Jan 20 gives us cue to talk about Ajit Doval, RN Kao, Indian intelligence & spymaster, many unsung
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- As today marks the 77th birthday of NSA Ajit Doval & death anniversary of R.N. Kao, founder of RAW, Shekhar Gupta traces India's intelligence evolution and its unsung spymasters. Who were B. N. Mullik, R. N. Kao, Girish 'Gary' Saxena and the many unsung ones in episode 923 of #CutTheClutter
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Brought to you by @KiaInd
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Shekhar Gupta's 2016 column on Ajit Doval here: www.business-s...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read AK Verma's opinion here: www.thehindu.c...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Cut The Clutter episode 562 here: • Unfamiliar insights in...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s CZcams channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month.
czcams.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
oh0oy90p00p8y6
👉दाएं=हां,👈बाएं=ना,👇नीचे=धीरे धीरे,👆ऊपर=असंभव, ये नीच नेता, साहित्यकारों, धार्मिक पर्सन का गुप्त अघोर टोना काला जादू वाला इशारा होता है जिसका अंजान लोगों के ब्रेन पर नेगेटिव प्रभाव पड़ता है☠👢🕋🚩
India is India with its boundaries secured and systems to gain intelligence of enemies because of intellectuals like Kao, Naryanan and Ajit Doval. Salutes to brave sons of India!!! 🇮🇳.
Kerala Cadre made Indian intelligence what it is today
Breaking the stereotype that "smart people only wake up early", thanks Shekhar sir
Raw is really dumb tbh 😂 who sends marathi speaking kulbushan to baluchi speaking balochistan
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq bruh indians should stop boasting about Bangladesh, it was bound to go after how we treated it ! No country has won a two front war
@@hke.4475 Ask East Pak how dumb RAW is. Oops. East Pak doesn't exist any more.
@@hke.4475 Laughs in Lt Col Habib Zahir 😉
@@bb989ty3 lol yeah soon rest of pukistan will go.away too as it should. pukistan is a fake nation created by british
When I listen to Indian History in CTCs like this,I feel betrayed that my History books taught me nothing
I guess it's a good thing that the real spies and heroes preserving Indian securtiy remain unsung... Because then it becomes a testament to their undercover prowess, their determination to keep their objectives and methods little-known for as long as possible. If their identities and work were known by all in detail, even years after their retirement/death, it would certainly be a lesson to learn, to anticipate any future designs and nip them in the bud.
But these bravehearts also deserve our gratitude and respect, so I think having a national memorial for all the anonymous intelligence officers would be a better option for acknowledging their service to the nation, without jeopardizing their post-retirement lives and our future operations.
@@venkatvenkat7323 ISI is no. 1 (self proclaimed) intelligence agency in this world ,they don't care about secrecy because no one can match them
@@Crysizz well we all know how good raw is 😂 sending marathi kulbushan to baloch speaking balochistan
Kerala Cadre made Indian intelligence what it is today
@@hke.4475 yep that is why I said raw is nothing compared to ISI they are the best 👍
Some wag once opined that the only difference between the operation of a major
intelligence service HQ and the dominant newspaper of a great city is that only
one of them can manage to get out more than one copy by the hard deadline.
What an absolutely intriguing episode! Almost like reading a short spy novel. Fantastic research as always and a pleasure to watch.
Like Wet dreams not novels lols
@@khattakzindabad i
This episode deserves applause. These unsung heroes should be known to the people of India. It takes years of work and that too with life at risk. The strategy of having an NSA post as a different one altogether and making an operationally effective IPS/Military personnel rather than some bureaucrat to head it, is wonderful and utmost needed. This clear difference between now NDA and earlier UPA should be highlighted too.
It is the finest ever tribute paid to the true patriots of India,who risked their life with supreme sense of duty and sacrifice to protect the sovereignty of our motherland. In spite of all their dedication, they don't get the kind of attention,recognition and honor they richly deserve may perhaps be because (1) the very nature of their job is discreet and remains hidden, and demands secrecy. 2. Right from the time of Chanakya ( because spies were mentioned in 'Arthashastra' though the spying network might have existed much before him as an important apparatus to serve the King and the state), their job put them behind the veil of dark curtain,so people never knew about their presence or role unlike the military soldiers,who were more openly visible and the spies had no balladeers to sin g the tales of their sacrifice and heroic acts as in the case of military. The popular imagination is fed with stories of great warriors, but when it comes to spies, the historical time canvas is almost blank. 3. Perhaps because they are perceived more as bureaucrats and part of Govt aparatus, so honors and decorations are hard to come by.
Brilliant episode, as always.
Special thanks for taking the names of the unsung heroes.
@@sonu72049 Hey, Sonu. Not that I'm aware of. I mainly joined to support the channel.
I think they just give preference to your questions. And the CTC videos are available maybe an hour or so sooner.
Kerala Cadre made Indian intelligence what it is today
@@TheRishijoesanu How?
@@AkshatSharma1505 Did you watch the episode? Most intelligence officers that Shekhar Gupta is talking about including Ajit Doval are Malayalis. Keralites have a very large representation in navy, air force and intelligence, morr than any other state in India. In the early days IAF was called "India Nair Force" because every other pilot was a Nair/Malayali.
Anyone here after Karan Kundrra's tweet.
Dear SG, today you have exposed us to a new dimension of services that we had never truly appreciated for what they are. Thank you for the amongst the most brilliant and unique CTC.
Chinese didn't betrayed us we were the fool, Nehru was not Realistic his Panchsheel policy was dangerous act..
Why you commented bro . I also got payment to comment it from BJP IT Cellw
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq The fact that you are commenting at the comfort of your home is sufficient fact that Nehru didnt die in humiliation and was successful in bringing his visions of independent India into reality.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs Nehru according space to Tibetan government in exile was a diplomatic necessity. It brought the plight of the Tibetan to the global light. If anything it helped India to understand what was going around in Tibetan border. China didn't attack India because of Dalai Lama, China was already building the infrastructure in Southern Tibet and Aksai Chin from 1951-52. What made China Indian conflict inevitable was Zhou Enlai's visit and the way we reacted in 1960.
Instead of putting everything squarely as a failure (sweeping generalizations), we should look closely at the events individually and identify the immediate cause. In the case of 1962 humiliation, look around this visit, and the forward policy we adopted without adequate military buildup and deeper intelligence.
Nehru might have been a fool. But he's not here to blame, nor is he here to justify his circumstances. But there is an even greater fool and a coward in power today, right in front of our eyes. While china intrudes in Ladakh and builds camps in the NE, this cockroach and his govt is busy breeding internal hatred. He is not man enough to even have a press conf and interact with public, let alone answer for the diplomatic disaster he is overseeing.
Nehru was a fool. But his actions don't justify the Chinese aggression. Which BTW is still going on and India is not the only victim.
Here after karan kundrra recommendations 😦now I am addicted....
SG, Ajit Doval was actually under cover in Pakistan disguised as a Muslim for several years. He has himself narrated his story of being under cover and meeting a Hindu person there. Just search for it on CZcams and will find his video explaining his experience there.
His full of shit nobody other than india rates him he was a policeman lol he couldn't do anything to prevent ladakh intrusion which was instigated by ISI Chinese on record stated this SSG commandos helped Chinese troops and till this day chinese are making infrastructure in Indian territory he couldn't do anything when ISI ensured taliban take over Ghani government of afghnaistan he once said if paksitan does another Mumbai type attack he will ensure 1971 situation pak did pathankot and pulwama he couldn't do anything just like modi his a paper tiger
@@MohammedShafiq-id5ov bot
@@MohammedShafiq-id5ov Muslim
@@MohammedShafiq-id5ov surrender hijde army ke bacche 🤣🤣🤣
@@MohammedShafiq-id5ov POK local people are saying DOOSRA BANDA jo bhi tha usko pak army ne pakda 5.49 5.57 6.12 czcams.com/video/HppVMFR4ohI/video.html pakistanioyo dont forget to ask gafoora about DOOSRA BANDA 😂😂
Just watched this after kkundrra recommendation and this was interesting , learned things.
This is easily one of my favorite episodes!! Thank you sir!!
Never knew that George Orwell was also IIP officer..this ep is going to be one of my favourite
It's good to know about such personality who actually did something for the nation
they deserve to be acknowledged
Not to brag, but he was born in champaaran, bigar
Best spy is the one who goes unsung …. Just like wicket keeper in cricket… if nobody bothered about wicket keeper in cricket match means, he (or she) has done wonderful job
Its not always that history is ment to be changed
And to show that I will only say “ Ms Dhoni”
It’s about a situation and time and it changes
One of the best CTC in recent times; honouring the unsung heroes. 👍
Very good info about unsung heros of RAW & IB. Thank you Shekhar .. Nice video 👏👏🙂
SG, I usually don't appreciate your political biases however, with this episode, you have sort of redeemed yourself. Please put these stories for the next generation and pass on your excellent experience. Think of ways so that the next-gen doesn't ignore what you and your generation know.
he is still loyal to INC
Haha... 'Political biases'.. as if you are dereft of one.
@@sarthakpatra I am allowed and so are you dumbo! But he is a journalist, he is not.
@@raghavendramupparthy7950 💯
Haha. That's the best you can do? Grow up idiot. Don't be so dumb that you have to be called out one. How can you miss the point by so much. 😂
THANK YOU SHEKHARJI...!!!
Lots of unsung HEROES in our world... THEY ARE FAR BETTER HUMANS AND THEY SACRIFICED MORE FOR THE FAMILY , SOCIETY , NATION AND THE WHOLE WORLD , THAN THOSE PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN ELEVATED TO THE SAINTHOOD AND HAVE BEEN REVERED...!!!
KN RAO was class apart. The epitome of intelligence and a man of highest character
RN Kao.
It is very astonishing to see that Mr. Gupta forgot to mention about "Tiger" Ravindra Kaushik who was R&AW operative who by deception even rose to rank of commissioned officer ranks of the Pakistan armed forces but unfortunately his cover had been blown up & died in Pakistani prison. Then there is this person known as Sehmat Khan without whose input we wouldn't have had information about PNS Gazi was going to attack INS Vikrant just before 72 war!!!
Sehmat was shown in the film Raazi. Also watch the film Ghazi Attack which is one of the best submarine movies of all time. I thank RAW operatives who remain unseen and unheard.
Nice points of remembrance but perhaps the intent of this CTC wasn't to pay a memorial service to every one of those officers.
@@sainigagan5 But to me, this CTC is all about memorial service & achievements of all these undercover agents.
@@mikgsal1384 Already watched that nice movie...
Kk.. tweet ke bad Kaun Aaya..
Very refreshing to watch Sherkar Ji explain such intricate details of India's Intelligence Community.
an improportionally high number of malayalees seem involved in the indian intelligence business..
This is definetely one of the gem episode of shekhar sir!!
KARAN Kundrra ❤️
Thanks a lot to Shri Shekhar for remembering and highlighting the contribution of unsung hero's of Indian intelligence establishment.
Mr Arvind Dave mentioned at 24 minutes is living a retired life and is at udaipur.My salute to him for his work and contribution on the intelligence front
Brilliant! Shekhar, one really wishes you’d create a weekly show on pivotal events from the past. You have such a bhandaaaar of anecdotes and such a wonderful way of connecting dots. Please do consider. Superb episode, thank you ! 🙏🏽
Shekhar, Can you also talk about B. Raman in some occasion? Would be interesting to know of his contributions
What an amazing episode!! Like watching a documentary on Indian spy heroes!!
This episode made me watch few good spy movies all over again!!(Starting with Spy Game and Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy)!!!
Also if time persists will brush up on John Le Carre this weekend!!
Indian james bond kulbushan is with us
Wow what an episode, great stories of commitment and bravery shown for the nation. Great compilation SG and print. 🙏👏🏻
I am looking forward to the day when I meet Shekhar Gupta sir
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq kaha rehte hai address
Are bhai itna mat poocho public me😅
You will also be remembered for these kind of stories who nobody talks.. I like you these kind of content Mr Gupta... Well-done
Salute to those and all unsung hero's of this wonderful nation.
It is very important to remember such important figures in our Indian history! Thank you!
Thank you so much Shekhar Sir for sharing these stories of our great heroes and their great deeds. It’s unfortunate that we are so swamped with news around the politics and politicians but we hardly share/ hear any insights around our real heroes. Hope you would do some more episodes on them. Thanks
😅most of NSA is either keralites or from kerala cadre or both. Proud to be keralite! 🇮🇳👍
It is because the state cadre is shit this is the reason why they choose central deputation after working there for few years and after knowing how much kerala is full of anti national elements
@@Enchantedsqaure 😅 who hurted u? Seems a deep wound...
@@EldhoseJoseph its the truth. Kerala cadre is more influenced by communist party. The max no of islamic terrorists come from Kerala mc 😂
@@Enchantedsqaure opinion is not equal to truth. Lol! I know ur hurt. Hope u heal soon. And according to NIA, a bjp ruled Northern state tops terrorism. So wrong on that front also. Truth.. My foot...
😅anyways, not expecting sense from u either...
@@EldhoseJoseph it's a fact the max no of people who joined Isis are Keralite. Which northern state are you talking about I don't think it's a state anymore 😂
I can't imagine reading news as soon as I wake up after working for 12 hours in the news industry. Guptaji is a certified news junkie lmao
We Enjoy Your Outdoor Setting’s !
Greens behind You are very refreshing.
A minor hiccups of external noise’s makes it a very lively experience.
Loved this cut the clutter. So exciting with my early morning Darjeeling
Brilliant Mr. Shekhar Gupta..thank you for such deep and inside stories of our unsung heroes
Amazing piece from Shekharji and The Print. There is no other media channel that provides such well researched videos on wide ranging topics.
This show is very useful for me specially now before an exam.
One of the best and a very emotional episode of CTC. Most great spies go unknown is sad Truth we need to change in India
This is a good episode. After a long time, Mr. Gupta has really setup a good episode on India's intelligence stories
This is the reason why I still watch cut the clutter!
Yes Sir, It's really a pity that those who put their lives on line for the country are not given due credit...
Despite that we have people still taking these risks...real patriots I should say...
Shekharji you are among the few member of rare breed remain who still remained us old school journalism.Kudos for highlighting unsung hero of our country
#Ajitdoval is inspiration & best example set for our youths....Jai hind 🇮🇳🧘♂️🙏💪
Let's salute to Indian Lion unsung heroes who did best duty for nation. 🌹🌹🌹 Jai Hind
Another interesting fact, Former gov. Raghuram Rajan's father Govinda Rajan was one of the 'Kao'boys.
Really remarkable episode & came to know about real hero's 👌 👏 🙌 👍 Thanks Shekhar Sir 👏
It's episodes like these that make me a proud subscriber.
Shekhar ji… another gem from you sir. Goosebumps when you spoke about George Orwell. Can’t thank you enough for this…!!
What a wealth of greatness we have in these officers....my God thank you Mr Gupta i wonder which other journalist would even bother telling us about them....my salutations to these great people and to you too for sharing it with us .... so so enriching 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Diluted the subject by adding so many officers, would like to hear more about Mr. Ajit Doval.
A Gr8 tribute to our national heros
happy b'day to ajit doval. salute to R N Kao.
We the people of India will always be thankful for these unsung heroes of India. May our motherland be protected and safe from enemies
You can't say Ajit doval is bjp supporter ...I always heard this with lots of people...
Ajit doval is the person who work in every government whether it's is bjp or congress....
So many people try to defame him..just because bjp ... please grow up guy's
Because he work for this country not for any party ...
Just because bjp posted him higher level ...it's not like that ...
thank you Mr Shekhar guptha for a very informative coverage of our intelligence agencies.Hope some day their services to our nation will be duly recognized and acknowledged.
Wow what an episode of CTC Shekhar Ji. Salute to these heroes some remembered but many not who have sacrificed so much to keep our nation as one.
Thank you Shekhar, that was very informative and interesting. Stories of real heroes.
India MUST light a flame for unknown spies who worked for India and a memorial too.
Members only early access 👍👌
Everybody can see it now
Nehrus China policy proved to be a disaster. Such a pity. The reliance on China economically is now so pervasive and our skewed trade will bite India for a decade or more.
Thank You "ThePrint" and very much thanks to" Sir Shekhar Gupta". As my vocabulary is little weak I had a tough time understanding the meaning of words. Through, it gave me the felling of doing something for our country as we a knowledge citizen of India should utilise that knowledge for the betterment of India and our Globe as a whole.
(That's the felling I got & definitely I will utilise my knowledge for the betterment of India and the entire Globe as a whole.)
Thank You
This episode of cut the clutter is one of the best videos i have seen on the entire CZcams in the recent times. We would like to hear more about these incidents in detail in future episodes if possible. Thank you Sekhar ji.
I m always in awe of how you prepare and present... Just splendid, flawless and continuous rendition. Can't missout even for a second bcoz there's always so much of information flowing which is rarely, rather not at all available on any other channel.
Read the biography of RN Kao by Nitin Gokhale it was very insightful. I heard that Karan Johar purchased the rights to make a movie based on the book don't know what happened after that
Abdul Samad
Why ?
His Title in Indian mission in Pakistan was "Counsellor, Commerce & Trade", and there wasn't much commerce and trade with Pakistan back then.
\m/
I wanted to say
THANK YOU!! 🤗
Thanks to SG Sir for bringing out the stories of heroes behind the curtains. 👌👍
Woah!! Too much info for 1 CTC episode..I will definitely watch this if this becomes a 10 episodes or 12 episodes series.. very interesting!!
Doval the real Ratna (gem) of India!!!
Naming all those outstanding officers,you did a good job Shekhar ji. Thank you and salute to those heros whose works has never been highlighted. 🙏
It would've been fit to mention Mr Ravindra Kaushik as well, when it comes to operationally famous Intel officers!
One of the best CTC. Though it propped up more clutter than before and we want CTC on every incident and brave persons mentioned today especially Mukhtar Sheikh.
RN Kao, father of indian intelligence 🙏
I think this was one of the finest pieces in CTC. Thank you sir
We as a nation must strive to honour these unsung heroes who makes our country strong.
Hope this government after building the war memorial, will think about these heros 🙏
Oh my gooood George Orwell.... Shekar sir you amaze us every time
Would be really nice to know what newspaper websites Shekharji reads on everyday basis. Thanks in Advance 🙏
Thanks
Thank you for sharing these stories!! These are worth expanding into something like documentary series
Phenomenal episode. Great work SG sir. Only you can do an episode like this.
India should be told more about R.N. Kao. The Indian james bond, but silent version..
Man of that class will always be missed..
All who know what is going on this discipline have great respect for Ajit Doval in effectiveness and nationalism. However most experts in the discipline of spying mention that Kao was one of the greatest spy-masters ever. His caliber is recognized internationally. He rapidly made RAW into an organization of global respectability.
Shekhar Sir kindly make a story on Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and his possible 'after life' as Bhagwan ji
Thanks remembering the covert heros, one of the best episodes i have seen- thanks
Ajit Doval has spent 4-5 years in pakistan as an Indian spy. This will be very helpful to Modi in 'reversing partition'
What an incredible episode! Must watch!
Shekhar ji, please do an episode on the Devas media scam. Very cluttered and confusing 🙏🏻
Waiting for movie loosely based on Ajit Doval…Paresh Rawal we are looking to you :)
Must be added to the best of Cut The Clutter. Thanks SG sir
This is an extremely valuable episode for me... gave me a lot of information we usually don't have. Request you to please do another Cut the Clutter on IB. Also can we move the recordings indoor, there is just too much background noise.
Respected Sir, please please please do a special episode on "R N Kao India's first Spy" only. Was hoping to know more about Kao when started watching this video today but it wasn't about R N Kao.