Government Vs Judiciary: Who Should Appoint Judges? | Left, Right & Centre
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 01. 2023
- The appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and the high courts has become a major flashpoint between the government and the judiciary. There has been subtle and sometimes not-so-subtle sniping over the issue of the powers of the Supreme court. Days after Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankhar questioned the "basic structure" doctrine - as laid down by the Supreme Court in 1973 - the Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud said on Saturday it was "like the north star," providing invaluable guidance for the interpretation of the Constitution here - and elsewhere. Then today Law Minister Kiren Rijiju seemed to support the views of a retired high court judge, who said the Supreme Court "hijacked" the Constitution by deciding to appoint judges itself. The law minister commented while sharing a clip of an interview that it is the "voice of a judge" and that the majority of people have similar "sane views".
Watch Left, Right and Centre: • Left, Right and Centre
Wrestlers Continue Protest Against Federation Over Sexual Harassment Allegations - • Wrestlers Continue Pro...
About NDTV (English news channel):
NDTV is India's Most-Trusted News Broadcaster with the latest updates in news, sports, entertainment and much more from within India and around the world. Watch big political debates, exclusive entertainment interviews, news bulletins, current affairs, talk shows and tech reviews with our 24x7 news live streams, packed with credible information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.
Promoted: Find Best Shopping Deals On Amazon - g360.in/3twKm3m
Subscribe to our channel to get latest news updates.
Follow us on Social Media:
Facebook: / ndtv
Twitter: / ndtv
Instagram: / ndtv
Telegram Messenger: t.me/NDTVbot/?start=hi
Follow us on Google News for Breaking and Latest News Updates:
NDTV: bit.ly/3e5ngbP
NDTV India (Hindi News): bit.ly/3mNVwMY
Download NDTV Mobile Apps: www.ndtv.com/page/apps
#LeftRightCentre #SupremeCourt #CJI #DYChandrachud #JagdeepDhankhar #BreakingNews #LatestNews #TodayNews #News #IndiaNews #newsoftheday #newsoftheday
Most Popular Playlists :
Uttarakhand Town Joshimath Sinking
• Uttarakhand Town Joshi...
Jai Jawan With Taapsee Pannu
• Jai Jawan With Taapsee...
Congress' Bharat Jodo Yatra
• Congress' Bharat Jodo ...
Independence of Judiciary should not be compromised at any cost, Judiciary and CJI should never bow down to the government and save Constitution at any cost. Judicial appointments should never be done by government, rather Collegium should be made more transparent and Collegium has worked well for ensuring Judicial Independence.
How Collegium will be transparent.
why judges relatives got judge posts
@@rajapolmera3817 if not judges' relatives, it will be politician's relative if govt appoints.
No doubt, absolutely. The political parties should be away in the appointment of judges, If that too governed by plitical parties of their choice,then there will be no justice left for common man in this country. So no question of govt intervention, please!
Government is not the People. Government cannot appoint judges and call it as appointment by people 🙏🙏
The judges are not representative of the people, they are the servent of people. But the parliament is elected by we the people of India...
Totally. India will enter dark age. No politician will ever face trial.
Only free and independent Judiciary can safeguard freedom of the people against the tyranny of the absolute power of the corrupt government. They say power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
I hope the Judiciary must stand it's ground in this fight with the political executive to protect the freedom and liberty of the citizens 💪
Nonsense. The people elect the govt and can vote it out. It is nobody's else's business to decide who is corrupt.
The constitution says The president shall appoint the Judges after consultation with CJI. But the Supreme court has turned this on its head making it "The Supreme court shall appoint the Judges after consultation with the President".
👍
FOR THIS POST, THERE MUST BE COMETETIVE EXAM TO GET THE JOB WITHOUT ANY POLITICAL PRESSURE FOR APPOINTMENTS ON A RESPONSIBLE POST. JAI HIND.
Even the cm should be elected like this
Parliament should appoint the judges shortlisted by the elected executive.
Judiciary should be left alone by these BJP goons.
Elected party to the power, seeking to stick to the power, so the party in power is trying to snub every check.
Collegium system should be scrapped,Judges should be appointed through UPSC to ensure no hierarchy of particular caste and families prevail
UPSC can only conduct entrance exams. Upsc chairmen and members are themselves appointed by the government.
Yes 100% right
Central government wanted to use their might on judiciary , so that the judges can be made governor if they pas the order in their favor without crumps .
Lot of reforms to be taken in judiciary. Entrance exams, appointment body, judicial review committee should form,
Dont let it go as blackmafia
GOVT IS BIGGEST LITIGANT. NO WAY THEY SHOULD BE ALLOWED IN APPOINTMENT OF JUDGES. COLLEGIUM IS RIGHT IN APPOINTMENT OF JUDGES. THERE SHOULD BE SCOPE FOR IMPROVEMENT
Oh FINALLY ONLY ONE INSTITUTION IS having 70% constitutional independent institution also in and as other institutions which were in the RULERS BACKYARD AND LOST THEIR INDIVIDUAL CAPACITIES.THIS IS VERY DANGEROUS MOOVE AND DANGER TO INDIAN DEMOCRACY.ATLEAST FOR THIS FIGHT ALL POLITICAL PARTIES TO SAVE INDIA .
It is “we the people” not “we the majority of the people”.
In every major democracy after which our constitution is based, it is the elected representatives that appoint judges. This ensures that the judiciary reflects the will of the majority. Only in India do the judges appoint themselves and consider themselves unaccountable to the majority. This would be comical if it were not so ridiculous. The elected govt can and must change this idiotic situation.
There should be distinct criteria/experience in the appointment of H.C & S.C judges no Bhai bhatijabad will prevail in the judiciary.
If government appoint it is like CBI and ED!
I was taught (during my school days) that most contrasting feature between democracy & autocracy is the distribution of (legislative, executive, and judicial) power. So I guess, first we must address to questions like "What if government appoint judges (instead of Supreme Court)?"
Even for class 3 Government employers during promotion they check up central vigillance reports and employer confidential reports.For appointing judges government should take all formalities.
Judiciary should be fully independent. Especially when govt. is trying to have all yesmen everywhere.
Operation lotus
The people should and that’s government which is chosen by people.
How a high ranking official who took voluntary retirement became EC in a few days?😊😃
No government shouldn't involvement in judicial appointments
CJI And Coliseum Will Appoint Judges no Centres Interference.Centre also will come Under CJI of SC.
If Collegium fails then who will take action
America president ? Some one else
Judiciary and Govt wasting very valuable time of total judiciary. Look how 20000 house owners are crying for their houses for which they have paid 95%cost of houses a decade back.judiciary and Govt playing hide and seek with 20000 harassed common house owners in JPWISHTOWN,NOIDA.
It is the president who shall appoint judges. That means it is an executory decision, neither a legislative nor judiciary.
Thus It deduces that Supreme court’s power stops with recommendation. Recommendation means that the approver has the authority to drop anyone from the proposed list, though he doesn’t have any authority to include any one not in the list.
This is the basic structure of our constitution, built upon the tenets of dharma and dharma alone
Based on the past judgements, the appointment by President is fine. The guide lines should be available and should undergo once in 5 years. Today Gov of a state is appointed by President. The VCs for the universities are done by the Chancellors. The UPSC based will create seat reservation where unfit guys will occupy the powerful posts and the corruption routes will extend there too. Even Gandhi made the direction to Ambedkar to go with financial status based consideration, but Ambedkar hell bent on to caste and religion based system and even today we are getting screwed. Had it been like what Gandhi said, sure by this time, we would have gone multifold improvement. So the law needs revisions once in 5 years. The guidelines may be from politicians for the Collegium to consider / follow, but finally collegium should have the authority to recommend the list to president where presi is as usual select few and appoints them.
Very simple RSS SHOULD APPOINT JUDGES... already CBI, Ed, election Commission, CAG all chiefs of these are appointed by RSS...
What about Election Commission and EVM. People lost confidence in both now.
Is democracy only applies to legislative organ. Is the judiciary democratic. If yes then how? If not we are being fooled till today by the so called independent judiciary 😀😀
Courts have to to recommend then government should look their profile n they should see their performances then only to appoint for judges.
President should be appointed for twenty years. It will make him impartial
Clearly not LS, which has criminal record people as its members.
The Powers of the supreme court the shall not be diluted, or compromised by the authoritarian legislature.
Collegium appointment of judges in High
How a politition appoint a Judge?
The Vice President is not a politician anymore. He is holding a constitutional position and he can't behave like an ordinary politician. He should refrain from commenting on Judiciary.
Appointment by.judges will not solve enfringement of rights of people unless time bound imposed upon judiciary Independency.
God save this country from current regime
Go and wach court and performance and judgements after then comment
People of Dalit samaj assemble but no initiatives taken for remodeling of British colonial judiciary no sound.
Justice appointed by government of india 🇮🇳.
Elected government.
And make law all judiciary under IPC law nd income-tax nd NIA also under the P.m.
President nd p.m any time inquiry Justice they're terminate anytime if they're doing wrong
Except Desh Ratan Nigam other panelists useless
Nobody talks about pending cases in courts. The procedures should be changed using technology and with more courts. Free legal aid should be increased. Many persons are in jail because of this delay. Government and judiciary should sit together and solve this problem. They are getting paid by people money and they're not god. Because of this dadas are acting as judges and solving disputes instead of courts.
അനീതി നിലനിൽക്കുമ്പോൾ എല്ലാ മേഖലകളിലും തർക്കങ്ങൾ കൂടിക്കൊണ്ടേയിരിക്കും ! കുറ്റവാളികൾ ശിക്ഷിക്കപ്പെടുമ്പോൾ രാജ്യത്ത് സമാധാനം ഉണ്ടാകും ! കുറ്റവാളികൾ മേഞ്ഞുനടക്കുന്നിടത്ത് തർക്കവിതർക്കങ്ങൾ ഒഴിയില്ല !
Only Government of India should appoint the judges of high courts & supreme Court then only the courts are freed from the shackles of few family ...!
Bhakth spotted 🤣
Independence of Judiciary is more important.
@@AnkitKumar-yv5tp Independence of judiciary from the shackles of few lawyers & judges family is the need of the hour....!
@@daemontargaryen1123 an urbon naxal spotted ..😡
And then never expect justice when a politician in power does anything wrong.
President of India MS Droupadi Murmur should disincorporate British colonialism from Supreme Court which invaded Indra Gandhi in Allahabad High court.
Government should not nourish British colonialism judiciary Independency unbridled power harmful to sovereignty of India.
British colonialism judiciary Independency overreach unbridled power not Indian judiciary is Cobra which can intentionally cause hurt to sovereignty of India and political functionaries as well when get opportunities.
Is Modi government necessary .because they are not able to run the country properly, still they want all the laws in their hands.
This government's arrogance is increasing day by day, it is necessary to uproot them.
India's Jodi Siali is Independent The common man has a lot of faith in the judicial, what do these people want?There is no need for the judicial system to come under the control of the government.
Govt dega to last mein law and courts bi khatam ho jayega cbi ed jaise halat ho jayega,govt jo chahenga wahi hoga, kisiko nyaya nehi milegi ab
There is no question of appointments of judges British colonialism agents anti India.
Judges are crossing the boundaries defined in the constitution.
ACIKKEGIUM SYSTEM ONLY APPOINT THE JUDGES NOT BY THE OTHER.
College ium only appoint the Jude's of supreme court and high court
Law minister/ vice president should interfare for appoinment of judge.
The people should elect Judges.
What do you mean by people?? We must vote to elect judges like we vote for parliament & state legislatures.
SCVHAS THE POWER TO SCRUTANISE THE V FDA LIDITY OF LAW PASSED
Nighty please bring independent panelists on your debate
Gargi rawat you need to shut up in between to let people talk. Being the person to conduct a debate. Please don't superimpose.
This judg always guv injustic result gives favor of sys all knews
Who should appoint judges is absurd questions of talentless persons ?. India is Independent sovereign welfare democratic Government .the three organs of constitution are subject to recognition and control of constitution. British colonialism judiciary judiciary additional temporary alien rules of laws British colonialism judiciary now collegium system not above sovereignty of government. Which was incorporated temporarily in constitution to overcome hooliganism after Independence dealt with by Supreme Court. It does not mean to continue 75years should have been disincorporated revoked by President of India.
Only Modi ji
A commission should be appointed for appointment of judges and only those should be appointed as judges who follow the indian culture.
Modi is Indira.. bjp is congress 😂
only and only one objective and intent of the government of the day to tame,capture and to make committed judiciary..For bjp ,only sanghi agenda is paromount
why does it matter who appoints judges when judgement will be given by godi godi modi modi 😄😄😄😄😄
Nidhi unfortunate that you debates are standard has fallen to Godi media
Do not think judiciary is above all. In many states Judges play a role pro govt.
modi government now wants to make puppet of government
There is no question of appointments of judges British colonialism agents anti India.