‘The Mayor Is Not Going To Be Able To Survive This Recall’: Former Judge Demands Sheng Thao Resign
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 06. 2024
- Judge Brenda Harbin-Forte joined Cat Oriel on “Forbes Newsroom” to discuss leading the efforts to recall Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
A stain on the record? Oakland has been so stained that there's no room, it's a stain on top of a stain
There's not enough soap in the world to get that stain out. Permanently tainted.
Murder capital of this state for 12 consecutive years.
I can't blame the Mighty Raiders for leaving that cesspool of a city. I'm surprised the 49ers have yet to vacate San Francisco, another cesspool of a city.
@@M_Lev___ YOU ARE CORRECT! AND IT IS GETTING WORSE TOO.
@@M_Lev___ They have little to do with San Francisco now. They play 30 miles away. None of the players live in SF.
Thank you, Judge!
Not only The East Bay, but this world needs more individuals in it with your kind of common sense.
Isn't she the same woman who ran against the mayor? She started the recall as soon as Sheng Thao won for mayor. If it's that same woman, she doesn't care about the city, she cares about that paycheck. If she truly cared about the city, she should've tried working with the mayor and the city for better changes. Where was the recall when previous mayors failed to do anything for the city? You expect the mayor to resolve years of problems in city overnight is not gonna happen. Such hypocrites.
New actor, same show.
Cov neeg dub no chim vim Sheng fired lawv tus dub police chief lawm. Kuv yog Sheng ces kuv resign es cia lawv mam sib tua txhua hnub txhua hmo.
A stain on the wonderful record of Oakland , say it’s not true 😱
Mayor Thao was considered gone months ago. This recent incident is another reason why she should be given the door. The next mayor will have a hell of a time cleaning up the mess Mayor Thao caused, and earning the trust of the citizens within the city of Oakland will be one of them. I don't doubt that one bit.
God bless Judge Brenda Harbin-Forte. She seems like a good and honorable human being. We need more government officials, and citizens, like her.
Only a troublemaker & vindictive!
Thao doesn't want to know how she can improve herself to not warrant a recall from the people, she wants to know more about some fictional billionaires who are conspiring to remove her from office. She's power hungry. If anything, surrounding cities want her gone before her den of thieves spreads out & completely ruins their city too, perfectly understandable TBH.
Many people have not learned that blaming others do not change anything. We must own up to our mistakes and learned from it and try to do your best to tell the truth. I have never been afraid if I didn’t do anything wrong!
I’ll vote her out. She’s a disgrace and incompetent.
so are u! do u have voting rights?
If the only reason for the recall was the removal of a police chief, that’s not enough although I would like to know her reason specifically. The judge really didn’t specify anything she did. What was the FBI looking for ? Anyone can make a claim but that doesn’t make it true.
Please just leave this mayor alone. How hell she get in? You people vote her in after you want her out. That is not right. It’s wrong, did she stole your moneys. Did she broke the law ? Let her finish her term? God bless and love you
I totally agree with you let her finished her terms exactly..you go sheng finished your terms you have every right to do your JOB'S to the best of your abilities....you go girl's..
This is about black and Asian
Vote Red
What about bass And newsom?
It's too late Oakland. You'll continue with the thinking that brought her in. Blame yourselves.
A stain on Oakland's underwear
A stain on oakland's underwear??? Hahaha
A year in Oakland without a police chief wouldn't make any difference if they had 10 of them crime ain't going down not anytime soon
DEI voting is leaving qualified candidates behind, elect our officials based on their qualifications and experience.
DEI voting? Honestly what does that even mean? Stop fanning the flames.
Is she creating problems to the city? Does she bring crime to the city?
The city has been like hell for years, way before she moved to the city. It makes no sense to blame the usual problems on her. Too bad that Oakland has too many criminals and the police just couldn’t do anything about them
I believe my development would’ve been sooner than later head. I’ve been in a good congregation where this is taught steadily through the last years.
But I don’t have a complaint because that’s a story in its self.
I did attend a good word church for a while in the 1980s still circumstances cause me to have to move.
But I thank God for technology that all you good teachers ministered this beautiful internally so much beautiful work inside of me.
I’m now starting at Word of Life in NV.
This is my new beginning to be with a congregation that is speaking the same language amongst each each other. I trust I can be a good encouragement to those just starting to walk this out.Having gone through it myself only to find out that It’s all true, just all beautifully true.
mind boggling.
Where’s las Vegas at
Oakland got worse under shang tao. This was all a $ grab for her. She needs to step aside and let someone else clean up her mess.
Purge.
Is it just my device or is it a little hard to listen to what is being said? Sounds muffled!
Now if we can get the same energy for the so-called "Super Mayor"
OAKLAND IS A BIG STAIN ON AMERICA...
When she doing her job every one have to help on each other not just remove her out office even those vote for new mayor will the same situation if everyone not put hand on help other the problem I see is discrimination
you dont get it
Nice mayor and restaurant
My 2 cents…
Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao is ethnically Hmong . Her Hmong parents are refugees from Laos. The Hmong in Laos lived mostly in villages.
The Hmongs are actually ethnic Chinese who immigrated from China… settling in Laos, Vietnam, and Thailand years ago.
Before and during the Vietnam war, the CIA and the American military recruited the Hmong as scouts. They were jungle experts as most came from the small villages in Laos and Vietnam. They provided the needed expertise about the jungle… the combat zone area (like the Japanese-American Niseis of the MIS during WWII who were Japanese language experts… who shortened WWII by 2 years). I heard a lot about the Hmongs when I was in Vietnam.
When the US left Vietnam and let the VC and North Vietnamese take over South Vietnam, many of the Hmong who served with the US Military fled to Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines to escape persecution. None of us in the US know what happened to the Hmongs who couldn’t escape. Can only guess.
Sheng Thao’s father could have been a Hmong who fought alongside the Americans against the VC and North Vietnamese
Sheng Thao is Hmong-Chinese. She is smart… as many Asian women are. She graduated from UC-Berkeley… one of the top universities in the country. Does she need a speechwriter to craft her speech to tell her side of the story? I don’t think so. I don’t think those were crocodile tears you saw when she made her speech. I believe it came straight from the heart.
SO WHAT???
@@Jojo-fy2ud Left is right... up is down... black is white... Need I paint you a picture?
Hidden in a hotel with cronies writing her speech sucks. she is both mean and IMMATURE !
@@readyfortheworld9232 The Mayor is a graduate of UC Berkeley.. I don't think she needed help in writing her speech. She's a tough lady... much like her father was in assisting and fighting alongside the Amrican military. in Laos-Vietnam. What I see here is a Ms David and Goliath scenario. Put yourself in her shoes...
@@rodneyinefuku3810 ``You gotta love that only one person clapped when she finished her speech- They were packed in the room like sardines and even HER STAFF wants her gone. PRICELESS !
It seems that she is not doing a very good job.
She should be in jail.
I can't blame the Mighty Raiders for leaving that cesspool of a city.
There’s so many Stains on Oakland how can you tell where this stain is.
Oakland voted and recalled!
Oakland voted and recalled!
Oakland voted and recalled!
Oakland voted and recalled!
Oakland voted and recalled!
Oakland voted and recalled!
That is what they are good at!!!
This is interesting. First the judge never answered the question who is funding her and this recall effort? Second, Armstrong may have been popular but I recall at least two incidents in which he covered up for police officers inappropriate behaviors and misconduct. One incident had to do with a gun being fired in an elevator at the Oakland Police Department. Armstrong covered up the incident. The Mayor may not be prepared to lead a city like Oakland as it requires a lot of experience and support. Oakland has had poor Mayors and leadership dating back to at least Elihu Harris which was 1991. Mayor Brown in 1999 took over and wasted Oakland's time and resources and he did not understand criminal behavior and minds. At the end of his term, he concluded that their "are dedicated criminals" so had he understood that from the beginning he could have made a difference in that area. The point is, Oakland is in a situation that has become progressively worse and at this point it will need an experienced objective leader to start turning the city around. I can point to other cities in this country that may have had different contributing factors that led to it's downfall but the common thread is each city inherited poor leadership that wasted the cities opportunity to turn things around. One last point, Oakland has loss major sports teams over the years, Warriors, Raiders and not the Athletics. Unprecedented to lose 3 teams in a city that size!
All of you vote the same way every single time.
Sheng Thao needs to go with integrity. She fired the Police Chief and it was her first mistake. Now she associated with business thaw; the city needs a mayor who needs to save Oakland. Sheng comes short of that kind of mayor's quality. She tries but Oakland needs a strong person with solid skills to bring people together to save Oakland. She lost so much opportunities already. The best thing is to step down and allow Oaklanders to find the right leader to lead this beautiful city. It is not Sheng's fault, she just doesn't have the right skills to save Oakland.
Stained can't be stained.
Oakland is a stain on america.
Oakland won’t recall her now that she has street cred. She’s invited to the sideshow!
🤟😎 🤟
If mayor Sheng Thao was a black this never happened
ALL THAT HAVE SAT ON THAT CHAIR ARE A WASTE OF RESOURCES
The Interviewer looks like the woman in the thumbnail.
Both trans
Wallet Hub announced a list of best to worst managed cities in the country yesterday. Guess who is at the bottom.
The first comment clearly shows this former judge is aligned with the former police chief who was rightfully fired for withholding an investigation of his mishandling of an internal investigation of an unhinged police official who should have been fired. This mayor should resign, however, Oakland needs outside officials such as chief Floyd Mitchell to continue to do his job. He has just come in recently and has no ties to the ongoing corruption that exists in the city. This judge is apart of the problem.
Look to the riders case and this book written by astute journalists .
www.nytimes.com/2023/01/10/books/review/the-riders-come-out-at-night-ali-winston-darwin-bondgraham.html
Shens speech was a joke !
You gotta love that no one clapped when she finished - They were packed in the room like sardines and even her staff wants her gone. PRICELESS !
Better than none. ONE lone person clapped.
@@HerAeolianHarp The death stare she gave everyone for NOT clapping was CLASSIC ! How can you go on when even your staff wants you gone ? The people in the room were supporters and staff ( except media ). WOW ! NY Times said it was the defining moment ....
I just hope that if this lady gets elected mayor and fails, that people will start a recall campaign on her too. Only fair.
You give hope, Judge. Your state has become a bad joke. Everybody with a brain sees it.
Going Going Gone..... bye
Po go back to gong po long time
Guilty cry babies don't resign. She may or may not survive the recall but it will cost the city a lot of money and she is destined to have Oakland broke. Just see what happens in budget. Surely she will be funded but necessary departments will be screwed, all of them. So the position she holds is for Sheng Thao not for the people. That was evident from the beginning!
Oh dear, “Honorable” Brenda Harbin-Forte. Your new name is Susan Bassi Vanguard.
She is the stain!
I thought the FBI only went after Republicans under joey's handler's direction.
Only when it comes to Trump, do the handlers kick in.
Most often that is true.
Mayor pay your gambling debts.
a "shtein"
She's one of the billionaire's from Piedmont that Thao spoke of in her crying response?
Yep
I THINK EVEN IF YOU PUT MICKEY MOUSE OR BAMBI IN THERE IT WILL BECOME CORRUPT ...LOL
No kamal-alla is your stain
Oakland is a sht-hole anyway.
This former Judge lead the recall Mayor Sheng Thao because she fired her prefer police chief. This is revenge.
She removed her from the police selection committee all because she was outspoken of her dis-approval of the mayors police chief termination that was without cause at a time when laws were being enforced by OPD lead by the chief. You should see now with all the rampant crime and no enforcement why she spoke out as she understands the people of Oakland unlike the mayor. The mayor has been anti-police and law enforcement since she took office as a council woman. She was one of several to vote for a defund of OPD by 50%. Can you imagine how things would have turned out if the prev mayor approved of the defund and it took place?
She said that the police chief also had support from the community and that there are many other people demanding the recall. If that's the case it's not revenge, it's utilizing the process to remove an ineffective or corrupt leader because it's the will of the people 🤦🙄 How about waiting until the results of the recall are in before you go deciding whether it's just revenge or not? If it's revenge then the recall will likely not happen, if it's legitimately the will of the people because she is a bad leader then the recall will be voted for by those people.
This judge is a bad model for Americans.
@@tamaraspencer4024 100% with all you wrote 👏
@@Juctice6969 For taking part in a rightful and democratic recall??? OK... you are speaking for 90 + % of Americans that would disagree with your comment.