Of course Arthur and John because they are the main characters. Except them both, it’s actually Uncle. He was useless, but died while protecting the people he loved
Not including Arthur and John because they are the obvious answers, I would probably say Lenny. Happened so quick and had no time to react to it. Other contenders was Sean, Uncle, Kieran and Miss Grimshaw
Well they all had a hell of a life and got killed for a game and to suffer Arthur TRUELY suffered the most having TB especially in that time an age the rest was shot sure black power back then was weak in fact the game had no one suffer when shot but hell anything better than trying to breathe in hot open air realize that true pain ...NOPE SHOOT ME
No way it's *YOU* again. Aren't you from another comment section argument? Well, to put it simply, not everything goes as planned. He really didn't have a choice, and John thought that it was all over, when really it wasn't.
@@AHZIDAL_1 Your crazy then I remember playing rdr1 on my ps3 when I was 8 in my office chair and watching John get shot I sat there and cried for like ten minutes 😂
@@areyad.09 cap. He had so much character development. Arthur's was bad but John's was even more sad as he just accepted fate and died for practically no reason
@@sandiwch1247 I will say if you got the bad ending for Arthur then yes John's was worse, but if you got the good ending and had high honor in chapter six Arthur's was worse
I think the worst part about John’s death is him mentally preparing in the barn. You can just feel every thought in his head before he walks out to face the noise. He knew his days of running were over.
@Connor__RK800 it's not that, if he ran away he would just be Dutch 2.0. Abigail wouldn't be able to live like that and neither would Jack, he made the best decision possible.
@Connor__RK800I think the reason is because he already knew he cannot just run away anymore, even if he escaped with his family, the pinkertons will still find them one way or another, also putting his family at risk of more danger this time, and he didn't want his family to live a fearful life hiding away like that either.
At least Jack knows though. In the final cutscene where he takes revenge on agent Ross, he says "you sent him to do your dirty work, then you shot him like a dog". He understands that John didn't have a choice, and that everything he did was to protect his family
@@fable_enthusiast Killing Micah made it *_easier_* to find John. It never made it *_the reason._* *HE WAS BUYING LAND WITH THE SAME FAKE NAME THAT THEY ALREADY KNEW HE USED BEFORE ("JIM MILTON") THAT ALONE COULD'VE SCREWED HIM AND REALLY SHOULD'VE.*
@@fable_enthusiast killing Micah came years before hunting dutch Just say you don't like John and leave it at that. He didn't get a fair chance at all dude. There's a npc in the game who's named Emmet Granger, he made a deal with the feds and got his own ranch to live in even after all the murders he committed. So if you're telling us John chose his way you can stfu. His ending was unfair
@@AsapMilk no, it was redeemed because jack had the choice and as the story’s written at least, he only has to shoot Ross and alls redeemed from there because there’s no way anyone could trace him being shot on a hunting trip in Mexico back to jack. Beautiful if you really think about it.
Arthurs death was the saddest to me because Red dead Redemption 2 was the first video game I truely loved. And Arthur loved almost everybody in the gang and would do anything for them. I wanna thank Rockstar games giving me a game I will never forget. Thank you
John’s death hit the hardest. Everyone knew Arthur was gonna die or be arrested since he was never in the first game, but John was completely outta no where.
“21 SHOT WOUNDS, you didn’t leave him a chance did you? HE WAS BLEEDING, BEGGING FOR MERCY. And you shot him, again and again and AGAIN” -Detroit become red dead
For rdr3 all I want is for it to be about either how the gangs was formed ending at the Blackwater massacre or a alternate timeline where John remembers what Arthur said and leaves
Expanding off of your comment, I think a Dutch origins story would be cool even though he’s the villain and we know what happens in the end, but seeing him rise up and talk his way in and out of trouble along Hosea with younger versions of the gang would be awesome.
@@Rrr_558This is going to be a long comment but fuck it. Here's my idea. What if we start as Dutch Van Der Linde as a 15 year old boy, there are cut scenes where he sees his mother depressed and he just can't take it anymore, so now the player can move and the objective is to sneak out of home and flee never returning. Dutch leaves home at that age in the year 1870. Then we go to Hosea, his childhood and him growing up on the mountains, fast forward to a 17/18 year old Hosea attempting to steal a chicken. The player can now move and the objective is to steal a chicken, then a cut scene is of you getting caught. And so he gets caught and he's about to be hanged while the people are chanting and rioting for him to be free, then a sheriff steps in and shoots the ropes, the player can move Hosea and the objective is to flee out of the area while holding his throat and fleeing and a cut scene when they grab the sheriff and hang him instead. Sad music plays after the death of the sheriff. 1876, Dutch and Hosea are arrested, they spent hours in a jail cell, they find a way out and before they escape, they tie the sheriff up on a chair. 1877, a young 14 year old Arthur is running around causing trouble to elderly folk. One day Dutch and Hosea go up to Arthur and introduce themselves, they offer him to join them. He agrees. I have more so i will comment tomorrow with more story progression.
This whole interaction hit me. I never knew my dads dad, because he died when my dad was little. And my kids will never know my dad because he died when I was little. Here’s hoping I can break that cycle 🤷🏼♂️
Arthur was such a deep, misunderstood character. Probably the best character rockstar has ever created. John wasn’t entirely complex but he did everything he could for his family. Both different, both great
@@StrItsSelf I wasn’t saying one was better or worse than the other fam. Just that they’re different. Arthur was much more complex than John, that’s just fact.
@@pup123434 yeah I feel that with the first RDR the whole game is kind of tailored towards the western gunslinger fantasy, all the outfits, challenges, music, characters all had the western movie feel, John was basically the lone wolf gunslinger for the most part becoming a legendary name, but RDR2 felt like it tried to be a more real setting, not the western movie fantasy (not saying it's bad) Arthur's character had the advantage of being surrounded by the gang and the hundreds of interactions and sides missions you could with them to get to know them better, the way you could interact with everyone with greet/antagonize system and the numerous lines Arthur just spat out made everyone feel alive. The whole story revolved around the death of the outlaw, civilization moving in and the slow deterioration of the gang and Arthur's attempts to try to prevent that and his failure to making him realize they can't go back and he especially can't with his diagnosis so he fights with who he is to try and change, his story and the journey he goes on is just more complicated than the first one because it's a more internal struggle with himself, John's is a little more surface level with try to save his family by taking out his past, but I will say that the cutscenes he does get with the gang in the first game did have some good writing, like with Dutch "we can't fight nature" the dialogue john would with the gang members in the first one set their characters but they were very vague with how everything went down and their actual relationship and the second one just fleshed everything out so much more
Arthurs death was sad but johns death was even sadder. Despite john turning a complete new leaf but still suffered the consequences of his past. That corrupt agent ross was never gonna let him go
@@theslavecrusher5947 Arthur did it all becuase of Dutch , becuase Dutch manipulated him to kill and make money from the very start when he was a child, later on, when he found that he's gonna die and was terminally ill with TB, he gave this all up and preferred to do acts of love and care just like the nun at the station told him😌
All I have to say, he was a great man always fighting for the right things he was better than a cowboy. He was a man he died for everything he’s standing for. God bless his wife and his children.
Atleast they marston family got 12 years with eachother outside of the gang More than most got Edit: I’ve been having some minor back and forth in the comments and I’ll just get my point across here. I’m a fan of the overall redemption series. And I like to have a conversation about every storyline and every character. So when people pop up only talking about 1 character. As an actual fan of the overall story and characters I just hope there was others who likes to discuss all of the elements and not the same 3 things
@@Donbros can anything be said about the redemption series other than Arthur? I’m a fan of the series overall me mate not just redemption 2. I like to talk about everything
@@xxsaruman82xx87 yes I am aware of that. But it’s how nothing else can be spoke about. I love the series have done from the start i love and understanding the characters more than most but I would like it if more people could talk about more aspects than 1 character or bit Arthur’s sacrifice was a huge part of the redemption story and it’s awesome but I would like it if more would talk about other points about everything
Nah he got to spend like all of 1899-1911 with them if u think about it. It wasnt till 1911 that Ross made him start searching all over New Austin for Bill Javier and Dutch
One thing I have to say is that uncle’s death is extremely underrated. The guy was lazy and useless but in the end he died protecting the people he loved.
I was 15 when RDR came out 14 years ago and I haven’t played through it since but my god I can still remember how I felt when John died.. I had never seen a protagonist die in any form of media before.. to say I was gobsmacked is an understatement. It’s only now that I’m older that I can really understand how dirty they did him and after playing through RDR2 it just makes it feel all that more rotten.
People now only talk about fucking Arthur while this character was made and inspired by John Marston Kids nowadays don't know to enjoy good games like GTA 4 and RDR 1
I've tried so many things to survive the last scene in the barn. I almost turned off my console before saving I was so destroyed. Really good story line, absolutely insane
I don’t know if this happened to you but when I tried to survive the agents I killed were shooting the rifle even tho they were dead in the cutscene lol. Man I even remember using the Mauser because there is 15 agents or something very close to it
@@squttle no, but I did manage to kill like seven of them. So if you think about it, the law in that county would be crippled for a long while. That thought at least made it better
Bro Jack had by far the hardest life in the Red Dead series. Everyone who he grew up with left. He lost his parents, Uncle, found out his dad died because of killing Micah. Then we never even see what becomes of him🤧. Truly tragic
When I first heard this, I immediately cried because I lost my dad when I was no older than Jack is in this video. Thats my worst fear if I ever become a father. I want my boy to know his Dad and be proud of me. Jack really deserves his own game.
And the most sad, it’s what Jack will end like his dad, gang don’t want to make Jack a murder and a robber like them, but at the final we see, what Jack stay like them…
Everyone always talks abt Arthur’s death but John literally went through 3 journeys deeper and deeper into hell having to kill some of his pals in the process so he could get his family back only to be killed right after along with the man who raised him after his father
John and Arthur have the most sad death Arthur because of how he ended and John because even though he wasn't the best father and husband he loved them and would do anything to save them
I think Eagle had a sad death but John and Arthor were good men in bad situations, they had good hearts and wanted to make their lives better. Sad how they gave everything for others dreams, at least John got out before he died
Im so glad i got to experience rdr1 without any spoilers and that moment had me reloading saves with tears in my eyes. Even though arthurs death was sad you knew from the start that he was gonna depart at some point and halfway you learn how and why and you could prepare. John on the other hand did everything right and you think youre working towards a wholesome ending for john and his fam and all of the sudden there is the government there to destroy another family, killing john and turning jack from a gifted kid to a outlaw
Idk why but Johns death is just a little sadder than Arthurs if you played RDR1 as a kid then played RDR2 epilogue as an adult, then replay RDR1, it just makes Johns story so much more impactful and knowing that he died almost at the same age as Arthur just hurts bro. At least jack got a good 6-7 years with his dad😢
Who had the saddest death in the Red Dead Redemption series
In your opinion
Of course Arthur and John because they are the main characters. Except them both, it’s actually Uncle. He was useless, but died while protecting the people he loved
Not including Arthur and John because they are the obvious answers, I would probably say Lenny. Happened so quick and had no time to react to it. Other contenders was Sean, Uncle, Kieran and Miss Grimshaw
Ayy wassup. I know this is out of context, but plz tell me the song you used in the Django edit
Well they all had a hell of a life and got killed for a game and to suffer Arthur TRUELY suffered the most having TB especially in that time an age the rest was shot sure black power back then was weak in fact the game had no one suffer when shot but hell anything better than trying to breathe in hot open air realize that true pain ...NOPE SHOOT ME
It’s uncle he died protecting his loved ones and he had L U M B A G O
"I ain't going nowhere"
*f*cking leaves home for 70% of RDR1*
@@varsancton he said "I ain't going nowhere" not "I ain't going nowhere unless I have to"
@@FunnyRedemption No shit sherlock
@@damianovich1512 "no shit Sherlock" 👶
No way it's *YOU* again. Aren't you from another comment section argument? Well, to put it simply, not everything goes as planned. He really didn't have a choice, and John thought that it was all over, when really it wasn't.
Goofy comment
I've never felt more sad in a game than seeing John get killed
I felt worse when Arthur died
@@AHZIDAL_1 Your crazy then I remember playing rdr1 on my ps3 when I was 8 in my office chair and watching John get shot I sat there and cried for like ten minutes 😂
@@AHZIDAL_1 johns was bad, but not worse than arthurs
@@areyad.09 cap. He had so much character development. Arthur's was bad but John's was even more sad as he just accepted fate and died for practically no reason
@@sandiwch1247 I will say if you got the bad ending for Arthur then yes John's was worse, but if you got the good ending and had high honor in chapter six Arthur's was worse
I think the worst part about John’s death is him mentally preparing in the barn. You can just feel every thought in his head before he walks out to face the noise. He knew his days of running were over.
@Connor__RK800 it's not about being a coward, it's about giving his family a peaceful life.
@Connor__RK800 it's not that, if he ran away he would just be Dutch 2.0. Abigail wouldn't be able to live like that and neither would Jack, he made the best decision possible.
@Connor__RK800I think the reason is because he already knew he cannot just run away anymore, even if he escaped with his family, the pinkertons will still find them one way or another, also putting his family at risk of more danger this time, and he didn't want his family to live a fearful life hiding away like that either.
and he died hoping Jack would keep running and not look back. Jack did though.
"Don't worry. I ain't going nowhere."
Still have a scar in my heart.
At least Jack knows though. In the final cutscene where he takes revenge on agent Ross, he says "you sent him to do your dirty work, then you shot him like a dog". He understands that John didn't have a choice, and that everything he did was to protect his family
True
Nah, John made his choices too, he was forced to hunt dutch, not to kill f* Micah
@@fable_enthusiast Killing Micah made it *_easier_* to find John. It never made it *_the reason._*
*HE WAS BUYING LAND WITH THE SAME FAKE NAME THAT THEY ALREADY KNEW HE USED BEFORE ("JIM MILTON") THAT ALONE COULD'VE SCREWED HIM AND REALLY SHOULD'VE.*
@@fable_enthusiast killing Micah came years before hunting dutch
Just say you don't like John and leave it at that.
He didn't get a fair chance at all dude. There's a npc in the game who's named Emmet Granger, he made a deal with the feds and got his own ranch to live in even after all the murders he committed.
So if you're telling us John chose his way you can stfu. His ending was unfair
@@AsapMilk no John is a blatant idiot, don't you remember he got a loan with HIS REAL name??? Ofc the Pinkertons killed him
It hurts me to know that Arthur gave everything for John and his family. And Jack had to follow the same path as his father.
It's almost as if redemption was dead from the start
@@AsapMilk no, it was redeemed because jack had the choice and as the story’s written at least, he only has to shoot Ross and alls redeemed from there because there’s no way anyone could trace him being shot on a hunting trip in Mexico back to jack. Beautiful if you really think about it.
4 years later
But at least jack was able to live a peaceful life with a new family later on
I think he became an author later on, cause there’s a book in Franklin’s house in gtav
Arthurs death was the saddest to me because Red dead Redemption 2 was the first video game I truely loved. And Arthur loved almost everybody in the gang and would do anything for them. I wanna thank Rockstar games giving me a game I will never forget. Thank you
dude, what's up with Arthur? john video lol
❤
The most kiddy comment I’ve ever read 😂😂
Arthur die?
@@allthingsjax7913no just keep playing the game until you finish
To see John wearing Arthur’s hat, shows that deep down he loves Arthur
Uh
You have a choice to wear it. But if you don’t change he wears his own hat
@@PepperStep_Most of the time yes, but sometimes he wears Arthur’s hat regardless of player choice.
Does anyone know what coat he wearing?
Just 4 fuckin years later. Man rockstar pays attention to details
This wasn't one of those cases. This had nothing to do with close details.
Rockstar does it again
red dead revolver story got me like ;ccc@@joebama6911
Only game Company that make quality games on almost every game. I cant even think of a bad Rockstar game.
Only game Company that make quality games on almost every game. I cant even think of a bad Rockstar game.
He died protecting his family. Besides from all of his killing, John Marston was a good man. Comes from Arthur, maybe.
John's good because he's just himself, he didn't get this goodness from Arthur
damn he was not a good person, he was kind of a piece of shit. kind of a lot of a piece of shit actually
He always was less a killer than arthur was
(Arthur didn't want to kill neither)
@@nightmarepegasus4141 John only killed bad men in rdr1, he killed killed te rebels tho but he didn't kill a single lawman
So he wasn't such a "killer"
“I’m not crying, my eyes are just sweaty”
Eyes dont have sweat glands
@@BaklavaBOY-lr3jwDo testicles have them? I live in the cold so i wouldn't know, my balls never sweat.
@@joshuamartinez7409 not the testicles but the area around them does
@@BaklavaBOY-lr3jw The scrotum? Interesting, I need a vacation to Hawaii or something.
John’s death hit the hardest. Everyone knew Arthur was gonna die or be arrested since he was never in the first game, but John was completely outta no where.
Sad to see the best gunslinger that ever walked the face of the earth die helplessly at his own home
I believe arthur was a better gunslinger
@@Wolf_losoI think you could make a case but honestly John was a slinger
@@OnliiAvii Arthur is the Goat
@@SurajGupta_3D like I said you can make the argument I don’t doubt or agree
Anyone know the so g
To do all the work for Ross just to get shot 21 times, and to still stand like a REAL ONE.
6 times*
21 times*@@joseluismarin9979
@@joseluismarin9979it was 21 times
“21 SHOT WOUNDS, you didn’t leave him a chance did you? HE WAS BLEEDING, BEGGING FOR MERCY. And you shot him, again and again and AGAIN”
-Detroit become red dead
@@Ghostrider-qp2pimore like Detroit Become Redemption
For rdr3 all I want is for it to be about either how the gangs was formed ending at the Blackwater massacre or a alternate timeline where John remembers what Arthur said and leaves
Expanding off of your comment, I think a Dutch origins story would be cool even though he’s the villain and we know what happens in the end, but seeing him rise up and talk his way in and out of trouble along Hosea with younger versions of the gang would be awesome.
@@Rrr_558This is going to be a long comment but fuck it. Here's my idea. What if we start as Dutch Van Der Linde as a 15 year old boy, there are cut scenes where he sees his mother depressed and he just can't take it anymore, so now the player can move and the objective is to sneak out of home and flee never returning. Dutch leaves home at that age in the year 1870. Then we go to Hosea, his childhood and him growing up on the mountains, fast forward to a 17/18 year old Hosea attempting to steal a chicken. The player can now move and the objective is to steal a chicken, then a cut scene is of you getting caught. And so he gets caught and he's about to be hanged while the people are chanting and rioting for him to be free, then a sheriff steps in and shoots the ropes, the player can move Hosea and the objective is to flee out of the area while holding his throat and fleeing and a cut scene when they grab the sheriff and hang him instead. Sad music plays after the death of the sheriff. 1876, Dutch and Hosea are arrested, they spent hours in a jail cell, they find a way out and before they escape, they tie the sheriff up on a chair. 1877, a young 14 year old Arthur is running around causing trouble to elderly folk. One day Dutch and Hosea go up to Arthur and introduce themselves, they offer him to join them. He agrees.
I have more so i will comment tomorrow with more story progression.
@@joshuamartinez7409I think it’s tomorrow lil bro
@@LeGmJames My son commented this.
This whole interaction hit me. I never knew my dads dad, because he died when my dad was little. And my kids will never know my dad because he died when I was little. Here’s hoping I can break that cycle 🤷🏼♂️
Arthur was such a deep, misunderstood character. Probably the best character rockstar has ever created. John wasn’t entirely complex but he did everything he could for his family. Both different, both great
John was the better character lmao you probably just never played the original 😂
@@StrItsSelf nah, I played the original and I disagree
@@StrItsSelf I wasn’t saying one was better or worse than the other fam. Just that they’re different. Arthur was much more complex than John, that’s just fact.
@@pup123434 yeah I feel that with the first RDR the whole game is kind of tailored towards the western gunslinger fantasy, all the outfits, challenges, music, characters all had the western movie feel, John was basically the lone wolf gunslinger for the most part becoming a legendary name, but RDR2 felt like it tried to be a more real setting, not the western movie fantasy (not saying it's bad) Arthur's character had the advantage of being surrounded by the gang and the hundreds of interactions and sides missions you could with them to get to know them better, the way you could interact with everyone with greet/antagonize system and the numerous lines Arthur just spat out made everyone feel alive. The whole story revolved around the death of the outlaw, civilization moving in and the slow deterioration of the gang and Arthur's attempts to try to prevent that and his failure to making him realize they can't go back and he especially can't with his diagnosis so he fights with who he is to try and change, his story and the journey he goes on is just more complicated than the first one because it's a more internal struggle with himself, John's is a little more surface level with try to save his family by taking out his past, but I will say that the cutscenes he does get with the gang in the first game did have some good writing, like with Dutch "we can't fight nature" the dialogue john would with the gang members in the first one set their characters but they were very vague with how everything went down and their actual relationship and the second one just fleshed everything out so much more
@@StrItsSelf bro have you never heard people can have different opinions?
Bro even died near the place where he said he wasn't going nowhere
Read my name🤨
He kept his promise but not in the way we wanted
In rdr 2 he get those scares from wolves and Arthur saves him and then in rdr 1 he still has them I wish both of them never died
guy under me is MAD over the REPLIES 💀💀💀💀💀
Morgan got betrayed by his so called father, Dutch.. and that is like a dagger between the shoulder blades.
what’s this gotta do with my boy john lmao?
@@juliandelao4570 the creator of this video commented “who had the saddest death in the red dead redemption series”
@@CaptainMonkefrJohn did. Johns death was a defining moment in gaming history.
Why so?
@@user-vd6me7ox6cWdym? How so?
Arthur was a caring man.
What that gotta do with john💀
He literally murder so many people 💀💀
@@basilplushie2534 me with low honour arthur because i was bored 💀
@@basilplushie2534 murdering people doesnt make you a bad person💀
@@daijonalexis4814 Yes it does, what are you insane?
To take bullets like a champ you gotta be made like steel
-some wise man-
When i play rdr1 and finish it, when i saw that john marston died is crazy really make me cry.
If you hear a character say “I ain’t goin nowhere” that means they’re going only six feet under
Read my name🤨
💀💀💀
@@glyxer7734 i didnt know they had an emoji of john
@@gonnacry5077 gawd 🤨📸
@@glyxer7734 gonna cry?
Arthurs death was sad but johns death was even sadder. Despite john turning a complete new leaf but still suffered the consequences of his past. That corrupt agent ross was never gonna let him go
Si lo vez de una perspectiva realista era un delincuente y asesino.
What Joh dies? Arthur too?
@@17MrLeon yea
And that's why jack ended him on the river while fishing.
John dies???
OG red dead we all miss it 😢
Why so?
This just hits different... I really felt sad after that...
RIP Aurther Morgan and John Marston, They were good at heart.🤠😭
Aurther 💀
Not really, they did very very terrible things in canon that are unforgivable, their demise was undeserved, but their past lives were evil
Arthur was truly good at heart
@@theslavecrusher5947 Arthur did it all becuase of Dutch , becuase Dutch manipulated him to kill and make money from the very start when he was a child, later on, when he found that he's gonna die and was terminally ill with TB, he gave this all up and preferred to do acts of love and care just like the nun at the station told him😌
@@PEACEMAKERS_OFFICIALdon't forget he said to Mary I've got some people I need to take care of and Arthur was loyal
Rdr 1 is the way of representing dad's going to buy milk
The credits were heartbreaking too even the mission when you propose to abigail and go for your photo taken
All I have to say, he was a great man always fighting for the right things he was better than a cowboy. He was a man he died for everything he’s standing for. God bless his wife and his children.
well.. sort of, his wife is dead lol.
He didn't actually go anywhere, he stayed there 😞
RIP John Marston
“When the time comes you gotta run and don't look back”
-Arthur Morgan
I just wish there were more duels in rdr2, feels like you can do one in every town in rdr1
Atleast they marston family got 12 years with eachother outside of the gang
More than most got
Edit: I’ve been having some minor back and forth in the comments and I’ll just get my point across here.
I’m a fan of the overall redemption series. And I like to have a conversation about every storyline and every character. So when people pop up only talking about 1 character. As an actual fan of the overall story and characters I just hope there was others who likes to discuss all of the elements and not the same 3 things
Arthur sacrifice earned that
@@Donbros can anything be said about the redemption series other than Arthur?
I’m a fan of the series overall me mate not just redemption 2. I like to talk about everything
@@r3idmcread212 They just made the point that Arthur’s sacrifice allowed John to escape
@@xxsaruman82xx87 yes I am aware of that. But it’s how nothing else can be spoke about.
I love the series have done from the start i love and understanding the characters more than most but I would like it if more people could talk about more aspects than 1 character or bit
Arthur’s sacrifice was a huge part of the redemption story and it’s awesome but I would like it if more would talk about other points about everything
@@r3idmcread212 then why not bring up the points in question? Easiest way to get the conversation going is to bring it up.
WW1 started
Ww1 started in 1914
So that’s what jack did the rest of his life fight to the death
@@Minecraftplayer72 i doubt they would've put outlaws in the military
@@gergopiroska5749 You'd be surprised.
@@gergopiroska5749 oh you naive little boy
John and jack's life is a sad sad story and even though John passed there's still potential for jack if they make a RDR 3
“He was like a brother to me.” -john marston
John got 4 years only, but in that 4 years he had lived more than someone in a lifetime.
I think u mean he lived more than any outlaw would in a lifetime. Regular civvies, no
Nah he got to spend like all of 1899-1911 with them if u think about it. It wasnt till 1911 that Ross made him start searching all over New Austin for Bill Javier and Dutch
Grandma said “don’t worry we’ll have those good times again” as I cried in her arms. 3 days later, 6am, mom got the news.
I’m so sorry!
Oh, that's so sad....😢😢
John is a good father he tried protecting everybody and he is still trying😭
They kid was raised well
"Yanopa, I wish i met Yerpa"
Read my name🤨
@@bahbah6 no one cares
@@bahbah6 no
Hi I’m back again
@@sandeepgill9975 lmao welcome back
Arthur was right…
„When the time comes, you gotta run and don’t look back“
Arthur Morgan was such a good character. I miss him so much.
One thing I have to say is that uncle’s death is extremely underrated. The guy was lazy and useless but in the end he died protecting the people he loved.
Careful with that spoiler lol most people nowadays haven't even played RDR1 😆
@@StrItsSelf it’s been out for a long time so it doesn’t really matter
@@StrItsSelf ive played both so he isnt spoiling anything😂
I was 15 when RDR came out 14 years ago and I haven’t played through it since but my god I can still remember how I felt when John died.. I had never seen a protagonist die in any form of media before.. to say I was gobsmacked is an understatement. It’s only now that I’m older that I can really understand how dirty they did him and after playing through RDR2 it just makes it feel all that more rotten.
People now only talk about fucking Arthur while this character was made and inspired by John Marston Kids nowadays don't know to enjoy good games like GTA 4 and RDR 1
Mr Morgan watching the sunrise
A moment of silence for Arthur as we see the hat John was wearing in 1907. 🙏🏿
I ain’t going nowhere
YET
R.I.P John marston a loving husband, and a good father😢
and a good friend..
I don’t really think he was a good father..
Arthur's death is definetly one of the saddest. 😢. I remember playing this game and this video is making me want to play it again.
This is John.. he had a much more impactful death
I've tried so many things to survive the last scene in the barn. I almost turned off my console before saving I was so destroyed. Really good story line, absolutely insane
I don’t know if this happened to you but when I tried to survive the agents I killed were shooting the rifle even tho they were dead in the cutscene lol. Man I even remember using the Mauser because there is 15 agents or something very close to it
@@squttle no, but I did manage to kill like seven of them. So if you think about it, the law in that county would be crippled for a long while. That thought at least made it better
@@justanotherDeth true that’s good. Wish you could save him lol
@@squttle for reals though, but that's a pretty good depiction of how it was. Real cool game
@@justanotherDeth That’s true, even to this day the government will use and throw away people like they did to Marston even if they help
Jack held him to it. Buried him right where he once stood and said "you ain't going nowhere"
Saddest part is in my playthrough when John said that he wasn't going anywhere a thunderstorm happened as he was saying that.
This scene didnt made me cry at first but when i played it again after playing rdr2 it all came crashing down
“I aint going nowhere “
Dies after 4 years😔😔
We failed you John, we couldn’t save you….😢
You can with enough time and modding
It really hurt when uncle said “your a sick man Arthur, a very sick man” while in Rhodes. RDR had always been good at foreshadowing
When Edgar Ross said "Your father killed himself with the life he lived" he was 100% right.
"IVE COME FOR YOU , ROSS!"
Might be the best video game line ever
If they don't make these games into movies, I'm gonna be upset.
No its deserve to only game
It's just that. Movies will never capture the escence as entirely as the games.
Games have infinitely more time. That's the only reason these games were able to convey this much emotion.
@NoahCanFB very true. Maybe it would work better as a series
I think it'd be better as a series season 1 (Red Harlow) Season 2 (John Marston) Season 3 (Arthur Morgan) perfect trilogy
Man,John wearing Arthur’s hat hits hard
John death made me even more sad, he was pure soul and trying best for his family and sacrificed in the end.
“I ain’t going nowhere.”
He says this before he dies too
Bro Jack had by far the hardest life in the Red Dead series. Everyone who he grew up with left. He lost his parents, Uncle, found out his dad died because of killing Micah. Then we never even see what becomes of him🤧. Truly tragic
So true man so true
Im not dead! (This is a joke. I know this is a red dead redemption video.)
Uncle does in the undead nightmare. I believe and its said
we all know the lumbago took uncle
@@MicahKGamingWdym? Are you Jack Marston?
Bro I cried my eyes out when this happened
"I ain't goin nowhere"
--Every dad of 2023
The fact he was able to stand for just that short amount of time after being shot that much is incredible
He's just broken just like the rest of us..... 😢
Brk Rockstar is so good at making masterpieces
He wasn't going anywhere, Marston stuck himself deep into the roots of that place.. ._.
When I first heard this, I immediately cried because I lost my dad when I was no older than Jack is in this video. Thats my worst fear if I ever become a father. I want my boy to know his Dad and be proud of me. Jack really deserves his own game.
Sounds good but where would the story go with him. He never lived that life, no reason to follow his father's footsteps cause he saw where that lead
I don't know if RDR3 can match our expectations anymore, we lived through some good times
When the word grandfather doesn't exist:
I remembered playing this when I was younger and it made me realize how much I’d miss my dad when he’s gone.
I replayed red dead redemption last month. still brings me to tears.
And the most sad, it’s what Jack will end like his dad, gang don’t want to make Jack a murder and a robber like them, but at the final we see, what Jack stay like them…
a masterpiece, rdr series for me is the monalisa of the modern era
Bro what are you smoking lmao
@@nob9705 high on life
wait until GPT is added - west world is almost here
He kept his promise though. He didn't go no nowhere.
Until he left for 80 percent of rdr1
@@Fortnitedog1236 yeah but he was kinda forced to go away a little while because of the government wanting him to kill bill, javier, and Dutch
Everyone always talks abt Arthur’s death but John literally went through 3 journeys deeper and deeper into hell having to kill some of his pals in the process so he could get his family back only to be killed right after along with the man who raised him after his father
"i ain't going nowhere"...
John and Arthur have the most sad death Arthur because of how he ended and John because even though he wasn't the best father and husband he loved them and would do anything to save them
Most disturbing death in video game lore. None of us were expecting that.
Who else reloaded that mission 5 times trying to save John ✋️
I’ve never played RDR but this video made me Cry as much as all of you guys did
"Evil people make broken people. Broken people make evil people."
preach 🙏
John and Uncle, dying Protecting people they Loved, still gives me the chills😢
😂
“For once in your life be a god damn man”
Arthur 1899
Imagine just being with your father and having fun but, your father dies in horrible way I would cry all day.💔
I think Eagle had a sad death but John and Arthor were good men in bad situations, they had good hearts and wanted to make their lives better. Sad how they gave everything for others dreams, at least John got out before he died
John Marston a loving father and one of the best gunslingers
Im so glad i got to experience rdr1 without any spoilers and that moment had me reloading saves with tears in my eyes. Even though arthurs death was sad you knew from the start that he was gonna depart at some point and halfway you learn how and why and you could prepare. John on the other hand did everything right and you think youre working towards a wholesome ending for john and his fam and all of the sudden there is the government there to destroy another family, killing john and turning jack from a gifted kid to a outlaw
I have beatin that game and cried for 4 days because he died by 7 guys rest in peace
I feel really bad Jack, he pretty much watched them all die😔✋
Is that Jack Sparrow in your profile picture?!
@@TheFunnyDictator yes?
@@Vipex_XS Who do you like better, Jack Sparrow or Jack Marston?
@@TheFunnyDictator Jack Sparrow
@@Vipex_XS Are you Indian like me, lad?
🗣:its just a game
When Arthur died: ........
When john died: .......
When lenny died: .......
Idk why but Johns death is just a little sadder than Arthurs if you played RDR1 as a kid then played RDR2 epilogue as an adult, then replay RDR1, it just makes Johns story so much more impactful and knowing that he died almost at the same age as Arthur just hurts bro. At least jack got a good 6-7 years with his dad😢
If a video game character promised they're not gonna leave them or mentioned the ladies, it's a hint that they're going to die
“I ain’t going nowhere” *proceeds to fucking die in 4 years and leaves home for 70% of rdr1*