@MACK BAHAHAHAH she was having her moment like "*falsetto* turned toOooOoOooooo" and then she heard the drummer and she had to go quickly to the be and I can just imagine her saying something like "stop singing my part now baby" or "somebody s doing the wrong note" as she does that insane resonant belt run
3:11 when the drummer messed up she improvised a mind blowing riffs and runs. Sadly she never did that again ever. And they changed it on dubbed version. 😢
Even though the drummer screwed up Mariah effortlessly caught up to the drummer's mistake that it didn't seem like there was anything wrong. She's just gifted musically. Most artists would've faltered and screwed up there.
I still prefer the live/undubbed version. You can hear the clarity and smoothness of her voice through it. But whatever version, it's still Mariah and it will always be good 💖
The tape is the same from the second take here. The sound quality is better on tape rather than this echo version from the arena. There's no point in filming multiple versions if they're just going to dub it later.
@@xejelah unfortunately the long run towards the end “and it was aaaaaowaoh hoahaahahheweweeoah that you” isn’t the same and she re-recorded that in the studio and dubbed it
When you realize that the dubbed version primarily uses the recording from the second performance but the audio from the run at 3:00 in the first performance 🤯🤯😍
2:49/2:55/3:13/3:16/7:41/8:22/8:46/8:56 Mariah turned MSG into an abattoir. Her resonance sounds more pronounced here than on the dubbed version. "Big mistake. Huge."
I don't know how you guys can still perpetuate the myth of dubbing after seeing this. There is no dubbing. This is the live performance. Each song has multiple takes and its easily identifiable which version went on tape. You're talking about arena echo rather than the full colors of her voice straight from the mic feed.
xejelah There is no myth that this concert is dubbed and sometimes quite heavily so. If it weren’t, we would be able to find her G5 in Hero in the amateur footage, we would hear the whole verse removed from the DVD version of ABMB, we would have amateur footage (like this) of Forever, we would hear the timing mistakes she made in Make it Happen, we would hear some higher belts and different runs in the VoL performances, and there are other very clear instances where vocals were changed or created for the DVD release. By definition that is dubbing. There is nothing wrong with that and it’s industry standard for DVD releases of concerts. It doesn’t change that the undubbed vocals are some of best delivered by any contemporary female recording artist. It just is what it is.
@@xejelah Dubbing doesn't mean lip synced. They polish the vocals, add some notes, mute the crowd, etc. The DVD version of the concert is dubbed, but it really didn't need to be. Some of the umdubbed vocals are better than the dubbed ones lmao
Sony should have put the making off and mistakes on extras of DVD, or should realeased Double DVD with a documentary including the mistakes. Would be nice having those raryties.
Mariah would never allow that. She loves perfection too much. Just look at how long it took her to finally release the St. John the Divine undubbed concert... And she probably mostly did it only to increase the chances of scoring the 19th #1 (which she did and we love that).
However you are spot on about this one and the GMA performance. Both are unbelievable...especially when she says "to-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo-yeahhhh" at the end
Mariah probably fired that damn drummer lmao. Isn't it taxing on her voice to sing a song with such complex vocal lines twice in a row while hitting the same notes and runs and everything? Damn
@@CesarJoel94 Oh no dahling, her slaying her vocals wasn't the cause of her minor vocal decline. It was mainly because she barely had any rest after the Daydream tour, and drank a bit as well. Not to mention her husband stressed her even more, so no wonder her voice became exhausted in 1998. She still had amazing vocal moments in 1997-1998 though. 🤓
It is cool to see the process of it all. Music is not perfect when it comes from people and that’s the beauty of it. I love how she works with it and still transcends
„Prayed through the NIIGHT” My Dear God.... I just wish I live there so I could experience once live version of Mariah Carey with stamina she had that time❤️
The first one was better i think the runs were amazing! I just wished she would have done the Feels so alive F5 live she did in the DD tour but this was cute.
2:49 F#5 of God 2:522:55 SO RESONANT 3:13-3:19 Drives me insane they couldn't use this incredible run b/c of the stupid drummer. I can't... He messed up twice!
It wasn't until Charmbracelet that Mariah really thickened up with womanly curves, then she gained some weight from TEOM touring, lost it for 2008, then gained it in 2009 for the pregnancy and never really lost it despite slimming down briefly for 2013. 2017 was by far her heaviest year. It was shocking to see. Since then she's stabilized with a mature body. Alas, I doubt Mariah will slim down significantly again. She likes pasta and wine too much.
All you hoes better be under 200 lbs judging The Queens body like that shes been skinny her whole life and yall are really writing essays about all the times Mariah got her body right when its always been right in my opinion...
i'm OBSESSED with the run she does from 3:16-3:19 whewwww the agility
It’s truly insane! Such a shame it’s left out of the dubbed version!!
That extra high note is everything
the way she just played over it lol
OMG. How on Earth did she do that?? Just insane!
@MACK BAHAHAHAH she was having her moment like "*falsetto* turned toOooOoOooooo" and then she heard the drummer and she had to go quickly to the be and I can just imagine her saying something like "stop singing my part now baby" or "somebody s doing the wrong note" as she does that insane resonant belt run
5 people are suffering from alienation.
Ha ha ha! Yes!
haha~ you're right, I laugh so hard, you just made my day
9 now
Still suffering
10 now.
the audience were so lucky she sung my favourite song twice!!
3:53 Treated me kaaaaynd... oh boy!
Lol 😆
Mariah singing high notes during daydream era was just like a walk in a park!
LITTERALLY. This girl walking and running while still making them notes perfect
@@whitneyhouston1122 and with heels
And now we know why Mariah always signals the drummer at the end of Vision of Love for almost every performance after this one ...
falconer i think she started it in music box era tho
@@AchillesandArtemis also snl 1990
i think it's bc her first performance ever of this the timing was messy
Really hahahahahaha
imagine the scolding she didn't give him?
She used to do the same in the debut era !
3:11 when the drummer messed up she improvised a mind blowing riffs and runs. Sadly she never did that again ever. And they changed it on dubbed version. 😢
Imagine this Mariah at Carpool Karaoke.
Jon Adol Her voice would've probably sent the car doors flying.
It would be too much for us normal humans
Jon Adol She’d be so sad and restricted, and would keep a fake smile...
She was Jame’s first carpool karaoke guest, I think 2015 it started
Omg!!!! No one would be ready
MAN...her voice used to SOAR during this era! Straight to the rafters!!!
she had lots of natural resonance.
@@Sttephy30 She had it, but didn’t take care of her voice. Oh wait, she can still sing like this. Now go away trumplican.
Imagine This voice in Divas Live. 😳
Celine and aretha would not sing with her 💀💀 they would be like nope i would prefer to keep my career
not even 3 years difference from the divas vh1 to this performance…has her voice rlly changed that much?
The undubbed is better than the dubbed
3:16 absolutely in love with this run tho
YASSS 2:49-2:55 SLAYS ME! ESPECIALLY WHEN SHE GOES UP FOR "LOVVVEEE" and then says HEY HEY! yass
YES
That might be the most resonant she has ever sounded! So so good
Boon Lit Tan i really think this her best concert. She was on fire and her voice was too. Most resonant ever too
I think the 1st F#5 on i had a vision of love on the 1st take was taken from that performance to dub The tokyo dome 1996 performance
@@boonlittan5115 Actually, listen to Make it Happen from this same concert, that is the most resonant.
Even though the drummer screwed up Mariah effortlessly caught up to the drummer's mistake that it didn't seem like there was anything wrong. She's just gifted musically. Most artists would've faltered and screwed up there.
ikr she was still able to have enough breath to do the sustained note at the end. usually u wouldnt have enough breath if mistake comes like that
I still prefer the live/undubbed version. You can hear the clarity and smoothness of her voice through it. But whatever version, it's still Mariah and it will always be good 💖
The tape is the same from the second take here. The sound quality is better on tape rather than this echo version from the arena. There's no point in filming multiple versions if they're just going to dub it later.
@@xejelah I agree, plus the vocals on here on just as good, so why dub it in the first place!🙄
@@xejelah unfortunately the long run towards the end “and it was aaaaaowaoh hoahaahahheweweeoah that you” isn’t the same and she re-recorded that in the studio and dubbed it
@@hounddog127nope it was taken from the second time Mariah performed this song
3:13 the run she does is so beautiful
Now i know why on the dvd she was smiling when she started singing this song!!! She messed up the intro. Lol Mimi so cuteeeeeeeeeeeee.......XD
When you realize that the dubbed version primarily uses the recording from the second performance but the audio from the run at 3:00 in the first performance 🤯🤯😍
This is better cause her vocals are more free sounding and not all muffled. Dubbed version takes away her resonance and bright tone.
Her Undubbed ALWAYS had way more RESONANCE!
2:49/2:55/3:13/3:16/7:41/8:22/8:46/8:56 Mariah turned MSG into an abattoir.
Her resonance sounds more pronounced here than on the dubbed version. "Big mistake. Huge."
I don't know how you guys can still perpetuate the myth of dubbing after seeing this. There is no dubbing. This is the live performance. Each song has multiple takes and its easily identifiable which version went on tape. You're talking about arena echo rather than the full colors of her voice straight from the mic feed.
xejelah There is no myth that this concert is dubbed and sometimes quite heavily so. If it weren’t, we would be able to find her G5 in Hero in the amateur footage, we would hear the whole verse removed from the DVD version of ABMB, we would have amateur footage (like this) of Forever, we would hear the timing mistakes she made in Make it Happen, we would hear some higher belts and different runs in the VoL performances, and there are other very clear instances where vocals were changed or created for the DVD release. By definition that is dubbing. There is nothing wrong with that and it’s industry standard for DVD releases of concerts. It doesn’t change that the undubbed vocals are some of best delivered by any contemporary female recording artist. It just is what it is.
@@xejelah Dubbing doesn't mean lip synced. They polish the vocals, add some notes, mute the crowd, etc. The DVD version of the concert is dubbed, but it really didn't need to be. Some of the umdubbed vocals are better than the dubbed ones lmao
@@xejelah The arena echo is her resonance.
The resonance u are hearing is “false resonance” which means that it’s not coming from her voice, but the echoes of the stadium.
I can hear her vibrato more in this video
Devin Mera It sounds like MusicBoxriah's vibrato tbh 🌚😌
Her calf definition is still easily seen in the blurry amateur footage lmao
Scalping Degenerates she was DEFINITELY doing some leg presses.
her calves kept her from flying back into another dimension at 2:49 from that wild F#5. we almost lost her.
Fervid Amid the Dandelions IM SCREAMING YOURE HILARIOUS OMG
+ZoeyRush thank you!!! ily!!
Fervid Amid the Dandelions skinny
The first performance has the better first half and the second has the better ending. Incredible stuff and better than the dubbed, oddly.
Maybe they combined them together.
8:21 damnnnn Mimi
3:53 I actually really liked the way she started it :/
same
Sony should have put the making off and mistakes on extras of DVD, or should realeased Double DVD with a documentary including the mistakes. Would be nice having those raryties.
CHEGA DE PÃO E CIRCO frl :(
Mariah would never allow that. She loves perfection too much. Just look at how long it took her to finally release the St. John the Divine undubbed concert... And she probably mostly did it only to increase the chances of scoring the 19th #1 (which she did and we love that).
Another clairvoyant....Rarities 🙂
Omg you foresaw her latest album's name. The Rarities
@@mario123m But the St.john devine was never a DVD and it was never dubbed. It was just filmed.
3:16 what a beautiful vocal line!
It's like nothing for her to sing this extremely difficult song!!💕✨🙏🏻🌈
In my opinion this is her best version of vision of love live in the daydream era. But still not as legendary as the GMA performance.
Edel Diaz true but sometimes I prefer Mariah's raw voice.
+Edel Diaz VoL at London 1996 is better!
+Lamb Forever I love london so much more! hahha I love all vision of love preformances cause they're always live.
I honestly think her performance from London in her Daydream tour was her best. Her voice FLIES
However you are spot on about this one and the GMA performance. Both are unbelievable...especially when she says "to-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo-yeahhhh" at the end
Mariah probably fired that damn drummer lmao. Isn't it taxing on her voice to sing a song with such complex vocal lines twice in a row while hitting the same notes and runs and everything? Damn
Exactly this is the reason her voice changed in Butterfly :(
@@CesarJoel94 Oh no dahling, her slaying her vocals wasn't the cause of her minor vocal decline. It was mainly because she barely had any rest after the Daydream tour, and drank a bit as well. Not to mention her husband stressed her even more, so no wonder her voice became exhausted in 1998. She still had amazing vocal moments in 1997-1998 though. 🤓
@@qxyzzz The nodules too theyre the main thing keeping her voice from being 100% and on the days Mariah sings around them she sounds soo amazing
@@zalenahquaddy4354 Pretty much, she doesn't get enough recognition for being a powerhouse vocalist who's had nodules since childhood.
@@qxyzzz exactly!! How sad she did it was a miracle
8:52 I thought it was a whistle 😂😂😂😂
The frequency and resonance of her voice wow
The ending on the first attempt was so fucking powerful that "BEEeeeeeeeee YEAAAAAHYEAAAAHHHH" my absolute fav
Her vocal styling (runs), on par with her vocal range was unstoppable in this era!!
Man definitely a coloratura!!!!great vocal performance and such a troll
3:54 ... ... treated me kahiiind -O BOY!
Mariah is really a living harmony. Just wow. Love you always, Mariah 😘😘
OMG that voice is just so amazing!
Hands down 🙂🙂🙂 this queen is unreal
That run! 8:27 😻
It is cool to see the process of it all. Music is not perfect when it comes from people and that’s the beauty of it. I love how she works with it and still transcends
3:12 she was so mad
Wow didn't know this happened. Love the 3rd attempt
„Prayed through the NIIGHT” My Dear God.... I just wish I live there so I could experience once live version of Mariah Carey with stamina she had that time❤️
3:14 she was like wait for meeeeeeeeeeeeeee dahling
4:10 fantastic band 💀
Lmaoo
this always makes me laugh lmaooo
jajaja i loooooooooooooooveee heeer :)
and her bloopers too xD
I grew up listening to Mariah Carey & gosh, she is amazingly amazing!!!! Always been a beautiful woman & always had a beautiful voice!!❤🎉
Lmao that C#5 on “be” at 3:13 is so piercing, i thought i lost my eardrums for a second
Flat
@@vg6761 delulu
3:17 crazy!!!
3:16 is crazy!
Those people are very fortunate to experienced this kind of vocal slayage
It has been approximately 7 years and theres only 2 dislikes !
Gunawan Bachtiar its been 9 now and only 4 dislikes
5 :(
Gunawan Bachtiar 9 🙄
All I am here to type is that Mariah Carey is very musically inclined.🥺🥺💖
Queen of vocals omg
Her vocal peak.
I know thank ♥️♥️
@@aricarey1474 lol not you
@@ervis6926 lol butterfly worst era but still good
@@mjrone9886 yeah
@@ervis6926 his name was MSG undubbed before he changed it to butterfly era
3:11 that was so iconic lol, I prefer this part compare with the other perfectly timed ones
The first one was better i think the runs were amazing! I just wished she would have done the Feels so alive F5 live she did in the DD tour but this was cute.
This is legendary
And now almost 10 years and 4 dislikes. Queen ever ♥️
That one who caption this footeage deserve Heavensss
Damn, she's so incredibly blessed.
Amazing. Wow. Amazing.
I didn't know this can happen in a live concert. It's like shooting a movie where several takes is normal. 😁
Yeah, wanted it to be perfect for the DVD
@@debutriah2854 perfeccionistriah
@@emc2era988 multipletakesriah
@@debutriah2854 and both of them ended floptv unplugged
@@emc2era988 lmao always coming for mtv unplugged 😭
its better than dubbed version
2:49 omg
Man I wish the first vocal take was the one used cause she sounded so perfect except for when the drummer messed up of course but I love it
My first time with love my first time with u, i had a vison of love... mariah 😍😍😘😘❤️❤️
The best years of her
2 people didn't have a vision of love...
+Rafa Medina THERE ARE STILL ONLY 2 DISLIKES LOL!!!
Rafa Medina 2 years omg
Now it's 3 Lol
Now it's 3 Lol
Rafa Medina LoL
3:16 😍
Love you forever mariahhh
Im glad that the drummer messed up..if he didn't..then we don't have take 2 vision of love or a.k.a one of her best performance
lol she's soo dorky I love when she messes up her intro...first she messes up the ending and then she messes up the intro. haha Soo cute, Love Mariah.
tipofmytongue1024 she didnt mess up the ending it was the drummer who was too early!
I'm pretty sure the band messed up the intro, the drums were supposed to come in half a second before she starts singing.
So beautiful
XDDD that girl scream omg XDD dying
This is gold !!
8:20 AND IT WAS ALL
This performance slays the dubbed one
i love every version of dis xD her voice is so sweeeeetttt xD !
she sang twice?? wow
She had to, the STUPID DRUMMER screwed up TWICE!!!
@@Tatai805 Damn, it was a mistake he probably is better than YOU
@@Tatai805 y'all are being harsh wtf???
@@Tatai805 mariah actually made a stupid mistake prior to the ending. Repeating the song was inevitable even if the drummer was right.
@@earthkeeper1 what do you mean?
Just, wow.
I AGREE! LOL i was like OMG.. wtf. I couldnt imagine what went through her head.
the F#5 at 8:25 sounds better here than in the dubbed
Sounds natural
2:48 wth how could you even produce a sound like that? I'm reffering to the "I"
talent
@@solteudoongie4519 *technique
Almost the same way you'd do a vocal fry, but with a lot more power and less air
@@debutriah2854omg debutriah my fav era
8:25 I was punched in the throat
" oh boy" 😂😂😂😂
2:49 F#5 of God 2:52 2:55 SO RESONANT 3:13-3:19 Drives me insane they couldn't use this incredible run b/c of the stupid drummer. I can't... He messed up twice!
It’s not like the drummer’s perfect😂😂😂
So why call the drummer stupid
Can you play the drums perfectly?😂😂😂
❤❤❤
It’s almost been 9 years of this video and only 4 dislikes lol
10 people didn’t turn out to be
Mariah carey is superior...
7:42 is so hard to do
She’s so skinny
skinny legend
It wasn't until Charmbracelet that Mariah really thickened up with womanly curves, then she gained some weight from TEOM touring, lost it for 2008, then gained it in 2009 for the pregnancy and never really lost it despite slimming down briefly for 2013. 2017 was by far her heaviest year. It was shocking to see. Since then she's stabilized with a mature body. Alas, I doubt Mariah will slim down significantly again. She likes pasta and wine too much.
@@got2bjosh she looked so good at e=mc2 era and at the beginning for miam era 😭 and i also agree with you on about her during 2017
@@heartriah she looked stunning in early 2018
All you hoes better be under 200 lbs judging The Queens body like that shes been skinny her whole life and yall are really writing essays about all the times Mariah got her body right when its always been right in my opinion...
JLo could never.
Take 1 3:01 3:13 3:16
Take 2 8:29 8:46 8:50
im the 30.000th viewer 😂
Where's the undubbed version of Forever?
There isn't one, Becuase they recorded forever without the audience