Egypt Says No to Palestinian Refugees: Cairo Abdicating Responsibility? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 10. 2023
- Egypt Says No to Palestinian Refugees: Cairo Abdicating Responsibility? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Egypt in is talks to set up a humanitarian corridor and provide aid to Gaza. But Cairo doesn't want Palestinian refugees. It has kept the Rafah border crossing closed for the last few days while Gazans make their way south.
Does Egypt have a larger responsibility to Palestinians considering its deep historical ties? Palki Sharma tells you more.
Also read: www.firstpost.com/opinion/van...
---
Israel Hamas War | Egypt | Cairo | Gaza | Humanitarian Corridor | Palestinian Refugees | Rafah Border | Firstpost | World News | Latest News | Global News | International News | Trending News
#israelhamaswar #egypt #cairo #gaza #rafah #corridor #humanitarian #refugees #palestinian #firstpost #worldnews #latestnews #globalnews #internationalnews #trendingnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
We’re on the verge of reaching 3 million subscribers on CZcams! Are you part of our community yet? Join us!
Subscribe to Firstpost at www.youtube.com/@firstpost
I have been here since the beginning. So, proud the you continue to give true reporting.🎉
I always follow and appreciate but at times stopped during WION media days due to your anti American sarcasm, which of course your followers loved. Still can't figure out who on your writers team is so full of poison. Step in PM Modi and the New Jersey Mandir and Temple complex. USA has the last laugh. Pray for peace
Egypt solved their problems with blood in the streets and nobody said a word!! Now Israel wants to do the same and tarred and feathered? Do you HATE the ISRAELI ES that much world,I think so!!!😔
Jews Are Less Than 1% of the Human Population But 23% of the Noble Prizes That Benefit All of Humanity - Including 20 Jewish Women. ISRAEL Has 13 Nobel Prizes!
Fact 1.
Jews have been living in Israel for 5784 years.
The “5 BOOKS of MOSES” is a historical record.
Fact 2.
The HOLY KORAN states that the Holy Land, JERUSALEM, belongs to the Jewish nation of MOSES, the Israelites [Qur'an,"Night Journey," chapter 17:100-104]
Fact 3.
“Jerusalem” is mentioned 660x in the Hebrew Bible.
“Jerusalem” is mentioned 146x in the New Testament.
“Jerusalem” is mentioned ZEROx in the Koran.
When Arabs pray in Jerusalem, they turn their back to Jerusalem and face Mecca!
Fact 4.
ISRAEL supplies GAZA with food, water, electricity, fuel, medicine, and 18,000 jobs that earn 10X the amount that they earn in GAZA.
Fact 5.
HAMAS-JIHADISTS unleashed 8000+ rockets into Israel: 2008, 2009, 2012, 2012, 2014, 2021, and 2023.
Fact 6.
Arabs Nations started all the Arab-Israeli wars and lost all of the wars:
1948-49, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1982, 2006, and OCT 2023.
Fact 7.
1948: A Million Jews were EXILED from Arab Countries into THE STATE of ISRAEL.
I am the one that 3 million subs ❤❤❤❤ lot of wishes from CHANG NAGA TUENSANG NAGALAND NORTHEAST INDIA THUMAI
Muslim nations love to feign solidarity with Palestinians when it works in service of their animosity towards Israel. However, when it comes to actually helping Palestinians they are silent.
Yes we know they just want money and every fake show of solidarity with Palestine is laughable considering that Pakistan’s Zia Ul Haq was responsible for slaughtering 1000s of Palstininians.
Oh they do love old lady's wallet Egyptians
Yep
Well said
true... I thought the other day they were concerned with the Palestinians caught in this war... but when it's actually time to act on their "being concerned"... they say/do otherwise... they couldn't even let a few hundreds enter their borders..
Well done Poland for looking after your own people
Poland took extremely good care of refugees from their neighbor. Egypt... well, they suck.
I'm visiting Poland next week, cant wait.. the reason why im going to spend my money there, is because of what they did for Ukranians.. also, they put a ban on muslim refugees years ago... wish my country had a spine like Poland...
@@marksudlow5083 Poland was incredibly generous towards Ukraine, and (probably unexpectedly) it paid off in droves. By now they've already received more in income taxes from the jobs of refugees than all the money they gave to Ukraine. And I'm certain they will have Ukraine's gratitude for decades, and incredible respect from all of us from other countries.
Great idea about vacationing in Poland, I had not thought about it but I will have to put it on my vacation list. I know they have some amazing mountains if you like to go hiking.
@@marksudlow5083Poland gave 500k visas to Africana and Asians it was a big scandal that the former government lost the elections
@@nospamallowed4890And vacation revenue will help in its own way as mentioned. I had not thought about considering where your disposable income should go for a 'vacay' decision, and that is a good idea.
More media should be asking these questions instead of blaming Israel for a humanitarian crisis
Yeah no because it's very very clear that the western world doesn't care if Jews die they only care of the brown people died that's what their mindset is even though there's Arab Israelis who would and do fight for Israel and they're trying to tell you that this is ridiculous what you're suggesting they refuse to hear it
Exactly. I don’t understand why Egypt isn’t letting Palestinian’s in? There is a humanitarian crisis.
@@user-yh9yi4xi7i the obvious, practical reason, is that it would destabilize the country and too expensive for Egypt, that has been for over 10 years dependant on saudi & UAE money.
The moral reason is, why would it be for Egypt, to pay for Israel's bill ? if gazans go to Egypt, it's obvious they're not coming back, while Israel will annex the Gaza stripe. So ok, Israel takes the lands, ethnically cleanse it from its people, and it's to Egypt to deal with the mess ?
Plus, even if it's just projections, what happens if 2 millions of gazans are re-settled in tents camps in sinai ? Hamas reconstitutes there, Egypt sinks in chaos, Hamas starts again to launch rockets at Israel. And then, Israel pretext to self defense, to invade and annex Sinai, and seize control of the Suez Canal. The world officially condemns, in reality, it accept it, to keep the Suez canal operationnal.
GOOD FOR EGYPT ..THE UK SHOULD TAKE THE SAME STANCE???
"we won't let them in because we know EXACTLY what they are like" : Egypt
No, as an Egyptian we will not allow ethnic cleansing in favor of the zionist terrorists
I remember reading that a Polish or Hungarian politician directly say that Muslim countries should take in Muslim refugees and Christian countries should take in Christian refugees, but why aren't Muslim countries taking in Muslim refugees, because they know that they are far more radical than their own nationals, and you're telling us to take them in as refugees?.
Brotherhood indeed.
Why create the cesspool and blame others. Don't treat humans as animals. No body cares . Don't shift blame . There is ties with Britain and all her people and Israel so what's new .
Cos... the doctrine of the Muslim brotherhood is in the mind of the people in Palestinians. All these Arab countries have realised the days of oil is gone and are trying to advance. So inviting this ideology into your society will create wars.
But it was the West that caused the war, not these Muslim countries so u should be held responsible.
Most refugees are in Pakistan turkey and Bangladesh and still people have the audacity to ask Muslim countries while all this conflicts are created by west
It's like having poor relatives to whom you are willing to give a little money, but you will certainly never let them move in with you.
Egypt learned her lesson and is protecting their country. Jordan is the same
They are causing problems in Canada. One of them shot a gun into a Jewish school. We do not accept that in Canada. Not acceptable. No more Muslims in Canada.
In Jordan it’s black September riots between Palestinians and Jordan
Jordan has taken in many MANY Syrian refugees, and others. But right, not Palestine.
I do not blame Egypt because They have learnt history from Jordan. Jordan king was kind enough to offer shelters and food to Palestinians in 1970s but they paid back their gratitude with assassination plots to Jordan King.
Civil war in Lebanon?
I remember the palestinians killing christians!They cut the babies out of their moms,like they did in Israel!@@vanitajaipuria3663
The civil war!IREMEMDER!
So muslim don't trust muslim.
Porkistan killed their 25000 palestinians brothers in 1970 (black september) for money and now supporting palestinians 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Hypocrites they r!!
Always remember this pattern,
1) Conflict is always between islam vs other religions
2) Other islamic countries will not accept those affected muslims as their refugees, but they somehow sneak into non-islamic countries. (Russia, whole EU problem with refugees: France, Germany, Spain etc., India divided into 3+ countries, Iran was not an islamic state initially)
3) once they are into non-islamic countries, they create separate laws and try to break that country too.
Stay strong Israel 🇮🇱
T.R.U.E.
AND.. IF they could't find anyone to fight.. they will create war between themself.
That's bcos there's nothing peaceful about the outcomes of the practice of real Mohammedan Islamism. As Peaceful Co-existence was foreign to Mohammed so also it is to his followers millennia after.
Turkey is the country that welcomes the more refugees in the world, get your facts straight or shut up. From what I see all the conflicts in the world have on common factor : USA, Israel and Europe destroying everything for their own benefits or putting oil on fire in every continent, like in Mali, Lybia, Afghanistan, Ukrain, Liban, Palestin, Syria, North and South Korea, Taiwan...
Then pretend they own the country and have that feeling “The first ones” lol 😂
I guess Egypt doesn't want hamas in their country.
Well, obviously if returning Gaza to the Palestinians didn't bring peace in 2005, then returning to '67 borders won't, either.
You can’t blame Egypt. Why would any country allow terrorists or potential terrorists into their country. That’s just suicidal. Egypt can see it, but not others.
These are Palestinian people They lived in a country named Palestine. They are not terrorist If I come to your house & rob your belonging. If you retaliate, I call you robbers do you think it fair to you?
Yeaaah, you can't blame Egypt, you caaan't blame Hamas, you caaan't blame the Iranian regime, you caan't blame the Talibans, but for sure you can blame the Jews for the hypocrisy of these people? LOL
Majority of Palestinians are not terrorists and don't like who rules over them. I am American and don't like who rules over me. OBIDEN
European countries should learn from Egypt
@@walidhashim6340" Birds of the same feather flock together" same people voted for hamas as their leaders that means they belive in hamas and their ways.Egypt cannot trust them 100% They can turn Egypt to a war zone.Who wants war?
India:-Hindu vs Muslim
Israel:-Jews vs Muslim
Europe and America:-Christian vs Muslim
Myanmar:-Buddhist vs Muslim (Rohingya)
Bangladesh:-Hindu vs Muslim
Middle East Country:- shia Muslim vs sunni Muslim
Nigeria:-Christian vs Muslim
Pakistan:- Muslim vs Muslim
Pakistan:- Christian/Hindu vs Muslim
Afghanistan:- Muslim vs Muslim
Now
Nepal:- Hindu vs Muslim
And they say Islam is the most peaceful religion.😊
But Islam is spreading so quickly than your community 😂😂😂
Because you never read. You are by born Muslim too. So if you ignore your religion who cares. You are wrongly justified. You have only one EYE. Do not you see Big WAR currently Christian Russian Versus Christian Ukrainian. You stupid enough to see this? Do not you see China Buddhist killing Indian Hindu soldiers everyday! Do not you see that Indian Hindu Soldiers killing millions of Srilankas Hindu Soldiers in SriLanka??? Do not you see that Nepali Hindu killed by Indian Hindu???
Stupid do not have any knowledge!!!
Islam is the only true religion from God. If you really search for truth you can find it. If you have hatred you will never see because you close your eyes 👀!!!
Big WAR between Christian Russian and Christian Ukrainian Currently killing hundreds everyday you don’t see it. How stupid you are just Generalizing. Why you do not appreciate that all Hindus Indian work and feed their families from Middle Eastern Muslims countries??? Do you understand what the hell you are saying.
In USA all Indian Bangladeshi and Pakistani live together without any issues. If you come to USA Jewish and Christian would not give you any respect. Only Muslim Bangladeshi and Pakistani respect you. Stop spreading hatred!!!
This is a dumb take from this
@mohammedashif982 Because no one give birth like pigs. We have to raise our kids. Give good education. We don’t create jihad members.
Salman Rushdie is vindicated !
Egypt saw the result of letting Palestinians into Jordan and Lebanon and decided they wanted no part of it.
Everyone seems to forget/ignore so many things. Previously Palestinian civilians have a habit to incite civil instability and independence insurgences to destabilize the government of the country they are being harbored in (kuwait, Jordan, Lebanon, etc), which may be one of the reasons Egypt does not want too many of them in their borders.
True, not to let history repeat itself what really happened in Jordan, Lebanon, and Kuwait.
It seems Egypt is the only country that understands what happens when you have Open Borders and how it Drasticaly effects their society. A good lesson for Canada, USA, France, Sweden, etc. etc. etc.
AMEN!!
The Gazans are Egyptians and of Saudi their population they left behind in Gaza in 67. They took back Sinai but not their population.
Arab proxy war. That Iran has taken up.
You're obviously know nothing about what you are commenting on!! America/Babylon, gives those Arab countries billions every year to keep them quiet, for instance Egypt recieve 50 billion from America
The countries with the biggest pro Palestinians protests too.
I can tell you, that even some of us left-leaning Swedes, wanted better controls, on who got into our country. As well as, a better (more effective) integration system.
A snake knows another snake. That's why the border stays closed.
😂😂😂😂😂
😂
Hahahahahahahaha
🙏
😂😂😂
Arab nation states i.e. Saudi Arabia , Egypt 🇪🇬, Lebanon 🇱🇧, Libya 🇱🇾, Qatar 🇶🇦, UAE 🇦🇪 etc know full well what would happen if they allow enmass Palestinians into their subjective territories. This is exactly why these exact nations disallow them entrance. EU, USA & others have yet to learn.
You failed to mention that Egypt refused to retake control of the Gaza Strip as part of the Camp David accords, it didn't want the headache.
I think Egypt knows how unreasonable Hamas is & that importing people inculcated by Hamas terrorist education is destabilizing.
They want it to be Israel’s problem, not an Egyptian problem. Egypt has its own problem with terrorist & do not want to make it worse.
@@-IT. The only way to make it worse is to import terrorism to the UK & USA.
Egypt is not stupid
egypt knows they will turn against them. These people have been at war since the begining of history, they don't know anything else. Even when they are sheltered in peaceful tolerant countries that pay for their healthcare and housing.
Allowing Palestinians into Egypt alleviates their immediate plight, but hampers their cause. Should Egypt concede then any remaining Palestinians will be ushered out in similar fashion until none remain.
*Hamas took the bait.* Intelligence did _not_ fail. Some occupiers are deliberately being sacrificed in order to justify wiping out these remaining Palestinians. In 1948, a gang pursuing power-that did not lack shelter-drove inhabitants out of their homes and seized their property, having come from fine homes themselves that local residents could only dream of owning. With machine guns mounted on the back of jeeps they strafed the countryside. Without pity. Without remorse. Devoid of conscience. That was not evil?¹³ _Why can't these people that have been uprooted and whose lives have been shattered just lie down and die quietly instead of resisting their fate?_
¹³ The _Cremation Cult,_ a Satanic creed, replaced worship of God and is the _de facto_ official religion of the public service. Ignition without fuel resulting in perfect combustion leaving no residue of ashes and bone fragments. _That_ they cannot deny. Instead of the Holy Bible are volumes on this cult conviction. An invocation by occupiers caught up in this conflagration is never to God, it is always to the _Cremation Cult_ that pardons their presence on land that does not belong to them, in a classic bait and switch, having long ago discarded the pretense that their brazen theft of real estate was the outcome of a divinely ordained pledge.
³ The plan contrived by the British, approved by the UN, requiring Palestinians to relocate from their homes where their livelihoods had been established over countless generations was tantamount to a slow death sentence. Their means of earning a living was terminated and even if they had funds to make relocation possible, which most did not, they would have encountered resentment, overt hostility and violence in an effort to drive them back and would not have been able to recover from their ruin.
remember that this people are the same people who laugh and dance last saturday with the slogan happy october egypt know how dangerous people are they
Well, to be honest... Palestinian refugees haven't had the best track record when it comes to being a good guest... They tried to overthrow the Jordanian government (Black September) and were also a key driver of the Lebanese civil war. So... I mean.. I am not sure if that's one of the reasons but it definitely doesn't help.
If so, Egypt and the other arab countries should stop being hypocrites and let Israel do what they need to do without interference.
Ah, but that would assume honest behavior, and I don't think those countries even understand the concept.
Gazans are originally Egyptians. Read in Wikipedia.
The Egyptians are so selfish. Just Sinay itself is bigger than Israel. Egypt should take in the women and children. Or let them pass through to Africa.
Ms.Sharma, you are one of the few journalists I trust and watch. I appreciate your transparency and unbiased reports.
“You get the government you deserve,” is my message to everyone, including the Gazans. Fix your own country/state/whatever you want to call it. It isn’t Egypt’s fault. It isn’t Egypts responsibility to take the Gazans in.
Totally agree with Egypt when they say No to Palestinian Refugees. Palestinian people of Gaza put the Humas government in power so now it´s time for them to take responsibility for their judgement. The movement of millions of people/refugees put other countries in danger, stay home and clean up your mess.
Very well spoken 👏
exactly
Well said 👍
@@lazaropeedro8881 wrong, most in Gaza didn't vote for Hamas, last election was 15 years ago and more than half the population too young. Lies.
Liar, most people in Gaza too young to vote last time there was election 15+ years ago. Israel is murdering children with their ethnic cleansing and genocide the ruling ultra-right Likud has promised and is delivering, half the population is children.
Q. Why won't Egypt let in Gazans.
A. Because they don't want Hamas. They might bring problem to Egypt and overthrow their government eventually similar to what they did in Jordan.
2 millions refugees in Jordan
1 million in Syria Lebanon
Muslim countries help Palestinians but they also know Israel will NEVER let them return to their home.
Israel point of view is simple : we as Jews have nowhere else to go. You are not people of Palestine but just Arabs so why don't you relocate to a neighbor Arab country where you don't risk death. It sounds cynical but it's really how they think
@@Tryste I mean... If they just let them in Israel then they will just massacre Jews, what's the point in that ?
Also what they did when they were given refugee status in Lebanon. Lebanon was predominately a Christian country. Once the Palestinians built in numbers they started attacking Christians. Now it is controlled mostly by Hesbollah.
@@anthonypanepinto9685 ask a Lebanese before talking nonsense, the 3 religion live in peace and share power equally.
@@Trystedude the PLO of Palestine created the Lebanese civil war
They're smart🤷🏿♀️
EGYPT, YOU ARE REASONABLE, AS THE REAL WORLD OBSERVE YOU ARE REASONABLE FOR WHAT YOU ARE DOING. THE HAMAS INITIATE THE MOVES SO THAT IS THEIR PROBLEM...YOU HAVE A PEACFULL AND HAPPY COUNTRY SO YOU HAVE THE RIGHT SITUATION NOT TO BE INVOLVE AGAIN IN ANY STRUGGLE. CONGRATS...
Europeans 🇪🇺 should learn lessons from Egypt 🇪🇬...
Already too late..
Europe is done.
Canada too.
Their own brothers are not taking them, perhaps Iran should take them 😂 . Impossible 😂😂
Big comedy, carry on 😂😂😂
Yes sadly true 👍 brothers what kind a Muslim would do that
What a nonssense. Egypt and other muslim countries has not bombed and did not caused the humanitarian crisis. Would you clean up some else's mess on the street?
Pakistan - self proclaimed leader of the ummah (Muslim Brotherhood) has been oddly silent and mousy in disposition......not the usual RA RA ranting and shouting
@@ttemp2631 then don't stand there and cheer and talk s@#($&. Moving on, leave Israelis to do the cleanup job.
This is not abdication of responsibility. This is a very reasonable policy. Why would Egypt want to import an enclave of militant hate into their state? Egypt has been trying for years to stabilize the regional situation. Letting Gazans in will only expose Egypt to the animosity and let Hamas take root.
I'm actually shocked that people today have to ask such a question to Egypt. Jordan allowed a great many Palestinian "refugees" in back in the 70's., and in return they tried to overthrow via assassination the ruling family and Govt of Jordan, which became known as "Black September".
Also, Palestinian "refugees" allowed into Lebanon were key elements in starting the Lebanese civil war ,which basically ruined that Nations economy from which they have never really recovered. It appears these "Palestine Supporters" know nothing of actual History, and the havoc that has followed the Palestinians everywhere they go and how many times these " innocent refugees" turned out to in reality be trained and hostile Terrorists and subversives.
My mother always say “make your bed and lie in it.” They started this mess and don’t want peace so let them figure it out themselves.
Wait how are you so confiedent when u talking bs WHO started this bcz this didn’t start in 7th ocotober it started 1948
@@noname...8162czcams.com/video/r7GAg8sWDpI/video.htmlsi=94Y8YxosxteORUm3
Very smart of Egypt. They know very well how peaceful these people really are
No that's not it , it's because islam demands the extermination of the Jews
Peaceful people believe and act on Newton's law of ...every action has equal and opposite reaction.
No good deed goes unpunished.
Hussein let Arafat and the PLO into Jordan in 1970.....
Go research "Black September Jordan"
They are at the find out part right now.
Because they know better.
Good Work. Thanks.
most islamic country said "we are with Palestine" but won't help its innocent people🙄
"innocent" . lol
I'm also confused 😂
INNOCENT BWAHBBHAWBHAWBHWAHBAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
@@adw6894yes not all of them support hamas plus what about babies and children it's horrible,war is no place for a child they are innocent
Their bond is for hate not love. They hate Israel and non muslims so they show support. It's not that they love muslims.
Everyone seems to forget the “3 No policy” of the Palestinians. 1. No peace with Israel. 2. No negotiation with Israel. 3. No recognition of Israel. Egypt must keep the border closed even to aid. Enough is enough.
A hard stand as this is not conducive to lasting peace.
The only other solution is that ALL the illegal muslim squatters ( Israel, Gaza & the West Bank) must leave quietly, else be pushed out, just as the rohyngias were from SW Myanmar.
Israel threw them in concentration camps and commits war crimes as attested by UN and all major world human rights groups. Only in small list of countries under propaganda is Israel not condemned. Israel invades and occupies outside their lawful borders. Why would anyone recognize theocracy committing same atrocities, Israel, as German Socialist Party of 1930s and 1940s
Gazans are originally Egyptians. Read in Wikipedia.
The Egyptians are so selfish. Just Sinay itself is bigger than Israel. Egypt should take in the women and children. Or let them pass through to Africa.
This says alot!Egypt
Says it all.
Nobody in the world has anything similar like this. No Christian, Jew, Hindu, Buddhist, Atheist would deny entry to another one. Take Poland as a good example who welcomed Ukrainian refugees, because they were fellow Christians and Slavics. But a Muslim would deny another Muslim if he's a Palestinian. That's how the Middle East works in contrast. There seems to be some hatred between Arabs that we in the rest of the world cannot grasp.
Its coz they are sunni muslims but thats not the tip of the iceberg its actually the way of spreading jihad
Because Palestinians are troublemakers. Nobody want have them .
Who would like to invite terrorism in their country.
It might not be a hatred thing. It could just be a major liability and the logistics of it all. Lives are more important than logistics but only they could hopefully be honest enough to further explain why.
@nisrmasry8812 Agreed! If they leave, Israel will definitely never allow them back into the land because the ultimate goal is twofold: genocide and complete seizure of the Palestinian territory. 👍💯❤️
Egipt is not terrorist country their decision is correct and good for its people.
Yeah but when a European country doesn't interfere in the Isreal/Gaza conflict, they are bad. If Egypt preaches peace then they should lead by example and not hypocrisy. I mean Muslims should care for one another. Isn't that the point of protesting
@sepulvedablvd7846 thank you 👏👏
No Egypt has alot of extremists too, your only safe if your a muslim, all other minorities are killed
Egypt is not, but over too many Egyptians are terrorists and many more are full of hate.
EGYPT WILL NOT ACCEPT PALESTINIAN 1st they know what really reason of ISRAEL for PALESTINE LAND they will steal again same like what happened 1948. If Palestinian refugees accept in Egypt they stay in Sinai then Israel will say sorry we accidentally bomb Sinai then start fight with Egypt to steal again another land.. ISRAEL IS STEALING LAND GENOCIDE MURDERER
Didn't Egypt already have issues with Hamas, but they were called Muslim Brotherhood several years ago? It took a military coup to break the Muslim Brotherhood problem. Why would they want that again?
Tells you a lot about their culture, Damn.!!!!
Selfish people.
Egypt: We support our Palestinian brothers but...not in my backyard.
Allll Arab countries have 1 word for the Palestinians begging for help: NO.
Yah real brothers
And they lectured and criticize Poland when they not take Muslim immigrants and now Palestinian in such a bad horrible situation and they have nothing to do with taking them as refugees this is the love and support they have and they lecture west about Islamphobia these jihadist countries hijacked the west and destroyed their good image 😢 wake up west and fight
So much so for the global ummah
They are independent friends when u hav moneys
2 millions refugees in Jordan
1 million in Syria Lebanon
Muslim countries help Palestinians but they also know Israel will NEVER let them return to their home.
Israel point of view is simple : we as Jews have nowhere else to go. You are not people of Palestine but just Arabs so why don't you relocate to a neighbor Arab country where you don't risk death. It sounds cynical but it's really how they think
Didn’t Christian Lebanon do that years ago , and Then they Destroyed Beirut???
There are a couple of additional wrinkles in this story. Some years ago, when there were many many palistinian Arabs In Jordan, the were such bad guests that the King had to eventually call out the army to overcome their depredations on the civilian population. When Iraq invaded Kuwait, the Kuwaiti government said that their Palistinian population sided with Iraq. They are reported to have expelled a number of Palistinians equal to 30% of their population. No Arab government wants a repeat of this sort of debacle on their territory.
Coz they Know better, They are not fools like European Union.
Yeah! They are smarter than European comrades.
It really baffles me how these Islamic countries won't take Palestinian and other Muslim refugees. What does brotherhood mean to them? Do you only use the word "brother" when it's convenient?
It is quite simple what their term of 'Muslim Brotherhood', means to them, it mean the expansion of Muslim people into Europe and America, non Muslim Countries, with a traditionally Christian culture and heritage, quite simply it is a policy of expansion! The expansion being the spread of the Muslim faith and ideology, I hope that clears things up for you !
Thank you
Simple:
They don't want terror1sts in their homes!
What a nonssense. Egypt and other muslim countries has not bombed and did not caused the humanitarian crisis. Would you clean up some else's mess on the street?
@@ttemp2631 ofc you can,when you say they are your own people...
when you say you can die for them and fight against israel
@@tryit2136 or arm them to fight the war criminals.
Easy. They’ve seen this movie several times. It always ends the same way. Miserably.
Thanks, now I understand.
Bravo
They should be sent to Pakistan
Only issue is Pakistan has no money to book even flight tickets
The theives rulers hve the money 😂...the puppets of USA
😂😂
Hahahahhaha
Hahaha yes Pakistan deserves them since they love them so much
Remember, one day you will face God and they’ll judgment then you will see your fate right now you are going with Mike and lies and that is disgusting. Don’t forget Muslims have their glorious time for long time but then they indulge into materialism and left the teachings of Quran and Islam so they are paying the price but you with your short sightedness and head full of mind I just hurting yourself and your soul.
Egypt has seen how these “people” conduct themselves in Europe, hellbent on degrading the civilised world.
Abdicating responsibility? Really? They are actually being VERY responsible to their own people, to whom they owe their first allegiance, as they know what the people in Gaza are really like.
That would be like inviting the local Gang Banger's to move in with you.
I can't imagine a country anywhere in the world who would want to be responsible for hundreds of thousands or even millions of refugees from a neighboring country. It's a big responsibility and a big cost. However, Egypt might be willing to act as a go between for refugees heading for neighboring Muslim countries. Sadly, I don't think the surrounding Muslim countries want them, either.
This is just because they are so good, reliable, peaceful and innocent. Egypt does not want Hamas. Nobody wants them.
Who would want a cancer in his house
What do you mean you cannot imagine a country that would do that. The U.S. is doing it right now. But for the current administration it's a political move.
America is doing it every day thanks to Biden.
Canada and most small European countries as of latest...
I am tired of seeing free Palestine #s’. How about #stophamas
You should also have enough integrity and humanity to say stop apartheid and land theft. You must be another supporter of white supremacy, which is the rule of Israhell.
Stophamas. God bless Israel.
Egypt knows their characters..😀
Because they know what happened to Lebanon when they let Palestinians in!
All Muslim nations & others are crying for Palestinians including Egypt. Egypt is ready with aid ar Rafah border. But they don't accept Palestinians for the fear that these people will never go back to Gaza & will become their permanent burden. Why not those nations threatening Israel for multi front war share the burden of Palestinian refugee? Its only 2.2 million people? Right? Its easy to shed crocodile tears but when it comes to actual action no one takes first step. Its easy to Israeli's are shameful but look at these nations' action. Its shameful too.
Do you know what happened when Jordan in the 60s allowed Palestinians to come and settle. The conflict erupted after the PLO, which had been based in Jordan since 1967, began to act as a state within a state, challenging King Hussein's authority. Hussein saw this as a threat to his throne and to Jordan's stability.
On September 17, 1970 (called the Black September), the Jordanian Army launched a crackdown on the PLO (with the help of Pakistan Army which sent its Brigadier with a few thousand Army men). Thousands of Palestinians were killed and PLO defeated.
This is why no Arab nation wants Palestine refugees. They are a nuisance.
Other Muslims countries will not accept Muslims raise with other docrines because they know someday they will be a burden and a problem to their country. Let those country with the same docrines adopt Palestinians refugees.
The deserted n vast Sinai Peninsula can not just cram in 2M Gazans but the entire middle east.
Undermining the Palestine cause is stopping Egypt (and middle east ) from helping fellow muslims . You may lose a strip of land (or even Palestine) but can get along with life than putting the scores and their generations in misery
Palestinians are not acceptable by their Arab countries yet they call them bros WHY ?
Porkistan killed their 25000 palestinians brothers in 1970 (black september) for money and now supporting palestinians 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Hypocrites they r!!
The UK had been importing this into our country for decades
Exactly!
Because a muslim leader know radical islamic mentality, more than a Christian.
Egypt and Arabs people : we can protest to show soliderity but will not let them enter into our house 🤣🤣🤣
Like every mother says " go play outside" 😂
Egypt and the Arabs: We may need to show solidarity, but we will not allow the expulsion of the Palestinians from their land for the benefit of Israel
Such interesting facts not mentioned on BBC Thank you
Hamas is the Muslim Brotherhood. The people who tried to overturn Egypt not so long ago. The first responsibility of the Egyptian government is the protection of its own people. We cannot blame Egypt for simply carrying out its first and foremost responsibility.
Because these countries know the truth about their own people. All the cry, pity, love, humanity is only to force secular nations to take them in.
looks like someone knows their Brothers well
Hypocrisy rules the World.
Perhaps the civil war they caused in lebanon and jordan has lots to do with this refusal
And siding with Saddam Hussein in Kuwait.
Egypt’s actions sound remarkably sensible to me and I think we should copy them
Egypt has the right to protect their own citizens. Pres. Sisi responsibility for his countrymen is paramount. I stand with EGYPT 🇪🇬 with his decision not to let their border open for Gaza refugees.
I hope Biden takes heed.We Dont need Hamas we've got enough that probably got in through our Southern border
I thought Islam and helping the ummah was greater than your pretend nationalism
@@Zahbriinah Egypt said no more! Maye the MB morphed into other extremist groups?
So then I assume you have no opinion on the current Gaza conflict? If Egypt can deny these people, do you recognise Israel’s right to do the same?
@@ChakraVart1 Every country has the responsibility to protect its own and aim for some economic and social stability. Palestine chose leaders and there's a charter that says to destroy Israel. Hamas, as it's leaders, chose to not build a country for their own people. What is supposed to happen next? How do you answer that?
They don't want them there. They are also afraid of hamas they don't want them so glad you're asking the question that's why I love your show.
Good for Egypt! The Palestinians have nothing to offer Egypt but political instability and extremism. Just look at what happened when Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon allowed them into their respective countries.
U can just feel the love of Muslim country’s 🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭
Whats left out of this report is that the Muslim Brotherhood is the sworn enemy of the current Egyptian admin. Lets remember the military overthrew the Muslim Brotherhood. Ppl have died, been jailed and tortured on both sides. Does anyone think Egypt wants to let in more of its enemies? The last time Egypt let in refugees from Gaza, those people started attacking the Egyptian administration as well as Israel from the Sinai.
We are talking about saving lives. Everyone keeps insisting the civilians don't support Hamas, so why deny them?
Syrian Pres. Bashar al Assad dislike Hamas and call it as just another name for Muslim Brotherhood.
The Muslim Brotherhood in Syria was exiled and banned as a political party.
In all Arab states, Muslim Brotherhood is not welcome. It has a history of militancy and insurgency in Syria.
the civilians do support hamas. They are hamas. See that the big downside of being a terrorist without uniform or other marking like a normal soldier. If you hide between other civilians, everyone becomes a target. As soon as a hamas soldier takes off his green headband he goes back to being a civilian. So, logically you have to view every single civilian as a potential enemy. Hamas is only hurting it's own people in the end.@@ruthhorowitz7625
@@ruthhorowitz7625oh they support them.
@@ruthhorowitz7625don't you know that there are more than one other crossing on Israel Gaza border to be used if Israel real intention is to Save lives of them
Of course they dont want to import in terrorism & extremism into their land. They know what's it all about. They know what time it is. Cant blame them.
Ancient Egypt would be proud
They won’t let them in because they will never leave .
So sad 😞 that rich Arab countries like Qatar , Kuwait , Saudi Arabia don’t want to take innocent people
Innocent people always suffer
A lot of them are not innocent sorry to say. How do you possibly filter who is a terrorist and who is not!
At present you can't describe who is innocent who is terror. Come to reality. Don't trust people who is more loyal to religion than his own motherland.
ya ya...for you if someone muslim they are innocent ..even though they are terrorists..nothink to amaze
Exactly they are the people who voted and nurtured hamas for years. Giving aid money for making weapons .
When Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait, he promised Palestinians part of Kuwait so Palestinians welcomed the Iraqi army but when the Kuwaitis and the USA defeated the Iraqi, the fate of Palestinians in Kuwait was not good. Some of them were killed by angry Kuwaitis. That set the precedence why nobody would take the refugees in.
Thank you for your factual reports.
They know how Horrid they can be!
Blood of Philistines!
And most of the. World don't know Ancient History!
Its a tragedy for the women and children that each and everyone in Gaza is brainwashed to support Hamas..I dont blame Egypt for not letting them in
I feel bad for the Gazan civilians trapped but I understand why Egypt refuses to admit any of them. Egypt just doesn't have the economy to support so many refughees and they don't want any potential Hamas militants within its own borders.
Read history of black September 1970.
@@nisrmasry8812well said sir, does the ordinary Egyptian consider Hamas to be a terrorist group and hold no regard for the Gazans?
@@nisrmasry8812 and what is the proportion of those innocent people among the Gazans? 50%? 30%? 80%?
@@nisrmasry8812 makes sense, thank you for your response and take care
2 millions refugees in Jordan
1 million in Syria Lebanon
Muslim countries help Palestinians but they also know Israel will NEVER let them return to their home.
Israel point of view is simple : we as Jews have nowhere else to go. You are not people of Palestine but just Arabs so why don't you relocate to a neighbor Arab country where you don't risk death. It sounds cynical but it's really how they think
Egypt know that they will be like France or Sweden if they will allow it.
Wait a bit. They will those locusts. Do not let them in - you will be sorry.
Thank you
Egypt is playing as the clever one in the game. Respect.
and Poland are being criticized for not taking in refugees.
🤣🤣
Right !
😂😂😂😂😂lol...
why should anyone even tell another country what they should do but yes unfortunately since we are under the eu we are dictated by their laws
Wow...I wish that guy was the U.S. president. We're being invaded here from 185 coutries and it's destroying us.
How sweet, they point finger to Europe when they don’t allow Muslim refugees enter, but when Egypt don’t allow Muslim refugees everything is fine 😱 double standards in the Muslim world
This channel is the only one that has real journalism
So much said about Westerners ~ this lot of people, the Gazans voted for a Hamas governance regime; they are deemed “undesirables” by their Arabic brethren. The Gazans have doomed themselves as fugitives and they do not practice/live normalities of civilians’ lives.
The Palestinians were the victims of their Leaders with too much Greed, Hatred, ang Power hunger that they become so selfish neglecting all the needs of Commoners Palestinians except leaders families who lives lavishly, on the first place I cried for these thousand civilians who are suffering now to the extreme of their well being because of the arrogant and selfish decisions of their Leaders. Lord, please help these people.
@@loidanellas9257
Firstly, they must reflect upon their own mistakes n adopt a positive forward approach. In same essence of the Chinese struggle for common good against the KMT during China civil wars. Nobody, would care n help “enough” to uplift these forsaken Palestinians(it is the same as KMT, whereby US was the supporter. KMT leaders riddled the Chinese economies with corruption n personal gains, against the welfare of the common people); only Palestinians can help themselves.
Egypt literally did this once and look where it go them, can't blame them for saying NO
🎉❤i love listening to all your reports....such a brilliant way of explaining ❣❣❣🥺🥺
At least this war is exposing the absolute hypocrisy of certain nations. Solidarity my foot. Rip to all innocent victims.
It truly exposes the hypocrisy. 😂😂😂😂
Very smart of Egypt. They know very well how “peaceful” these people really are. lol
Let Iran allow them in instead of threat to Israel I think it's shows brotherhood than giving them only weapon and moral to fight nd destroy their own house
They will not leave palestine till death said by Hamas leader ( living in Qatar) .
They could care less about them!
@@gamesbond6143 😄
Egypt is smart. They don't want trouble maker. If allow to enter they will cause trouble between Egypt & Israel.
Hats off to Poland for past decisions!!!!
tbh the migrants that where trying to come across in 2021 was not to enter poland to settle but as a gateway to germany, i do not hear migrants saying i want to go to poland, seeing how poland hates anyone that is not Caucasian, any person of colour wanting to get a visa for poland are crazy
Meanwhile, thousands of Jews worldwide are pouring into Israel to help their fellow Jews. Get the picture, people?? This is why Israel will continue to survive and thrive-even though they are surrounded by enemies on all sides
All jews should go to israel to help ! Why isnt chuckle schumer there? With fat boy nadler?