money as they need.
I’m surprised they didn’t call Moody’s downgrade an “act of antisemitism “😅
Satanyahu: *MOODY IS RUN BY KHAMAS!!!*
Why are we including the Golan Heights as part of Israel?
because we own it habibi come and take it
Because it is.
@@Sapnfap Larping as an israelí has to be a new low.
@@Sapnfap I don't have any interest in engaging in nationalistic shit slinging. The channel doesn't include occupied territories as part of countries' territories like with Crimea and I'm asking them why they're not doing that with the Golan.
Go find someone else to be a youtube commenter with
@@masha22092000r then Ukraine and baltics is part of Russia
As long as America is owned by Israel this scenario may not happens
Can you explain to me exactly how america is owned by Israel?
@@UHS840 Lobby? Overrepresntation among elites like media, law, finance and academia?
@useodyseeorbitchute9450 over representation in America? You do realise that just because someone's Jewish doesn't mean they're from or support Israel, right?
Rather than just listing a bunch of sectors with absolutely zero context, explain to me exactly how Israel owns America. How exactly does Israel own the media, law and financial sectors in America and how do they use thos to the benefit of Israel?
@@UHS840 While it's not guaranteed for any particular individual, they are rather highly-ethnocentric group, so that's the general tendency. Which part of there is plenty of people in power who deem particular country as their own, they would try to be patriotic in relation to to their fatherland do you deem as surprising?
"Owning" is indeed a bit excessive term, as that particular faction generally dislikes Bibi. But being specific, concerning outcomes. Annual subsidies? ME policy shaped in a way that is highly expensive for the US but benefits Israel? Positive media coverage?
@useodyseeorbitchute9450 Wait, so you're justification for your belief in a higky antisemitic conspiracy theory is to double down and say anyone who's Jewish must support Israel because "they are a highly ethnocenttic group"? Well thanks for getting the blatant antisemitism out the way in the beginning so everyone can see you're clearly someone who's opinions shouldn't be listened to. Until everyone respects each other regardless of faith or race there will be no peace, you're part of the problem.
You still never listed exactly how Israel controls the US (other than the fact America has Jewish people there so they must be owned by them). You gave no names and no context just repeated the original comment but made it longer.
NO !
Your videos are nice, and I always follow them very closely, and like them a lot; but your graphs are often full of problems. E.g., the one at 25s is missing year 2021, and now I don't know if it is just missing or if you meant 2021 and 2022 in the last two lines.
Do Lebanon. Its crazy
You really need to re-record that promo you do for every video, you say "ring the bell" very strangely.
Correction: After minute one. Israel didn't declare independence in 1948. It declared a state that was taken by force of occupation.
"Defence" expenditure... yeah right
that doesn't surprise me
A few problem with video.
1. Moody report not only said that the Israeli government didn't agree to the international proposed solution to Gaza, but also that there was no other plan on the table. And that even if Israel government agree to the international proposed medium/long term solution, there is no garantee it will work or improve the situation. Interestingly the government responses I saw didn't adress the second part, only the not agreeing with international solution (because that kind of retoric is well accepted locally)
2. The prediction in the video that the voting would probably move left, seems to be based on nothing but pseudo-logic reasoning. Considering the track record of tldr with logic reasoning I wouldn't hold my breath on this happening. In my opinion there is a high chance this will prove completely incorrect. Next week local election might give some indication on this.
This channel gets it wrong alot. But then again, its called tldr. They really are just pointing stuff out and making a few guesses. They didnt claim to be doing otherwise, except in the really stupid clickbaits.
Greetings from Israel. The polls currently show the centre-left is leading. But in my opinion these polls are worthless, because in the next election there will surely be a new protest party that isn't included in the polls. I don't think the local elections are relevant, because the parties had to submit their lists before October 7, so there still isn't any new protest party running.
You should also talk about the west bank's economy. Between workers in Israel loosing jobs, the PAs tax revenues being withheld and possibly the collapse of UNRWA, it's a mess.
The political aftermath is what I'm worried about most here. Netanyahu is proving himself to be a threat to his nations democracy. Even if he's ousted, the extremist parties might not. In that case, especially with Netanyahu's proposed law reforms still in limbo (iirc), it means Israel is on the edge of a slippery slope that could see it turn into a dectatorial ethbistate. Not only will that spell a bleak future not just for Palestinians, but Israelis too. Their country could devolve into another corrupt, Middle Eastern dictatorship.
4:58 so Netanyahu has decided to pull a Qatar, how lovely.
Good
Israel doesn’t have to worry about its economy, the American Taxpayers will pay their bills.
Yes
iv'e literally subscribed and again unsubscribed at 1:15.
please be accurate and specific what exactly is "after declaring independence in 1948"
dependence from what exactly? were they occupied?
It is unbelievable that you made a whole video about Israeli post-war politics and economy without even mentioning Benny Gantz's party, National Unity, which only recieved 12 seats in the last elections but got significantly stronger since joining the war cabinet to have some centrist influence on Bibi's extremist government. That party is now getting around 40 seats (a third of all parliament) in anyone of the election surveys and Gantz is surely on his way to become the next prime minister, a reassuring fact as Israelis are looking for safety, stability and unity, all of which are things Bibi is unable (some would say unwilling) to provide.
It also shines a light about the complexity of Israeli politics, as the war against Hamas is by far a consensus opinion, but that doesn't mean supporting a Bibi-Smotritch-BenGvir coalition.
And that's before sanctions. 🤞
dream on
Dont worry they have US tax money
I am american.
Just fyi, Israel doesn’t get this support for free as it has to spend it 100% inside the US.
This support represents 0.6% of israeli GDP to out in perspective 😅
And it represents 0.0013% of USA s gdp…
That man is not doing anything to uplift Israel
Subtract America's $3b annual 'gift' and where is Israels economy?
Let’s check if God loves Israel if the USA doesn’t support them with free money
@@bulbigood6558Gods not going to save Israel now any more than he did in 70AD. Once again, their self-righteous arrogance blinds them into believing God favors and will protect their wickedness.
3b is a small amount for a developed country
Israel’s total gdp is 488.5B
Israel won the war back then but underwent hyperinflation in the 1970s for similar economic reasons. That is why their currency is called "New".
Nope! UNRWA funding cut. So got extra money now😅
Thats just suicidal on the part of Netanyahu
Israel is the 21st Rhodesia
As an Israeli, this video is pretty informative
As a colonizer *
Israel has a bank account called the United States taxpayer so they aren’t worried anything they need the US will provide
dang
No
This sounds so similar to the video you did for the russian economic crisis... Eventually nothing happened. Same here with israel , they will recover
"Israel doesn't need aid," no it does!!
Not really
Just do the math
America gives 3 billion dollars per year
That's something like 300 dollars per person ( almost 10 million inhabitants)
And the GDP of Israel is 50.000 per person
So believe they will be fine
its more like 4 billion and america is not the only nation funding it, not to mention its purely military aid and not economic aid@@MateoMPM
@@faroukm4148 so proves my point even further, Israel can do pretty well without economic aid
No.
Nothing the American taxpayer can't handle :)
All this attrition for the Ben Gorin Canal... Tut, tut and when that fails and when Palestine is Free, the entire western economy will collapse... "Hit the button"!
That explains India's pro-Israeli genocide stance
The US will be ready with the blank chequebook.
like they send 60 billion dollars a year abroad on a regular basis, on 4 of it go to israel on regualr basis(aside from us military presence in europe,korea and the pacific). maybe the us govs think maintaining the petro dollar system,the sway over the suetz canal,the sway over most of the gulf countries economy and defense sectors and the sway over south east asia's energy supply(from the middle east) + controlling the gas and oil prices around the world is worth something
Who wants to invest or live in a purely evil state
well, the country is morally bankrupt ....
Why was it important to point out how much Gaza economy dropped VS Israeli ?
Seems like a diversion of the main topic of the video
Who would have thought maintaining apartheid ethnostate could be this expensive
Diverse states are even more expensive, so this part does not seem like an issue. It's rather war without even clear war aims that may make investors a bit nervous.
@@useodyseeorbitchute9450 Israel IS a diverse state but they segregate certain groups. That type of oppression always comes with a cost. It also locks out a big potential workforce from many jobs that investors like to get filled
@@tomlxyz What would be the alternative cost? In the US desegregation lead to White flight due to crime spike hitting the more productive population. If the main problem had been oppression, then the oppressed populations would be doing fine elsewhere or would be doing fine after even mild tuning down oppression. The only case where such process was actually observed was collapse of communism.
American will ready to help their master to fix their master economy
I can only hope that Israel can quickly recover from this and that Netanyahu will be held accountable for what he’s done.
Too hell with Notinyahoo and Isreal