this song will forever be the saddest thing I've heard. The music just moves me in a way and I always get goosebumps when I listen to it but this, this is the first time I've listened to the actual lyrics in English
How can I repay you, brother mine? How can I expect you to forgive? Clinging to the past, I shed our blood And shattered your chance to live Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed How can I return your wasted breath? What I didn't know has cost you dear; For there is no cure for death Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete Back through the years we reached for you Alas, it was not to be And how can I make amends For all that I took from you? I led you with hopeless dreams My brother, I was a fool Don't cry for the past now, brother mine Neither you nor I are free of blame Nothing can erase the things we did For the path we took was the same How could I expect to call you wrong? How could you be blamed for what we've done? Both of us were fools in our desires As we flew too close to the sun Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete Back through the years we reached for you Alas, it was not to be My dreams made me blind and mute I longed to return to that time I followed without a word My brother, the fault is mine So where do we go from here? And how to forget and forgive? What's gone is forever lost Now all we can do is live...
I can't stop watching all of the covers of this track. Everyone I've seen is so beautiful. The Fullmetal fans are some of the most devoted. Beautiful voice by the way.
How can I repay you brother mine? How can I expect you to forgive? Clinging to the past I shed our blood, and shattered your chance to live. Though I knew the laws I paid no heed. How can I return your wasted breath? What I did not know has cost you dear, For there is no cure for death. Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete. Back through the years we reached for you. Alas, twas not meant to be. And how can I make amends, for all that I took from you? I lead you with hopeless dreams. My brother I was a fool. Don't cry for the past now brother mine, Neither you nor I are free from blame. Nothing can erase the things we did, For the path we took was the same. Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete. Back through the years we reached for you. Alas, twas not ment to be. My dreams made me blind and mute, I longed to return to that time, I followed without a word. My brother the fault is mine. So where do we go from here? And how to forget and forgive? What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live.
You sang this beautifully, and for that you have my admiration. Your voice sounding like Alphonse's just makes this even more perfect, especially the second part.
Wow this is just...amazing! I just felt a huge flashback of when I heard this in FullMetal Alchemist. Incredible singing and one of the best covers I have ever heard.
INCREDIBLE. One of the best adaptions ive heard. This song is so powerful and influenced FMA a lot for me, to bad FMA brotherhood doesnt have such emotional music.
This is making me cry so hard right now you wouldn't believe. I love this with all my heart~ Especially the first "beautiful mother" was so stunning... My ears aren't even worthy of hearing your wonderful voice. Please forgive me that I love this nevertheless... !
You actually made me cry here! Dammit. ...think I'm gonna subscribe so I'll probably be crying a lot more from now on. You have the most beautiful voice, seriously.
i want to try my own cover for this song forgot all about this...wow its been a long time. i found the english version but i really preferred the original russian until i heard your version. props to you this is way gorgeous. has the same emotion the russian version had. by any chance is there a way to get an mp3 of this? would love to have this on my ipod if thats ok...lol
Can anyone understand that extra verse? How could I expect to call you... something how could you be blamed for what we've done both of us were fools in our desires as we flew too close to the sun Cant get that last word in the first one...
I'll look those up. I think I remember Zoids being on tv in the morning when I was a kid and I've heard of Trigun, it sounds like it may be worth a watch. And I'll have a look at Touhou as well.
this song will forever be the saddest thing I've heard. The music just moves me in a way and I always get goosebumps when I listen to it but this, this is the first time I've listened to the actual lyrics in English
A voice like that probably costs an arm and a leg. No, wait, that's for kick-ass alchemy skills.
How can I repay you, brother mine?
How can I expect you to forgive?
Clinging to the past, I shed our blood
And shattered your chance to live
Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed
How can I return your wasted breath?
What I didn't know has cost you dear;
For there is no cure for death
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete
Back through the years we reached for you
Alas, it was not to be
And how can I make amends
For all that I took from you?
I led you with hopeless dreams
My brother, I was a fool
Don't cry for the past now, brother mine
Neither you nor I are free of blame
Nothing can erase the things we did
For the path we took was the same
How could I expect to call you wrong?
How could you be blamed for what we've done?
Both of us were fools in our desires
As we flew too close to the sun
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete
Back through the years we reached for you
Alas, it was not to be
My dreams made me blind and mute
I longed to return to that time
I followed without a word
My brother, the fault is mine
So where do we go from here?
And how to forget and forgive?
What's gone is forever lost
Now all we can do is live...
Thank you
This is the single most beautiful version of this song and that 1 verse everyone forgets is there!! I LOVE IT!!! 10/10!
Not better than the original
@@beurtalvarez what do you mean not the same ? Original is russian
@@beurtalvarez yes, I missunderstood this. I just meant that original had more soul
I can't stop watching all of the covers of this track. Everyone I've seen is so beautiful. The Fullmetal fans are some of the most devoted. Beautiful voice by the way.
How can I repay you brother mine?
How can I expect you to forgive?
Clinging to the past I shed our blood,
and shattered your chance to live.
Though I knew the laws I paid no heed.
How can I return your wasted breath?
What I did not know has cost you dear,
For there is no cure for death.
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete.
Back through the years we reached for you.
Alas, twas not meant to be.
And how can I make amends,
for all that I took from you?
I lead you with hopeless dreams.
My brother I was a fool.
Don't cry for the past now brother mine,
Neither you nor I are free from blame.
Nothing can erase the things we did,
For the path we took was the same.
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete.
Back through the years we reached for you.
Alas, twas not ment to be.
My dreams made me blind and mute,
I longed to return to that time,
I followed without a word.
My brother the fault is mine.
So where do we go from here?
And how to forget and forgive?
What's gone is forever lost.
Now all we can do is live.
Praise be the ones that suffered alongside this song. For those that understand I shed a Tear
You sang this beautifully, and for that you have my admiration. Your voice sounding like Alphonse's just makes this even more perfect, especially the second part.
i cant stop listening to this. gorgeous.
Beautiful. Simply Beautiful.
your fantastic.......i could listen to you all day and night.
Wow this is just...amazing! I just felt a huge flashback of when I heard this in FullMetal Alchemist. Incredible singing and one of the best covers I have ever heard.
wow ...
just wow ...
INCREDIBLE. One of the best adaptions ive heard. This song is so powerful and influenced FMA a lot for me, to bad FMA brotherhood doesnt have such emotional music.
Music that brings me to tears🤧
This is song to which i lay down my head, close eyes and just listen.
Thats so fucking beautiful
This is making me cry so hard right now you wouldn't believe. I love this with all my heart~ Especially the first "beautiful mother" was so stunning... My ears aren't even worthy of hearing your wonderful voice. Please forgive me that I love this nevertheless... !
wow...your voice makes this song more beautiful....
i have been looking for this for almost a year now, this is still so beautiful :')
so beautifull *sniff* so beautifull...
Beautiful. My favorite anime and you do this beautiful song justice. Well done.
there is some holy signature to your voice that fit perfectly to this song and it's thames
You actually made me cry here! Dammit. ...think I'm gonna subscribe so I'll probably be crying a lot more from now on.
You have the most beautiful voice, seriously.
Oh wow. This sounds gorgeous in your voice.
Have you tried Inner Universe from Ghost in the Shell?
That one person, who missed the Like button, doesn't recognize the beauty of this song. Very well done, blackrose1m! :D
It's so beautiful.
Oh my god, you're voice is beautiful! I cant word well enough how much I love it! You did a really great job.
Wow... Amazing voice!
Really beautiful ^___^ I'm going to go look at your other work now~
Is there any way that I could download this?
I love this.
Such a beautiful voice!!
beautiful!
you made my day thx.
Wow... That was amazing! You have a voice that is very professional! Good job!
Also, this is completely beautiful. I love this song, and you have an amazing voice.
You have a stunning voice
Very nice. You have a beautiful voice and it sounds amazing singing this song!
i want to try my own cover for this song forgot all about this...wow its been a long time. i found the english version but i really preferred the original russian until i heard your version. props to you this is way gorgeous. has the same emotion the russian version had. by any chance is there a way to get an mp3 of this? would love to have this on my ipod if thats ok...lol
Oh wow. O.o you sing beautifully...
wow
That was fantastic. You sing like an angel.
0-0 You. sound. AMAZING!!!! VIC'S GOT COMPETITION!!!! Your awesome!!!
It's amazing. I tried to sing it too, but I've lost every good thought about mine version listening to this one. You have voice of an angel :'D
Don't tell Vic, but your voice is so recommended for this song.
Bravo!
Whoa, this is gorgeous
Your voice honestly reminded me of honey. It's so smooth and beautiful!
Another beautiful song Marianne. I loved Full Metal Alchemist. :)
Can anyone understand that extra verse?
How could I expect to call you... something
how could you be blamed for what we've done
both of us were fools in our desires as we flew too close to the sun
Cant get that last word in the first one...
You definitely don't know it yet after 8 years. It's "wrong".
I love the song, but I wish that you could have chosen a different picture. It sort of reminds me of the bitter sweet ending of the 2003 anime.
+pixiedragon At the time there was no talk of Brotherhood just yet so no happy ending.
@smadadenu lol i didnt mean this song i meant like other songs with the kinda melancholy sound.
OMG! You're voice's beautiful!! *u*
Vic Mignogna, back down.
We should link this to Vic's youtube-account. He'll probably love it as much as we do.
this was beautiful :')
Beautiful!!! Just beautiful! Can I steal your voice?
Congrats! You've tied with Vic(in my opinion).
Your voice is so pretty...
this is beautifully sung but i think it loses something when it is not sung in russian.
I'll look those up. I think I remember Zoids being on tv in the morning when I was a kid and I've heard of Trigun, it sounds like it may be worth a watch. And I'll have a look at Touhou as well.
Imagine singing it at a musical
waahhh~ so pretty~
With earbuds direclty in my ears it does distinctly sound like 'wrong'
T^T I don't know why but this makes me cry...great job though, your voice is very soothing.
Omg why is there no download button!?!?!
OMG, LittleKuriboh liked and Favorited this video!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How were you able to get this karaoke version? I know there is many, but I want this version without instruments playing the melody.
Check this out. I tried to make the perfect backing track, but failed. But I did it. czcams.com/video/3g_ENuNevsA/video.html
@TheLuluBrown just copy the link and google video2mp3 put in link and download, That's what I did now I can listen to this lovely singing when I want
Did you link a copy of this to livejournal back in the day?
@dark0shade little kuriboh, the creator of yugioh the abridged series
You have a really beautifull voice!! Can we have a download link PLEEEASE!
MP3? Pleasepleaseplease?
So beautiful, you have such a wonderful voice.... (I still working on my singing voice) >< *Faves* :D
@BlazePyron in during/after
@ForsakenPalazzo HEY! back of the line like the rest of us
Есть 2021?
Little Kuriboh just liked this. In before all the YGOTAS fanbois.
anyone notice that there should be alchemy circle in al hand xD? haha n i love ur singin btw :3
OMG! your voice, i love it. XD how did you get that kind of voice?
is there a way to download this? I want it so badly for my mp3
this is what i miss from brotherhood this song isn't in it =(
You definitely need to watch fullmetal alchemist! It's the most amazing show!
1 troll has visited this awesome video!
@WaterFlareon No one thumbs uped your comment because they were mad that they didn't have anything good enough to exchange for her voice.
you got a subscriber
@XxAluminaAngelxX he favorited this video
Six dislikes from hommunculus
does LK watch fullmetal alchemist?
@AlexChurchASR theres like a million different versions of this song, lol
@ThePuffinsrock DOWNLOAD IT HURR DURR
google
@deathsent
Yeah, I adore YGOTAS, so I guess it's during. :/
This song orginally in Russian so how could she sing this song in English when Vic Mignonga sang this first in English?
@iamazombiekitten
I wonder what would you give to her, in exchange for her voice, to satisfy the equivalent exchange
Well, to get technical, it'd have to be something beautiful that iamazombiekitten could do or something she has. .-. Hm.
My guess is: How could I expect to call you wrong.
If anyone here knows any other songs that have a similar kind of sound like this please tell me cause this was Beautiful
Also Check out my LP's :)
Hmm i like Vics more.
Sorry, but is that a dislike? i think that was a hamunculis
@rebeccab32 fullmetal's mom!