Akbar Birbal - What we should know | The Real Story | Brahm Kavi | Mahesh Das
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 10. 2020
- This video traces the life of Birbal as a Poet, Diplomat, Administrator, Military Leader and his impact on the Religious Policy of Akbar. The immense affection and faith Akbar had in Birbal knows no parallel in Akbari History and is borne out of the times when Akbar had put his life in danger to save Birbal's. The uncontrollable lament of Akbar on Birbal's demise was a source of envy for many in the Court.
Please share your thoughts on - trystwithhistory@gmail.com
For more wonderful content, please Like, Share and Subscribe to our channel and Follow us on our social media handles :
Twitter - / tryst_w_history
Instagram - / trystwithhi. .
Music Credits - CZcams Audio Library
This not-for-profit educational video is based on the information material sourced from the following suggested readings for the viewers;
1. Raja Birbal (Life and Times) by P. P. Sinha
2. Popular Jokes and Political History, Case of Akbar, Birbal and Mulla Do Piyaza by C. M. Naim
3. Cultural history of Medieval India - edited by Meenakshi Khanna
4. collection.cooperhewitt.org/o...
5. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birbal
6. www.newyorker.com/magazine/20...
7. theprint.in/pageturner/excerp...
8. www.thebetterindia.com/119423...
9. thediplomat.com/2017/12/the-r...
10. www.discoversikhism.com/sikh_g...
11. alchetron.com/Birbal
12. blog.aaobihar.com/jalan-museu...
13. www.bl.uk/onlinegallery/online...
14. www.rarebooksocietyofindia.or...
15. www.notesonindianhistory.com/...
16. Photo credits to Wikimedia Commons and above
अक़बर के मीना बाज़ार के बारे में क्या विचार है आपके?
तब ये लोग अपने पिछवाड़े छुपाते है
आपने बीरबल के जीवन को उनसे जुड़े चुटकुलों से बाहर निकाल कर प्रामाणिकता से स्थापित किया। उनकी कविताओं को भी बहुत अच्छे से प्रस्तुत किया।
धन्यवाद सर। कुछ अनजाने पहलुओं को श्रोताओं के सम्मुख प्रस्तुत करने की कोशिश है।
Is it true that Akbar changed the name of Prayag to illahbad/allahbad? If so, why did he do so?
To promote allah and his religion
Where was Birbal the advisor then?
@@vinayaknaik2602 why would he care about that? He was just an employee
@@CK30585 Yes, he was just another courtier who was witty. So what's great about that? Let him remain in the story books where, at least there, he scores some points over Akbar.
@@vinayaknaik2602 who knows what happened 500 years ago.. but akbar and his courtiers were not interested in Hinduism .. their propaganda was Islam .. so they were not good for bharat
Sir we have privilege/ flexibility to (modify /edit/add ) our Puranas based on prevailing circumstances of that time as our books are not based on religion/ belief system but emphasises on ideal way of living .
So connecting Akbar with past life philosophy is hard to digesting theory.
It gives a feeling that this story is trying to cover the wounds and bring feel good factor to our past.
We merely relate what is written and is part of the research done. Reference to reading material is given in the description of the video. We agree on the editworthyness of Puranic literature with passage of time. Having said that, we are of the view that much research still needs to be done in Indian History.
आप बिलकुल सही बात कर रही हैं आक्रांताओ की बर्बरता को ढकने की नीति.............
@@trystwithhistory8480 if somethings are written in a book that doesn't make that true. you are making a video on that means u believe that and want your followers to believe same. better make a video on something which tells people how akbar was a religious bigot and killed Hindus. Hindus are already very tolerant and have become dhimmis after being ruled by barbarians for long. Better research in something to make people come out of dhimminess. But your video is only doing opposite. Feel good that we were ruled by a barbarians , feel good in serving them. feel good if again we get same fate. Already our motherland got divided by this dhimminess and again heading towards same.
@@trystwithhistory8480 You can very well relate history written by the Indic scholars instead of that written by the leftists posing as historians.
In the course of entire history millions of humans have lived and died following hundreds of religions , The Gods of Hawai or Egypt or Ancient Babylon did not save those who died under misery though prayed for them, Not a single cylinder of oxygen became full on it's own in the Pandemic. When two Hindu kings fought in the ancient times before any "foreign" power came into India ..who died..?soldiers for no cause except of their kings..You have not been wounded, Nobody insulted you.. You have a complex,based on a fictional pride.. That somehow..these brutal kings of past who killed each other for power are related to you and they were grand just because they belonged to the same religion.. Power is and was the only Aim of these rulers...Try to speak about Injustice or criticize a local leader of ruling party..Them we will see what wounds are..
Sir, kya aisa nahi ho sakta hai? Akbar ko khush karne ke liye us daur mein Bhavishya Puran mein ye sab daal diya.
बिलकुल हो सकता है , ऐसा कई पुस्तकों और ग्रंथो के साथ किया गया है।
Of course, not only this but many other manuscripts were altered by people who hate India or Hindus
Birbal got converted to Din Ilahi so readily because Akbar got him married to a beautiful muslim woman. So out of gratitude towards Akbar, Birbal was ready to do anything.
India needs more creators like you sir. Every time your video ends, I feel a bit less ignorant and a bit more enlightened.
This so called "Tejasvi" raja Akbar led to the third jauhar of Chittore in 1567.
Those so called great Rajputs persecuted lower caste people and still do so in rajasthan
@@Playerone1287 absolutely but to say one is evil and other is gracious is foolishness. Kingship knows no kinship.
@@vinod.19 glad you understood my point you seem like a nice person, nice to meet you
Where can I read that letter of 6 pages?
Ye sab Katha aapne kis kitaab me padi hai? 2 4 ka naam hame bhi batain.
Sources are given in the description of the video. Please see.
पिछले जन्म के राज इन्हे पूछ लो l
Why have you stopped uploading videos for past 6 months?
What an eye opener....thanks for sharing the interesting anecdotes straight from the Court records KK Sir.
Amazing informative video of you . Birbal death was one of the reason for the Akbar death later on . As because Akbar did not withstand the loss .
Akbar started a new religion named “Din-I-ilahi” based on Islam, Zoroastrianism and Hinduism. Birbal was one of the first followers of the faith. Even Akbar’s own families refused to convert but Birbal did without hesitation.
सर ये तो बताएँ अकबर ने ऐसा क्या किया जो वो स्वर्ग पहुंच गया।🤔
sahi kaha aapne vo to nark jaane yogya nahin tha adharmi
Sahi pakade hai
Akbar ne Mina bajar khola tha hindu aurto ka bajar
@@funtasticfanish4493 sir purano me aadha sach aadha jhunth likha ha hamare vastvik granth ved hain 🙏
@@pratibhasingh8224pata nhi Aaj ke time mein kya saccha hai kya jhoota kyunki bohot saare granth toh mughalo ne jala diyee th......
@@himanshukaushik8779 right
Great..Thanku so much...You're a candle in the darkness sir... Kindly make the video on Kailash Parvat..
What an Irony that Beerbal used all his intelligence against his own countrymen or there was no Indian King who could use Beerbals intelligence
It is still happening...
Lol..Butt Hurt spotted.
@@TheBR911 😂😂😂kuch bhi,we can say the same to the workers of East india too
True and we were thinking that Birbal is really great. Both suited each other. Such a shame
Awsome video. Thanks for this content
सर कहा जाता है अकबर अनपढ़ थे तो उन्होंने विलाप पत्र कैसे लिखा 6 पन्ने का। plz reply late hai pr बताइयेगा जरूर
I guess you haven't seen a single ncert history book.
Cuz kings used to narrate words to the writers.
It were writers who used to write give the words it's magic
GREAT WORK
THANKS FOR DEPTH INFORMATION
You remind me of my dad )) Awesome work 👏
Wow please keep making such videos..
Well researched and rare insights and anecdotes about the Akbar - Birbal partnership. Thanks for the information shared.
brother..that was no partnership...Birbal was converted to Dene-e-ilahi..
haha yeah great research that a guy swallowed cow's hair with milk and was born as akbar in the next life, what a load of crap
totally concocted story with no proof from any primary source.
Akbar kaise mahan hua
Agar akbar mahan tha to humare shiromani maharana Prataap kya hai
Ek hi mahaan ho skta h kya...?
NewNews👉बहुत रोचक और हैरतअंगेज जानकारी के लिए धन्यवाद । वैसे वीरवर जी को सिख धर्म गुरु ने मरवा दिया उसने उनको एक लेप दिया था जिसको लगाने के बाद किसी भी हथियार से कट नही लग सकता । ऐसी भी कथा है
I don't understand why this perspective of history is not being taught to us in schools ...through this we can understand the history way better and can learn moral values too
Bcoz fitting all these things in the history classes of young students will be a big overload on them. Already history is a hated subject by many. + Jitna history padhne ko school mein tha aur hai, woh toh sabne samajhke padha hi nahi.. aur abhi zyaada chaahiye 😂
@Gulrez Rana lol I studied in the times when bjp was never in the power ... even today's syllabus is not renewed its just same
Awesome Work Sir! I'm your student from today! :)
Beautiful content and beautiful presentation.
Great explanation 🙏
I love your entry Sir🤗
So calm and radiant....
Stay blessed 💚
Thanks a lot for sharing this interesting aspect of history! Proud and partially sad to know how the important aspect gets forgotten and only the unnecessary humour prevails! Respect to your work Shriman ji!
Thanks sir... very Informative
राजा रामचंद्र कहा के थे आपने उनके फ़ोर्ट की इमेज भानगढ की लगा रखी है जो की अलवर राजस्थान मे स्थित हैं प्लीज बताये
Sir,,,,, U & Your Informative presentation is Amazing... It's help all of us to Know Our Real & proud History. Pl start again make videos... Pl keep it Up 🙏🏻
Very interesting and impressive Sir, please introduce yourself at the beginning of each video.
Simply Awesome 👌👌
Hats off👌👌👌👌👌
Lovely, really enjoyed
Excellent information
Never imagined this was the truth
Akbar was a great King
Your knowledge is incredible.... would really appropriate if you can dedicate a video to Bhavisha Puran
Bhavishya Purna is a recent work of dubious origin. Also his assertion " Akela Muslim Raja " is patently false. Mahmud Ghazni finds a mention in Bhavishya purana. Nicholas Sutton ( scholar at Oxford centre for Hindu studies), while debunking Zakir naik's fraud claims , emphasised that Mahamud used in Bhavishya Purna is actually Mahmud Ghazni (Not Muhammad the prophet)
Non of them is holy to be mentioned in any hindu puranas.
excellent knowledge sir .. thanks...
It would be more interesting if it were a homosexual love story.
Sir can you please provide the source where it says that Akbar is the only Muslim ruler to be mentioned in Bhavishya Purana. I have searched it up repeatedly but it does not show. Aurangzeb is mentioned, as well, it seems according to the Google search. Can you please give me the source?
Hi. Thank you for being inquisitive.
The sources on which the video relies are detailed in the description. Kindly have a look.
very knowledgeable vlog.thankyou sir
Thank you for sharing these pearls
Great, you brought a wonderful portion from the history otherwise everyone is telling their own version now a days.
Super explained 🙏
Very much informative, Sir
Please be factual because both the characters could have done a lot better for Hindus. However, Meena bazar and degradation of Hindus throughout the empire is hidden from Hindus in India. You are part of that legacy, following the path shown by Nehru and Romila Thapar.
Can you mention any primary source that refers to Meena Bazaars being organized by Akbar? Would like to read up on it.
आप जैसे महा पुरुषो सै देश की भावी पीढी को संस्कार मिलेगा बहुत बहुत साधुवाद
Sir the end almost bought tears to my eyes, the way you have depicted this is nothing short of Nizammudin and Khusrow. Please keep up the good work, would love to meet you someday, I have a group of friends who are archeologists and anthropologists, would love if you couldn’t spare some time. 🙏🏻
Sure. Please mail us your number at trystwithhistory@gmail.com. We will call back.
Great ! Thank you. Greetings !
While growing up, we Bengalis knew these Akbar Birbal stories as the stories of Gopal bhand- bhand probably translates to comedienne and if I am not mistaken the king whom Gopal served was Samrat vikramaditya
Gopal bhar and samrat vikramaditya is a different story based in nadia nabadeep
They r not at all the same
and in Mithila...we know these stories as of Gonu jha
You mean Chandragupta
gopal bhar server raja krishnachandra roy of nabadwip who was a vassal king under nawab alivardi khan
Supab research sir. 🙏
What was the meena bazar sir?
Excellent research n the best heard compering skills bro🙏🙏
Thank you Anirudh bhai 🙏
For non hindi speakers it would be great to have some English closed captions 🙂
Sir, very interesting. can you please add the primary source of evidence for the contents of the videos that you prepare including this video.
The references are given in the description of the video.
Sir Akbar must have gone to Jannat,
And this stories which you want to establish, Akbar started doing surya puja, and gave grants to temples, is hard to believe,
When people believe you so seriously, please don't use words "ye mana jata hai", every word you speak must be your fact findings from old scriptures, and not what you believe.
I really enjoyed this narration of history. It was full of facts and devoid of any biases. 👍👍👍
Good job 👏 thanks
Great video sir
Awesome Sir. I cannot remember when I was last amazed by a narrative and its narration. In this age and context, I was so captivated by your grasp over history that the ending disappointed me.... simply because it ended.
Brilliant explanation!
Requesting the maker of these episodes to also release a book with each episode converted into a chapter, with some of the illustrations.
That way, the hard copy will serve people who want to read more than listen or see.
+1
Akbar was equally brutal and most of ur info is just suni sunai baat.... No facts at all
2hy no new videos sir ? :(
the poems uve shown, akbar wrote those in persian and not in hindi language right?
Thank you for the query. The poems shown, except the last one, were written by Birbal. His pseudonym features in each of them. Braj bhasha was as much in use in Akbar's time.
@@trystwithhistory8480 i didnt knew akbar used to compose poems in braj language too.. thanks for the knowledge 🙏
Nice video 😊
Superb...highly informative...thank u for such wonderful elucidation in history
आदरणीय सर
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
परशुराम जी का जन्म वास्तविकता में कहां हुआ था... यदि कोई प्रमाण हो.. तो कृपया हमसे भी साझा करें.. 🙏🙏🙏
Renuka ji himachal
Nice video 😊👏
waah sir lazwab
बीरबल की इतनी सटीक जानकारी आज आपसे जानी । आपका बहुत बहुत आभार।
Bahut bahut dhanyavad sir itne mahatwapurn jankari Dene ke liye
Very nice information 👍
The Pratisarg section of Bhavishya Puran has been quite contentious, with many scholars considering it a political forgery
बहुत सुंदर कथा वर्णन। धन्यवाद।
पुराणों में बहुत कम ही है जो वास्तविक और सत्य हो.....मुगलों के महिमामंडन की कलाओं मे से ये भी एक है....... और आप जैसे लोगों की चर्चा तो खैर क्या ही कहे.....
बहुत सुंदर प्रस्तुति और जानकारी
Superb reasearch
great information sir..Its an eyeopener which tells the real story of akbar birbal relation...
बहुत गलत बता रहे हैं आप।।
वीरबल का जन्म घोघरा गाँव सीधी जिला मध्यप्रदेश में हुआ था ना कि कानपुर,।।
Cultural History of Medieval India edited by Meenakshi Khanna, Page 29.
Please read on Google Books here books.google.co.in/books?id=ZbKv3zyIFD8C&pg=PA24&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
Sir Maharan Pratap, Ranavghan, Maharaja Krishnakumar sinhaji, Shivaji Maharaj... In sabaka bhi history video banaye sir.
Great research. Very informative video.
Your style to capture attention is awesome ...please make more videos
Pls mention language of video in title
English title then why only hindi ?
Just one word WOW..
Great knowledge sir
Sir sorry to rectify you but birbal was born in sidhi and was diwan at rewa riyasat in mp
Many thanks for watching the video with interest. And thank you for the comment.
May we request you to share the source. Our video is based on the sources mentioned in the description. You may like to check them out.
akbar birbal ki stories ka source kya hai aur ismein se kya saare unoriginal hai ya kuch
बहुत सुंदर ॐ सनातन धर्म का सार ह । आत्मा परमात्मा कर्म अधर्म पुनर्जन्म ओर ईश्वर ॐ जय श्रीरामम
This relationship of Akbar and Birbal is fascinating and definitely well presented. It strikes a chord so similar to the relationship of Alexander and Hephaestion where Alexander gave up his royal duties to mourn the loss of Haephastion, who was his lover , for several days.
Maybe Akbar too had this enmeshed relationship with Birbal that was more than just friendship or professional duty. That made him so protective of Birbal to put himself in harms way. Just like the love between Alexander and Hephastion.
Learn to know, forget about recognizing, acknowledging and/or respecting other forms of love between individuals!! You guys are suffering from OCD!
@@somaganguly955 Homophobia is curable. So it will eventually and wont need this OCD to only see romantic love between a Hetero-romantic couple as the only form of valid love in the society and Homoromatic love as something negative. And these history lessons reminds us back that we didnt need any OCD for love. May it be across religion, caste, sexuality or gender.
Wah ji very nice👍👍
Akber slaughtered 40000 civilians at chittor and this guy telling us that he is a great king.Distorian
Sahi Kaha Jai Shri ParshuRam
eye opener .....
Sir please continue 🎉🎉
Excellent
Thank you Sir