Buy THIS Instead of the Kindle Oasis.
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- The Kindle Oasis used to be my favorite device to recommend for anyone buying an e-reader. However, today in 2022, the Oasis has become outdated, and there are better options available. The Kobo Libra 2 is a great alternative for anyone willing to leave the Kindle ecosystem to try something different.
Kobo Libra 2: geni.us/BJ2o
Kindle Oasis: geni.us/aISmLJ1
0:00 Video Starts
0:51 - Kindle Oasis Features
2:36 - Kobo Libra 2 Features
6:50 - Final Considerations
Disclosure: Some links in the description may be affiliate links, which earn me a commission for qualifying purchases. I'm also a participant in the Amazon Associates program. To learn more, you can read my affiliate transparency disclaimer here: go.maneetpaul.com/affiliate-d...
------------------
Hi there! My name is Maneetpaul Singh, but I usually go by Maneet (pronounced muh-neet). I'm based out of NYC and make CZcams videos about Kindles and reading books. My mission to help people use Kindles to read more, learn more, and live a more present life.
I'm also a Sikh with a love for blue turbans. If you want to learn more about Sikhi and why I look the way I do, check out this short documentary I made: • THEY CALLED ME OSAMA (...
Links:
💌Subscribe to my newsletter: go.maneetpaul.com/newsletter
📚Join my book club: go.maneetpaul.com/book-club
📖Follow me on Goodreads: / maneetpaul-singh
🐦Chat with me on Twitter: / maneetpaul
📸Hang out with me on Instagram: / maneetpaul.singh
If you want to get in touch, you can also email me hello@maneetpaul.com
I literally gasped in shock when I saw the title. This is a brave statement in the e reader world 😁
As someone who's a little biased more towards Kobo than Kindle, but tries to hide that bias online (like in comments on some of your other videos), I agree with your points!
Your videos are helping me buy my first paper-like e reader! I’ve only ever tried kindle fire and i didn’t like it cause i have a tablet… but now that i read a TON more, i am researching a paper style device and these are SO HELPFUL!!! Thank you! ❤
The thing that bothers me most about the Libra 2, but I haven't seen any other review mention yet, is that raised edge on the 'handle' side. In previous Kobo generation, the entire handhold side was angled to make it easier to hold. On the new modles, there is only the very edge that is raised. I have found that, when using the Kobo for hours at a time, that edge creates a very uncomfortable pressure point on the thumb. It was so bad I found myself often holding the device by the *narrow* edge instead! The Paperwhite has been a much more natural and comfortable device to hold.
You are doing amazing veerji! Not a huge kindle user but still love watching your videos.
Really appreciate your support, veerjee! 🙏🏽
100 percent agree I just switched from the oasis to the libra 2, I love it
How would you compare performance? I’ve seen comparisons between the Libra 2 and the newest Paperwhite, and the kindle seems to be considerably quicker when navigating and turning pages. I had an Oasis which got stolen so thinking of switching to the Libra 2, but I wouldn’t want it to feel like a downgrade.
I received my Kindle Oasis ( 10th generation) about two weeks ago and it has been one of the best investments I have made in my life, not only to read everywhere but on top of that I save a lot of money I download all my books for free from the internet, upload them to my Kindle and voila
Whereas before whith regular books I had to pay for them individually like everyone else , a kindle is more practical and way cheaper in the long run
Both of these e-readers are great, and the choice comes down to preference. Here are other things to consider :
Before I got my Kindle, I did a lot of research and one thing that stunned me was the life span of the Kindle vs the Kobo. I saw a few videos in which Kobo users stated that they woke up one day and their Kobo refused to work and they had to replace it. Whereas, I saw videos of people still using their first gen Kindle. I don't doubt that Kindle oasis may have the same problem, I just didn't see any videos when I made my choice.
Since I'm not one to change devices so long as the one I have still works (I have an iphone 5), I went with the better quality finish.
For me the page turn buttons are a must, and them not always working on the Kobo is a straight no.
The USB-C isn't a game changer for me. I charge my e-reader maybe once a week, so really I have no issues with this.
Finally, since I move around with my Kindle and read in different places at different hours of the day, the automatic temperature control has become a feature I greatly appreciate. It's a shame the Kobo doesn't have it.
As for the eco-system, this is where I had issues with Kindle as it is a closed system. Yes, one can transfer any books with 3rd party apps, but it is a bother. With the Kobo, this isn't an issue. This is where I find the Kobo shines over the Kindle.
Finally, there is the ethical choice. And this it where it pains me to have a Kindle. But I read in English, French and Spanish and the place that has the biggest collection of e-books is still Amazon.
Whether one has a Kobo, a Kindle or another type of e-reader, the objectif is to read. As long as that is possible and enjoyable, go for it, regardless of the brand.
I rely on Calibre to transfer non-Amazon books, many from Guttenberg.
@@williamlaine2116 I do too, but it is still a hassle...
With your ending, what was the point of this then?
I will say my newer kindle has not held up as well as my older kindles have. It just died one day and stopped working after only two years where I still use my voyage from 2014 and my really old paperwhite that was purchased before my voyage. I don’t think they are built as well now IMO.
@@nerdanalog1707I use kindle app on my iPad - two clicks and any book or a web article is sent to the device
I just bought a Kobo Libra 2 a couple of weeks ago - am loving it! And the Kobo Plus catalogue available here in Australia. I had no problems with my Kobo Aura H2O, so I'm giving it to my husband. I also have a Kindle paperwhite and had issues with the new software update and had to do a factory reset, because it wasn't syncing properly. it seems fine now. Kobo was the first e-reader I started with in 2011 and I purchased a kindle a few years later so I could read Kindle Unlimited books.
Amazon in the US has a 30 day return policy for both Kindle and Kobo readers so I decided to try both and keep the one I like better.
The Oasis is more comfortable to use one-handed due to its shape and lighter weight, but due to its slipperiness the grip I have to use when reading in bed requires inverting the page turn button directions, the setting for which is buried seven levels deep in the menu.
The Libra 2 is somewhat less comfortable to use with one hand but still good enough to do so, and grippy enough in any reading position to always keep the same button settings. That combined with its much sharper screen made the Libra the device to keep for me.
I am having trouble making up my mind too for prime day. I am glad I can buy both and try them out.
The thing about metal chassis is once you put a cover on it (which you are likely to do on a reader) the 'quality feel' disappears.
If you want the Oasis, don't give up on it because of the price. Rather look for refurbished ones. I just got mine through Amazons refurbished program for 150 dollars (32 GB and without advertisement). So my Oasis was even cheaper than the new Paperwhite Signature
This is exactly what I did as well. Still has the 1 year warranty and I don't see where it was ever used. Looks brand new
This is a great option. Buying Amazon refurbished feels like new, but at half the cost.
Great video
Always love your videos. You one of the guys that influenced me to get a Kindle. By the way, I just wonder, how many e-readers actually you need? 😆
Need? Just one.
Actually have? Too many 😅
Oasis grip- I've improved grip by changing the reading orientation to 'landscape' and reading with the 'heavy/thick' section on the bottom & in my hand. If you Really like holding the Oasis with thick-side to the side you can run a length of painters tape along the curve between the thin/thick sections.
Thanks! Good tips!
. Reading stats & badges
. Overdrive
. Pocket
. Library theme (instead of kindle which interface looks like a cellphone more and more.
These 4 details are making me buy the Kobo Libra 2 even owing the Kindle Oasis already.
Love my Kindle Oasis, also love my Kobo Sage. In an ideal world I’d just buy them all, they all have pros and cons. I regularly use both these two though, but I really like the extra space on the Sage, means I can read some things which don’t display as well on the Kindle.
Hi,dude,I never used any E-ink devices, can we browse internet and download pdf's in Kindle oasis,or can you please suggest me which Kindle version has the browser and can download pdf's from internet. Thanks in advance.
Even with the Oasis recently on sale for $199 (8GB model), I still chose the Libra for one reason. Auto-rotate!! It’s crazy to me that the kindle can only be horizontal or vertical, but not both.
I agree. I decided to get an eReader & bought a paperwhite signature edition (on sale) oasis (on sale), & Libra 2 to test drive all 3 of them for a few weeks to decide which one suited me best. I was really surprised by how much better the UI & ergonomics of the Libra 2 was compared to the two Kindles. Much better experience overall. Also installed Koblime on it for that 2-way sync & backup the Kindles have. Perfection.
Thank you!
the Kindle Keyboard, the first one I bought was fantastic and I feel that every Kindle I have had since is inferior. It had page turn "buttons" on both sides of the screen; the top ones to go forward and the bottom ones to go back. It was brilliant to navigate and so easy to organize my books. The Kindle Paperwhite I have now is OK but a pain if I want to check on facts from another book and accessing Collections is a nightmare+. Kindle should go back to the beginning.
That would be cool if they released a Kindle Classic model with updated screen, but had the form factor from the keyboard 3. That was my first and one of my favorite Kindle models that I’ve owned.
I buy 100% of my books and audiobooks in my 300+ book "library" from Amazon, so I guess I'm stuck with the Kindle line. 📚
Yep, if you're deep in Amazon's ecosystem, it's hard to switch. I relate!
I have long wanted to buy a Kobo e-reader as Kindle e-readers are not compatible with libraries here in Canada. What has held me back is the number of reports of poor QC with Kobo combined with extremely bad customer service if you have a problem.
Could you please comment on how accurate this info is?
Great but the kindle has the x-ray feature, which is essential for my interest. No other ereader has anything like x-ray right?
I want to get my first ereader soon. I am leaning towards getting a Kobo device because of the overdrive feature where I can get books for free at my local library in Canada. I also don't want to bother with the extra steps to get epub books on kindle devices. Lol I'm considering the Libra 2 and Clara HD. I read Kobo could be releasing an updated version of the Clara HD. My buy target is around the end of Oct or first week of Nov. I'm hoping they will release a new device then.
The Clara HD is long overdue for an update. I’m sure we’ll find out soon! I think Kobo is the right choice for you 👍🏽
Stating with my kindle oasis until it stops working. Then moving to another kindle. However if you do not have an ereader you should consider other platforms.
Where can I find a e-reader that can text to speech as it is in the kindle fire with different voice profiles you can choose from.
Be able to follow along with audible book and the kindle book at the same time.
I just got the new signature kindle, really disappointed. You can use the screen reader but it is clunky and you can only change the speech speed. You either listen to the audiobook or read it but you can't do both at the same time. Do you know if a reader that can and still access kindle unlimited library. I really appreciate your videos.
very good video and very solid points.
I do like the Kobo Libra (as I've mentioned before). I did play around with the page turn buttons and they "flip" the page no matter where I push them. So maybe QA/QC is letting some poor quality buttons slip through.
My big issue is that it still randomly goes to sleep when I'm reading it. I know for sure it isn't because I've pushed some button accidentally. It doesn't happen often (about 7 times since Dec), and sometimes it'll come back on again by itself before I have a chance to do something. My suspicion is that it has something to do with the sleep cover activating sleep mode from the back.
The ecosystem isn't an issue as I don't plan on buying anything from Kobo. I get enough books from the library, and my Amazon books I've already run through Calibre so now I can convert them for reading on any device I choose, not just Kindle.
So interesting that you aren't having any issues with the buttons. Maybe I'm just really unlucky! And yes, the sleep issue you're describing sounds like it could be related to the sleep cover. That's annoying!
I have so many books on my Amazon account there is no going away from a Kindle. I am smart enough to remove DRM on the Amazon books and uploading them do a different e-reader but I am too lazy. Not to mention my mom will have a tough time doing it. Also Kindle Unlimited
Same. I went to an iPad mini recently and love it. I don’t do a lot of direct sunlight reading so it works for me. And a color display is so important to me!
@@mamatidbits I tried that for a while but I can do much more careless with my kindle. I toss that thing anywhere and anyhow. It is surprisingly tough
@@rcuadro that’s so true. Also I still use my Oasis in the hot tub. I would cry if I dropped my iPad in there 😅
Thank you
I chose kobo over the kindle, mainly because I don't live in the USA 😅 Kindle unlimited isn't available over here and also I can't buy books without a credit card ( here It's normal to pay with debit so I don't have one ). So getting kindle books would be too much for a hassle unfortunately. I would really loved the PW5 if it wasn't for the amazon ecosystem.
The country you live in makes a BIG difference. For moth places outside of America, the Kindle ecosystem is difficult to use.
Would you suggest using a screen protector on the Kindle? I heard even the matte ones give off more glare than the actual screen.
I personally use a case, but no screen protector. I never enjoyed using those.
I will wait Oasis to update before I buy it. Here in Brazil Kobo left, now there is only Kindle.
In my country, the price gap is small. Have a hard time deciding which one to buy
I’m agreed with you. I have a Kobo libra 2 and I really love it. The only facts that make me prefer the Kindle oasis it’s the material. The Kobo libra is made with plastic, a resistant plastic but plastic and my edges have just broken after few months 🥲
I just checked the prices of both devices (here in Germany) and the Kobo Libra 2… is actually more expensive! 199€ 😮
The Kindle Oasis is 179€.
I want to upgrade my eBook reader and I actually liked the Kindle Oasis (and I was hoping for a new version!) but I think I will wait a little bit more
32gb? no ads ?
I wonder if the page turn buttons make a noise when pressed? I read in bed while my husband sleeps and this could be a deciding factor…
Have you tried out the Kobo Forma?
Brother what is the budget e ink note taking device??
where do you buy books for the Kobo
Just got a Kindle Oasis from woot which is an Amazon owned company, refurbished for 150. Love it.
Enjoy! That's a great deal
help i cannot buy kobo in india any way to buy?
Great content .. does Libra 2 have auto rotate ?
Yes
I have been so torn between oasis and Libra 2. I already have an older Paperwhite but I don't think it's very sharp. If I buy both can I return the one I don't like from Amazon?
The Libra 2 isn't sold by Amazon directly, so I'm not sure how returns work. I'm assuming you can return it, but it might not be as simple as normal Amazon returns. You'll notice the Libra 2 isn't marked with the "Prime" label, because it's sold by Kobo and is just listed on Amazon.
You can return the Kobo within 30 days for any reason! I bought mine directly from Kobo
Kobo ftw as I can basically borrow any books for free using the overdrive feature from my national library. So cool
Where to buy in India.
The page-turn buttons on both the Libra and the Sage suck big time. They’re too small, too flush with the handle, flimsy, and they just don’t work sometimes which is so Annoying you’ll stop using them altogether. Especially on the Sage which is Kobo’s flagship e-reader, this is unacceptable. Also, I find the overall speed of the interface on the Kindles much much better than the Kobo’s. (I’ve used various Kindle and Kobo devices through the years).
The Libra 2 and Oasis 3 are the same price where I live.
I have a Kindle Voyage which also has the physical page turn buttons (not really like buttons though, something different wih haptic feedback) and in my opinion, way better than the Oasis. I wish they would revive that model and give it another go.... Also, my complaint with the Oasis, for $279 this should definitly have a faster processor AND usb-c. There is no excuse for this....
I love your videos and they are a good source of info....
So if you have a kindle why do you have so many books behind you ? Does kindle have every book you can ever need ?
My chief criticism of my Oasis 2 is the battery life of about 6 hours of reading without the lights or WiFi, on a charge. You don't discuss battery life.
Yeah my battery life isn't this bad but it definitely isn't great. Doesn't bother me tho so not an issue for me. Still love it.
why do you need to keep the wifi on while reading ? I only turn on the wifi to download the book. The only reason to turn on the wifi is when you want to read wikipedia while reading.
I said I use WiFi only to download books. Without it or light on, I should get the longest time on a charge, not only about 6 hours.
@@williamlaine2116 Ah! Sorry buddy I miss read your comment. My experience with the battery has been very good. I get 6 days from my oasis from 0 to 100. Brightness 7, warmth 6, wifi turned off, bluetooth turned off and no dark mode. Dark mode on kindle consumes more battery than the light mode. It's because of the screen tech kindle uses. In dark mode kindle has to color the entire page black with e ink while in light mode it's only the letters. Also standby on oasis for me is insane. Easy 2 to 3 weeks or maybe more. Hope that helps. :)
@@sanwalfarooque2747 Thanks. I don't use dark mode but thought it used less power. The battery level guide is misleading: I turn my Oasis 2 to sleep & may find the level down by 35% the next day. I also don't use its Bluetooth.
I gave up on my Oasis almost 6 months ago. I went with a Fire tablet instead, but that's only because I'm so enmeshed in the Kindle universe with over 5000 titles on my device right now. I was really impressed with the Kobo, but didn't want to have to try to repurchase or convert my titles.
5000! You're a walking library! :) I thought I had a lot of books on my Kobo (over 400 now). Wow, 5000!
thats how bezos get you sadly.
I have the same issue with about 2600 books.
Likely pirated and you’ve probably only read less than 5% of those titles.
I use a pop socket with my oasis which alleviates the of a case
The best is to buy one of the latest android e-readers like the BOOX leaf or the BOOX Nova Air so you have both Kindle and Kobo books plus everything else.
I was wondering if you had forgotten about the Paperwhite 5, but then I checked the date on this video. I guess the Libra 2 made some kind of sense before the PW5 came out.
april 22, 2022, that was yesterday from me 😅 the Libra 2 and PW5 are both out this moment. Or I don't understand you well? 🤔
@@quintym7090 I thought it was last year. I guess it isn't.
I wonder when Oasis will drop the price knowing they are selling a premium product that isn't their best product in there line of Kindels. That or they will have to revamp it to make it better or discontinue it all together. I still love my Oasis and wouldn't want anything different but it isn't the best one. I have to have the buttons and to be honest the metal design is nice but who notices it when you have to put a cover on it because it is so slippery. Lol What do you think will become of the Oasis in the future? Love to get your thoughts.
Honestly, I think Amazon will stop making the Oasis like they did the Voyage. They'll probably replace it with something else. I hope I'm wrong, though!
@@Maneetpaul I kind of agree with you.
Do you think Amazon secretly bought Kobo and plans to upgrade Oasis by adding features of Kobo (and eleminating Kobo competition at the same time)? I’m speculating because Amazon buys companies routinely and Kobo is now being sold on Amazon, which is strange (except if it’s because Amazon bought it and is in process of integrating).
Kobo was bought by Rakuten so it's technically a Rakuten subsidiary. I don't think Rakuten will go through a divestiture in the near future. I'd say this is unlikely.
What? Oasis is the most ergonomic ereader. I tried paper white, but it’s terrible compared to oasis.
Had the libra 2, had to return it, software was too buggy, the OS didn't feel cohesive and the store to me is a joke with its suggestions and presentation. Also the cheap creaky plastic (had 3 different libra 2's) and those annoying rocker buttons (vs the oasis ones) just turned me off. Stuck with the new PW instead, also plastic/rubber, but much better on the build quality imo.
I don't know why I'm watching this since Kobo is not even available I'm my country
I’ve got both. The kindle oasis is superior in every way.
Not in every way. The price sucks 😂
@@pedecia fair point. I paid £25 more for my oasis 2 than the kobo.
@@johnw9981 I went to see the oasis yeaterday and held it in my hand... Such a nice device with premium materials used..... I think well worth the price difference... You will use it for many years to come..... I will not purchase the kobo now. Probably I will go for the BOOX Nova Air instead. Premium materials and android ereader but cost evem more 😂
It's CARTA. Cart-tuh...
Not car-tra.
Lol, I'm kidding of course, but you've mispronounced that word in every video. And it's driving me crazy. I feel better now. 😁
What about the thousands of dollars worth of Kindle books I've purchased over the years?
man your tripping.... kindle is the king of the ereaders!!!!
For the price point, I’d consider getting the larger Kobo Sage 📏🤔🧐 But the Oasis 3 and Libra 2 is an apt comparison. I had to get both since I have large manga libraries in both Amazon and Rakuten Kobo. I also have a medium-sized manga library in Barnes & Noble. And, yes, I have used up all the internal storage in all 3 32GB devices 📚📚📚😎👍🏽
HOWEVER, all my audiobooks are on Audible and 99% of my 400+ e-books are on Amazon Kindle 📚😎👍🏽
Is the small battery not a concern in the sage? I received it few days ago from amazon but returning it and gping to get an android BOOX ereader. Unfortunately cannot open it and return it here in japan. Must be sent back packed and new.
@@pedecia
The battery is terrible, yes. I’d either keep it plugged in most of the time or get the battery cover, like the Oasis 1 🔋🧐🤔
Thank you!