Hamas releases video of Israeli-American captive held in Gaza
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 04. 2024
- Al Jazeera’s Bernard Smith, reporting from occupied East Jerusalem, says the nearly three-minute video of 23-year-old Hersh Goldberg-Polin shows him openly criticizing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
In the video, he appears to say that Netanyahu is “not doing enough, blames him for not getting the captives out,” Smith said.
“Remember, of course, when these videos are released they are not speaking freely, they are being told what they can and cannot say by their captures,” Smith said.
According to the footage, Goldberg-Polin says he’s been “underground” for about 200 days, so there is “no fixed time on the video”, Smith said, adding that it’s the first video of its kind in about three months.
“Israel calls the use of these videos ‘deplorable, psychological warfare’,” Smith said.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Palestine #Gaza #Israel #IsraeliCaptive #Hamas #GazaHumanitarianCrisis #KhanYounis #Rafah #Maghazi #GazaWar #IsraelHamasWar #IsraelGazaWar #GazaShortages #GazaAid #GazaDestruction #GazaUnderAttack #GazaHospitals #GazaBombardment #GazaRefugeeCamps #GazaCity #DeirElBalah #NuseiratRefugeeCamp
U.S. has already given permission for the invasion, even if they try to say its against their will!!
it's all done with the US backing.
we told him but he didn't listen is their usual lie
I totally agree with you because the US has a tradition of saying one thing and doing another.
Same people and they wanna it .
Yes
Recently palestinians received humanitarian aid - a huge amount of pamperses
So sad
@@iosebchikvashvili1864those pampers should have been delivered to the IDF.
Hold Joe Biden and Tony Blinken responsible for enabling these atrocities.
Yeah, Joe and Tony should have asked Hamas nicely not to abduct these people...
They are the ones funding this war even an x idf soldier spoke out over what they are made to do he even said its wrong
@@WoeBringer1195 that wouldn’t have happened if those people were not on stolen lands
So sad, they don’t care about their own people 😔
@@cfwin1776 so the indians should attack the United States?
Everyday is proof that humanity has no bottom.
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)
does this include 7 th October and celebration of Hamas heinous act?
No don't put this one on humanity....the Arabs, the Israeli, their religions and their bloodthirsty gods are responsible for this. Not humanity.
@@Cyroos Does this include the 1948 occupation, murder, rape, massacre of Palestinians from their homes, villages, land by foreign Europeans with ZERO connection to Palestine?
Why would you NOT show the video? Are you kidding me?
Exactly, why waste time yakking about something they don't show.
because in the video he was criticizing Natenyaho and said stop killing us he killed most of the captives by his barbaric bombardments
@@TheraP2014 just by the picture it showed enough... by the way, its israeli media thats always yakking on things they claim and dont show
@@gingeek4776wow, and I’ve been saying the same thing this entire time 😂😂
Netenyahu wasn’t very smart by bombing indiscriminately, when the chances of the tunnels their beloved hostages are in could very well collapse in on itself as a result
they showed the whole video, its on CZcams, IG and twitter, look it up
Why won't they let him and the others go?!
Why won't Israel release the innocent prisoners they hold for no reason? Thousands of them
@@user-kq9hr2hk3c don't know how to tell you this but if you attack people on the streets no matter what the reason is and how old are you, then you should be imprisoned.
@@Nov-5062are you saying this American went to a music festival also went to attack people in Gaza and that’s why he is “imprisoned” in Gaza???
@@NgaBalkan no no no of course not, there was someone talking about palestinian prisoners and they deleted their comment. I just replied to it.
@@Nov-5062 ah got it! Thanks for explaining 👌
Don't stray either to the right or to the left,
turn your foot away from evil.
Centrists are just fascist but don’t want to admit it
Recently palestinians received humanitarian aid - a huge amount of pamperses
So sad
Oh, your Highness doths speaketh. 😂😂😂
All these people have dual nationality !
And????
90% of israels population only has 1 passport and that is the israeli passport.
@@SlayingYouDailythat explains why they are fleeing at the first sight of danger to their origin countries.
What about the ones who are only israeli? Do they not deserve to go home?
@@hawwa21 brain drain. Who would want to live in an apartheid country committing genocide?
And some pple says Israel shouldn't go into Rafa...r you kidding me?😮
Crime Minister Satanyahu.
🥱
Hahaa goodone
He's certainly S@tan
Netanyahu = king of kings
Hammas threw a grenade that took off his hand. There's a video showing them dragging him on a truck while his hand is bleedוng.
The video is on
T e l e g r a m
HAMAS is evil
It is understandable that a captive can be critical. However, and what concerns me, is the treatment of the Palestinian captives.
You should be more concerned about the 10,000 Palestinian prisoners, mostly not charged, many children, all abused and some tortured and raped!
IsraHELLi's treat the Palestinian hostages the same way they treated the dead innocent babies, children, teens, young adults and elderly throughout Gaza and the hospitals... it's shown in the mass graves unearthed these past 7 months an onward. Found dead with their hands bound behind their backs, many mutilated, disfigured, tortured and in pieces... Reich, IsraHELL?
Totally believe it because IDF some S*ck Bastards!
@@merihtouman1169I think Bradley just mentioned that!
that does not concern me at all!!
I'm tired of hearing Pro Israeli journalists what's wrong with Al Jazeera these days
It goes both ways, so don't try to smooth over anything. Why don't they talk about the 10k falsely imprisoned Palestinians. Sisi and Abdullah do not care what happens to the Palestinians, so the hypocrisy of Sisi pretending to care about casualties.
Because they are not hostages, The Palestinians in Israel are prisoners who committed crimes such as murder and murder attempt. They had a fair trial and convicted.
@@Shalom4UsNow They are falsely imprisoned. Where in a civilized country are kids tried in a military court for throwing a rock? Why is someone jailed for defending themselves? They are held in administrative detention without charges. Get your hasbara together. I wouldn’t buy into it.
@@Shalom4UsNowhow liar you're. Disgusting how much childs womens detained without trial ? Pharaons kicks you romans too europeans burns you before i don't understood i had hempaty but not any more you can't spread else than hate .
@@Shalom4UsNow They are falsely imprisoned. Where in a civilized nation is kids tried in a military court? Why is someone detained for defending their land? Why are Palestinians held in administration detention with out charges? Look into who's murdering whom. Don't spread your HASBARA because I can see right through it. I am not someone off the street to buy into the LIES people like you peddles. Keep that for yourself and those in your circle.
@Shalom4UsNow They are falsely imprisoned. Where in a civilized nation is kids tried in a military court? Why is someone detained for defending their land? Why are Palestinians held in administration detention with out charges? Look into who's murdering whom. Don't spread your HASBARA because I can see right through it. I am not someone off the street to buy into the LIES people like you peddles. Keep that for yourself and those in your circle.
I love it. You entitle the vide "Hamas releases video of Israeli-American captive held in Gaza" but then you don't show any of it, not even excerpts, and not transcript either. Your Israeli masters will be happy with you, bravo collaborators!
islamist click bait
NBC shows it.
I've been thinking Aljazeera isn't as against the war as they say they are. Nothing but profiteering.
And you don't pay attention to the word Israli American,the co lo nialists, thieves!
Shame on the USA administration.
why are you not showing the video?
NBC News shows it.
(Times Of India)
He. Israil. Mediya. Us. Hand. Or. Sapoter
Targets like children in a playground, a house with 13 children and 2 women? Is it just me or are they now deliberately going after children?
U late to the party...they v bn on it for years... thanks to social media they got no room to hide this time...
What about Palestenian hostages, including children, kidnapped by IDF?
Netanyahu have mental problem
And hamas don't 🤔
the problem is called islam
Seems Aljazeera has totally brainwashed you. Get life.
Same words were used on German guy...the irony...
Remove your brain from your bottom. That’s not where it belongs
The irony that the hostages are likely the most well fed people in gaza.
That s a lie
@@deborazandbergen6358 source? idf bot trust me bro
liar
@@DanaE-ss7zmproof?
I agree, they're looked after as proven by the released people who said they were treated with respect.
Qatari government hired PR firms to "wash" the death of over 25K workers constructing the world cup facilities.
They paid little compensation to the poor families, mostly Sri Lankan, Indian and Pakistani.
But this unjust regime is very much about justice for Palestine.
i'm sure that has absolutely nothing to do with their superiority complex, religion or desire for a worldwide caliphate, slavery and child marriage lol
@tantebaguette
Are you?
How many did US kill in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Libya, Vietnam? And Gaza still killing so shut up.
You are wrong, they don't care about Palestinian either. If they did they would have moved a finger. Nobody did anything..
@@ummabdu4862 Its rare to see actual humans instead of bots. Maybe you guys are bots.
@@user-bv5tu1qy8h your opinion doesn't concern me
There were 11 granades thrown in the shelter! Hersh and his friend threw out the granades. Hersh's friend died but saved 8 people! See CNN report where Hersh's parents are interviewed by Anderson Cooper.
Where's the video???
Where is the video mann...???
My memory is so bad, I can't be charged. But I can be President! Joey Cannibals Biden.
Aljazeera why do you blur his face? Every news outlet showed it. It’s no secret
How come none of the channels are showing the video? None of the American channels are, but I thought that this one would.
"They're not speaking freely" ???
Where the video?
Shame on Egyptian government , can't you take refugees for few days , and shame on Israel for Rafah ground invasion. , Rafah is totally the residential area of displaced civilians of Gaza. Shame on IDF for Rafah offensive , shame , shame on you IDF.
few days becomes few decades
that's why!
meanwhile, Hamas just walking around under the cover of civilians.
@@user-bh4tl6ob4v I give just suggestion. Might possible several months.
No because that is Israel’s plan all along. They want to take Gaza and build houses for settlers at the beach. Never.
If refugees go into Egypt they'll never get back in
They aren't going to tell us what he said. Bs
What did he actually say ? why can’t you show it with English subtitles
Where is abo obaida words on this channel i dont find it
You all realize that the hostage is criticizing Netanyahu because Hamas would kill him otherwise? It’s basic Prisoner of War tactics
The video deleted by CZcams you can see it in Algazera Arabic
The title of the video in Arabic
فيديو لأسير إسرائيلي
Thank you for sharing... I am sure more stories do come up... All result of the 'Bibi show'... As long, as Biden does not say stop...the whole world is watching. 💫🙏🙏
targeted genocide as opposed to...??
The word SHAME is not a thing for corrupt politician.
Why aren't you showing the actual video of the Israeli captive?!
Has come out in the meantime
Trust me... I strongly believed that, the captives are never in GAZA... They are somewhere in the neighboring countries...
Where's the live message?
Has come out from Al Jazeera.
Netanyahu must be held accountable for allowing the "laps in security" that made 10/7 possible.
IDF must be held accountable for their many war crimes.
Where is that video😢😢😢😢😢
Al jazeera arabic
Google "Hersh Goldberg"
Looks like it's being censored in the west
@@Liz-xy4vd No, I recently watched it.
@@BRNNTNT from where?
i am sure they were forced to say those things
God bless your efforts Aljazeera to cover news about my country Palestine 🇵🇸
Why is Hamas holding him
Much more targeted???
And who have they been targeting until now in Gaza? So more children and their families … Meanwhile let’s please not forget the horror and suffering of those in the West Bank…over 100 children murdered there. The vast number of mounting casualties is desensitising the world.
Dreadful.
They probably threaten his life if he didn't read their script
Bismillahir Rohmanir Rohim.
La ilaha illallahu Muhammadur rasulullah. Sollallahu alaihi wa sallam. Astagfirullah, Nastagfirullah, Allahummagfirli, Robbigfirli.
This is the son of the Mother that’s speaking out, going on news channels & speaking engagements all over. Praying this is a recent video & not Hamas psychological warfare, like when someone put a funeral wreath on the porch of the family of another hostage. 🙏🎗️😢
Except Hamas is not operating *within* Israel, so if any random one-off harassment tactics are going on, it wasn't them. But it's interesting to hear that mentioned in light of the thousands of murdered/starved non-combatant children in Gaza. Then again, these attempts at distraction from the Israeli/Likud war crimes there mirror the AIPAC-controlled US Congress, whose stance is that it only matters if it happens to Jews.
It's time to leave Ancient world problems for the Ancient world. Their religons and their bloodthirsty gods have led them to this fate. Let their religon and their gods lead them out.
Nothing to do with religion. Just a colonial land grab.
Joe Biden is doing this.
What YOU TRYING TO HIDE SHADING HIS FACE WHEN ISRAEL NEWS AND OTHERS SHOW THE WHOLE CLEAR PIC OF HIM.
Palestina 🇵🇸 livre ❤
Why don't u show his face? Too scared and drugged to be unobscured? What happened to his hand? Flew off like his sanity.
Free Falasteen free falasteen
What palestine😂DOESNT EXIST LAND THIEVES
free falafel free humus
I have mass respect for your news stations...at least your station tells the truth! Mine doesn't.
Targeted operation, sure...
stop genocide!
Wheres his face?
There is another video of Al Jazeera with his face, part of arm cut off and full message.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4ccan you provide a link?
I thought only Ukraine were allowed to use captured people in videos
Covardia
LoL, Hamas holding gun behind the camera and order to speak so. 😂
He was taken 'captive'... It sounds so innocent. They never use the word 'hostage' because that will harm their narrative.
Nothing Innocent about the word captive
How about the THOUSANDS of CAPTIVES taken by Israel and held without charge INDEFINITELY?
what about the Palestinian hostages
@@shkdesigns4249those are not hostages but criminals in jail
@@dsj82 8000 children are criminals?. please.
Ldont let him out til the Israel decided to ceasefire
Nethahooo is the main cause. His indiscriminate bombings of Gaza killed innocent civilians. No one condemned the atrocities comitted by israel on the helpless civilians of Gazam
remember vietnam?
They r not humans
Whatever
These guys all sound a bit unsure of what they do for a job.
Repeat or recite? ……….very difficult.
American israli hmmm!!and they are saying Palestinians to go from Palestine it is not yours
I have friends who are Israelis but their parents moved to Europe and they were born in Europe. So they have both citizenships...
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Hmm 🤔 what about George bush and Tony Blair 🤔
Running gag
Off with their WHiggs
Super Nova Rave festival = Zone of Interest film.
Well, if hostage families are critical of Notnowyahoo I suspect the actual hostages are more so. Seems the arm has healed well, so he definitely got medical attention? Stockholm syndrome will also have kicked in long, long ago.
clearly have no idea how sick the terrorists are they made him say every word
WHAT DID A VETERINARIAN TREAT HIM TOO LIKE MIA.
Stockholm Syndrome doesn't exist. People made up the myth because the incident was so badly handled by the police that the hostages felt safer with their captors, and no one could comprehend why anyone would fear the police more than someone taking them hostage.
Within most of Islam hostage taking suicide or terrorist attacks are not permitted They
are considered great sin In the Quran it is written that 5ff anyone killed person
unless it was for murder or spreading mischief on earth it would be as ifhe killed all of
mankind And ifanyone saved life it would be as if he had saved the lives ofall
mankind Quran 532
where's the video?? WHAT ARE YOU HIDING?? HONESTLY WE EXPECT BETTER THAN THIS FROM YOU AL JAZEERA COME ON
Al Jazeera has published the video in the meantime
(Times Of India) ✅
Powerf Hasbara indeed the wretch will not like this one bit .
Israel could never stand for the truth
ONLY THING HAMAS IS CONSISTENT IN IS EVERY TIME MOUTH OPENS LIES FALL OUT RIDICULOUS SEE THROUGH LIES JUST LIKE THEIR BOGUS PROPAGANDA
The hostage was obviously told what to say..don't be so naive
Really??!
So...?
@@semirhalilovic1567history needs to be rewritten... Those Germans were very patriotic...we know see the truth with our very own eyes...
(Times Of India) 👀
.=====> Enhance Your Satisfaction …. By Understanding Your Existence …. Se arch EXISTNC
Thetruthhurtsmeta
FUNNY YOU ONLY NEWS THAT HAS SOMETHING TO HIDE AND THE WORLD KNOWS THIS😂
And the hostages held children Palestinian in israhell jails in there own land Palastine
"Captive" what kind of semantics game are you playing Qatari-owned pro-Hamas propagandists at Al-Shiteera? Call a spade a spade. He's a hostage! And have the audacity to show the actual footage.
🕊️🇵🇸🇾🇪🇱🇧🇮🇷🇿🇦🇧🇷🕊️🌱🐡🐬🕊️
USA 🇺🇸 power is the dollar 💵
Worldwide 🗺️ trade is dollar 💵
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️
Captive? Don't you mean a peaceful individual violently taken is a hostage!
Egregious to have Hamas blame Israel for his injury. Isn't his well-being now responsibly of Hamas since held in their charge held as a hostage and held against his will???
And he is continually being harmed and exploited when all that is needed is for those holding him against his will is to safely release him. Period. And those that stole him from his loved ones be held accountable.
He is in captivity
🇵🇸❤️
So they had festive near gaza fence.. The audacity.. Of zaonists.
You must be really stupid. It was a festival celebrating peace. Many of the victims love palis. In fact, there were also moslims taken by hms. You can search for that information. One of the elderly ladys taken was part of the movement peace now. They took their own moslem brethren to gaz. Look it up.
of who? lmao nice one mo, married any children recently? or was that the other mohamed?
You lie
after; having 40,000 children, women, and babies killed are we still thinking about these Israeli hostages?
You're an idiot😢😢😢
Western media will have you believe 1 jew equals 100.000 muslim baby lives
Why not are they not human its what started it … theh were kidnapped from home imagine ur kid in thay hostage would u be saying same thing
what about the thousands of kidnapped by Israel@@harshvardhancse1
The deaths in Gaza are all the responsibility of hamas
Kristallnacht 2024!
😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂 Israel US 😂😂😂😂😂
🏳️