Is Infinite Punishment Fair, Is Gelatin in Medicine Permissible | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi | Q&A #13
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 11. 2019
- Q1: Is it fair to be punished for all of eternity for a finite number of sins? 00:11
Q2. Is gelatin in medicinal tablets permissible? 22:59
EPIC Masjid
Please Donate at www.epicmasjid.org/donate/
www.epicmasjid.org
/ epic.masjid
/ epicmasjid
------------------------------------------------------------------------
EPIC is a multi-ethnic, multi-racial, multi-lingual, non-sectarian, diverse, and open community committed to full and equal participation and involvement of men and women who are community members of EPIC and subscribe to accept its rules, regulations, and procedures. EPIC is committed to civic and civil engagement with communities of other faiths and society at large.
All of its activities are in accordance with the teachings of the Quran and following the teachings and traditions of Prophet Mohammed ﷺ (Peace Be upon Him).
I'm starting to realize that I love this Q&A format, Shaykh. People don't put you on spot and you really get the time to prepare the best & deep & profound answer. May Allah bless you.
What a great intelligent well spoken scholar of islam. Marsha Allah
It is said
Mash allah without r
Are u from Albania
We use with r🙂
this is not a scholar
@@sulomalaj1588 hamaram halal police is out
SHK Would he now believe in this nonsense himself?
Mashallah excellent as always. Such depth of understanding and research, and such a beautiful way of explaining. May Allah protect you from all evil and grant you a long and healthy life.
No doubt YQ is one of the Great scholer alive now ...😍
YQ is a fool, spreading fear and hatred.
@@JohnStopman prophet was also accused same by munaafiqs in madinah...so whoever spread proper deen they will have to undergo same experience....
so Call what u want ...he will be rewarded for all😍😍😘😘
@@mnizam84 Muslim countries are among the most violent in the world, It's clear YQ doesn't spread love, peace, and tolerance in any real (lasting) way. His words will only spread the middle-eastern version of bigotry and hatred in the West. Our experiences of the last 1400 years (islam's many imperialistic wars, claiming the lifes of millions, and enslaving many more), proves that to be true.
@ John Stopman,
Does my Christian brothers & sisters ever thought -
1.
How is it possible,
That no Prophet of old testament ever
told anything about ''Trinity"?
if "Trinity" is True,
Didn't it exist at their time?
2.
And if Islam is False then why,
The people of the places where all the Prophets
of the Bible lived are now Muslim?
Even where Jesus Christ(pbuh) lived are now Muslim?
That was a wonderful, scholarly talk on both subjects.
The chemical makeup of vinegar is that the OH molecule in alcohol takes on Oxygen atoms easily and is transformed into vinegar. Therefore the properties are changed completely.
Mashs Allah great answers and genral knowledge from our beloved shiek yasir. May Allah swt preserve him for our ummah.
Ameen
Jazakhallah Khairan
Alhamdulliah Great inside answers,I always have this question in my heart and I got a most satisfying answer,May Allah reward you and your family,inn sha'aAllah.
I always love it when the Sheikh go off on a tangent. MasyaAllah.. it really increases my knowledge.
Shaykh is doing a great job
I have this question too. My son is an atheist. That's the biggest sin. He is an amazing person. He helps me and his brother and sister. He has a soft heart. He is deceived and so are many people. Yet he will go to hell forever. 😓 May Allah have pity and mercy on all those deceived. May Allah help me trust it's fair.
Well your son all good deeds are waste until he not want reward from anyone for that deeds. Just because he is doing good work to be nice for people whether Muslims have different intention
you can contact IERA they are based in UK. i think they help with this kind of issues.
السلام عليك يا أختي.
Make duaa for him sister, keep making duaa in the times duaa accepted, at night, between azan and iqama, jumuaa between asr and maghrib etc. Do your best to explain to him, have your local muslim community scholar speak to him. May Allah guide him. If he doesn't come back well then he made his choice and no one to be blamed but him.
like one of the uncles of Rasul Allah saw, he didn't know Islam and died just before the rasul receives revelation. May Allah Guide us all.
Finite errors do not deserve infinite punishment.
Assalamu Alaikum. The Sheikh went all chemical engineer towards the end :D Great session, please make more Q&A sessions.
He actually is an engineer by academic qualification, alhamdulillah. 😂
@@AaliyahAliSlaveOfAllah Yeah Mashallah
The world may go unfair but Allah will always provide fair judgement....this should motivate all Muslims around to get their heads out of these capital punishment doubts......
JazakAllahukhairan
It's agreat lectures ever answer my questions
Hafizakallahu ya sheik wallah I love you for the sake of Allah.I always follow your lectures &Alhamdulillah boost my knowledge
JazakaLLahu Khairan
Alhamdulillah we live to listen this lecture.
Al Kawthar Would he now believe in this nonsense himself?
@@fatimaachy5764 Why you open an account to reply nonsense?
Shukran. Very informative lecture.
Rakhi savant
@@taufeeqkhan2629 what does mos transistors stand for?. Because I live in South Africa.
@@maymunasavant1687 maymuna savant is an Indian name????
@@taufeeqkhan2629 well! THE Prophet S A W. One of the wives name was maymuna. and I got a English surname. But I'm a Indian from South Africa.
Sheikh Yasir is GOAT. Mashallah
GOAT is used for someting evil, so you should never use it, in this term
@@tahiribnmohammad5410 not really, goat mens Greates of all time. Nonetheless, we shouldn't use these terms that carelessly, cause only Allah is the Greatest, no one else.
@@nadianusratkolygazi5084 i know it means greatest of all time, but really it has another connatation
Immature comment let's leave it at that please.
I have never heard GOAT to have an evil connotation in america and in particular modern vernacular and it seems as if some of you are reading your OWN perception of the word into the OP comment. GOAT here is equivalent to Shaykh Al-Islam in which case I DO agree that in my lifetime so far I think Shaykh YQ is Shaykh Al-Islam
40:55 plot twist
@6.00 this is a problem - if we don’t understand obviously there will be rejection and why is that haram? We can’t keep asking only to get wrong answers or answers that don’t help in being intellectually honest. Looks like, whether we like it or not we just have to blindly accept that this is the truth else we burn. How convincing and convenient!
Please make the Q&A session 1 hour.
Ya skheikh can u elaborate on the issue of kitchen or the restaurant kitchen, where pig meat peperonni, is steak on/in the oven and beside that they used same oven or steaking oven for halal meat? does the halal meat become haram while cooked or steak with the same pig meat or unhalal meat? some subways sell both halal and unhalal meat kebabs and pizza while cooking it in same oven or fripan or steaking plate? any answer please!
About the matter of najis and taahir, there are nearly 8 billion of us humans walking on this planet today, and a quick back-of--the-envelope calculation would mean that we produce more than 8 billion liters of urine every single day assuming that each of us drinks an average of a liter of water per day. Multiple that by 365, and then by 10, and we have more than 30 trillion liters of urine produced over a decade. Where did all that urine go? And we're only talking of a single decade here. The point is, najis urine is recycled by the environment into taahir water over and over again. So najis becomes taahir, and taahir becomes najis, ad infinitum.
Does anyone know how to submit questions for this Q&A?
In my heart (As Allah inclines me towards some of the truth Insha Allaah), the concept of "FOREVER / ETERNITY" in the sight of Allah Almighty is not such that a mere human being can never comprehend. In other words, its futile to try to understand the concept of "time" as regards to the Hereafter.
Allah knows best so don't make active claims
Daily vitamin poll is too big for my throat and so I want to use take the chewable kind which is 2 per day.
to make gelatine in industrial settings, the boiling is lengthy and the processing is extensive and as proteins are denatured at a relatively lowish temperature (far lower than boiling point), i would have thought that any proteins used in making the gelatine, would have changed even at its carbon base, its attachment moeities and various other basic molecular structures. Yes some sturctures do not change on boiling ie H20 remains H20 after boiling, it doednt break into Hydrogen and Oxygen.. so I cant see why the processed gelatines are not considered to undergone far more changes than is needed to satisfy the fatwa requirements
I WAS ABOUT TO MENTION VINEGAR...
Eternal hellfire (torture), requires infinite cruelty. A god who indulges himself in such acts of utter lovelessness, is not able to be anything else _but_ cruel. Forget about infinite peace, forget infinite (unconditional) love: there's only infinite rage, infinite vengefulness, and infinite cruelty.
Also watch Hasan Radwan's response: czcams.com/video/T1raAMO3ipw/video.html
Do you expect God to shower people with love when they ignored him their entire lives and reward them with palaces and gardens.
So you want a gourmet meal and you don't want to pay for it, is there such a wonderful thing in this world? If there is I would like you to give me such rewards too for free.
When you never bothered asking God for rewards of afterlife, why should he even give you?
@@kakalam6004 Your god doesn't exist. And my first post is proof of that by pointing out that it is illogical for your god to exist.
If there is a Creator, then 'it' must be 100% *impersonal,* because I never saw a(ny) _personal_ god 'do anything' in this Universe. The only thing I see, are his self-proclaimed followers 'telling me' their god is out here. And 'talk' (i.e repeating ancient texts) doesn't prove anything at all.
Your and mine statement mean nothing, if God is there he is perfectly capable of showing his existence the way he like and defining the way he wants himself to be defined as. Take upanishads, dasatir, ancient Chinese shen theology, Torah, Bible and Quran...all have one thing same "God is One and cannot be percieved/seen by creation/eyes/any vision.
So if I compare your lifespan of few decades and your limited knowledge with the statement that has been there for thousands of years defining God, it is clear which is more credible and constant within the flow of time.
Besides there were millions of nations who denied God and were destroyed, you mean nothing compared to those nations and mighty people and Kings. They were buried under sands of time and so will you be and another millions of people will come and deny God, nothing new or strange, the warnings are for those who heed, not for heedless.
And lastly certified record are prove in of itself.
@@kakalam6004 Before I forget: If it was up to your god, he would never prove his existence to us, but deities that don't exist can't do anything.
Well my God is fully capable of defining Himself , and doesn't need humans to define what he can and cannot do.
And why would God even need to show himself to feeble beings like humans, jinns and Angels that might be obliterated by sight of Him?
It's more logical to send telegraphic messages.
You seem to think you are all capable to even view God's existence with your feeble capabilities and body, when you can't even stare 5 mins to a midday sun without going blind. Its amazing how people ask prove of God overestimating themselves even when it's been said again and again that you are incapable.
31:11 uh oh he in trouble now lol🤣
The Survival Scrolls Yes Indeed. RAF M.S. Chemistry M.S. Chem Engg., M.D. Holistic Health.
One of the reasons people have a hard time grasping the eternality of Hell is because of mercy. People know fire hurts and feel mercy towards someone that will be there forever. But had they known what Allah knows about those destined for this they wouldn't have shown them mercy. And the reason Allah can punish a people with such severity is because such people won't encompassed in Allahs Mercy on that Day. Imagine if you had no mercy for someone, could you then pity them? These people won't have mercy towards them so they won't every find respite. We are believers know Allah is not unjust and He is Fair and Just. So we will trust Allah that these dwellers of Hell are people *unworthy* of Allahs Mercy. That is why the people of paradise will never feel an ounce of mercy towards the people of Hell, even when they look at them as we learn in the Quran. They will even speak with them but won't have any mercy towards them. Mercy is what makes us pity, so don't feel mercy over a people unworthy of it. *"... So do not grieve over the defiantly disobedient people."* Surah 5:26
That's just sad lmao. "Oh they're simply not worth the mercy, so just let em burn". Wanna know who said that? Hitler, to his soldiers who were having a hard time gassing little children.
Sheikh, I have a simple question but have not read a thorough or sensible explanation. Can you please speak about the ruling for plucking or grooming eyebrows? Thank you.
It is not allowed to pluck or groom your eyebrows because doing that would change how your face looks physically. Changing what Allah SWT has given an individual is wrong and it is like doing plastic surgery too. Same reason why we can't draw a living creature because you are creating something and only Allah SWT is The Creator.
@@sameerabanu2553 with all DUE respect that doesn't seem to be a very strong evidence considering we are allowed to CUT and groom hair everywhere else but I do remember hearing a hadith about it therefore i don't do it but then again i'm a man so i would never even care to do it anyway lol
@@YZ4hunnid if we were to think like that nothing would seem convincing dear brother. Sometimes it is only for Allah SWT that we do certain things.
Y Z We’re not supposed to question Allah SWT’s guidelines. Just be patient and believe and follow what Allah has said. May Allah guide you.
@@sameerabanu2553 Yes, I know the common explanation however I would like to hear the Sheikh address it and explain it in more detail. He does such a superb job explaining the methodology of rulings.
Yes Alhamdulillah I got my answer ,sitting in peaceful room and shaykh done with it sitting in a peaceful room and now we have justified to burn the people for billion and billion.........approaches to infinity. Of years on the basis of misunderstanding just misunderstanding. we can understand that it is misunderstanding , But y our wise God who created this universe in very wise manner can understand???
And quran says we do not give someone the pain more than that he can afford.
Can Shaykh afford it ??
Allah is Rehman
Allah is Raheem
Allah is wise
Allah is Mohsin
Allah is Ghafoor & Munsif
How do I get him to answer my question. I’ve been emailing him the question I have for months but he never chooses my question. I know his email is askyq@epicmasjid.org but he never responds to my emails. I feel like I am not the only one who has this problem. I am pretty sure other people email him about actual important questions they have but I think he only chooses the questions he wants to give an answer to and ignores the other questions and emails. Does anyone know how do I get him to answer my question.
What is your question. 100 of emails,,,, it's difficult
MOS Transistor I mean I get it it’s like hundreds of emails but it sometimes get really frustrating that’s you don’t even get a reply. Like at least he should do his best to reply to emails as much as he could
They don't much have time to give reply to all the mails.
I recommend maybe twitter and facebooking him as well since lots of people of will be sending him questions as well
Considering that hell doesn't exist and there is no afterlife, the question "Is it fair to be punished for all of eternity for a finite number of sins?" is meaningless.
"Is gelatin in medicinal tablets permissible?" This depends if you value your own life & welfare over and above the man-made instructions of some imaginary cult figure.
Please be as forthcoming with evidence as you are with your conclusions.
@@gazmr4270
The default position is that hell & an afterlife do not exist until proof is shown otherwise.
Same applies to religious texts. Totally man-made until proven otherwise.
@@lewis72
Using that logic, why do you prepare anything for tomorrow and who has guaranteed this tomorrow for you?
@@gazmr4270
Previous experience would heavily suggest that tomorrow won't be that different from today.
No one has guaranteed tomorrow for me. There is just a very high probability that tomorrow will become today.
@@lewis72
I am sure there are others who can call upon previous experiences too that tomorrow can be very much different from today.
I don’t claim to be Sunni
Allah is my lord
Islam is my religion
Muslim are my people
Question: Would tanning a pig skin make it lawful to use? Just Wondering.
If gelatin is stated as a bovine product & we know that Allah TA was not mentioned in the slaughtering of the animal, what is the position then ? JZK
Assalam Aleikum Shayikh
Humbly speaking, base on the evidences supporting the termination of jahanam it seem to be true if one critically look at it from the angle of Allah's names. That is ahzab (عهذاب ), this is not found in HIS names but Araheem and Arahaman are part of HIS names. HE said everything shall perished except HIS face قل شيء هالك, if HIS face shall remain, is it not evidence that all his attributes shall remain intact? If that is the case by HIS willingness ahzab is not HIS name and shall not remain till eternity. و الله علم
A brother this educated made such a basic mistake, he said didn’t matter if 99 percent of people before said it....yet Rasul’Allah sws said my Ummah will not unite on falsehood, the hand of Allah is with the jammah
Some points of Law will always remain the same. That which the Qur'an is clear on. That which Rasulallah sallalaa'alayhiwasallam was clear on. Beyond that is the guidance of the Khulafaa and the Scholars of Deen. Some things we have been advised to stay away from, as a Mercy from Allah and His Messenger.
What chapter and ayat was that where "Hell is forever unless Allah wills....?"
Assalamu Alaikum brother if I am not wrong tdy I read sura an'aam in this sura I read the same verse which you asked so you can
11:107
The sura name is an'aam aayah nmbr 128
@@zumra1768 yes 6:128 is another
Surah Hud, second last page.
I really don’t know why it’s alway the science and not the mainstream while mainstream were always strictly Sunni!
But there is something about tanning animals you can’t eats skin not becoming tahir that’s the issue
Question 🙋 can someone used alcohol to rens his/her hands 👐 and eat lunch?
You can use hand sanitizer.
@@kakalam6004 lol
Drinking alcohol has no effect on others things touched afterwards. And I should know: because I love a good cold beer, from time to time ;-)
Infinite punishment is fair when you truly realize that the crime of rejecting Almighty Allah is infinitely evil. Hindu idol worshipers take heed. Worshiping idols is no joke
I am agnostic but I meditate and give thanks for my existence to whatever created me, be it God or the laws of physics. It sounds to me like according to Islam, this is a better position than following any other religion?!
@@1986tomdavies yes its certainly better than atheism, but become a Muslim and worship the Almighty Who gave you life. He created the universe. Every human has a soul. After death there is more. We all have to stand before Him.on Judgment Day. Would you rather stand on that Day having bowed before Him and pleaded for His mercy when you were alive or not?.Ill give you a hint, He will forgive those who did so and cast the rest to damnation who didnt show gratitude to Him.either by worshiping idols or rejecting His very existence. The choice is yours I hope you make the right one
@@1986tomdavies
My friend, you are on a good path. Remember though, this is one of the things that we should not settle for less when there is better. In our case not just better but the best path has been made available to us.
The position you hold with regards to giving thanks to the Creator is a position that pious people of the past have held before they come upon the Truth during times when religious scriptures under mankind's protection became corrupt and unreliable. But the truly pious people would have never stopped seeking for truth. Truth will be sent to you and your sincerity will help you to recognise it when you find it.
That's just str8 up evil lol how could you even think like that?
Gelatin is making with pork...
Or empty medicine into halal capsules and consume it...go to a doctor for guidance
Its mind blowing to think in 100 trillion years, we will all still be around.
Subud jj إن شاء الله
We’re relaxing in gardens
SHK amin
Jo James Paradise is only for muslims. And for those who never heard of Islam but pass a test on the Day of Judgment. Christians who believe God is a man will enter the fire for all of eternity for their idolatry
@@jojames6621 The original person you replied to @SHK clearly stated ان شاء الله
Idk if you can read Arabic or not but he said InshaaAllah. Meaning if Allah wills it. He didn't arrogantly say he will definitely be relaxing in gardens he said InshaaAllah only if Allah wills it so your whole point is invalid.
Also Satan can't force us to do anything. As long as we turn to Allah and ask for his forgiveness and protection he can't do anything. You're talking about him as if he's so smart and powerful, no he's weak and arrogant and foolish
No we won’t, it’s mindblowing that you think that.
Get ready for the pdfs to come about "we need to ask a chemist instead of a faqeeh"
nah...no one does pdfs anymore...they do youtube videos :)
everyone has a speciality , if a scholar doesnt know something he may/ will consult a specialist in that field and based on that person he goes to he might get the right or wrong answer its ijtihad and so its gonna have diffrences of opinion/ruling might change /good investigate into those certain dunyah issues . you can be a faqeeh & chemist ,doctor,scientist etc.
DR. SHAYKH YASIR QADHI, please explain with justification, why did Muhammad not fly at Day time, so that people can see miracle and believe Muhammad and his Allah as written in Quran, was it too hot at Daytime at scheduled Shab-e-Miraj that Muhammad changed the plan and flew at Night in cool at Shab-e-Miraj night?????? All miracles God/Allah did, as written in the Bible, was in daytime in front of people, so that people can see and believe God. But Islam is a special religion where miracles are done behind the scene so that people don't see but believe blindly. Please explain, thanks.
That miracle was for him a gift from Allah to the prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallam not meant to be shown to ppl..
MO UKBU, you said "miracle was for him a gift from Allah to the prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallam not meant to be shown to ppl" But in Torah, Jobbar, and Ingil we find Allah/God gave gift to prophets, to His beloved Son Jesus Christ to show people that God is living God, so that people believe unseen God of Spirit and Truth by their heart without any doubt, fear and love Him.
No miracles, Jesus Christ SON OF GOD did in private. After Resurrection of Jesus Christ he appeared to 500 people as proof of God's gift to His Son; Jesus Christ went into Heaven in broad daylight in front of many people in daylight to prove that He is alive now. Jesus Christ gave life to dead man Lazarus in front of villagers to proof God's gift to Jesus Christ as His Son. This proves without any doubt that something is wrong with Muhammad's miracles flying and splitting of moon into half.
@@alimalyas3762
Listen that particular miracle was for him only this does not mean he didn't perform miracles, because he performed many!
As for time constrained miracles like jesus and moses than those kind of miracles were for their time as their messages were temporary. So because Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wa sallam was sent to the whole of mankind and till the day of judgement his miracle cannot be time constrained so Allah gave Muhammad the miracle that would last until the end of times and anyone and any person can witness it. THE QURAN
You take care my Christian friend
@@alimalyas3762
Prove to me Jesus and Moses did those miracles did u see it? Did ur dad see it? Ur mum?
We affirm it coz Allah affirmed it otherwise all will say heresay fairy tails!!
@@alimalyas3762 the Prophet Muhammad performed many miracles in front of many people, such as a small meal increasing enough to feed hundreds of people, water bursting from between his fingertips, the tree trunk crying loudly when he stopped leaning on it, and that's just a few. There are so many more. And don't even get me started on the prophecies, how he predicted things that would occur word for word. Explain that Mr cross-worshipper. Oh wait let me guess you'll say it was the devil as you Christians always say when someone presents logic and facts. The example you gave of him is just a single example and trust me people mocked him just like you're doing now. Peace be upon him.
I can debate him for years on this topic about some of the stuff he mentioned and prove him wrong.
You might be in utter surprise where people are applying this theory without knowledge. Horrendos stuff they are doing. And also people from different faiths are involved.
That's very arrogant of you to say you would prove him wrong when there hasn't been a discussion or debate. Humble yourself a bit, and send Dr. Qadhi your credentials, prove you can defend yourself through experience and scholarship, and ask for a debate. The world knows who Dr. Qadhi is and yet I've never heard your name mentioned in any religious or academic circles. You have an uphill battle to fight but you might be able to get an audience. Or register your academic credentials on Academia.edu and publish your own documents refuting Dr. Qadhi. Good luck to you.
Baba baba black sheep have you any wool. Yes sir yes sir 3 bagful.
Some of the old lectures of him are really good, but why should I mention it here. This is for one particular stuff that I am intrigued.
@@thewallcometh1444 not here to fight a battle or gain credentials, I am good with my credentials, Neither I need any audiences. Neither I want to be rebuked.
Gelatin is making with pork..eat pork is HARAAM
Pork is nothing more than mere flesh. There's nothing haraam about it. And some god calling it haraam, doesn't make it so.
@@JohnStopman A Muslim eating pork and drinking alcohol is by far much better than a non Muslim who doesn't.
going into details like this was forbidden by the prophet , The Sahabas never asked questios about Halal and Haram , because it is clear in the Quran.
And I ask Allah to prove his existence yet he doesn't do it or isn't capable of it
Wait for resurrection day Or go and pray in mosque with good intention
Allah SWT is capable of everything. Believing in Him when we can’t see him is the part of the test of this world. Those who do will have rewards and those who don’t won’t have the same rewards. The Quran is clear about this, and the rest is your choice. May Allah guide you.
Nah... it's all nonsense for the uneducated.
Religions serve no measurable purpose.
@@lewis72
You have the means to definitively measure purpose?
@@gazmr4270
I don't but others do.
Health.
Longevity.
Wealth.
Education.
What does Islam offer in any of those areas ?
Would he now believe in this nonsense himself?
Shouldn’t really change his colour in the thumbnail
If firaon would not have died,he would have continued his mischief-for eternity..
Allah caused him to die
Thats why his punishment is eternal..
As for those who believe in Allah, they fear him.. so at a point they would stop their wrong action, so believers punishment is not eternal.
Allah says he have a softcorner for believers
Credit: baseera media youtubechannel
But i modified some language and added some extra
Although Sheikh YQ explained it better, but I ve one better explanation on this.
Keep it in your pocket.
say it
Pls share it with logic or source
How can heaven be heaven when those in heaven know their loved ones are in hell?
If someone disobeys Allah, then he or she aren't your real family or loved one.
Say if your son or your dad chooses to go against the one who created him, then you will choose Allah because he is more lovable and more merciful to us than our family could ever be.
And this is where the famous Islamic rule comes in where the prophet said “There is no obedience to the creation in the disobedience of the Creator”.
When it comes to family or God, if the family go against Allah you will choose Allah.
heaven/hell is a reality like this life/death , not our subjective view of what is heaven for us. many prophets like noah (as) , lut(as),muhammad (sallahu alihe wa salam) etc that had a family member that went astray or died upon disbelief like abu talib , so you can love someone but if the message of islam is conveyed to them & they reject it in their heart and died in disbelief , it doesnt matter how good they were in other aspects. Allah has made clear the punishment of those who commit crimes/shirk and if they choose to be of that category they get that punishment , Allah is most just , to be just it requires punishment/forgiveness/etc. like a person who kills the king and is given life sentence in jail , you should be pleading with your son to not do the crime/ change vs questioning the law/punishment.
if your son is alive i advise you to give your son dawah or have someone knowledgable give dawah to your son. and encorage him to consider islam , & make dua for him , you dont know when he will accept islam.
@@darktigerx if pleading worked, he have a changed head. If prayer worked he have a changed heart. Its between Allah and him now. I only hope what he says is not truly in his heart. Only Allah knows. Lots say they know Allah and claim to be Musim, but actions speak louder than words. I just pray my son knows and loves God. As long as his faith is of one God and not a pagan faith, I will feel secure in knowing he is safe. Too many Muslims do good only for the prize. I think Allah sees intention. Intention counts. Just following rules is not enough. A person must have sincere love of Allah and mankind. I wish life was easier at times. I wish life was less lonely at times. One thing I am very grateful for, is that my son never believed in the trinity. I raised him Christian because that what I grew up with. I am still learning Islam. It's difficult to learn alone. It's difficult to keep my deen as a single mother. Insha Allah I will learn and keep pushing forward.
Didn't the Prophet said follow the jama'ah then why did he refused the majority.
Majority of that period of time
It is plausible that the hadith had a particular context. It seems like the Prophet's (ﷺ) instruction to follow the majority is related to the issue of taking a collective decision. For example the issue of declaring jihad, beginning and ending of lunar months, appointing a leader. Since in these cases a collective decision is needed to be taken for the practicality of the issue, otherwise there will be just anarchy. But as for deciding whether a concept and ruling is haqq or baatil then the criteria is the strength of the evidence from Qur'an and Sunnah, not the majority position. As the Prophet (ﷺ) said in another hadith that, 'My ummah will never unite upon error.' Please note that the concept of ummah is not just a spatial concept but also temporal. In other words, there will always remain from the ummah of the last Messenger (ﷺ) someone who will point out the error. It is entirely possible that he may come at a later time since the wording of the hadith allows this possibility. Obviously a mujtahid Imam (it is arguable though if Imam ibn Taymiyyah is a mujtahid or not) has the obligation to understand an issue directly from the text of the Qur'an and Sunnah, it is not correct for him to follow the majority if he understands that the text is meaning otherwise. Our tradition gives this academic freedom to a mujtahid Imam. We need to understand that our tradition is a dynamic one, it is neither a clergy system like Catholicism, nor a chaos like the online forums where every Tom, Dick and Harry can have his opinion. I agree that it is a tight rope to walk for the tradition. But any authentic, honest, pragmatic and dynamic intellectual tradition needs to do this balancing act prudently in order to preserve its relevance and integrity. And Allah knows best.
Jamaah doesn't ONLY mean majority it means the TRUTH as well .. Refer to the statement of Abdullah ibn Masood
It can also mean the salaf
It is Quran and Sunnah that you follow first thing. Jamaa'ah comes later and with a condition that they follow the first two. Ibn Taimeeyah including Ibn Qayyim, as explained in this video went against the opinion of the majority in the past because they have a proof from Quran on the possibility of Jahannam not existing forever, for example. If someone doesn't agree with him or both of them, then they must provide the evidence from Quran itself to prove that their interpretation or understanding is not correct. The opinion of the majority alone are not qualified to rebut a Quranic verse and thus dismiss it. On the contrary, Quran will always sit on judgement over hadith and opinions.
My brother, be aware how often you make devil horn signs with your left hand during your lecture.
That's all you took from this?
@@jeanbaptiste3470No not at all but It struck me a lot and I warn my brother about this, so that he is aware of himself doing it. The shaytaan loves these gestures and is often the cause of it. Maybe he didn't notice that from himself, so I warn my brother instead of ignoring. We should all warn each other about this. I hope this answers your question, Salaam alaikoem wa rahmatoellahi wa barakatoeh.
@@Daniel-fl4mb some people also think that hand signs have only one meaning. Across the world they may have many different meanings and origins. We have a handsign for a telephone call where we close the three middle fingers and spread the thumb and pinkie wide open. No sane person would assume such a person encourages Satanism. As always, use one's sense.
@@jeanbaptiste3470 I agree, I am with you. Hand signs are not necessarily bad. Similarly we use the index finger when we pronounce the shahada. But only when we use the horns of the devil, that is a sign that Allah dislikes alot , so we must be aware of it because Shaytan travels through our body and sometimes let you do things that you are not aware of, just to play with us and make fun of us, so we have to be very careful and Allah knows best.
Unnecessary issues are discussed, waste of time.
Sheikh and Doctor of misguidance
Very few scholars have done as much damage to Islam as ibn Taymiyyah. He is the common factor in all Islamic extremists, militants, fanatics and terrorist groups and organizations ... hint! hint!