What are the Farm Bills and how will they affect farmers? | NL Cheatsheet
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- Last week, two #FarmBills which bring in sweeping reforms in India's agriculture sector were bulldozed through #Parliament. This happened while farmers and Opposition parties were holding widespread protests saying the reforms will be a death knell for India's agriculture sector.
You're probably wondering: Are these Farm Bills good or bad? Are the reforms to the agriculture sector proposed by the #ModiGovernment beneficial to farmers, or are they harmful?
Resident Parliament nerd Meghnad S explains what the reforms are all about, and how they will affect farmers.
EXTRA Reading material for fellow nerds:
- www.prsindia.o...
- www.prsindia.o...
- www.prsindia.o...
- vivekkaul.com/...
- indianexpress....
- indianexpress....
- indianexpress....
-------------------
Sign up for our all-new media newsletter: bit.ly/StopPre...
Support independent media and subscribe to Newslaundry: bit.ly/paytokee...
To watch this and many more videos, click on www.newslaundry...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
This guy could be anywhere between 18 to 45 years old
lol
Child-like and childish as well. 😅
accurate description
czcams.com/video/Aoy72iONERk/video.html
@@aseemrk come on , 13 ??
While you covered most of the points of the bill. You missed a very important point that resolution of contracts etc will not be done by courts but via the SDM. As you know our farmers are so game with contract law and SDMs in India are so honest. This will work perfectly in favour of the farmers whenever an issue with a corporation arises.
Also pls update the video regarding the other very imp. Bill - the Essential commodities act. Doing away with it -Wouldn’t that lead to even more hoarding & blackmarketing by big biz?? Chronology...
@Geetha Rani M There isn't much option. If you're getting shit prices currently and someone comes and gives you better option then surely they'll be tempted. There are many who barely make enough to sustain their family, won't you be tempted to go for such an offer. Maybe you've never seen/worked on a farm so let me give you another analogy. At your job you barely make enough to sustain you and your family, now a corporate comes with a better job offer with much better pay, are you not going to take it?
@Pasta They have to give a higher rate initially to tempt the farmers. Its once that the farmers are trapped in the contracts that they can change things. Since you're giving the example of Canada and US, read up on the history of how it worked over there. Initially it worked quite well over there it was much later with consolidation of the existing companies etc that things began to change.
He looks like Flipkart Advt. child in Adult attire😂
Underrated and pin-worthy
thats what you focused on ?? He explained so beautifully! really no article or video has dumbed this whole issue like this. Hats off to NL
Ha ha ha
And that's what you focussed on the whole time 😔
Haha! Yes! Good observation!👍
Make a person so weak that he should consider breathing and surviving as development
@subhadeep mandal aa gaya modi ka pilla
exactly our thoughts for the last few years. according to the sanghis, we should be indebted to have been born in this land so should keep paying these goons all our money to stay alive. if we are not in jail, we should consider ourselves lucky for the day until one day our luck will run out!
@@shresthjaiswal7687 czcams.com/video/Aoy72iONERk/video.html
@@ytadltspv czcams.com/video/Aoy72iONERk/video.html
Is this a real quotation? Doesn't feel like it..
You missed out the most important fact... Farmers are not actually against bills.... They are saying just assure us MSP in writing in bill....on which govt is giving verbal assurances which is not acceptable to them....farmers are more intelligent than all economists put together...
Very intelligent indeed sir. I am a dhania, karipatta farmer. Will any govt give MSP? And will FCI buy from me if the price goes below MSP ? Or the rice/wheat farmers of Pubjab and Haryana are more equal than me ?
Hugely underrated comment!
Sorry you are mistaken. It is just not about MSP, but it also includes contract farming, no tax from private buyers, and removing some foods from essential foods. There are more intricacies apart from these points.
Then comes issue of hoarding as there will be no law or legislations that will govern the private players as they will not be bound by law or government support.
@@tatakaye2 sir, farmers very well know that once MSP is assured, they can face any challenge....by demanding MSP, they have not only simplified their demand but also have won the respect of every Indian except those you know who not be named....otherwise you would be adjudged anti-national
He explained both sides of the issue so clearly that even my kids were able to understand the issue in its entirety. Good job !!
Yeh, especially the middle finger part
Yeah, Indeed.
I think it is better to take a paid news than the regular 9PM one.
Historic and Disaster are now synonym in India😂
True
So are idiotic and intellectual
Do takka aur bhakts too😂
@@bipulkumar5070 Intellectuals warned against demonitization and GST in current form. Keep living in your dream world. BJP supporter is synonymous with anti India after all.
(Just some constructive criticism) You guys joke about Newspaper Ads for Farmers and Migrant Labourers in English but never make these Explainer videos in Hindi. Atul Chaurasia is good, but he doesn't do a lot of detailed explaining.
If u want to share a video which explains it in hindi I Suggest the video made by Akaash Banerjee and Study IQ education
Not everyone speaks hindi... Whats wrong with English to reach other state people.. If you prefer hindi watch them..
@@Pa1j-2608 well it is a problem cause English too isn't really a spread out language and many people don't know the language.
Its more of a language that the academic section understands.
Hindi is by far the best language for this even though its also not universal...
See the thing is clear in last 6 years. Every scheme & policy from NDA is perfect and top notch on 'Paper'. It falls flat when the time comes for ground level implementation and execution!
@subhadeep mandal I am present in here since last 6 years so i can comment from 2014-20! And surely not interested in knowing what all happened in 2k years!
@subhadeep mandal sher shah suri's land reforms and revenue collections...
His Sadak e azam also called grand trunk road
Ashoka reign in totality i.e. from revenue collection to management of affairs of state
Akbar's jizya abolition and mansabdari system also his faujdari system
I guess I've made my point...
Also the British copied the police system of thanas and chowkies of mughals...
Before you make any opinion ... I have studied these systems
@subhadeep mandal omg you are too old! Breath well my friend.
@@ashutoshsingh450Any chance we can know what happened before 2000 years 😂
Reminds me of Tughlaq🤔
Here are the names of the 3 Bills
The Farmers Produce Trade & Commerce (Promotion & Facilitation) Bill
The Farmers (Empowerment & Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill
The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
I think the names were intentionally made so big so that people wouldn't feel interested.
When its historic, it spells disaster.
Lol. True that....
This is called pseudo liberals
czcams.com/video/Aoy72iONERk/video.html
Not really, it all depends on the execution.
Let me contact Oxford University press to change the meaning of Historic. Based on contemporary experiences.
@@manzoorathar11 😀😀🤣
"You might have noticed my dear viewers that we do not live in an ideal world." that's hysterical 🤣🤣
Keep on educating us with such useful informative videos.
To educate atleast you pay somthing to them boss, they cannot do it freely boss...
Right 👍
@@MrBalamuralikrishna youtube takes care of that bro.. you can subscribe and help out as well
@@bharathg7284 Actually that's if you monetize the video. As per newslaundary they don't
@Arun Sar cherrypicked?? Did they manipulate anything related to the topic or lied to you like BJP(RSS). Or did hide any information related to the topic. They picked the following topic cause govt fucked up and 80% farmers protesting. If you want them to report on any specific topic request them
Potatoes and Onions are not there in essential foods. So yahh it will go the way petrol and gas is going. Sab changa sii
@subhadeep mandal well the irony is the recent events of labourers trying to get back to there home's and they were left to fend for themselves. Hindu's or Muslims it's the staple.
@subhadeep mandal you may eat the potatoes and Onions with barcodes on them👍
@subhadeep mandal Arey but petroleum also comes from under the earth na :P
@subhadeep mandal to put this in a short context economy of scales are related to the total produce of potato and onions unlike other leafy vegetables which have shorter life and hence not exported . Potato and onions are exported and pricing for them needs to be constant checks . It has nothing to do with hindu and muslim its profitable for and loss making sometimes hence its classified as essential
@@dnyaneshshinde8151 are bhai he is a paid gobarbhakt.... U can see him in many comments ranting illogical.
Even RSS farmers union is also against this bill they know exactly what is going to happen due to this bill. Paapi Paitt ka swaal hai.
czcams.com/video/c6gW_sUORSg/video.html
Farmers are not educated in economics. Watch this video till the end.
@@raghavmc Farmers are far more educated than him. They have PHD, lawyers in these unions.
@@raghavmc haha.. even Modi too is not educated in economics.
Farmers are far most educated then this chai wala😂
@@JasRakhra your teacher is educated, he must be the prime minister right?
Timestamps👍
0:07 - Into
1:20 - Cheatsheet
3:24 - Farmers bill is good in theory
4:08 - Three main contentions
9:00 - Farmers are suspicious
9:52 - How to make this bill great?
💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
Our country is a mixed economy in theory and an agricultural economy in practice. 😇
Our country is a mixed economy in theory and a messed up one in practice.
Mixed economy means existence of both , private and state owned enterprises in an economic system. It has nothing to do with sectoral contribution or occupational dependency of a country.
Meghnad aged 20 years during this lockdown.
I have spoken with many real farmers regarding farm laws.
Mostly they compare it with ola and uber model of business.
Their biggest fear is:
The corporates will give very good rates initially, then all the farmers will sell only to corporates.
Then as a result of no business in APMC yards, APMC will collapse, as such even MSP will collapse.
Once the competition with government is eliminated.
Only then the corporates shall indulge in exploitation of farmers and the consumers.
By rigging the rates of commodities according to their wish, because of their storage capacity, and in-between collaboration amongst many corporates.
Its a logical scenario according to me.
Solution could be:
The government can give assurance that it will never stop MSP and keep on running APMC by subsidy for next 25 years.
Meghnad has been quite fair to the proposed laws. Contract farming itself had been recommended by MS Swaminathan. The point is that since some of these reforms have already been tried out and didn't work out as expected, coz you know, the world is not ideal, doubts regarding their implementation and discussion of steps (with stakeholders) required to correct them are pending. The way the govt went about this is so undemocratic and farmers are clearly unconvinced is the problem with this. Last I checked, India is not an authoritarian state as per its constitution. Remember folks bold does not necessarily equate to wise.
I hear disaster when Modi says historic
Yeah cuz our history was disaster ....
@Shree Harsha read the Manifesto, they didn't mentioned About bill. Don't let the TwitterMedia fool you
@@HarshHit har shit - Nehru, shartri etc were idiots cause they let the cabinet to make roads, dams, iit, aims etc in this country they should have ruled this country like a dictator and not let them be what they are today
@@xd-ho2hi Abe idiot they mentioned even rahul gandhi talked about those bills in many interviews and even @BKU_KisanUnion supported those bills in 2019 and supported Congress
@@5004500 that's a copy of Kejriwal's speech. Nice try. But temples are not built using public tax money.
Without congress bullshit communist approach our country wouldn't go in emergency and closed economy. Neither would've become a puppet of USSR. We were taken decades back.
Thank you , this is exactly what I was looking for last evening , to understand the farm bill better before passing any judgements/comments . This was helpful and it’s strange that no news channel or website has put effort into explaining it to us !
Listen to Dr. Ashok Gulati on (The Print) channel, rather than listening to half baked information that this video has.
For bjp EVERYTHING IS HISTORICAL.
Look Modi ji just pooped yellow, ohh historic !!!!
@subhadeep mandal childish and immature bhakt....🤣 Chal mai saaf kar rha hu but bhai tu to KHAAAA rha hai 😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
@@primenumber1800 hahaha ,lmao perfectly answered
@@primenumber1800 bro, he a paid troll. Just look at all the recent comments which have a reply he is every where doin his job so professionally. Kudos to him🎉🎉
@@yashinhussain2557 I KNOW BRO 😉...I was having a lill fun.....inki bato se pta chal jata hai inki MENTAL CONDITION.
It may be good in theory
And after that whole story told is about IF big giant companies overtook it
Ohh that IF you can put that anywhere
And I think people feel insecure about something when they are in a good situation
Farmers are in the worst condition in our country and if government is trying to do something you people are doing what if what if
Everywhere what if what if
Aap logo ke hisaab se to government Ko koi law hi nhi banana chahiye kyoki tum log har cheez se insecure feel karte ho
Khud Darr ka mahol failate ho fir kahte ho Darr ka mahol hai
Thank you for this valuable information. This is happening all around the world. It is about disapropriation of farmers and humanity at large. And privatisation through coporate business which have no understanding of life or respect of nature or humanity. In Germany government is making so many stipulations that farmers are close to insolvency as they cannot do all the investments the government is asking for. Once farming is stopped in Germany - of course food needs to be imported. This way they can make the world dependent by "owning the food chain" they can "control" humanity. Vandana Shiva has brought this scheme to light and she is a woman of wisdom and foresight as well as fortitude. Thank you and God bless you. May the true people of earth rise in love and truth and may we live in harmony with the sacred planet.
Take the example of govt school and private school, govt hospitals and private hospitals. All govt institutions are in defunct state😬😬
So instead of upgrading them, let's just introduce the private sector! What a great idea!
Good to know that opposition is still speaking for the people.
BJP has totally closed their eyes and ears.
Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja Take ser bhaji Take ser khaja. But yahan Praja tantra me praja hi raja hai. Aur Is raja ne 5 saal invisible kapde pehne rehne ka decision liya hai. Aur is raja ka mantrimandal bhi use ye vishwaas dilane me kami nahi rakh raha ki usne invisible high tech kapde pehen rakhe hain. I feel like laughing at our own selves.
@subhadeep mandal Not saying it's all wrong but if you've watched the video I hope you've already seen the other side of the coin too. If you can't, you're part of the problem.
@@ashwatimenon5481 reminds me of school days.
@@outdoorquest3005 😂😂.
Why did you exclude the fact that msp is not a legal provision? Also, it was promised in an election manifesto that it would repeal the agricultural produce market committees act and make trade in agricultural produce - including export and Inter state trade - free from all restrictions. Why then are we raising barriers when in principle all of us agree it's good for the farmers? APMC is not going anywhere either, so everyone has an option to sell there.
We were told that govt would no longer regulate price of petrol, and it will be decided by free market. Yet the prices didn't become negative 🤔 I wonder why?
Must say, every time to oppose just to oppose is will lead country no-where. I know some of the economists also favored these bills. Anyway, without private players, in airlines to cellular sectors, where we might have been, we all know. Anyway, for such a big & complex country, not everyone can be made happy.
So if Punjab & Haryana protest & no other major states are protesting then might be political influence. Else, entire country is mostly into farming. So country should have been burning if all are not happy with it!
Now farmers are also termed terrorist... Jiska khate ho usi ko dikha🙏🙏
@Doller Man lavde Kangna ne bola h esa
@Diptasree Choudhuri Agreed , she thinks of herself as the role model of feminism of our country
@Diptasree Choudhuri Sadly , that's the harsh reality of our society and the people who just oppose these are branded 'anti-' .
These pseudofeminists just try to fabricate the world in their own way hiding in the shadow of feminism. I mean feminism is basically about equality and no judgement. People who actually understand feminism doesn’t carry this badge of being a feminist.
@Diptasree Choudhuri Exactly , people need to be more open minded because these types of pseudo people come and go. They don't give a damn about righteousness. What they want is to make an impact of their false ideology on the mindset of the people so that they can be ideal role models.
@Diptasree Choudhuri Yeah they are far better role models than these pseudo ones. If one wishes to look up to ideal persons then they should look out for these types of persons which really want to make a better society.
What I like is he was neutral about bill and explained pros & cons in crux
This bill is not disaster nor historical or game changer. India needs our own R&D high yields and oil seeds farming revolution
Modi ji ne kiya hei, mukesh ji ki jeb ka khyal kiya hi hoga!
Bhai bhai bhai bhai bhai.. 🙏🏼
Reliance retail just bought out big bazaar..you think that’s just a coincidence..?
@@ankushchauhan2133 chronology bhai....
@@ankushchauhan2133 lol how much does big bazaar earns from their farm products
Keshav Mittal a lot
As a farmer I find it good. I can sell to anyone I wish. I not just a farmer anymore , I am on the way to become a businessman myself.
👍👍
Well said
boosting Co operative farming,
legal backing from govt in contract farming for farmers,
strict APMC and FCI regulation with regular audit from CAG/local audit bodies,
escrow account held by govt in contract farming,
strict implication of MSP in contract farming,
pressure on easier language of contracts keeping farmers' right (monitoring protection of plant varieties and farmers' right act,2001) in mind.
increasing limit(case by case basis with proper legal and mercantile reason) but not abolishing it in essential commodities act
As a layman I think these should be in those new farmer bills
Greatest living Punjabi/ Greatest living Indian is Manmohan Sir.
U didn't catch correctly private players will not pay the taxes whereas APMC has to pay ..
@bakunetsu storm The bootlicking government has the term "business incentive" to ensure that the corporates who fund them do not have to pay tax
@bakunetsu storm I ask you 2 questions regarding the conception of government giving job and private sectors giving jobs:
i) There are 2 choices: a) Where salary is high but job security is not present. b) Where salary is low-moderate, but job security is present. Which one will you choose?
ii) As per the clause of WTO that India became a part in 1991, trade barriers are to be removed, and government should not pay subsidies to the farmers. US is also a part of WTO, still it provides their cotton farmers subsidies, and that's why they can sell the cotton at abnormally low prices in global market. But 3rd world countries like India are being pressurised to remove the trade barriers. Is this free and fair globalisation? This question is part of NCERT Class 10 Economics book under chapter globalisation. You can download the NCERT app for verifying.
@bakunetsu storm Also, regarding the per capita income, I can show you an example to prove why it is a deceptive way of measuring the development of a country.
Let's consider 2 countries A & B, where 5 people live in each country. In country A, the salary of 5 people are 25,000, 5,000, 2,500, 7,500, 10,000. And in B, the salaries are 10,000, 9,000, 9,000, 10,000, 7,000. How do you understand which one is more developed using per capita income as a factor? A has more per capita income, but the difference is huge, and in B, though the per capita is less, the salary is more or less equal.
@bakunetsu storm I'm too against the license raj. I opt for another form of market system. But yes, take your time and debunk the rhetorics of neo-liberal economy.
Here's a link where you may visit for a look. I found the data in the issues to be very authentic.
www.rupe-india.org/44/note.html
@bakunetsu storm do a bit of research on the condition of famers in the United States
Guys, you're doing great work but please make the content more accessible and have closed captions for those who are hard of hearing. Just a thought. Thanks.
Clearly presented arguments from both sides. However, the last point that our government can (in fact regularly does) limit free market operations in agriculture by banning imports and exports at the expense of Indian farmers should not be held against this particular bill. The fact exists independent of this bill. We can only hope that the tendency will reduce gradually as it only hurts our agriculture industry.
The very fact PM assured that MSP will continue and the bills are for farmers welfare is reason enough to oppose it. We have dozens of examples what happens when he promise Achche Din!
Thank you Meghnad
This was informative as well as entertaining.
Wrong on few aspects. For example: Price Discovery will still happen
A few questions.....
1. Why only wheat and paddy crop recieves MSP ??
2. Why Punjab and Haryana APMC have the highest cess of 8.5%??
3. Why having APMC since 1965 still ensures only 6% of farmers are getting MSP??
4. Why can't we promote better FPO/FPC to empower farmer to make better deals rather than always saying that a farmer can't negotiate ???
Finest and fairest exposition/explanation of the Farm Bills ever on digital and electronic media. Congratulation. इतनी अच्छी समाज पब्लिक को देंगे तो Digital Media Regulatory Bill आयेगा ही ना। बेचारी कंगना और अरनव के पेट पे लात मार रहे हो?!
They always do things that are good in "Theory" but "Implementation me phat jaati h
Dis govrmnt is way too good in givings things dat nobody ever asked for,
Notebandi,
Triple talaq,
Adhar ,
Gst reform,
370,
Caa,nrc
Minus gdp,
Labour reforms,
Still dey will serve u
With the exception of notebandi and minus gdp?? (whatever that is) everything else you've mentioned were things (most) people wanted..
Just cause you don't want something doesn't automatically mean everybody else doesn't want it either..lol..
Living in a fools paradise......
Finally.. An ad on this channel to watch without skipping... 💛
Correction the APMC in different states is regulated by the respective SARKAR of that PARTICULAR states. One of the major concerns of the farmers was the fear of losing land to the BIG GIANTS which was not discussed in the video, which in turn is just fear with no grounds since THE CONTRACT FARMING AS TOLD IN THE BILLS AND IN THIS VIDEO will ONLY be done ON THE PRODUCE and IT MUST NOT INCLUDE BINDING OF ANY KIND on THE LAND of the farmer. I completely agree that these reforms seem to be a bit Theoretical-Revolution, but the need of the hour is to plug the loopholes which are giving the farmers GENUINE concerns not FORCE the COMPLETE WITHDRAWAL OF THESE BILLS. I would not like to talk about HOW THE BILLS were passed tho.
I loved it when u said the 3rd bill is still pending till I record & the date of recording was displayed on the side.
Nice!
This is basically the American way of doing things... Free market looks only good on paper
U mean to say that you would not like an economy like America?!lol
doesn't socialism sound the best of paper ?About free markets, you wouldn't be saying that pre 1991 when India was a closed economy. Capitalism has it's evil but it works better than any other model. We just need to ensure the integrity tax distribution to curb capitalist exploitation. Free market + a progressive tax distribution system works. A socialist economy will fail always.
@Wargolldur Deva I believe this is due to the dominance of large "factory" farms, as well as GMOs, and high pesticide usage. The quantity may be up, but in a number of cases quality, taste, and nutritional value are down. Also, many small farmers have been hurting (trump sold them a bill of goods, nothing improved for them). If there's anything in those bills which would allow corporations to take over farms or exert control over farmers, then I say protest, protest, protest!
@@ishan9220 oh boy...I only have faint memories of those days. No telephones, even landlines...you had to wait years after 'booking' one, same with water connection, electricity. Only Doordarshan ( but here I have to say that programmes were of moderately better standards than sas bahu bs and bodybuilder/supermodel mythological ghisi piti serials of today) on TV. Long lines in front of ration shops. No transparency of information, every news provided by the government. Ah! The nostalgia!😊
Let me put this first. I'm not A bhakth. Now, the guy says more time should have been given to discuss this at length. The answer is going to be NO, because this reform has been pending since independence. Don't know what is new going to be found now after all these years
Dear Sir: Agreed that Punjab and Haryana farmers are doing well and they want the current STATUS QUO to continue. But there are other farmers in the rest of INDIA who want to scale up and do something. For example, KERALA FARMERS are all ready to scale up on JACK FRUIT POWDER and are making arrangements for cold storage system which will be made available through FPO (farmer producer organizations). Like this there are many many examples. If Punjab and Haryana are happy with STATUS QUO then so be it.
Very informative with a generous amount of sarcasm ! Ouch Modi ji ouchh
Best explaination.
Bt the media is busy with news of Kangna - Rhea - Urmila..etc....
Such a historic decision of market control , make petroleum price hike in India while price law in international market
At least, to strike a compromise, Govt. need to have a seperate agency to act as a business resource center for the farmers in each state that they can go to; to give them business guidance, teach them business & negotiating skills etc.
Without that, it's like throwing them out of the ship and they're saying, they don't even know how to swim. Govt. They are the backbone of Indian society, Govt. needs to have understanding, empathy & compromise
दो f.i.r. होने के बाद संसद में फूट-फूट कर रोने लगे थे ''योगी आदित्यनाथ ''
13 f.i.r. होने के बाद भी जनता की आवाज बनकर सीना चौड़ा करके खड़े हैं यूपी के शेर ''संजय सिंह Ji ''
🤣🤣🤣 . Vo phir tum log hamko Bakt kahte ho.🤦
Meghnad is my favourite ❤️
TATA is Investing in BigBasket . So They can Make Farmers rich, selling their Produce (Products) abroad.
From this video to your analysis in the dumb questions to farmers video, your growth in understanding this topic is historic.
Hay news laundry,
Actually, you missed some point on
For example,
1.the future and options
Let consider reliance (remember jio bulldozer marketing tactics) company buy all future rice bags at a fair price from farmers in India 🇮🇳 , which is not yet to seeded. Which create artificial scarcity in future using it he keep higher prices than MSP which led to chaos in buyer and where let to a shortage in government state-run reaction stores poor people can't eat their meals.
2.There will lose the small and micro scales farmers in India.
MSP was not only supported price but also it gives money for buying small things like agriculture equipment and fertilizer keep running. Where private companies never keep on their minds because their holy grail is profit.
Which will not support their likelihood hence they turn over the city for there survival. Let to losses in small and microscale farmers and huge migration towards to city and jobs loss.
@subhadeep mandal
Will I mentioned it jio marketing campaign
Was just waiting for your video on this topic 🔥🙏
This bill will empowerment for farmers of India.
Actually i guess you didn't searched enough for this thing, i mean this subject is complicated but just to explain it simply doesn't mean providing wrong or half information.
Where is he wrong? Point it out.
@@71espn
» Farmers still have a choice to sell their cultivation in open markets rather than APMC infact majority of farmers sell their cultivation in open markets because the APMCs are far from their reach and the transportation cost is high, they can't afford. There are other factors as well for selling their crops in open market.
»Middle man, 6 of my known ones are Middle men here. Out of these 6, 2 are Licensed and 4 operate in open market. For 2, it's like govt. job, not much income but secured. Rest 4 are earning more than any of the licensed middle men trust me they are making the dow(pun intended). Farmers sell more in open markets and these middle men rip them off cause of no MSP law there.
» Farmers are demanding to abolish the new bill because it will give more benefits to open market middle men(who are already ripping off the farmers) and the farmers will still go empty hands.
»Now coming to corruption in APMCs, remember 2 of my relatives, yeah they don't have clean hands as well. Majority of farmers don't know about MSP standards and how it is calculated, the middle men provide them with enough money in hand in the starting but then they exploit them by the help of outsiders in the name of Money Landers for expanding their fields, Urea and other fertilizer providers who sell coal at the price of diamond. Farmers have no choice but sell their crops in open markets from next time and 6 of my known ones are already waiting for them out there.
» Farmers who understand these webs and are ready get out of it can't just come out because when they come to know about it they are already too late and trapped drastically, here govt. subsidiary system helps them but the amount of debt, their living expenses, education expenses for their children leads them to a tree and rope and you know what happens then....
Thank you for doing so much of research and simplifying and explaining it us.
Kangana kanagana kangana . . . . . . . . BJP is waiting for you.
Kangana should join BJP... the only person who can dismantle anything.
Kangana abh kisi ke saath TAN KI BAATH KAR RAHI HAI
So Supreme court is also A bjp agent
High court tooo
international monetary fund too
US president Joe Biden to
Centrist and Intellectuals Too
They all supported farm bil
Talked neutrally
Not exaggerated flaws
And arrived to conclusions
People like you are virus for the nation
For Misleading others
People from maharashtra still not aware that this is implemented in Maharashtra since 2016 no news channels shown this news at that time.and that's why there is no protest against the bill in Maharashtra ☹️
ताकि किसान और आम आदमी उसको और अच्छी तरीके से समझ सके आपका चैनल बहुत अच्छा है प्लीज प्लीज इस बात को समझिए हमारे देश में जिन्हें आप को समझाना जिन जिन की आप बात कर रहे हैं उनमें बहुत से लोग हिंदी जानते हैं और बहुत कम लोग या 10 परसेंट भी नहीं होंगे जो इन इंग्लिश जानते हैं तो कृपया है हिंदी में बताएं
According to bakths, *"70 SAAL MEIN KUCH NAHI HUA"*
BUT
✓ Even before Modi was born, India had prepared the world's best Constitution and started its implementation from January 26, 1950.
✓ When Modi was just six months old, India had hosted the first Asian Games in New Delhi and Jawaharlal Nehru introduced India's first five-year plan.
✓ Before he turned one, the IIT Kharagpur was established in 1951.
✓ When Modi turned two, India held its first general elections in 1952.
✓ Before Modi celebrated his 4th birthday, India created the Atomic Energy Establishment, Trombay (AEET). It was later renamed as Bhabha Atomic Research Centre.
✓ When Modi was just 11 years old, Indian Army liberated Goa and French-ruled Pondicherry , became part of India as a Union Territory.
✓ By 1961, India had established 2 IIMs and five IITs.
✓ By the time Modi turned 13 years, India had built Bhakra Dam ,Himachal Pradesh.
✓ Modi was just 14-year-old when Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) was formed.
✓ When Modi was about 15 years old, India's had fought and won the second war with Pakistan in 1965.
✓ When modi was learning to ride bicycle, india had already started manufacturing aeroplanes and helicopters.
✓ When Modi was about 17 years old, the foundation of the Green Revolution was laid and farmers harvested the first crop of high-yielding wheat.
✓ When Modi was 19-year-old in 1969, ISRO was founded, nationalized 14 banks,Tarapur Atomic Power Station became operational.
✓ When Modi turned 21 in 1971, India was fighting its third war with Pakistan.
✓ When he was only 24, India conducted peaceful nuclear test at Pokhran in 1974.
✓ Long before Modi became the Prime Minister, India had already taken the initiatives for Chandrayan, Mangalyan, GSLV, Mono Rail, Nuclear Sub-Marine, Agni Missile, Chetak, MIG, Arjun Tank, Sukhoi, Dhanush, etc.
Therefore, India WAS a powerful nation with a robust economy before modi gov.
During the last 70 years India has grown tremendously and all ex prime ministers have taken brilliant decisions due to which india is now one among the biggest powers in asia .
Modi and his bhakts would not have raised the question '70 Saal Mein Kuch Nahi Hua' if they would have read history.
You forgot about 1962 debacle with China, that happened because of Impractical, unrealistic policy of "hindi cheeni bhai bhai " . Even after annexation of Tibet ,India did not prepare for possible confrontation with China . Nehru ji was a Hyper pacifict who did not not believe in defence preparedness .
Also Why did we have to fight thrice with Pakistan ? That is because during 1947 half of Jand K was left with Pakistan despite India winning in 1947 war .
If every thing was so nice ,why did Indian economy hit rock bottom in 1990 ?
Kindly read about licence permit raaj .
How can you forget militancy in Punjab , Indira Gandhi 's support to Bhinderawala ,1984 anti sikh riots , Terrorism in Jand K ,Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus ?
Ofcourse godd initiatives were also taken but these blunders cannot be ignored .
Lal Bahadur Shastri , P V narasimha rao were the best PM that India had .
Now try writing down the blunders done by governments in those 70 years. I can promise you, that list will be 10 times bigger than which you just mentioned above.
Presentation could have been made in a less frivolous way.
Yeah true.. felt something exceeding the limits..
Once I went to my local sabzi market and saw a famer selling vegetables, he was selling freshest and greenest vegetables, and at lowest prices, and that did tasted better when cooked. In future I would love to buy from farmers directly.
I come from an India where supposedly educated ppl celebrate repeal of laws that would've liberalized farming economy, enabled farmers to sell anywhere, reduced food prices.
We need more of this
Please release this in hindi, as most of the farmers do not understand english.🙏
Most of farmers knows their stand.
Farmers are already very informative it's us who are lacking
@@bhardwajparth 👍👍👍
Its tragedy for small farmer
dairy industry in india has ben privatised , so far there is no monopoly
the law says MSP won't be removed.
private players do not mean just huge corporates , it also includes start ups , individual investors , etc , it is a spectrum.
these laws were necessary for india's agricultural sector.
only 6% farmers in india enjoy MSP.
the excess food bought by food corporation of india from farmers gets stored and when food corporation of india runs out of spaces to store it just gets dumped . Pvt players will have more resources to manage , store , these products , even export .One of the three laws will educate the farmers about new and modern techniques and different variety of crops .
Where ever open market has been formed , the ones who are willing to provide better services have gained more profits .
Even the farmers can join and form cooporatives .
Next prime minister ambani
Why chowkidar working for him 18 hours
It's 24 hours sir
Ambani is pm of India currently. Modi is just fake pm
That's funny but ...what if he WAS the PM?
So, in short it is good for farmers .
Guarantee minimal prices should be remaining.
But farmers should be also free selling to anyone they want.
Also huge thing is not able to sue companies for not paying the farmers. All liability is written out of the bill. This is what killed sugarcane and other farming practices in punjab. Only rice and wheat now since they have msp and farmers dont get exploited by the companies that have prime minister in there pocket.
One of the simplest and the best explanations I heard so far with all the satire and humor. Thanks. 😁
Brother today i watched u for first time, and i have became your fan. Such a beautiful way of explaning such critical stuff
Licensed middlemen are such saints! They have always worked and nothing but for the welfare of the ppl. They have never arm twisted farmers to anything. We don't need no reforms. Also, this reform has been discussed and in contention for more than 10 years. Should have atleast been discussed 10 more years before its implementation.
For those who say newslaundry does propaganda against government should watch how meghnath also highlighted the positive points
Not a BJP supporter at all but I feel this reform is good.
So your "feeling" would decide the future of crores of farmers?
@@IamRanJos can you explain why these bills are bad?
@@alaapsarkar It will most likely create a monopsony in the market where the buyers are very few (MNCs and huge companies). This will force farmers to lower their prices in order to sell their crops to the buyers available. This is what Meghnad means by exploitation as when there are only few buyers and thousands of sellers prices might go too low for the agricultural practice to be sustainable. The middlemen was made in order to prevent this type of exploitation but bureaucracy without transparency made APMCs into a sort of exploiter too. In order for this bill to be successful, govt has to ensure there are number of buyers available to sell these produces to. This way farmers can sell their produce at a fair price as they aren't force to sell to a select few. How can they do this? Mujhe nahi patha yaar main to economist expert nahi hoon thoda padha hua hoon.
@@alaapsarkar If I have to venture however, they have to put a limit on mass hoarding on very huge MNCs (like the JioMart which will be coming soon) this way they cannot form a huge stake of the buyer's market and create the monopsony that I had mentioned in my previous comment. They need to regulate this aspect or else we'll become like the agricultural practices of African countries where liberalisation has led to food security issues(Case study of Senegal and comapnies forcing farmers to grow cashew nuts [I don't remember correctly if that is the crop] ).
@@harshithh.s.7513 Regarding your 1st point there is already a monopsony which are the authorised mandi traders. This bill doesn't remove anything, mandis are still there, government can still buy at MSP and now the farmer can also sell their produce in other markets. This bill breaks monopsony.
Before this bill the farmer could only sell their produce to their allotted mandi now they can sell at mandis or to anyone else. If they don't get a fair price from the open market they can go to the mandi and sell at MSP, that option is still there.
I need to look up on your second point.
When they say #Historic..
For me it sounds like #Disaster
And no one needs to understand #farmbill, if farmers say NO , it should be and it should remain as NO
@Krishnan Unni Madathil there are the farmers who saying no and there are some complete villages who are fighting against it
@Krishnan Unni Madathil I had never involved in misinformation....this is what I liked and this is what I support...I agree there are some +ves in the bill but at the same time there are some negatives too...
My opinion is gov should clarify the doubts of farmers and pass the bill with complete transparency
@Krishnan Unni Madathil and I'm not taking about anyone else except farmers 👍😀
Nothing good ever came out of a sentence that started with, "And no one needs to understand." Not all farmers are protesting. My family is farmers and they're pretty okay with it.
"No one needs to understand"
You are suggesting people should stop applying their minds and protest/support something without even understanding it. If lazyness was measured in metres, yours my friend would be taller than Burj Khalifa
More than half of the states in country don’t have APMCs/ or have already passed Bill to sell outside of APMCs anyways.
If APMCs and MSPs are here to stay and the new Bill is providing additional option, I’m failing to still understand what the problem is. ? What am i missing. Farmers can continue to seek in APMCs - what’s the challenge.
I know, it’s a a question from partial information most of the citizens have. Just trying to get the macro picture
If they had to set up a select committee to review the bills, the time limit of 6 months for an ordinance to be passed in the parliament would have expired, thereby lapsing the bill.
How old is this guy, I am totally confused 😕
Under 30 I strongly believe
हॅहॅ
29 to be precise !
@@adamkane8305 make it trending how old is Magnad as binod
@@ravees1611 but what about those whitened head
Anchor is nuts. Excellent presentation...
But he is telling truth....
Farmers across the country =
Bunch of farmers of punjab and haryana.
Why is CZcams showing ads with newslaundry videos
"THE EMINENT INTELLECTUAL" 🤣🤣
Very well explained,
I know farmers are concerned but instead of demanding to repeal the whole act but specific amendments should be carried out which is denied by farm leaders.Therefore farm leaders need to be more sensitive to this issue.
Glad u were not biased on your take.. we just need unbiased news in these times. If there is proper regulation of this with farmers not being taken advantage of then I tnk the farmers will be hugely benefitted by this bill.
Says "They will do it to teach a particular country a lesson" and coughs 😂 epic
it's a stale style of joke - perhaps epicly new to your ears!
is it just me ? or his voice is actually very similar to Saiman Says?..🤔🧐
Both of them are marathis so ig that explains.
This needs more views. Couldn't ask for any better explanation weighing both pros and cons
Liberals would never support communism, or any other authoritarian regime. So not sure what you have put those two together. As a liberal I have to agree that the goal the government is pursuing is good the reforms will harm allot of people who rely on farming. The underlying idea is that small scale farming is unsustainable, as they will not be able to compete with big farms "corporations". The government want's to quickly reform the farming sector with disregard to what will happen to farmers. In my opinion the government should create a government farming fund that would issue out loans and grants to farmers for land acquisition and modernization and give out additional subsidies to those farmers that would want to sell their land and offer them financial incentive to change profession. The government should also prevent land monopolization by judge corporations that want to enter or increase their hold on the farming market. If the reforms are done right, farms will become larger and more modernized and thus will be able to produce more produce that could be sold at cheaper prices. The farmer will earn more, the food will be cheaper. The government should not leave behind those that decide (or in a worst case scenario will be forced by the market) to sell their land. These people can start businesses that provide services for farmers. Poland went threw similar reforms and has done fairly well with it's farming market. The government in Poland has oversight over the farming industry as provides financial incentive (lower taxes, grants and low interest loans) to farmers.
Both extreme solutions will be damaging to people. The current system is unsustainable as small farmers produce very little and thus cannot compete on an open market without government subsidies. Even with the subsidies the farmers earn very little which doesn't allow them to invest in modernization. The liberalization of the farming industry will force many farmers out of business as big players will outperform and outcompete small farmers that will be forced to sell their land and figure out by themselves what they should do now. The latter solution wan't to quickly change the faming market no matter the human cost - Margaret Tatcher style. This will have quick beneficial results for the country but many farmers will be left to fend for themselves. Furthermore there is a risk that uncontrolled land acquisition fulled by corruption will create a handful of huge corporations that control and dominate the market, destroying even large independent farmers.
Reforms are necessary but they have to take into account Hunan lives that they will directly affect, and not only the big picture and macro data.
Good luck!