சூப்பர் ஸ்டார் போட்டுத் தந்த காபி | அன்னக்கிளி ஆர் செல்வராஜ் | Chai With Chithra | Part 3

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
  • #rselvaraj #rselvarajinterview #chaiwithchithra #Rajinikanth
    சூப்பர் ஸ்டார் போட்டுத் தந்த காபி | அன்னக்கிளி ஆர் செல்வராஜ் | Chai With Chithra | Exclusive Interview | Part 3
    TO SUBSCRIBE TOURING CINEMAS
    / @touringcinemas
    For Advertisement & Enquiry : mktg.t.talkies@gmail.com
    contact no : 7358576544
    For All Latest Updates:
    Like us on: / toouringtalkies
    watch us on: touringtalkies.co/
    Follow us on: / toouringtalkies
    / toouringtalkiess
    subscribe us on :
    / @touringtalkiescinema
    *************************************************************************************************

Komentáře • 122

  • @pandiyann4896
    @pandiyann4896 Před 4 lety +32

    தலைவர்க்காகவே வந்தேன் . தமிழ்நாட்டின் சூப்பர் ஸ்டார் கையால் காபி கசக்கவா செய்யும் அருமையாக சொன்னார் நன்றி ....

  • @skskr1884
    @skskr1884 Před 4 lety +56

    செல்வராஜ்சார் இந்தி பட சீன் சொன்னீர்களே அதை கேட்டு இப்பொழுதுகூட அதிர்ந்தேன்
    நீங்கள் என்றும் திறமையான
    ரைட்டர்தான். இன்னும் நிறைய
    படங்கள் பண்ண வேண்டும்.வாழ்த்துகள்.

  • @shaijuraj1505
    @shaijuraj1505 Před 4 lety +10

    நல்ல நண்பர் தன்னையும் தாழ்த்தாமல் தன் நண்பர்களையும் தாழ்த்தாமல் காப்பார்... இவர் நல்ல நண்பர்

  • @senthilnathanganapathy2585
    @senthilnathanganapathy2585 Před 4 lety +10

    செல்வராஜ் பேட்டி சூப்பர். கதை கேட்டுக்கொண்டு சிறுவன்போல் வாய்பார்த்து நின்றேன். மூன்று பகுதிகளும் பார்க்க தொடர்கதை ஆவல்போல் இருந்தது

  • @ramvenkatesh9554
    @ramvenkatesh9554 Před 4 lety +16

    ஆர். செல்வராஜ் ஹிந்தி படத்துக்கு கதை எழுதின விஷயத்தை கேட்டுட்டு யூடியூப்ல போய் பார்த்தேன் .அவர் சொன்னமாதிரியே டைட்டில் கார்டுல முதல்ல கதை திரைக்கதை ஆர்.செல்வராஜ்னு பேர் பாத்து ரொம்ப மெய்சிலிர்த்துப்போனேன்

    • @ramvenkatesh9554
      @ramvenkatesh9554 Před 4 lety +1

      That Hindi film is "Sone pe suhaaga" . We can see his name in title card @ 11:46

    • @nagarajanss6872
      @nagarajanss6872 Před 4 lety

      How many Hindi films Sir? Very happy to know you have faced stiff competition from Mr Khader khan and succeeded

  • @sithishnews6903
    @sithishnews6903 Před 4 lety +9

    Selvaraj sir you're wonderful humen being, we pray for you long healthy life

  • @gomathik3107
    @gomathik3107 Před 4 lety +16

    *0.35 about Thalaivar*

  • @sankaranc3178
    @sankaranc3178 Před 3 lety

    கே. வி மகாதேவன் அவர்களே சிறந்த இசை அமைப்பாளர்
    என்ற தீர்ப்பு. .....நன்று.

  • @lu-sci-ou-sat
    @lu-sci-ou-sat Před 4 lety +18

    Mr R Selvaraj was the story writer for Alaipayuthey..Why mr Chithra lakshman didn't ask this? Disappointed interview with great personality!!

  • @jaileader
    @jaileader Před 4 lety +2

    I have seen all three parts.......... really inspiring.... thx

  • @krisvel111
    @krisvel111 Před 4 lety +3

    Class interview....looks he is great human being

  • @priyahnj7402
    @priyahnj7402 Před 4 lety +3

    Super sir really good feeling s sir.

  • @lkpk536
    @lkpk536 Před 4 lety +17

    Disappointing to see that this has ended so shortly Sir. No story on collaboration with Mani rathnam

  • @karthigeyancmt2398
    @karthigeyancmt2398 Před 4 lety +3

    What a great legend he is!!!

  • @user-tj8cj8dy3z
    @user-tj8cj8dy3z Před 4 lety +7

    அலைபாயுதே பற்றி கேட்கவேயில்லையே சித்ராசார்?????? எப்டி மிஸ் பண்ணீங்கண்ணே???

  • @roserose2627
    @roserose2627 Před 4 lety +1

    Excellent. Thank you Chitra sir.

  • @sachinsachin-ek5zr
    @sachinsachin-ek5zr Před 4 lety +11

    ரஜினி அருமையான மனிதர்

    • @INDHRAJITH643
      @INDHRAJITH643 Před 4 lety

      useless fellow

    • @sravi955
      @sravi955 Před 4 lety +5

      @@INDHRAJITH643 போட பொட்ட தெவடியா பயலே நாற கூ தி மவணே ஒத்தா கொம்மாலஒக்க

  • @natarajansuresh6148
    @natarajansuresh6148 Před 4 lety +12

    புல்லாங்குழல் கொடுத்த மூங்கில்களே இசை m s v. Selvaraj sir

    • @vasudevancv8470
      @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety +2

      The comedy is he said he had a Cassette with him Fully Containing Pullanguzhal Kodutha MoongilgaLe Song alone throughout - playing continuously. He praised the song to Sky High without knowing MSV was the Composer. He didn't even listen to Chitra Lakshmanan who corrected him saying it's not KVM, But, MSV. Any way it's a Thumping Victory to MSV. Pallandu Pallandu Pallayirathaandu is a verse written by Periyaazhwar, but this man wrongly said it's by AandaaL. I saw a few years ago in Sun Music, "Chippi Irukkudhu" Song was shown as Music by IR. In another Video in the U.Tube, for Ore Vaanam Ore Bhoomi Song "VaLaamaana Bhoomiyil Sugamaana KalaimagaL" photo of IR is shown instead of MSV. Let these illeterates wallow in ignorance. God only should save.

  • @nsanand84
    @nsanand84 Před 4 lety +1

    Sir excellent Interview... Pls inform to Mr R Selvaraj to create a Wikipedia page for him....

  • @novycher
    @novycher Před 4 lety +1

    R, Selvaraj அவர்களை ஒரு முறையாவது பார்த்து விடவேண்டும். ரஷ்ய குடிமகனாகி இன்றுதான் படிக்க ஆரம்பிக்கிறேன். இறைவனின் ஆசி உங்களுடன்...

  • @kesavarajgopalan6033
    @kesavarajgopalan6033 Před 4 lety +2

    For thalaivar

  • @srinevasanam2589
    @srinevasanam2589 Před 4 lety +1

    RS sir very nice heart touching frank open speech,Ur character is also very nice , in particular for ur behaviour for not mixing with people who are big and busy in their field not to mingle and keep away inside the border without crossing until they call you nice Ur comment about Khadarkhan is also good, on tamilians in Bombay Cinema , But they respected our Sivaji verymuch, Acors like Prithivirajkapoor, Rajendrakumar, Sunidutt, Dilip Kumar, Sanjeev Kumar Dev Anad !ashok Kumar and many others , AMSrinevasan

  • @gmsfootwear2490
    @gmsfootwear2490 Před 4 lety +5

    Humble Human Thalaivar

  • @karthigeyancmt2398
    @karthigeyancmt2398 Před 4 lety +1

    Very innocent man

  • @Pandiyankaliaperumal
    @Pandiyankaliaperumal Před 4 lety +2

    Nice interview with a great story writer and human being. As others told in the comments section me too felt the interview finished abruptly. Other than that excellent interview. Probably considering the length of the interview would have been edited by the editor abruptly. But still great narration by the writer, I wish Tamil film industry should utilize him.

  • @rathispositiveview
    @rathispositiveview Před 4 lety +2

    Addicted to your show..👁👁👁👁

  • @karunavijai
    @karunavijai Před 4 lety +2

    Sir you telling Hindi story en kannula neer kasiyudhu sir goospambs.

  • @balajibala9782
    @balajibala9782 Před 4 lety +1

    R.Selvaraj Sir speech super.

  • @thirumalaip7895
    @thirumalaip7895 Před 4 lety +1

    Very innocent speech

  • @mathik1000
    @mathik1000 Před 4 lety +1

    Valuable information. U done good job sir.

  • @r.sudarson760
    @r.sudarson760 Před 4 lety +2

    Excellent

  • @vishalraj-yf8jn
    @vishalraj-yf8jn Před 4 lety +3

    Watched the whole series.. a gentleman to the core.. love him..

  • @YTD72
    @YTD72 Před 4 lety +3

    Most interesting interview
    Among all Chai With Chitra episodes but Chitra was irritating with cutting off Selvaraj many times and ending abruptly.

  • @rajasekaranrajasekaran2918
    @rajasekaranrajasekaran2918 Před 4 lety +11

    அங்கோவார்ட் பற்றிய தங்கள் முயற்ச்சி வெற்றி பெற வாழ்த்துகள் சார்....

  • @sathizstyle1484
    @sathizstyle1484 Před 4 lety +8

    ThaLaivaR...😉

  • @drgunasekarank159
    @drgunasekarank159 Před 4 lety +6

    ஜெய்கணேஷ் குரல் மாதிரி இருக்கு

  • @shreyavikram267
    @shreyavikram267 Před 4 lety +11

    அவரோட ஹிந்தி பட அனுபவங்களை எல்லாம் இன்னும் கேட்டு நிறைய விஷயங்களை நீங்க தெரிய படுத்தியிருக்கலாம். திருப்பி திருப்பி பாரதிராஜா முதல் மரியாதையை பத்தியே கேக்குறீங்களே சார்!

    • @Indian2285
      @Indian2285 Před 4 lety

      அத்தனை இந்தி படங்களும் அந்த ஒரு முதல்மரியாதை க்கு ஈடாகாது என்பதால்...

  • @RajaN-ef8sz
    @RajaN-ef8sz Před 4 lety +2

    Super sar

  • @venkatesanr2828
    @venkatesanr2828 Před rokem

    Good

  • @dinakarkasi
    @dinakarkasi Před 4 lety +1

    உயிருள்ள குழந்தையை எறிந்த O.ஹென்றியின் சிறு கதையை அப்படியே எடுத்து உங்கள் ஹிந்தி படத்தில் வைத்துவிட்டு இந்தியாபூராவும் என் சீனைப் பாத்து மிரண்டுருச்சுங்குறாரு....

  • @shreyavikram267
    @shreyavikram267 Před 4 lety +11

    செல்வமணிக்க்கெல்லாம் 6 பகுதிகள். இவருக்கு மட்டும் 3 பகுதிகள்.. நீங்க எதோ பேட்டியை முடிக்க அவசர படற மாதிரியே தெரியுது? ஏன்?

    • @ashwinachu5610
      @ashwinachu5610 Před 3 lety

      சித்ரா சார் பேச்சின் (உரையாடல்) இடையே திசை திருப்புகிறார். தெளிவாக தெரிகிறது.

  • @itzthebeebrothers7848
    @itzthebeebrothers7848 Před 4 lety +1

    Part 2 not published.. please do it chitra sir

  • @sundararajanmurari222
    @sundararajanmurari222 Před 3 lety

    Selvaraj is a remarkable man. , அவரை சினிமா என்கிற குறுகிய வட்டகுள்ளதில் அட் அடிக்கிட்டகளே

  • @soundirarajansoundirarajan5371

    Very good man

  • @kannanvasudevan9665
    @kannanvasudevan9665 Před 4 lety +1

    Wow 😄

  • @joetv533
    @joetv533 Před 4 lety

    super

  • @panneerselvam4959
    @panneerselvam4959 Před 3 lety

    பாலதண்டாயுதத்தின் நண்பர்செல்வராஜ்...

  • @Manikandan-yl9od
    @Manikandan-yl9od Před 4 lety +8

    Thalaivara.....

  • @SELVARAJ-cx2of
    @SELVARAJ-cx2of Před 4 lety

    Superb cl sir n rs sir

  • @shanke300
    @shanke300 Před 4 lety +1

    Too many cuts. There is no full interview. Sad.

  • @sravi955
    @sravi955 Před 4 lety +2

    தலைவருக்காக பார்த்தேன். சூப்பர்.

  • @jaileader
    @jaileader Před 4 lety

    அந்த இந்த பட சீன் சூப்பர்.... .

  • @marimuthuas4165
    @marimuthuas4165 Před 4 lety +6

    Sri devi father Iyyappan was from Sivakasi & not Virudhunagar. Of course they are nearby. Bhagdad city is not in Iran. It is in Iraq.
    Understandably, you both don't want to reveal the "open secrets" of partition between Ilayaraja & Vairamuthu , though you both should know them very well.
    It has been widely reported on the reasons for separation, on on line.
    1. Vairamuthu had objected to Ilayaraja's music in a film whose music muted ,in his opinion, his lyrical line's as it could not be heard & appreciated by the audience.
    2. This one is somewhat more serious as reported in media.
    Vairamuthu had reportedly made some innuendo ( indirect slur) against Ilayaraja's caste back round in a public platform.
    3. Vairamuthu wanted to write all songs for a film which Ilayaraja changed in a film roping in Poet Vali.
    4. Vairamuthu while being busy didn't come in time whenever called by Ilayaraja.
    5. Ilayaraja changed his poetic lines when he didn't come in time for a film.
    These could be false or true. Truth could be more or elsewhere. But all these are in online.
    The fault presumably lies only with Vairamuthu. One must be aware of practical truths most notably in film world .
    Once, it must be at Vairamuthu's behest, Sri Karunanidhi himself made a oblique request to Ilayaraja to patch up with Vairamuthu. Ilayaraja didn't listen.
    Recently when ilayaraja was hospitalized again Vairamuthu had obliquely made a laudatory reference to him on a public platform for his recovery in a bid to patch up.Both too didn't work for vairamuthu.
    Then he tried through Seenu Ramasamy to permit him to write atleast one song in a yet to be released film produced by Ilayaraja's son Yuvan shankar raja.
    He was rebuffed sternly. This third attempt too fell flat.
    The reason is quite simple if we add up all facts arithmetically.
    Both have deep ego. One has much more than the other. But the other one is forbidden by his ego to go to Ilayaraja to talk frankly & patch up.
    He might have thought that It might be construed below his dignity or as surrender.
    Vairamuthu should have learnt from Bharathiraja. The latter has no ego hassels at all. He is frank & also forthright in his views. Both traits are welcome.
    He has had many differences in the past with illayaraja . Still they have been reunited all the time. How could it be ?
    Many times Bharathy Raja had acknowledged & said that ilayaraja was a real genius in music. None could match him. That is an acknowledged truth by one & all. Vairamuthu differs & contests that.
    Bharathy Raja or Vairamuthu can claim excellency justifiably in their respective field but not geniousness.
    Bharathiraja knows this truth. But Vairamuthu's ego refuses to accept this. He wants equality with Ilayaraja.
    Ego is a virus in one's personality. It keeps chasing mirages in practical life. Ego less is the happiest state & a peaceful paradise.
    Even an amateur poet knows this. Unfortunately a great poet like Vairamuthu is ignorant.
    Ilayaraja exhibits his ego through his work & also his acerbic speech while Vairamuthu in his laudatory speech only.
    The public forgives Ilayaraja whereas it is not prepared to confer equality on Vairamuthu at par with Ilayaraja.
    The difference is rhat Ilayaraja's ego is tougher but he is very honest. He has a helping attitude but obstinate too. Yet he never forgets or forgives other's insults.
    Vairamuthu should know the history. There were many like him who were on the wrong side of ilayaraja.
    Examples.
    L R Eswari refused to sing his first song in Annakili.
    P. Suseela blamed Ilayaraja for her error in singing in a film when ilayaraja was an assistant to music director Kumar.
    T.M.S Soundararajan insulted Ilayaraja on a public platform.
    None of them were given chances to sing in ilayaraja music in films subsequently except occasionally.
    Janaki was too willing to sing his first song in Annakili. She has been
    his favorite singer since then.
    What ordinary people like most - music or poetry ? Undoubtedly music.
    Who cares about poetry except very few intellectuals ?
    Vairamuthu should have realized all these facts & accepted the reality. His ego only has spoiled his career for so long.
    Besides, if Ilayaraja had denied him the first chance & persisted in his refusal to Bharathiraja then where would have been Vairamuthu ?
    He would not have been known to the film goers nor to anyone in the industry till today . All his books would be sleeping in library.
    He should have been grateful to others for their help. Gratitude is not Vairamuthu's great forte, it seems.
    But ilayaraja is still grateful to Panchu Arunachalam for giving him the first break in film music.
    And also to S. P. Balasubramaniam who helped him prior to his entry into film world.
    Life is all about mutuality. None can stand on his own.
    Unfortunately both fools & intelligent are in denial mode of this maxim.

    • @prabhuchennai4027
      @prabhuchennai4027 Před 4 lety

      Arumai'ana introspection(idhuku Tamil varthai theriala)...most high light of the above points: people like music than poetry: unmain'ana vishyam, ungal puridhal parata'thakavai....valthukal, Mr Marimuthu

    • @marimuthuas4165
      @marimuthuas4165 Před 4 lety

      @@prabhuchennai4027
      நன்றி.
      Introspection = சுய பரிசோதனை

    • @Relaxingtime4me
      @Relaxingtime4me Před 4 lety

      Could have been short and articulate. Can't concentrate half way through. Kadaisila enna thaan solla vareengannu suthama puriyala. I agree about Ilayaraja's ego, but I like him. Vairamuthu, I hate him, but Ilayaraja illana Vairamuthu vala thirai ulagathuku vanthirukka mudiyathunnu neenga solra point debatable. Who are we to know God's plans for someone?

  • @indianindian8045
    @indianindian8045 Před 4 lety +1

    very simple & straight man

  • @ganapathis1989
    @ganapathis1989 Před 4 lety

    Small correction please - Nutan was travelling with Khader Khan and not with Anubam Kour.

  • @jayakumarseenivasan
    @jayakumarseenivasan Před 4 lety +1

    Y sir, didn't speak about "அலைபாயுதே"?

  • @prabakarangovindarajgovind4279

    Selvaraj sir ungala patha majar suntharajan sir mathiri irukinga

  • @josenub08
    @josenub08 Před 4 lety +3

    everything was good. abruptly winded up the talk.

  • @TheYoga1212
    @TheYoga1212 Před 4 lety +1

    Sir when you will do long interview with your director ????

  • @banairamaswamybalan5354

    The replies are abstract.

  • @shr011104
    @shr011104 Před 4 lety +12

    Chitra Ji, looks like you were deliberately cutting Mr Selvaraj short and way too many edits too. All these days, I was of the thought that this was an honest attempt by you to bring the interesting stories behind movies, but now disappointed that you too are releasing only comfortable content.

    • @vasudevancv8470
      @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety +1

      No, Never. What he projected sometime ago about the relationship between Jaishankar & MGR was utter false. People in the film industry during Mid 1960's to late 1970s very well knew about the soured relationship between these two. Especially, in 1977-78, when Jaishankar acted in Kalaignar's film, Vandikkaaran Magan which had a political colour and had a dig at MGR and the ruling AIADMK Govt made MGR even more unhappy and when Jaishankar tried to meet CM MGR to handover flood relief donation, he refused to meet Jaishankar and also not accepted the flood relief donation money reportedly given by Jai. This sensation news came in many Thamizh News papers at that time. Chitra Lakshmanan conveniently covered up that incident. There was said to be one more sensitive matter for the soured relationship between MGR & Jai which is unwise to be mentioned here.

  • @haarshanhaarshan7553
    @haarshanhaarshan7553 Před 4 lety +1

    Chitra sir sivachandran sir interview marathudathinga

  • @rn2226
    @rn2226 Před 4 lety

    ❤️

  • @cramesh2576
    @cramesh2576 Před 4 lety +1

    Naina super

  • @sankaranc3178
    @sankaranc3178 Před 3 lety

    தமையன்.... மகன்...... டைரக்ட் செய்த படம் எது

  • @balajiiyer142
    @balajiiyer142 Před 4 lety +1

    Shooting pogama maten panathumela padupen sonnaru eppo ketta he says he was in mudhal mariyadhi shooting edhu thaan unmai

    • @Relaxingtime4me
      @Relaxingtime4me Před 4 lety

      You didn't listen to him properly or you misunderstood him.

  • @johnsonjo8454
    @johnsonjo8454 Před 4 lety

    Thalaivar

  • @senthamilselvan5115
    @senthamilselvan5115 Před 4 lety

    Sir bagdath kadhai yeluthunga,

  • @panneerselvam4959
    @panneerselvam4959 Před 3 lety

    பாக்தாத் பேரழகி...

  • @johndoss1241
    @johndoss1241 Před 4 lety +2

    நிழல்களின் யுத்தம்

  • @sundarm9624
    @sundarm9624 Před 4 lety +1

    Kadaisiya chatunu mudinjiruchu.

  • @panneerselvam4959
    @panneerselvam4959 Před 3 lety

    சங்கரையாவுக்கு இப்ப 100வயது...

  • @CoffeeRoamer
    @CoffeeRoamer Před 4 lety +12

    thanks for exposing vairamuthu always a culprit,,, no wonder he is strongly hiding behind dmk......

  • @lingaphotos
    @lingaphotos Před 4 lety

    ......................

  • @srinid.m3169
    @srinid.m3169 Před 4 lety +2

    Who is the son of this man

    • @kumar4486
      @kumar4486 Před 4 lety

      Dinesh selvaraj.he is mani rathnam assistant and directed vikram prabu thupakki munai movie

  • @srinevasanam2589
    @srinevasanam2589 Před 4 lety +1

    ur talk about KVM is excellant But people we’re behind MSV as usual, But KVM song Mayakkum Malai pozhude née po po, was used by MSV, in Gulebhagavali, Like many songs MSV life from other popular tunes which many may not know, ur very bold in appreciating KVM

    • @rravi1045
      @rravi1045 Před 4 lety +3

      Mr. Selvaraj's bias against MSV is evident in attributing Pullanguzhal Koduttha to KVM. He did not even have the courtesy to acknowledge Mr. Lakshmanan's correction of the same. I am not questioning KVM's prowess but where was the need to bring in MSV's name? In fact, all songs of the "Krishna Gaanam" were composed for pre-written lyrics as were many of his (MSV's) film compositions (Nenjirukkum varai, gauravam, Apoorva Raagangal to name a few) as well. It was the situation that determined whether "meter" or "matter" came first. Mr. Selvaraj (and you) would benefit by listening to the Endrum MSV program broadcast in Mega TV.As for "Mayakkum Maalai" MSV had no need to lift that (or any other) tune. That song was composed, I think, for Koondu Kili and could not be included in the film and the same producers wanted that song in GuleBhagavali even though MSV-TKR were signed up for the movie. MSV claims that he insisted that KVM's name be included in the credits but KVM, as always graceful, said it was not necessary.

    • @srinevasanam2589
      @srinevasanam2589 Před 4 lety +1

      R Ravi sir, Thanks for ur immediate reactions but I only mentioned one song Do you know how Sentamizh then mozhiyaal from Hindi,tune, Thaazhaiyaampomudithu, Yengal dravidaponnaaade, Otrumayyaay from Bhagappirivinai, All tuned from hinditunes, Ican show many from KVM direct lifts but that we’re fully retuned in Tamil, But MSV only in ur words got inspired to make in Tamil,But when Telugu,m,Hindi films remade he did not use the same scale for original tunes to make iin Tamil Forinstances Moogamanasulu, Jonymernaam, This was only to show that he was for from copying , that was only misleading his talent capacity, MGR was capable of understanding this, He Only insisted KVM to tune OndreKulamendru paduvoam in differant way though aavoiding original tune of Yemaalikthere bhnadhu , I am not accusing that MSV did not do good songs nor he is not good music director, I agree he has done wonderful songs no doubt but RS was only made open bold comment in Tamil cinema who talked about this, Unkowingly in the talkhe appreciates MSV by slip of tongue for Pullaanguzhal which is also true, Here in London during Dhashra festival many listened to my singing Pullaanguzhal well received byaudiances at various places as fisrst song in my Orchstra program , If my singing is successful for the last many years it’s because of this particular song only Thanks to MSV, KK, TMS , just for ur emotions, A.M.S from East Yorkshire, UK

    • @rravi1045
      @rravi1045 Před 4 lety +3

      @@srinevasanam2589 Sir, I am aware of MSV's songs inspired from others and MSV himself has openly acknowledged them. In fact, all great music directors have borrowed on and off from others. But, honestly, what fraction would these be of the innumerable number of songs MSV has composed? My main grievance was why Mr. Selvaraj has to put down MSV while praising KVM? This has to be seen in the context of his interview, Part - 1 where he refers to friction between his close friend, Panchu Arunachalam and MSV.

    • @srinevasanam2589
      @srinevasanam2589 Před 4 lety +2

      R Ravi ,Now I understood of r feelings, I also noticed that RS is jumping in his talk from main question, in Part one when Chithra asked about his relation with Sivaji , he did not answer at rather talked about other people who r close to him,, He is just self boosting person trying to convince and impress upon others on himself, but honest on his word , Any way I agree also with you on MSV too, but only feeling is people did not recognize other Music Director who were simply best inthose years example G.Ramanthan, S.V.Venkatraman, S.Rajeswarrao, Master Venu, Adhar Naranrao, Veda, S.Dhakshinamurthy , S.Ramarao , Sathyam and many who were short of praise by the fine world for their excellant work , Ghantasala tuned many good songs, but not in count,, that is my own observation, Best wishes , A.M.Srinevasan East York, UK

    • @vasudevancv8470
      @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety +3

      @@srinevasanam2589 Your views seem to be clearly born out of your aversion towards MSV. NO DOUBT, MSV was the ONLY COMPOSITE COMPOSER to have composed music to a wide range of films to a wide range, to any situation, to any genre. Without knowing the background, don't quote Mayakkum Maalai song in Kule Bagaavali. MSV has openly said in an interview to Podhigai TV that Producer TR Rammanna wanted to use this KVM's tune originally made for one of his own films and MSV told that the music for that song alone by KVM be shown in the Title Card, but, KVM had reportedly told there's no need. For Modern Theatres Kaidhi KaNNaayiram, the song Konji Konji Paesi Madhi Mayakkam was lifted by KVM from the Hindi film. So too, for Sivaji Starrer film Uthaman, KaeLaai Magane KaeL Oru Vaarthai was lifted from Hindi. Why did you conveniently forget these samples? Do you say KVM is not a great composer because he too has lifted a few songs from. Other languages? Ridiculous. In the film, Pallandu Vaazhga (Thamizh Version of Dohonki Bharaat) why can't u compare KVM's version of Pudhiyadhoar Ulagam Seivom with that of MSV's Unparalleled composition of the same song for Chandrodhayam? Same MGR (Mentioned by you) only wanted MSV to do Ulagam Sutrum Vaaliban after realising the fact that none other was suitable to compose music for that Genre. Same MGR only insisted on MSV to do NaaLai Namadhe (Remake of Yadonki Bharaat) despite MSV refused to accept it initially. Both for Sivagaamiyin Selvan & NaaLai Namadhe, MSV composed his own tunes and he didn't adopt even a single song from Aaradhana or Yadonki Bharaat. Why did you conveniently forget these facts? MSV didn't shy away or hide about the few he adopted as it is or which inspired him to give a modified version with his Value Additions. Don't be biased. Be fair and accept MSV was a true creator who broke the trend of composing every song based on Carnatic Raagas adopted by his predecessors mentioned by you. MSV was the First one to have given Thousands of Compositions born from his own imagination rather than developing from Any ready made templates. If any one else did like him, he would certainly have gone mad. A few benchmark samples are given here for his wide range & wide genres: Aarodum MaNNil Engum Neerodum, Naan Paesa Ninappadhellam, Paattukku Paatteduthu, Ennai Eduthu Thannai Koduthu, ALL THE SONGS FROM THE ILLUSTRIOUS KARNAN, Pudhiya Paravai, VeNNIRA Aadai, Kaadhalikka Naeram Illai, MuthukkaLo KaNNgaL, Poo MudippaaL Indha Poonguzhali, Nenjirukkum EngaLukku, Buddhan Yesu Gandhi, Engirundho AasaigaL, Maadhavi.Pon MayilaaL, Oru Maharaja Oru MahaRaaNi, Poo Maalaiyil,. ORU RAJA RANIYIDAM, Paarvai Yuva Raani Kannoviyam, Oru NaaLile Uravaanadhe, Sirippil Undaagum Raagathile, Poo Poova Parandhu Poagum Pattu Poochi Akka, for Comedy Genre Muthu KuLikka VaarigaLa, Kaasikku Poagum Sanyaasi, Appappa Naan Appanalladaa, ThaLLu Model Vandi idhu, Prose cum Poem - Andha NaaL Niyaabagam, Aani Muthu Vaangi Vandhen, Varavu EttaNaa, Bhoomiyil Iruppadhum Vaanathil Parappadhum, Oru NaaL Iravu Pagal Poal Nilavu, for Horror genre - Nenjam Marapadhillai, Kunguma KolangaL Kovil Kondaada, Aagaayathil Thottil Katti, for mimickry genre - KadavuL Amaiithu vaitha Maedai, Junior Junior, then EAZHU SWARANGALUKKUL, Aadi VeLLi Thaedi Unnai, Swing Swing Unadhu Oonjal Naan, Love is Fine Darling When U R MIne, Hello My Dear Wrong Number, Ninaithaale Inikkum song with just 2 words, Sippi Irukkudhu, a pure Hindi Song composed on his own in the same movie Varumaiyin Niram Sivappu, tunes for Pudhu KavidhaigaL in Agni Saatchi and Oru Indhiya Kanavu, the List Goes On and On and never ends. So, be fair and think twice before making loose comments. U R comparing MSV with his predecessors and saying others were not recognized. No, every MSV fan has got high regards for KVM & GR and held them in high esteem. At least KVM got national recognition for 3 of his films, but MSV & KaNNadasan got none, just not even a Padma award for their very big contributions. But, his songs got award for Playbacks. U compare MSV with his Successors and U will realise he didn't get adequate recognitions he deserved. Also, pls come out with the list of his succesors' songs that were lifted. If you don't know, track the list in the U.T which is very much available.

  • @mrdj7285
    @mrdj7285 Před 4 lety

    Who is his son ?

  • @arumugamc1584
    @arumugamc1584 Před 3 lety

    Jj

  • @vasudevancv8470
    @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety +2

    Pallandu Pallandu Pallayirathaandu is a verse written by Peryaazhwaar and Not by AandaaL. Ridiculous! The Illustrious devotional Song: Pullanguzhal Kodutha MoongilgaLe was composed by MELLISAI MANNAR M S VISWANATHAN and NOT by KVM. This Entire Music Album containing 8 wonderful songs were composed by MM MSV - only to KaNNadasan's Pre-written Lyrics. Selvaraj's Statement shows his ignorance and his lack of knowledge . K V MAHADEVAN was a great Music Director, but MSV was a Composite Music Composer who has composed music to a very wide range of songs & films - to any situation, to any range and to any genre. MSV was a Composer Beyond Comparison, a Composer Nonpereil!. When he mentioned Panju Arunachalam didn't like Avandhaan Manidhan Songs, it shows Panju Arunachalam's lack of taste and his bias against MSV. Because, in Sivaji GaNesan's 175th Film Avandhaan Manidhan, all the 5 Songs composed by MSV to KaNNadasan's lyrics - Anbu Nadamaadum Kalai Koodame, Oonjalukku Poo Chootti, Engirundho Oru Kural Vandhadhu, Aattuvihthaal Yaadhoruvar Aadaadhare KaNNa and Manidhan Ninaippadhundu are all ever shining Gems and Super hit Songs. Only a Tasteless Idiot could say he didn't like those songs. Utter Nonsene!

    • @rravi1045
      @rravi1045 Před 4 lety

      Vasu Sir: Nice hard-hitting response!!!It is amazing how a person's bias can make him/her dim-witted!!!!

    • @sudarsanmn1062
      @sudarsanmn1062 Před 4 lety

      Panchu's dislike for MSV songs could be for some personal reasons.But, if he is the reference point, then Panchu and consequently Ilayaraja didn't like Mudhal mariyadhai , as per Chitra lakshmanan's previous posts. Just imagine, how this gentleman Selvaraj would have reacted to it if Chitra Lakshmanan had said it during the interview.

    • @vasudevancv8470
      @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety

      @@sudarsanmn1062 Nice Question posed by U. So, It clearly shows lack of taste.

    • @vasudevancv8470
      @vasudevancv8470 Před 4 lety +1

      @@rravi1045 The joke is, he said he had a Cassette with him full of ONLY ONE SONG - continuously playing the song Pullanguzhal Kodutha MoongilgaLe. Ha Ha Ha!! So, even if he couldn't appreciate MSV whole heatedly, his mind, heart & soul have enjoyed that Song and he appreciated the Song to Sky High even without knowing who was the Music Director. It's a Thumping Victory for MSV.

    • @rravi1045
      @rravi1045 Před 4 lety +1

      @@vasudevancv8470 Mr. Chitra Lakshmanan tried to correct him but he did not seem to notice. Let him wallow in his ignorance. After all, Ignorance is Bliss!!!

  • @aravindtalkies1837
    @aravindtalkies1837 Před 4 lety +1

    Firstttttt

  • @seeniklk
    @seeniklk Před 4 lety +1

    சினிமா சிஐடி

  • @r.sudarson760
    @r.sudarson760 Před 4 lety +1

    Excellent

  • @nmsivakumarlic4761
    @nmsivakumarlic4761 Před 4 lety

    Good