REACTION: RED Taylor's Version + New Vault Tracks

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
  • RELATED VIDEOS
    All Too Well (10 min version) reaction - • Reaction: ALL TOO WELL...
    Red breakdown - • ALBUM BREAKDOWN: RED -...
    Red Vault Tracks breakdown - • BREAKDOWN: Red (Taylor...
    Support this channel AND get extra content on Patreon 💛 / chatsandreacts
    FIND US ON SOCIAL MEDIA
    Twitter - / chatsandreacts
    TikTok - / chatsandreacts
    Instagram - / chatsandreacts
    Personal Instagrams -
    / emily_hunt
    / bonnyrebecca
    CONTACT - chatsandreacts@gmail.com
    Hello and welcome to this weird crevasse of the internet where we get really excited about music (particularly Taylor Swift) and break down our favourite albums and songs. Our names are Bonny and Emily, and our aim with these videos is to share our love for music and also share context and understanding around the songs, by highlighting breaking down the lyrics, melodies and production. We are so happy to have created this little community that is just as unhinged as us when it comes to music 🤪
    0:00 intro
    4:14 state of grace
    7:04 red
    10:15 treacherous
    15:20 i knew you were trouble
    18:42 all too well
    23:03 22
    24:23 i almost do
    26:31 we are never ever getting back together
    29:26 stay stay stay
    31:42 the last time
    34:18 holy ground
    35:30 sad beautiful tragic
    37:15 the lucky one
    39:18 everything has changed
    42:22 starlight
    44:53 begin again
    46:28 the moment i knew
    47:53 come back...be here
    49:15 girl at home
    52:43 state of grace (acoustic)
    54:39 ronan
    58:47 better man
    1:02:13 nothing new
    1:12:20 babe
    1:15:17 message in a bottle
    1:20:22 i bet you think about me
    1:27:29 forever winter
    1:33:48 run
    1:39:19 the very first night

Komentáře • 1,8K

  • @sheeranpotterlover
    @sheeranpotterlover Před 2 lety +543

    My favourite "that was offensive" queens are back

  • @marlikauffman4994
    @marlikauffman4994 Před 2 lety +4750

    everyone say THANK YOU BONNY FOR EDITING THIS FOR US SO QUICKLY

  • @tpwkemily267
    @tpwkemily267 Před 2 lety +2757

    'offensive' 'fathomed' 'illegal' 'superior' and 'rude' are now daily adjectives in my life and i regularly feel the need to *emily scream*

  • @thomascampbell350
    @thomascampbell350 Před 9 měsíci +38

    I’m so glad she re-recorded Ronan. The idea of scooter owning the rights to it makes me want to punch a wall

  • @lucca5823
    @lucca5823 Před 2 lety +3049

    emily's love language is slapping bonny

    • @codepurpleindahood
      @codepurpleindahood Před 2 lety +18

      😂

    • @beahanna
      @beahanna Před 2 lety +7

      hahaha

    • @C-Iris
      @C-Iris Před 2 lety +49

      Hahaha true!! Bonny's right side of her body is getting special treatment 😆

    • @raelee735
      @raelee735 Před 2 lety +5

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @magdalena9405
      @magdalena9405 Před 2 lety +10

      OK, this is a month old comment, but I'll just skip that. I'm Chilean. As a country, we hug, kiss, would probably grab each other's arms in a similar scenario with the same ease and might occasionally push each other in a soft way. The tender hitting of the arms seems pretty normal too. If something exciting were to happen to me or a friend, I would be grabbing her arm and swaying us in the craziest way. Yep, we are a fun crowd

  • @chatsandreacts
    @chatsandreacts  Před 2 lety +3603

    Do you guys like us reacting to the whole album or would you prefer just the vault songs? I hope you enjoy this video as I worked so hard on the editing to make it fun and entertaining even thought its long 🥰❤️

    • @dontdeletethexos
      @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +870

      Love that it's the whole album! Thank you for taking the time to film your experience so we can share it with you 💓

    • @jadeswift9327
      @jadeswift9327 Před 2 lety +519

      we love that u post the whole thing and not just the vault tracks

    • @allisonaguilar5861
      @allisonaguilar5861 Před 2 lety +392

      love watching the whole thing! feels like listening along with friends, these 2 hour vids feel like 20 mins with you guys!

    • @isabellegatapia5658
      @isabellegatapia5658 Před 2 lety +199

      Whole album!!!! It’s the best seeing what you guys think about how it all sounds now!!!!

    • @riaraut5311
      @riaraut5311 Před 2 lety +147

      The whole albums!!

  • @mitorree31
    @mitorree31 Před 2 lety +640

    She went from "will you still love me when I'm nothing new?" to "and when I felt like I was an old cardigan under someone's bed, you put me on and said I was your favorite."

    • @nikolamurphy
      @nikolamurphy Před rokem +19

      such a great parallel omgggg i love this!!

    • @easyveganfoodie
      @easyveganfoodie Před rokem +27

      Also the line in call it what you want to “loves me like I’m brand new.”

  • @heyyitsmel
    @heyyitsmel Před 2 lety +264

    "they don't know about the night in the hotel" "if you like causing trouble up in hotel rooms" PLS

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +2335

    Your friends are real ones coming in with all the lyrics. This seems like such a beautiful group of friends experiencing a wonderful album together, thank you for letting us be part of this

    • @chatsandreacts
      @chatsandreacts  Před 2 lety +281

      I know tell me about it, absolute legends ❤️

    • @laurenjennings4104
      @laurenjennings4104 Před 2 lety +19

      This makes me want to take a trip to Australia just to sit with all of you sipping coffee .....like were on a late night show haha and listen to the next release. I truly believe its going to be speak now because..... she had a match box merch for red with 19 matches in it.
      "Dont you think 19s to young to played by your dark twisted games" But I took your matches before fire could catch me so don't look now. Screams Speak Now

    • @sumanbabar9591
      @sumanbabar9591 Před 2 lety +4

      Ya. Almost seems like an omniscient narrator.

    • @ajax-lvr
      @ajax-lvr Před 13 dny

      @@laurenjennings4104 you were right lol

  • @lizardqueen7052
    @lizardqueen7052 Před 2 lety +331

    taylor: "i bet you think about me"
    swifties: GIRL YOU KNOW WE DOOOO

  • @nicolehunt4873
    @nicolehunt4873 Před 2 lety +292

    Nothing New: “Will you still want me when I’m nothing new?”
    CIWYW: “Loves me like I’m brand new.”

  • @leetahs9051
    @leetahs9051 Před 2 lety +289

    Okay but describing the vocals as “crisp” is the most accurate ever. Like maccas sprite.

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +1543

    If the documentary isn't called "Taylor's version" I will be UNWELL when it comes out

    • @blinkforpinks6079
      @blinkforpinks6079 Před 2 lety +13

      A documentary is coming out?

    • @dontdeletethexos
      @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +123

      @@blinkforpinks6079 nothing has been confirmed, but people are assuming that this is such a big part of Taylor's experience and career that she wouldn't not document it

    • @jankova0013
      @jankova0013 Před 2 lety +13

      @@dontdeletethexos I'm 100% sure she does. But I'm not sure we'll see it :/ I desperately hope so tho!

    • @disgustedrn4215
      @disgustedrn4215 Před 2 lety +10

      @@jankova0013 I'm definitely sure she has documented the rerecordings and stuff because she does it for ever album in existence of hers. So y'know..... You never know 👀

    • @hnereirgrd
      @hnereirgrd Před 2 lety +10

      “Taylor's Version: The Documentary” 👀

  • @GeraIsShook
    @GeraIsShook Před 2 lety +2068

    MY FAVORITE TAYLOR SWIFT REACTORS 🙌🏻

    • @dani.p
      @dani.p Před 2 lety +14

      YAAAAAS! Gera!!!!! Esperaba que las conocieras

    • @judehizon5607
      @judehizon5607 Před 2 lety +10

      and yam haus ❤

    • @wgrodrig5651
      @wgrodrig5651 Před 2 lety +17

      Gera tu eres nuestro Chats & Reacts en Español ❤️🧣

    • @joshuaramon123
      @joshuaramon123 Před 2 lety +5

      I watch your videos even though I don't understand your language!

    • @debishvebishwish4839
      @debishvebishwish4839 Před 2 lety +4

      Aaaah I love you too although I doesn’t understand anything that you said, but it’s your passion and love for Taylor that matters to me. Love you!

  • @everythinsrosie9765
    @everythinsrosie9765 Před 2 lety +904

    Forever Winter is speculated to be about Taylor’s old friend Jeff Lang who passed away in 2010. She use to share her music with him before it even went out to public to get his opinion. 😢 she sang during his funeral and won an award the next day and dedicated it to him.

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +88

    I love that the all too wells have different sounds. It gives the five minute version it's own moment and makes sure that it doesn't get lost under the ten minute version. She's a genius

  • @valf2498
    @valf2498 Před 2 lety +639

    Funny thing, Ed Sheeran actually liked Run better than Everything Has Changed and he was so happy when Taylor asked him to re-record it he always felt that was their best collaboration

  • @Emma-vd6zf
    @Emma-vd6zf Před 2 lety +853

    The Vault tracks are literally an entire album in themselves. There are so many and they are all SO STRONG 😱

    • @amandaleighplans
      @amandaleighplans Před 2 lety +60

      I wasn’t big on Fearless vault tracks but Red ones are all so INCREDIBLE that I’m actually going to lose it when we get 1989 and Rep vault tracks

    • @amandaleighplans
      @amandaleighplans Před 2 lety +42

      Ok now that I typed this I just realized…. SPEAK NOW VAULT TRACKS. I might actually die. SN is one of my fav albums it’s full of bops oh my god

    • @jimbob2427
      @jimbob2427 Před rokem +4

      @@amandaleighplans and speak now!

    • @Taytaystwixtor
      @Taytaystwixtor Před 11 měsíci

      @@amandaleighplansyou good?😂

    • @rightwhereyouleftme12
      @rightwhereyouleftme12 Před 7 měsíci +4

      ​@@jimbob2427This aged so well

  • @michelle6337
    @michelle6337 Před 2 lety +313

    Nothing New breaks my heart because she wrote this before the whole TS is over party debacle after 1989. So she was already worried about how long people would "allow" her to be successful, a concept she mentioned in Miss Americana too, and then people tore her down in exactly the way she feared in Nothing New.

  • @sabrinaanne2300
    @sabrinaanne2300 Před 2 lety +3825

    timestamps besties!!
    4:09 State Of Grace
    7:03 Red
    10:15 Treacherous
    15:20 I Knew You Were Trouble
    18:38 All Too Well
    22:58 22
    24:24 I Almost Do
    26:30 We Are Never Ever Getting Back
    29:04 Stay, Stay, Stay
    31:16 The Last Time
    34:14 Holy Ground
    35:15 Sad Beautiful Tragic
    37:07 The Lucky One
    39:17 Everything Has Changed
    42:09 Starlight
    44:44 Begin Again
    46:17 The Moment I Knew
    47:47 Come Back... Be Here
    49:09 Girl At Home
    52:40 State Of Grace (Acoustic Version)
    53:59 Ronan
    57:31 Better Man
    1:01:56 Nothing New
    1:12:12 Babe
    1:15:07 Message In A Bottle
    1:20:12 I Bet You Think About Me
    1:27:26 Forever Winter
    1:33:15 Run
    1:39:00 The Very First Night

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +700

    I think we can all agree that Taylor swift and Jack Antonoff owns our asses at this point

    • @michealrhodes974
      @michealrhodes974 Před 2 lety +13

      Jack owns our bussy's

    • @debishvebishwish4839
      @debishvebishwish4839 Před 2 lety +45

      Add Aaron to that list too. The way I screamed when I saw him in IBYTAM MV

    • @michealrhodes974
      @michealrhodes974 Před 2 lety +25

      @@debishvebishwish4839 not me reading this as "the way I CREAMED when i saw him in IBYTAM MV" *slowly applies clown makeup*

    • @abbinorth55
      @abbinorth55 Před 10 měsíci

      UNCLE JACK AND GRANDPY AARON

  • @andreannetheberge-dupuis1398

    I'll twist the knife about Ronan a little more, but the lyrics where actually composed using quotes from the blog Ronan's mother wrote (and is still writing to this day) where she is writing directly TO Ronan...
    And then Taylor credited Maya as co-writer...
    So yeah 😅😭

    • @juvenallunaortega7546
      @juvenallunaortega7546 Před 2 lety +45

      That's definitely the saddest TS song. Heartbreak songs are nothing compared to Ronan

    • @dcandleonna
      @dcandleonna Před 2 lety +26

      oh my god. oh my GOD. this made it even sadder, to imagine Ronan being sung by his mom 😭

    • @cmcm4204
      @cmcm4204 Před 2 lety +12

      I have to skip, it’s too sad. That and Soon You’ll Get Better 💔

    • @sikinboat
      @sikinboat Před 2 lety +8

      And to make it even harder the lyric video she released for Taylor’s version is photo clips of Ronan and his family. Really didn’t need to cry that much when it came up but there was no possible way not to.

  • @matildaonvideo
    @matildaonvideo Před 2 lety +306

    1:16:57 The swinging arms chorus when Bonny is ~enjoying~ and Emily is ~processing~ is a big mood. Now I can't get a hypothetical, slightly slower, more strings version of Message In A Bottle by The Corrs out of my brain Bonny!!! Amazing call 🤩 x

  • @aqsireyrey
    @aqsireyrey Před 2 lety +498

    I think the reason that Girl at Home was done different was maybe it was how Taylor originally imagined it to be. She never said it so this is all from pure assumption but from what I remember Girl at Home (2012) felt very unfinished honestly. It's also amazing that this just proves how through these re-recordings, she just can do whatever she wants.

    • @EriDexter
      @EriDexter Před 2 lety +80

      I think she’s said before that Girl At Home stolen version was a demo? Maybe she told Scott she wanted to make it poppy and he said no so she just used the demo! Maybe that’s why it was on the deluxe not the standard because she wasn’t super happy with it?

  • @jasminsmith4023
    @jasminsmith4023 Před 2 lety +358

    This album captured Taylor's true potential as an artist- lyrically and from a production standpoint. The re-release proves who she was always meant to be and now IS.

    • @flxwercxrpse1871
      @flxwercxrpse1871 Před 2 lety +15

      Exactly. I feel like they (BMR) cut out a real, raw part of Taylor and its so maddening we missed out on it for years 😤

  • @Naomimvl
    @Naomimvl Před 2 lety +147

    Forever winter is about a friend from high school. She talked about singing at his funeral getting a BMI award in 2010. Speak now had just come out, so she probably wrote this song as if he was still here regretting she couldn't do more for him.

  • @joellem625
    @joellem625 Před 2 lety +106

    “The last time” was everything that song walked so “exile” can run! And forever winter hits differently it’s so beautiful!!

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +573

    State of grace is one of her best opening tracks. I SAID WHAT I SAID.

  • @dontdeletethexos
    @dontdeletethexos Před 2 lety +181

    This album is just like nostalgia bottled for me, it was such an overwhelming experience hearing Taylor's versions of the songs that I listened to during my teenage years

  • @laurenwhitaker17
    @laurenwhitaker17 Před 2 lety +43

    I love how it went from “I think it’s strange that you think I’m funny ‘cause he never did” with Begin Again to “I was never good at telling jokes, but the punchline goes…” in All Too Well (10 min)

  • @moumitasinha815
    @moumitasinha815 Před 2 lety +582

    It's actually crazy how with Nothing New the allusions totally fit with Olivia Rodrigo even though the song was written years ago (as seen in the Lover diaries)

    • @boy.erased
      @boy.erased Před 2 lety +47

      reminds me of ‘the lucky one’ as well. a young girl rising to fame and realizing she’s not happy.

    • @lol9600
      @lol9600 Před rokem +3

      CRAZY RIGHT

    • @jimbob2427
      @jimbob2427 Před rokem +2

      @Avery Jay thankfully the song was written way before Olivia got mainstream attention

  • @cielocatapat
    @cielocatapat Před 2 lety +64

    THE MOST AWAITED REACTION!! THANK YOU SO MUCH 🥺

  • @phuct7621
    @phuct7621 Před 2 lety +237

    forever winter is actually about Taylor’s best friend who passed away when they were only 21

    • @phoebepitman2025
      @phoebepitman2025 Před 2 lety +5

      Yeah, Corey Monteith from glee 🥺

    • @jen760
      @jen760 Před 2 lety +37

      @@phoebepitman2025 it might be her high school friend, he passed away from a drug overdose, she mentions him in her bmi award. we won't know for sure, it could even be about her brother

    • @phoebepitman2025
      @phoebepitman2025 Před 2 lety +2

      @@jen760 ah yes that makes sense!

    • @TheNraveles
      @TheNraveles Před 2 lety +13

      @@phoebepitman2025 Corey actually passed after red came out and this song was was written before. It’s def about Jeff Lang

  • @MskLeeSay
    @MskLeeSay Před 2 lety +627

    Message In A Bottle could’ve definitely been in the Lizzie McGuire Movie.

    • @cantbleednow3639
      @cantbleednow3639 Před 2 lety +10

      Omg also you can add it to any dance sequence and it fits everytime

  • @carolinestreithorst4729
    @carolinestreithorst4729 Před 2 lety +146

    Do you know that Maya wrote most of the lyrics herself on a blog about Ronans journey? Taylor was so touched by her words that she decided to make a song out of it and Maya is listed as a songwriter for this one.

  • @jasonramstad6576
    @jasonramstad6576 Před 2 lety +299

    The way coming here after a new Taylor release has become compulsory.

  • @cerigau
    @cerigau Před 2 lety +106

    I feel like the whole re-release experience isn't complete without you guys' reactions!!! ❤️🧣

  • @shairamore
    @shairamore Před 2 lety +94

    I read somewhere that Message In A Bottle can be a Barbie soundtrack and I can’t UNSEE UNHEAR UNIMAGINE it anymore 😩😂

  • @myeahonline
    @myeahonline Před 2 lety +618

    About the “Fuck the patriarchy” lyric, someone pointed out that it’s probably supposed to be that the keychain had the words “Fuck the patriarchy” instead of it being said by Taylor or Jake. So it brings out his false hipster feminism , and that keychain is so opposite to how he’s treating a woman. I think that’s a very interesting narrative to take too since he’s really painted as a hipster-indie-too-cool-to-try-to-impress-your-dad energy.

    • @cmcm4204
      @cmcm4204 Před 2 lety +33

      There are fuck the patriarchy keychains available on the site. I bought two 😂

    • @Nath13ify
      @Nath13ify Před 2 lety +18

      that's what I thought too and in the short film he is throwing the key at her

    • @AllTheArtsy
      @AllTheArtsy Před 2 lety +23

      That's why it's in quotations. "Fuck the patriarchy" keychain. That he's tossing to her, making her pick up. Hence, the opposite action to the words. My god some people are dense lol

    • @cmcm4204
      @cmcm4204 Před 2 lety +1

      All The Artsy crawl back under the rock you came from buddy. There are two perfectly acceptable explanations for the lyric. It could either be a direct quote from a person or an inscription on the keychain. This channel is a happy place where people come to exchange ideas, not throw insults around.

    • @AllTheArtsy
      @AllTheArtsy Před 2 lety +16

      @@cmcm4204
      "And you were tossing me the car keys
      Fuck the patriarchy (out of context, just said by... someone, i guess)
      Keychain on the ground"
      Suuuure that makes sense

  • @norajamieson1908
    @norajamieson1908 Před 2 lety +751

    As someone who struggles with mental health and has had a really rough year where I wanted to leave more times than I can count, Forever Winter makes me absolutely bawl . . . I know it may sound corny, but when I hear her say "please don't go" it feels like it's directed at me. It makes me remember that there are people who'd miss me, who'd fall to pieces on the floor if I left. It reminds me that I'm not just fighting for me and my future self, but my brothers, my mother, my dogs, and everyone who loves me as well. My favorite vault track by far

    • @andweoop3254
      @andweoop3254 Před 2 lety +31

      i hope ur doing well❤️❤️

    • @norajamieson1908
      @norajamieson1908 Před 2 lety +40

      ​@@andweoop3254 Thank you for your well wishes, blessadly I am coming out the other side of what felt like an endless dark spell. Every day gets just bit brighter. And to anyone who stumbles upon this comment keep fighting for your future self - you will always be grateful you did. I certainly am.

    • @jcs1090
      @jcs1090 Před 2 lety +27

      You matter. Stay.

    • @norajamieson1908
      @norajamieson1908 Před 2 lety +15

      @@jcs1090 I am trying my very hardest. Thank you so much for saying that

    • @PLazz257
      @PLazz257 Před 2 lety +16

      Same I think Forever Winter is the best vault track for me once I understand the lyrics deeper

  • @matthewk8279
    @matthewk8279 Před 2 lety +465

    The fact that Taylor featured phoebe on a song that should’ve been on the original album….. she’s trying to kill me. It’s just too offensive and iconic and rude.
    So excited for this!

    • @chatsandreacts
      @chatsandreacts  Před 2 lety +119

      Nothing New is my fav vault song its soooooo offensive I can't bElieve whats happening. B x

    • @garimasharma4812
      @garimasharma4812 Před 2 lety +9

      I love the Lucky one but Nothing New feels so much more personal, in terms of references and now looking in hindsight how things have played out for her... It's my favourite track from vault as well

    • @ericlecuriste
      @ericlecuriste Před 2 lety +8

      @@chatsandreacts I also immediately thought about Olivia, so so weird she did not post anything regarding Red on her social media, radio silence, quite sad, wish she can still be herself and spontaneous, despite entourage and pressure

  • @midnightsbabe
    @midnightsbabe Před 2 lety +222

    Can we take a moment to appreciate Bonny's editing? It's PERFECT.

  • @hollybeck605
    @hollybeck605 Před 2 lety +66

    I still can not get over how perfect All Too Well 10 minutes is. It is the WHOLE PACKAGE. I've listened to it practically on repeat all week. And isn't it amazing how it doesn't FEEL like a 10 minute song?!

  • @emiliollerenas213
    @emiliollerenas213 Před 2 lety +434

    Nothing New is such a fantastic song! So powerful and Phoebe and Taylor have such gorgeous chemistry

  • @elenatti
    @elenatti Před 2 lety +1226

    timestamps 💋
    4:14 state of grace
    7:04 red
    10:15 treacherous
    15:20 i knew you were trouble
    18:42 all too well
    23:03 22
    24:23 i almost do
    26:31 wanegbt
    29:26 stay stay stay
    31:42 the last time
    34:18 holy ground
    35:30 sad beautiful tragic
    37:15 the lucky one
    39:18 everything has changed
    42:22 starlight
    44:53 begin again
    46:28 the moment i knew
    47:53 come back...be here
    49:15 girl at home
    52:43 state of grace (acoustic)
    54:39 ronan
    58:47 better man
    1:02:13 nothing new
    1:12:20 babe
    1:15:17 message in a bottle
    1:20:22 i bet you think about me
    1:27:29 forever winter
    1:33:48 run
    1:39:19 the very first night
    separate video for all too well ten minute version!

  • @ajbella5446
    @ajbella5446 Před 2 lety +258

    I think the "Girl at home" taylor's version was the actual sound Taylor envisioned it to be in the original album. And remember that Scott and the management of her label required her to have a certain number of "country-sounding" songs and so they just decided to convert it to the country sound we all grown to know in the first record.

    • @sagittarianwolf8513
      @sagittarianwolf8513 Před 5 měsíci

      Yeah, it's stupid how she can't do her own mixing in that stupid label

  • @codepurpleindahood
    @codepurpleindahood Před 2 lety +245

    It’s not a chats and reacts video until Emily says “you don’t know what you don’t know” 😂 love you guys

  • @rikki7953
    @rikki7953 Před 2 lety +417

    I don't have any swifties in my life so you guys are really filling a hole in my heart

    • @karensokol7081
      @karensokol7081 Před 2 lety +15

      Yes, me too! It’s nice to be able to share my love with y’all.

    • @averynormalpotato8620
      @averynormalpotato8620 Před rokem +4

      I trick my friends to listen to taylor all the time and like 3 songs in their like wait a minute this is still taylor

  • @nesclaire
    @nesclaire Před 2 lety +44

    I’m literally just as excited to watch this as I was listening to red for the first time!!

  • @ameliafoley1691
    @ameliafoley1691 Před 2 lety +51

    I think part of why her voice sounds so incredible on these recordings is because, unlike when she first recorded them, she has been performing these songs for almost a decade. She knows how the smallest of changes can impact the listener and how to perform the intricacies of each line in the most superior way. Practice makes even better than perfect ✨❤️

  • @adeleolmastroni1545
    @adeleolmastroni1545 Před 2 lety +43

    "Anyone who doesn't like Starlight, don't trust them" EXACTLY

  • @leetahs9051
    @leetahs9051 Před 2 lety +19

    8:14 “she delayed that street” i lost it hahaha emily you’re fab

  • @ameliafoley1691
    @ameliafoley1691 Před 2 lety +49

    As a Mum of two little boys, one of which had just turned four - Ronan turns me into a puddle of tears everytime I hear it 💙

  • @cookiemonster5040
    @cookiemonster5040 Před 2 lety +43

    Emily abusing Bonny’s arm: 👊🏻💢
    Bonny: 😄😄

  • @ninreck5121
    @ninreck5121 Před rokem +11

    I love how in the beginning of forever winter you both perfectly depict the dual nature of the song, Em worried because of the lyrics and bon just vibing to the production

  • @ToniGorton
    @ToniGorton Před 2 lety +28

    I’m SO excited for her rerelease of her Debut. That will show the true growth of this amazingly, beautiful, talented woman.

  • @ally_roro1482
    @ally_roro1482 Před 2 lety +29

    How beautiful is it that Taylor and Ed wrote Ran together as their first song as new friends ten years ago and now they’re still close friends ten years later and they finally released this song 🥺❤️

  • @bratndahwz
    @bratndahwz Před 2 lety +42

    I believe Forever Winter is about her friend Jeff Lang who died right after Speak Now released. She sang at his funeral the day before she won BMI Country Songwriter of the Year. czcams.com/video/zp1peBYUT00/video.html
    For context, he died in November and her 21st B-Day was a month later.

  • @reyeza1922
    @reyeza1922 Před 7 měsíci +10

    girl at home tv is so underrated, this song deserves attention!

    • @Luisluispenalivecommx
      @Luisluispenalivecommx Před 6 měsíci

      Is one of my fav, alongside red, holy ground, I knew you were Trouble, WANGBT. though I care less for the rest, Red is not one of my fav albums but Gir at home TV stands up tall

  • @Itschibi
    @Itschibi Před 2 lety +29

    Why no one is talking about how your gorgeous puppy enjoys “I bet you think about me” 😭❤️🐶

  • @quinroseman7233
    @quinroseman7233 Před 2 lety +314

    the thing i like about this reaction is that y’all embraced the slight differences in some songs. Some reactors were like “It DoEsnT SOuNd ThE SaMe!” and i was like… yeah, it’s been almost a decade. So thank you for allowing the re-recordings to live their own lives without holding them completely to the originals.

    • @stupidfuck6060
      @stupidfuck6060 Před 2 lety +27

      Swifties on twitter are calling it trash because they say that some instruments don't sound the same 💀 those people are ridiculous

    • @taylorsversion6927
      @taylorsversion6927 Před 2 lety +21

      @@stupidfuck6060 …that’s literally the point wut💀 like they’d sound exactly like ten years ago

  • @averiwright1109
    @averiwright1109 Před 2 lety +25

    Omg Ari is so cute!! She’s like why are y’all so excited? What’s going on? What’s happening? She’s excited because y’all are excited. I just can’t with her! I love her. Also Emily and Bonny y’all are ICONIC. Such a perfect representation of Swifties❤️

  • @KyleOgilvie1
    @KyleOgilvie1 Před 2 lety +351

    "If you hate stay stay stay, you hate fun." Facts are facts. Taylor herself says 'it's so fun' so Stay Stay Stay slander is not sanctioned.

    • @folklore9062
      @folklore9062 Před rokem +2

      I like me! But not stay x3🙃

    • @raullll.222
      @raullll.222 Před rokem +4

      @@folklore9062 but stay x3 is so cute to dedicate to someone or when you're in love + i love the bridge

    • @folklore9062
      @folklore9062 Před rokem +2

      @@raullll.222 i bop to it but i don't like it that much

    • @welcometonewyork1496
      @welcometonewyork1496 Před rokem +1

      I used to hate stay3x so much but I love it now😅

  • @Mandyn8868
    @Mandyn8868 Před 2 lety +49

    emily’s country accent is KILLING ME as someone from tennessee

  • @yookshie6785
    @yookshie6785 Před 2 lety +11

    Taylor's sigh in RONAN IS TOO MUCH I ALSO CRIED DAMNNNNN 😭😭👁️

  • @annoyinglyopinionated4674
    @annoyinglyopinionated4674 Před 2 lety +34

    I love nothing new it epitomises Taylor’s emotional and social intelligence not to mention her musical ability! It also reminds me of this quote from a book that stuck with me about the viciousness of people -“they’re gonna bleed you out till your nothing, and then they’re gonna ask how you died”

  • @Hannah_jo25
    @Hannah_jo25 Před 2 lety +78

    Run: “This thing was a shot in the dark”
    Get Away Car: “We never had a shot gun shot in the dark”
    AND BOTH SONGS ARE ABOUT RUNNING AWAY IN A CAR!!! 🥲

  • @AKLabs-xl4re
    @AKLabs-xl4re Před 2 lety +29

    Red re-recording is sooo iconic but imagine if Taylor collaborates with Harry Styles for 1989. Harry has always been respectful of Taylor after the breakup and I think they’re on good terms now.

  • @carlijnvanderheijden4024
    @carlijnvanderheijden4024 Před 2 lety +20

    The way I'm not able to watch a 1 hour and 45 min long lecture, but on the other hand, I have no problems with watching a 1 hour 45 min long reaction video from Bonny and Emily, AND I'M HERE FOR IT ❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @josuebarrera1877
    @josuebarrera1877 Před 2 lety +20

    Forever winter is about Jeff lang, one of Taylor’s friend who overdosed after speak now was released hence the lyrics, “all this time I didn’t know, you were breaking down”

  • @keyshlanarvaez6921
    @keyshlanarvaez6921 Před 2 lety +327

    Taylor: "They don't know about the night in the hotel"
    Harry: "If you like causing trouble up in hotel rooms"
    Yep is about Harry xD

    • @stepbystefh
      @stepbystefh Před 2 lety +44

      "And if you like midnight driving with the windows down" AAAHHHH OMG

    • @livbarberr
      @livbarberr Před 2 lety +5

      Harry and Taylor had not dated when red was released. They started dating in december 2012, she released Red in November 2012.

    • @keyshlanarvaez6921
      @keyshlanarvaez6921 Před 2 lety +25

      @@livbarberr They met on the kids choice awards (March 31st, 2012). It was rumored that they were interested in each other after that, and started talking (not quite dating, but yeah). Then some photos of Harry kissing another girl were leaked. So Taylor called off whatever was happening between them (hence "I knew you were trouble" was created, and yes that one is about him bc the guy in the mv has a ship tattoo). So yeah, I think "the very first night" is about Harry, but at the very beginning of their relationship.

    • @JustJulie-cz8fs
      @JustJulie-cz8fs Před 2 lety +6

      It’s not Harry; this is about Jake. Back when Jake Taylor dated he flew her out to London, and they had a romantic hotel date in London. Harry and Taylor only dated later in late 2012 the album was already done then.

    • @JustJulie-cz8fs
      @JustJulie-cz8fs Před 2 lety +4

      @@keyshlanarvaez6921 This isn’t true though. In that same article (Vanity Fair) his representative and friend, Ben, denies those claims. The “source” in that quote said, “their hands were up in each other’s hair” but when you look up the photos, there are 0 photos with Harry’s hands in a models hair, or hers in his.
      What debunks this as well is after KCA’s, One Direction flew out to Saturday Night Live, located in NY. Taylor flew out too and was there the same week as One Direction, but instead was spending time with Dianna, some singer-guy whomever it was, and Emma Stone. She never visited Harry.
      If we believe those rumours, then that means Taylor dated Harry for only 1-week, or actually 3-4 days realistically as soon as they met. It just doesn’t make much sense.

  • @aloe2573
    @aloe2573 Před 2 lety +40

    Harry wrote a song called “if I could fly “ same as her “the very first night “ song. 😭

    • @JustJulie-cz8fs
      @JustJulie-cz8fs Před 2 lety

      They’re not related though, ICF came out in like 2015.

    • @cadencefrances
      @cadencefrances Před 2 lety +4

      @@JustJulie-cz8fs it’s literally on the same album as perfect “and if you’re looking for someone to write your breakup songs about” so it’s not out of the realm of possibility

  • @AnnaStafford
    @AnnaStafford Před 2 lety +77

    I’m hoping she’ll release a docuseries with six episodes that shows the process of re-recording each album 🤞🏻

    • @MermaidCore_
      @MermaidCore_ Před 2 lety +1

      Yes!!!! Emmy for Ms. Swift!! Or a full length movie 🎥

  • @caitrose543
    @caitrose543 Před 2 lety +17

    I love this whole friendship dynamic! I wish I had friends like this to freak out over albums with, but at least I have these videos ❤️

  • @mrsperfectlyfine1602
    @mrsperfectlyfine1602 Před 2 lety +15

    The best thing about being a Swiftie and Taylor re-recording and re-releasing her albums again and listening to the songs we’ve heard a hundred times and freaking out about it

  • @finefrenzied
    @finefrenzied Před 2 lety +61

    I wish I had girl friends to listen with and get excited with me over Taylor.

  • @lesleynunez512
    @lesleynunez512 Před 2 lety +14

    In the very first night, it says “they don’t know about the night in the hotel” and I immediately thought of 1D’s song perfect which is suspected being about Taylor from the line “if you’re looking for someone to write your breakup songs about, baby I’m perfect”, the music video takes place in a hotel room as well and describes that feeling that their love might crash and burn but feels perfect in the moment.

    • @JustJulie-cz8fs
      @JustJulie-cz8fs Před 2 lety +1

      That was after though. If she wrote this in early 2012, and not late 2012 then there’s no chance it’s about him.

  • @ximethemermaid
    @ximethemermaid Před 2 lety +11

    1:06:39 i love that they both go into praying position when phoebe's verse begins because it IS a holy experience

  • @Jb18775
    @Jb18775 Před 10 měsíci +9

    51:09 emily predicted the future

  • @leetahs9051
    @leetahs9051 Před 2 lety +166

    AHHHH SOOOO EXCITED!!!! My faves and the best album and i physically cannot handle this video i adore you both. My comfort channel💛💛💛

    • @chatsandreacts
      @chatsandreacts  Před 2 lety +37

      omg 🥺don't make me cry, we are so grateful for this community !!!! ❤️

    • @leetahs9051
      @leetahs9051 Před 2 lety +6

      @@chatsandreacts love you both sooo so so much thank you for this corner of the internet 🥺🥰💛💛💛💛

  • @im_juanm
    @im_juanm Před rokem +6

    The happiness on Emily's face when she heard that in fact, taylor did the same adlibs for i knew you were trouble is so relatable

  • @crystalrose_pa
    @crystalrose_pa Před 2 lety +39

    I don't even know that it was Taylor deciding "the world's not ready" for the "f*ck the patriarchy" line; If I had to guess I would say the label pressured her to not include it because they wanted to maintain her "good girl" image. I think she really had to censor herself in a lot of ways because of that. And I 100% believe it was in the original because I think Jake probably genuinely had a "F*ck the Patriarchy" keychain because that was the persona he presented to the world but wasn't really living it in their relationship, and I think that's the whole point of that line.

  • @wgrodrig5651
    @wgrodrig5651 Před 2 lety +61

    You really didn’t have to but we’re so grateful that you did this for us. We are so UNWELL! Blondie chose chaos but there we are again 🧣

  • @joeywy__8528
    @joeywy__8528 Před 2 lety +61

    Before watching: I bet this is gonna be the best reaction I have ever watched!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @whosafraidoflittleoldme18

    i cry every time i hear Forever Winter because i've been on both ends, ive talked people out of it, and ive had people talk me out of it, and now that ive healed and made it to almost 17, i can definitively say, it does get better eventually. it'll be a rough healing journey, might even feel worse than where you are already, but it's so worth it to be able to feel genuine happiness. coming from someone who struggled since i was 7, believe me, you'll heal. you'll relapse, but that's part of the process. it won't be a straight line, but by the end of it, you'll start realizing how much you could've missed if you did go, and feel grateful you can experience this happiness again

  • @mauradudley
    @mauradudley Před 2 lety +25

    Bonny, you are a legend for editing this and cradling that speaker listening to the re-records.
    Edit: I appreciate that you all reacted to IBYTAM exactly the way I did at 1030 at night in my house. 🤯

  • @emmasanntos
    @emmasanntos Před 2 lety +192

    omg, it's almost 11pm in Brazil, but who cares?? I'm gonna watch this right now. So excited!!

  • @matildaonvideo
    @matildaonvideo Před 2 lety +658

    14:26 Wait, was that “Taylor Swift knows who we are” because she gave us all the 10 minute version of All Too Well that we never knew just how desperately we needed, or did I miss her acknowledging you two somewhere?!? 😱👏 x

    • @cielocatapat
      @cielocatapat Před 2 lety +207

      taylor liked and commented on one of their tiktok videos

    • @mada7660
      @mada7660 Před 2 lety +101

      she commented that she loves them on a tiktok (with 13 exclamation points) hahah

    • @matildaonvideo
      @matildaonvideo Před 2 lety +64

      Ahh thank you for letting me know, just found the TikTok! That's one of my faaavourite moments of their folklore reaction video so I can't *believe* Taylor saw it. So happy for you two!! 😻 x

  • @hurricanecatrina9548
    @hurricanecatrina9548 Před 2 lety +19

    Begin Again made me sob because it’s like you can hear her singing it about Joe now. She’s found her person 🥺

    • @arushi3621
      @arushi3621 Před rokem +6

      oh girl i-

    • @ry._an
      @ry._an Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@arushi3621 noooo stopp 😭😭😭😭😭

  • @hermess.hollock8291
    @hermess.hollock8291 Před 2 lety +8

    I get so happy every time you post a reaction video because I feel like I’m also in your living room, screaming, crying, and dying with you.

  • @Eric_BroArmy13
    @Eric_BroArmy13 Před 2 lety +14

    LMAO I like how your dog just waltzed in at 1:23:03 paused a couple of times and started wagging her tail.
    She was like "I bet he does! Go off my queen!!!"
    I bet she's a swiftie.

  • @giulialeoni411
    @giulialeoni411 Před 2 lety +5

    Your reaction to "I bet you think about me" was a whole boost of serotonin

  • @melodiekarama2434
    @melodiekarama2434 Před 2 lety +9

    The re-release has made me realize something about State of Grace I hadn’t heard before. “I’m walking fast through the traffic lights / And I never saw you coming” sounds a whole lot like a car crash. 😩

  • @katyjean862
    @katyjean862 Před rokem +5

    Watching in Nov 2022... I discovered you two a few days ago while digging deeper into the midnighTS tracks. I have to say that you two are my new digital besties (which I need because I live alone). You two are so fun, sweet, positively beautiful, and knowledgeable about music, music production, Taylor Swift, lore and lyric... It is OFFENSIVE how much you know about our beloved Queen's career and music.
    I'm so proud of you for putting together this wonderful channel with truly amazing videos. So much here to enjoy. Excellent editing!! If you aren't rich 🤑 yet from all these skills, you should be. 💜💜💜

  • @jennette_mccardi
    @jennette_mccardi Před 2 lety +7

    OMG!!! The fact that everything is perfection is just criminal !! My fave vault track has to be the very first night. Such a bop!

  • @jasmingatti6970
    @jasmingatti6970 Před 2 lety +20

    most iconic vault tracks - and i have a suspicion they will keep getting BETTER as we head into 1989 and Rep (REP DOESNT HAVE ANY BONUS TRACKS SO WHATS GONNA HIT US THERE AHHH 2023 ME WILL DIE). Even Speak Now vault songs have to be just written by her and TAYLOR SWIFT (TAYLORS VERSION) WILL BE SUPREME, cant fathom.
    I love the album as a whole but I've mostly been bouncing around the vault tracks while listening because they make me so UNWELL. I need to get into Ed's new song, like i had to for Everything Has Changed (which i now absolutely love) so that will happen.
    I'm so glad I got today off work so I could watch this IMMEDIATELY LOVE YOU TWO.
    Seeing Amanda, Kara and Brae's faces at the end was so wholesome too, they are such great chicks!
    Thank you for continuing to let me fathom this masterpiece of an album,

  • @yazminpadronbarragan.8727
    @yazminpadronbarragan.8727 Před 2 lety +18

    I love the fact that you so quickly know that The very first night is a Harry Styles song. I believe that TOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @agusfcoronado
    @agusfcoronado Před 2 lety +3

    My Red TV experience wasn’t complete til I have this. My comfort channel forever. Thank u so much ❤️‍🩹

  • @roxannaperez6486
    @roxannaperez6486 Před 2 lety +18

    There’s an old interview with Taylor floating around where she’s talking about All to Well and how she had to pair it down from the 10 minutes, and she mentions she had the f-word on it but took it out. Could be that “fuck the patriarchy” was always there… 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @enchanted_daylight89
    @enchanted_daylight89 Před 2 lety +49

    The way I initially thought Message In A Bottle would be a sad song, and it ended up being THE BOP after Mr Perfectly Fine!!!! So Unwell!!!! And yes Emily and Bonny leading all the Swifties in Taylor's Era, thank you so much, definitely worth the wait! ❤️❤️❤️❤️