A Dish Best Served ROLLED
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 05. 2024
- A sticky subject for me… rotary broaching. I thought I had it figured out. But maybe not. So let’s build one not from my imagination this time.
#inheritancemachining #machineshop #hobbymachinist
Buy this kit here (not sponsored or affiliated): www.hemingwaykits.com/HK2570
Patreon (Early Access + Ad Free + Drawings) - / inheritancemachining
Drawings Store - inheritancemachining.com/?pro...
Merch: inheritance-machining.mysprea...
Instagram - / inheritancemachining
Website - inheritancemachining.com/
Amazon Storefront (affiliate links): www.amazon.com/shop/inheritan...
Thank you again to the Micrometer level Patreon members listed at the end of the video!
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
1:06 Play Time
3:14 I tried…
6:49 Loose Ends
8:09 Shank You Very Much
11:06 This Part is Boring
13:01 PG-13
14:45 Reverse! Reverse!
17:31 Slant Touch This…
19:51 Is it drafty in here?
22:03 Baking with Brandon
24:36 And… ACTION!
26:22 Near Miss
FAQ
Drafting Equipment (affiliate links): amzn.to/3P0HvMe
A/V Equipment (affiliate links): amzn.to/3Pi45jB
Editing: Final Cut Pro X
Intro Song: Way Back Way Back When (Instrumental Version) - Gamma Skies
www.epidemicsound.com/track/S...\
• A Dish Best Served ROLLED
© 2023 Inheritance Machining, LLC. All Rights Reserved. - Věda a technologie
If this project was my smallest to date, then it only makes sense that the next is the LARGEST!
build a lathe
Yes indeed
Damn are you going to empty your box of shame? jk
The box is definitely not named well. Box of treasures would be a better name, considering how much we all learned while it was being filled!
😳
HECK. The playdoh bit made me finally understand how those things work. GENIUS!
right? i have never understood the wizardry of the broach until now.
I still don't get how its cutting... The playdoh just gets push out the way in the example.
yup that was a really good call, I sometimes use plasticene to check what hammer blows I need for blacksmithing but I would never have considered it for machining
@@thegoldenatlas753 its a lot like a shaper or wood plane where the cutting edge slides across the metal/wood cutting a shaving but the broach cutter just moves forward more slowly
me tooo xD
Due to your videos I now chamfer my cheese before putting it back into the fridge. They're fantastic
😂 Thank you
Best comment of the day award!
Oh yeah, that’s the helper tax whenever I grade Parmesan
I think that I will steal the phrase "chamfer my cheese" it is just too good
"You're making it weird" sliding up while he slowly pops that bar in and out had me laughing so hard. I love the comedy bits interspersed throughout the videos.
And it was 2 minutes after admonishing himself to not bust through the bottom too fast. He knows his audience
@@zildjianbabyYup!
And now all of us know what Machinist Porn is...
😄😁😆😅😂🤣
We now know his "search" 😳🤣🤣
I had headphones on so I heard everything.
EVERYTHING
Surprised there wasn't some Barry White over the top..
I felt that breaking carbide boring bar in my soul.
That little click of failure echoes forever
😭
You need to make some holders for those small carbide boring bars.... a missed side project methinks...!@@InheritanceMachining
I want to see a boring bar holding thin strips of a sliced junked circular saw to rescue those brazed carbide tips
@@adven999
No stranger to the snap here. Those looked like Micro 100 tools. That stuff is so nice.
Calling out "the two jankiest bolts I could find", then making two bolts to satisfy the notion of Eric's desire to see some bolts made, then explaining that those two new bolts would replace the janky ones, is some grade A Chekhov's Gun setup/payoff. 👍
If only I had that foresight. Those were literally the only bolts I could find!
I saw it coming. It definitely had that foreshadowing tone.
Yep, and the mini boring bars that should be used for a long time...
I had always wondered how rotary approaches actually worked. That Play-Doh demonstration really helped me understand.
Who knew kids toys could make it more understandable 😂
@@InheritanceMachining Is it primarily plastic deformation or by cutting action at to "top" corner/face (or perhaps some combination of the two)? If it's mainly by shear, I imagine you have to really slow down the feedrate so you don't outpace the broach, right?
@@MacroAggressorShould be both of it's working correctly. If you want to break it down, imagine the behaviour of a 1 degree slice of the action in cross section.
What always amazes me the most with these projects is the sheer number of tools that you need to make tools. AND you need to know exactly what the best combo of those tools is, to properly create a setup that will let you make the other things. Figuring out how to get things positioned to machine a precise angle is always magical to me.
Once you do it enough times it kinda becomes a second nature, plus you kinda build up a collection of clamps, blocks, and angle cheat codes. Basically as you make a thing to solve a thing, you should hoard the thing you made to make the thing.
To be fair a lot of tools i use are just because I can. There are multiple ways to skin a cat, especially in machining. There are whole gangs of people that make everything with just a lathe. Including parts that are milled!
@@InheritanceMachining Why do those ‘gangs of people’ use lathes for milling?
Because they’re lathe-y… 😂
@@wayngoodman3099 😆
as a european I appreciate you telling us the metric sizes of (some of) the parts! Would be a nice addition to have that in every measurement, maybe added in the editing stage?
@MatthewSmith-rl5ox NASA used the metric system, joke's on you 😂
@@MatthewSmith-rl5ox I hope you're joking haha
not in the 60s @@original_snipod7812
As a kiwi I'm pretty much comfortable with both so long as its thou not fractions. (39/64ths ? 😢)
Yeah, just some text on screen is plenty.
The addition of the drawing when you were doing the internal boring was a GREAT and helpful addition. I think clickspring does similar and it really does help with the additional context!!
Nice! I'm glad that came across how I hoped. Thank you!
Don't cry, man. We are here for you. :)
No, go ahead and let it all out! We could all use a good cry once a week, I think.
I never understood how a rotary broach worked, until now. I learn something new with every video you put out. Thank you!
Playdoh for the win! Thank you
I had only understood when someone else did a similar project (though I think bought the entire thing) and used it on a mill. I think it was a square hole that was being broached for a keyway with a hole that was later being cut out
You channel is so damnably satisfying, Brandon. It gives me such joy to see a new upload. Exactly what I need after a stressful week of work. Thanks so much for the care, attention, humor, technical skill, and humility you show. You really do have something special going on with your work and videos. Thank you for sharing with us!
Absolutely my pleasure, Anthony! Thanks for always being here
Wanted to say, I absolutely adore your video-specific intro teasers. It comes across super polished and always gets me a bit hyped and curious seeing the highlights.
My wife appreciates this comment especially 😁 Those are her creation and idea!
THANK YOU for using metric! Finally your measurements mean anything to me!
Yeah these weird americans use hamburgers and what not for meassuring but the metric system
Easily the funniest machinist on CZcams
*this old tony has entered the chat...*
Have you not seen This Old Tony, ahem.
*this old tony has entered the chat*
Oof don't let This Old Tony hear that
Don't let Old Tony hear you.
I’m just here to boost the algorithm. I love this shit.
Knowing where that one extra left out screw goes is already a battle that's been won! I usually have to spend 15 min figuring out where that goes (I usually deal with laptop and phone boards with different length, thickness and format screws). Usually left with few at the end.
For real... also sounds like the array of bolts you have around a small engine cover haha
YEY ! meter for the win, i finally understand the scale of what you are talking about !
😁 were my hands not a good reference? haha
7:57 Using an inside micrometer with a rod to pick up the cut piece? Maximum respect!
Telescopic gauge, not internal micrometre
The playdough demonstration really helped! Thanks. In your last attempt I was soooooo confused about how it worked.
I'm glad! Yeah I didn't do the explanation justice that first time thinking most people were already familiar from ToT's series one it. I was wrong 😅
Can't wait for the side project that is making the box of shame larger.. also the fit that you made weird was completely understandable, every one of us would've done the same 😊
😂 that's what happens when my wife does the edits!
Finally, someone has enabled me to understand how these crazy things work.
that cross section overlay is so cool! haven't seen other CZcams machinist do that yet
Agreed!
This Old Tony.
@@BrilliantDesignOnline Thanks! Someone said they may have seen Clickspring do that too.
Knowing that its the new video day, I was refreshing YT to see when it shows up. At some point during the video, I noticed that the number of likes was 500 then by the end of the video it reached 1000. Now that's what I call a success. Congrats for all the hard editing work. Your videography and story telling are exceptional! Thank you for inspiring me!
Wow... that is nuts... I'm still blown away everyday by this channel. Thank you so much, sir!
Click the bell, then go to your profile, settings, notifications, and it'll alert you as soon as.
Wasn't expecting Brian to have such an accent. Really made me crack up.
I love the kiddo-friendly visualization.
Oh my, it was only at the very end when you used the rotary broach in your mill that I finally understood how the heck it works. The rotary action is misleading. It’s all in the wobble! 😮 😂 Thank you sir. 👏👏👍😀
You sir deserve a pid controlled heat treat kiln.
( The parts have gotten cheap too!)
Oh I know! It's on my list!
Hardening of steel is best done by dipping in oil than water after reaching a cherry red temp of around 900 deg C. It doesn't matter if that is used oil too, but a good clean new oil is always welcome. Annealing, on the other hand is done by dipping in water or just left to cool down to room temperature naturally. This is the method taught to me during my apprentice days at Bosch, Bangalore, India between 1981-1984.
That is true for much of the commonly used tool steel in home workshops, which is most often O1. (The O is for oil hardening). Also for many hi tensile steels including chrome moly grades like 4340.
However quite often tool steel is better served by a water quench (usually with salt added) such as with W1, or a cold air blast (eg A2, also HSS). In particular, steels intended for air quenching should never be quenched in liquid.
One of the best yet!
14:15 is a machinists greatest moment
underrated comment
So excited to watch this, but I have to admit the broken tap in the beginning just makes me want to see that neglected tapping fixture that hides in the background get some love. :D
😂 i made a better one with that tap follower. I can't bring myself to clean that old fixture up!
You can use a magnet to check the rigth temperatur for hardening steel. If its not magnetic anymore you got the right Temperatur for quenching
Joining the "didn't know how a rotary broach worked until today" crew. These demonstrations are fantastic for the people that aren't familiar with machining!
Playdoh for the win!
What a great project, and so beautifully shown!
Thank you, Ron!
🎉now you can make one at 1:1 if you can find bearing that work. Sweet build.
I think your grandfather would be so happy to you diving in and making all the cool tools and parts. I know I would be. 😊
😁 Thanks, Joe!
Nice and relaxing as always
This Old Tony made a cool rotary brooch video too, happy to see more about it
Before you made it weird, I literally made a delighted chirp while sitting alone in the kitchen and surprised my dog. Truly satisfying fit.
😂 I don't think I've ever chirped in my life!
I work hard and revard myself with this video and sure enough, I fell asleep half way through. Got woken up by monkey howling and I now get to rewach the whole thing gigling at every oportunity guessing what did he break this time?
Fantastic project and video mate! Your editing is really starting to embrace the entertainment side of making videos :P
Just one note on rotary broach tools; you should grind a concave radius on the tip of the tool, similar or greater than the clearance angle you cut the sides at. This creates a negative rake angle on the tip and improves cutting performance massively. And some tips on hardening and tempering; keep the material cherry red for longer if you can, it helps the material austenitize properly, and use quench oil if you can. Water is rightly very effective, but brutally so if quenching parts with stress concentrating geometry. Brine is good middle ground (water and salt). And Tempering should be done at 2 hours minimum regardless of thickness, even though the scripture says an hour per 2,54 cm.
Looking forward to your next project!
Thanks for the tips!
AND kind words 😊
Silver steel is designed to quench in water......"Silver Steel Hardening
Heat slowly to 760 - 800°C using the upper end of the temperature range for lower carbon contents and lower end of temperature range for higher carbon contents. Austenitize until the temperature is uniform. Quench into well agitated water.
The approximate quench hardness is 65 to 69 Rc."
"You're making it weird" we've all done it. Nothing more pleasing than that pop
These videos are so awesome! Everything from the crisp visuals to the fun narration makes it a blast to watch! Thanks!!
Thank you!
what I find most amazing is that somebody thought it would actually work when they designed the first one
For real
Thanks to you I made it weird and now I feel weird!
Das a very niiiice!!! Lol I knew it! There’s always something hidden up your sleeve…! 🃏 🃏
I absolutely love your channel. Watched 3 of them in the past hour after you were recommended to me. I bought a Bridgeport and Southbend lathe for the muscle cars I work on. Unfortunately we got nailed in Florida by Hurricane Idalia and I'm remodeling everything. My equipment, luckily had minor damage and watching your videos is getting me amped up to redo the mills again. Plus the lessons you're giving are top-notch. Thanks, Bob
Great video as always! Would be cool if you did some sort of tutorial series?
Thanks! I avoid avoid sounding like I know what I'm doing. I still make silly mistakes haha
great project! surely you've already fixed the lathe misalignment?
Awesome content. I'm learning quite a bit here...
Thanks for the explanation of how it works! I didn't understand how it's different from just pressing a hex peg into a circular hole, but after you told that it's at an angle, it all really clicked together. I lvoe this channel.
YOU MADE it werid by POINTING IT OUT!
I love how you have started to be more lively in your videos compared to how you were a year ago when I started watching.
I usually take a little while to come out of my shell 😂
LMAO "you're making it weird" and the oh yea's was hilarious. Love your videos and your attention to detail.
😁
I "oooooo'd" out loud when I heard the first suction pop. So, no, not weird 😂
Nice to finally see a video with units i understand completely. Lol, i kid, being canadian I do actually use both. Just metric makes more sense to me.
Hope everyone is taking care
😂the post credit scenes just made me cry with laughter. As always thanks for a top tier video.
Nice work!Thanks for the look.
Your work is so elegant.
Your playdough illustration of how a broach works was brilliant! Keep up the great work!
love when you edit the image to show the technical drawing on the part as you bore the inside diameters, it helps understanding the whole process.
These vids are world class. After the little Play Doh thing, I FINALLY understand how these things work! Thank you!!!
"Fffffffffffailure ... is good!"
Brother went straight from anger to acceptance! I felt that little snap in my neck.
😂
I enjoy your humor. I also enjoy your processes. Thank you for your efforts.
"And for 'Most Educational Use of Play-Doh in a Machinist Setting' the award goes to....Inheritance Machining!!!!"
Would love to see a 2x sized one.
The clay demonstration on the lathe was a great visual!
Thanks!
When you are broaching the steel, it looks like the tool pushed into the jacobs chuck a bit. It might warrant making sure the shank of the tool is set back all the way so you arent just relying on how well the jaws grip the shank.
This is the comment I was looking for. For reference, its at 25:54
Good catch! I left it out for that aluminum test so I could access the shank screws but didn't find out it wasn't sufficient until the steel 😁
That is auto thumbs up for you sir!Don´t need to watch the video to know it is golden!Thank you sir,very much for these!
What a really great demonstration for folk that dont know. Nice!
Thank you sir!
11:54 I built this tool and yes its very tiny. These mini threads right here eere the hardest part probably. Surprised i hit them honestly
The apron bit was *chef's kiss*
Marvellous work, as per. Much kudos for even mentioning metric, just so good to hear.
😁 Thanks
As usual I enjoyed your video. The playdoh was perfect to explain the process.
Thanks, Ben!
Make ALL the bolts!! That’s so great!
The subtitles get me everytime! Are we talking about an Eric from Canada who talks about emotionally distant garbage?
That 'pop' was very satisfying. Thank you for this moment.
That's by far the best demonstration for how a rotary broach works I have ever seen.
Thank you sir!
the editing to put in the overlay at 11:22 is amazing, would love to see more like it!
That was a very nice tiny project. Thank you ❤
Thank you!
14:06 I totally understand. Makes the words "wire, EDM" pop up in my head...
14:23 🤣 “you’re making it weird” just as I was thinking it 😏
Awesome project. Thanks for sharing. 🤘😎
Great demo with the playdough!
Thank you for the videos, I do nothing with machining but it interests me, and your vibe soothes me to no end.
much appreciated!
Nice. Probably the best video on a rotary broach I have seen.
That titel. Spot on!
Very well done sir! Very well done indeed!
Thanks, Bjorn!
BTW, that was the best explanation of how a rotary broach works! Why couldn't anyone else just explain that only one corner cuts like that, rather than handwaving?
Admittedly my first attempt at an explanation (previous video) left a lot of people mystified haha
good video brandon..thanks for your time
@11:23 - channeling your inner Clickspring.I like it.
I always eagerly await your videos. So much fun to watch. Great content AND editing. Thank you!
Thank you!
Man, I felt that sigh at 4:17 in my sole.
Thanks for another awesome project!
Always the best part of my day.
😁 Thank you, Chris!
Comedy and machining. Feels like I'm back watching This Old Tony videos. Great work!
that "kiddo friendly" example was fantastic haha really explains it as simply as it is
Thanks! I'm keeping the playdoh around for future explanations haha
I love this channel so much, the little bits of humor are great!
How cool to see you here, man. Thanks!
Nice. I look forward to your videos now. Thanks for making em.
Thank you, Sir. My pleasure!
Bro I love this channel. Thank you so much, the vibe is so chill, it's like being in the workshop with your dad or something. This is gold, please don't stop, and thank you for sharing your projects with us man ✌️
Are you calling me old? 😂 Seriously, thanks, man. I really appreciate it
@@InheritanceMachining no such thing as old, 8'm saying you're wise 😉
Awesome Work !
some of those threads really are thread fine I applaud your switching form metric to imperial and back again too, nicely done.
I often use imperial and metric measurements when I build things but only because I get a more memorable number depending on which one I use.