Jim Bob Duggar's Sister and Niece Open Up about Past - SHINY HAPPY PEOPLE: Duggar Family Secrets

Sdílet
Vložit

Komentáře • 65

  • @enjoyingmyvodka1013
    @enjoyingmyvodka1013 Před rokem +150

    Im glad Amy’s mom gave her that freedom she seems like a friendly well grounded young woman

    • @mikescrazycomedy7362
      @mikescrazycomedy7362 Před rokem +11

      Amy mom did not want her to go through hell and let her choose her own path.

    • @enjoyingmyvodka1013
      @enjoyingmyvodka1013 Před rokem +2

      @@mikescrazycomedy7362 I’m glad

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +9

      Amy's mom didn't have a whole lot of freedom herself, and she gave Amy the life she wasn't "allowed" to have!

    • @enjoyingmyvodka1013
      @enjoyingmyvodka1013 Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@LisaKoffler I’m glad she did

    • @Miss_Camel
      @Miss_Camel Před 11 měsíci +3

      I’m so, SO proud of her and Jill for this, it makes my heart really full

  • @aileenmccarthy8660
    @aileenmccarthy8660 Před 11 měsíci +41

    Amy was so refreshing because she was so involved even tho her cousins were so different from her, because she loved them so much...she is true family!!!

  • @kellyewhiteside709
    @kellyewhiteside709 Před 10 měsíci +17

    Love Jill. Love that Amy and Deanna are the cheerleaders for Jill. Think it will take a lot for Jana to break free. John and Jana in away I feel like the grown up in the way to protect their younger siblings.
    Josh’s actions and how Jim Bob handled it thrown apart this family.

  • @OscarMPG1
    @OscarMPG1 Před 9 měsíci +8

    I always thought that Amy was the sane person of that family and this documentary proved it.

    • @gsmith6026
      @gsmith6026 Před 5 měsíci +2

      Amy was my favorite. She was a breath of fresh air compared to the Duggar’s.

  • @amberreid6242
    @amberreid6242 Před rokem +62

    Sue seems like she loves her uncle but had to let that relationship go when he risked the health of his daughters to keep making money

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +6

      My paternal grandmother told me that money can do terrible things to people, and she was right!

    • @5656moon
      @5656moon Před 11 měsíci +2

      who is sue? her name is amy and her mom's name is deanna

    • @amberreid6242
      @amberreid6242 Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@5656moon I meant SHE

  • @style_icon997
    @style_icon997 Před 11 měsíci +11

    Amy's very lucky that her mom gave her more freedom that she didn't have when she was young!

  • @LisaKoffler
    @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +17

    Missionary Baptist? WOW! That sounds more like a cult! Amy experienced "culture shock" while growing up, and it's extremely stressful to have to be CONSTANTLY reminded of the extremely strict rules of the Duggar Household!

  • @Weiyinglou
    @Weiyinglou Před rokem +32

    Jim bob's father was in and out of jail, and his mother was a fundie. Though his mother wasn't IBLP she grew up in a time when those ideals were at the forefront of society anyway. As for Josh, he's a sociopath.

    • @kataeva2220
      @kataeva2220 Před rokem +1

      I know jimmy lee wasn’t very religious like his wife.

    • @virgosbonnet7896
      @virgosbonnet7896 Před rokem +1

      Mary became a member of the IBLP in the early 80s after attending a seminar. She then later introduced Jim Bob and Michelle who eventually joined after they had Jill

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +2

      Josh was BORN a sociopath, and he'll die that way! I thought the situation was reversed with Jim Bob and Michelle joining Bill Gothard's IBLP cult first and Grandma Mary joining the cult later!

    • @kataeva2220
      @kataeva2220 Před 11 měsíci

      Mary looked too kind to be in this crazy cult.

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci

      Kata Eva, "too kind?" I'd like to think that she would have been smart enough to avoid cults altogether - whether she lived in the Duggar House or not!

  • @skippythealien9627
    @skippythealien9627 Před 11 měsíci +9

    filming reality TV must be such a fucking exhausting experience

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +2

      It is, and I've watched a few reality TV shows, and there were some I liked better than others!

  • @kataeva2220
    @kataeva2220 Před rokem +18

    I didn’t know Mary and Jimmy Lee Duggar were strict with Deanna and Jim Bob such as banning rock and roll music and school dances, deanna from becoming a cheerleader and wearing blue jeans for a while. I thought Jimmy Lee was more secular than his wife Mary. Wow

    • @virgosbonnet7896
      @virgosbonnet7896 Před rokem +1

      Not so much Jimmy but Mary. Jimmy from my understanding wasn’t religious at all it was all Mary who later joined the IBLP and had Jim Bob and Michelle join after they had Jill I believe

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +4

      I thought it was the other way way around, with Jim Bob and Michelle joining Bill Gothard's IBLP cult first, and Grandma Mary joining the cult later!

    • @kataeva2220
      @kataeva2220 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@LisaKoffler that’s what I thought. Jim Bob and Michelle joined iblp first then Mary Duggar joined

  • @mikescrazycomedy7362
    @mikescrazycomedy7362 Před rokem +9

    I was raised missionary Baptist and yet my parents did not teach me the conservatives views. I knew of no pants. After this small clip

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +1

      REALLY? I just hope you're now in a better situation!

  • @laureljade3476
    @laureljade3476 Před 10 měsíci +1

    0:26 looks like Jack Torrence from the Shining

  • @anne-mariezack
    @anne-mariezack Před rokem +14

    Don’t ever put anyone, any person, on a pedestal. Ie The Pope, Buddha, your mother, your pastor etc. The Bible is full of ppl who God loved even in the midst of some very ghastly sins. Who wants to be put on a pedestal anyways?

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci

      I don't! I agree that God loved people who committed very ghastly sins, and I hope he rewarded them after they "repented" for them! Sadly, Josh himself isn't capable of that, because he was BORN "a bad seed!"

    • @WillBlindYouWithLight
      @WillBlindYouWithLight Před 11 měsíci +1

      People do that to me all the time, I don't particularly like it. My whole life i thought I didn't fit in, but now I know it's because I stand out. When I try so hard to blend in.

    • @anne-mariezack
      @anne-mariezack Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@LisaKoffler You mentioned God so I would assume that you understand that no one is beyond His saving grace

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci

      Anne-Marie Zack, absolutely!

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci

      SARAH, I have Asperger's Syndrome, which is the highest functioning form of autism, so I know what it's like to be a misfit! It's a sad and lonely experience being the one person in the room NOBODY likes, and I learned to accept the fact that I'll NEVER be "normal!" I get therapy and take medication for depression and anxiety, and I hope you get help, too!

  • @carysjosie
    @carysjosie Před 8 měsíci +1

    A quick clue is the fact that they don’t go to a local church. Definitely a cult and they have caused harm not only two family members but the church as a whole.

  • @WillChandlerFLD120
    @WillChandlerFLD120 Před rokem +5

    They wernt poor attended private schools. Amy was on like 5 shows for a total of 30 minutes

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +1

      Somehow, they were able to get what they wanted!

  • @Chamelionroses
    @Chamelionroses Před 11 měsíci +4

    Worrying about kids billowy undies...but still had child abuse ignored that was known. Did the quiverful fundie parents blame the kid for fornication abuse?

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 10 měsíci +1

      YES! The IBLP cult is called FAKE Christianity! It's patriarchal, and that's why girls and women are treated so badly! The whole situation is sickening!

    • @gsmith6026
      @gsmith6026 Před 5 měsíci

      I am sure the girls were blamed for Josh molesting them.

  • @savagesfortruth
    @savagesfortruth Před měsícem

    My aunt husband was like this very religious person kids couldn’t even watch cartoons because it was from sinners and when my aunt kidney were falling they wouldn’t get her treatment god was going to heal her through the healing minstry but eventually she lost most of her eye sight to type 1 diabetes and it a genetic disorder I suffer from as well kidney that don’t function properly

  • @Weiyinglou
    @Weiyinglou Před rokem +5

    And i'd like to add, for anyone interested there is a docuseries on youtube about pedophiles and one shocking conclusion is that true pedos are rare (exclusively attracted to children) most are attracted to children and adults and have minor deformities such as under developed non-detached earlobes.. like the ears of.. JOSH DUGGAR JARED FOGLE AND LARRY NASSAR. Pedophila was also heavily in corelation with conduct disorder, anti social personality disorder, and narcsissm.

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +3

      Have you ever heard of "a bad seed?" It IS possible to be BORN that way, and that's the case with Josh! I didn't check out Josh's earlobes, but it doesn't matter, since he's now in prison where he belongs!

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci +1

      NO 2 pedophiles are exactly the same, but it doesn't matter, as long at they're ALL behind bars!

    • @laurenj432
      @laurenj432 Před 5 měsíci

      What’s the name of the docuseries?

  • @karmamarie2543
    @karmamarie2543 Před 10 měsíci +1

    I think I would’ve went and got baptized again. Just saying

  • @astroemerald3175
    @astroemerald3175 Před rokem +13

    Pssssssssstttttttt Mish's Sister is lesbian !!! Of course , she has been disowned by the family . Even the " nice " ones .

    • @briannagilmore1110
      @briannagilmore1110 Před rokem +1

      What makes you think she’s a lesbian?! 🙄

    • @shauna345
      @shauna345 Před rokem +13

      @@briannagilmore1110 Maybe because she said shes a lesbian and has been with her partner since 1988.

    • @Kirsten_is_cursed10
      @Kirsten_is_cursed10 Před rokem +9

      @@briannagilmore1110it’s in one of the episodes. She attends a family event with her partner, and none of the Duggars talk to her. Keep up. 🙄

    • @kataeva2220
      @kataeva2220 Před rokem +4

      @@briannagilmore1110 one of Michelle’s older sisters, Evelyn is a lesbian and lives with her partner. Michelle and her big fundie family don’t have much contact with her at all. She was shown once on 17 kids and counting during the big family reunion episode.

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 11 měsíci

      The IBLP cult doesn't allow LGBTQ! ANY member who is will be disowned and ostracized!

  • @sue-annbray6250
    @sue-annbray6250 Před 11 měsíci +1

    With 19 kids you have to be strict! Lol

    • @LisaKoffler
      @LisaKoffler Před 10 měsíci +1

      That's true, but there's a right way and a wrong way to do that! Jim Bob and Michelle made the worst mistake joining Bill Gothard's IBLP cult instead of a REAL church, along with parentification, which is a form of abuse! Strict parents care, but "mean" parents don't!

    • @gsmith6026
      @gsmith6026 Před 5 měsíci +3

      There is a huge difference between strict and abusive. Look up blanket training. Something that Michelle did and praised. It is cruel and abusive.