Pink Floyd, Bring The Boys Back Home - A Classical Musician’s First Listen and Reaction
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
- #Pinkfloyd #rogerwaters #thewall
Continuing in the vein of the war, couched in words resembling an anti-war protest slogan, but set to a triumphal military march, this song, along with Vera, might feel randomly placed, and yet… His voice is part of the mass choir. The entire chorus is calling out for brothers, husbands, fathers, to return and fill the void which, for Pink, became a wall. And now in his isolation, Pink comes to dwell on this loss and its impact on his life.
Here’s the link to the original song by Pink Floyd:
• Bring The Boys Back Home
_________________________
If you want me to do a First Listen and In-depth Analysis of YOUR song of choice, or if you want an exclusive 1:1 session where I can answer your questions, dig deeper into a topic, or even coach you in your musical experience, such as a music theory, piano, or harp lesson, singing, music reading, etc, follow this link: ko-fi.com/amys...
If you want more, join my Patreon: / virginrock
Twitter: / virginrockmusic
Instagram: / virginrockchannel
Facebook: / virginrockchannel
Special thanks to those who are keeping my ko-fi cup supplied:
I’ve formed the habit of publishing all the names of my supporters simply because I appreciate your appreciation of my work, and I want to recognize each one of you personally. But, unfortunately, CZcams allows a limited number of characters for the description, and I cannot fit all names anymore. So, this is my message to each one of my supporters personally:
THANK YOU!
_________________________
Amy Shafer, LRSM, FRSM, RYC, is a classical harpist, pianist, and music teacher, Director of Piano Studies and Assistant Director of Harp Studies for The Harp School, Inc., holds multiple degrees in harp and piano performance and teaching, and is active as a solo and collaborative performer. With nearly two decades of teaching experience, she teaches privately, presents masterclasses and coaching sessions, and has performed and taught in Europe and USA.
_________________________
Credits: Music written and performed by Pink Floyd
This video may contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. VirginRock is using this material for educational, critical, research, and commentary purposes in our effort to promote musical literacy and understanding. We believe that this constitutes a “fair use” of the copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, which provides allowance for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond “fair use”, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
If your copyrighted material appears on this channel and you disagree with our assessment that it constitutes “fair use”, please contact us.
I’ve seen a few comments, not necessarily critical, but frustrated that this series is taking so long. Can I just say I am actually enjoying the fact that it’s drawn out this way … I realise we live in an age of instant gratification and binge watching, but I like the fact that I’ve been enjoying this series for a year now, rather than maybe watching it over a month or two, and it being long forgotten by now! Once it’s done, I will miss the pleasant surprise each time I see a new episode.
Thanks for your work!
Well said, my friend ... well said... Don't be so eager to grow old and die... It'll be here and gone before you know it...
@@hullbarrett I’ll resist the urge to quote some “Time” lyrics 😂… but yes, you’re quite right!
Thunder long gone..........
Gluttons and ogres devour quickly, but connoisseurs savor slowly.
You're right about the impatience, but sometimes we are like little children when Christmas approaches.
Sitting in front of the Christmas tree, contemplating the presents at the foot of the tree, tempted to weigh them and handle them, in order to guess their contents.
But Christmas is only a few days away, so in our eyes, we will have to wait "forever" before knowing their contents.
The ending of this part sets up for the next... transitioning from inside Pink's mind back to real time. "Time to go" is for the tour manager outside Pink's hotel room trying to get him to "The Show".
I always associated the war stuff in this album as Pink's desire to have his father back in his life. Lost in the war and left with an over compensating mother.
It’s part of it
Thats pretty much the exact setup of the story of Pink and his adult issues.
I'd agree, that but also the ending of all wars I think.
especially considering the cut song from the album, "when the tigers broke free." I'm honestly glad that song was cut from the album because otherwise it would be genuinely too emotionally overwhelming for me. Its placement in the film is perfect but in the album I don't know where it would fit without just making the record so sad as to be too sad to bear.
This is such a TEASE! We all know what comes next. Let's get on with it!
"Hello Hello Hello ! Is there anybody In there !"
@@gfakruddinahmad8316 Just nod if you can hear me...
The best guitar solo ever...
"Just nod if you can hear me"
Yeah, do you realize it's been a year since she started reacting to this album and we aren't even 3/4 of the way through yet?
For me, after the desperate plea to bring the boys back home, the 'Time to go", knocking and "Are you feeling OK" are flashback's to other parts of the album. For example "Are you feeling OK" comes from One Of My Turns when he has taken the girl back to his apartment and is just about to go berserk and smash everything up and "Time To Go" is, I think, from Is There Anybody Out There of which we get a small reprieve at the end of this track.
I think that this is all part of that meltdown. He has, as you say, condensed the feelings of war fatigue into one short song and this is further reinforcement of his state of mind.
"Time to go" is in the 'present' moment. Pink is zoned out in front of the TV, and his manager (Bob Hoskins, in the movie) is knocking on the door because Pink is supposed to be on his way to the concert.
I’ve always thought that the “time to go” and knocking are happening in real time. They’re the people coming to get him to play the concert. Then they enter the room and comfortably numb occurs
You can also hear the teacher saying "Wrong, do it again" from Another Brick in the Wall part 2.
I think you are right that this is part of the meltdown. I think of this part as audio representations of all the bricks in the wall; the teachers cruelty, the wife’s infidelity, the loss of his father.
Good analysis. I seem to remember that someone (Roger?) said about the movie that he saw Syd say like that and the promoter saying “Time to go” (onstage). Then he’s dosed up …. and thus can, but he loses his mind. It’s sad and brilliant ❤ and reminds us how Syd is another narrative thread ❤❤
when the drums fade we are left with voices swimming in pink's head as he sits in a catatonic state in his hotel room. you hear the teacher saying, "wrong! do it again!", the groupie saying,"are you feeling ok?", the telephone operator saying,"see he keeps hanging up...and it's a man answering",and his manager banging on the hotel room door yelling,"time to go!" referring to the concert pink is scheduled to play,but is in no condition to do so. in a last desperate attempt to reach out to the real world, pink's mind once again cries,"is there anybody out there?"
enter the doctor,and the magnificent song "comfortably numb"
well done!
The Wall really MUST be taken in and experienced as a single piece rather than individual songs. The Wall is the truest example of a "concept album" that I know of. When I first heard it as a single piece (as intended) at the age of sixteen, it literally changed my life. It's themes of alienation and madness still move me today.
Vera and Bring the boys back home are my favorites
I love those low voices that come in a couple beats before the last "bring the boys back home" with that very deep "bring". My favorite part of the song.
I hear all the combined sound and voices as the "thin ice of modern life" that Pink is skating on. He feels that everyone else is just going on without any of the pain that he feels as a result of the war, almost as if it never happened. Thus, is there anybody out there? And from Vera, does anybody else in here feel the way I do?
You've seen the movie by now and surely know how moving this bit is.
The last lonely cry "home" within context is just heartbreaking.
In flashback form, reliving trauma that never dissipated; his hope, a fantasy that should've been reality and makes no sense not to have been (as with so much else in life), persists like trauma does, compartmentalized and unaccessed, an alternate timeline that is only reasonable, embodied in this case by agreement and the force of shared emotion in a chorus of loved ones, builds to the foreground as if what reality should have been, was (or is, from the perspective of flashback), the call for their return surely heard and will be understood, only to recede into the realization of now, with just the trauma and his suddenly lone plea extending outward, left. Looking/feeling back to what was so important, intimately sacred (and yet shared amongst so many, as confirmation), then coldly abandoned by how life has actually turned out, his call reaching out into nothingness.
Enter, at that point, the many pressing patterns of voices as stressors in his life, accumulating and operating as machinery, brutally revealing the routine and seemingly ordinary sources in society of why the call had extended outward into nothingness instead of resulting in an answer of compliance. Those audible hallucinogenic stressors WERE the response to his futile childhood call, now facing him, filling the vacuum (which may have been preferable).
The isolation or sense of absence that trauma leaves in an individual can give way to a revelation of its cause (represented by a distorted immediate), being worse than the nothingness there before.
I heard the wall 20 years at 17 years old, my life has been different ever since.
Yes, it's powerful art. Thanks to Roger's personal experience of loss due to war, we're seeing the so often unseen casualties of war, the families left behind after loved ones are lost. It is simultaneously a great thing and a sad thing. May it be realized, "...Bring the boys back home. Don't leave the children on their own no no. Bring the boys back home...". ❤
The looped voices at the end are from preceding songs: the school master's bullying, Pink calling his wife and her lover answering the phone, and the detachment caused by constant touring as signified by the groupie's voice from 'One of my Turns'.
And of course, 'Bring the Boys Back Home' can be seen as bringing soldiers back from the war, and also be read as bring the boys (Pink's band and their crew) back home after extended time on the road (as Pink Floyd actually did).
These things, along with Pink's father's death in the war, are certainly four 'bricks in the wall'. Not sure why there's nothing from Pink's mother here? That would make sense.
The door knocking and 'time to go' is I think a roadie or promoter calling Pink to the stage with no response, which feeds into the next song, Comfortably Numb.
There wasn't an audio clip of his mother from the film to use, I believe, and certainly not an anxiety producing one if otherwise, but its absence here sort of also preserves how he would like to think of her (as shown throughout all of Mother aside from its end) in a more cherished and protective role, from even before his father died.
The soldiers are marching away yet Pink sees them going off to war.. the desperation of a child being alone is slowly fading into his current situation as the current voices of discontent fill the last bit leaving him as alone as he was as a fatherless child... stunning actually.
The next song is the one that made me buy the album. I do love every bit of it though. Loving your analysis.
Looking forward to this one and the rest of the album
After the music ends Pink is having a flashback while someone knocks on the hotel room door to get Pink for a show.
remembering the teacher's cruelty 'Wrong! Do it again!' the groupie's obliviousness, 'Are you feeling ok?' the wife's betrayal '... it's a man answering.'
AAAAAAAAAAH. The anticipation at the end!
(I love that Amy's doing this her way - I'm just expressing a genuine gut reaction to the music not going where it's "supposed" to go)
Oh, god, I can't hear that without my mind getting ready.... You are in for a treat on the next one. And you ARE NOT allowed to pause during a guitar solo. You're about to hear what some people think is the greatest ever.
Comfortably Numb is the high water mark of Pink Floyd's career.
Slight correction: Comfortably Numb live at Pulse is the high water mark of Pink Floyd's career. IMHO the greatest guitar solo of all time.
Na, not for me. Not even my favourite on the album. Shine on you Crazy Diamond parts I to V and Sheep are probably my favourites.
Great guitar solo, obviously and one of the great songs, but nothing on Echoes, Time, or Shine On
Nearly a year later, we're finally at the doorstep of Comfortably Numb.
You know….Floyd is one of my two top bands, but The Wall is not among my top three albums from them and as long as your Wall project is ongoing I know you won’t be doing other songs by them. At this point I’ll be glad when this project is complete…. I think it’s coming up on a year since it began? And I’m guessing another six months to completion. yowza . Quite an undertaking. You’ve done a fantastic job with it. One for music archives.
I think Virgin Rock should consider Echoes next
czcams.com/video/PGwPSPIhohk/video.html
Of course you know it by now, but the voice "Time to go!" and the banging on the door are back in the present time. :) And the next piece, Comfortably Numb, explains it all. Which BTW I consider the masterpiece of this album. If you haven't watched the live performance of Comfortably Numb, do yourself a favor and see it. It takes it to a whole new level.
Specifically live at Pulse, yes?
I saw an interview with Rodger Waters and he said when he was three or four years old he told his mother he was going to get a tractor and go get his father!! He guesses he chose a tractor cuz it was the biggest loudest most powerful vehicle he knew about at that age and he figured as big as it was that would get his father back!! Funny how a mind works at a young age.
Christ that's so heavy😢 poor, dear kid.
When the Tigers Broke Free, Bring the Boys Back Home, Comfortably Numb... i dunno about the rest of you, but this album makes me cry... and that's awesome.
I started listening to this album in my childhood, back in the 80s, because my uncle had the vinyl discs and I was fascinated with the illustrations; all those creepy characters and marching hammers behind the white bricks. So, I would listen to the album while looking at that wonderful painting by Gerard Scarfe, not understanding a single word since English is not my main language. I never studied English, one of the ways I learned the language was trying to figure out the lyrics (this was before Internet was a thing) and translating the songs in this album. Bring the Boys Back Home was one of my favorite songs when I was a kid.
Time has arrived. Waiting so long for this moment 😊
Please dont let us wait for too long before the next song!! greeting from Mexico!
We know what's coming next boys!
Also, don't forget, Comfortably Numb is the last song on the 3rd album side, when you have to flip over the record and start the next side :)
3/4 of the way through the album after a year. What progress.
@@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk stop moaning
ahhh! I reached the end. Right before the one. great job. love all the videos.
These voices at the end is actually segue into the next song which is Comfortably Numb.
So time to go x 3 is actually the part of the beginning of the Comfortably Numb.
So that’s the Manager / concert organizer wants the Pink to go to the concert and the rest of the sounds of people were actually the groupies and other staff having the behind the scenes times.
We're all just so eager to hear the next song.
That little bit in the end is a lead-in to the next song, Comfortably Numb. It really has nothing to do with Bring The Boys Back Home. The guy knocking on doors saying "Time to go!" is supposed to be the tour manager (or one of the tour staff) knocking on the doors of the band members, telling them to get going, it's time to get to the show to perform... Leading to Comfortably Numb
Yoy let me with the honey in the lips........comfortably numb is wonderful, specially the last part, the guitar solo in Bm
"You are almost finished analyzing this album, and I'm excited to hear the latest judgment about the complete album. Your next album should also be 'Dark Side of the Moon' by Pink Floyd. Thank you for your hard work in providing us with this in-depth analysis of music."🤗
At first the meaning was to go directly from "Is there anybody out there" to "Comfortably Numb": "Hello, is there anybody in there", but waters though to put some in-between so the second half didn't seem so intense.... He wrote "Nobody Home" in two days, and it ended it up like that, with "Is there..." and "Numb" a few songs apart.
When you're through with this album, you really should watch the movie... I think you'll be surprised at how the movie answers a lot of questions and ties things up... Plus it's just an amazing piece of work...
She has been. She recorded her first listen, videos then watched the movie and recorded her deep dives. She's releasing them out of that sequence, alternating between first listens and deep dives. Go see the deep dives, they're caught up to this point.
I think she said long ago she already heard and reacted to the whole album, and she also watched the film. I'm not sure if the deeper analysis videos were also recorded long ago or if those videos are new. I think the whole reaction videos are available in her Patreon.
And yes, I agree, the movie is amazing! =)
czcams.com/video/F5LrSztttnA/video.html
All those background noises was his thoughts / memories of all those bricks in the wall (wrong..do it again is the school master, the phone ringing and the operator, is about the infidelity but the (time to go) is the present seeping in, as it’s time for him to “go to the show”
you have to listen to "the wall" front to back, its an epic story that cant be broken up into chapters.
Every time I hear the "Time to goooo" I picture Eric Idle from Monty Python saying it. Similar voice.
💯 👍
When you started, did you know how big the rabbit hole was? It is what got all of us.
I can’t explain, you would not understand. This is not who I am. (Sing it loud enough for the neighbors to complain.)
Starts slowly rocking back and forth.....
I also appreciate the slow pace. Gives me time to keep up. :)
Ohh yes. "The wall" one of the most popular records in the English speaking world
There are several meanings of the song in this location... one, of course, is the absence of his father, lost in the war, and the yearning that he came back alive... the other is that he is touring and has no home; in fact, his home life is falling apart because of the infidelities (both himself and his wife). You can hear him yearning to "return home," but there is no home to return to...
No. there's no one or nothing beyond The Wall !!
The message in this song needs to be driven home; especially as Armistice Day is in one week's time.
This tune as well as in Vera, both in the isolated mind of Pink as he O/D's in the hotel room putting all the peripheral crap of his modern life behind him, is probably a recollection of the records his mother would have played. 1940's brass band music, war tunes, swing that the young boy would have remembered and which swirled around his head as he lay on the carpet.
This is the scene at the start of the next tune when the doctor comes in. Pink by then is on another level of consciousness. Not a moment of realisation, but a dark knight of the soul. Prescription drugs take care of that. Big Pharma is the new Mother.
Next song is going to be the GOAT!
watch the movie give you more of an idea of the storyline. love the intensity of your feeling for the songs. blew me away first time to
czcams.com/video/F5LrSztttnA/video.html
so far your best reaction to the wall.
I am from Portugal, and i really like the way this analyses are made by the Teacher. It will be awesome if the Teacher could Analyses Atom Heart Mother , a song of Pink Floyd , divided in 6 parts , no vocals, but with Violin, orchestra and much more .
Please don't make us wait another loooong 2 weeks to see your reaction to The Next Song!
Amy I recomend you to see the film The Wall directed by Alan Parker, you will finish to understand all this master piece, remember that The wall is also a soundtrack of the movie and if you miss the visual part you are missing the half of the conceptualization of the complete piece.
czcams.com/video/F5LrSztttnA/video.html
Ma'am ! You SHOULD react to the whole "Final Cut" album as well. Conceptually, Final Cut is the continuation of "The Wall".
Agreed 💯..
But musically waaaaaaaaay less interesting.
@@ulfingvar1 However I liked it !
@ulfingvar1 I seem to recall suggestions that some band members thought "The Final Cut" was a collection of songs that weren't good enough to get on The Wall.
I'm not sure this is true though as it's all about British life in the Maggie Thatcher era and for that reason alone, I can't see how it can be considered a continuation of The Wall.
@@gfakruddinahmad8316 OMG not The Final Groan!
Next song...i need your reaction for the next song.
The vocal style is Welsh male choir
Of course the brilliant Comfortably Numb (David's?) serves beautifully as a fantastic if a bit dark (and accurate) song in itself as well as an integral piece of the Wall. It's been in my repertoire since 1980. Another Brick in the Wall as well was a disco hit - I'm not kidding, I danced at every club in WeHo (West Hollywood) and the disco joints loved that song. Everytime I hear a song from the Wall my head plays the album from the end of the song.
David wrote the music and Roger was tasked with making The Wall specific lyrics for it
@@rorybessell8280 - Roger shared credits? Incredible. Naw, he wrote excellent lyrics. David's natural affinity for that song kinda make it his.
Thanks
Great! 👍🏻
The problem is that we all know what is coming next. However the analysis could take forever.
Among other things, the orchestration foreshadows The Trial
Ha ha yes we know whats next!!
Hi guys. Please listen to the pulse l overll pulse t I
Pompeii Version
This is the cornerstone of the entire opera.
LOL... Most of the comments are about waiting for Comfortably Numb 🙂
Pink Floyd used to make albuns which just made sence if you listen all of song in the sequence. I think could be an error to listen and analyse each track isolated way. Sometimes, isolated, the song could not make sence. Fortunately you are listening all of the álbum and probably you'll see what each one represent in whole. Thank you for your job.
Two preludes needed for the mammoth we're about to witness. I certainly hope you will be left speechless , just for a moment or two. Looking forward to your thoughts on this next one .
on a tangent, she should listen to Motorhead's song 1916
Dead silence..... Followed by the best B minor in rock.
Time to go , I think is referring to it's time for Pink to go and get ready for his next show.
Among other things. It's also time to go fully crazy.
The voices at the end r all his previous experience coming together. This piece is an intro to the next n should really have been heard as such .
Portion of an interview with Roger Waters:
Roger Waters: "[Vera] precedes, what is for me anyway, the central song on the whole album: Bring the Boys Back Home."
Interviewer: “Why?”
Roger: "Well, because it's partly about not letting people go off and be killed in wars, but it's also partly about not allowing rock and roll, or making cars or selling soap or getting involved in biological research or anything that anybody might do, not letting that become such an important and 'jolly boys game' that it becomes more important than friends, wives, children, other people."
Waters own father was killed at Anzio in 1944. He has been as consistently anti-war as any songwriter I know of over the past 50 years. If you have a chance to listen to "The Final Cut" album, it's ALL anti-war.
Buckle up.
After you do Comfortably Numb, do your self a favor and watch the Movie The Wall. It's the album brought to life along with the music.
Can't wait till you get to Comfortably Numb. One of the best rock songs ever recorded.
You know we’re just waiting for her to hear the next one…lol😂
orchestral vocally
I can't wait till you comment the next song, "Comfortably Numb". It's considered a masterpiece by a lot of people who know music and has one of the greatest guitar solo's of its time (of all time???) by the excellent Mr. David Gilmour.
Not long now for CN....
Also " Amused to death " should be next
Any chance you will cover other Pink Floyd albums after you finish with The Wall?
Personally, any album from the Roger Waters era (Dark Side of the Moon, Animals, Wish you Were Here, The Final Cut) would be awesome. Not really a fan of their hippy-sounding Syd Barrett era or the post-Roger Waters era.
I would particularly love if you would listen to The Final Cut. Lots of people hate it, but that's because it's a more nuanced and subdued album. It's technically a sequel to The Wall, because it touches on the same themes of war and corruption (amazingly, if I might add), but unfortunately it doesn't have that variety in music styles. It's still great though.
Remember that his father was drafted due to the war. He wants his father back so badly...
Comfortably Numb is mostly known for David Gilmour's guitar solo, especially the live version from the "Pulse" album (live album, you should really listen to that one and watch the video).
Wow, thank you for the information :)
I realise this will mean going off piste a bit for you.... but please, please, please watch the live version of Comfortably Numb from Pulse 1994 AS WELL AS the album version. It contains what is widely held to be one of the greatest guitar solos of all time!
Please do the Final Cut album
Can you make reaction video to comfortably numb ?
It's too bad she's not reviewing dark side of the Moon we could hear a 25 minute analysis of the 17-second song speak to me.
Why so much Pink Floyd and Beatles! Cliffs of Dover!
Please use the Pulse version of comfortably numb. It ls them at their best! But, watch the movie version too to see Pink's transformation. Recently Waters did amother vetsion . No guitars. Very dark But please use the Pulse version. This is the first apex of pinks journey. The next b e ing the trial.
She is reviewing the studio album. She can watch the live version at some other time.
@@79BlackRosewell. What t ever version she uses, it is still high point poe e
1. I vote Pompeii version the best
2. Pulse the second best
3. Waters Wall Tour at O2 London 2011
The Pulse version!? You having a laugh? The best live version of Comfortably Numb is Delicate Sound of Thunder👍
@@derekspitz9225Yes! Additionally, the Delicate Sound of Thunder version of Sorrow is much better than the Pulse one. It also has the incomparable On The Turning Away.
watch the movie all will be revealed!!!!
Please use the OK links
...e alla fine scivola in CONFORTABLY NUMB
I hate to disagree with you, but "The Time To Go" at the end is reality trying to wake Pink up, but you'll figure that out later....
The next track, Comfortably Numb, is a lot of Floyd fans' favourite Floyd track. Personally, it's not even my favourite on the album, that's still to come. I can't wait to see you listen and disect it.
The voices at the end, they were all about expectation and conformity. They turned out to be futile. Pink was one of the boys going to war with himself and wanted bringing back home, in his mind at least. He was pleading for help.
Reacting to every song on an album in order is a good idea, but whoever suggested this album wasn't thinking straight. It's such a flowing, interconnected experience that chopping it up into separate songs makes it nearly unintelligible. I feel sorry for Amy being subjected to this dumb idea.
Here we are after a year of reacting to The Wall and only 3/4 of the way through the album. Milk it for all it's worth I guess, but Dark side of the Moon is more important IMO, and by the looks of it you won't be getting into it until about mid 2024. What a shame.
My sentiments as well
I agree with you about living in the modern age of instant gratification... However sitting in a den and listening to a concept album with some songs less than a minute long and then critiquing them for over 30 minutes warrants the need for a little criticism.... If you're going to commit to something then go at it the appetite that you actually want to hear the music and critique it..... Many of us have jobs where we are not at home. Many of us have children that are not at home but they need to be dropped off and picked up from school. Some of us work two jobs. But taking this much time to listen to the wall it's like you are critiquing everything in parts 1 & 2 of The godfather. We all lead busy lives... But if you're going to commit to something then commit to it wholeheartedly.,. Not a song every other week.. it's turning into clickbait and a gimmick for money to top off those clicks.... Come on you seem like an educated person let's not take advantage of the audience.
Boy I've heard of milking things but this is getting ridiculous..... Vera and bring the boys back home is a total of what 1 minute 40 seconds of music...... If anything combine those songs and do a further deeper analysis into the more popular and layered songs like comfortably numb.,. But this milking it for every click is growing tiresome. Come on now if you've never heard comfortably numb I forgot a bridge to tell you in Brooklyn....... Stop playing The click game and start playing the songs that make this record so iconic... Turning into a cheap gimmick now.. you're better then that.......