SILENCE IN THE LIBRARY / FOREST OF THE DEAD review | Exterminating Doctor Who podcast | episode 42

After many mentions on the podcast, we finally get to discuss Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead to question whether it truly is as good as its reputation. We talk the greatness of River Song, the scariness of the Vashta Nerada, the Moffatness of the story, the sadness of Donna Noble, and more! George also gives his definitive New Who companions ranking as well as taking a look at some of the latest news and rumours.
#DoctorWho #TenthDoctor #RiverSong
INSTAGRAM -
/ edw_podcast
TWITTER -
/ aidangulamedia
Hosted by Aidan Gula and George Ellis, Exterminating Doctor Who is the show where life-long Whovians debate whether Doctor Who's most talked-about episodes are as good or as bad as their reputations!
00:00 Intro
01:26 River Song
08:23 Moffat Era
11:51 News & Rumours
19:09 Starting at the End
28:43 The Doctor & River
35:35 Doctor Moon
39:09 Donna
47:19 George’s Companion Ranking
56:25 Cal’s World
59:00 Vashta Nerada
1:07:18 Final Thoughts
1:13:16 Next Time

[@thebigscreenpodcast8332]

Yeahhh, the only detracting things in this one are the effects of disfigured Miss Evangelista and the CAL stuff which seemed very convoluted by the end. Would also go with a 8/10 but part 1 and the ending of part 2 are exceptional pieces of Doctor Who.

[@alanalittle3649]

amazing watching this now and knowing you were right about that casting call -- seems to be the new Rose character!