Years ago I worked for a government department. The unofficial motto was "we have to be seen to be doing something". Actually doing something, let alone doing it competently, was a secondary concern at best. Watching this show brings back so many memories.
Dr. Thomas Sowell was a communist before working in the U.S. State Department. Running into the same situations as you did, and coming up with solutions that nobody was interested in, he started looking for evidence that his own beliefs led to anything good. Discovering quite the opposite, he became a capitalist, convinced of the incompetency of governments and the idiocy of intellectuals.
It's been forty years, and any of the political tricks in this series are still being used today. And they will be in the forty years to come. Amazing series, thanks for uploading!
Truly a timeless TV series. Still see everything happening today as it did back then. At least back then they were more competent at coving up their incompetentcy
I dimly remember reading that John Cleese was sounded out to play Humphrey. Back then, in my teens, I was a fan of Terry Thomas and thought that he too would have made a great Humphrey. And Norman Wisdom as Hacker? Delicious!
“Has it ever struck you that life is all memory, except for the one present moment that goes by you so quick you hardly catch it going?”― Tennessee Williams..................
That's what you expect from pioneer of comedy! along with industrial revolution, many many dark yet innovative deeds! Don't mind my dark but honest humour guys! Much respect to English nation! Salute!
I'm currently re-reading my aunt's hardback copy of Yes Minister. Must be the seventh or eighth time. I'm also lucky enough to have watched both shows in three countries. When enacted, the humour hits so much quicker and is so much ticklier, what with the actors' expressions and all.
I stumbled across a random comment elsewhere about this magnificent show and this is my first viewing. Very impressed! This is close to what we have in the U.S. but, we can waste more money AND screw over the workers at the same time.
Seeing Hacker loose his mind when Humphry tells him the long list of reasons as to why the staff are there, all the while ignoring that actually the real reason as to why there is no actual medical staff at the hospital is because of decisions made by other departments which he has no direct control over because the thought of him not being in control terrified him, is quite entertaining. He is like an ignorant glory-addicted child: he doesn't want to accept that he just doesn't want to take the time and effort to understand why the hospital isn't opened he only cares about what the simple-minded popular people who criticise him say, and so he stamps his feet in impatience and when it all comes back to bite him later on he panics.
Since India became a colony of East India company first and then when British monarch took over its administration by having the ICS until its independence in1947.After which India Indianized the ICS to UPSC .The governance of our civil servants at the highest echelons of government is much worse. Having introduced the infamous quota system which selects these civil servants not by merit but by quotas.Which the British would certainly not done in India. I myself have given this exam ,choosing Indian Foreign service as the first choice, but also sat for post graduation in English literature.But even in our academic system the quota system appears. And this infamous quota system is there not only for 5 or 10 years after our independence but has got entrenched in our academic institutions without redemption.
*Why have you zoomed in so much as to cut more than half the original footage in view? This is awful, and completely ruins what was (and still is) a great series.*
@@samsowden You mean there are *still* conspiracy theories floating around regarding _"Fair Usage Policy"_ under International Copyright Laws Sam? That's incredible! CZcams stopped using *ALL* algorithms to detect illegal breaches of copyright, way back in May 2016, when the UK and US governments agreed to a joint fair use policy. Then I think Australia, Canada and Japan signed up to it next, followed eventually by the rest of the world with very few exceptions, most notably China, North Korea and some of the smaller African countries. All anyone has to do to comply these days, is acknowledge who owns the original copyright in the info beneath the video if known. In other words, avoid claiming it to be there own property. So you, I, or anyone else could upload full HD episodes of _"Yes Minister"_ to CZcams *as long as* we acknowledge in the written blurb underneath, that the copyright of the material is still owned by the BBC. Sorry to be so long-winded, but I hope that's clarified things for you? Take care.
@@DrAnne-mc8er I was a WW II child and graduated from Edinburgh in 1965. We were taught courtesy to strangers throughout my education.. We are all strangers on the internet. so please be polite please explain the radio to tv comparison . We must make the best of what we can get free. Otherwise read the books.
Yes, change the playback speed to .75. Also, the screen ratio should be reduced, as mentioned, and the canned laughter made me stop watching what should have been an enjoyable show bu alas, t not so. I will watch something else.
I have posted information below. It is from Wikipedia, so take with a grain of salt. They are usually broadly correct, although there may be incorrect details. This always has been very interesting to me, (The British Prime Minister's abode.), as our President's Official Residence is The Élysée Palace on the Champs-Élysées, 8th arrondissement and the French Premier, (Our PM.), lives at The Hôtel de Matignon in Paris, located in the 7th arrondissement, just south of the Champs-Élysées, and both residences sound a bit Posh. The British PM sounds like he lives just up the street and commoners can just drop round for a spot of tea and a biscuit! Probably not, but I'll just imagine Boris sharing a pint with a constituent. -1-8 Downing Street were the houses between Number 9 and Whitehall that were taken over by the government and demolished in 1824 to allow the construction of the Privy Council Office, Board of Trade and Treasury offices. -9 Downing Street, named in 2001, is the Downing Street entrance to the Privy Council Office and houses the Department for Exiting the European Union. (Booo! That's me, the girl making this comment, not Wikipedia, sorry. We'll miss you Brits and Scots, Welsh and N. Irish.) It was formerly part of Number 10. -10 Downing Street is the official residence of the First Lord of the Treasury, the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. The two roles have been filled by the same person since the 1720s with almost no exceptions. It has fulfilled this role since 1735. Originally three houses, Number 10 was offered to Sir Robert Walpole by King George II in 1732 and now contains approximately 100 rooms. A private residence occupies the third floor and there is a kitchen in the basement. The other floors contain offices and conference, reception, sitting and dining rooms where the Prime Minister works, and where government ministers, national leaders and foreign dignitaries are met and entertained. At the rear is an interior courtyard and a terrace overlooking a garden of 0.5 acres (2,000 m2). Other residents of 10 Downing Street are the Spouse of the Prime Minister and family, Downing Street Director of Communications and Chief Mouser to the Cabinet Office. -11 Downing Street has been the official residence of the Second Lord of the Treasury, the Chancellor of the Exchequer since 1828. The residence was built alongside the official residence of the Prime Minister at Number 10 in 1682. -12 Downing Street, formerly the Chief Whip's Office, houses the Prime Minister's Press Office, Strategic Communications Unit and Information and Research Unit. In the 1820s it was occupied by the Judge Advocate-General, although it remained in private ownership. It entered government hands when purchased by the East India Company in 1863, and was occupied by the marine and railway departments of the Board of Trade. It was badly damaged by fire in 1879, and underwent further changes. -13 Downing Street was originally part of 12 Downing Street before the housing area was partially re-built and re-numbered in 1876. -14 Downing Street formerly closed off the western end of the street. It was leased as a town house from 1723 to 1797. It was acquired by the Crown in 1798, and was used by the War Office and Colonial Office in the 19th century. Some parts were demolished in the 1860s, and by 1876 it had been removed completely. -15-20 Downing Street, long since demolished, were at one time houses leading up to Horse Guards Road. -15-16 formerly housed the Foreign Office, which also occupied two houses on the south side of the street. -18 was occupied by the West India Department of the Colonial Office -20 was occupied by the Tithe Commission.
You're right, it shouldn't be...on the other hand where it isn't cropped and sped up you have to pay for the privilege, so just mark this under beggars can't be choosers
They are trying to beat the CZcams contentID system. Honestly if you don't want to pay for it (is it on BritBox?) there are better places to locate it.
@@mygaffer Yes, I have the choice to watch a video, or not. If it is well done, I will, if it is a butchered mess then I won't, and not my fault if the channel loses viewers, and income from YT. I have seen the series elsewhere, once when these episodes came on on TV, and years later on other web sites.........for free as well...:) But if you like watching rubbish videos, then that is your choice, and hope you enjoy them...:)
Ah, you do know that this show is over 40 years old right? It's a tape no such thing as digital back then. Or are you just whining for the sake of it? This was pre recorded you idiot.
Donna Evans hey I am not an idiot!! I just made a comment and you are so very rude! ( I am being very, very polite in my reply- which I actually do not intend to be taken as a true response ). Don’t be so silly!
orlando098 the video is cropped and has a vignette with the aim to circumvent the copyright bots of CZcams with the aim to avoid the video to be taken down.
@Ruth Collins 🤣😂😅 you are very _very_ stupid aren't you? This has been magnified and fucked about with unnecessarily. It's not a matter of when it was made. I saw these when they first came out. If you have a copy all you have to do is upload it! Not fuck with it. P.s. I think you should go and live in scunthorpe
Years ago I worked for a government department. The unofficial motto was "we have to be seen to be doing something". Actually doing something, let alone doing it competently, was a secondary concern at best. Watching this show brings back so many memories.
Any other institution would change management.
@@dadikkedude so true. But the problem was everyone had become accustomed to the idea that one could never get fired from a government job.
Was it the Department of Administrative Affairs, by any chance?
A department is not evaluated on results, it's evaluated on activity.
{:o:O:}
Dr. Thomas Sowell was a communist before working in the U.S. State Department. Running into the same situations as you did, and coming up with solutions that nobody was interested in, he started looking for evidence that his own beliefs led to anything good. Discovering quite the opposite, he became a capitalist, convinced of the incompetency of governments and the idiocy of intellectuals.
It's been forty years, and any of the political tricks in this series are still being used today.
And they will be in the forty years to come.
Amazing series, thanks for uploading!
Forty
@@MrGranfield
Hah! Live and learn.
Thanks!
@@jairkerker2821 I know you would do the same for me lol.
In my country too
@@vim1000
Would that be Sri Lanka?
Perfect comedy, much of which is still frighteningly relevant. Sir Humphrey’s speeches highlighted the brilliance of Sir Nigel Hawthorne.
Truly a timeless TV series. Still see everything happening today as it did back then. At least back then they were more competent at coving up their incompetentcy
The award for most hygienic hospital reminds me of a cheese shop uncontaminated by cheese.
Best British comedy ever, I love it..
Comedy? As a former civil servant, I can assure you that this is a documentary.
@@Phriday13th😂😂😂
@@Phriday13thThat has always as I saw it.
My dad used to love this show along with Fawlty Towers! A nostalgic trip down memory lane! :)
I dimly remember reading that John Cleese was sounded out to play Humphrey. Back then, in my teens, I was a fan of Terry Thomas and thought that he too would have made a great Humphrey.
And Norman Wisdom as Hacker? Delicious!
I own the full DVD set and rewatch about every two years. Brilliant TV.
It remains as sparkling relevant today as it was 40 years ago.
Yes. Frighteningly so.
Best Political Documentary ever made.
Shame half the picture was missing!
“Has it ever struck you that life is all memory, except for the one present moment that goes by you so quick you hardly catch it going?”― Tennessee Williams..................
Classic episode. Classic series. They don't make TV like this anymore, sadly.
Thank god for DVD's!
Great show.
Change the playback speed to 0.75 in settings and it's perfect!!!
TY!
Yes, baby!
The driver was "The Common Man" acting the nuisance and asking uncomfortable questions.
"I didn't get where I am today by opening hospitals for the benefit of patients!". CJ!
LOL. I have been watching Reginald Perrin lately.
That's what you expect from pioneer of comedy! along with industrial revolution, many many dark yet innovative deeds! Don't mind my dark but honest humour guys!
Much respect to English nation! Salute!
Brilliant!
Brilliant! I love this series.
This is definitely one of my favorite Hacker episode's lol.
Read the BBC Paperback book of Yes Minister and Yes Prime Minister ( second hand) I reread it all the time. Useful indeed in New Zealand
I'm currently re-reading my aunt's hardback copy of Yes Minister. Must be the seventh or eighth time. I'm also lucky enough to have watched both shows in three countries.
When enacted, the humour hits so much quicker and is so much ticklier, what with the actors' expressions and all.
At 4:15 approx: "How are we supposed to govern responsibly if backbenchers get all the facts?"
The NHS is a galloping bureaucracy says the minister, Humphrey say no Minister it is a gentle canter at the most ,fine use of phraseology.
Who is still watching this during Covid? The best thing.
been watching for pass 40 years odd years!
The best 3 acters together with outstanding script writhers
I stumbled across a random comment elsewhere about this magnificent show and this is my first viewing. Very impressed! This is close to what we have in the U.S. but, we can waste more money AND screw over the workers at the same time.
We’ve come a long way since the 80s.
One of the most realistic episode of the series
Ah yes, compassionate
Thank you so much!
Wonderful, thanks Kyle
Thank you! Xxx
Fantastic documentary.....
Cheers Kyle..
Sir Humphrey,” no, no, it’s to make everybody better.”
You would think this was the NHS today.
Certainly in the Covid outbreak! Hancock announcing things that hadn't even launched repeatedly
Just discovered rhis thanks to British boyfriend.
So funny and still so true!
I have no knowledge of the document which the honorable member is brandishin
His face at 2:31. Priceless
Made In The BBC Classics.
And nothing has changed...
Still a better healthcare system than what we Americans have…
What speed was this recoeded at its too fast .
Try playing at .75 speed instead of normal
They speak in the English manner. A lot faster than some other groups
Administrative staff and no doctors and nurses no patients but don't worry about it😂😂😂 administration is more important than healing the sick😅😅
Im in government OMG no comment
It's lucky that I am listening to this while playing PC games, instead of watching. I need to slow the speed down, though.
{:o:O:}
Government at "work"
Seeing Hacker loose his mind when Humphry tells him the long list of reasons as to why the staff are there, all the while ignoring that actually the real reason as to why there is no actual medical staff at the hospital is because of decisions made by other departments which he has no direct control over because the thought of him not being in control terrified him, is quite entertaining.
He is like an ignorant glory-addicted child: he doesn't want to accept that he just doesn't want to take the time and effort to understand why the hospital isn't opened he only cares about what the simple-minded popular people who criticise him say, and so he stamps his feet in impatience and when it all comes back to bite him later on he panics.
HOW CAN I FIND THIS SERIES PLEASE TELL ME
what's with the shooting angles. I feel like I am missing half the screen
the problem with government? Humphrey.... lol
this is south australia at the moment with the covid19 hotel and security cock up
Love this show, just not on CZcams.
Classic Victorian government with Sir Dan Andrews 🤪
Outstanding comedy. a pity it's been stretched to fit the 16:9 ratio, it's a lot better in the original 4:3 format.
Stretching the format and playing at a higher speed is a common sleazy trick to avoid copyright strikes.
Is that why Humphrey and Bernard seem to be talking so much faster and higher pitch voices. It just seems weird.
Funny as it is its the thought that Governments around the Globe work like we see here that is crinchworthy.....
Cor ' blimey Guv ' .
This show makes me think of poker
Since India became a colony of East India company first and then when British monarch took over its administration by having the ICS until its independence in1947.After which India Indianized the ICS to UPSC .The governance of our civil servants at the highest echelons of government is much worse. Having introduced the infamous quota system which selects these civil servants not by merit but by quotas.Which the British would certainly not done in India. I myself have given this exam ,choosing Indian Foreign service as the first choice, but also sat for post graduation in English literature.But even in our academic system the quota system appears. And this infamous quota system is there not only for 5 or 10 years after our independence but has got entrenched in our academic institutions without redemption.
That is now commonplace in the UK, we are the victims of the usual liberal left thinking by making everyone seemingly as clever as the next...
Very Interesting Thank You
I don't mind them working together, but I hate it when Hacker wins.
The sound is very poor
I wanted to give this 1/4 like to align with the proportion of the show I was able to watch on this overly-trimmed aspect.
Then the BBC would force CZcams to delete it
I wouldn't be too sure about 'Billy Fraser's' right to hold an Equity card. Appalling attempt.
*Why have you zoomed in so much as to cut more than half the original footage in view? This is awful, and completely ruins what was (and still is) a great series.*
So it doesn't get detected by the CZcams copywrong algorithms and taken down?
@@samsowden You mean there are *still* conspiracy theories floating around regarding _"Fair Usage Policy"_ under International Copyright Laws Sam? That's incredible! CZcams stopped using *ALL* algorithms to detect illegal breaches of copyright, way back in May 2016, when the UK and US governments agreed to a joint fair use policy. Then I think Australia, Canada and Japan signed up to it next, followed eventually by the rest of the world with very few exceptions, most notably China, North Korea and some of the smaller African countries.
All anyone has to do to comply these days, is acknowledge who owns the original copyright in the info beneath the video if known. In other words, avoid claiming it to be there own property. So you, I, or anyone else could upload full HD episodes of _"Yes Minister"_ to CZcams *as long as* we acknowledge in the written blurb underneath, that the copyright of the material is still owned by the BBC. Sorry to be so long-winded, but I hope that's clarified things for you? Take care.
The dialogue is still heard
@@mavisemberson8737 Why do you think society moved on from radio to television Mavis? What century were you born in for god's sake!
@@DrAnne-mc8er I was a WW II child and graduated from Edinburgh in 1965. We were taught courtesy to strangers throughout my education.. We are all strangers on the internet. so please be polite please explain the radio to tv comparison . We must make the best of what we can get free. Otherwise read the books.
Can't understand a thing with the muffled audio.
That is because you are a foreign twat...
British English, innit😁?
Yes, change the playback speed to .75. Also, the screen ratio should be reduced, as mentioned, and the canned laughter made me stop watching what should have been an enjoyable show bu alas, t not so. I will watch something else.
This is a very poor quality. Do you record it in your lounge using your phone.
.......yet, FREE.
These pointless 2/3rds screen captures suck.
Totally agree ....... unwatchable!
@@annettekleynhans7956 Then don't watch.
This is to avoid a copyright strike...
It's the only way to get around copyright so we can watch it for free. If you want to watch it properly then you have to pay for it.
No complaints here,better than nothing.
To all those who commented the sound is too faint or fast, sorry THIS IS ENGLISH. Learn it
Nah, this is English sped up to avoid copyright strikes, fixed if reduce the speed to 0.75x
quite right. English people speak fast. Especially in comedy.
TOO FAST!!!!!!!!
Fernando Ulrich me trouxe até aqui
If PM is number 10, who are numr 1-9?
The PM'S HOUSE is number 10,it's the prime minister's address, number 10 downing street ,the PM isn't number 10 himself (or herself)
That's what he meant - who lives at nos. 1 to 9?
@@michelez715 well that's not what he said
I have posted information below. It is from Wikipedia, so take with a grain of salt. They are usually broadly correct, although there may be incorrect details. This always has been very interesting to me, (The British Prime Minister's abode.), as our President's Official Residence is The Élysée Palace on the Champs-Élysées, 8th arrondissement and the French Premier, (Our PM.), lives at The Hôtel de Matignon in Paris, located in the 7th arrondissement, just south of the
Champs-Élysées, and both residences sound a bit Posh. The British PM sounds like he lives just up the street and commoners can just drop round for a spot of tea and a biscuit! Probably not, but I'll just imagine Boris sharing a pint with a constituent.
-1-8 Downing Street were the houses between Number 9 and Whitehall that were taken over by the government and demolished in 1824 to allow the construction of the Privy Council Office, Board of Trade and Treasury offices.
-9 Downing Street, named in 2001, is the Downing Street entrance to the Privy Council Office and houses the Department for Exiting the European Union. (Booo! That's me, the girl making this comment, not Wikipedia, sorry. We'll miss you Brits and Scots, Welsh and N. Irish.) It was formerly part of Number 10.
-10 Downing Street is the official residence of the First Lord of the Treasury, the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. The two roles have been filled by the same person since the 1720s with almost no exceptions. It has fulfilled this role since 1735. Originally three houses, Number 10 was offered to Sir Robert Walpole by King George II in 1732 and now contains approximately 100 rooms. A private residence occupies the third floor and there is a kitchen in the basement. The other floors contain offices and conference, reception, sitting and dining rooms where the Prime Minister works, and where government ministers, national leaders and foreign dignitaries are met and entertained. At the rear is an interior courtyard and a terrace overlooking a garden of 0.5 acres (2,000 m2). Other residents of 10 Downing Street are the Spouse of the Prime Minister and family, Downing Street Director of Communications and Chief Mouser to the Cabinet Office.
-11 Downing Street has been the official residence of the Second Lord of the Treasury, the Chancellor of the Exchequer since 1828. The residence was built alongside the official residence of the Prime Minister at Number 10 in 1682.
-12 Downing Street, formerly the Chief Whip's Office, houses the Prime Minister's Press Office, Strategic Communications Unit and Information and Research Unit. In the 1820s it was occupied by the Judge Advocate-General, although it remained in private ownership. It entered government hands when purchased by the East India Company in 1863, and was occupied by the marine and railway departments of the Board of Trade. It was badly damaged by fire in 1879, and underwent further changes.
-13 Downing Street was originally part of 12 Downing Street before the housing area was partially re-built and re-numbered in 1876.
-14 Downing Street formerly closed off the western end of the street. It was leased as a town house from 1723 to 1797. It was acquired by the Crown in 1798, and was used by the War Office and Colonial Office in the 19th century. Some parts were demolished in the 1860s, and by 1876 it had been removed completely.
-15-20 Downing Street, long since demolished, were at one time houses leading up to Horse Guards Road. -15-16 formerly housed the Foreign Office, which also occupied two houses on the south side of the street. -18 was occupied by the West India Department of the Colonial Office
-20 was occupied by the Tithe Commission.
@@andersonsmith979 Thanks
It's brilliant stuff spoiled by an over cropped video. This shouldn't have been released like this. 😠😠😠
You're right, it shouldn't be...on the other hand where it isn't cropped and sped up you have to pay for the privilege, so just mark this under beggars can't be choosers
@@89Keith I do pay for the privilege, I subscribe to CZcams Premium and it really annoys me to see that.
@@preschau yeah that doesn't really make a difference as CZcams aren't the holders of the copyright, that would likely be the BBC
@@preschau CZcams Premium is garbage. I recommend you save your money.
As comedy is in the timing and this running at a ridiculous speed all the comedy is lost. Alas.
You can play this at 0.75 speed, it's in the menu you can access by clicking the 3 dots in the upper right corner of your screen.
Exactly
Hahahaha
Gave up, as it is one of these silly zoomy videos, and the sound isn't too good either.
@Jim Alley
Hi Jimmy, you obviously do. Goodbye.
They are trying to beat the CZcams contentID system. Honestly if you don't want to pay for it (is it on BritBox?) there are better places to locate it.
@@mygaffer
Yes, I have the choice to watch a video, or not.
If it is well done, I will, if it is a butchered mess then I won't, and not my fault if the channel loses viewers, and income from YT.
I have seen the series elsewhere, once when these episodes came on on TV, and years later on other web sites.........for free as well...:)
But if you like watching rubbish videos, then that is your choice, and hope you enjoy them...:)
@Andrew
Thanks, I will look it up as long as I don't have to hand over my credit card details to watch anything....:)
I agree it is awful, really awful sound and video. Rubbish👎🙀
@
You don't speed up Yes Minister, you just ruin the comedic timing. Fool.
This is why you play it at 0.75 🤯
Awful visual and sound reproduction. Presumably recorded directly from a bbc tv transmission. 👎
Ah, you do know that this show is over 40 years old right? It's a tape no such thing as digital back then. Or are you just whining for the sake of it? This was pre recorded you idiot.
Donna Evans hey I am not an idiot!! I just made a comment and you are so very rude! ( I am being very, very polite in my reply- which I actually do not intend to be taken as a true response ).
Don’t be so silly!
putting up rubbish versions for profit....yeah right
call it as you see it. fucking bullshite posting for profit. what a dick
What profit ?
there are no ads on my side, I think he doesn't get squat
@@hellbender31 The poster of this episode went to a lot of trouble to keep it on this platform.
Terrible quality vid, I love this series but couldn't watch this
Try speed 0.85
Rubbish audio and video. Not worth watching.
It was fine. The programme was made around 40 years ago, what do you expect?
orlando098 the video is cropped and has a vignette with the aim to circumvent the copyright bots of CZcams with the aim to avoid the video to be taken down.
Reduce to 3/4 speed
@@orlando098 Bravo..... could I add to your obvs -- and FREE
This is terrible ...cannot watch
take this shit down
@Ruth Collins 🤣😂😅 you are very _very_ stupid aren't you? This has been magnified and fucked about with unnecessarily. It's not a matter of when it was made. I saw these when they first came out. If you have a copy all you have to do is upload it! Not fuck with it. P.s. I think you should go and live in scunthorpe
Brilliant!