MSR Whisperlite vs MSR Dragonfly

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
  • Brief description of how I rate the MSR Whisperlite and Dragonfly stoves

Komentáře • 39

  • @ryodeo1341
    @ryodeo1341 Před 3 lety +9

    You can simmer the old whisperlite, once it's hot and running well, shut it off. Depressurise your fuel can. Then pump only 3-5 pumps, relite your whisperlite which is now in simmer mode, occasionally add a pump when it gets too low, a bit more faff but good if you want a long simmer.

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety +1

      Hi Ryo, thanks for your comment. I no longer have the Whisperlite. I dare say there are various techniques for simmering but I find the Dragonfly much easier now. It’s a switch on and go unit 👍

    • @ryodeo1341
      @ryodeo1341 Před 2 lety

      @@RichDavey Thanks for the video comparison, like you I too have the Dragonfly (dragon roar as I call it) and I also perfer it overall. Another plus is you just have to wipe the soot off the spreader plate and it's all clean again (and the shaker jet is a bonus over the old whisperlite)

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety

      @@ryodeo1341 definitely Ryo. It’s an exceptional unit 👍😊

    • @impulsestar6431
      @impulsestar6431 Před 2 lety

      Can you do it with a new whisperlite universal as well?

    • @lorengrimes5293
      @lorengrimes5293 Před rokem

      @@impulsestar6431 yes

  • @justinalbright4434
    @justinalbright4434 Před 3 lety +10

    You pumped the international too many times. The trick to that is to only pump it like 10 to 15 times. No need to pump it after it is lit. That is the key to controlling it. The international shines on it easabilility to interchange parts and take it apart easily compared to the dragonfly

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety

      Hi Justin, thanks for your comment. I tried that but still found the dragonfly much easier to control. I no longer have the international now.

  • @MarcMallary
    @MarcMallary Před rokem +1

    The pot stand is not good for small pots on the Dragonfly.
    I put wire between the inner points to form a triangle.
    They could make it lighter.
    My gasoline jet is stuck, so I can't use the Diesel.

  • @outdoorsqc107
    @outdoorsqc107 Před 2 lety +1

    the metal tube of thesee stoves can be tweaked so that the fuel bottle is further away from any flame. it is safer this way ;)

  • @mikeecker146
    @mikeecker146 Před 2 lety +2

    I have both. Dragonfly is so loud but I do like it better.

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety

      Don’t get me wrong Mike they both are excellent but for controlling I prefer the Dragonfly 👍

  • @garethwilliams2173
    @garethwilliams2173 Před 2 lety +2

    A small bottle of meths to start the stove avoids those nasty sooty feathers that get everywhere.
    I’d like to see how the dragonfly manages with diesel. I tried it with the international but couldn’t get a flame at all (and used all my meths).
    Diesel is a horrible fuel but can be the only fuel available.

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety

      Yes indeed. I have tried that method Gareth.
      I have been put off using Diesel due to the smell. Petrol not perfect though either.
      I guess there may be an opportunity to use diesel sometime.
      Thanks for your comment

    • @gearhead-do1xh
      @gearhead-do1xh Před rokem

      I've got the Simmerlite and Dragonfly and I just use a napkin to wipe off the soot 🔥🏕️

  • @NunalSaPaa
    @NunalSaPaa Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you so much for this!

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety

      Your welcome Nunal. Hope this helps 👍😊

  • @iamrocketray
    @iamrocketray Před 2 lety +1

    Have Both, But the dragonfly is my go to stove, starts better and cleaner if you use meths.

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety

      Totally agree Ray.
      I will try meths 👍

    • @cawoodsob
      @cawoodsob Před 3 měsíci

      Interesting I use petrol exclusively on my Dragonfly, I find it cheaper and it lasts forever - how does the meths ‘last’ as a fuel source?

    • @ashab1
      @ashab1 Před 2 měsíci

      Meths is just for priming?

  • @adrenalinjunky3197
    @adrenalinjunky3197 Před 3 lety +1

    The controllability of the dragonfly is the deal winner for me. The ability to use the heat in various levels increases the usability of the stove and will also help with fuel saving. Fat boy from Bainton

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety +1

      Thanks for the comment Paul. It is indeed the controllability on the dragonfly that makes this stove versatile. The Whisperlite is in no way a loser. It excels in simplicity and speed in boiling water.

  • @drcoolit
    @drcoolit Před 2 lety

    the flame spreader mechanism on the Dragonfly is similar to other stoves that use these spreaders (such as Primus Omnifuel) yet they don't have this precise of a flame control. Do you have any idea why the Dragonfly excels in that department?

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety

      Not sure, but it’s certainly very controllable

    • @hfg4qhmg237
      @hfg4qhmg237 Před rokem +1

      Dragonfly is a 2-lever.
      The main valve on the tank side adjusts the fuel and the contol valve on the burner side adjusts the air.
      The whisperlite is 1 lever, so you can lower the air pressure to a low flame, but you can't raise the air pressure to a high to low flame.

    • @AquaTech225
      @AquaTech225 Před rokem

      @@hfg4qhmg237I don’t think it’s adjusting air. But more the valve on the pump is more crude shut off and the valve stove side is a much finer needle valve changing even smaller amounts of fuel flow prior to reaching the burner.
      It’s definitely not adding any air. That’s how you can make the stove if anything more dangerous. Depending on what’s ran in it.
      Fuels need heat an oxygen to burn. So it’s feeding liquid fuel to the stove. An before it leaves out of the jet. It’s heated because of the priming which is turning the liquid to a fuel vapor. Not a fuel an oxygen vapor. Just a fuel vapor. An at that moment the fuel vapor is missing right away with atmosphere and having the oxygen to burn.
      It’s just the matter of two valves more control in general. But the second one may be a finer needle cake making it’s control more sensitive than the more crude flow shutoff on the pump

  • @brentsmith5647
    @brentsmith5647 Před 2 lety

    Brilliant

  • @alanbrown7155
    @alanbrown7155 Před 3 lety

    Hello there. I'm thinking of getting one. Can I run this with diesel fuel. Thanks.

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety

      Hi Alan, great stove. Yes with the correct jet that comes with the stove it can be used with Diesel.

    • @alanbrown7155
      @alanbrown7155 Před 3 lety

      @@RichDavey Great thanks.

  • @Pao69614
    @Pao69614 Před 3 lety

    Can msr stove use fuel mix with alcohol?

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 3 lety

      Hi, it’s not recommended to burn alcohol in the MSR

  • @jayk3784
    @jayk3784 Před rokem

    저소음상향식 연소캡 잇써요

  • @joemama22
    @joemama22 Před 2 lety +5

    This dude is a rookie...

    • @RichDavey
      @RichDavey  Před 2 lety +3

      That’s true Robert. I am no expert that’s for certain

  • @277toby
    @277toby Před rokem +3

    Bro you have no idea what you’re doing ! Lol

    • @jamesf8864
      @jamesf8864 Před 10 měsíci +3

      How about you tell him (and everyone else watching and reading) what he's doing wrong, and how he can do it better?