$50 v $300 Running Shoes - Can You Buy FASTER Race Times?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
  • Could you take 5 minutes off of your Marathon time or 30 seconds from your 5km PB JUST by putting on better running shoes? Yes. I think you can. But I want to prove it...
    I tested 4 of the top brands "supershoes" against one of their middle of the range shoes that didn't have a carbon plate. Could I find anything that would tell me i'd be faster in the pricier shoe? Something to justify the purchase! I would say the results were pretty conclusive...
    Find Dustin on Instagram at @labratrundown
    Find Fordy at @FordyRuns
    Find Ben at @BenIsRunning
    Find Andy at @TheFODRunner
    Contact Us -
    Email - thismessyhappy@gmail.com
    Website - www.thismessyhappy.com
    Strava - Ben and Mary Bridges
    Insta - @thismessyhappy
    Patreon Coaching - www.patreon.com/Thismessyhapp...
    Facebook Page - This Messy Happy
    Facebook Group - 'This Messy Happy - Running and Triathlon'
    Fitness Freaks Podcast;
    Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/3enTvn2...
    Apple - podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast...
    All Others - anchor.fm/s/395c595c/podcast/rss
    Ben's Running Gear
    Watch - Garmin Forerunner 920XT - amzn.to/3goy0Bc
    Trainers - Asics Gel Nimbus - amzn.to/3hf7GuV
    Race Socks - Compressport - amzn.to/3kOczwY
    Training Socks - Balega - amzn.to/3kSlzkA
    Shorts - 2XU - amzn.to/2PZiK3e
    Hydration Vest - Ultimate Direction - amzn.to/3g19DcR
    Visor - Compressport - amzn.to/2Ecqyf2
    Mary's Running Gear
    Watch - Garmin Vivoactive 4S - amzn.to/2EczFgu
    Trainers - Ascis Gel Nimbus - amzn.to/2PTf3Mq
    Socks - Balega - amzn.to/30Yz6zm
    Shorts - Nike - amzn.to/2Y3N6pq
    Hydration Vest - Ultimate Direction - amzn.to/3h5b4Zc
    Strength & Conditioning Gear
    Home Pull-Up Bar (£25ish) - amzn.to/2Ys5vx1
    Weights Bench/Squat Rack (big money - mine was about £250 if that helps)
    Triggerpoint Grid Foam Roller (£25ish) - amzn.to/3i1jD8j
    Larger Pilates Band (£10ish) - amzn.to/2Ys9utt
    Power Bands (£12ish) - amzn.to/37VRXwO
    Renpho Percussion Massager (£35ish) - amzn.to/3fRI0Du
    Adjustable Dumbell Set (£60ish) - amzn.to/2VeFq2u
    Camera Equipment
    Vlog Camera - Canon M50 - amzn.to/3h5c0ga
    Sound - Rode Mic - amzn.to/3kREtZ9
    Joby Gorillapod - amzn.to/31WBF43
    GoPro Hero 8 Black - amzn.to/3aw819D
  • Sport

Komentáře • 148

  • @jodibeck
    @jodibeck Před rokem +88

    I find the main benefit is not in the actual speed of the super shoe but the fact that they don’t wreck your legs which means you can train more and the benefits flow through to better race times. So a 2-3% increase could actually be 5% due to the additional training leading to even faster times.

    • @bleachworksbrewingbwb7895
      @bleachworksbrewingbwb7895 Před rokem +6

      I'm really feeling the recovery times have improved since switching to the endorphin speeds I'm a total amateur but the investment has paid off alot even just for my leg health 😂

    • @MrKingamaziah
      @MrKingamaziah Před rokem +4

      Very true, the value of carbon plated super shoes ( I have way too many) is really about protecting your legs and not so much a magic carpet speed without any extra effort. I train in carbon plate and non-carbon plated shoes. They are not magic, but they do give me a less fatiguing run especially at tempo speeds. I find my long runs are more “entertaining “ as well ;)

    • @multechpro7151
      @multechpro7151 Před rokem +1

      exactly thats what i was gonna say too

  • @paoloruns
    @paoloruns Před rokem +16

    Great video, man.
    Probably the best way to go about getting to run in these supershoes is get the older version of them that usually goes on sale for $100. That way, you aren't breaking the bank and you get to experience what others paid $200-$300 for.

    • @tadejdanev5030
      @tadejdanev5030 Před rokem

      best way is to buy just at the moment new model is announced and on the corner, and like u said on sale. Got me NB 1080 V12 for 87€ :)

  • @tesserwithpaul
    @tesserwithpaul Před rokem

    This is my favorite video of yours to date. Worth watching to the end!!

  • @SeeChadRun
    @SeeChadRun Před rokem

    Love the analysis and the final thoughts!!! 100%! Great video Ben

  • @mark.betterliving
    @mark.betterliving Před rokem

    From the old videos to these, there is a lot more work, editing, and quality, and it shows, keep up the good work Ben!!

  • @11tobago
    @11tobago Před rokem +1

    Wow super interesting . Loved the video and editing is 💯 keep doing what your doing guys your on 🔥

  • @kaiwen2010
    @kaiwen2010 Před rokem +1

    Nice timing for the info Ben!
    Was trying to buy a good shoes for my new running adventure
    At least I know costly shoes will improve running performance

  • @timeonfeet
    @timeonfeet Před rokem +9

    Great insights Ben and really sensible conclusion too. I've never bought super shoes myself as I've always thought they can give such marginal gains that is only part of a bigger picture with many other factors like consistency and varied training but I would be intrigued to get some one day and see how much of a difference they could make.

  • @lindagrohmann3022
    @lindagrohmann3022 Před rokem +6

    Really interesting, great video! I'm not a very experienced runner and have two pairs of running shoes so far, none of them supershoes because I'm still in university and can't afford them at the moment. Still, your results confirm my experience to some extent - running feels so much more effortless in the Saucony Endorphin Speed 2's I bought discounted a short while ago than in the Brooks Cascadia 16 which are my first ever proper running shoes. Not that the Cascadia are bad or cheap (they were 140euros when I bought them new last year and I had to save up for them for quite a while). I find them more comfortable and stable, and they're also more of a trail shoe so not really made for road running, but I enjoy running more in the Saucony because they are much more bouncy. But then it also makes me feel like I'm cheating a bit - maybe that's just the negativity that sometimes gets me, or it's because I don't fully understand what people mean when they say "supershoes make you faster". Yes, they make you faster in the sense that you can run faster than in other shoes at the same effort, but do they also make you faster in the sense that they improve your running form long term and thereby help you become a better runner? If you're running more economically in supershoes, does that translate to better running form and thus faster running in any kind of shoe? I would hope that it does, that would make me feel better about how much I enjoy running in my Saucony shoes :D In the end, I guess whatever helps someone run more and safer is good, so I'll keep alternating between my two pairs like I do now and hope that it helps me both improve my form and speed and also keep my joints healthy. Thank you for the amazing content, love that you brought in so many other people and their opinions and expertise as well!

  • @lcpholman
    @lcpholman Před rokem +1

    Great video, and of I love how you (of course) bring everything back into perspective at the end. What I really want to know is, can I, as an overpronator who "requires" stability shoes, race in these super shoes (there don't appear to be any stability super shoes :) )? When I have my gait analysis done, it is always at a very slow pace, and my mechanics just aren't the same when running faster - foot strike goes further forward, reducing the degree of ankle/arch collapse. I can see that for the majority of training, I need stability - because that is done at an easy pace - but for races (and enough training runs to be confident them) ?

  • @Jack_Casey005
    @Jack_Casey005 Před rokem

    This video is an awesome concept, really enjoyed!

  • @JackD87
    @JackD87 Před rokem +1

    Great video. Would like to see the Vaporfly included in the next round of testing!

  • @warp9wb
    @warp9wb Před rokem +2

    Thanks for the video. Really enjoyed it. Been considering a supershoe for sometime now but I've always considered myself too slow (50min 10k) to justify spending money on a supershoe. Would be interested in a video to see if the performance benefits described in your video extend out to slower runners/paces as well.

  • @stickyrice.
    @stickyrice. Před rokem

    Love the ending message ❤

  • @chrisvanbuggenum871
    @chrisvanbuggenum871 Před rokem +1

    Nice effort mate! With cycling you can do tests like this and keep watts steady and get clear data, but with running its a lot harder to have steady effort and record the time saved or not saved.

  • @JaymeJay
    @JaymeJay Před rokem

    Thank you, been waiting for this video!! I wonder if you having a perceived effort prior to putting the shoes on also helped keep your heart rate down.

  • @jameschaves5723
    @jameschaves5723 Před rokem

    Ben this was an absolutely brilliant video! I really appreciate you saying that the shoes are a luxury and there are so many other things that one can do to improve their time.
    Proper training and nutrition alone can yield more than any super shoe.

  • @Aeronwor
    @Aeronwor Před rokem +1

    I really liked the take away at the end.

  • @stever1514
    @stever1514 Před rokem

    Brilliant Video. Counterpoint- Born to Run ch. 25. The studies are pretty old now and they're more about injury rate than speed, but it's some interesting alternative ideas.

  • @clairhardywynn5620
    @clairhardywynn5620 Před rokem +1

    Gr8 informative vid ….. I wear the Saucony Shift just because there soooo cushioned and bouncy (1st model more so than the 2nd! 🤔) I don’t think I can say if I run ‘better/faster’ in them than my previous guide iso as training varies so much its hard to say - I just love the way they feel and they make me happy 😃

  • @FordyRuns
    @FordyRuns Před rokem +4

    Great video as always and made better by those three handsome really smart lads from the UK 😎

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem

      Ha ha gotta love the UK run crew! Thanks so much for being a part of it, buddy. As I said to you, you absolutely NAILED the prediction 🤯

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem

      Ha ha gotta love the UK run crew! Thanks so much for being a part of it, buddy. As I said to you, you absolutely NAILED the prediction 🤯

  • @MrShanebizzle
    @MrShanebizzle Před rokem

    Love your channel

  • @CraigRowand
    @CraigRowand Před rokem +1

    Great video! I was wondering what all the short treadmill runs on Strava this week were in aid of 😄

    • @Mercury688
      @Mercury688 Před rokem +1

      I can’t tell you how excited I am that you mentioned they are on strava!

  • @genedollaway6466
    @genedollaway6466 Před rokem

    Well done!!

  • @50Something
    @50Something Před rokem +2

    Great video! I have both the Triumph and The Endorphin Speed! The Triumph have been relegated to lawn mowing duties, they are THAT bad compared to the Endorphin Speed. I run lots of hills and I'm 30 seconds faster per kilometer on a good day! The shoes make a huge difference to me. One other point, my hip pain magically disappeared with the Endorphins and resurfaces quickly with my other shoes. Spend the $50.00, you won't regret it!

  • @qcomberette
    @qcomberette Před rokem +1

    For me, above the speed of time is enjoyment. So I love, love the feel of running in the Endorphin Speed. It feels nimble, light and springy compared to when I run recovery in my NB 1080v11. I would love to try the Alphafly just to see how it feels.

  • @ep2653
    @ep2653 Před rokem +1

    Once again, great video 👍🏼👍🏼
    Just curious though, why no Brooks shoes in your collection?

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      Harder to get hold of in Thailand. Thanks though 😊

  • @jackwentrunning
    @jackwentrunning Před rokem

    Mate, cracking content as usual, how you enjoying Thailand a year or whatever after moving??

  • @Mercury688
    @Mercury688 Před rokem +5

    I love my Hoka trail shoes because they are so supportive for my ankles and knees while on the trail. They have been a game changer for me during my long runs. I’m probably not faster in them though lol

  • @mintcloud5026
    @mintcloud5026 Před rokem +29

    This was really interesting, and I really appreciate you mentioning the other ways you can improve at the end. I've always thought that the best way to achieve a BQ or another running goal is to improve your ability rather than bodge your way there with an expensive pair of shoes. And the big question for me is: are you cheating yourself with these shoes? For example, if I improved my marathon time by 4 mins through super shoes, I won't have actually improved my fitness or marathon ability by 4 mins, and that's what race times represent for me. I'd rather see a true improvement in regular shoes than feel like I've cheated my way to an arbitrary time with expensive shoes. Plus, £250 for a pair of shoes is ludicrous and it feels like a never ending game by the shoe companies that I don't want to support. Maybe that's just me :)

    • @aliasgharkhoyee9501
      @aliasgharkhoyee9501 Před 2 měsíci

      Definitely don't pay that kind of money for a set of shoes. However the previous versions of some of them may be similar enough and cost less than 100 quid often, in which case it could be worth it to be able to run more - as recovery is much quicker, leading to genuine fitness gains. Reduced stress on your legs and joints, hence faster recovery and increased training is a major benefit in the long term.

    • @andrewturner5706
      @andrewturner5706 Před 15 dny

      No it is not just you. Just enjoy your running.

  • @paulouellet4926
    @paulouellet4926 Před rokem +1

    I found the review extremely interesting. In the future it could be fun to compare the lightweight racing shoes (Streakfly, Takumi sen 8, Reebok Run fast pro,etc) vs the marathon racers to see if the weight advantage have the same result as the carbon plated racers on heart rate.😀

  • @davidh5429
    @davidh5429 Před rokem +4

    My main reason for training in Alphafly's is because even after 300k, they still feel better then any brand new cheap trainer. Feel way more fresh as well after every run.

  • @jackwentrunning
    @jackwentrunning Před rokem

    Any video with Ben, Fordy, FOD making an appearance is a belter

  • @gaiusvelleius
    @gaiusvelleius Před rokem +1

    a stryd pod would have been really nice to have for this kind of testing

  • @SamsaraRevolves
    @SamsaraRevolves Před rokem +4

    Great video! I'd love to see a similar comparison between barefoot/minimalist shoes and super shoes.

    • @growtocycle6992
      @growtocycle6992 Před rokem +1

      Gotta be very careful when regularly running very long distances to avoid injury
      Barefoot running had been proven to cause injuries

    • @danielberg8437
      @danielberg8437 Před rokem

      @@growtocycle6992 what proof? I run barefoot specifically to avoid the injury I was getting with cushioned high heel raised shoes that conditioned me to heel strike

  • @jkmorbo
    @jkmorbo Před rokem

    I love the bottom message of the video because it's so true.

  • @dugifreshh3753
    @dugifreshh3753 Před rokem +1

    I’ve tried so many different shoes/brands and nothing has compared to Vaporfly. They are something else! I waited ages to buy some thinking it was a myth but they knocked over 30 seconds off my 5k time straight away which amazed me as i was literally knocking like 2 seconds off now and again up until then. I’ve since gone over a minute faster and it’s obvious because I’m fitter too but mainly down to the Vaporfly. When I just train in my Pegasus i feel like i can’t get any speed up now!

  • @jos8192
    @jos8192 Před rokem

    Thank you very much. That was so interesting. I really appreciate that you compared within brands. I think a lot of us have a lot of brand/shoe loyalty and maybe only change when makers retire a shoe or b*gger up a shoe refresh. This took a lot of putting together by you. Go-kuro-sama! (as they say here in JP).

  • @jethalalstanaccount2129
    @jethalalstanaccount2129 Před rokem +1

    I ran my first 5k in a cheap Decathlon shoe ₹700( $10) . My legs were a complete wreck for a Week and I could barely walk after.
    Cut to this year when I ran a 12k race in the Invincible ZoomX ₹16595( $200). Absolutely no pain in my legs. Even after doing about 300k on my shoes in the last year, they've barely worn out and still look and feel very good

  • @TheBasssausage
    @TheBasssausage Před rokem +3

    After running for 5+ years my opinion is if you really want to get better times and you are putting the effort in is to choose the right races (flatter) and at the right time of year (cooler).

    • @andrewturner5706
      @andrewturner5706 Před 15 dny

      But if the shoes give you that mental lift to train a bit harder why not have the shoes as well?

  • @gjsnel8748
    @gjsnel8748 Před rokem

    A somewhat related question, hopefully you can help me! I have the Saucony Endorphin Pro 3. Great shoe, but relative to the Pro 2, I think the laces are a little short. Therefore, I am not fully comfortable with the shoe lacing, and rather replace it with a longer one. Do you have perhaps have any suggestion? I like the 'resistance' of the laces whereas laces in normal trainers can be somewhat smooth.

  • @RaoBlackWellizedArman

    Thank you again. Great video as alwyas!
    As a regular runner, I find the obsession with shoes, their hype and the marketting around that unpleasant if not disgusting!
    Yes, If I'm racing, I want the best shoes in terms of performance and speed. But if I'm training, I want something comfortable (cushioned), nice-looking and cheap. And believe me, there are tons and tons of those off-brand shoes that have all these qualities, some retailing for less than 15 bucks.
    Yes, I understand the obvious benefit that super shoes give the runners with all their bounciness off the ground, contact time, vertical oscillation etc, etc. But if you're training (to become healthier and stronger) none of this matters, does it?
    What puzzles me is the people who go on and on explaining how this shoe is very lightweight, for example, and then they wear them on hills on training sessions. If you're deliberately training on hills for their obvious benefits, then why do you worry so much about a few grams on your shoes? Isn't that self contradictory?
    At the end of the day though, I, too, understand it. You may wanna buy a shoe, just because it makes you feel better, or you just want that brand logo. I'm sometimes like that with other items as well. But please everyone, do not echo the voice of marketting departments of shoe companies and certainly do not be their mouthpeace!

  • @hammersmithbridge9115
    @hammersmithbridge9115 Před rokem +2

    I held sub 3 pace for 10 consecutive years from the age of 45 running running 12-13 marathons a year over 3 of those years. I always ran in Gel Kyano's or trail running shoes - in 2015 I stupidly bought two pairs of the Hyper Speed 6 that weigh 5 OZ's and to be fair were billled as middle distance shoes or for people weighing in as Mo Farah - they were billed for sub 2.45 type runners and a flat shoe but they felt really good and I thought I was on to something. I held sub three pace to mile 12 and the feed station before the turn to tower bridge when both hamstrings or whatever is in the back of your legs above your knees literally exploded without warning - like a grinding hault - the following day I had bruises the size of tennis balls on the back of both legs.

    • @John_Wood_
      @John_Wood_ Před rokem

      how many miles per week were you running during that time>?

  • @DenisPasek
    @DenisPasek Před rokem +4

    My personal experience is that I gain 15s per km in my Saucony Endorphins compared to the Saucony Ride or the Gel Nimbus, which is definitely the slowest shoe I use. This is for the easy pace somewhere between 5:30-6:00min/km. At my half marathon race pace of 4:40min/km it‘s 10s per km. So this is 3-4% more speed for me.
    I still train in the „slow shoes“ most of the time. Switching to super shoes for racing or time trials then gives this feeling of running way more easily, boosting confidence in reaching your goals.
    So I can totally support your findings. 👍

  • @mikefaber3567
    @mikefaber3567 Před rokem

    What you found makes sense. Even w the Hokas maybe the drop doesn't agree w your mechanics. But I take the middle of the road approach in that I wait out the next model and get the old version. I got endorphin pros for 100 on sale and Skechers speed freaks for 90 on sale. Probably won't work w Nike's but I'll make the rest of it up in training.

  • @reieli87
    @reieli87 Před rokem

    Im still confused how shoe rotation works. Maybe im overthinking it but do you select the shoe while you select the race and only train with that only pair? Enjoyed the content but i feel dont have experience grasp this topic yet. None the less is worth the watch and educational 🤓😊

  • @runningclueless
    @runningclueless Před rokem

    Would there still be a benefit in the vaporfly to a 6 hour marathoner or would a ‘sturdier shoe be more advised?‘

  • @ptlewis2000
    @ptlewis2000 Před rokem

    I would liked to have seen the other metrics. Over longer distances like a marathon, those will have a greater impact in my humble experience. As I found with my Zoom Fly 4 marathon experiment, despite the historical higher HR and perceived effort, the metrics were right, and by the end of the race I had the lowest average HR I've ever recorded for a marathon. Also a new Masters PB on a harder course. That's obviously a unique experience for my handicapped body. I should do the AlphaFly marathon experiment as well, even though there are some stability concerns. Now I have a respectable OTC insole on my flatest foot which helps with those other metrics, like Vertical and Ground Contact, specifically GCT Balance.

  • @pierce9128
    @pierce9128 Před rokem

    Hi Ben and Mary, question about runners. I used the brooks glycine 19 for easy run and for speed / race I used ascis gt1000. Recently I got the saucony endorphin speed 2 and now find the brooks feel like bricks when on long easy runs. What trainers would you recommend for easy runs thanks

  • @mplouse
    @mplouse Před rokem

    Love the Alphaflys but hate that they only last for 150-200 miles. I tried the Vaporflys and wasn't a fan. I ordered a pair of Gel Nimbus for daily training. I was happy to hear you ran marathons in them. I hope they work out for me.

    • @FatUglySadMan
      @FatUglySadMan Před 10 měsíci

      They really do last longer than 200 miles.

  • @bh4560
    @bh4560 Před rokem +1

    My first run in the alphaflys I accidentally got a 5k pb and thought I was running 50secs off my pace lol. They definitely work lol.

  • @raysollarsthehappyjogger5907

    My super shoe is my pair of ASICS Metaspeed Sky's. I have yet to use them in a race. I prefer my S/E Speed V1 's. The important question gets down to who you are as a runner and how important speed is vice comfort and stability. I'm 65, I opt for the latter.

  • @jjeniece
    @jjeniece Před rokem

    Interesting. I did a 5k in Pegasus yesterday and my legs were a little sore after. I’ll break out the endorphin pro 2 next time and see what happens.

  • @desangesquinous
    @desangesquinous Před rokem

    Nice review but I would have liked if you had noted a couple other factors. These shoes vary greatly in terms of weight and drop. Why were some shoes easier to wear? You'll find the ones that you rated the highest tended to be the lightest in weight and also have the least amount of drop. What are you paying for when you buy "super shoes"? The technology to make the shoe as light as possible is certainly a component. The choice to reduce the drop should not impact price, but likely does. If you could find a $5.00 shoe that weighs 6 oz or less and with 4mm or less drop and that fit the shape of your foot well, it would probably rate right up there with the high-priced shoes.

  • @jondalgas7201
    @jondalgas7201 Před rokem

    Must have taken a long time to make this video, thanks

  • @trimad6128
    @trimad6128 Před 6 měsíci

    Great video as usual but just wondering why you’re talking in $$?

  • @garyeales676
    @garyeales676 Před rokem

    which is the most comfortable list

  • @oldmandice2731
    @oldmandice2731 Před rokem +3

    I bought Asics Metaracer for a sprint tiathlon and it dropped my 5K time by 30 sec's straight out of the box. Felt like I was cheating. My current training shoe is a Brooks Launch 8 and when I switch to the Metaracer its like I have added springs to my feet.

  • @moytheboy22
    @moytheboy22 Před rokem

    Was this testing not based off power (watts) instead of HR?

  • @lessmith7906
    @lessmith7906 Před rokem

    Just out of curiosity, was there much difference in the weight of the shoes.

  • @mratran
    @mratran Před rokem

    Are super-shoes worth it for slower runners? I won't mind running my same "slow" paces with less effort, but, is the extra cost worth it?

  • @justthinking2241
    @justthinking2241 Před rokem

    Ben in a box 🤣

  • @joelmead
    @joelmead Před rokem

    I managed to find some Asics Metaracers used for £50. I have broken the 20 minute 5k in the Metaracers and my PB in the 10k. They are faster, lighter, and almost unfairly propulsive. You also have the mental boost of wearing carbon shoes. You already feel faster before you even start running. You just go faster. Doesn't mean you can't run great times in normal shoes. My Mach 4s are fantastic for racing and perform really well. However carbon is noticeable improvement.

  • @SamsaraRevolves
    @SamsaraRevolves Před rokem

    I've been wearing Vibram Five fingers for almost 15 years and tried 4 pairs of "super shoes" today. Holy crap. That's all I can say. I'll let you know how they fare after I try a pair on a long run.

  • @joerig96
    @joerig96 Před rokem +1

    ".... letting everybody hear you coming" because we all know that Next% really very noisy shoes 😂

  • @ReReChan
    @ReReChan Před 11 měsíci

    the shoes' names kinda reminds me of the brooms names in Harry Potter :D

  • @tyunboy
    @tyunboy Před rokem +2

    Super interesting video. Wondering if anyone can comment on whether or not it’s worth training in a regular shoe like the Peg and then switching to Alphaflys on race day. Or would it be better to train/race in Alphaflys only?

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +3

      I think the main limitation with training with shoes like the Alphafly is how quickly they perish in comparison to a shoe more suited for training. I tend to race only with Alphafly (sometimes the odd session) but I want to preserve them for as long as possible in races 😊

    • @dugifreshh3753
      @dugifreshh3753 Před rokem

      Train in pegs race in Vaporfly for me. In your case alphafly 👍🏻

  • @stevestarr9769
    @stevestarr9769 Před rokem

    I've always said, showbiz and shoebiz are only different by one letter. Until ZoomX and the plated shoes came along, I DON'T think shoes significantly changed or improved since the mid 90s (I started running in 1977.) But the Super Shoes I think HAVE made a real difference for racing. I also once said that if you gave EVERY runner a Nike Pegasus (or Brooks Ghost, or any very basic shoe) to train in, 95% of runners would be perfectly fine. Again, shoebiz and shoebiz are pretty closely related.

  • @scalyskincw210
    @scalyskincw210 Před rokem +1

    Mate, you've got an excellent collection of singlets - mind telling me where you get them from?

    • @scalyskincw210
      @scalyskincw210 Před rokem

      P.S. loved the video

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      Hi Charles! Thanks for the kind words. Loads of my vests are given out at races but some of the ones I’ve bought are from Nike, Run Through, Asics etc. all good 😊 👍🏻

  • @HS-fm9kv
    @HS-fm9kv Před rokem

    commenting on Adidas:
    Adidas Adizero Pro (plated) v Adidas Adizero Adios 6. Former seems to give better efficiency- as in marginally faster pace with marginally lower HR
    Same 16km hilly circuit saturday long run...
    Variable weather and night before....

  • @guillermovargas8564
    @guillermovargas8564 Před 8 měsíci

    What Nimbus did you use? 24 or 25? There is a big difference between the two. The 25 has a nice improvement over the 24 (your words, not mine! 😂)

  • @LWRC
    @LWRC Před rokem +1

    @10:05 Ave Kcals/Min for all the shoes are nominally within each other as there are other factors which would swing the results more than what the shoes would contribute!!! The variances are statiscally INSIGNIFICANT!!!

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem

      Woah! Why you shouting? 😂 it’s just a bit of fun and my findings 😊

  • @FatUglySadMan
    @FatUglySadMan Před rokem

    Love alpha fly use them for more than racing use them for lots of training, keep my old legs fresh.

  • @iiii2903
    @iiii2903 Před rokem

    It would have been easier and more accurate to make those tests with a powermeter foot pod (like a STryd)

  • @andrewturner5706
    @andrewturner5706 Před 15 dny

    In your summing up ,I think you overlooked the mental side of things. Once someone believes that the shoes are better than the older ones and that they will enable them to do more proper training, intervals etc. they have everything going for them. Add the fact that they will be spurred on by the ridiculous amount of money they have invested. Listen to any online coach on you tube and they will often contradict themselves in their first sentence so possibly the shoes will be a better way of investing that ridiculous amount of money.

  • @elkingdm1
    @elkingdm1 Před rokem +1

    Curious why you used the Saucony Speed instead of their Supershoe (Pro)?

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      Mainly because I don’t own the pro’s 😂 I did say that in the video though 😉😊

    • @SamsaraRevolves
      @SamsaraRevolves Před rokem

      I tried the speed and the pro today and the speed felt more like the Alphafly. It was only a 2 minute treadmill test, but the feeling was noticeable.

  • @celticstephenhill
    @celticstephenhill Před rokem +1

    Man I wish you would've tested the Alpha's lil brother the Vaporfly. Your testing distance was more of a 5k racer pace and the Vaporfly is lighter so many ppl think they'd be even better suited for this pace than the Alpha.
    If you ever do that alpha-vapor comparison, I'd LOVE to see your results.

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      Thanks dude. Already done! A few months back. It’s somewhere in all of the videos though 😊

    • @celticstephenhill
      @celticstephenhill Před rokem +1

      @@ThisMessyHappy I'm on it...thanks!

  • @ryanmiskin8925
    @ryanmiskin8925 Před rokem

    Not all heroes wear capes.

  • @rhinopaul
    @rhinopaul Před rokem

    Going slightly off topic. But as we are discussing gaining extra seconds/minutes in a marathon. It made me wonder, has anyone or is there a mapped fast route of say the London marathon. ie, which line of sight to take when running on the road to knock of time?

    • @fastinradfordable
      @fastinradfordable Před rokem

      Tangents

    • @iiii2903
      @iiii2903 Před rokem

      stay in the middle of the road, and in the inner part of the curves. That should do it.

  • @dawoudabdallah5121
    @dawoudabdallah5121 Před rokem

    Why there is no adidas shose???????????

  • @1dylanflowang
    @1dylanflowang Před rokem +1

    where is the result? i can’t find it in the description

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      I’m not going to put it in the description! Where is the incentive to watch the video? 😉😂

  • @jw2par
    @jw2par Před rokem

    Have you done a video of the running vest your wife wears at the end of this video ? Have you done a best running vest video?

  • @pierre-simonlaplace9496
    @pierre-simonlaplace9496 Před rokem +1

    1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, SIKTH, 7th...

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      No idea what this means but I enjoyed it anyway 😂

  • @garymanders1273
    @garymanders1273 Před rokem +1

    Marginal gains at best...lets remember these shoes are casts and aren't made for the individual generally, to get any meaningful measure is virtually impossible for the individual..i can see a greater advantage with these shoes towards the pyscology of running as in a placebo effect....you believe you can so you will...far bigger factors are your gait cycle. core strength aerobic fitness and your structural fitness..which i can only see being negatively affected long term by negating the effect to a certain extent of training and recovery and forcibly altering your gait using a shoe that has not been designed for you as an individual .personally not worth the cost to me...fairplay to those who think they are worth it

  • @roydos949
    @roydos949 Před rokem +2

    I cut around 2 minutes over the last four half marathons i ran, going from 1. 33 to 1.31 using Vaporfly`s. Add to the fact that i am 63 in month i shouldn`t due to age deterioation be getting faster!

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      When technology improves, and remains legal, take the gains 😂

    • @roydos949
      @roydos949 Před rokem +1

      @@ThisMessyHappy Hopefully the next iteration will take me under 1:30 :)

  • @igrand6473
    @igrand6473 Před rokem +2

    Did you have caffeine when you did test??

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem +1

      No. I have one caffeinated drink per day at 7am with breakfast. Same every single day 🤟🏼😊

  • @acasualviewer5861
    @acasualviewer5861 Před rokem

    I need to find some $50 shoes..

  • @cole6383
    @cole6383 Před rokem

    I'm here because my physio said I need a decent premium pair of shoes because of my recent knee injury.

  • @PhiyackYuh
    @PhiyackYuh Před rokem +1

    To simplify it for you guys, if you think the shoes will make you faster or slower then you are more likely will get that. Its the power of belief and placebo. Same analogy of buying all these gadgets, aero this and that marketing hype bs. Its your beliefs.

    • @ThisMessyHappy
      @ThisMessyHappy  Před rokem

      I agree to an extent. I’m a big believer in placebos. But there is also scientific evidence like vo2 testing etc. So I win either way 😊

    • @ptlewis2000
      @ptlewis2000 Před rokem

      I actually would respectfully disagree, at least in my recent experience. I feel faster in the super shoes and everyone told me I should. I took a chance and wore a non-super shoe because of the metrics, even though I felt I worked hard, and I ran faster in the non-super shoe that everyone loves to hate. So at least in my experience, the power of belief did not trump science. or is it math? Analytics? You know what I mean! LOL

  • @peterdeboer5773
    @peterdeboer5773 Před rokem

    Spending $300 for a good pair of shoes is nothing compared to the madness that is going on in cycling. Not long ago a bike of $1500 was considered a very good bike. Nowadays, people are happily spending over $4000 for a new bike. Magazines try to convince you that bikes of $1500 are for beginners.
    Running is a cheap sport anyway compared to many other sports. But I agree with the final words, it is more important to just have fun!

  • @fastinradfordable
    @fastinradfordable Před rokem

    I won my last HM with thrift store house shoes.
    Nothing felt better than crushing ppl in their next%

  • @bigdhav
    @bigdhav Před rokem

    Put one on each foot and you'll go in a giant circle. 😂

  • @ABucc
    @ABucc Před rokem

    I always run better in my super shoes than my daily trainers. Can't be a coincidence, I'm an average runner.

  • @JuanCastro6
    @JuanCastro6 Před rokem

    I think you should have tested them while running a mile. This would have allow you to see how fast you can run a mile on each shoe.

  • @alanrobinson2229
    @alanrobinson2229 Před rokem

    I think the psychology of running in perceived better/pricier shoes can effect heart rate and thus all your other conclusions.
    Like placebo
    Personally,my heart rate goes up at the thought of these disintegrating quickly at that price....lol

  • @michaelalbrecht3395
    @michaelalbrecht3395 Před rokem

    I paid 30 bucks for a pair of saguaro shoes on Amazon and guess what I don’t need to spend 200 plus on a pair of super shoes to run better or faster

  • @user-hq4se6ee5z
    @user-hq4se6ee5z Před 10 měsíci

    How do you clean your 👟 so well? Spill the secret.

  • @djking44151
    @djking44151 Před rokem

    So what you're saying is I should probably ditch my Amazon Basics shoes...

  • @danielwebb8402
    @danielwebb8402 Před rokem +1

    Still can't beat Dunlop greenflash

  • @johnferrera8804
    @johnferrera8804 Před rokem

    The only way you could do this test right would be if the person testing would not be able to see what shoe there wearing. Thats the only way to take out the plocebo effect

    • @iiii2903
      @iiii2903 Před rokem

      Don't look at your shoes when you run, or you will hit a pole...😂