Many talented artists sang their versions of this song. Joseph Busto was so great and made it really popular to young ones who are not that familiar with SG Wannabe. So Hyang, Solji, EXO's Xiumin, Chen and Baekhyun sang this nicely. But for me, the best version is the original version of SG Wannabe, with Chae Dong Ha. Let us not hate. This is a very emotional song and all artists who sang this gave justice. 😊
In fact, SG WANNABE is the original group of the song..stop comparing them with Joseph.. I knew if they were not sing this song,then Joseph will never know the song as well..sorry for my bad eng..it not my mother's tongue
they're the reason why Joseph know about this wonderful song let's be honest they are the first inspiration give them their respect, but Joseph is great too I keep listen to his ,
true, joseph sang this song better than most of us...but u shouldn't compared him whenever u guys watch original singer sang this song...every performance had difference environments...let's see how u compare joseph's version with kim jin ho's immortal songs performance of this song...jin ho's performance very amazing and simply hearbreaking...joseph is amazing, but no need to compare him with original singer...there is no reason too since this song itself already an amazing song, so we should respect them both
I don’t know why you’re so mad about it. I just listened to Joseph’s song and I was so curious of this song because it sounded so beautiful. He did a great job by bringing out this song again to us. And we came to know about this song. This is song is amazing and thanks to Joseph for letting us know about this song. I love this song very much now.
No matter what version it is, no one can beat Kim Jin Ho’s voice🔥❤️ Full with emotion, u can hear sadness, angry and comfort in his voice. As long as he is the one singing Saldaga either solo or with Sg Wannabe, it will always be Freaking perfect😍🔥❤️❤️!!
It's the way SG Wannabe sang, it's their style, and it seems they got such a bad mic? The best version of "As We Live" was sang by SG Wannabe's Kim Jin Ho on Immortal Song 2 (it was like a comeback stage for Kim Jin Ho who take a hiatus for a while). Not saying Joseph version was bad, he's good. But if you wanted to see the best version of As We Live, I suggested the Immortal Song 2 Kim Jin Ho's version. Solji's version also one of my favorite.
I totally agree with Yasmine Rachmania. Check out the very emotional version sang by Kim Jin-ho, in his comeback performance on Immortal Song 2: czcams.com/video/P6IXyHIxERo/video.html
Why I love ballad songs, is because many people can relate to it. SG Wannabe not only sang, they delivered the emotion as well. And every singer has different way of delivery emotion into the song and different voices. That’s why this version hit me harder than others.
it's a really good song and all versions of it ,is great but my favorite version is the performances that include Chae dong ha❤😢 his voice is wow it's a big lost that he is not hear any more
some people keep on saying that other versions are better than the original. i know its your opinion but can you at least respect the original singers? maybe some fans here dont even know what this song means to SG WANNABE. If you like the other version then dont watch this. but at least respect SG WANNABE and dont say that " *insert name* was better that the original".
I don't know why this version of sg wannabe for saldaga is not that great. But this title on youtube sounds alot better and more original. "SG Wannabe Saldaga live". This is by far the best version of their song. Performance is also way better and more emotional. Don't know why that is. Are these 2 videos way different in timeline?
Stop saying that Joseph brought you here, seriously nobody cares...that kid did a good job, but he could never bring out the same emotions SG Wannabe does, especially Kim Jin Ho. And if you're not aware of the feelings and memories they get singing this song, don't go around saying baseless things like "Joseph sang it better than the original singers" cuz that's not even close to being true. And as a SG Wannabe fan that came here to enjoy this wonderful performance of a song i really love, i find comments like that annoying and offensive...
Unlike us who already known them, there are plenty others who have yet to discover this gem. So isn't it a great blessing that Joseph has introduced a new community that didn't know who SG wannabe was to their awesome music?
she cannot accept the fact. nobody saying this guys version was not good. but i believe if u heard joseph version, u get more feeling on that sad love song. what so big deal if other people can sing the song better than original singer? The new arrangement of music & joseph deep feeling makes the song more fresh. wasn't that good?
if you liked the Joseph version you must to see Kim Jin ho singing on immortal song 2.... it was the most touched song that I ever hear.... sorry for my bad English!!
@@eternityashley Murió uno de los ex integrantes del grupo, David, se suicidó después de dejar el grupo. Deseaba ser solista y actor, pero se suicidó 😭
wow. after seeing the exchange student smash a cover. I just had to see the original. I don't understand what they are saying but I know good music. wow
Lagu ni sendiri ada memori tertentu antara cha dong ha dan sg wannabe..tolong respect the original...mungkin versi ni x sama dgn versi yg asal...tpi mereka tetap terbaik..
Me encantan SGW estupendas voces,separadas y unidas una Maravilla y esta canción preciosa aún sin saber su letra en Español, ojalá alguien leyera éste mensaje, es el deseo de muchas fans Latinas que alguien las tradujera,seria para nosotras increíble Gracias por el Regalo de sus voces Éxitos Felicidades ♡♡♡☆☆☆ 8/5/2020
Kim Jin Ho sang the hell out of this on Immortal Songs and other solo performances - even the show where the audience had to guess who was the real singer between him and 2 other hidden singers was better than this. This is not one of the band's best renditions as a collective (see older performances) - an off night I guess.
"SG Wannabe Saldaga live" search that on youtube. That is their best original version. Yes this version is not that great. The other version, it'll take you flying to the moon.
Omfg nobody cares that joseph brought you here...also dont say that he sang it better because you most likely haven't checked out kim jinho's performance on immortal song 2. If you haven't already DO IT NOW
arabella no one cares if Joseph brought you here..but check out___? The originals sung the song wonderfully and so did Joseph. Videos go viral and bring us to the original. SG Wannabe song was so great it brought people from around the world to figure out who was the originals. Hush and let everyone sing.
Obviously Joseph also did very well... But you can't compare it with the original version.. Original version will always be the original one.. Nobody can ever beat the original version.. not even god...
![SG WANNABE - Partner For Life / Lalala / Love You [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Af5Kwd5JhDA/mqdefault.jpg)
![SG WANNABE - Partner For Life / Lalala / Love You [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](/img/tr.png)
Many talented artists sang their versions of this song. Joseph Busto was so great and made it really popular to young ones who are not that familiar with SG Wannabe. So Hyang, Solji, EXO's Xiumin, Chen and Baekhyun sang this nicely. But for me, the best version is the original version of SG Wannabe, with Chae Dong Ha. Let us not hate. This is a very emotional song and all artists who sang this gave justice. 😊
That’s true
Joseph made me like this song
Then Exo also performed it with Xiumin high note
In fact, SG WANNABE is the original group of the song..stop comparing them with Joseph.. I knew if they were not sing this song,then Joseph will never know the song as well..sorry for my bad eng..it not my mother's tongue
they're the reason why Joseph know about this wonderful song
let's be honest they are the first inspiration give them their respect, but Joseph is great too I keep listen to his ,
Wee??
Salgada cover from joseb not bad... Good voice ..
Joseph sing better
true, joseph sang this song better than most of us...but u shouldn't compared him whenever u guys watch original singer sang this song...every performance had difference environments...let's see how u compare joseph's version with kim jin ho's immortal songs performance of this song...jin ho's performance very amazing and simply hearbreaking...joseph is amazing, but no need to compare him with original singer...there is no reason too since this song itself already an amazing song, so we should respect them both
I don’t know why you’re so mad about it. I just listened to Joseph’s song and I was so curious of this song because it sounded so beautiful. He did a great job by bringing out this song again to us. And we came to know about this song. This is song is amazing and thanks to Joseph for letting us know about this song. I love this song very much now.
*NO MATTER WHAT PEOPLE SAY THIS IS THE BEST VERSION OF THE SONG*
Awwww nope!!
I prefer Solji version, but that's great too!
Stop this guys, Exo's version will always be the best. 😂💪
Cbx version is the best 😂
Joumana Hassan sry but are you Guys kidding me? They're the original Artists and Jinhos Performance on Immortal Songs is just breathtaking
누구하나 노래로는 빠지지않음
멋지다
Kim Jin ho makes me cry every time he sings this song!!! So beautiful 😭😭
No matter what version it is, no one can beat Kim Jin Ho’s voice🔥❤️
Full with emotion, u can hear sadness, angry and comfort in his voice.
As long as he is the one singing Saldaga either solo or with Sg Wannabe, it will always be Freaking perfect😍🔥❤️❤️!!
It's the way SG Wannabe sang, it's their style, and it seems they got such a bad mic? The best version of "As We Live" was sang by SG Wannabe's Kim Jin Ho on Immortal Song 2 (it was like a comeback stage for Kim Jin Ho who take a hiatus for a while).
Not saying Joseph version was bad, he's good. But if you wanted to see the best version of As We Live, I suggested the Immortal Song 2 Kim Jin Ho's version. Solji's version also one of my favorite.
Sohyang is better
Yasmine Rachmania Jinho's version is seriously the best. It always brings me to tears. His singing was A+
Yeah solji bring me here
I totally agree with Yasmine Rachmania. Check out the very emotional version sang by Kim Jin-ho, in his comeback performance on Immortal Song 2: czcams.com/video/P6IXyHIxERo/video.html
I agree with you
Why I love ballad songs, is because many people can relate to it. SG Wannabe not only sang, they delivered the emotion as well. And every singer has different way of delivery emotion into the song and different voices. That’s why this version hit me harder than others.
놀면 뭐하니 보고 온사람?ㅋ
명곡 중에 명곡 살다가 세월이 흘러도 가슴이 먹먹 해지고 내 자신이 힘들때 자주듣는. 노래 Sg워너비 보고싶네요
it's a really good song and all versions of it ,is great but my favorite version is the performances that include Chae dong ha❤😢
his voice is wow it's a big lost that he is not hear any more
some people keep on saying that other versions are better than the original. i know its your opinion but can you at least respect the original singers? maybe some fans here dont even know what this song means to SG WANNABE. If you like the other version then dont watch this. but at least respect SG WANNABE and dont say that " *insert name* was better that the original".
I don't know why this version of sg wannabe for saldaga is not that great. But this title on youtube sounds alot better and more original. "SG Wannabe Saldaga live". This is by far the best version of their song. Performance is also way better and more emotional. Don't know why that is. Are these 2 videos way different in timeline?
@@InfiniteBeingX ㅇ쇼
The original is the best. Lastest live performance is in Hangout with you.. love them. Break my heart everytime hearing this song 😭
exactly. i love their latest version on the hangout with yoo the most!
Stop saying that Joseph brought you here, seriously nobody cares...that kid did a good job, but he could never bring out the same emotions SG Wannabe does, especially Kim Jin Ho. And if you're not aware of the feelings and memories they get singing this song, don't go around saying baseless things like "Joseph sang it better than the original singers" cuz that's not even close to being true. And as a SG Wannabe fan that came here to enjoy this wonderful performance of a song i really love, i find comments like that annoying and offensive...
the truth is I came here because that kid! deal with it
And you just feel the need to brag about it???? Did anyone ask you how you got here? Watch the performance and move on.
IMHO Solji sang it better
Unlike us who already known them, there are plenty others who have yet to discover this gem. So isn't it a great blessing that Joseph has introduced a new community that didn't know who SG wannabe was to their awesome music?
she cannot accept the fact. nobody saying this guys version was not good. but i believe if u heard joseph version, u get more feeling on that sad love song. what so big deal if other people can sing the song better than original singer? The new arrangement of music & joseph deep feeling makes the song more fresh. wasn't that good?
still get goosebumps eveytime listen this song
+Anh Võ I know right same here!
Only real SG Wannabe fans can really appreciate this song. RIP Chae Dong Ha. Love Lee Seok Hoon, Jin Ho, Yong Jun. =)
The original will always be greater. One of the most emotional songs ever. Awesome song, awesome voices
이노래는 원조sg워너비가 최강임ㄹㅇ
ㅇㅈ...
아직도 이딴 댓글이있네 머저리새끼들
이석훈 사랑한다 제발 이런 댓글 보지말고 노래해🙏🙏🙏 김용준 김진호 이석훈♥♥♥♥ +김용준 김진호 이석훈은 sg wanna be이고 원조야♥♥♥ 사랑한다 삼햄들♥♥♥ 절대 노래해 마이크 잡아♥♥♥♥이석훈김용준김진호채동하
이석훈김용준김진호채동하 함께해♥ 사햄들♥♥
마지막 살다가에 김진호 손 떨리는거 봐라 와....
this classic.... is still heart-wrenching even in 2015
I feel bitter because I miss Chae Dongha. ... it's not the same without him... but still in love with this song and group... thanks for coming back ❤
i feel like crying
EXO CBX brought me here, even though I love their version, this one is amazing too!! Plus I love Xiu's high note!
if you liked the Joseph version you must to see Kim Jin ho singing on immortal song 2.... it was the most touched song that I ever hear.... sorry for my bad English!!
Sol Suiffet what is the title of the song. I want to listen to it..
+MsJirel it's called immortal songs 2 Kim Jin ho As We Live
yes.kim jin ho in immortal songs make me cried all night and i keep repeat saldaga.especially at the part when chae don ha appeared in the screen.
이때 노래부르는 창법이 다 특이하네...
제목에 적혀있는건 영상 업로드 날짜이고 방송일은 110416 M SOUND PLEX 입니다 (110402 녹화)
동하님이 살아있을 당시 녹화네요 ㅠㅠ
This song make me wanna cry. Amazing!
lol i just found out this song when the dumb trio from moms diary sing it and i kinda like itttt
I really love this song, so talented people in Korea, so many beautiful and joyful voices
Chenbaekxi brought me here.
Nicole Logrono sameee
Same
Annyira szeretem SG WANNABE -t! Olyan érdekesen szép hangjuk van! Sokat hallgatom őket! Nagyon jó dalaik vannak!❤️❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏👍
Amazing performance
I literally love this song
very good
정말 아름다운 노래
r.i.p chae dongha
i already know this song last year
Which guy died? I just heard this on another show. Such a sad song 😢😢
@@eternityashley chae dong ha
@@eternityashley Murió uno de los ex integrantes del grupo, David, se suicidó después de dejar el grupo. Deseaba ser solista y actor, pero se suicidó 😭
@@eternityashley former member of Sg wannabe
still in love with sg wannabe and this song.
Every time they sing dong ha part it just make the song even sadder RIP dong ha
So Hyang bring me here. . . the original studio version sound amazing, but cant deny so hyang cover it pretty powerfyll :)
SG wannabe history , i love this song
살다가 살다가 살다가 너 힘들때~
EXO-CBX brought me here. Just. WOW 😱
same here!???😊
Este chico lleva en su sangre la musica en todas sus presentaciones le pone corazon y canta muy hermoso bendiciones Kim Jin Ho
Sgwanabe the best band in korea❤️❤️🙏🙏 respect
Best korean band
wow. after seeing the exchange student smash a cover. I just had to see the original. I don't understand what they are saying but I know good music. wow
I've seen many people cover this song and I've just seen the original artists. This is the only version that has made me emotional. They are amazing
sg wannabe was always ob my mind....nothings comes close to them...salute from Malaysia....
Oh, that group still exists! Congrats.
KIM JIN HO!!!
Joseph Butso !!! yes he a rnb Carisma in sing voice thats why its a awesome how he sings :) but its so amazing, the original is good too
A musica toda é uma emoção, mais esse cantor principal canta com o coração
Lagu ni sendiri ada memori tertentu antara cha dong ha dan sg wannabe..tolong respect the original...mungkin versi ni x sama dgn versi yg asal...tpi mereka tetap terbaik..
Kan.. dan maybe arrangement muzik tak sama. Sbb ni main dgn live band.
this gives church vibes with the music and the high notes
Me encantan SGW estupendas voces,separadas y unidas una Maravilla y esta canción preciosa aún sin saber su letra en Español, ojalá alguien leyera éste mensaje, es el deseo de muchas fans Latinas que alguien las tradujera,seria para nosotras increíble Gracias por el Regalo de sus voces Éxitos Felicidades ♡♡♡☆☆☆ 8/5/2020
우와..
ألاغنية رائعه عميق احبهاااا كتيير مميذه واصواتهم كمان رائعه رائعه 🤧🥺🥺🥺🥺
눈물 나버림
i got to see this coz i'm curious about the song that Joshep sang last night..
same :)
Same 😂
Same 😂
Lol Me Too :)
The hardest song to sing because of the very sad lyrics😢
Dongha's part .... So sad ....
sohyang brought me here hihi
I like the Old style of this song... The team it's not complete whithout shae dong ha
I just wanna say , i love you.... ❤️💚💜💙👏🏻
Hi...im. from indonesia 🇮🇩
I still cry Everytime I hear this don't
😧
Awesome👏
This is why jeon wonwoo loves SG Wannabe sunbaenim👏
Wow I like it thanks seventeen
Exo cbx brought me here. I respect original version!
Kim Jin Ho sang the hell out of this on Immortal Songs and other solo performances - even the show where the audience had to guess who was the real singer between him and 2 other hidden singers was better than this. This is not one of the band's best renditions as a collective (see older performances) - an off night I guess.
I love this song so much !!
😭why I cry
"SG Wannabe Saldaga live" search that on youtube. That is their best original version. Yes this version is not that great. The other version, it'll take you flying to the moon.
amazing voice
kim jin ho is the best 😍
와... 김진호.. 👍
Wow i didnt know Eugene from buzzfeed sang!
Omfg nobody cares that joseph brought you here...also dont say that he sang it better because you most likely haven't checked out kim jinho's performance on immortal song 2. If you haven't already DO IT NOW
arabella no one cares if Joseph brought you here..but check out___? The originals sung the song wonderfully and so did Joseph. Videos go viral and bring us to the original. SG Wannabe song was so great it brought people from around the world to figure out who was the originals. Hush and let everyone sing.
얼마전 k팝스타를 봤는데 거기서 박진영 심사위원이 그런말 하더군요. 과도하게 몸짓과 목소릴 내는 참가자에게. "본인은 자기 목소리가 듣기 좋을까?" 라고. 지금 갑자기 그런 생각이 드네요.
ok, you're here for being TEAM BANDWAGON guys.... we get it
how great joseph make it this song possible to sing by only him
They especially his (main vocal) voice has faded. Unfortunately but time can change that.
Obviously Joseph also did very well... But you can't compare it with the original version.. Original version will always be the original one.. Nobody can ever beat the original version.. not even god...
I would not compare any version cause great original that why remaster one also impressive.
^^ SG is the best
Joseph Butso brought
me here
and missed soundplex so much
Kereeeeeeennnn from INDONESIA
yes joseph busto was good, but nothing will beat the original.
Masterpiece
Xiumins high note anyone??
Joseph Busto brought me here!
same !!!
me too
me too \o/
same here
same here
왠지 이 노래가 고 채동하님의 한이 사무친 노래 같습니다 끼워맞추자면 노래가사도 그렇고 채동하님이 노래 부르실때도 보면...너무 안타깝습니다
-대단-
hermosa cancion ♡♡♡
Miss Dongha
놀면뭐하니 보고오신분…?🙌🏻
이석훈은 확실히 이 노래에 잘 안 묻네.
Exo CBX brought me here ☺
wow
EXO CBX brought me here
Prefer Joseph Busto's version .. the delivery is much smoother .. and i feel this song should be sang by 1 person its more seamless.
You should watch forestella version
yes it's true that the original is is unique but for me I love the fake one by Joseph
I wish I can understand the lyrics