I've been waiting for someone to do some testing of the fake Strongarm. They're going for $33 and up on eBay now here in the states. Real ones are going for $75 and up. The Prodigy can be found for as low as $50 if you're patient but mostly $60 and up. I already have an older LMF II but I want something lighter so I've been debating between the fake Strongarm or a Prodigy. Thank you for helping me make my decision, lol. In return, I subscribed.
The real gerber strongarm from gerber isnt manufactured in china. Its made at a factory here in Portland Oregon. Tho i do know that gerber does go thru a factory in China for some of their knives so its possible that factory has access to the strongarm specs and design
@@Thoringald77 From what we told , but if it's assembled in Portland Oregon and products in China then they can say made in USA so I've been told. Not saying that the case but they can manufacturer a item in China and box it in the USA and say it American made.
Bud.... I got one and my mate has the real thing, and I'm with you on this, bloody great value for money, the only argument he has is , " it's a fake", but it dose the same job. 👍
I’ve got the Gerber Strong arm but the rest of my knives are Mora’s. Garberg Carbon and the Kansbol, the Eldris and the companion and companion HD and last but not least I’ve got the outdoor wood carving basic. I’ve also got the Fiskar X7 hatchet. It’s a good wee start for me.
Hello, I have the same fake knive.. ordered it from aliexpress for 19 euro .I was curious. Only optical difference I could find is the buttons on the sheath are coyote brown and on the original gerber they are black. On the webside they don't show the logo's name etc. But it looked just like the strongarm and I ordered it. When I got it I was quite surprized.. Gerber box, Gerber logos , made Oregon USA, all the sheath options... WTF..... On the Chinese webside they say the steel is "stainless" So I started using this as a knife to beat on.. And was so surprized .. like you in the video... It holds an edge decent, about aus8 I would guess. It's a very good knive for the price I have to say. I coundn't break it, I still use it... Now .. I'm totally against clones and fake knives , I have high end knives and I pay for them. But for this one I have to be honest, it's an amazing good knive for the price... Gerber should sue them!
I just saw this knife on eBay. Almost bought it cause I thought it was a strongarm. Then I saw the price,& thought something was off. That's why I looked up this video. I can't believe how good it seems to work. Now I'm wondering if the ones on eBay that claim to be real are in fact real.
Few things that stand out on the blade is your handle has a sharper profile where it dips in and the bade has a rounder curve where it meets the grip. On the sheaf you have two small holes for water drainage whereas mine has only one. It makes me wonder if it’s really worth them making fakes if they are so close in quality to the original. Like how is that supposed to be financially viable? This is what I think is happening. Gerber (along with myriads of other companies) moved the production over to China for cheaper labour (slave labour in some cases allegedly) the problem is is that for these companies trying to make a quick buck or two don’t realise the future implications. China has no problem with stealing intellectual property whatsoever and now they have there manufacturing factories 🏭 and will simply carry on making i phones, Strongarms McDonalds etc and sell them back to us and thereby over saturate the market and undercut the real companies not to mention how much they sell in China itself, they simply rebrand the name. It’s not to hard to realise when they are making Knives for Gerber like the Bear Grylls etc, they can make flawless copies of the originals no problem. And it serves our companies right since they have totally betrayed us.
I f ok t get it, how can China do these fakes that look and behave identical to the real thing? If it’s exactly the same but fake then how are they exactly going to make money using same quality materials and manufacturing? Maybe it’s to try to sabotage the real company
R.L. held up well. I own a few original Strongarm knives and there's not much difference that you can see unless they are side by side and from the footage of the fakes I have seen those R.L. are not too bad , especially for a budget buy blade.
Even if it’s a fake at £14 and keeps an edge win win. It looks to be well made so only time will tell. Bit like a Rolex from Thailand u know it’s fake but keeps time and is sum what waterproof best 10 quid I’ve spent lol.
Paul Brock used it again at the weekend and it's holding up amazing starting to think it might be real but regardless as you say if it works it works lol
@@outdoorbasics2562 It's not real, it's certainly fake. It can be noticed by some details on the chief. In the original, the canvas strap goes over the buttons on the back. I can see that much in the video.
I bought one from eBay which I believe it to be a fake, but an awesome fake, tough, and I ordered one right off the gerber website and I can't tell the difference. I went ahead and ordered another fake Strongarm this time with serrations and I'm hoping it's as good as my fine edge fake one.
I have the exact same one. I believe that is a true Strong arm or a very good fake. Mine has the serial numer 0870118B on it. The opposite side of the molle attachment clip has a capital A on it. I got mine directly from Gerber website, so I'm assuming if yours has all that, it's legit.
I picked up one of these from temu a few days ago. If i hadn't watched youtube about the fake ones i would never has known. This knife is almost a perfect copy of the real thing. It looks good, quality so far is good and the blade was pretty sharp out the box. Not bad for 15 bucks. At this price i can beat the hell out of it and not feel bad.
I got a couple from temu too. I’m curious when you remove the belt hang/ vertical carry part and your left with just the part that snaps around the handle you end up with a few inches that just dangle off the end. Like I feel there should be a button male vs female swap to secure it back down.
If you were on a budget and looking for a knife to really torture the hell out of it (I mean really take it through it's bushcraft paces), which one would you chose, this fake Chinese Gerber for £18 or a real SRK for £65??? How is the steel of this fake Gerber holding up 5 years later???
Hi Stuart. I’ve been wanting one of the knives for months! Where did you get the fake from? At £14 it’s worth buying just to see if the knife suits me. Love the videos keep up the good work 👍
jackmtbiker hi mate it was a gift so not sure just do a Google search next time my mate is up I'll ask him I'll defo know for the following video saying how it preformed over the next few weeks ☺
I have the same knife. I do not think it is false, it must be a batch of Gerber that came out with some irregularities and decided to put it on the market at a lower price. Counterfeiting a knife to that level of accuracy and quality is not something that results in profit.
If your Strongarm has hollow grind then it's Counterfeit. If it has flat grind then it's Original. Yes, Chinese can even make a decent fake product but it's still a fake. They still make profit on it or they wouldn't make it. Use your brain!
@@LXT43 I have 2 green color fakes that I got from an ebay China vendor; one was hollow ground and the other flat... They cost about $30 CDN each which is less than 1/3 cost of the real Gerber. I do have a legit Gerber version and while the fit & finish is slightly better, Gerber QC failed to notice that the webbing was missing one snap.
I’ve got the real one and the only difference I can see is that the buttons are lighter colour on yours than mine. Anyway pal your in Scotland 🏴 so am I. I live in Port Glasgow and if your not far then why don’t we meet up and compare our Strongarms? I’m knew to bushcraft and would like to join a community of like minded people. Also, I have invested in tons of gear and haventnay a clue what to do with it all 🤣🤣
@@b.bushcraft7332 i decided to try one. i ordered the one from aliexpress that states its made from 12c27 steel.i dont know if its true or not but i have beat it pretty hard and it still looks almost new. it has totally shocked me with its toughness. it looks just like the real one. it weighs less though.
@@G911CX I just received mine that I got from eBay. It was $30.00,& I'm not sure if it's a copy or the real deal. Everything looks right, the box it came with, the directions it came with,& all the markings on the knife. It's crazy!
@@hgarza1136 sometimes i wonder how they are able to earn money. I mean they have to ship the stuff. Well, they don´t give a s...t about environment and so on but still. Bought a "Voltron" fixed Knife made out of D2 Steel with G10 Handles the sheath Kydex with a Tec Lock for about 20 Bugs for fun- it was really well manufactured and razor sharp...
I've been waiting for someone to do some testing of the fake Strongarm. They're going for $33 and up on eBay now here in the states. Real ones are going for $75 and up. The Prodigy can be found for as low as $50 if you're patient but mostly $60 and up. I already have an older LMF II but I want something lighter so I've been debating between the fake Strongarm or a Prodigy. Thank you for helping me make my decision, lol. In return, I subscribed.
Maybe the Factory in China produces during the Week for Gerber and on the Weekend for their own sale ^^
The real gerber strongarm from gerber isnt manufactured in china. Its made at a factory here in Portland Oregon. Tho i do know that gerber does go thru a factory in China for some of their knives so its possible that factory has access to the strongarm specs and design
@@Thoringald77 From what we told , but if it's assembled in Portland Oregon and products in China then they can say made in USA so I've been told.
Not saying that the case but they can manufacturer a item in China and box it in the USA and say it American made.
@@Thoringald77 ASSEMBLED IN portland made in china ! this is the them knife
I love this knife,even if it is a fake,if it holds up like the real one then it'd be a keeper too mate,good video.
Bud.... I got one and my mate has the real thing, and I'm with you on this, bloody great value for money, the only argument he has is , " it's a fake", but it dose the same job. 👍
After a bit of time I have also bought the cold steel SRK from Aliexpress.... mmmm see what you think bud. 🤔
@@johnfromscotland1050 how does it hold up?
Just got mine can’t wait to put it to use. Keep up the bush craft skills. Cheers.
I’ve got the Gerber Strong arm but the rest of my knives are Mora’s. Garberg Carbon and the Kansbol, the Eldris and the companion and companion HD and last but not least I’ve got the outdoor wood carving basic. I’ve also got the Fiskar X7 hatchet. It’s a good wee start for me.
Hello, I have the same fake knive.. ordered it from aliexpress for 19 euro .I was curious. Only optical difference I could find is the buttons on the sheath are coyote brown and on the original gerber they are black. On the webside they don't show the logo's name etc. But it looked just like the strongarm and I ordered it. When I got it I was quite surprized.. Gerber box, Gerber logos , made Oregon USA, all the sheath options... WTF..... On the Chinese webside they say the steel is "stainless" So I started using this as a knife to beat on.. And was so surprized .. like you in the video... It holds an edge decent, about aus8 I would guess. It's a very good knive for the price I have to say. I coundn't break it, I still use it... Now .. I'm totally against clones and fake knives , I have high end knives and I pay for them. But for this one I have to be honest, it's an amazing good knive for the price... Gerber should sue them!
How has it held up
Before i even get in to this video, let me run that intro music back! 🔥
Great video brother , I've never seen a knockoff before . But still seems like a good knife , I subscribed .
I just saw this knife on eBay. Almost bought it cause I thought it was a strongarm. Then I saw the price,& thought something was off. That's why I looked up this video. I can't believe how good it seems to work. Now I'm wondering if the ones on eBay that claim to be real are in fact real.
Does this one have a hollow or sabre grind? The original has a sabre grind
Few things that stand out on the blade is your handle has a sharper profile where it dips in and the bade has a rounder curve where it meets the grip. On the sheaf you have two small holes for water drainage whereas mine has only one. It makes me wonder if it’s really worth them making fakes if they are so close in quality to the original. Like how is that supposed to be financially viable? This is what I think is happening. Gerber (along with myriads of other companies) moved the production over to China for cheaper labour (slave labour in some cases allegedly) the problem is is that for these companies trying to make a quick buck or two don’t realise the future implications. China has no problem with stealing intellectual property whatsoever and now they have there manufacturing factories 🏭 and will simply carry on making i phones, Strongarms McDonalds etc and sell them back to us and thereby over saturate the market and undercut the real companies not to mention how much they sell in China itself, they simply rebrand the name. It’s not to hard to realise when they are making Knives for Gerber like the Bear Grylls etc, they can make flawless copies of the originals no problem. And it serves our companies right since they have totally betrayed us.
this comment is all facts
How does the knife perform so far?
I've got the real one, but your's looks and performs the exact same as mine. I think I'll buy a fake as a spare. At the price, why not! Great video!!
I f ok t get it, how can China do these fakes that look and behave identical to the real thing? If it’s exactly the same but fake then how are they exactly going to make money using same quality materials and manufacturing? Maybe it’s to try to sabotage the real company
The fakes are hollow grind as opposed to saver grind. Just another little difference that most don't happen to mention
R.L. held up well. I own a few original Strongarm knives and there's not much difference that you can see unless they are side by side and from the footage of the fakes I have seen those R.L. are not too bad , especially for a budget buy blade.
It held up well, some fakes are made as good as the real thing 🤘👊
Vc fez o certo mostrou ela. Ação , parabéns
Even if it’s a fake at £14 and keeps an edge win win. It looks to be well made so only time will tell. Bit like a Rolex from Thailand u know it’s fake but keeps time and is sum what waterproof best 10 quid I’ve spent lol.
Paul Brock used it again at the weekend and it's holding up amazing starting to think it might be real but regardless as you say if it works it works lol
@@outdoorbasics2562 It's not real, it's certainly fake. It can be noticed by some details on the chief. In the original, the canvas strap goes over the buttons on the back. I can see that much in the video.
I bought one from eBay which I believe it to be a fake, but an awesome fake, tough, and I ordered one right off the gerber website and I can't tell the difference. I went ahead and ordered another fake Strongarm this time with serrations and I'm hoping it's as good as my fine edge fake one.
I have the exact same one. I believe that is a true Strong arm or a very good fake. Mine has the serial numer 0870118B on it. The opposite side of the molle attachment clip has a capital A on it. I got mine directly from Gerber website, so I'm assuming if yours has all that, it's legit.
Hello sir,does the knife still hold up to the challenge or is it broken.Will appreciate for reply.
Hi still going strong and still takes and keeps a grate edge
@@blackbelt7931 Thank you sir, morning here, have a great day.
With the ones actually from gerber the sheath and handle all match color wise.
I picked up one of these from temu a few days ago. If i hadn't watched youtube about the fake ones i would never has known. This knife is almost a perfect copy of the real thing. It looks good, quality so far is good and the blade was pretty sharp out the box. Not bad for 15 bucks. At this price i can beat the hell out of it and not feel bad.
I got a couple from temu too. I’m curious when you remove the belt hang/ vertical carry part and your left with just the part that snaps around the handle you end up with a few inches that just dangle off the end. Like I feel there should be a button male vs female swap to secure it back down.
i buy one and an prodigy for 30 euros the duo definitivly a good knives
interesting review
13 dollars on temu right now all different colors too. 12c27 steel
Up date ( knife is hard to sharpen...... Threw it against a tree and the handle broke lol )
man.. Chinese people are taking their "job" seriously..
If you were on a budget and looking for a knife to really torture the hell out of it (I mean really take it through it's bushcraft paces), which one would you chose, this fake Chinese Gerber for £18 or a real SRK for £65???
How is the steel of this fake Gerber holding up 5 years later???
You’re gonna cut your finger off holding the knife like that.
I have the gerber strongarm and it wasnt real expensive I paid $45 US so I know mine is genuine does yours say made in Portland OR?
The Fake One and the Real One have "Made in Portland" on the knife.
Hi Stuart. I’ve been wanting one of the knives for months! Where did you get the fake from? At £14 it’s worth buying just to see if the knife suits me. Love the videos keep up the good work 👍
jackmtbiker hi mate it was a gift so not sure just do a Google search next time my mate is up I'll ask him I'll defo know for the following video saying how it preformed over the next few weeks ☺
Outdoor Basics great stuff, il look forward to the next video 😊 cheers mate
jackmtbiker dhgate
It was bought on AliExpress and including postage came to just shy of £18
AND THE FOLLOWING AFTER USED ..................?
I have the same knife. I do not think it is false, it must be a batch of Gerber that came out with some irregularities and decided to put it on the market at a lower price. Counterfeiting a knife to that level of accuracy and quality is not something that results in profit.
If your Strongarm has hollow grind then it's Counterfeit. If it has flat grind then it's Original. Yes, Chinese can even make a decent fake product but it's still a fake. They still make profit on it or they wouldn't make it. Use your brain!
Original is US made, fake is Chinese. Metal is definitely different.
@@LXT43 I have 2 green color fakes that I got from an ebay China vendor; one was hollow ground and the other flat... They cost about $30 CDN each which is less than 1/3 cost of the real Gerber. I do have a legit Gerber version and while the fit & finish is slightly better, Gerber QC failed to notice that the webbing was missing one snap.
Is it carbon steel? Does it throw sparks?
for the price it aint carbon steel it must be stainless steel.
Fake knife is good enough until it gives in at the worst moment possible.
Where was this bought from , I'm really interested in getting one.
1danhel
Dhgate
AliExpress
I’ve got the real one and the only difference I can see is that the buttons are lighter colour on yours than mine. Anyway pal your in Scotland 🏴 so am I. I live in Port Glasgow and if your not far then why don’t we meet up and compare our Strongarms? I’m knew to bushcraft and would like to join a community of like minded people. Also, I have invested in tons of gear and haventnay a clue what to do with it all 🤣🤣
Is it full tang?
Yes, it is.
Understood only about half of what was said.
That's part of the entrainment over multiple reruns :p
did you figure out if it is real?
We got several more from the same supplier and they've all worked really well
@@b.bushcraft7332 i decided to try one. i ordered the one from aliexpress that states its made from 12c27 steel.i dont know if its true or not but i have beat it pretty hard and it still looks almost new. it has totally shocked me with its toughness. it looks just like the real one. it weighs less though.
@@scottc95 Do you have a link? :) I think I saw your post on blade forums, they really took offense!
if yall can't tell the difference between the grind on the blade something is wrong
It's the same quality
Just saw another vid. He had the real,& fake. The fake didn't clip into the sheath just right. It should make a kinda popping noicewhen seated.
If this is the only Difference i go for the "Fake" 22€ instead of 100-120€ that´s a huge difference
@@G911CX I just received mine that I got from eBay. It was $30.00,& I'm not sure if it's a copy or the real deal. Everything looks right, the box it came with, the directions it came with,& all the markings on the knife. It's crazy!
@@hgarza1136 sometimes i wonder how they are able to earn money. I mean they have to ship the stuff. Well, they don´t give a s...t about environment and so on but still. Bought a "Voltron" fixed Knife made out of D2 Steel with G10 Handles the sheath Kydex with a Tec Lock for about 20 Bugs for fun- it was really well manufactured and razor sharp...
@@G911CX slave labor,lol!
Dont you feel like a silly cartoon character talking like that?
I definitely would.