Question Time - Tony Blair hustings, 24 April 1997

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 03. 2017
  • On Thursday 24 April, with one week to go to the general election, Tony Blair takes questions from the Question Time audience.
    Note: Opening titles and theme tune removed for copyright reasons. I have added annotations so you know what the voiceover said.

Komentáře • 445

  • @max__pain
    @max__pain Před 7 lety +192

    Wow. They don't clap inanely after every sentence.

    • @pippipster6767
      @pippipster6767 Před 6 lety +4

      Craig
      Told not to obviously.

    • @jamesguy1030
      @jamesguy1030 Před 4 lety +1

      C J ~ Yeah,
      i think that it’s very important that the public gets both sides of the debate and the other side of the propaganda.
      Please check out the very important information in amazing documentary series called =
      “EUROPA THE LAST BATTLE”
      All Ten episodes are well worth watching.
      Removed and Banned in many places, However You Can Still Find it iF You Look hard enough
      (it’s also available on DVD)
      it’s one of the most important & fascinating documentary series to come out this decade and should be shown in our schools and colleges worldwide.
      if it was shown on the mainstream media then we would win our fight for freedom over night.
      We all must do our best to spread the Truth and wake our people up from a very deep sleep.
      if you can, Please share it with as many people as you can before it gets Removed & Lost Forever.
      The Censorship Continues but
      OUR WEAPON IS TRUTH !
      God Bless (Bitchute)

  • @Sr68720
    @Sr68720 Před 7 lety +148

    holy shit they actually talked about policy back then fuck me!!!!

    • @shawofeverything3716
      @shawofeverything3716 Před 7 lety +12

      I know right, it's bizarre.

    • @BlyatimirPootin
      @BlyatimirPootin Před 2 lety

      Instead do shouting 'sovereignty' or 'traitors' or whatever bullshit the loons come out with

    • @dudeyfeb88coach
      @dudeyfeb88coach Před 4 měsíci

      They do - get brexit done , save us all from the evil and smart virus , stop the boats and reduce inflation of course

  • @wildernessuk
    @wildernessuk Před rokem +43

    6 minutes in was classic Blair. Slated by a member of the audience and he charms them. Saw him do this so many times and persuade those who were sceptical of him. Guess that's probably one reason why he was so succesful.

    • @axelbruv
      @axelbruv Před 2 dny

      Agreed. He talks a good talk. I can see why he was so popular.

  • @kylebewley7790
    @kylebewley7790 Před 2 lety +188

    Such a shame he ruined his legacy with the Iraq war. I’ve been very interested recently in researching his earlier days. He was miles above anyone who has come after him. On a national level this is the kind of leader the country needs right now.

    • @anonymousthanks4718
      @anonymousthanks4718 Před 2 lety +8

      Amen

    • @malcolmjawohowelll2892
      @malcolmjawohowelll2892 Před 2 lety +21

      Tony was a supreme master of communication .and was able to present his case and confidently argue against opposing views ..whether he was right or wrong on a given topic,he knew how to make his case

    • @benhannay9042
      @benhannay9042 Před 2 lety +2

      He was fantastic and even with the Iraq war he was lied to by the Americans. The information he gave the country was what he knew at the time, his legacy was ruined by bush. Still he should’ve listened to the people instead of listening to the Americans.

    • @TheOfficialThundazz
      @TheOfficialThundazz Před rokem +16

      @@malcolmjawohowelll2892He was a barrister before entering politics so that is perhaps why he was able to be so convincing in an argument. Aside from that, he was just naturally charismatic and had a smile and a way of talking that seemed to subliminally say “trust me”.

    • @bd1845
      @bd1845 Před rokem +1

      Agreed Kyle. Looking at all the stuff like winter fuel payments, free TV licences for over 65’s, the minimum wage, peace in Northern Ireland. Then backing a total idiot right wing president like Bush. He still believes today he did the right thing and I don’t shed a tear for that Monster Saddam Hussein who had killed 000’s of his own people but what happened after with the de- stabilisation that was always going to happen was a catastrophe of epic proportions. You listen back then and the tories still ran massive public deficits and increased taxation etc but have always apparently been the party to run the Economy better… yeah right. I say this by the way as someone who has voted Tory in my life more than Labour.

  • @novadruid4175
    @novadruid4175 Před 7 lety +248

    I love how polite people were back then.

    • @kazamshah4543
      @kazamshah4543 Před 7 lety +10

      Yeah. wonder what changed, eh?

    • @phosfer7853
      @phosfer7853 Před 7 lety +53

      The BBC used to have standards and didn't let in a bunch of fat, old, cunty UKIPPERS who shout after an answer they don't like

    • @ClearOutSamskaras
      @ClearOutSamskaras Před 7 lety +3

      God bless you for saying that Novadruid. Some things that we have should be kept, we need to strongly reject the things that are unacceptable.

    • @ramage05
      @ramage05 Před 7 lety +19

      Novadruid standards dropped in UK after 1997 - due to Labours policies. Mid 90s were amazing in UK - been in decline since

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety +8

      TheCausation he let in Less than May!

  • @nudgexs
    @nudgexs Před 6 lety +131

    No matter what people think of him he smashed this out the park!!

  • @h0ckeyd
    @h0ckeyd Před 8 dny +4

    As much as anyone dislikes him, Blair would have walked over both Starmer and Sunak with a performance like this.

  • @JoeskiPolski
    @JoeskiPolski Před 9 měsíci +20

    Look how far our society has denigrated. Imagine seeing a crowd that well dressed and respectful in questions and answers in 2023. Sickening.

    • @snakedriver
      @snakedriver Před 4 dny

      You still get respectful people, the problem is question time is an awful show with loaded audiences that is more interested in pushing agendas than furthering debate.

  • @villeporttila5161
    @villeporttila5161 Před 2 dny +1

    The most impressive thing about this video is the amount of times Blair flat out told someone they were wrong. No politician these days would have the courage to do that

  • @dogbastardly6101
    @dogbastardly6101 Před 7 měsíci +17

    The young man at 5:25 is Andrew Griffith, now a tory MP and just appeared on the Question Time panel himself on 23/11/2023

  • @danmccaffrey8322
    @danmccaffrey8322 Před rokem +43

    Exceptional political operator. You don't have to like him. He was a cut above anything offered since, Labour or otherwise.

  • @euanwill6196
    @euanwill6196 Před 7 lety +83

    The quality of politics has truly diminished in this country! People here are competent, intelligent and polite, how has the quality of debate and intelligence diminished so much in twenty years?

    • @Nine-Signs
      @Nine-Signs Před 7 lety +3

      Competent?
      A snippet of the last 40 years.
      225 billion PFI debt
      virtually no council housing built
      education grants cut
      tuition fee's introduced
      private landlords let rip
      refused to renationalise the railways, more PFI
      privatisation in the NHS introduced
      And our children sent to kill and die in order to kill another nations children, on a pack of lies.
      Competent??? Hardly.
      armyofall.wordpress.com

    • @euanwill6196
      @euanwill6196 Před 7 lety +9

      I meant the audience not the politicians. The quality of debate here is certainly higher than that in a 2017 QT.

    • @Nine-Signs
      @Nine-Signs Před 7 lety +5

      That's because back then the audience was chosen at random, not selected by an "audience manager" who is known for re tweeting Britain first in her time, as happens today.
      Question time has been owned by a small welsh production firm since 2013 which is a shell company to hide its real owners, an american venture capitalist firm called vitruvian partners LLC. The BBC no longer owns nor controls nor funds anything nor anyone on it.
      Today on the panel you get two right wingers, a centrist a wet left and a sponge(an artist a poet etc). If a question is asked that makes the right look bad you give it to the sponge, if a question is asked that makes the left look bad, you give it to the right or the wet left depending on whom dimbleby thinks will do more damage to the left which wants to change the economics.
      Welcome to era of manufacturing consent in order to hide the truth and prevent you from demanding that change.
      armyofall.wordpress.com/THINGS/

    • @euanwill6196
      @euanwill6196 Před 7 lety +6

      It's all a conspiracy! Maybe a better explanation is that people are less well informed these days. There is an abundance of information, but a lack of analysis. Analysis, whether you agree with it or not, helps you inform your own opinions, and perhaps that is what has changed a long with other factors. I think the growth of UKIP and growing voter apathy from 2005 onwards is also relevant. As for QT itself being selectively bias, it continues be criticised for that from all sides- suggesting it is actually quite unbias. Although in my opinion, it would seem that a softer left backbencher often seems to represent labour, rather than someone more aligned with Corbyn, however, over the GE campaign this year, the audiences seemed to me to be very left leaning. Cheering left wing policies and booing right wing stuff. I think if the audience was less vocal in terms of booing and clapping during the debate, quality would be enhanced, because that way viewers aren't influenced by what could be an unrepresentative audience.

    • @rumourhats
      @rumourhats Před 4 lety +1

      It kinda coincided with access to high speed internet broadband.

  • @Dean-qe9cl
    @Dean-qe9cl Před 4 lety +83

    You gotta admit Tony Blair was on the Ball.
    Every Question he had a Answer Too and Was Never Owned.
    The Truth is Tony Blair did his Homework.
    He Just Outclassed and Totally Owned in the Tories in 1997 and 2001.
    2005 was when he started to show the Tories Some Way Back into Office.
    Tony Blair was a Leader however Gordon Brown wasn’t I am Afraid which is the Reason for Labour’s Defeat in 2010.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety +2

      Dean 11785 Yes Brown was just made a scapegoat for Blair that’s why people chose him to mess up the left hoped that NL would fail to prove the left right

    • @brumav9779
      @brumav9779 Před 3 lety +7

      Yep in 97 and 01 he was suave and composed. You could tell he was shook in the 05 QT special, and he knew that he had to resign before the public saw his tenure as smoke and mirrors. Career politician, actor, coward and fraud - that’s Tony Blair summed up.

    • @JD-Media
      @JD-Media Před 3 lety +8

      @@brumav9779 Hell even in 05 he still handled himself pretty well compared to other politicians.

    • @MarlboroughBlenheim1
      @MarlboroughBlenheim1 Před 3 lety +2

      He was a lawyer so of course he was able to do this

    • @ER1CwC
      @ER1CwC Před 6 měsíci +1

      The key differences between Blair and Brown, in my view, concerned decisiveness and the ability to sense which direction the political winds are blowing. Blair was just much more adept on both of these fronts. Just a better politician.

  • @Liz-xr1eq
    @Liz-xr1eq Před 4 lety +46

    Half of these people think he's a raging Tory and the other half think he's a closet communist.
    Glad to see the Tony Blair discourse hasn't at all changed much in over 20 years.

    • @tylertone2776
      @tylertone2776 Před 4 lety +26

      It's hilarious, but the government he ran was exactly as he said- fundamentally center-left with certain inherited aspects of center-right social policy that was overwhelmingly popular

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety +2

      Tyler Tone Until the next election taxes begun to go up and then Iraq...

    • @wessexfox5197
      @wessexfox5197 Před 2 lety +2

      His activities at university and affiliations of him and many of his cabinet during their university days very much supports the latter. Go and read Peter Hitchens and realise that this man was a Machiavellian genius who introduced several cultural and institutional revolutions which have Americanised and changed this country forever.

    • @StrongandStable17
      @StrongandStable17 Před 9 měsíci +3

      ​​​​@@wessexfox5197
      And *his 10 years as Prime Minister* very much does not. But obviously his University days are more relevant then his decade in power huh.
      If Hitchens said the sky was green would you believe him?
      Unfortunately for him, *articulacy does not equal accuracy.*
      Quite clear which sibling the smarts went to.

    • @wessexfox5197
      @wessexfox5197 Před 9 měsíci

      @@StrongandStable17 no I wouldn’t but if you can’t realise what Hitchens has written about Blair is the Gods honest truth then there’s no helping you.

  • @MisterOGradz
    @MisterOGradz Před 7 lety +31

    I was born on this day. Time goes quick.

  • @ethanroee
    @ethanroee Před 13 dny +2

    The gulf in glass this man had in front of a live audience compared to todays politicians is wild

  • @Lamilton82828
    @Lamilton82828 Před 5 lety +55

    Very interesting watching Blair at his heights I don’t agree with his ideas but he’s a smooth operator

    • @themasteryourdaddy.6307
      @themasteryourdaddy.6307 Před 3 lety +3

      It was all acting. The truth came out eventually, he taking money from the banks, on the board of major banks Goldmen and Sachs, hes Rupert Murdochs child's God Father. He spoke out for years about Jeremy Corbyn, stabbing the Leader of the Labour Party and destroying it. But what an actor. What a bastard, what a war criminal, he advises dictators now, because their the only people who'll learn to him.

    • @countingcards1208
      @countingcards1208 Před 2 lety +10

      @@themasteryourdaddy.6307 You disregard all the good he did, life was better under his rule than it was for a long time before and ever since.

    • @wessexfox5197
      @wessexfox5197 Před 2 lety

      @@countingcards1208 oh yeah, section 127 of the Communications act of 2003, devolution that has slowly destroyed the Union, manipulation of crime statistics etc he was terrible all throughout his tenure. Go read Peter Hitchens and watch Academic Agent and read his works (Neema Parvini) and wake up to the truth of what this Machiavellian traitor has done to Britain.

    • @toastedterps
      @toastedterps Před 9 měsíci

      Lol@@countingcards1208

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@countingcards1208really?

  • @cmcg3738
    @cmcg3738 Před 4 lety +27

    I strongly disagree & actively despise some of the things Blair did, like Iraq to mass immigration, but by the time of the next general election he will be the only Labour leader to have won an election for half a century. The Corbynistas refuse to draw any lessons from this. Labour is now at a crossroads similar to that of 1983. Sadly, there is no Neil Kinnock to vote for.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety +4

      C McG There was. His own son who refused to stand. Sir Keir Starmer is the front runner. He’s totally learned from Blair.

    • @hvern0n
      @hvern0n Před 4 lety +1

      @@veggie42 I'm not too sure. Wishing to campaign to rejoin the EU doesn't seem smart to try and win back the traditional northern voters.

  • @HammerHealedCD
    @HammerHealedCD Před 4 lety +15

    Polite,smart,humour.....watching this audience tells you how wrong this country has gone.The Q at 43.55 'What is your vision of the EU in 20 years time'....UK voted leave 19 years on!! Love to find out if the guy asking the Q was a leaver or remainer!

  • @coderider3022
    @coderider3022 Před 3 dny +1

    I watch’s this that night ! Still remember it. Everyone in school said parent were voting labour and it showed me how many were doing it.

  • @Scuba-Ry
    @Scuba-Ry Před 3 lety +51

    It's amazing how the people's perception of good leadership changes over time:
    Tony won a landslide majority by actually answering the questions set up by he media.
    Boris won a landslide majority by hiding in a fridge, away from questions and the media.

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 3 lety +2

      Boris got a large majority because he actually delivered what people wanted.

    • @yao052
      @yao052 Před 2 lety +10

      @@BossySwan by hiding

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 2 lety

      @@yao052 no

    • @anonymousthanks4718
      @anonymousthanks4718 Před 2 lety +6

      @@BossySwan Corruption? Parties? A failed Brexit?

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 2 lety

      @@anonymousthanks4718 no

  • @zedrake
    @zedrake Před 3 dny +1

    Imagine not being interrupted every 5 seconds. this was class

  • @ThatGuy-fd5px
    @ThatGuy-fd5px Před rokem +10

    I like the old school politicians having ago back at the audience/public.

  • @alexw6105
    @alexw6105 Před 7 lety +17

    Thanks for adding this @davidboothroyd, important part of recent British history whatever your political views

  • @MarlboroughBlenheim1
    @MarlboroughBlenheim1 Před 3 lety +32

    He was a really smooth operator and was ahead of the game when it came to brand and spin and compared to John Major and the Tories at the time he was a breath of fresh air.

    • @chrisrogers3457
      @chrisrogers3457 Před 2 lety +1

      NT GREAT LEADER

    • @deathspasm9
      @deathspasm9 Před 9 měsíci +2

      'brand and spin' has ruined politics. blair was an absolute disgrace

    • @MarlboroughBlenheim1
      @MarlboroughBlenheim1 Před 9 měsíci +1

      @@deathspasm9 ‘‘twas ever thus. Trollope wrote novels about this in the late nineteenth century!

    • @deathspasm9
      @deathspasm9 Před 9 měsíci +1

      he was a crook who should be in prison

    • @MarlboroughBlenheim1
      @MarlboroughBlenheim1 Před 9 měsíci +2

      @@deathspasm9 for what?

  • @matthewburns9911
    @matthewburns9911 Před 7 lety +26

    The time before the internet... at least in my household. i think I first got on the internet about 2000/01 using aol dial up... those were the days!

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety +3

      Matthew Burns yh I was using internet before then at school and in the local library I even read the pages

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety

      That was 1995 but there wasn’t much of an internet until the millennium

    • @chucky2316
      @chucky2316 Před 3 lety

      @@veggie42 no Romanian girls either I've spread my seed in a few belive me and 1 or 2 polish

  • @andrewwinstanley8217
    @andrewwinstanley8217 Před 24 dny +3

    No notes; just knew his shit.

  • @satoterror
    @satoterror Před 7 lety +8

    Wow that first question pretty much summed up his leadership from then on.

  • @NavidHarrid
    @NavidHarrid Před 7 lety +27

    Tony Blair was did some extremely abhorrent actions as PM, obviously the Iraq War being the most notable but I think Labour today could learn a few things from the man who won them three elections. Labour shouldn't be ashamed of their past, they should embrace it.

    • @allpoliticsnoeconomics4186
      @allpoliticsnoeconomics4186 Před 7 lety

      fuck me God no I could think of nothing worse. This man is just blathering - it's similar to Theresa May. She's watched videos

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety +2

      Usman Akhtar yes I still liked some of what he did, the smoking ban, he dared to put up fees for university getting more to study hard and the foxhunting ban so good

  • @martycrow
    @martycrow Před 2 lety +16

    *Watch carefully how Blair achieves his aims.*
    To the tough questions (almost all) he's not afraid to push back. He does so politely without apology but directly. Well, almost. Because he's already moved on to Stage Two which is to say why he and New Labour are different. How he accepts Labour's faults of the past, but times have changed. The audience resonates with this. Then comes Part Three, which is about how he (and New Labour) have a plan to make things better - not exactly how you've raised the question, but by now, you start to see things as he does and are persuadable that he's right and worth a punt.
    If one looks at the electoral map, one will see how difficult it is for Labour to win. England is pretty solidly Tory and Labour seats mainly in urban areas. Labour has to win more votes to secure a seat. Labour's presence in Scotland and Wales was much more secure in 1997 than now, and both offered Labour a solid base to make up for Tory shires and non-metropolitan seats. The position is quite different in 2022, and any chance of winning a GE by a majority is slim. It can only be done by appealing to a non-Tory vote in key marginals. The Labour surge of 2017 is often touted as proof that Labour can only win from the Left. This is a fallacy and a misreading of the figures. In a FPTP largely two-party system, battleground seats are so named because they make the difference and no amount of Left-purist dogma will bag these.
    Finally, Labour in the late 1990s was hungry to win. It became focused and disciplined. I know many voices on the Left were hushed up (perhaps including mine) but as TB says, it was better to be in power than not. Mine might not be a popular view, but it is a pragmatic one.

  • @mariejo4242
    @mariejo4242 Před 3 lety +21

    My god he had charisma. Such a Well-spoken, confident, handsome man

  • @RichardLamsdale
    @RichardLamsdale Před 25 dny +2

    It’s amazing that a lot of the same right-wing scare tactics they used in 1997 are still being used in 2024.

  • @hypnotechno
    @hypnotechno Před 7 lety +60

    take me back to 1997 - What has happened to the UK

  • @Bungle-UK
    @Bungle-UK Před 9 měsíci +9

    Whether you agree with him or not, there is no denying that he was an excellent leader. I remember him saying to Major at PMQs before the election “I lead my party, you follow yours” and, to be fair, he wasn’t wrong.

  • @IamWoodstaman
    @IamWoodstaman Před 4 lety +17

    Anyone else click on this thinking that was a young Blair in the audience?

    • @bieituns
      @bieituns Před 3 lety

      No that guy looks like that tosser labour MEP who held the sign up behind farage in Brussels saying farage was lying.

  • @Erectotoad
    @Erectotoad Před 7 lety +16

    Hey maybe I wanted to listen to the theme tune :(

  • @HalfManThirdBiscuit
    @HalfManThirdBiscuit Před 7 lety +9

    First question is a mic drop. The correct answer, Tony, is "yes, but no one will notice for another 20 years or so".

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety

      Cos Its 167 Cameron took off Blair in 2005 and ruined him! nowonder he didn't win in 2010 it was "Blair" v Brown like Brown saw a double of his rival! very sick ploy

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +5

      Bizarre that you're equating labour led by Blair and labour led by Corbyn. Labour lost heavily in 2019 because they had an out of touch eccentric, Corbyn, as leader.

  • @scottyk200
    @scottyk200 Před měsícem +2

    Even the announcer right at the start reminded me of better things. 1994 thru to 2001 were the best 7 years of my life, and I don’t think it was just due to me being in my 20s.

  • @harmlessdrudge
    @harmlessdrudge Před 6 lety +8

    Thank you for uploading this. Do you have the John Major Question Time?

  • @hakc97again
    @hakc97again Před 7 lety +6

    Do you have any other editions of Question Time?

    • @DBIVUK
      @DBIVUK  Před 7 lety +6

      I doubt I have many, to be honest. Might have some other election specials. But given the struggle I had to upload this one I might have to be careful.

  • @BossySwan
    @BossySwan Před 6 lety +20

    5:39 - Andrew Griffiths, former Tory PPC and CEO of Sky.

    • @samdoesvids1339
      @samdoesvids1339 Před 4 lety +2

      Wow, Boris has just hired him as an advisor also.

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 4 lety

      And now MP somewhere down south

    • @fryliver4953
      @fryliver4953 Před 2 lety +1

      @@BossySwan And now he's head of the #10 policy unit

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 2 lety

      @@fryliver4953 policy 1: free ice cream for anyone with blue front doors

  • @duckbizniz663
    @duckbizniz663 Před 10 měsíci +1

    It is good to hear from a young Tony Blair. He is dealing with a lot of populous concerns with him moving the Labour Party into the middle ground away from the far left. On the issue of referendum I fear he will be greatly disappointed in 2016. The faith he had with the Britons directly voting on the EU will surprise him.

  • @MrJohnQCitizen
    @MrJohnQCitizen Před 7 lety +19

    George W Bush at 0.02

  • @mrbeancounter90
    @mrbeancounter90 Před 6 lety +15

    59:25 Tony Blair (to audience member) "You don't sound very Scottish to me"
    "... Anthony Charles Lynton Blair was born at Queen Mary Maternity Home in Edinburgh, Scotland..."

  • @BossySwan
    @BossySwan Před 4 lety +4

    Things can only get, er, worse

  • @mekzcnt
    @mekzcnt Před 3 lety +2

    Please open auto subtitle for this clip. it’s very great clip.

  • @michaelsalter2967
    @michaelsalter2967 Před 5 lety +4

    the points on the EU at around 43 mins are so relevant now

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety +1

      Michael Salter and the fact Blair said “live within our means” and “older people are living longer “ OMG!! And yet not enough homes people didn’t know immigration would rise and who would join the EU by 2004... that changed everything

  • @adam4757
    @adam4757 Před 2 lety +17

    Fair play. He was excellent in this.

  • @wildsurfer12
    @wildsurfer12 Před 7 lety +9

    20 years on and Karen Haywood's prediction has come true. Who'd have thought Labour would loose in Stoke South?

    • @georgehayes3494
      @georgehayes3494 Před 6 lety +1

      wildsurfer12 luckily we're on the way back. The loss of Walsall north at the election was a legacy of Blair

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +12

      @@georgehayes3494 what an absolute joke. We lost because we elected Corbyn, the most unpopular leader in history.

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +1

      That's what you get if you elect an out of touch eccentric like Corbyn as leader.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety

      Corbyn was trying to keep New Labour but using Old Labour’s economics which didn’t work in the past.

    • @BlyatimirPootin
      @BlyatimirPootin Před 2 lety

      @@th8257 don't think so, the trends were there well before Corbyn ever became leader.

  • @benjamineckford1718
    @benjamineckford1718 Před 8 měsíci +1

    By the end he had them eating out of his hand. Blair was the ultimate master at this sort of thing

  • @TheMarmite09
    @TheMarmite09 Před rokem +5

    What an amazing speaker.

  • @montblanc6453
    @montblanc6453 Před 5 lety +6

    It was civilised, edifying discourse of this kind that elevated us and commanded respect the world over.
    "That England that was wont to conquer others
    Hath made a shameful conquest of itself."

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +1

      Are you from a different universe??

  • @MultiVince95
    @MultiVince95 Před 2 lety

    Thursday 24th April 1997

  • @Gar96229
    @Gar96229 Před 7 lety +37

    0:01
    Is that George W. Bush?

  • @robbibittybob20
    @robbibittybob20 Před 2 lety +2

    The good things about the New Labour government, like the minimum wage, the sure start centres, and class size reduction, were things Labour would have done anyway. The majority of bad things New Labour did - tuition fees, Iraq War, escalation of privatisation through PFI, the lack of redress to the anti-trade union legislation, the reliance on financial speculation, no nationalisation of the infrastructure, were exclusive to them. The only thing they had in common were a lack of an industrial policy.
    New Labour's faustian promise of electability no longer holds either - the only reversal of declining electoral fortunes since 1997 was 2017, when Corbyn was relatively unhindered by New Labour's absurd EU policy. Scotland has been lost to Labour too.
    The hysterical anti-socialist questioning from the audience is more foolish than ever.

  • @locorum9103
    @locorum9103 Před dnem

    Fascinating how conservative this audience is. 60 percent of the country were supporting New Labour at the time and the questions are all about unions and socialism. What show was this? Lol.

  • @veggie42
    @veggie42 Před 7 lety +4

    my first election!!

    • @DFandV
      @DFandV Před 5 lety

      Mine was 2010 when Tories came back to power.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 4 lety

      J Hibberd the excitement that election May1st 97 hot day I remember it well and the feeling that swept across Britain of Hope so sad how quick it changed and I lost trust after the Ecclestone scandal and the book A woman was reading the actual Third Way

  • @ceirwan
    @ceirwan Před 7 lety +56

    Its amazing to see how convincing a speaker Blair was back then. Major and the Tories didn't stand a chance, I especially liked how he dealt with the guy around the 15:00 mark.
    Apart from the Iraq war I would say that on the whole Blairs leadership was quite good.

    • @edwardrolling1411
      @edwardrolling1411 Před 7 lety +1

      You're a mug. I bet you go to church.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety

      RickkyP he didn't bring the separate care system into the NHS

    • @HaggardPillockHD
      @HaggardPillockHD Před 7 lety +3

      *I especially liked how he dealt with the guy around the **15:00** mark*
      He was a trained barrister. They deal with much worse in their profession.

    • @ceirwan
      @ceirwan Před 7 lety

      Eh?
      Not sure what religion has to do with it, but either way I'm an atheist.

    • @robfuller7841
      @robfuller7841 Před 6 lety +3

      Like any successful salesman selling you shit.

  • @eamonnevans8005
    @eamonnevans8005 Před 4 lety +8

    Tony Blair had not even been elected at this point and Britain actually meant something.

  • @Me-ji2pn
    @Me-ji2pn Před 6 lety +1

    Anyone remember watching this? Did it change your opinion?

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +3

      I think most people had made up their minds by then, if we're honest.

  • @seanwynne5848
    @seanwynne5848 Před 8 měsíci

    How many times did he say I SAY TO YOU?

  • @jimmyhopkins3589
    @jimmyhopkins3589 Před 3 lety +3

    Is it just me or does the guy on the thumbnail look like a nerdy version of Blair

  • @mactavishmac1134
    @mactavishmac1134 Před 3 lety +2

    He knows about housing especially in Bristol!! Ask him

  • @accadaccasuperstar
    @accadaccasuperstar Před rokem +3

    funny old world, pretty sure that "audience member" speaking at around 5:30 was doing the media rounds earlier this year defending bojo and his lockdown parties 😂

  • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
    @user-sf7kl9uh7k Před 7 měsíci +1

    It's amazing to think 18 years later we'd have Labour offering a slice of Clown Corbyn 🤡

  • @redrebel0066
    @redrebel0066 Před rokem

    My 17th Birthday! Dont remember watching this though.

  • @pgl0897
    @pgl0897 Před 7 lety +13

    33:38 - 34:26 is the most concise explanation for the 2008 financial crisis.

    • @jimmyhopkins3589
      @jimmyhopkins3589 Před 3 lety +2

      It was a GLOBAL financial crisis you stupid moron

    • @pgl0897
      @pgl0897 Před 3 lety +2

      @@jimmyhopkins3589 Yes. The root cause of which can be traced directly back through the collapse of the post-war consensus, the slash and burn deregulation of the thatcher/reagan era, and (with relation to the OP) the failure of post-thatcherite social democracy to address spiralling inequality caused by the neoliberalism of the previous two decades. Or, to put it in blair’s words, the idea that governments shouldn’t interfere with decisions that companies/the private sector make.

    • @jimmyhopkins3589
      @jimmyhopkins3589 Před 3 lety +2

      @@pgl0897 David Cameron was a fan of the bankers and thought the financial crisis was due to labour over spending. David Cameron was possibly one of the worst prime ministers there had ever been and had an easy ride during his time in office. Had he been in power during 2007-08 this country would have collapsed.

    • @pgl0897
      @pgl0897 Před 3 lety

      @@jimmyhopkins3589 agree on every point. Where it seems we differ is on whether blair was any better. Economically, his policy platform was and would have been indistinguishable from Cameron’s.

  • @BlyatimirPootin
    @BlyatimirPootin Před 2 lety +19

    I love the way Blair battered the Tory boys in the audience

  • @ClearOutSamskaras
    @ClearOutSamskaras Před 7 lety +5

    I noticed part way through that basically everyone is well dressed. Would this have been a rule by BBC for studio audiences for a question/discussion with Blair or other politicians?
    Edit: it must have been a rule to be dressed a certain way. The well dressed quality of the audience is basically at 95% from what we can see in the video.

    • @chrisharrison763
      @chrisharrison763 Před 5 lety +6

      People just had higher standards back then. Everyone made an effort, regardless of class.

  • @nbarrett100
    @nbarrett100 Před 7 měsíci

    13:38 really enjoyed the David Byrne cameo

    • @BossySwan
      @BossySwan Před 6 měsíci

      He may find himself quizzing Blair, how did he get there?

  • @manu56best
    @manu56best Před 3 lety +2

    42:50 same applied to EU referendum.

  • @BedsitBob
    @BedsitBob Před 3 lety +5

    6:35 His comment, about the Conservative threat to our pensions, rang rather hollow, after Gordon Brown's pension tax raid.

  • @LeethLee1
    @LeethLee1 Před 4 lety +4

    So interesting! He was what the UK needed then. Now it's Boris.
    History in politics so fascinating, because when you vote its private. It's peoples real feelings :)

    • @LeethLee1
      @LeethLee1 Před 4 lety +1

      @Bro Down Well, I should say it's what people 'Thought' they wanted back then :D
      We were all tricked by the Blair's and Obama's around. Trudeau now for example.

  • @jazzycrew
    @jazzycrew Před rokem

    05:28 current MP Arundel and South Downs, Andrew Griffith

  • @allancrotch2953
    @allancrotch2953 Před rokem +1

    how refreshing a question time without baying hounds

  • @Jairzinho121
    @Jairzinho121 Před 7 lety +10

    probably the greatest promise and greatest failure wrapped up in one leader

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +18

      If winning three elections is a failure, then please let labour have more failures than that

    • @goonies4616
      @goonies4616 Před 2 lety +4

      @@th8257 exactly this, and I find it astonishing that people have allowed the Iraq war to completely cloud their judgement of his skill and talent - he was a brilliant a politician.

    • @BlyatimirPootin
      @BlyatimirPootin Před 2 lety

      You're thinking of Boris Johnson

  • @rankingtrevor
    @rankingtrevor Před 6 lety

    16:10 is the guy on the right in the suit and tie ANDREW MARR???

    • @DBIVUK
      @DBIVUK  Před 6 lety +6

      I don't think it could be. For one thing, although the bloke in the audience looks a bit like Andrew Marr, he doesn't actually look like Andrew Marr looked in 1997. For another, Andrew Marr was Editor of the Independent in 1997 and it's highly unlikely the editor of a daily newspaper would be in the audience of a TV show in the last week before a general election.

    • @themasteryourdaddy.6307
      @themasteryourdaddy.6307 Před 3 lety

      No

  • @middleman3165
    @middleman3165 Před 4 lety +20

    Truly great man and the greatest peacetime leader the UK ever had.

    • @villeporttila5161
      @villeporttila5161 Před 2 dny

      Absolutely. New Labour's achievements and what they did for people's living standards and life chances in Britain are unparalleled since Attlee.

  • @andrewhuckle803
    @andrewhuckle803 Před 5 lety +9

    The argument that Blair was a secret Tory is a weak argument. If he was, he would have joined the Tory Party. I totally agree Iraq was his downfall, but it is tragic, he could have been a great Prime Minister.

  • @MontyCantsin5
    @MontyCantsin5 Před 15 dny

    3:54: Nothing has changed at all. In fact, things have become even worse for Labour under Starmer.

  • @somerandomasshole4561
    @somerandomasshole4561 Před 2 lety

    Why couldnt Labour have won just 2 more seats in 1997?
    Youve failed us, Great Britain.

  • @Genny-Zee
    @Genny-Zee Před měsícem

    The guy in the thumbnail looks like Tony Blair

  • @Lamilton82828
    @Lamilton82828 Před 5 lety +4

    John Prescott red socialist okay

  • @stevehillier7018
    @stevehillier7018 Před 6 lety

    Question. Answers please. Why do people say that the late John Smith would have become the Prime Minister in 1997 under old Labour ? And would have been a good one. So why did Mr Blair engineer New Labour saying that was the only way Labour could be electable ??????

    • @harmlessdrudge
      @harmlessdrudge Před 6 lety +3

      Steve Hillier Blair believed that John Smith was too complacent in thinking that it would take just "one more heave" to win the next election. That's why he reformed Clause IV once he became leader. Smith would have won the 97 election but perhaps with a smaller majority than Blair.

    • @chelseaking1735
      @chelseaking1735 Před 3 lety +1

      harmlessdrudge Smith would’ve won that election regardless. Anyone would’ve won it. Labour were going to win regardless of the leader similar to 1983. Tories were in complete destruction of themsleves and free fall. Smith would’ve won with a majority over 100 too I reckon.

    • @chelseaking1735
      @chelseaking1735 Před 3 lety +3

      harmlessdrudge labour were also 20 points ahead of the tories before Smith died

    • @danielking8946
      @danielking8946 Před rokem

      I've always wondered if John Smith was murdered

  • @pippipster6767
    @pippipster6767 Před 6 lety

    In the days before Bambi fucked everything up

  • @WORLD8NSH5KNIGHT1
    @WORLD8NSH5KNIGHT1 Před hodinou

    27:25 She is the sort of hard left extremist who would argue young offenders shouldn't be punished at all
    Blair - 1
    Criminal Enabler - 0

  • @forheuristiclifeksh7836
    @forheuristiclifeksh7836 Před 8 měsíci

    1:02

  • @marcnikolai
    @marcnikolai Před 9 měsíci +1

    15:49 dude got owned

  • @MrGranfield
    @MrGranfield Před 7 lety +43

    After this I will vote for Tony Blair.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety +2

      MrGranfield I did then

  • @ken-ip4ih
    @ken-ip4ih Před rokem +4

    36:05 Tony’s face LOL

  • @pizzaszit
    @pizzaszit Před 7 lety

    Karen was bang on!

  • @veggie42
    @veggie42 Před 7 lety +1

    OMG he's like Rees-Moggy!

  • @rolandrothwell4840
    @rolandrothwell4840 Před rokem +3

    Everything he says could be said by a Conservative. The rest is either anodyne or simplistic platitudes. Britain deserved so much better

  • @peterwakeman9930
    @peterwakeman9930 Před 7 lety

    2017 the current Labour Leader for the General Election has got better and will be like other after the election in need of the numbers to pass things

  • @RobertK1993
    @RobertK1993 Před 6 lety +1

    2017 the UK has rebelled against the EU

  • @TheSuperLegoMan100
    @TheSuperLegoMan100 Před 3 lety +1

    guy at 10:20 in is absolutely right

  • @user-vk2qw8fs7l
    @user-vk2qw8fs7l Před 6 měsíci +2

    You were prime minister for 10 years and nothing changed.

    • @DBIVUK
      @DBIVUK  Před 6 měsíci +8

      Longest period of sustained low inflation since the 60s; low mortgage rates; Introduced the National Minimum Wage; Over 14,000 more police in England and Wales; Cut overall crime by 32 per cent; Record levels of literacy and numeracy in schools; Young people achieving some of the best ever results at 14, 16, and 18; Funding for every pupil in England doubled; Employment is at its highest level ever; Written off up to 100 per cent of debt owed by poorest countries; 85,000 more nurses; 32,000 more doctors; Brought back matrons to hospital wards; Devolved power to the Scottish Parliament; Devolved power to the Welsh Assembly; Dads now get paternity leave of 2 weeks for the first time; NHS Direct offering free convenient patient advice; Gift aid was worth £828 million to charities last year; Restored city-wide government to London; Record number of students in higher education; Child benefit up 26 per cent since 1997; Delivered 2,200 Sure Start Children’s Centres; Introduced the Equality and Human Rights Commission; £200 winter fuel payment to pensioners & up to £300 for over-80s; On course to exceed our Kyoto target for reducing greenhouse gas emissions; Restored devolved government to Northern Ireland; Over 36,000 more teachers in England and 274,000 more support staff and teaching assistants; All full time workers now have a right to 24 days paid holiday; A million pensioners lifted out of poverty; 600,000 children lifted out of relative poverty; Introduced child tax credit giving more money to parents; Scrapped Section 28 and introduced Civil Partnerships. Not nothing.

    • @Andy-qe6kk
      @Andy-qe6kk Před 5 měsíci

      ​@@DBIVUK Blair built very little social housing, didnt reverse the de-industrialisation of the North, sucked up to the right-wing media, got us into an illegal war which killed 1m people and curtailed civil liberties.

  • @anonymouse740
    @anonymouse740 Před 7 lety +2

    The problem is you can't cut VAT on fuel while being a member of the EU...

    • @Nine-Signs
      @Nine-Signs Před 7 lety +13

      EU nations set their own VAT rates. The UK was and is free to do so on any item at any time.
      image.ibb.co/ftPJvF/vatEU.jpg

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 7 lety

      Anonymouse not below a certain rate because of competition

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 5 lety

      Have to have unanimous agreement

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety

      Bollocks.

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety

      @@veggie42 nonsense. You can lower it to any rate you want. They just couldn't abolish it whatsoever, once introduced. They could have lowered it to 0.00000001% if they wanted

  • @derbysocialclub5158
    @derbysocialclub5158 Před 5 lety +12

    "I don't see any difference between you and the Conservatives." That lady was bang on. And that would be their downfall.

    • @williamfrancis5367
      @williamfrancis5367 Před 5 lety +15

      ...and the reason why they get into power for 13 years. The middle-class vote become very important to winning elections, in the post-Thatcher years.

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 5 lety

      Yes I read a book The Third Way it was about the theory of creation of wealth to alleviate poverty via the capital of the wealthy and the welfare state would help working people but they stopped working

    • @veggie42
      @veggie42 Před 5 lety +2

      @@williamfrancis5367 Thatcher wasn't the Centre she was Right Authoritarian. It was for Labour to move to the centre to win left wing conservatives over

    • @th8257
      @th8257 Před 4 lety +8

      What a ridiculously stupid comment. They won three election in a row and stayed in power for thirteen years, more than any labour leader or government before or since. I wish to god labour had a "downfall" like that now.

    • @tara34952
      @tara34952 Před 3 lety +1

      @derby social club Ummm.... apart from the astronomical level of borrowing, the bloated public sector, insane levels of waste of public funds and subsequent debt... all of which are anathema to true conservative values....

  • @robhingston
    @robhingston Před 6 lety +5

    Tony Blair seems like a angel of light but his worst then the devil himself...
    we still paying the price for this sod